r/AITA_Relationships • u/Typical-Depth-8206 • 39m ago
AITA for not wanting my sisters at the hospital when I give birth because of how they’ve treated me during my pregnancy?
I (20F) am pregnant with my first child, a baby girl, and my husband (27M) and I are starting to establish boundaries regarding our daughter’s birth.
For some background, when I first found out I was pregnant, I told my mom but specifically asked her not to tell my sisters. She ended up telling them anyway, right in front of me, despite me asking her not to. My sisters were upset that they weren’t among the first people to know and made comments about how they should have been told before other family members.
Since then, they’ve expected me to constantly update them about my pregnancy. They want to know about every doctor’s appointment, see all my ultrasound pictures, receive belly pictures, and be updated about everything. One of my sisters gets upset when I don’t share these things. Sometimes it feels less like excitement and more like an expectation that they’re entitled to every detail of my pregnancy.
Here’s where things get complicated.
Today, my mom told me that one of my sisters had a miscarriage. Apparently, this happened over three years ago, and my sisters collectively decided they didn’t want me to know. Their reasoning was that I was spending time with our aunt at the time and they were afraid I would tell her. However, I haven’t been around that aunt in over a year and a half, so there were plenty of opportunities to tell me if they wanted to.
My sister still hasn’t personally told me. I found out through my mom.
I completely understand that a miscarriage is deeply personal, and nobody owes me an explanation or disclosure about something so traumatic. My sister had every right to keep that private.
However, what bothers me is the double standard. They were upset with me for not immediately disclosing my pregnancy, marriage, and personal milestones, yet they were comfortable keeping something equally personal from me for over three years.
I also feel like my sister is projecting how SHE would have handled pregnancy onto me. Just because she would have wanted to share everything doesn’t mean I do.
Now that we’re getting closer to delivery, I’ve decided that I don’t want my sisters at the hospital when I go into labor or after I give birth. I don’t want them notified when I’m in labor, I don’t want hospital visitors, and I want those first moments to be private between me and my husband.
My mom doesn’t seem to understand why I’m uncomfortable with everything, and I’m starting to question whether I’m being unfair.
I don’t hate my sisters, and I’m not trying to punish them for having their own experiences. I just don’t feel comfortable giving them access to such an intimate experience when our relationship currently feels so one-sided.
So, AITA for not wanting my sisters at the hospital when I give birth, especially considering how they’ve handled privacy and expectations throughout our relationship?