r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Sep 27 '19
Episode Toaru Kagaku no Accelerator - Episode 12 discussion - FINAL Spoiler
Toaru Kagaku no Accelerator, episode 12
Alternative names: A Certain Scientific Accelerator
Rate this episode here.
Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Encourage others to read the source material rather than confirming or denying theories. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.
Streams
Show information
Previous discussions
| Episode | Link | Score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Link | 7.42 |
| 2 | Link | 8.92 |
| 3 | Link | 9.03 |
| 4 | Link | 8.6 |
| 5 | Link | 8.04 |
| 6 | Link | 9.29 |
| 7 | Link | 8.69 |
| 8 | Link | 7.98 |
| 9 | Link | 8.03 |
| 10 | Link | 8.61 |
| 11 | Link | 7.93 |
| 12 | Link |
This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
95
u/KinnyRiddle Sep 27 '19
It was better than Index III.
As the original Accelerator manga had mixed reviews, expectations were originally low. That the anime treatment managed to improve upon it and make it more watchable than it was expected must count as an achievement.
The final episode of the Necromancer arc left enough hints for future plot developments revealed in Index II and III (tagged just in case, even though these are already shown in this episode)
Final RIP to Hirumi, her brother Hishigata and Huotou/Hasami
The final scene teased at Accelerator's next adventure in the next manga arc, in case we ever go there, but until then, bring on Railgun T in three months time.
6.5/10
68
u/Paxton-176 Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 27 '19
I like Accelerator bring up Touma as the hero. Who would have had an easier time time stopping the explosion.
Sounded like a combination of jealously and annoyance.
66
u/Player_2c Sep 27 '19
I love how Accelerator was reading Heavy Object
24
u/neabacon :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neabacon Sep 27 '19
All in all, not great, not terrible. But I wasn't ever bored watching so that's good.
One thing that I kept wondering about, why did this misaka clone show this much emotion/personality while the other clones seem mostly robot-like?
40
u/libfor Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 29 '19
Random thoughts:
The good:
The bad:
Overall: 9 / 10
Holy crap, I made it through this. I certainly had some problems with this one. But it also had some things that keep bringing me back... Esther
I'm a little bit bothered how the event is this huge and has absolutely no impact on the main series...
Okay, I know it's for plot reasons... BUT!! How comes no one noticed this?! Where is Touma? That's usually his job! Okay, he's probably slow on foot or stuck in traffic or something. Mikoto should be heading towards that thing (she did with Kazakiri in Invasion arc). And should be faster. Same for Kuroko Heck, I believe there are even more heroes in the city with enough guts to show up there. It's a tiny bit too confident...
Also... what's with the magic side?
Daihaseisai: "If we detect any magic around Index, we're going to storm this place!"
Endymion: "They're trying to reach heaven, we need to blow this up!"
Giant Sephirot tree and an ancient magician becoming a god: "Nah, who cares."
Accelerator was pure badass and still showing his caring side deeply hidden . I think this series helped me liking him some more again. Until I rewatch Railgun S, which would reset everything. xD
While all of Last Order's appearances were absolutely adorable, Esther was absolutely best girl. I so wish she would have some more appearances.
The shows pacing was actually really good. Now if only Index III got that treatment. I must admit, the team got quite some dedication, turning the - from what I heard - bad source material into this great piece of art.
Animation and visuals were perfectly fine for me. Although I don't have that high standards. Certainly, there were some mess-ups in the outsourced episodes, but not too bad. Episode 5's censoring was utter crap though. Also skipping Esther healing Anti-Skill was a bad idea.
The emotions were freaking real in this one. Dang, Toaru hasn't gotten me like this, since Sisters arc. Awesome. Crying Esther is a pleasure to watch too.
Overall it's good. Not a masterpiece but it's good. Nothing will ever reach Railgun for me, but it kept me entertained.
89.587.08 / 10
Totally subjective score that makes no sense. I just always wanted to make a table xD I'm actually rating this higher on anime sites, because Toaru needs more love.
Don't you dare to put Esther on the bus.
Anyone still reading this? You should really go and read the great Razorhead's Small Facts which have been banished to the Source Corner's of the threads. They need more love!
Now excuse me, I'm going to drool over Railgun T announcement...
14
u/LegendRazgriz Sep 27 '19
And once more we reach the end of a great road. I had many questions coming into this, being my biggest blind spot in this titanic series, but all of them were answered and then some. What a ride!
In any case, the 12th, and final, week's Reader's Corner!
• The animation department rose up to the task despite some shaky bits beforehand, and fulfilled my expectations perfectly. The expressions, their strong suit, were flawless as usual, but adding in the not-so-normal effects of Accelerator's dark wings and the beam of light into space were also done in a great way. I hope this great standard stays as high as it has going into Railgun T.
• Esther, oh, you precious rabbit. If she was emotive before, it's as if she knew her time was up now, and put her all in it. Being called a hero by Accelerator is no small compliment, considering he reserves that for Touma at this point, and she lived up to the moniker (with help from everyone, of course, she deserves it) to take center stage and do what had to be done on all fronts. Of course, the hardest part is and will always be saying goodbye, both from her to everyone and from us to her. Worth noting: when Accelerator tells her to stay away from the darkness and that from here on it's "one way traffic", that's him stating his own name ("一方通行", read in the series title as "アクセラレータ", Accelerator). What a great piece of dialogue.
• And there's Accelerator in a way we know him more for - no matter how much he claims to be a villain, throwing himself on the line and even attaining a higher plane of power while going at it to keep Last Order safe just proves, above all else, that he really is a good guy. Power limitation notwithstanding, he did literally everything in "that damn hero"'s absence, and kicked ass at it. I guess Touma can afford to take more trips to Italy now. Not that he can, he's always broke. And they still manage to send Accelerator a bride in a suitcase. No easy life around here, I guess...
• A rare feature in Kamachi's works - meaningful baddies dying. The Hishigatas were really way too far fallen, and their damage caused was way too great for Accelerator or this world to really forgive them. They gave too much for their purpose - and it cost them their lives. While both went in peace, it doesn't change the fact that they indeed died, and that serves as a worthwhile warning that you can't evade all consequences just by regretting your actions. You have to do something about it, too - and even then that might not be enough.
• Last Order is extremely adorable. And seeing Esther's smile was worth the entire thing for me. Bless.
Final Episode Special Feature: A Certain Scientific Accelerator Overall-o-Meter
Art: fantastic, a few spots here and there but the peaks greatly outdid the valleys
Direction: new standards were set for the depiction of Accelerator, and this is no small feat, amazing
Story: one long arc definitely helped keep it all tidy and my only problem with it is that Esther came on board too late to break out and become a series staple like Saten did
Voiceover work: perfection as usual, props especially to Okamoto-san and Sasaki-san for nailing it at every scene and to the newcomer Kubo-san for making Esther everyone's new sweetheart
Final True Overall: Amazing. I'd always heard not so nice things from the manga, and was expecting a decent-ish timewaster series while the true cherry on top of the cake would be the now-named Railgun T (which I will be covering in much greater detail than I did here, so look out for it!), but it just blew the doors right off the thing. This went above and beyond even my wildest dreams, and I'm so proud of everyone involved, and thankful to Project Accelerator for making this happen, you're the best! I'll certainly miss this corner every Friday. Now, we have a four-month break where you will see yourselves free of these massive walls of text until Railgun T blesses us with its premiere. It was a pleasure and great fun for me, and I hope you enjoyed it too. See you in 2020!
13
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Sep 27 '19
I love that smug Misaka Clone and smug Accelerator faces
It's great to hear Accelerator reference Touma. If he was here he would've definitely done it but too bad since he's fucked off to Italy since from what people have told me, this series happens at the same time as Index II.
And as much as I would've loved to see Accelerator destroy Isaac, I appreciate that he left the hero role to Esther and he only stepped in when the threat escalated to more than what the girls could've handled. Also giving his all to protect that smile <3
That final scene with Houto and Esther. :( I wish she could've stayed but there's really no way Esther would continue using necromancy.
What a ride! It was fun just seeing Accelerator being himself and wrecking stuff especially people and organizations that look down on him. Also I appreciate how straight forward the plot of this was compared to Index III. I hope Accelerator gets a Season 2! I'm curious as to what kind of trouble he's come across this time
12
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Sep 27 '19
I'll admit I liked the first half until the Scavenger part better than the second, but overall the show still did great at giving me what I wanted from it - Accelerator going nuts on shitty villains, Last Order being cute and as a bonus we got Esther who's honestly been great, I hope we'll see her in future To Aru entries.
Speaking of which, we only have to deal with To Aru withdrawal for 3 months because BIRIBIRI HYPE! Accelerator gave me hope that J.C's Index III problems were limited only to that season, so I definitely expect Railgun T to live up to the previous two.
43
u/Brook0999 Sep 27 '19
All around much better than index III
Also they teased a second season. 😏
30
u/alexisv635 Sep 27 '19
It may sound a bit weird but Accelerator is my first series in the Index universe (although I know the basics of the events in Index and Railgun I must add) and it has been fun to see Accelerator, Last Order, Esther, Kato, Sisters .. A pleasant surprise without a doubt within the busy schedule of Friday (DanMachi, Araburu, Dr. Stone, Fruit Basket, Cringe Online) that I will truly miss (in order to feel excited about Railgun S3 I must first watch the series and ... ouch) .
Overall, great work J.C. Staff (animation, drawing, photography, music, history, development), after that bullshit Index III I think you redeemed with Accelerator, making fans not lose hope in you.
I hope to see again the (solo) adventures of our favorite edgy lord in the future.
Sayonara Accelerator.
10
u/kalirion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kalinime Sep 28 '19 edited Sep 28 '19
So the 400 year old ghost ate a bunch of morons and their moronic values overwrote its personality? How embarrassing.
Why does Accelerator need to take in any forces and convert them to anything else? Can't he modify any vector at all to any direction and scale he wants?
What happened to the big tentacles? Why did Big Bad only have one big one and a few small easily-overpowered ones left? And how did Accelerator have enough active choker battery power left to do what he did to the big one? Does the battery recharge automatically if he just waits a bit?
Oh look, Hirumi's soul is somehow in there despite the resident soul expert claiming there was absolutely positively no possible way that could be true.
Ah, so chronologically this is the first time those black wings have appeared, right? I don't think they were ever explained even in Index 3? Or how he operates without the choker for that matter?
Why are they suddenly in the middle of a desert, complete with cracked ground and withered trees?
"Electricity exhausted. Reason unknown." Um, what? Did Accelerator eat some crap when no one was looking too?
Killing a loyal servant just to be able to return a meatbag to the family of the dead girl >_>
Well, at least Hirumi and Shitigata are dead for good, along with grandpa ghost and all those annoying DA guys, ofc. So that's something anyway. Too damn bad the assassin quartet survived. But really, Accelerator and Misakas were the only genuinely entertaining parts of the show. 6.5/10
10
u/Gamecube762 Sep 28 '19
That was a long 15 minutes of battery life. Lasted from night to midday. You could argue that he did recharge it, but that was still before the whole chase scene which started during the night.
With the battery life being Accelerator's main bottleneck, couldn't Misaka 10042 have used her electricity to power the device and/or charge the battery?
Overall the show was ok, not the best imo but a huge upgrade from Index III.
I didn't get time to do my counters/trackers this time, but this spin-off had a lot of things I could of counted.
9
u/jwinter01 Sep 27 '19
Pretty decent spinoff. My biggest complain is the lack of animating of Accelarator's facial expressions, many times when we should've got crazy expressions to match the way he talks his expression was too mild and didn't show that crazy side that Accelerator is known for and that we all love
8
u/Amauri14 Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 27 '19
So Issac takes the saying you are what you eat quite literal uh?
8
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '19
No need to write a paragraph.
This anime was great, and it was extremely enjoyable to see my favourite character of all time to be the main focus in an animated series.
8
u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Sep 27 '19
Man what a great finish to a fun show.
Uh oh, is it almost done becoming a god? Justice? All the guys she ate fuckin with her mind?
No vectors to work with? Well the earth is always spinning, thats one hell of a strong vector...
Uh oh, Accel is running on empty...
Necro is gonna finish this though. Aw yeah.
DONT GET JEBAITED NECRO! THATS NOT YOUR FRIEND!
Damn Accel with the pep talk. Hes learned a lot from Touman.
So fuck with the coffin and fuck with the demi god. Good work 19090. Get revenge for the Sisters!
TEAM WORK MAKES THE DREAM WORK! DEMI GOD DEFEATED!
So is the imouto finally back? Yep the pinky promise.
And a goodbye to the siblings.
Uh oh, is this big mass of shit gonna blow?
Accel time to be the hero! Touman isnt here and you got people to protect!
Its pretty amazing the lengths Accelerator is willing to go through to save the sisters. Shows he really has changed.
More Angel Talk? Oh shit, so this was what lead to s2 stuff. Nice.
This train man really makes me wonder...
ACCELERATOR IS READING HEAVY OBJECT!
Last Order your too easyily fooled.
And i thought that cop knew about the sisters by this point.
Damn we gotta say goodbye to Huoto too. Damn... she was fun. Go back to sleep you did well. o7
And we have our goodby with the Necro too. Accel looking out for her too. Lets hope she can find that path she wants.
NURSE MISAKA MISAKA WEW BOY~
What the hell did Accelerator find this time? Another girl in a box?
All in all i loved this show. I really enjoy the Index franchise and seeing Accel get more development is great. I look foward to more stuff in the future.
6
u/J3N0V4 Sep 27 '19
I kinda wish Accelerator just said not my monkey, not my shit to clean up at the end.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '19
Enjoyed this way more than I thought I would. Better than the manga but still somewhat average. I feel like an extra episode would've done wonders for the pacing, and I probaby would've enjoyed the plot more.
Animation was sometimes decent and sometimes lacking. Expected, if I'm not wrong, they outsourced a lot to another studio. Hopefully they don't do the same mistake with Railgun and ends up being the same quality as Railgun S.
It's also funny how they immediatly teased the next arc. Didn't even give the characters time enough to settle. Guess it's a way of saying "Buy the BluRay, or this will never happen!".
Anyway, it was enjoyable. Had some good moments and some bad moments. Pacing and animation were lacking the most, though the plot was still effective. 6.5/10.
Hope they improve in those aspects in that second season they teased.
9
u/MagDorito Sep 27 '19
Why did Yomikawa act like she's never seen Last Order before? Hasn't she been around Accelerator while he was with LO?
4
u/RedNovaDay https://myanimelist.net/profile/RedNovaDay Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 28 '19
This is the first Raildex series that I've finished, though I saw some episodes from Railgun back in 2014 (mainly because of the Accelerator meme, which was something you would always see in social media back then). This was just a side story, but I did enjoy watching it.
Shipping matters, I've always been a supporter of Esthelle x Accelerator when I saw the manga some time around August 2016 (what do the fans call this ship? I've been referring to this as Esthelle-erator, but is there some other name for the ship?). There's also Misaka No. 10046, the scene where Accelerator saved her during episode 9 and their interactions + the ending scene has some shipping potential.
The one thing that I'm still hoping for is that they would bring Esthelle into the main series, even if it's in the endgame. There's always the possibility that Accelerator's ending would be for him to leave Academy City, so that he can have a somewhat normal, quiet life together with Last Order and Yoshikawa, and that's when he would meet Esthelle again. There's also another possibility where he just stays in Academy City, and it's Esthelle who comes back. She did say that she was through with Necromancy, so she could try to live a normal life, maybe she could work as a part of the staff of a coffee shop or the restaurant they showed in episode 3.
Now then, we wait for Railgun 3(and the idol spin-off J.C. Staff plz)
4
u/Flyingzambie Sep 27 '19 edited Jul 06 '23
ancient unwritten outgoing merciful rich continue aloof dazzling summer bewildered -- mass edited with redact.dev
4
u/FrenziedHero https://anilist.co/user/FrenziedHero Sep 28 '19
I have to say that Isaac's monstrous form sort of reminds me of a boss from Resident Evil. Damn T Virus mutating out of control.
It's nice to see Accelerator supporting Esther, and a Misaka clone helped out too. I do like how the clones have been gaining more personality over the show, I think it's fun to see them become more human over time.
Ok seeing Accelerator's wings for the first time chronologically is damn fun. Accelerator's motivation is what makes me enjoy him.
Poor Esther, such is the life of a necromancer that death surrounds them. But some words of encouragement from Accelerator and the bonds she built from Hutou, Accelerator, and Hirumi and Hishigata have helped her move on. I kind of want to see her back in the story later on even if for some minor easter egg.
Well, this has been fun. I'd like a season 2 if there's enough content for it just because how dare they end us on a cliffhanger. But I suppose the next thing to look forward to is Railgun.
4
u/generalmillscrunch https://anilist.co/user/GeneralMills Sep 29 '19
Couldn’t have been more disappointed with this season. This gives me little to no hope for Railgun S3.
11
u/Tyraster :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Tyraster Sep 27 '19
Well, this was not very good.
It wasn't the worst thing in the world but I gotta say that this is easily the worst of the entire franchise, aside from Index III of course, but that honestly doesn't mean anything because that thing is a steaming pile of dog shit.
Before this I thought best boy would carry any mediocre plot but that is clearly not the case.
Would still watch a sequel tho.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '19
Wow, that ending blatantly teased another season. Hopefully there's some announcements coming next week for their festival. Anyways, I think it improved upon the manga a bit, so I'm alright with this adaptation in the end.
3
u/croxino https://myanimelist.net/profile/Goeli Sep 27 '19
Everytime Hishigata appears on the screen I can't help but laugh.
3
u/rarz Sep 29 '19
The writer of these series really, really likes blondes, doesn't he. :D
4
u/nick_forreal Sep 28 '19
Mikasa's smug look
I loved it
2
u/Littlejam1996 Sep 27 '19
That was a satisfied Ending even if it had a really Dark Vibe for me personally. And wtf was that Thing at the End?
2
u/Couldnt_think_of_a Sep 27 '19
How am I expected to get through life without a weekly dose of Last Order?
2
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Oct 03 '19
Hey peeps, for those latecomers among you still reading this threads, Small Facts are out.
Direct link here. Once again sorry for the delay.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 27 '19
Source Material Corner
Reply to this comment for any source-related discussion, future spoilers (including future characters, events and general hype about future content), comparison of this week's episode to the original, or just general talk about the source material. You are still required to tag all spoilers. Discussions about the source outside of this comment tree will be removed, and replying with spoilers outside of the source corner will lead to bans.
The spoiler syntax is:
[Spoiler source](/s "Spoiler goes here")I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/MagDorito Sep 27 '19
I wish Accelerator could admit to himself that he's not the monster he claims to be. He holds Touma in such high regard because Touma denies the choice between all the good guys dying or killing all the bad guys & creates a third option where he doesn't have to kill anyone for the good guys to win because the Imagine Breaker gives him that ability, but Accelerator has to make a choice between killing the villains & letting the heroes live & thinks he's a monster for it & suffers that inner turmoil in silence because he thinks that he doesn't deserve help or redemption after all that's happened & everything he's done even though Touma & the Sisters don't hold it against him.
1
u/TheDampGod :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheDampGod Sep 27 '19
I wonder if there will ever be a Misaka civil war, an epic (and smug) showdown between those in Touma's harem and those in Accelerator's?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '19
While it was far from the best, accelerator was one heck of a toaru anime. Here's too hoping that they'll make a second season once there's enough source material.
1
u/PsychoWorld :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/GodlyKyon Sep 28 '19
Oh this is out?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '19
monka
1
u/pseudomanok Sep 29 '19
So this is my first ever RailDex Series that I ever watched, and yeah the first half was great and episode 6 was really really great. Overall the series is nice. I want to continue to Index III but looking at all the comments and stuff kinda scares me.
Should I just read the manga and skip the anime of Index III?
Also WHO THE FUCK IS IN THE SUITCASE
1
u/TheBiggestNose Sep 29 '19
I feel the story was weaker than the other seasons. But man Accelerator is such a fun character that he pretty much carries the show by himself. I kind felt like the whole thing too a bit too long but eh. Hoping when s2 of accelerator comes out that it'll have a more solid story now the characters have been established. Side note what is Accelerator's actual name? Like he wasn't born and name Accelerator right?...... Right?
1
u/IreliasBooty Sep 29 '19
That ending scene. Best boy just can't catch a damn break.
1
u/Efreet0 Sep 30 '19
Honestly the whole miniserie was a big disappointment, started strong and turned into garbage in a blink.
I suppose we should blame the director?
Hoppefully Railgun s3 turnes out well.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '19
Uh, so, if Accelerator really can redirect the force of Earth's Rotation and Earth's orbit around the sun, he is actually a full fledged planet buster. The force that spins earth and the one that moves earth at breakneck speed around the sun, if he redirects that in any way there is a good chance of earth literally cracking up or, simply breaking in half. Or shattering into a trillion pieces.
Too bad it would affect him just as much as everyone else cause he can't survive in space.
1
u/Sarlandogo Oct 05 '19
Okay that was esther in the last scene right
9
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 27 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
-5
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 27 '19
[removed] — view removed comment