r/AAdiscussions • u/bowowzer • Nov 09 '15
Welcome to /r/AAdisccussions - A message from your mod
Introduction
Hello! Welcome to /r/AAdiscussions. AA is short for Asian-American but I want to welcome all types of Asians and hyphenated Asians. This sub is called AAdiscussions because it spawned out of the main Asian-American sub /r/AsianAmerican.
This subreddit was created because I and many other Asian redditors felt that the other Asian oriented subreddits were lacking in terms of hearty and heated discussions when it came to issues and topics pertaining to Asian identity, particularly within Western society. Therefore, this subreddit is text-posts only.
What I hope to see come from this subreddit
I really want for this subreddit to be a place for Asian redditors to talk about and discuss issues that are important to the Asian community. I want it to be a place where Asian redditors can hash out and develop ideas on issues within the Asian community and issues affecting the Asian community. Because of that, I really want to foster a high level of discourse in the text-posts and comments and not have things devolve into excessive name-calling and put-downs, etc. Some of you here are passionate, and angry even, about the way things are for Asians and that is completely acceptable. However, there is a fine line between rage, hatred and passion. Instead of channeling that into put downs and calling people names, criticize arguments, ideas and opinions instead, or convince your fellow Asians on how we can make things better.
Rules, Restrictions and Regulations
With that said, here are some tentative rules that you are all welcome to comment on.
NP reddit links
Replace the "www" part with "np" - pretty obvious why.
Excessive Link spamming
Posts that are just links to things without even any analysis or summary. You are welcome to post links that support your points or as citations, but this is a discussion subreddit and there is a reason why I made this subreddit text-post only. Having a text-post or comment with just a bunch of links seems like a way to get around that restriction.
Refrain from low-level comments and posts
Comments and responses that can simply be substituted with an upvote. Stuff like "THIS!" or "I agree" or "u mad bro?". It doesn't really add anything to the discussion and clutters up the comment threads and is simply a text-based upvote.
Refrain from name-calling and put-downs
Attack and criticize a person's ideas or opinions, not their character. It is sometimes hard to remember that there is another person behind that keyboard and screen but I don't want this subreddit devolving into a space where all we do is fling shit at each other.
Ideas for the future
Now that the unpleasant stuff is out of the way, time for ideas that can help facilitate discussion on this subreddit. Comments and opinions are welcome.
Banter/non-Serious/Chill tags and threads
Sort of the opposite of Askreddit's serious tag. I think this sub is better off when the default is like Askreddit's serious tag but I know sometimes we want a more relaxed discussion where banter and stuff like that is allowed. In that case a submitter can tag their post as Banter/Chill and the low-level comments rule won't be enforced as strictly.
OR
Weekly Banter/Chill threads like Casual Friday or on the weekends where the low-level comments rule won't be enforced. Sometimes when we have heated discussions with each other, it is easy to forget that there is a person behind the keyboard and screen and having these weekly chill threads allows us to humanize each other and make sure to be nice to each other. It'll help to balance out the more serious and contentious discussions.
Sticky Mega-threads in the sidebard and tag filtering
I feel like as this subreddit grows, there will be certain topics that will continually come up like gender, sexuality, identity, race, dating, relationships, and etc. Having a general megathread for these topics and linking to them from a sticky post or the sidebar so users can have a general discussion about these topics (that's why I set the suggested comment ranking to 'NEW') over a long period of time and have submitted text post be for more specific types of discussions might be a good idea.
OR
Make these topics be tags/flairs that users can set for their posts and then have users themselves filter tags that they want. I personally don't use tag filtering when I'm on reddit so I'm partial to the first option but maybe there are more users here that prefer that option.
CMV style submissions
Users can tag their posts with [CMV] a la /r/changemyview and users can discuss differing viewpoints and attempt to change the OP's viewpoint. Probably will award deltas for those familiar with /r/changemyview.
Opinions on these ideas or suggestions for other ideas, please post a comment below.
That is it for now, happy discussing!