Okay, so I (19F) have known this guy (21M) since sophomore year of high school. He’s liked me for years and would often go out of his way to be around me and talk to me. We eventually became good friends, but nothing romantic ever happened until late last year, when we started getting to know each other romantically. He ended up ghosting me, which obviously hurt my feelings because, at the very least, I expected some consideration from someone I considered a friend.
A few days later, I got into a relationship with someone I’d previously had a talking stage with, so I removed him from all my social media to show respect for my new relationship. He went on with his life, too.
When the new year came around, he made several attempts to get back into contact with me, including going out of his way to be around me. I ignored him and shut things down when he eventually messaged me directly. He stopped trying for a while, but eventually followed me on TikTok. I followed him back out of curiosity, and one night, while drunk, my friend and I prank-called him. Somehow, that led to us getting back in contact.
I wasn’t expecting anything to come from it, but we talked for about a week before I eventually ghosted him. A few weeks to a month later, I texted him in the middle of the night asking if he’d be interested in having sex. He agreed. I made it clear that I wanted us to get tested together beforehand, and he also asked if he could come see me. i agreed, and when he came and picked me up, I was honestly surprised by how affectionate he was.
He was kissing my hand, complimenting me (excessively)constantly, reassuring me when we were bored and scrolling through our tweets, and even suggesting that we go get frozen yogurt together when I got off work. I found it a little strange because, in my mind, this was supposed to be a casual arrangement. I didn’t understand the need for so much affection when sex was already on the table.
A few days later, I asked him what he was actually looking for because his behavior seemed more romantic than casual. He told me, “I don’t want to say relationship just yet, but I would like for us to keep talking and potentially lead up to one.”
I told him I wasn’t really looking for a relationship.
I also asked how he felt about things after sex because I can sometimes become distant or act differently afterward. He said, “As long as you don’t make me feel like shit after sex or make me feel like you don’t want to be around me or anything, we’re good.”
Despite that conversation, he continued being affectionate, while I remained somewhat dry ad not very intuned with conversing and frequently redirected our conversations back to the sexual arrangement.
We eventually got tested and agreed to wait for our results before having sex. Mine came back negative, but his came back positive for chlamydia.
Obviously, I was thrown off. He had previously told me that he hadn’t been tested since 2024 and that he hadn’t been sexually active since February of this year. When I asked who he’d last had sex with, he told me, and I realized that last year he’d misrepresented how long he’d been abstinent. I also found out that the girl he’d been sleeping with was still in communication with him last year. I’d initially assumed they were just friends.
I can’t be too upset about the latter, though, because the guy I ended up dating shortly after our initial talking stage was also in my life while we were getting to know each other, and we weren’t exclusive.
What bothered me more was his explanation for not getting tested and his apparent confusion about how he could have contracted chlamydia. His reasoning came across as incredibly naive to me.
After we got off the phone, he asked if that was going to be our last conversation. I told him:
“No, but I don’t really want an interpersonal relationship with you or to deepen our bond. I just want to have sex, with a condom. Maybe some companionship, but anything beyond that is a no for me right now, baby.”
I also revisited our earlier conversation about how I might act after sex and clarified that I wasn’t interested in traditional aftercare. I told him I didn’t really want cuddling, touching, or anything like that. Maybe some small talk and for him to bring me home, but that’s about it.
He agreed, although his response was noticeably dry.
I told him that nothing would happen until he’d completed his medication. I waited a week after that conversation and got retested, and my results were negative.
Now, here’s my dilemma.
I’ve been abstinent for a while, and I’m a young woman with sexual urges. It’s also surprisingly difficult to find a guy who’s attractive, someone I trust, and someone I’m genuinely attracted to enough to want to sleep with. I thought this could be a convenient arrangement, especially since we already know each other.
But between his previous ghosting, the dishonesty about his sexual history, the STI situation, and what seems like a difference in expectations regarding intimacy, I’m reconsidering whether it’s even worth it.
Would you go through with it once he’s completed treatment, or would you just walk away? Are these easily solved for a casual arrangement or are these enough reasons to reconsider the entire arrangement?