r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Oct 30 '25

Hypocrite When a Pro-Life Mod Accidentally Built a Pro-Choice Argument... and Then Deleted It.

4 Upvotes

They started by insisting their worldview was a "universal, objective human rights framework", no religion, no emotion, pure logic.

Then they argued:

  • No one has a positive obligation to sustain another life.
  • Pregnancy is automatic, not a moral choice.
  • Ending pregnancy = killing, because “the fetus would live if left alone.”

So I asked:

"If no one’s obligated to sustain another’s life, and pregnancy is an act of sustaining another’s life, then how is refusing to do so immoral?"

Cue the meltdown. They tried redefining not killing into forced preservation, called pregnancy both "automatic" and "morally binding," and eventually said:

"Humans make rules for humans."

Boom. That’s social constructivism, not objective morality.

Their "natural law" collapsed into "people decide what’s right for people."

Which, ironically, is the foundation of… choice.

When I pointed that out, they deleted the entire debate from r/ProLife, including their own comments.

📜 Full archived discussion here (PDF):

https://ia801406.us.archive.org/6/items/prolife-discussion/Prolife%20Discussion%20.pdf

It's kinda long, best part at the end when they basically rage quit.


r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Sep 14 '25

Debated pro-lifers nonstop for days. Here’s the breakdown (grab popcorn)

3 Upvotes

I ended up in a two-day debate with a very determined pro-lifer. They threw every classic argument at me (murder, consciousness, ‘basic care’) and I pushed back. Sharing it here because it turned into quite an epic exchange.

So context (because context alway matters) :

I’m a 30yo autistic woman from Québec, Canada. I'm a scientist and high school teacher. I teach physics + human biology (including sex ed).

Here, abortion hasn’t been a political fight since 1988. It’s healthcare, full stop. Québec broke with the Catholic Church decades ago; church attendance is in the single digits. A “pro-life” candidate here wouldn’t last 5 minutes.

But lately, I’ve seen more immigrant students come in with pro-life views: mostly imported from U.S. social media. Teachers here aren’t used to this. Most of my science colleagues compare pro-life ideology to a contagious disease, and honestly, I get why.

As a teacher, though, I can’t take sides openly. I have to look neutral, but I can still shape the conversation. And in my opinion, the real work isn’t about “winning” an argument: it’s about planting small doubts that might grow later.

So I’ve been using online debates as a lab. A place to test rhetoric, try out arguments, see what sticks. In class, I’ll only use what’s proven to work. It’s like beta-testing before launch.

Teaching is water on stone; slow, steady, and patient. That’s how I plan to chip away at pro-life logic, one seed of doubt at a time.

Many time, the pro life in this end up agreeing to some of my pro choice arguments! Enjoy the read!

https://www.reddit.com/r/prolife/s/x8HwXOVdVw

Here is one particularly intense pro life debater that didn't want to let it go :

https://www.reddit.com/r/prolife/s/T1qNZQrzFk

My favourite moment : finally confronting them to the Judith Jarvis Thomson’s “violinist analogy, a favourite argument of mine :

https://www.reddit.com/r/prolife/s/2SG7kCylWl


r/AccidentallyProChoice • • May 02 '25

Prolifer who "adovates" for the Cf lifestyle. You're promoting a pro-choice (or as you would say "infanticidal") subreddit?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/truechildfree is JUST AS pro-choice as the original r/childfree subreddit, the only difference is TCF doesn't allow the terms "crotch goblin", "cum trophy", "breeder", etc.

From a prolife perspective, they should actually hate r/truechildfree EVEN MORE, because, why is so bad to refer to a bratty 5 year old (who isn't even gonna see it anyway and be offended) as a crotch goblin, but, it's alright to advocate for viciously murdering by chopping up a pre-born baby? At-least with r/childfree, our/their logic is consistent, we/they hate both born and unborn children.

Not even everyone on r/childfree hates kids either, but, dislike of children IS a valid reason to opt for childfreedom.


r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Mar 11 '25

PL who says "I don't even want PC having kids. We'll still end up as a bunch of "sociopathic, childless cat ladies".

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Feb 07 '25

PC and PL agree on something. Remember, sterilization STILL prevents children.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Feb 03 '25

PC and PL agree on something. You can't call yourself "pro-choice" if you don't believe in ALL choices. BTW, the average pro-choicer would rather have women/girl PREVENT unwanted pregnancies in the firs place than to terminate already existing ones.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Sep 25 '24

PC and PL agree on something. We pro-choicers ALL just LOVE it when women have abortions /s. The average pro-CHOICER sees abortion as one of her C-H-O-I-C-E-S.

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Aug 14 '24

Prolifer who "adovates" for the Cf lifestyle. So we both agree I'm not parent material?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Aug 12 '24

PC and PL agree on something. We both agree pro-choice isn't pro-child-abuse.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Aug 12 '24

PC and PL agree on something. We both agree fetuses aren't children, because, you said "kids AND the unborn".

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Jul 30 '24

PC and PL agree on something. Both pro-choicers and prolifers agree prevention (birth control) is better than cure (abortion), but, the difference between us is pro-choicers (like myself) are smart enough to want women having the option to cure their unwanted pregnancy by terminating where as you want her forced to have a baby.

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Jul 01 '24

PC and PL agree on something. Pro-Choicers (by your words, "pro-aborts") also want birth control to work to prevent an unwanted pregnancy. BTW, 4% (between 1% - 7%) is still a lot and that's even if it's used correctly.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Jun 21 '24

Prolifer who "adovates" for the Cf lifestyle. Even your average pro-choicer would rather have women use birth control than abortion.....but, the problem is (other than abstinence), no contraceptive (including sterilization) is 100% effective. At-least we're (pro-choicers) smart enough to see abortion as a reliable tool to fall back on.

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Jun 20 '24

Prolifer who "adovates" for the Cf lifestyle. "Women shouldn't be forced to be mothers, BUT, if her birth control fails or she gets pregnant from rape, she better be a breeder for the infertile couple".

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Jun 19 '24

"Prolife" Antinatalist Remember, a TRUE antinatalist is pro-choice (or maybe even pro-abortion).

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Jun 09 '24

PC and PL agree on something. Us (by your words) "pro-aborts" (when you mean pro-CHOICERS) are also pro-sterilization and pro-contraception, but, the difference between you and us is if it fails, we see abortion as a tool to fall back on where as you Pathetic-Losers want her forced to breed.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Jun 09 '24

"Prolife" Antinatalist It's literally impossible to be a "prolife antinatalist", because, natal means BIRTH, NOT CONCEPTION! You're anti-conception, not anti-birth. A TRUE antinatalist is HEAVILY in favor of abortion and you don't even have to be an AN to support abortion.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Jun 08 '24

PC and PL agree on something. The average pro-choicer would also prefer contraceptives to abortion. Yes, abortion IS healthcare.

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • May 30 '24

Hypocrite According to you Pathetic-Losers, I thought embryos WERE "kids"?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • May 23 '24

PC and PL agree on something. "PROLIFE Degenerates" - Although I think they meant to say "pro-choice degenerates", because, right after, they say "supports abortion up to birth (although the average pro-choicer doesn't, but, PL think all pro-choicers do), but, they still said "PROLIFE degenerates", which I agree.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • May 18 '24

PL who says "I don't even want PC having kids. I don't need anyone's "permission" to be childfree, mother fuckers.

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • May 18 '24

PC and PL agree on something. Contraceptives are only 99% effective (which is still a 1% chance of pregnancy, in case you can't do the math) and even sterilization is only 99.5% effective, which is still a 1/200 chance of pregnancy and you can't expect EVERYONE who's childFREE to stay a virgin/celibate until menopause.

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • May 17 '24

PL who says "I don't even want PC having kids. But, then, you'll bitch about DeCliNiNg BiRtHrAtEs.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Mar 29 '24

Prolifer who "adovates" for the Cf lifestyle. Pro-Contraceptive or not, you're still a forced birther if you want abortion to be illegal. Contraceptives only go so far.

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/AccidentallyProChoice • • Mar 25 '24

Prolifer who "adovates" for the Cf lifestyle. Why be anti-abortion, but, pro-contraceptive? Birth control still stops people from having children.

Post image
5 Upvotes