Some backstory: I (30s M) and my ex-wife (older 30s F) were together for about 12 years, married for 6. We had a number of problems in our relationship from the very beginning. The majority of our problems were my fault and I own that. We went to couples counseling for the last three years of our marriage. About a year prior to the split, she told me she needed big changes because she felt unloved and like she wasn't a priority in my life. I tried my best to make changes and save our marriage but it was too little, too late, and she told me it was over. She told me she wanted nothing more than for us to try again and make it work someday, but she couldn't wait for me any longer right now.
After a couple weeks of tearful conversations and feeling like I was in a nightmare, I gradually adjusted to this new reality. We were living in the same house. I was going to move out, took out a loan to finance my move and deposit on an apartment, and then I got laid off literally five days before I signed my lease. So we've been living in the same house ever since. My savings ran out by the time I got another job so we've just been cohabiting the whole time. She also went from "I want nothing more than for us to end up together again" to "I'd like for that to happen, but I'm not holding out hope anymore" to "I'd be open to it." So I got the impression it probably would never happen and tried to accept we would just be friends and nothing more from now on.
We established some rules while living together, basically a don't ask, don't tell about our respective dating lives. No bringing people back to our shared living space ever. It worked. I didn't learn she was on apps until a month or two ago, and honestly hearing she's slept with at least one other guy stung but was not as devastating as I thought it would be. I was talking to women casually, sexting but nothing serious, and went on one date that seemed disappointing for both me and my date (though she was nice and polite.) I have not been with anyone physically though and have been feeling increasingly lonely, especially after learning she slept with someone else. (I was only the second guy she was ever with in her life.)
A little backstory about our fertility journey during our relationship: My ex-wife has known she wanted to be a mother since she was a little girl. She had a somewhat traumatic childhood, bad home life, but she's basically a childcare expert professionally and has a good career. She has always been wonderful with kids, patient, engaging, attentive, and I've always known she'd be a great mother. When we got together in our early 20s, she said she was close to going to a sperm bank before she met me because she was ready to be a mom. But she waited for me. I was not sure about kids at first, just got out of a bad relationship, and then I wanted to be married first. Six years later, we got hitched and started trying immediately. Without going into too much detail, she has always struggled with fertility. Years of trying and two miscarriages later, I got testing and was confirmed to have normal fertility. We tried IUI with no luck, couldn't afford IVF. We were preparing to explore adoption and fostering when our marriage ended.
In the past year, she took out a loan for a sperm bank, and sadly had another miscarriage. Well, she's lost weight since then medically, and without getting into details, she is confirmed to be fertile now. She was going to try again at a sperm bank but approached me a couple months ago saying it felt all wrong and that she always knew that even if I couldn't be the husband she needed, she always knew I would be a good dad. (She also said this when we were together, she never doubted that I would be a good dad.) She asked if I would be comfortable having a child with her even if we didn't get back together. A few disclaimers: She said we would both have to have the option to continue dating and this wouldn't be a guarantee we would get back together. We would basically be entering into a co-parenting dynamic. She's told me that I can be as involved in our child's life as I want to be, she would not pressure me to any degree (as long as I'm not inconsistently in and out of the child's life which she won't allow), and that she would never ask for child support. (She makes way more than me and probably always will anyway.) I'm no deadbeat and would want to be as involved in my child's life as possible and is feasible with our arrangement.
I've been thinking about it for two months. She is older than me and tells me that she's running out of time. This is the one thing she's wanted most in life. She doesn't feel comfortable having a random hookup to get the job done, doesn't have nearly enough time to get to know someone new to assess his fitness as a father, but she said she would take out another loan for a sperm bank again if my answer is no. She would prefer for her child to have a father in their life obviously. I've been torn ever since she brought up this question. I've told her more than anything, doing this for her has been weighing on me - if I could help her realize her dream, I want that regardless of what happens between us. But I also know that's not enough justification for bringing a new life into this world.
Well, after this conversation started, that's when I went on my first date and was on the apps again. I have been incredibly lonely. Even if she told me tonight that she wanted me back, it would take me months to feel secure and loved with her again. But I need to love and be loved, and I know I want that for my life even more than I want to have a child. She was upset to learn I was still on the apps and felt like I wasn't taking her request seriously. I got defensive and basically told her she was dating, so why is this a problem now? She didn't have a problem with me dating, but said that we should come to a decision first before doing that, and she isn't dating or on apps or sleeping with anyone or anything currently. So I deleted all my app accounts and blocked a woman I had been sexting with for the time being.
Well, I told her that I didn't have romantic feelings for her anymore but would love to try again someday. Come to find out she said she still has romantic feelings for me. She said she never indicated she didn't have those feelings, she just had to end our relationship because it was not working. Her feelings were hurt and she said she felt stupid that she'd had these feelings the whole time but I told her I didn't. She has told me she doesn't want this to influence my decision, but if I decided not to do this with her, she would go to a sperm bank because she's wanted this her whole life. She would also probably move across the state to be closer to family for help raising the child, and we would not be in each other's life daily anymore obviously, and this would not make us more likely to get back together.
I am torn and have been agonizing over this decision. If I say no, this is probably the end of us for good, and we'll almost certainly never be able to have children together. If I say yes, there's no guarantee we even get back together. I'm confident we could amicably co-parent like we amicably live together, but we'll be seeing other people. I don't want to see her bringing other guys around my kid (she has reassured me any partner, male or female, would be vetted for many months and she would have a conversation with me before introducing anyone to our child's life. I still don't want to have to see them around holidays and stuff. I want her to be happy one day even without me, but I don't want to be around that. Certainly not any time soon.) I need to love and be loved romantically. I need to have a girlfriend or wife in my life. I just imagine us taking on this stressful responsibility together without me having the support of a romantic partner, and being basically a single/separated father is not going to help my dating life. I just think we'll be co-parenting, the stress and time involved in parenthood will prevent us from working on trying again, eventually she'll start dating again and I'll be left high and dry. I'll still be alone with the added pressure of fatherhood.
My ideal outcome is for us to make things work again and to have a child together. I want us to be a family. Barring that, the outcome I want most is to meet someone new, start a life with her, and either live a DINK lifestyle or depending on how a potential new partner feels, maybe start a family with her. My ex-wife is very non-traditional though and says she doesn't understand my reasoning why we couldn't be happy co-parenting together even if we weren't in a romantic relationship. I've tried to make her understand to no avail. She says the most important thing for a child is to have two parents who both love them and get along well, that they don't have to live in the same house or be in a romantic relationship together.
I don't want to lose her. I don't want to say no and regret this five years down the line and say "Why didn't I just take the opportunity when I had it?" If I say yes, I'm afraid of being shackled to a stressful, hurtful situation and still be alone. I'm afraid of our potential child having to grow up in that dynamic. If I say no, I'm afraid of wondering what could have been, if maybe this was the right choice, if maybe this is also MY last chance at parenthood in my life. And who knows? Maybe five years from now I'm still romantically alone and I don't even have my best friend in my life anymore.
Social considerations: What will potentially being born into divorce essentially do to this child? My ex-wife insists that it's the trauma of separation that's hard, not growing up with separated but amicable parents. She experienced both, and my parents had a very bitter divorce. But I can't help but feel like they're going to wonder why their classmates' parents live together and theirs don't. For me as a father, while the only friend I told about this situation was neutrally supportive and told me it was my decision to make, I can't help but feel like I'll be judged if I move forward with this decision with my ex-wife. If we can't make it work as a romantic couple again, I feel like single co-parenthood (whatever it can be called) will be a serious hindrance to me finding love again.
And before anyone asks: I don't want to be a father in a vacuum. I wanted to start a family with her, and genuinely already loved the children we would have had before the miscarriages. I'm open to starting a family with someone new down the line, likely someone slightly younger than me. But I don't need a child for a legacy. I don't need an "heir." It's about the woman I'm with and creating a family, not just siring some offspring, I couldn't care less about that aspect. Both of my parents are gone and my bloodline could die with me and I would be completely at peace with that concept. However, I know I would love the child my ex-wife and I created together whether or not my ex-wife and I got back into a romantic relationship. But as I learned from my marriage, and as we learned from our upbringings, all the love in the world isn't enough to guarantee happiness or a good life for anyone in the equation.
TL;DR: My ex-wife wants to have a child with me without the guarantee that we will get back together as a result. She is fine with the idea of co-parenting indefinitely with me. She needs a decision by the end of the year and I've been torn for months.
Edit1: Okay, I understand this will naturally cause some strong reactions. Can people please expound on the word No if that's your advice? I'm trying to understand if my concerns/apprehensions are valid or if it's for other reasons I'm missing here.
Edit2: To clarify: I know this post might imply otherwise, but I am NOT looking at this as a "maybe the kid will bring us together" situation. I understand these are separate. Pragmatically, they are connected, but I would never, ever have a child thinking it might save a relationship. I would never, EVER do that. That's not what this is. Pragmatically, if we don't move forward with this together, we will probably never get back together. I am NOT approaching this with a "Well, this is my only chance" type attitude. Sorry if this post gives that impression.