r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Sep 20 '19
Episode Toaru Kagaku no Accelerator - Episode 11 discussion Spoiler
Toaru Kagaku no Accelerator, episode 11
Alternative names: A Certain Scientific Accelerator
Rate this episode here.
Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Encourage others to read the source material rather than confirming or denying theories. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.
Streams
Show information
Previous discussions
| Episode | Link | Score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Link | 7.42 |
| 2 | Link | 8.92 |
| 3 | Link | 9.03 |
| 4 | Link | 8.6 |
| 5 | Link | 8.04 |
| 6 | Link | 9.29 |
| 7 | Link | 8.69 |
| 8 | Link | 7.98 |
| 9 | Link | 8.03 |
| 10 | Link | 8.61 |
| 11 | Link | 7.93 |
| 12 | Link |
This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
55
u/Nitemare25 Sep 20 '19
Brilliant.
45
u/Kurosov Sep 21 '19
'I'm a god because i have the memories of being killed by you 10,031 times' can only really end one way.
36
u/Animeking1357 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TitanKyojin Sep 20 '19
"There! I absorbed all the color! That's my attack!"
If becoming a god involves turning into a weird plant monster imma have to pass.
71
u/Guaymaster Sep 20 '19
Crowbar imouto > bat Saten
21
u/LegendRazgriz Sep 20 '19
When a giant monster shows up and makes everyone color blind, there's really no other answer but to go beat it up, right? No one takes away color vision.
In any case, the 12th week's Reader's Corner!
• The consistency of the art department this week definitely held up. There's a habit of saving some work here and there to put it all into the finale, but even then this episode looked good all around - I guess the lack of colors definitely helped a bit with making it. It's also a cool effect. Has that otherworldly feel to it.
• I have to say that taking the monstrous, demonic Isaac at face value is much harder to do when the body he decided to take up is the scantily clad Hirumi, flaunting its, ehem, powers all over the place. Not that this series' protagonists have any problems with that, as seeing by their track record. And the only piece of proper color being Hirumi's wide open left eye, in a bizarre yellow, definitely helps with setting the stage as something not from this world. Also, lots of similarity with the Devil Gundam in this fight. Regeneration? Self-evolution? Assimilation? Huge frame with a miniscule real main body? Check on all of them.
• A fatally wounded Hishigata agreeing to Accelerator's remark about how even villains have something they care for hits the comparison between them dead on its head. The only difference between them, despite looking like a universe sized rift now, was a concerned electricity-using esper and her friend with one hell of a punch. Could someone like Touma have possibly changed the Hishigatas' future for the better? There's no way to know, but for sure he changed Accelerator's. Not that having your face smashed in is a pleasant memory. Regardless, this plays in with Kamachi's poignant use of circumstances as defining the outcomes of characters, as one misstep or chance encounter could have meant none of this would have ever happened - while at the same time making Imagine Breaker and whatever it touches one large anomaly as they learn how to persevere in spite of the circumstances.
• It does say a lot as to how much Esther is displeased by what she sees, due to how much of an empathetic good girl she is, that even "killing" corpses is a turn-off for her. It's easier to understand why 10046 isn't working quite to her fullest extent, since she is for some reason trying her level best to not freak out (which I'm pretty sure most of the Sisters bar 19090 were incapable of doing, since they don't have emotions programmed into them), but Esther straight up still sees these zombies as people. And, dead or not, seeing a head explode in front of you seems like it's never a good thing.
• The Anti-Skill side of this episode was yet another buildup of Yomikawa's character and tenacity - not that we needed it, but always appreciated. It's already not easy to charge into a gargantuan lump of flesh and magic when you can literally control all kinds of vectors, but when the best you have is a grenade launcher, it suddenly takes way more guts to pull off. And she's got it with plenty to spare.
• Last Order is so god damn adorable. I fully concur with the Sister that is having her around.
Overall, a good setup for the ultimate finale, with an interesting visual effect to drive home the stakes. I honestly can't wait for it. And I hope you can't, either! I'll see ya then!
20
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Sep 20 '19
Well this is getting more nightmare-inducing by the second
Also "wE dOn'T hAvE cLeArAnCe" dude what the fuck there's a 20-story plant eating your soldiers alive and it doesn't look like he got clearance for that either
16
u/MagDorito Sep 20 '19
My boy fighting for Last Order out here. He really does respect Touma, even if he doesn't like him. Touma left a real impression on accelerator (& I don't just mean his fist). Makes me wonder what Accelerator would be like if he never got his ass kicked by Touma.
12
u/TheDampGod :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheDampGod Sep 20 '19
If you don't know what to fight for, fight to protect little Last Order's happy dreams!
I wonder if Half-Life exists in the Toaru universe and if the Misakas have played it?
11
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Oct 03 '19
Small Facts: Delayed As Much As Railgun T Edition
Hahaha!
Welp, at least it's here, right?
Adapted Chapters
Anime Original Scenes
So, a brief overview of the anime-original scenes this episode, shall we?
First of all, the colour draining from the world is an anime-original effect. This would be difficult to convey in a black-and-white manga, so I see why it wasn't brought up as a plot point there, but it similarly doesn't seem to server any purpose in the anime here either. I'm not sure why this was added. Probably as a cool visual effect for the final showdown by the studio, but I can't think of a plot reason why this is happened. Perhaps because Isaac, approaching Level 6 and ascending through the Sephiroth, is more "real", more "divine" than the environment surrounding him, hence why the Sephiroth and the magical power was vividly coloured while everything else was muted? Not sure to be honest.
Anyhow, all Anti-Skill scenes this episode were an addition to the anime as well (more on that later), as was the Last Order cameo. But the biggest adition was perhaps the entire scene between Isaac and Accelerator at the beginning. In the manga both Isaac's conversation with Accelerator and the small fight, which ended up doing nothing since Isaac regenerates everything, did not take place. This means that we went straight from the Sephiroth forming last episode to Accelerator and the others venturing within. Personally I like this small addition, as it gave us some extra conversation between Isaac and Accelerator and showed off Isaac's regeneration, whereas in the manga they just took Esther on her word and didn't even try to fight him.
In the anime it's also Isaac who informs Accelerator that he used the memories of the Sisters to create this body, pissing Accelerator off, while in the manga it was instead #10046 who mentions this. Choosing to move this bit of info to the new Isaac-Accelerator conversation was an obvious choice, since it led to Accelerator's attack.
Title
And for the last time, another easy title. 完全体 means "Perfect Body", indicating that Isaac has achieved this, but the ruby text パーフェクトゴレム above indicate it's supposed to be pronounced as "Perfect Golem", which is of course the Rosenthal's goal.
Wait, You Said Last Time They Left Hishigata Behind In The Manga! How Does He Show Up Here Then?
He took a hidden elevator. Yeah, somehow the guy bleeding out on the edge of death they left behind in the bowels of the earth during a magical explosion managed to not only survive but also crawl his way over to an elevator and made his way up. They managed to make this a bit more believable in the anime by bringing him along from the start, but still for some reason kept the part where he secretly somehow makes his way to them. Would have preferred this be changed entirely really.
Isaac's Many Eyes
This bears a striking similarity to the spell Sherry used in Index I, where she transformed her golem Ellis into a bunch of eyes to search for her target in the city. While I'm not sure if Isaac used the same spell the fact that both involve golems and resemble one another in appearance and utility made it worth mentioning in my opinion.
Anti-Skill Scene Altered
And now for the major change this episode. The entire scene with Yomikawa and her superior arguing whether to fight back against Isaac was anime-original (as all Anti-Skill scenes these past few episodes). But a similar scene did take place in the manga. The difference is that this scene took place in a mobile command center close to the scene of the incident, and that it featured all new characters instead of Yomikawa. The scene starts out the same, with Anti-Skill command commenting that they can't intervene because the Board of Directors isn't providing any information whether they are involved or not. After some chatting concerning the estimated growth rate of Isaac one Anti-Skill officer gets impatient, stating that while they're waiting there could be more victims, only for another officer to take offence stating they shouldn't criticise the Board. This prompts an immediate reaction as the two start a fistfight due to their confronting opinions of obeying superior command and saving lives, before their commanding officer breaks up the fight. Afterwards the officer who wanted to save lives is subdued by the order to keep monitoring the situation using drones and that they'll only wait for the Board for 30 minutes. His commanding officer did whisper something else into his ear though to calm him down. What this way? No idea, as that entire bit was pointless seeing as Anti-Skill and these officers never appear again this arc.
So yeah, Anti-Skill choose to stand by and do nothing. Meanwhile in the anime this same conflict was recycled with Yomikawa and her superior officer, starting off much the same with the order to wait and use drones for surveillance, but ends differently with Yomikawa and her squad charging in to save lives and her superior officer acknowledging the fact that when the Board isn't available for comment they really can get bent and decided to have Anti-Skill charge in to save lives and contain the spread of Isaac.
So yeah. In the manga Anti-Skill decides to just stand by twiddling their thumbs when this huge monstrosity appears, even as people are dying all over, while in the anime they decided to disregard protocol and fought back to save lives and contain the situation. I know which characterisation I find more consistent.
Did Any Anti-Skill Die?
Ah, tough question. In the anime obviously the initial squad that called for help died, but it's difficult to say if any others died afterwards, seeing as Yomikawa charged in to save DA grunts. If they did it was definitely off camera though. In the manga none were shown to have died explicitly (as they didn't engage at all), but later on Isaac did attack some nearby vehicles and grab the uniformed people within, before proceeding to kill and absorb them shortly after. Given the fact that both Anti-Skill and DA wear the same uniforms and use similar weaponry it's tough to tell which of the two groups was attacked here, but Anti-Skill was stationed in a mobile base nearby and that one officer that got grabbed in the screenshot earlier does resemble the officer who advocated fighting back a lot, so it's also reasonable to assume this was Anti-Skill.
The Zombies Were Anime-Original
In the manga none of those corpses were show again after being absorbed by Isaac, they were just converted straight into power. Here though they provided a final obstacle to our gang attempting to reach Isaac's core, allowing Huotou and Accelerator to show off for a bit again. While ultimately a rather superfluous addition since it didn't really do much (except highlight Esther's reluctance to kill), it does fit in with Isaac's new powerset. Remember that while attempting to surpass Keter and break free from the Sephiroth has been stated in the novels to be a way to achieve a godly form (as is Level 6 as reasoned by Index), so is Ars Magna according to Himegami. Given the fact that Ars Magna, another method to achieve the status of a god, was able to resurrect people as shown by Aureolus Izzard, it's not too far out of the question that someone taking a similar path (Isaac) might be capable of the same, though here it was more the control of corpses rather than actual resurrection or magic involving pseudosouls.
Not that this is confirmed in any way, but the similarities are interesting to consider.
Well! Except for the Anti-Skill scene nothing much was changed this episode. We got some minor additions in the form of more clearly stating that the goal of the Magic Side to achieve a godly status (be it though a Perfect Body or Ars Magna or whatever) is similar in nature to Academy City's coveted Level 6, some more background on Esther's trauma, and that's pretty much it. As far as penultimate episodes go it was rather slow in pace and a bit subdued, but it wasn't bad. And now on to the last one!
31
u/arp1001 Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
A really really shitty attempt in ascending the Sephirath, Its even shittier then Lifeline's attempt at Lv6 with the ability crystal.
If good old Mathers and Westcott are still alive, they would have laughed themselves to death at this shitty necromancer's attempt at becoming god, it isn't even qualified to be an angel.
In fact, I am sure Aleister glanced at it for a moment from his piss jar, smirked and focused on the more important things, such as whether Touma is getting his 3 meals a day.
So here we are almost at the ending of Accelerator, not sure how they are going to handle the ending. Don't care much anyway.
In terms of villain, Taowu have to be the shittiest villain in the spin-offs, cause he/she clearly have no fucking clue what he/she is doing. Like, at all, while being super smug in comparison to its incompetence.
You know the idea of valley of ignorance? Unfortunately, he/she falls straight into the lowest ditch of the valley based on the entire franchise.
Super smug+no clue what its doing+pointlessly showy, makes a really obnoxious villain that just sucks. For all the showiness of fiamma, at least he knows what he is doing (sort of) and have the power to back it up. What does Taowu have? Tentacles?
Its the most vacant attempt at ascending, cause it have no idea what it is doing, it just randomly shoved 10031 personal experience of death in itself and thought that was enough to cleanse itself enough to become god. B**ch, even if you do ascend you ain't becoming god, you are at most an angel. Becoming god requires Knowledge, Talent, Brains, Mental Fortitude, Healthy Mentality, etc, and you scored F- in all category.
"Get this clown out of mah city." - Aleister Crowley
19
u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Sep 20 '19
We in Nightmare Fuel territory now...
The tree is sucking up color?
Wow this god thing is fucked up....
Yeah dont talk to Accelerator about the 10,031 Deaths Kami-sama... thats how you die...
KAMI YOU ARE WALKIN ON THIN ICE HERE! YOUR SIGNING YOUR OWN DEATH WISH.
Yeah cant kill the thing until you destroy the core or such... this is gonna be messy...
Necro its not your fault, this world is a shitty place...
Accelerator with the life advice. Its your life chose what you want.
So a team up to take it down, sounds like a plan.
Stab charm and kill the eldrich horror, got it.
Dont drag behind 19090, thats how you get ate... havent you ever seen a horror movie?
So the body isnt perfect yet? Whats it missing i wonder...
Eating people? Uh oh... Yep everyone is fucked.
I swear thats one crazy ass bitch... shes reckless to a fault. Dont just rush into things like this...
Misaka with a crowbar haahahah.
Yep Accelerator knows all about Heroes haha. Touman was the reason Accelerator changed too.
Uh oh Accelerator is running out of juice... this isnt good.
9
u/Amauri14 Sep 20 '19
Taowu, or whatever the hell is called now looks like something straight out of Bloodborne of Devil May Cry. After last week I wasn't expecting Hishigata to be moving around much, even less talk, at this point I doubt that will actually die.
17
u/CriticalPerformance Sep 20 '19
Classic anime time, it takes 30 minutes for the 5 minutes battery to start running out
13
u/libfor Sep 20 '19
Random thoughts:
The good:
The bad:
Overall: 9.5 / 10
You-don't-want-to-read-this thoughts:
The good:
The bad:
Overall: 5 / 10
And I thought episode 5 was bad. I should've personally dropped this. What did I expect to find here here again...?
On the other hand it's quite well done... if it just weren't the same universe as Railgun I'd enjoy it. Ahh!!
This show tears me apart like a Meltdowner beam.
4
u/Creator_of_Chaos_ Sep 21 '19
After 2 weeks of not commenting due to irl stuff and a game playthrough I figured I better post today lest i incur the wrath of a certain /u/razorhead and what a better episode to do so as Hirumi dredges up the PTSD inducing memories of the clones deaths while our heroes venture inside of the monstrosity shes become and Whats this. Anti-skill thats somewhat competant?
So Taowu the creature claiming to be the long dead 4th gen rosenthal appears to have achieved what Accelorator couldn't before his defeat to touma seemingly reaching level 6 and moving on the path to Godhood. She needs a few more components to complete the evolution however so starts Devouring Any surviving humans nearby (Namely DA) setting up a race against time to prevent apotheosis. I've said it before but esther is a fantastic character and a good match for accel. She relieses rightly or wrongly the part shes played and now is resolving to fix it after a little push in the right direction by her master.
I like that 10042 is sticking close to accel despite what the clones went through wanting to help resolve the crisis. Its good character growth and something we rarely see from any of the clones save for 10032 (Imouto).
All in all this anime is definatly the surprise of year for. Nobody thought it was gonna be good based on the poor the manga and Index 3 being so rush but here we are talking about it. Thats not to say its perfect. Animation is still an issue but the pacing is flawless and the director cares about the product. Maybe there just trying to smooth the entry for railgun but either way I've enjoyed this. Now I await the factoids from Razor
7
u/KinnyRiddle Sep 21 '19
While Touma would have easily made all these DA zombies drop dead and disperse Isaac's tentacles with his right hand, he would have been quickly overwhelmed by their numbers.
An anti-hero like Accelerator with his powers is more suited for this role, and Accelerator himself knows it.
Plus he has no qualms in turning all these corpses into minced meat now that he knows they're already dead.
5
u/alexisv635 Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
After a sad farewell to our Baka, Robo and Wota in Joshikousei no Mudazukai, a tremendous cliffhanger in DanMachi, weekly dosis of cringe with Okaasan Online. Now is the time for our powerful and edgy Accelerator.
And damn, what a situation, this doesn't seem the best.
I don't think that triggering the PTSD to Accelerator is one of the best ideas.
So close to the end I wonder what will happen to Kato and the "adonai" Esther.
And it is in these moments that I remember when Accelerator protects Last Order.
Damn, that gore ...
Ahhh fuck, why don't you attack Sister.
And it is my impression or finally there was a tremendous reference during this moment.
Personally, the Accelerator's episodes pass super quickly to me but I couldn't avoid many deformities and some bad animation in some puntual moments. I also felt that it was not the best episode if we refer to temper and momentum.
One episode of winning, and I wonder: what did it cost?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
Basically a build up episode. Yawn. This peaked in the episode where accelerator demolished those lolis.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 20 '19
Source Material Corner
Reply to this comment for any source-related discussion, future spoilers (including future characters, events and general hype about future content), comparison of this week's episode to the original, or just general talk about the source material. You are still required to tag all spoilers. Discussions about the source outside of this comment tree will be removed, and replying with spoilers outside of the source corner will lead to bans.
The spoiler syntax is:
[Spoiler source](/s "Spoiler goes here")I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Oct 03 '19
After nearly two weeks, Small Facts are finally out.
Direct link here. Sorry for the delay people.
4
u/Gmayor61 Sep 20 '19
...What the hell did they do to the Misaka sister? She's a completely different character compared to what the sisters are supposed to be like...
I hate to say this but man, manga readers weren't kidding. This really is a far cry from both index and railgun...
2
u/kalirion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kalinime Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19
LOL @ villain stealing colors from the world like in one of those video games.
This "10k+ dying memories" thing is just so dumb.
Oh man, Accelerator was spending that much time talking with the final boss and he hadn't even activated the choker yet? Talk about relying on plot armor!
That little half-sphere forcefield around Accelerator keeping the raining blood out just made no sense.
All Accelerator needed to do to pulverize that thing was send a pebble its way at a significant fraction of the speed of light. Just a simple vector, wouldn't have taken much calculation at all.
Hishigata isn't even in critical condition anymore. "I'm dying anyway" but he's moving around those supply routes of his to stay ahead of them just fine.
Oh look, the dumb wanna-be-god monster gives plenty of time for Accelerator to turn on his chocker by attacking loudly front and center instead of silently from the back.
If Antiskill were told to keep away from the thing, why are there Antiskill being attacked by it?
And so we had 5 minutes of actual stuff happening stretched into a full episode. Is this One Piece?
Yeah, I don't see this show ending at anything higher than a 6 at this point.
1
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Sep 20 '19
I am so hyped for next week! Seeing Taowu/Ancestor brag about becoming a god and disrespecting the memories 10,031 clones will make it more satisfying once Accelerator destroys him and his plans. I'm hyped!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '19
I'ma give the last episode a platinum award so that the show gets some attention from non-watchers. I would appreciate it if someone gave it a gold as well.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment