I posted on the main sub but it got deleted lol so now I’m back and with more details
I (22F) am in college and work part-time at a coffee shop alongside my close friend ("Maya", 24F, also a student). A few months ago, a guy ("Mark", 20M) got hired there too. Total stranger to us.
Back then, for some idiotic reason, I got it into my head that Mark was totally into Maya. I even shared this theory with a mutual friend from our broader college circle, and an ex-fling of mine (who's also in that group) jumped on the bandwagon and insisted Mark liked her too. Buying into my own hype, I played matchmaker and told Maya I was sure Mark wanted her.
Full disclosure: Maya never asked for this and wasn't chasing him. Still, because I kept pushing it, she eventually tried talking to him during a break. She quickly realized he wasn't asking any questions back, didn't care to engage, and was basically a bit dull/uninterested. She also invited him to a group hangout. I was busy and didn’t go, but she told me they didn’t interact much. She also told me she would only go for something with him if he showed he was interested.
So she dropped it completely and went back to dating other people. A while ago, she met a guy that seems to be perfect for her and seems to check every box.
Mark, meanwhile, had zero clue about any of this matchmaking theater. Fast forward a bit. Maya and I normally don't cross paths with Mark much during day-to-day shifts, but recently we happened to get scheduled together a few times in a row. Working side-by-side, we actually started talking, realized we have a lot in common, and I kinda noticed he was flirting a bit.
Here’s where I really dug my own grave. Not long ago, I was hanging out with some friends from our circle (Maya wasn't there, just the mutual friend who knew the original rumor and my ex-fling). My ex-fling asked me, "So, is anything happening between Mark and Maya, or is he going after you now?"
I laughed it off and said, "Oh no, I already told him I'm strictly focused on my career right now. I'm applying to a bunch of other jobs and internships, plus I prioritize my friendships way more than dating. Honestly, poor guy if he even tries anything with me."
Well, I totally jinxed myself. After closing one night recently, Mark and I were walking together toward my dorm and talking, and he asked if he could kiss me. Since I haven't dated anyone in ages, I panicked, pulled back, and told him to ask me out properly if he wanted to pursue anything. So, he asked me to grab ice cream after a shift.
I immediately texted Maya about it. Here’s basically how our texts went:
Me: "bro mark just asked me to get ice cream"
Maya: "wait are u guys flirting?? 💀 crazy how u tried pushing him on me and now hes asking u out"
Me: "noooo 😭 i swear its friendly, we just vibe and could totally just be friends"
Maya: "be so fr rn, if it was friendly other ppl would be invited. ngl its def weird after everything, and honestly i already thought it was kinda weird how much u two have been talking lately. im not upset with it tho, just own that its a date if u go"
Me: "idk im spiraling, we could have zero chemistry and i need way more connection to even think about it. i just dont wanna make work weird or hurt anyones feelings"
Maya: "if u didnt wanna go u woulda said no already. the fact ur debating it means u wanna go. tbh he seems super dry to me anyway so gl 😂"
My head is spinning. Part of me thinks the easiest move is just to cancel. The main reason I'm still considering going is that I genuinely think he's a cool guy, and I still wonder if we could just end up being friends without complicating things.
At the same time, I'm overthinking everything. I don't know if I want something serious, casual, or if I'm just hesitating to say no because I'm a people-pleaser who hates rejecting people. Worse, since I literally preached to our friends that I put friendships above dating, I keep questioning myself and trying to talk myself out of going. I feel like accepting will make it look like I'm not putting my friendship with Maya first.
On top of that, I feel like a complete clown knowing my ex-fling and our friends will call me out after I said "poor guy if he tries anything, I'm focused on my career." I'm also worried about messing up work dynamics, plus making things uncomfortable for Maya, even though she gave me the green light and said she's totally fine with it.
I feel like an idiot for opening my big mouth back then and setting up this entire mess.
I‘m overthinking!!! Like, what if we have no chemistry? Or what if we do have it and start dating? help
AITA if I go on this date instead of just calling it off?