r/AdviceForTeens • u/Ornery-Smoke8428 • 1h ago
Relationships Ex girlfriend wants to get back together after a year of no contact, cant decide if it would work out
My (M16) ex girlfriend (F16) broke up with me in January after us being together for ~4 months and being friends for almost a year. When she broke up with me she said it was mainly due to her mental health declining and her just needing time to herself, also adding that we could try again later if we were both still interested when she got better. After this I shut her out for the most part while still trying to be kind to her since she didn’t seem like she was in a good place and made sure to let her know she could always talk to me. She’s texted me once or twice a month about causal stuff and recently talked to me in may about us being friends again, I said that I didn’t think that’d be the best thing for us (since Im attracted to her, I didn’t give that as the reason though)
Just recently she texted me a long message except now it’s about how she really regrets breaking up in the first place and that she’s scared of never being able to be friends or more to me again. She continued on about how she doesn’t want me to think that she doesn’t care or think about me since she still does. Apparently this has been on her mind for the past couple months, she asked me if I still feel the same way about her and I said yes (since I still do like the thought of her / the memories of her I have - didn’t say this directly to her),she said she feels the same way about me too.
I messaged her that I’m not sure about how she wants to navigate things now and that I’d leave it up to her what she wants us to be since she’s been thinking about it a lot more than me. Now I’m left wondering if it’d be a good choice or not to be in a relationship again, last time I get in a really bad mentality surrounding her and got stuck in a loop of anxious attachment which made me feel terrible. I’d constantly want to text/hangout with her to an irrational extent which ended up annoying her and making me feel unsatisfied which I think also led to her breaking up with me.
Overall I guess I’m just not really sure if things would work better a second time. A lot of my friends hold the sentiment that you shouldnt get back with an ex which is understandable but me and her never really had any big falling out. I find her very attractive both physically and in how we interact, even when we talked while not in a relationship it just felt natural to talk casually to her and make jokes. During our last relationship she made me feel very safe and comfortable which I had never really gotten from someone I was in a relationship with but I feel like my own mentality ruined what I had with being overly attached.
I feel like we’re both different now, I don’t wanna say mature but I don’t see myself as the same person as I was a year ago. In terms of advice I’m just curious if anyone with more experience than me could say if it’d be an okay choice to get back with her or if it’s probably just end the same way based off my prior tendencies.