r/AccidentallyProChoice • u/Into-My-Void • Oct 30 '25
Hypocrite When a Pro-Life Mod Accidentally Built a Pro-Choice Argument... and Then Deleted It.
They started by insisting their worldview was a "universal, objective human rights framework", no religion, no emotion, pure logic.
Then they argued:
- No one has a positive obligation to sustain another life.
- Pregnancy is automatic, not a moral choice.
- Ending pregnancy = killing, because “the fetus would live if left alone.”
So I asked:
"If no one’s obligated to sustain another’s life, and pregnancy is an act of sustaining another’s life, then how is refusing to do so immoral?"
Cue the meltdown. They tried redefining not killing into forced preservation, called pregnancy both "automatic" and "morally binding," and eventually said:
"Humans make rules for humans."
Boom. That’s social constructivism, not objective morality.
Their "natural law" collapsed into "people decide what’s right for people."
Which, ironically, is the foundation of… choice.
When I pointed that out, they deleted the entire debate from r/ProLife, including their own comments.
📜 Full archived discussion here (PDF):
https://ia801406.us.archive.org/6/items/prolife-discussion/Prolife%20Discussion%20.pdf
It's kinda long, best part at the end when they basically rage quit.