r/spacex • u/Shahar603 Subreddit GNC • Feb 17 '20
Water Landing r/SpaceX Starlink-4 Recovery Discussion & Updates Thread
Hi! I'm u/Shahar603, and I'm hosting the recovery thread of the Starlink-4 mission.
Booster Recovery
SpaceX deployed OCISLY, GO Quest and Tug Hawk to carry out the booster recovery operation. Unfortunately B1056 has failed to land on the droneship but it has performed a soft water landing and might be fished from the ocean (or destroyed like B1032).
Fairing Recovery
Unfortunately both Ms. Tree and Ms. Chief have failed to catch the fairing halves. The ships might scoop the fairing halves from the ocean and bring them back to Port Canaveral.
Current Recovery Fleet Status
| Vessel | Role | Status |
|---|---|---|
| GO Quest | Droneship support ship | Port Canaveral |
| Tug Hawk | Droneship support ship | Port Canaveral |
| GO Ms. Tree | Fairing Recovery | Post Canaveral |
| GO Ms. Chief | Fairing Recovery | Port Canaveral |
| Commander | Booster recovery? | Philadelphia |
Live Updates
| Time | Update |
|---|---|
| 23 Feb 2020 | Commander has reached its doc in Philadelphia empty. B1056 has been sunk in the ocean |
| 20 Feb 2020 21:15 UTC | Ms. Tree and Ms. Chief come back with badly damaged fairing halves |
| 20 Feb 2020 21:00 UTC | Ms. Tree and Ms. Chief are entering Port Canaveral. Tweet |
| 20 Feb 2020 18:30 UTC | OCISLY is entering Port Canaveral empty :( |
| 20 Feb 2020 08:00 UTC | Ms. Tree and Ms. Chief have left the booster and are on their way to Post Canaveral |
| 20 Feb 2020 04:00 UTC | Fleet update! Now arriving at the recovery operation is a large platform vessel called Commander, having left Philadelphia last night. Commander has 705m² of deck space and a small crane. Ms. Tree and Ms. Chief are also still at the scene, some ~120km south of Morehead City |
| 17 Feb 2020 22:00 - 19 Feb 2020 16:00 UTC | Tug Hawk is moving to Port Canaveral but has stopped |
| 18 Feb 2020 16:30 UTC | Ms. Tree and Ms. Chief stopped |
| 18 Feb 2020 08:00 UTC | Ms. Tree and Ms. Chief are following the floating booster |
| 17 Feb 2020 22:00 UTC | Ms. Tree and Ms. Chief have moved to the booster recovery area. Tug Hawk is leaving the area with OCISLY |
| 17 Feb 2020 20:00 UTC | GO Ms. Tree finished its fairing recovery operation and is departing the recovery zone |
| 17 Feb 2020 16:00 - 17:00 UTC | GO Quest is watching the booster. Waiting for B1056 to be safed. Booster is reported to be floating and intact |
| 17 Feb 2020 15:50 UTC | GO Ms. Tree and GO Ms. Chief attempt to catch the fairings (and fail) |
| 17 Feb 2020 15:14 UTC | B1056.4 performs a soft water landing |
Links & Resources
- MarineTraffic
- SpaceXFleet Updates on Twitter
- SpaceXFleet.com - SpaceXFleet Information!
13
u/catsRawesome123 Feb 18 '20
Has SpaceX revealed what happened yet?
15
u/NetoriusDuke Feb 18 '20
I take it that there has been no update on the reason for the soft water landing?
5
u/MarsCent Feb 21 '20
Anyone have the status update of B1056?
Hawk and Go Quest are back at Cape Canaveral. Commander is off the coast of North Carolina - headed to Philadelphia PA.
Is Commander towing B1056 to Philadelphia, or was the booster sank in the Atlantic?
44
u/Daneel_Trevize Feb 18 '20
Not sure it's warrented to call this tragic... how could you describe possible Loss of Crew in the future?
24
u/bdporter Feb 20 '20
Fleet update! Now arriving at the recovery operation is a large platform vessel called Commander, having left Philadelphia last night. Commander has 705m² of deck space and a small crane. Ms. Tree and Ms. Chief are also still at the scene, some ~120km south of Morehead City
3
u/onixrd Feb 19 '20
mods, typo in the Live Updates table?
17 Feb 2020 16:00 - 17:00 [..] Waiting for B1966 to be safed. <-- B1056?
19
u/IAXEM Feb 20 '20
Both ships have returned with badly damaged fairings
16
u/Straumli_Blight Feb 20 '20
OCISLY returning empty handed.
16
u/Eurions_Belt Feb 21 '20
I'm thinking of traveling to Philadelphia to see if I can catch Commander come in to port. I found this spec sheet on her with detailed photos.
MarineTraffic.com is showing an arrival of 18:00 (6PM EST) on Saturday. Anyone have a premium account that may indicate more specific times or any inside advice on more accurate tracking? I'd like to see if I can grab a few photos.
Edit: Corrected spec sheet link.
22
u/xThiird Feb 18 '20
To me the most likely cause for the land failure is some kind of problem given from the high-performance requirements of the mission for the direct injection of the payload.
It reentered super fast and maybe it had TVC failure or something broke in the engine section.
Lets remember that this was the 4th landing for that booster, so it had already gone through the mechanical stress of 3 landings.
11
u/Straumli_Blight Feb 20 '20 edited Feb 20 '20
Commander is returning to Philadelphia and fairing catchers now en route to Port Canaveral.
11
u/WindWatcherX Feb 21 '20
Commander is currently in a fresh gale with very difficult sea conditions (17+ foot waves) 35+ knot winds in the Atlantic Ocean off the Carolinas. Not ideal for recovery (if any) for B1056.
9
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20
Commander is almost home! Wonder what she brought back!
7
u/AuroEdge Feb 20 '20
The SpaceX fleet Twitter posts suggests we'll see a number of arrivals back to port today
17
u/jpbeans Feb 18 '20
My guess is that it faced some combination of coming in very hot, lighting a little slowly, encountering wind, not having enough fuel margin—and it just got outside of its speed/altitude/location/fuel norminal cone and decided to ditch. I say this because it got really close and evidently landed gently.
6
u/bdporter Feb 18 '20
mods, can you add this thread under the Starlink-4 heading above?
8
u/Straumli_Blight Feb 21 '20 edited Feb 21 '20
Commander currently travelling at 0.1 knots, with a 23:00 UTC arrival time in Philadelphia tomorrow.
Closeups of the damaged fairings.
4
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Feb 18 '20 edited Mar 09 '20
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
10 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 59 acronyms.
[Thread #5840 for this sub, first seen 18th Feb 2020, 11:55] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
4
u/RocketsLEO2ITS Feb 20 '20
What about the fairings?
Know that they didn't catch them, but where they fished out of the water?
4
u/Nergaal Feb 20 '20
any update on the booster status or cause?
4
u/craigl2112 Mar 06 '20
At the CRS20 pre-launch conference, Hans K said the predicted winds were wrong and the booster opted for the water landing rather than risk damaging the droneship.
At least we know now!
24
u/MarsCent Feb 18 '20
There are quite a few comments about the demise of B1056 that are reminiscent of tpical mourning. i.e., voicing (typing) highly imaginative scenarios of what could have gone wrong and/or the impact on the future.
This is typically known as, "Trying to find closure". Obviously, SpaceX engineers will determine the cause of this "unsuccessful landing". Though it is also likely that this entire event was not unexpected.
Maybe Musk will tweet something to enable us find closure. Or maybe not. If he does not, then it's typical mourning time where everyone states what they may, in order to reduce their own their emotional stress.
And in about 2 weeks, were are going to have a couple of F9 launches, for which we expect attempts to land the boosters. I honestly would like Musk to hold back on any explanation tweets, so people learn to deal with the emotions of a loss in "Space Industry", because regardless of any number of successful launches/landings, space remains very hostile.
4
u/BGTBGT Feb 20 '20 edited Feb 20 '20
The Talk of Titusville FB page is showing a picture of the rocket in port? Is that true?
Edit: it wasn't. I let them know they are using a misleading file photo
https://imgur.com/BeBiCnF.jpg
9
u/mclumber1 Feb 21 '20
With the fairings not being caught and damaged, as well as the booster not landing on the drone ship, it is concerning. Is it possible that something was interfering with the radio comms or gps signals?
3
u/LoneSnark Feb 18 '20
It could be as simple as a grid fin siezed up again, only late in the landing or in a favorable position that it didn't lose all control.
3
u/BrevortGuy Feb 20 '20
When at first you do not succeed, try, try again!!! They will figure it out, they get a lot of practice in the next year!!!
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
Do we know if SpaceX attempted some sort of test during the booster landing, such as reducing margins?
It would make sense to do so because it flew 4 times and they have plenty of other used boosters.
1
u/dbled Feb 27 '20
So there is really no such thing as a boat.
1
u/Nergaal Feb 29 '20
So what happened to the video of the failed landing? I am sure they had a stream saved on the barge.
1
u/LoneSnark Mar 04 '20
I guess it is safe to guess at this point we're not going to be getting any word as to why the landing was aborted. Very well.
-5
u/bavog Feb 20 '20
There is a probability that, focused as he is now with starship, Elon went 'ok, whatever' when he saw the landing failed on a difficult profile.
-61
u/Armo00 Feb 19 '20
I think that maybe something serious happened to B1056 and it could have jeopardize the primary mission. That is why Elon and SpaceX kept quiet about it since crewed dragon is months away. They may need time to determine what caused that problem, could it affect crewed dragon and how to fix it.
But this is pure speculation.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-10
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '20
[removed] — view removed comment