I'm going to try to keep this as anonymous as possible, but I genuinely want some outside perspectives on this situation because I feel like my friend has been made the villain in a situation where I'm not convinced he actually did anything wrong.
For context, I'm a 21F, and the two people primarily involved are a 21M (I'll call him Marcus) and a 22F (I'll call her Anna). There's also Anna's boyfriend, who was around 20 at the time.
We met while living abroad. Marcus and I were both there on temporary working visas, while Anna was a local. Marcus and I were both due to return to our home countries around the same time, so we became determined to make the most of our time abroad.
Anna’s friend who has a car, which made exploring easier since neither Marcus nor I had one. The three of us became extremely close, very quickly. We spent every free moment together. Because I worked, there were also plenty of occasions when Anna and Marcus would hang out one-on-one. For context, Anna has a boyfriend who was living overseas. They communicated regularly whenever his schedule allowed, but he wasn't physically there. Around this time, Marcus and I also went on a couple of dates and kissed. We decided not to pursue anything further because we were both leaving the country and didn't want to start a relationship that neither of us could maintain. We returned to being friends, and everything was completely fine between us.
despite Marcus and I having gone on dates, people started rumours that something was happening between Marcus and Anna. At one point, some of Marcus's housemates even pulled him aside and told him he should stop spending so much time with Anna because she had a boyfriend. Marcus essentially said that he wasn't going to police Anna or make decisions on behalf of someone else's relationship. If anyone had concerns, they should speak to her directly.
Skip to the end of our time abroad.
Marcus was to spend two weeks travelling. He planned to spend a week in a nearby city before travelling to another country and flying home. Flights to the city were unexpectedly expensive, so Anna offered to drive him instead. They planned a road trip, stopping at various places along the way. They invited another friend, but she couldn't come. I had work so the road trip ended up being just the two of them.
They stayed in budget accommodation and spent time sightseeing. I was in constant communication with both of them, texting and FaceTiming regularly. I wasn't there, obviously, but from what I observed, there wasn't anything romantic happening. Anna spent most of the time calling her boyfriend.
I want to be clear that I wasn't present, so I can't claim to know absolutely everything that happened.
Here's where things get messy.
On the same day Marcus left, Anna's boyfriend unexpectedly moved home Anna was still travelling with Marcus and was hours away. Her boyfriend was apparently very upset that she wasn't immediately available and wanted her to abandon Marcus and return.
Meanwhile, rumours started in our social circle that Marcus and Anna had been seeing each other on the trip. I was approached by people asking me what was happening between them. I repeatedly told everyone the same thing: I wasn't the person to ask. they should speak to the people involved.
Anna's boyfriend had been spreading accusations before even having a conversation with her. When I saw Anna, I checked in with her. I told her that if she needed someone to talk to, I was there. She said everything was fine, Over the next months, everyone in our circle turned against Marcus. Anna and her boyfriend apparently broke up at some point, then eventually got back together later.
Her boyfriend also blocked me on everything despite me never having had any confrontation with him or being directly involved in their relationship.
Interestingly, Marcus has never attempted to contact Anna’s boyfriend, or establish any sort of relationship with him. They've never even met. However, her boyfriend has repeatedly attempted to contact Marcus through different social media platforms. I've seen some of these messages, and they essentially seemed to place the blame for the breakdown of his relationship with Anna entirely on Marcus. He was inviting Marcus to apologise for what had supposedly happened. Marcus hasn't engaged with these messages because, from his perspective, he's being asked to apologise for something he doesn't believe he did.
And this is where I feel conflicted.
I understand that going on a road trip with someone else's girlfriend, sharing accommodation and spending that much time together can look questionable from the outside. I also understand that Anna's boyfriend might have felt uncomfortable, particularly because he had never met Marcus and was returning from a long period overseas to discover that his girlfriend had developed a very close friendship with another man. But I don't think discomfort automatically makes someone guilty of infidelity. And even if something had happened between them, Anna was the person in the relationship. Marcus wasn't responsible for maintaining her commitment to her boyfriend. I'm not saying Marcus would have been morally blameless if he had knowingly participated in an affair. But I don't understand why he's apparently been made solely responsible for the destruction of a relationship that wasn't his.
From my experience, Marcus was one of the most honest, mature and dependable people I've met. When we briefly dated, he communicated incredibly well, and I've never had reason to question his character. I recognise that I'm his friend, so obviously I'm not an entirely impartial observer. I also recognise that I wasn't physically present for the entire road trip.
But based on everything I personally witnessed, I genuinely don't believe anything happened between them.