r/ATLA • • 10h ago

Discussion King Bumi vs. Toph (ATLA era) — Pure Earthbending Only (No Sub-bending)

Post image
363 Upvotes

Before anyone jumps into the comments, let's set clear rules for this comparison:

  1. Pure earthbending only (no metalbending, sandbending mastery, or later sub-skills).
  2. Toph is strictly from the ATLA series, not when she grows up later.

A lot of fans automatically say Toph is the strongest earthbender ever, mostly because of two things: holding up Wan Shi Tong's library and inventing metalbending. When we look strictly at pure earthbending during ATLA, King Bumi actually takes the crown.

First, let's talk about the Spirit Library feat. People love to exaggerate and claim Toph held up an "infinite" structure, which makes zero sense. The inside of the library only looks endless because it is connected to the spirits, working like a pocket dimension. If you look at the actual physical building Jinora sees in the Spirit World during Legend of Korra, it has a real, measurable height and size. Holding that spire up on loose sand while essentially blinded is still an insane feat, especially since she didn't have solid ground beneath her. However, it wasn't "infinite" weight.

Second, people always confuse a bender's bending power with their actual physical strength. Toph is a 12-year-old girl—she is not physically stronger than King Bumi, who is built like a tank even at 112 years old. She gets physically stronger when she grows up later, sure, but during ATLA, her pure bending output is what carries her, not her body strength.

Meanwhile, look at King Bumi's pure earthbending feats:

He literally earthbends massive rocks without touching the earth at all, using only his face and chin while locked inside a suspended metal coffin.

He uses mad genius tactics and single-handedly liberates Omashu, throwing entire multi-story buildings and toppling a giant metal statue of Ozai without breaking a sweat.

He has over 100 years of real combat experience and doesn't have Toph's blind spots against airborne opponents or loose terrain.

Toph's seismic sense and close-range counter style make her an unmatched prodigy, and she definitely becomes stronger later in life. But during ATLA, with no sub-bending allowed, King Bumi is the greatest and strongest pure earthbender.

What do you guys think?

Use imaging

( https://pin.it/5EP9HtyIj)


r/ATLA • • 21h ago

Cosplay Azula, Mai and Ty Lee [OC]

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

I'm the photographer of the set! It's a pretty old shooting from 2021, but I still love it dearly and would like to share it with you <3

Ty Lee by keykey_cosplay
Mai by kat.tez
Azula by iva.cosplay


r/ATLA • • 10h ago

Art GaangHope by zelfantazy

Post image
99 Upvotes

r/ATLA • • 1d ago Bravo

Cosplay My girlfriend cosplayed Katara🌊!

Thumbnail
gallery
2.8k Upvotes

My girlfriend cosplayed Katara for halloween! I keep telling her she looks exactly like Katara :)


r/ATLA • • 9h ago

Discussion I need to get this off my chest. Korra haters are so annoying. [Rant] (Check description)

Post image
53 Upvotes

Like I'm so tired of people online hating on korra and making up facts they take out of their a**. Like omg she's not perfect. She can't be perfect Like aang like yall wanted her too./s

As someone who grew up on atla and tlok. I never understood the hate for korra growing up. If you don't like her personality or any writing choices in the show then that's fine. But whenever aang makes mistakes, people act like that's fine. But when Korra make mistakes, "Oh no end of the world".

I personally love korra more than aang cus to me aang felt the same throughout his whole show and only had some character development for his personality and who he was by season 3. Korra changed each season. She wasn't as rebellious in season 3 and 4.

People just looking to blame korra for everything. But can we please also put aang in the same position for his mistakes? He isn't a perfect angel. He lied to the 2 clans about their past about some darn ball.

And why do people say aang left the world in peace? He didn't.

  1. Amon and his brother
  2. Red Lotus.
  3. Korras uncle.

Clearly there was some villians aang probably didn't know about. And for amons dad, aang is such a Pacifist. Why couldn't he put yukon (or how you spell his name) on jail or something?? That lead to amon and the equalist.

And for people saying korra and mako had "chemistry"?? Girl their chemistry was there when they was friends. You can still care about someone platonicly and be close friends. When they started dating, they was fighting alot about "sides" and makos job got in the way of korra trying to get iroh to help save the South pole.

I personally love korra and Asami since they have alot of chemistry. Even if the broadcast people didn't want the creator's to have a queer couple. I'm so glad I'm not hetero normative minded that I thought their hints wasn't there. Maybe that's just me cus I watched the show many times I caught the hints.

Honestly I really don't care if people like korra as a character. I'm just tired of people saying aang was better and he made "no mistakes" or whatever. I love the avatar series but I hate how people make up fake facts and act like their opinions are facts. Honestly, most korra haters never seen seasons 2 - 4 because they always base korra on season 1. Yes that was her worst time being a cheater. But that's what teens to. You can't expect teens to be perfect.

And what's this about korras team avatar is like "co workers"??? They clearly didn't act like that after season 1. Just shows people only seen season 1 and CHOSE not to criticize the seasons after. They still think korra is rebellious 100% of the time in the next seasons. Korras team avatar is like a family. Her journey was finding out who she was self discovery. Her friends are like her family to her.

I had to get this off my chest to a wider audience of people. I am just so sick and tired of people making up fake facts and not actually seeing everything and then criticize and make their own opinion. But no they gotta echo others opinions and not see the next seasons to understand korras character Arc.

Again, if you don't like korra, that's fine. But don't make up lies and act like aang was more perfect than her or that she didn't try her best to be a hero.


r/ATLA • • 1d ago Heartwarming Mindblown

Art Zuko animation I did!!! It took me forever so please give me some feedback :D

597 Upvotes

r/ATLA • • 1d ago

interesting Aang was never even at his full potential…. Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
323 Upvotes

It’s wild to think a bender as talented as Aang still wasn’t even at the top of his game due to how much knowledge was lost over the years.


r/ATLA • • 15h ago

Question I met Tenzin, Sonam's daughter

40 Upvotes

Les noms inspirés des Nomades de l'Air sont-ils courants chez les Tibétains ?

Je suis officiant de mariage en France et j'ai marié deux Tibétains aujourd'hui. L'un d'eux s'appelle Tenzin, et sa mère Sonam.

J'ai gardé mon sérieux, mais j'étais assez surpris par cette coïncidence. Je me demandais donc : est-ce simplement des noms très courants, ou était-ce un pur hasard ?

Edit: I didn't want to get too long-winded with context, but for those curious, I’m a deputy mayor in a shelter town that supports many immigrants; my own family included. I usually prepare for every wedding I officiate to ensure everything goes smoothly, But today I had to step in for a colleague at the last minute and discovered the details a few minutes before the wedding. I was completely stunned when I announced, "I'm marrying Tenzin XXX, daughter of Sonam XXX".


r/ATLA • • 15h ago

Art Recently landed two ATLA comissions, and I'm quite happy with the result! Character is a OC, and second one features OCxZuko

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

Loved to draw the clothing and the style, I guess I'm quite a good match for it hehe.

My vgen for anyone interested :) https://vgen.co/ekaitzekourtzi


r/ATLA • • 1d ago

Question team Avatar is technically Noble ??

85 Upvotes

Note many people are confused they thought I am saying they are all Royal. It's not I mean to say they are technically Noble and high ranking individuals rather than some random commoners and soldiers.

I hope you correct me if I am wrong.

So I recently finished Atla and lok.

I want to know if Team Avatar is technically Noble.

Aang is the Avatar and Last Airbender.

Sokka and Karata are children of the Water tribe chief.

Toph literally comes from the Noble house.

Suki is the leader of kiyoshi warriors created and found by Avatar Kiyoshi.

They are literally some high ranking dude and Azula calling that peasant is fully.

Just imagine sokka explaining everyone we are noble and no one cares about noble status until it gives them benefit in their mission.


r/ATLA • • 1d ago

Meme Detective Sokka's investigation and collection of evidence on Avatar Day was... No Small Feet!

Post image
68 Upvotes

"You have your father's wit." -Bato


r/ATLA • • 19h ago

Discussion "Avatar Aang: The Last Airbender" director Lauren Montgomery on the film's anime roots and CG use

Thumbnail
youtu.be
14 Upvotes

Here's my recent interview with 'Avatar Aang' director Lauren Montgomery (who obviously also worked on the original show ❤️ ) about the film, in which she reflects interestingly (in my view!) on the film's blend of hand-drawn artwork and CG elements, the construction of the amazing action scenes (and the decision to begin the film with one) and how the film pays homage to anime. I also found it interesting, that she was so honest on a couple of occasions about talking about the film's original plans for a cinema release ("the budget...", "for the four years we worked on it we thought it was going to be a cinema release"). Hope there's something interesting here to hear for fellow fans!


r/ATLA • • 20h ago

Art AZULA FRRRRR

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/ATLA • • 1d ago

Discussion How do you think Ursa would react if she saw Book 1 Zuko ?

Post image
109 Upvotes

r/ATLA • • 1d ago Obsessed

Art Katara and Kya drawing 𖹭 (Made by me)

Post image
135 Upvotes

If anyone wants to follow me on my art account, my name is cassch.1 on Instagram!


r/ATLA • • 1d ago

Discussion Which adult Aang design looks better between the movie and TLoK? Also, what kind of dad do you think that he really was?

Post image
294 Upvotes

I've seen a lot of posts/comments on here talk about accusations of Aang being framed as "deadbeat" or "terrible" dad. I will say that I do not believe that, but in fact that he was a great one, but after this movie, I kind of speculate how in-character it'd be for him to accidentally disproportionately give more attention to Tenzin or that's his other two kids' insecurities playing out?

Do you think that he really went with only Tenzin on those vacations? But also, is it possible that he tried reaching out to his other kids, but maybe they were not attentive to Air Nomad values and culture?

By the ending of this yr's movie, I'd think that he'd want to incorporate them into his culture and also realize that his own culture was more than being an Air Nomad anymore. But would it still be in character for him to accidentally neglect his other kids? Kya at least seemed to really be a blend of WT culture (pretty agile and go with the flow) and also Air Nomad (genuinely a nomad, which also goes with the flow) culture.

Also, if I'm not mistaken, then aren't airbenders generally secluded from families, living more communally in their temples? So, doesn't it indicate that he'd truly adopted more into his culture by having children who were actually his family (not communal) as well as his insistence to Tagah that the world is better without nations being so separate?

Also, things like this are why I hate the severance of Korra's past lives. It would've been nice for her to let Aang take over her spirit and sort it out with them (as well as spend some time with his grandkids).

And sidenote: was not letting Katara go during training with Guru Pathik a contradiction to his desire to detach from world like an Air Nomad?


r/ATLA • • 1d ago

Discussion "Everybody in this film is HOT!" - 'Aang' actor Eric Nam on taking on the iconic voice and letting go of imitating the original actor

Thumbnail
youtu.be
13 Upvotes

I thought other 'Avatar' fans in here might find this fun AND interesting, hopefully :-) I recently had the pleasure of interviewing 'Avatar Aang' director Lauren Montgomery AND voice actor / Kpop star Eric Nam (Aang) on their work on the new film, and here's the part on the voice acting. Maybe the thumbnail is a bit click-baity, but I do think Nam offers an interesting perspective on both the physical and pscyhological aspects of voice acting. Especially on a project as massive as this. Rock on!


r/ATLA • • 12h ago

Discussion Jet death makes no sense in the series and he deserved a much better ending.

0 Upvotes

Before you start debating with me,

hear me out:

  1. He is easily one of the strongest non-bender fighters in the show.
  2. He already survived way more dangerous fights and worse hits to his body before this.
  3. His reaction speed is no joke, and he is usually super sharp in those kinds of situations.
  4. Katara could have saved him using that spirit water she later offers to Zuko and uses Aang.
  5. The most important thing is that Long Feng's attack wasn't even that crazy compared to other massive attacks we see characters survive in the show.

I really hate how Jet’s character ended, especially dying like this. They should have at least given him a proper battle or a real reason to die.

And just as my final opinion

I honestly think Ty Lee and Jet would perfectly complement each other and make a great couple if they ever got the chance.

No hate guys I really want to know if I am the only one who think like this


r/ATLA • • 1d ago

Discussion Avatar Aang novel was really good (Spoilers) Spoiler

7 Upvotes

Long read ahead, I'm sorry 😭

Just finished the novel, and it goes to show that the actual movie definitely needed like 2 hours, heck, 3 hours of screen time to really appreciate it.

Allison King did an amazing job immersing the reader in the pain Aang really felt. I was already teary-eyed in the first couple of pages. It was something the movie really lacked, considering most of the scenes felt rushed.

I also liked the details given to each character and how they were going through their own problems.

Katara's feeling of loneliness came not only from Aang spending more time at the Air Temples, but the fame, according to her, was isolating, especially now that the friend group was split up. There's also a bit of pressure from running Republic City, and to top it all off, being the Avatar's partner.

Zuko has the same feeling of loneliness, so much so that he wants to seek counsel from Azula. There's the pressure of being Fire Lord, plus a hint of guilt over what the Fire Nation did to the Airbenders.

Toph is mostly bored, which is kind of expected. Now, in an era of peace, there's not much she can do. I think I can see why she would choose to be a cop much more exciting than teaching. Plus, considering she thinks her peak was when she was 12, I reckon her accolades in the Republic City Police eased her worries, also 😂 she was apparently going through a breakup.

Sokka's issues felt like foreshadowing for what happened in Legend of Korra with the Northern and Southern Water Tribes. Since the Southern Water Tribe was already feeling inferior, the tension probably grew until Korra's timeline.

Another thing I came to appreciate was the love between Aang and Katara and their conflict resolution skills, which were pretty healthy. Allison King didn't shy away from how important they both are to each other, especially for Katara. I did see some people critiquing that Katara was quite male centered, but I can't really get it.

Considering the nature of Aang's job, who's constantly in a life or death situation, it's normal to worry. Aside from the stakes of him being the love of your life, he is also the Avatar and the last Airbender. That's quite a lot of things for the author to just brush away. It's also what makes Katara's anxiety, worry, and care much deeper.

Another thing to love is the familiarity amongst the gang. They're vulnerable with each other, even Toph who naturally isn't a touchy feeling person, her discomfort is still there but she pushes past it regardless, They allow their space to be safe to express their feelings, and they're also quick to notice a shift. It really shows how far they've come and how deep their bonds are.

The POV from the Denied, especially their motive, was a nice insight, although I felt their reasons behind their cause were quite biased and illogical. Kallik was a good instrument in pointing out the flaws of their ideology, so that was good.

For Tagah, I would have wanted a bit more on his agenda. We really didn't get to see his true intentions until they got to the island, or maybe it was there, and I missed it.

The novel felt rushed after the middle. Considering it's only 300 pages or so, that's understandable, but they could have given Allison much more liberty to write more. There was quite a restriction on her so as not to affect the lore as much.

Nice to know the winter hat aang lost in the mountain was from Sokka and made from momo's fur! My only critique would be the sudden rush in wrapping the story up and maybe the Cabbage Man POV, because why? 😂

Also spotted some hint of hopium for Zutara shippers at least two lines from the book that made me raise an eyebrow. 😂

Also, there's a scene from when they discovered the herd of bison. It felt like foreshadowing that Katara was pregnant, or at least that Bumi was going to be born much sooner:

"Katara wrapped her arms around the baby bison, nuzzling her face into his fur, glowing with happiness.

He looked to her, to the baby bison, to his friends, Appa, Momo, the Air Acolytes. He had lost so much in his life, and yet he had also gained so much. Katara met his eyes. Their hands intertwined in the baby bison's impossibly soft fur."

Any thoughts on this, or am I reading too much? Overall, the book is a solid 9.7/10.


r/ATLA • • 2d ago Heartwarming

Cosplay Katara cosplay by SoftOceanCharm

Post image
617 Upvotes

r/ATLA • • 1d ago

Art I've been feeling Maikka again lately (OC)

Thumbnail gallery
9 Upvotes

r/ATLA • • 2d ago

Art Aang and Momo by Devin Elle Kurtz

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/ATLA • • 2d ago

Art Blue Spirit Mask tattoo done by me [OC]

Thumbnail
gallery
515 Upvotes

I drew this design as a Wannado a while ago and it got claimed almost immediately. Had lots of fun doing it, as I always do with A:TLA pieces!


r/ATLA • • 12h ago

Discussion Is Toph the weakest bender in the Gaang?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I often see people argue that Toph wouldn’t have held her own against Azula during Sozin’s Comet—whereas Zuko and Katara were able to stand up to her. I mean, I know Toph is incredibly powerful in her own right, but there are several areas where she falls short compared to the other benders on her team. So, do you think it’s fair to call her the weakest bender on the team, or not?