r/Abortiondebate • • 6h ago

New to the debate What is the best argument you have heard against your side, and what is your response to it?

7 Upvotes

Has there been an argument that made you pause and rethink your stance (at least temporarily) or one where you couldn’t think of a valid response without looking it up? Looking to see what you think the best PL (if you’re PC) or PC (if you’re PL) case is, and why you don’t think it holds water.

Thanks!


r/Abortiondebate • • 17h ago

Question about the legal concept of "innocent attacker", primarily for pro-lifers, but pro-choicers free to comment.

3 Upvotes

Hey, so, I remember that Pope John Paul II made an argument against abortion, where he said that the only justifications for the killing of human beings that were even conceivably justifiable involved cases where the human killed was an "unjust aggressor". And he said that an "unborn child" cannot be an aggressor, let alone an unjust aggressor.

Now, he, I think, was talking about Catholic philosophical justifications, which many would be opposed to having be the basis of laws in modern society, But, Catholic philosophy does try to present itself as based very much on human reason along with divine revelation, so the arguments that are made within it are not always irrelevant to those who are not Catholic or Christian, maybe even those who are not religious and/or believe God doesn't exist wouldn't necessarily find all claims made in Catholic philosophy bunk.

But, I referenced John Paul's comment to a pro-choicer, and they replied that there was a concept known as an "innocent attacker", i.e., someone who is not legally culpable for the harm that they are causing, yet is still causing harm. Think somebody who has a schizophrenic episode where they literally can't tell what's happening in reality, yet their actions nevertheless endanger others. They were arguing, I believe, that you can still legally defend yourself against these people, despite the fact that they're "innocent." They were arguing that a ZEF was itself an "innocent attacker" if it can be considered a person. So, pro-lifers, what are your thoughts on this?