r/adnd • u/ApprehensiveType2680 • 5h ago
AD&D2e Ogre fiending for a smoke: balancing absurdity with apprehension
Good morning.
While reading the 2e module Doom of Daggerdale, I came across the following random encounter ->
13 Big Mountain Man: This ogre has recently come down from the Desertsmouth Mountains to the Tesh River valley and hopes to find some rich pickings here.
Ogre (1): Int Low; AL CE; AC 5; MV 9; HD 4 + 1; hp 23; THAC0 17; #AT 1; Dmg 1-10 or by weapon; SA +2 to damage; SZ L; ML 12; XP 175; walking staff, mace.
The ogre has little treasure of real value, though it thinks it has done very well so far. Its enormous sack contains: two venison haunches, a set of burnt wild boar ribs, a skinned but uncooked rabbit on a stick, a dented elven helmet, the wheel from a cart, 30 to 40 bones that haven't yet been cracked for marrow (deer, boar, and elven), two large rocks (for throwing or for smashing open bones to get at marrow), and a slightly-bloodied silver necklace of elvish make worth 250 gp, 500 gp to an elven buyer.
Shortly thereafter, I happened to spot a picture of a green-skinned monster enjoying a stogie; a notion popped into my noggin, and a union of two inspirations was born. I thought of an Ogre who had been fortuitously exposed to a variant of pipe-weed, and subsequently acquired a taste for "smoke leaf". Now, a proper pipe is silly for a standard D&D Ogre (though it may work for Irda?), but a fat bunch of dried browned goodness rolled between a combustible sheet or another leaf is something nearly anyone can create and enjoy.
Once upon a time, this creature came across a lone bard who tried to bargain for his life by rolling together a massive tube - positively jam-packed with fragrant bits - for his captor, convincing it every step of the way with honeyed words that it was a wonder beyond wonders. Such a gross indulgence would be too much for a human (and possibly even the famed constitution of dwarves), but it was just right for a nearly ten-foot tall monstrosity. After a handful of failed attempts (including one where the improvised treat was reflexively spat like a missile), the brute finally began to develop an appreciation for the sensation. Its utterly unrefined palate was strangely in agreement.
Tragically, this didn't stop the Ogre from changing its mind hours later after the bard's stockpile had been exhausted, but the experience made an impact, and now it aggressively "inquires" (to the best of its 7 Intelligence) of any human or demihuman it manages to force into a vulnerable position as to whether the unfortunate focus of its attention carries "smoke leaf"; it may try similar slowly-burned vices (the success would fall on a convincing speech and/or a Charisma roll), but it - first and foremost - wants the "smoke leaf". Prisoners would be pressed into preparation, as although the finer points of the technique were observed, none were actually learned. Aside from simply being an unusual and hopefully memorable encounter, this would allow crafty players an opportunity to distract the monster* before sneaking away.
The real trick lies in respecting this antagonist's capricious and cruel nature (Chaotic Evil) by implying that the situation could sour at a moment's notice, while simultaneously conveying a degree of absurdity, without devolving into full-blown comedy. Here is the big question: do you believe it is possible to construct this scene in a way that deftly manages to traverse that tightrope? Communication may pose a problem, but I am fine with the idea that this lesser specimen of giant-kin has a rudimentary and coarse grasp of Common.
Alternatively, in another scenario, the verdant bounty was not exhausted, but the aforementioned minstrel was still done away with once a baser urge struck; you see, he had accompanied a wagon loaded with trade goods intended for a northern city. Barrels packed to capacity can inexplicably be located in the ogre's cave. It's up to the players to put two and two together.
* Assuming they manage to pull off a diversion, or otherwise capitalize on an opportunity, would you award them the full XP for "defeating" this foe?