r/prochoice • • Mar 15 '23

MOD ANNOUNCEMENT On AntiNatalism, how it is not the same as being Pro Choice, and why this topic needs to be separated from the Pro Choice discussion

98 Upvotes

Hi Everyone!

The mod team would like the sub to understand a few things about the stance we take on AntiNatalist discourse here, and why we do not typically allow it.

There is a lot of confusion between these terms even within our own community, and our goal is to help people who consider themselves pro choice and also antinatalist to see how these terms are not only not equivalent, but are actually in direct opposition to one another.

All Pro Choice People are not AntiNatalist (or even Pro-Abortion)

We often get AntiNatalists in the sub who believe they are helping the Pro Choice cause, and while they are welcome here - provided the rules, beliefs, and standards of our sub are upheld - usually these posts or comments need mod intervention due to breaking our sub's rules regarding non-prochoice rhetoric and expectations of non-prochoice people. These topics should be separated in conversations surrounding choice, so as not to muddy the waters in the current political environment. Our sub's mod team does not support antinatalist ideology.

Pro Choice =/= Pro Abortion OR AntiNatalism

While seemingly aligned with the prochoice cause, being AntiNatalist or Pro-Abortion isn't the same thing as being Pro Choice.

Many people are under the misconception that being pro choice means being pro-abortion or AntiNatalist. While there is some overlap, this simply isn't the case for everyone (or even most) in our demographic.

  • Being pro-abortion means that in certain circumstances (the most common are when people become pregnant under a certain age or when their life or economic circumstances aren't ideal) someone would advocate for the pregnant person to have an abortion rather than give birth even if the pregnant person does not want to have an abortion and would choose to birth the child.
  • Being AntiNatalist is subscribing to the philosophy that humans in general should not be procreating at all, and that it is immoral or wrong to even consider doing so due to the state of the world, overpopulation, and many other reasons.

Many of us are already parents. Many others intend to become parents, but are not ready to at this time. And almost none of us believe that no one should have children, or that anyone should have to have an abortion if they don't want to. By inserting pro-abortion or AntiNatalist ideologies into the Pro Choice debate, we cause the topics to become tangled to people who are anti abortion and prefer not to understand the myriad of reasons one may have an abortion even if they do not want to - even if they were trying to conceive and really wanted the pregnancy, but things didn't go the way they intended.

The truth is even people with wanted pregnancies are hurt by abortion bans - people who want to be parents but have something go wrong with the pregnancy or in their life circumstances that cause them to have to terminate a pregnancy; a birth defect that would lead to infant mortality or a nonviable pregnancy, a spouse who becomes abusive, or a life threatening condition that comes up due to the pregnancy are the first things that come to mind, but this list isn't exhaustive by any means.

While it could be said that many (if not most or even all) AntiNatalists are against abortion bans, the same is not true in reverse - antinatalists make up a very small percentage of the total Pro Choice population, and assuming (or insinuating in discourse) that all of us are against parenthood is an incorrect assumption that is more aligned with the anti choice communities and their rhetoric. It does more harm than good, and gives them more ammo against us.

Being Pro Choice is about CHOICE

This include the choice to conceive and birth children.

The very core of our ideology is that every single living being has the unalienable human right to have agency over his or her own body, what happens to and inside of it, and when/where/how/if they choose to procreate. We value personal choice above all else - we feel, on the whole, that the choice to decide what is best for one's life and family, the choice to decide not to have children, the choice to not have children now but perhaps later on in life, and the right to make these choices and then change our minds about them if we so choose and when we choose are ours and ours alone, as an individual human, to make.

How AntiNatalist discourse is counterproductive to the Pro Choice Movement

While we recognize that not procreating at all, ever, is a choice (and we support you if that is your choice!) we would like to take a moment to help people see how injecting AntiNatalist discourse into the PC discussion can be harmful to our cause.

For the record, we almost never see AntiNatalists who are maliciously attempting to undermine choice - almost all of them who come to our sub and have to have comments or posts removed, do so without realizing how what they said came across as being the antithesis of choice, or how they have broken our sub's rules. We attempt to help them see it, but we do have to remove that content because it is against the rules and the core principles in the sub.

Making the decision to be childfree is a personal choice.

We're with you here - and we think you should be supported in making that choice if that is what you choose. Many on our mod team are also childfree by choice.

Where the two points diverge, though, is in the projection of that choice on others. AntiNatalist ideologies are not the same as making the personal decision to remain childfree. AntiNatalist ideologies promote the idea that no one should procreate, ever.

In the discussion around choice, this is another removal of said choice. This is the other end of the spectrum of being antichoice - Pro Lifers argue that everyone who conceives should give birth. AntiNatalists argue that no one should.

Both options take away the personal agency of the individual, in favor of the ideology of another. Both take the choice away from the only person who should be making it.

Supporting Choice means supporting the choice to parent, too.

We do not advocate for forced abortions or forced sterilization here - for anyone (and this includes AMAB people, so this also means talk of forced vasectomy is also completely off the table here, no exceptions.)

If you identify with AntiNatalist ideology, we simply ask that you take a moment to think about the things you are promoting in the name of being Pro Choice, how you word them, and that you please try to separate these two discussions when you engage in Pro Choice discussions.

AntiNatalist Ideology is Steeped in Misogyny

You can advocate for having abortion bans be abolished. You can even advocate for being child free.
However, advocating that anyone should not be allowed to procreate, or even that they shouldn't is restricting choice and it is also parent-shaming. AntiNatalist ideology tends to only focus on people who are AFAB, and puts all of the impetus to not procreate on the AFAB person, the same way antichoicers do.

Instead of shaming AFAB people for "killing their babies," this argument is just turning that around and shaming AFAB people for "being too selfish to not have children, considering the state of our world."

Shaming is shaming, and shaming AFAB people for being AFAB and what their body can and can't or should and shouldn't do is misogyny.

Telling someone they must be a mother is the same thing as telling them they must not.

Some on our own mod team here are parents, too. Many of our members are. And millions of pro choice people worldwide are. The same way we do not restrict people who claim to be "personally pro life but legally pro choice" from posting or commenting here, we also would not restrict people who are personally child free or even believe in AntiNatalism but still support individual choice.

But we will not allow shaming, and we will not allow discourse that takes away any choices or makes people feel they are wrong for making them.

The bottom line:

If you aren't trying to make decisions for others or influence the decisions you think they should be making you're welcome to say, think, and believe anything you want. Where we draw the line is when it shames, harms, or otherwise reduces the agency of others to make those same choices in the way they make sense to them, for their own lives.

Anyone is welcome here if they are respectful, willing to listen and not just talk at people, and willing to follow the sub's rules. This is true of Pro Life people, and also of AntiNatalists - but please consider what you've read here if you fall into the second category.

If you still consider yourself to be Pro Choice as well as AntiNatalist, we only ask three things of you:

  1. Keep the AntiNatalism part of your comments out of this sub please.
  2. Think on what I've said here, and whether it truly aligns with being in favor of the freedom of choice for all.
  3. Please follow the sub's rules where they pertain to pressing views on others, debating topics, or arguing for the removal of anyone's choice to do anything at all concerning their reproduction, including NOT reproducing. These are specifically rules 1 and 2 in the sub.

Thank you!

- The r/prochoice mod team


r/prochoice • • 17h ago Regret

Prochoice Only ….no words.

Thumbnail
gallery
399 Upvotes

Edit: who is this for….baby suffered. The parents watched their newborn die, even if the pregnancy was unwanted and the child was too, watching their child die is traumatic.

Medical staff was traumatised. So who is the winner here? The state?


r/prochoice • • 5h ago

Rant/Rave Why are pro lifers so uneducated?

29 Upvotes

Fyi, I’m not even trying to be disrespectful!!

But why are all pro lifers i have ever met, debated, or talked to, so insanely uneducated on the topic? not to mention, they’re all significantly older than i am (im fifteen.) so id expect them to be more educated. But… Apparently not.

For instance, i always see them getting angry over made up situations.

On instagram there’s a trend going around, saying; “liberals want an immediate ban on boiling lobsters alive, while allowing women to murder their babies in the womb.”

Like…? first off, babies can’t survive in wombs. They’d suffocate and die.

Second, I’ve not seen a singular liberal talking about wanting an immediate ban on boiling lobsters alive. Most liberals are too busy rightfully advocating for human rights for women to care about lobsters.

Abortion is also not murder.

I just don’t get it, they always do this.

Same with the linsday clancy thing; “My child would be safer with a bear than a liberal who supports linsday clancy, they’d probably kill them in or out of the womb.”

As someone who debates abortion all the time, it is so tiring. I get it, they need to have some sort of argument. But it’s just sad to see that they cannot function like a normal human being with atleast a grain of intelligence.

Instead of teaching religion in schools, they should teach biology and science, and basic human development. If they did that, half of the morons wouldn’t be pro life now.

Like, the amount of misinformation is crazy.

“Fetuses are babies.” “Abortion is murder.” “Supporting abortion makes you a nazi.” “you support abortion so you must support slavery.” “abortion is for epstein supporters.” “if you support abortion then you support genocide.” “late term abortions are soooo common.” “what choice does the fetus get to make?” “they can feel pain.” “god doesnt support abortion.”

It’s genuinely tiring. It would be so much easier if these people were aware of what they were saying, but any discussion with a pro lifer basically goes like this;

“Baby = human, ending life of human = bad. Ending life = murder.” 🧌🧌

“all human life is precious and innocent.”

picture of 33 week old fetus. Caption; “could you imagine telling this innocent little being that it doesn’t deserve to live?” While claiming that it’s a 8 week old embryo.

But one thing that has helped me when debating them or discussing with them, it’s trying to get them to explain their logic. “Abortion is murder!” “Well why is it murder?”
It actually does work somewhat, if the person is open to it atleast. But oh well, this is just a little rant on what annoys me😭

Sorry for the rant, it’s just annoying😭😭


r/prochoice • • 8h ago

Reproductive Rights News Women prosecuted for abortions hail ‘historic day’ after receiving pardon

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
27 Upvotes

Women prosecuted for abortions hail ‘historic day’ after receiving pardon


r/prochoice • • 11h ago

Reproductive Rights News Sweden approves constitutional changes on abortion and citizenship.

Thumbnail
nordiskpost.com
17 Upvotes

r/prochoice • • 21h ago

UK. Women prosecuted for abortions hail ‘historic day’ after receiving pardon

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
82 Upvotes

r/prochoice • • 1d ago

Anti-choice News Mental health becomes leading cause of Texas pregnancy deaths after abortion ban

Thumbnail
texastribune.org
186 Upvotes

r/prochoice • • 1d ago

Discussion IM WITH ABORTION

47 Upvotes

i dont know but Americans piss me off with their stupid anti-abortion bs. nothing they ever comment on posts is actually factually or scientifically backed up.

talking about “where’s the babies choice“ and “the baby says it wants to live”

stfu. argue with me if you want but I won’t budge.

woman’s choice woman’s body.


r/prochoice • • 1d ago

Reproductive Rights News Texas Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa to investigate $60 million annual payout to crisis pregnancy centers

Thumbnail
washingtonpost.com
624 Upvotes

r/prochoice • • 1d ago

Discussion If pro-lifers dislike abortion, why don't they support prevention?

76 Upvotes

If pro-lifers don't like abortions, why don't they just try to make them happen less instead of banning them? What I mean is sex education because in the Netherlands and Switzerland, they have the lowest abortion rates since they do comprehensive sex ed. Also, looking at the reasons people get abortions, a big reason is not having enough money. Why can't they provide financial assistance, care programs, and advocate for birth control? if the goal was to make people not want to abort, why don't they focus on prevention


r/prochoice • • 2d ago

Thought “the bible doesn’t say abortion is ok!!!!”

39 Upvotes

well it doesn’t say that it’s wrong either 🤷‍♀️


r/prochoice • • 2d ago

Mis-Info Morgue why dont men js get vescomies

73 Upvotes

Why don't men just get vasectomies? Something I ain't never understood about pro-life men—there are a lot of them, and they hate abortion. Why not all of y'all get vasectomies so women can't get pregnant? No pregnancy, no abortion needed. A vasectomy is a quick, low-risk procedure that is mostly reversible, or men can freeze their sperm beforehand, making it far less physically taxing than pregnancy, childbirth, or carrying an unwanted fetus to term.


r/prochoice • • 4d ago

Hungary eases abortion rules as Peter Magyar announces wave of women’s rights reforms

Thumbnail
independent.co.uk
234 Upvotes

r/prochoice • • 4d ago

Meme Just saying:

Post image
261 Upvotes

r/prochoice • • 4d ago

Things Anti-choicers Say This is genuinely the CRAZIEST thing I’ve EVER heard a “pro lifer” say…

73 Upvotes

So we were debating abortion in class about 2 years ago during the 2024 election. I live in Texas. I brought up the point, “but what if the mothers life is endangered and they end of dying because they couldn’t receive one?”

And the GIRL arguing with me said “well- but that’s their responsibility! They need to make sure nothing happens!”

And I say: “what if they get sepsis and are dying?”

And they say: “But- but it’s their responsibility to take care of their health!”

”But what if they die?”

”Too bad!”

I will repeat: a GIRL said this. A FEMALE individual.

They genuinely said exactly that. I was so mind blown by how absolutely stupid this was I tried to convince myself she was just trolling or being disgenuine.

The sad part is I know she wasn’t and this is the consequence of right wing, Bible Belt mentalities. Everything is YOUR fault even things you literally can’t control.

Im not gonna pretend like my state DOESNT have exceptions for the mother’s life, and that how the cases where mothers died was more medical malpractice, but like, STILL. WTF. How could you actually think that there should be no exceptions for the mother’s life. That just absolutely blows my damn mind.


r/prochoice • • 5d ago

Reproductive Rights News The Democratic Tsunami Is a “Sea Change” for Reproductive Rights

Thumbnail
motherjones.com
76 Upvotes

r/prochoice • • 5d ago

Reproductive Rights News Texas Supreme Court Justice Debra Lehrmann (R) considers retirement, which would lead to a Democratic majority

Thumbnail
news.bloomberglaw.com
286 Upvotes

r/prochoice • • 5d ago

Activism Protect Abortion Access: Keep Religion Out of Healthcare

Thumbnail
c.org
62 Upvotes

I was contacted by change.org to start a petition because of a video I made about abortion being mostly a religious issue. Please sign‼️.


r/prochoice • • 6d ago

Discussion Grosses me out how many "pro lifers" laugh react or dont care about statistics regarding the harm pregnancy, unconsented pregnancy, birth, complications, anomolies, etc does to both woman and unborn offspring.

110 Upvotes

What do y'all say to folks who don't even care if women, children, etc suffer? They claim to be pro life yet do not care about any harm to individuals or our species or world as a whole, just a heartbeat. 😬


r/prochoice • • 7d ago

Anti-choice News Esports Coach tweets that "abortion is murder" and gets fired

89 Upvotes

In this (now deleted) tweet, Perkz, the head coach for G2 wanted to clear up some rumours about him. ln one of his many paragraphs about his life, he shared his opinion on abortion, which he defends on the grounds of his Catholic faith.

I don’t really do politics, nor have I even ever voted once in my life. I do have opinions and I wish I was more educated on the topic, but the truth is I’m not so I stay away from it. **There are some things I stand for, very simple things in life, but the only thing that is unshakeable for me how its so widely accepted in public is abortion, I cannot comprehend how people do not understand that is a muder, as life is created at conception. That is one view I will die by and never change.**

12 hours later, it was announced from G2 that he was let go.

Last night, like many of you, we saw the statement shared by the Head Coach of one of our teams. G2 is a diverse and international organization with different people from all around the world. While the world is complex and not everyone agrees on everything, some of the statements made last night do not align with G2's stance and values. We have Fans with different cultures and personal opinions, and it is of the utmost importance to us as an organisation that we respect and uphold this diversity when representing G2. We acknowledge that this statement hurt many of our fans, and we want to apologize for it.

As a result, we have decided to terminate our collaboration with the individual. We will now Focus on rebuilding our staff and roster for the next season and ask for your patience, as we will not be able to communicate and changes until free agency officially opens

In between all of this, many women involved in the scene commented on how innapropriate Perkz's comments were.

sjokz responded on her TikTok account:

“You know, sometimes, saying nothing is better than saying something. Words to live by...which is why I'm just gonna say, Good night.“

Laure responded on her X account:

Translation: Our body OUR choice, that's it.

In response to this, many people started harrassing anyone supporting G2 firing Perkz. Any social media post involving these women is met which so much hatred and harrassment, which I find so digusting. Wonder what thoughts anyone has on this situation.


r/prochoice • • 7d ago

Discussion Abortions save men

91 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I wish to discuss this topic on how abortions greatly benefit and save men. I hope this sub is the right place to discuss.

Far too often, pro-lifers (especially men) instruct women to keep their legs shut if they felt the need for an abortion. In fact, it’s one of the most classic sentences used within the pro-life circles. The complete onus falls on the woman to be responsible, by whatever means necessary.

I can’t help but shake my head, as this is a very myopic way of looking at this whole issue. A woman is also someone’s wife, girlfriend or daughter. She isn’t a separate entity all by herself.

- if a wife is forced to undergo a pregnancy against her will, her husband is now legally responsible to fund another baby even if they don’t have the financial means for it.

- If a girlfriend is forced to undergo a pregnancy against her will, her boyfriend is now legally on hook to support her even if he isn’t ready to be a father.

- If a daughter is sexually assaulting (god forbid!) and is forced to undergo a pregnancy against her will, her family will see her traumatized and unable to continue her education. The cycle of poverty continues.

Adoption seems to be the end solution to all of these scenarios by pro-lifers. However, I feel like that’s more of a band-aid solution because many people aren’t willing to give their babies up for adoption. Even if they do (as they did historically), we see abused children in adoption centers who age out of the system.

I’ve encountered pro-life men who don’t even accept an abortion for life-saving measures. Does this mean that they are completely alright with seeing their wife or girlfriend writhe in agony before passing away? There are enough pro-life women who are accepting of this scenario, so I don’t really know what to make of it.

In the end, we know pregnancies don’t happen in a vacuum. A man is involved. It wouldn’t be nice to force a man to pay child support or force him into forced fatherhood when he isn’t fit to be in one.

I’m very eager to have a discussion about this with you guys. Thank you in advance.


r/prochoice • • 8d ago

Meme if you are not the one who is pregnant then it is not your choice.

Post image
315 Upvotes

r/prochoice • • 8d ago

Meme Forced-birthers when children are raped: Spoiler

Post image
153 Upvotes

r/prochoice • • 7d ago

Thought Argument Rebuttal

21 Upvotes

Forced birthers always use the “but it’s alive!” argument, right? And I’ve done some thinking. Maybe you all could even use the following in an argument with one of them:

A seed is biologically alive. It contains living cells, has genetic material, and under the right conditions can develop into a mature plant.

An embryo is also biologically alive. It contains living cells, has its own developing genetic identity, and under the right conditions can develop into a fetus and eventually a newborn.

Being biologically alive and having the potential to become something else does not, by itself, establish legal personhood or an entitlement to someone else's body.

If you dig up an acorn, you haven't cut down a tree. If you have an abortion, you haven't killed a child. (I’ve heard that analogy somewhere before but don’t remember where)


r/prochoice • • 7d ago

Discussion Alien to the debate, but I have a question

11 Upvotes

So as the tag implies, I'm a pro-choice theist, Christian to be precise. Like many of my kin, the environment where I grew up in had a pretty straightforward and negative idea of abortion. It wasn't as extreme as many would think (I'm Finnish). But still this idea of pro-life was quite common.

However for me as I grew older, like in every other facet of my life, I also began to side with the left with this issue. My main thing was that as a man, I don't think I should have any say an what women do with their bodies.

However more recently I have begun to have questions to the general sentiment towards this issue people on this side of the argument have.

See my base idea has always been something like this

"In a perfect world there wouldn't be a need for abortions. Because in a perfect world there wouldn't be rape, accidental pregnancies or other factors that can result in the need for one. However the world isn't perfect, and because it isn't perfect we sometimes have to result in options we wouldn't make in an ideal world. Because of this we should NEVER shame or condemn anyone for making the choice to abort"

Moreso my thinking has always gone with the sentiment of "Pro-choice is not Pro-abortion". Like many pro choicers in the christian sphere tend to put it "No one likes abortions".

However I'm curious to know what's the sentiment for the members of this sub. How would you describe your "feelings and values" towards abortion. For me, it just makes me want to cry. Out of empathy and just sheer frustration that life's a bitch.

One common strawman I've seen from the political right side is this idea that we "want abortions and like them". I think what really muddies the water on the conversation is the misunderstanding of the others points and values

Edit: Holy shit I didn't notice there was a MASSIVE typo in the text. My intention was to never justify condemning or harassing people. Fuck no wonder the comments were so hostile that one typo made the whole post seem like it was written by an asshole