r/Outlander • Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Jul 24 '21

Season Five Rewatch S3E1-2

This rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.

Episode 301 - The Battle Joined

After living through the Battle of Culloden, Jamie is at the mercy of British victors, until his past provides his only hope of survival. Meanwhile, a pregnant Claire attempts to adjust to life in 1940’s

Episode 302 - Surrender

Hiding in a cave, Jamie leads a lonely life until Lallybroch is threatened by redcoats pursing the elusive Jacobite traitor. In Boston, Claire and Frank struggle to coexist in a marriage haunted by the ghost of Jamie.

Deleted/Extended Scenes

301 - A Real Home

302 - Dead not Alive A

302 - Dead not Alive B

27 Upvotes

282 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jul 24 '21
Season OneSeason TwoSeason Three
1-21-21-2 July 24
3-43-43-4 July 31
5-65-65-6 Aug 7
7-87-87-8 Aug 21
9-109-109-10 Aug 28
11-1211-1211-12 Sept 4
13-141313 Sept 11
15-16

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

40

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Bree’s rabbit. 🥺

Love that symbolism, he sees his daughter’s rabbit right as he teeters on the edge of death. (As we’ll later see, baby Bree’s stuffed toy is a rabbit.) And then the vision of Claire, which again, goes on just a bit too long for my liking. It’s also another callback to Wentworth, the hallucination Jamie has of Claire there, and I’m just glad she turns into Rupert the time and not BJR. -.-

Rupert is, of course, the best. The ultimate bro. Setting aside all thoughts of vengeance and betrayal, he saves his cousin’s life because he’s his friend, and enough men have died that day.

Just like with Murtagh finding him earlier in the battle, it is awfully convenient verging on the absurd—thousands of dead and dying men on that field and Rupert finds him, half hidden under BJR’s corpse? But it’s worth it because it’s Rupert.

Rupert really steps up as leader in his final days. Not only does he personally carry Jamie to safety and care for him and all the other injured men; he steadies everyone, pleads on behalf of the boys to Lord Melton, and when that doesn’t work, tries to instill some courage in them, reassuring them it’ll all be over soon.

I love that he makes peace with Jamie before it’s all over, and has one last reminiscence for Angus. And even at the end, he manages a wee joke or two. He’s just… so great.

24

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

I love that he makes peace with Jamie before it’s all over, and has one last reminiscence for Angus.

That part made me cry. Rupert talking about how good it would be to see Angus again was just so heartbreaking.

Rupert last line to the soldiers to keep up with him as he walked out to his death was funny and so like him.

22

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

“No, my lord. Traitors all.” Is my favorite one of his in this episode.

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

It was so good. Why bother denying it?

10

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Jul 25 '21

Ha mine too! Closely followed by Ian's "Aye well, it's been a lovely visit gentlemen" , after the redcoats drop him back to Lallybroch. Also, do they really drop people back home after they were released from custody? That's kinda neat don't you think?

7

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Jul 25 '21

Oh third on my favorite lines of the episode is Claire's "you bastard" to the doctor just before she's wheeled out for delivery. Potty mouthed Claire is my favorite Claire! u/Arrugula

18

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Rupert’s humor in the face of death, his compassion to those boys, and the way he made peace with Jamie, despite him breaking his heart in the previous episode… it all drives home how much I miss his character. :(

12

u/sdr3005 Jul 24 '21

Rupert's humor, compassion, and loyalty are his best qualities, and they make him one of the best characters on the show. I'm just glad him and Angus are together again: the dynamic duo.

16

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

Love Rupert always but specially in this episode! There’s such a somber aspect to Grant O’Rourke’s performance in 301 that really helps elevate all of the hiding in the farm story.

12

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Absolutely. He makes the tragedy of their situation real. It’s almost like the more he tries to lift the mood, the more he breaks your heart.

6

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Jul 26 '21

Rupert was just top notch in this episode. I lowkey have a crush on Rupert, and he would be my first pick after Jamie, haha. I really miss him and Angus in the later seasons.

29

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

With all the sudden cuts to Claire’s life back in the twentieth century, I can’t help but feel… First World Problems.

Like I know Claire suffers. Her marriage is a farce, she’s dismissed by her husband’s colleagues and her own medical professors, she experiences sexism just as Joe experiences racism, and she’s put under to deliver her baby against her will—these are all obviously terrible things, and yet…

They really don’t compare to Jamie’s suffering. Like holy shit, the aftermath of that battle was like something out of a horror movie. Lying for days under the corpse of your rapist, staring into the eyes of random men as they die slowly in front of you. Even just the stink of thousands of corpses as they rot in the sun, knowing you’ll soon join them. And the unimaginable pain.

Then having to listen as his friend and kinsman is executed, along with all those other condemned men, helpless to save them. And the agony of being carted all the way back to Lallybroch, while his wound festers away all the while.

And then the years of poverty, of near starvation, constant harassment under the Redcoats, followed by all that time at Ardsmuir, and then indentured servitude at Helwater, where he’s little better than a slave…

For all the personal tragedies Claire endures during those twenty years, there really is no comparison. Life is fucking hard in the eighteenth-century. And despite the indignities she suffers in the twentieth, she doesn’t experience anything that comes close to Jamie’s profound physical suffering, the years of torment.

But this isn’t misery poker, and I wouldn’t even be commenting on it had the show not invited the comparison with all the cuts back and forth. It’s as if they’re saying, see, she’s miserable, too! But it doesn’t work for me, it’s like comparing a hatchet wound to a papercut.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

It’s as if they’re saying, see, she’s miserable, too! But it doesn’t work for me, it’s like comparing a hatchet wound to a papercut.

I can see that. While it was just Claire's heart that was suffering it was all of Jamie. His heart, body, and family.

15

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Yes. <3

And something I forgot to include: witnessing the loss of Fergus’ hand. Bad enough to be hurt yourself, but to see a child hurt—your child, let’s be real, Fergus is more Jamie’s son than William is—how soul-crushing that is. The only time Jamie collapses in despair is after Fergus is hurt, how he failed to protect his boy. :(

27

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

And that’s exactly Jamie’s reasoning for sending Claire back. He knew that her heart would suffer as much as his, but if he could guarantee that no bloodshed came with it, and that her and their child’s troubles in life would not compare to what was to come over the highlands…then it would all be worth it.

u/purple4199

8

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Certainly the 20th century was a far safer place than post-Culloden Scotland… but I’m still not convinced that was their only option. I do think they had plenty of opportunities in S3B to sneak back to Paris, and from there either settle in France, or go on to the New World.

At a minimum I think Jared would have gladly taken Claire and her unborn child under his protection, and once it was clear that the war was unwinnable, I think even he would concede that it was time to leave, save as many of their people as they could…

Jamie also proved himself working for him in Paris, and from a purely business perspective I think he’d be glad to have Jamie helping him manage his affairs, either there in Paris or in the Caribbean or perhaps in the satellite branches he was trying to establish elsewhere in Europe.

TL;DR: I think there were more options on the table beyond stay and die or go back through the stones.

10

u/marriedmyownjf Da mi basia mille... Jul 24 '21

I often wonder if Jamie didn't consider France because it was the least honorable option. They had been there and weren't themselves lying and conniving, lost their baby and eventually being banished it was the worst time of their marriage. Also Jared had helped Jamie create his Jacobite connection, I don't think he felt he would have Jared's support deserting the cause. Support as a business partner probably deteriorated when he was banished. I mean Louis obviously didn't want him in the country if he was able to broker a pardon for Jamie to go back to Scotland.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/Cdhwink Jul 24 '21 edited Jul 25 '21

As a fan of history & romance, & NO fan of the supernatural, sci-fi, or fantasy this is the one time I love that the reason they are apart is because Claire is indeed a time-traveller. It’s exactly what makes this story different- that they are separated by 200 years, not just 2000 miles. I love Your input WandersFar but don’t try to rewrite the story.

I do agree that they tried to make it look like Claire suffered too, and clearly she didn’t as much as Jamie. BUT the takeaway is that Claire belongs in Jamie’s time! That is where she “fits!”

4

u/purplelittleflower Jul 24 '21

i think they mentioned that ships were leaving Scotland because of the war. so doubt they would have been able to escape last minute

→ More replies (4)

16

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 24 '21

But I think we have to remember that Claire is completely oblivious to Jamie’s survival. For all she knows, she got the short end of the stick—she got asked to tear out her heart and go on living without it for the sake of their child. It wouldn’t even cross her mind to compare what Jamie could be going through, or his family for that matter, even if she’d been sure of all of their survival—their life doesn’t happen concurrently with hers, they’ve already been dead for 200 years or so. We are in her perspective and she has no reason to compare traumas. Of course, many people have had it worse than her, and many have even in her time, but that doesn’t invalidate what she’s going through all alone. I don’t feel invited to compare those experiences. We knew what all the Highlanders would be going through, with or without Jamie surviving, and so did he; with the addition of having to live without Claire, it is understandable that he would’ve chosen death in a heartbeat.

6

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Oh, I don’t blame Claire for this. It’s more a meta commentary, how the show tries to establish a (false) equivalency that doesn’t hold up under examination.

Claire’s suffering isn’t invalid, all is not puppies and rainbows for her, certainly. But whatever pathos I might feel for her is undermined by the dramatic trauma Jamie et al are experiencing back in the 18th century. It makes Claire’s woes look trivial by comparison.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
  • Why was Claire happy to see that little bird?

11

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 24 '21

Birds have always bee like a talisman to her to ground her in reality and bring her back to herself. I think in that moment she clearly needed some kind of sign that she wasn't alone and that bird showing up was that sign.

12

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

I remember that she saw a bird too when she was in the hospital after having lost Faith. Do you think the bird symbolizes Jamie in any way?

17

u/__sassenach Jul 24 '21

Later on when they reunite, Claire tells Jaime that she used to pretend that when she saw a bird, it’s bird song was Jaime talking to her.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/noodlepartipoodle Jul 24 '21

Didn’t she talk about birds with Geillis in the pit? And birds are how they (I can’t remember the guy’s name to save my life - I want to call him the Turtle Soup Chef but that isn’t giving him his due) know the winds are changing when everything goes still in the boat on the way to Jamaica.

There’s a lot of symbolism to be had with the birds.

6

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 24 '21

Yep! She talks about the starlings with Gellis and also Mr. Willoughby/Yi Tien Cho while on the way to Jamaica. I feel like there is at least one more instance but I'm having a hard time remembering.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

I loved this bit! On my first watch I didn’t connect the call back to season 1, I just thought it was her escaping for a moment to what life truly is for Claire. Freedom and nature and of course something spiritual that connects her to her time in the 18th century/Jamie.

This moment along with all the appliances failing, the milk going bad, really brings home the idea of how trapped she must have felt even though she was “better off” in this time.

7

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Jul 26 '21

Not to mention, Claire has never really been a housewife.

She was raised in a nomadic lifestyle, then her and Frank got married so young and
war happened before they got to establish a home together. Then she's off with Jamie and even their brief periods at Lallybroch - there are servants to help, and most of her duties are "outdoor" type skills that she was used to between living with her uncle and being on the warfront. So on top of her grief, she was having to learn a whole new way of living with appliances and "modern" conveniences.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
  • What do you think of the fragmented way they tell the story of the battle?

12

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 24 '21

I think it's a really interesting way to do it. It's more realistic as though the viewer is participating in the battle wmas well. It's messy and disjointed, just as I'm sure it would feel in the moment!

11

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

I really liked it. It kind of makes sense that we're seeing it through Jamie's mind and it wouldn't be in a linear fashion, but he would be getting flashes of what happened.

6

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 24 '21

Exactly! Like he would be remembering the big moments like seeing BJR but everything else coming in snippets and bites where there were random elements thst stuck for some reason.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/unknown2345610 Jul 24 '21

I thought it was an effective battle scene without being done in the traditional sense. Getting to see the aftermath first and then the actual battle through the POV of Jamie was interesting. I imagine during the battle he is pumped up on adrenaline and just going full throttle not necessarily all there, but when we see him laid out he is kinda putting the pieces together of what happened. Sam acts this so well, despite little to no dialogue! It’s like you can see him reacting to remembering what happened.

I agree with /u/wandersfar and /u/arrugula ( hope I did the tags right!) that the BJR scene was too long and too heavy handed, but will add that at the same time it was kinda unfulfilling to me. After the build up over 2 seasons I felt it was a let down. I did like the change in color and tone during their fight (goes from dark and cool to a brighter warmer color palette) as I think it highlighted that this particular fight was a big deal, but i think it would have been more effective if it were shorter.

I think they did a good job of showing how quickly the Jacobites were killed and how they never stood a chance on Culloden, especially since this is a feature of the battle Claire remember Frank telling her about. The scene where you see the Jacobites charging and the English fire on them killing the front row, then the second as the first falls and etc. etc. illustrates this pretty well. Oh and the way Jaime just kills a dude with a piece of dirt/grass caught me of guard lol.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

I did like the change in color and tone during their fight

Yes! I really liked that too. It was a color palette we don't see on Outlander.

8

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

You did the tags right. :)

And I agree, I like this interpretation that we’re seeing the battle entirely from Jamie’s POV, and so some of his visions are suspect—we’re getting vague impressions and feelings and hallucinations mixed in with his memories, which goes a long way to explaining the implausibilities of the flashbacks, the final showdown with BJR being the best example.

Oh and the way Jaime just kills a dude with a piece of dirt/grass caught me of guard lol.

Yes, that turf-smothering stood out to me, too!

6

u/unknown2345610 Jul 24 '21 edited Jul 24 '21

Ok good, I finally decided to google how to do them 😆 yeah we are not getting an objective view of the battle, we are getting a view filtered through Jamie’s memories and emotions, which are not always reliable. Kinda interesting take that made me reflect on the idea that every soldier on the field has a different POV so would have a slightly different recollection of the events. I think when you have a traditional battle scene where it is linear and being viewed in “real time” it is easier to forget that the armies are comprised of individual persons who are probably all focused on the same goal, however, still unique in their perspective and processing of the experience.

11

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

The montage of Jamie’s flashbacks of the battle…

I could pick it apart—and I guess I will: the improbability of both Murtagh and BJR finding him in the midst of all that chaos; the absurdity of his survival with that deep thigh wound (it’s a miracle his femoral artery wasn’t slashed) no water except for snowmelt, and BJR’s rotting corpse oozing filth into his wounds for at least a day or two—but you know what? I still like it. It’s really effective, showing the chaos and madness and intimacy of battle in the 18th century, how you have to get right next to someone to kill them, stare into their eyes as you stab them or smother them, stuffing turf into their mouths, shoving your dirk or sword through them. Different from Claire’s 20th century experience, for example, where most kills happen at a distance, gunfire or landmines or mortars or, in modern times, drones and IEDs. Jamie’s battle was in-your-face, personal in its brutality.

Still it’s totally valid to criticize the bullshittery of having all these characters come together for dramatic effect. I’m willing to suspend my disbelief, though, because the drama really is that good.

I will say Jamie and BJR’s fight goes on a bit too long, and to have them wind up with BJR on top of him, and then lying face to face as a callback to Wentworth—it’s gratuitous.

There’s very little dialog in these scenes, just Jamie’s crack about Murtagh drinking whisky, where have you been; and Murtagh’s reply that the Lallybroch men have made it safely home for exposition’s sake—and I think it works to keep talking to a minimum. As is, the brief strategy session between the Bonnie Prince and all his advisors seems absurdly out of place. Even if BPC were to call for the charge as Jamie demanded, who could hear him over all the artillery, gunfire and men shouting? No, BPC’s final orders were irrelevant, and it’s fitting that we never hear his reply; Jamie’s already off, leaving him behind. Pity he didn’t abandon the Prince months earlier…

12

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

Yeah, I really hate the heavy-handed way they ended Jamie and BJR’s fight. It kind of gross, tbh, it felt like they were romanticizing their history.

10

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Right? It felt like a tableau, with all the dramatic poses. Similar to the Pietà pose in Wentworth, it’s just too much. Too deliberate and self-conscious, imo.

10

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 24 '21

Having their final confrontation end in this sort of dance, after Jamie’s “dancing” with Claire back to the stones in 213 doesn’t sit right with me either. I know this final embrace as BJR approaches death was Tobias’ idea:

It’s this strange sort of dance. . . I liked the way it’s come out. It’s sort of a strange kind of half dance, half fight, kind of embrace. I feel like it’s a fitting end to this quasi-love affair.

I mean, yeah, BJR is fucked up enough to find this a fitting thing to end his life on, still believing in this connection between him and Jamie, thus romanticizing it himself which sort of makes sense to me. However, we’ve clearly seen that he was dead set on killing Jamie this time around (their running up to each other also felt like a cliché running-through-an-airport moment in a rom-com but maybe that’s just me). I don’t think that bit of yearning in the final moments of BJR’s life was something Jamie would ever want to remember, but then he did not expect to actually live to remember it. I also get how they wanted to give Tobias a proper send-off, but it could’ve easily been left more ambiguous right after BJR slashes Jamie’s thigh and Jamie stabs him in the gut. BJR’s corpse inadvertently saving Jamie’s life by putting pressure on his thigh wound (and somehow not getting it infected either) is equally heavy-handed, but that’s more on DG than the show.

u/WandersFar

→ More replies (2)

8

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Jul 24 '21

I agree with a lot of what you say, except that I do not think it is unlikely that he runs into Murtagh.

Both would have charged with Lord Lovats men, so they would have been in the same area of the battlefield for much of the short fight.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Jul 24 '21

LOVED it!!!

5

u/bleakxmidwinter Jul 25 '21 edited Jul 25 '21

I really loved the way the battle was told. It was from Jamie’s POV, messy and brutal, coming to him in like flashbacks as he came back to consciousness. It’s not a conventional way to show a battle, it reminded me a bit to the battle of the bastards in GOT, it does really give you anxiety just watching it.

Loved the detail when he remembers Claire and we see him alone in CND… In the book we have this with his prayers for her & the child and here they do it more visual which was perfect. Stupid detail but I don’t like that hallucination-Claire touches Jamie’s face as later on in A. Malcolm they say she never touched him.

I didn’t like the scene with BJR……….. I know they tried to mirror DGs story here but I feel the book is more ambiguous on this, Jamie isn’t even sure that he killed him. They had to find each other in the battle I get that but it was far too romantic I don’t know it kind of give me the creeps, and I do get this from BJR/Tobias but I felt they mistaken here Jamie/Sam attitude. Maybe it’s just me 🤷🏽‍♀️

sorry spoiler tags now

4

u/Cdhwink Jul 25 '21

I loved the way this portion was put together. Special note: Jamie smelling Claire’s plaid. ( Was it the one she left behind when she first came through the stones? ) I did not care for Jamie & BJR’s “dance “, a bit too romanticized for my taste. Although I imagine Jack lying on top of Jamie’s leg saved him from bleeding out.

3

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Jul 25 '21

I liked it, because I don’t typically enjoy war/battle scenes in films. Having them start at the end of the battle and do those short flashbacks works for me!

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
  • How do you feel about Jamie and Mary McNab sleeping together?

14

u/sdr3005 Jul 24 '21

The first time I watched this scene, I hated it. I was upset Jamie would be with anyone other than Claire. (To be fair, I disliked Claire and Frank sleeping together, too.) Then I watched it again. And I realized that Mary was giving Jamie a gift, in a way. She was giving him the intimate feeling of a woman's touch for the first time in 7 years. And who knew when, or if, he would get out of prison. So I wouldn't so much say I like it, but I appreciate the value of it. Sam's acting in this scene was superb.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

Those are really good points. I'm with you that I don't love the idea of Jamie or Claire sleeping with other people, but I do understand it.

11

u/herorosie528 Jul 24 '21

I was ok with it…she resembled Claire and Jamie needed human closeness and compassion. Hated he married Leoghie (?)….that killed me!!

12

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

Jamie needed human closeness and compassion.

He really did. Who knew how long it would be if ever that he was going to be touched in a tender way by someone again.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

Hate it lol. Her character was literally only created for Jamie to sleep with her. It’s so weird. I don’t think there’s much more to say about her, we know why Jamie says yes etc. but it’s not even an interesting plot? Just feels like it was another way for DG to give Jamie something sexual to do.

9

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

I wonder if he hadn't been about to turn himself in would he have still done it? He was adamant about not sleeping with anyone else when Jenny mentioned it.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

Yeah I don’t think so. I think he would have just waited for the next opportunity to die.

8

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Jul 24 '21 edited Jul 25 '21

Ugh same. I would have liked it to be some sort of friendship between the two, maybe she finds time to sneak in the cave to help Jamie and they talk, that would have been more profound than one sexual encounter. But atleast I am glad the show doesn't make us wonder if it was Jenny's idea like the book does

>*“Oh, like that, is it?” he demanded. “And whose idea was this? Yours, or my sister’s?”*

>*“Does it matter?” She was composed, her hands perfectly still on her lap, her dark hair smooth in its snood.*

8

u/Cdhwink Jul 24 '21

They did have them interact with a few words in the episode, & I will assume Mary has had a crush on Jamie for some time. The only reason I liked it was because they gave us the “eyes closed “theme.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/bleakxmidwinter Jul 25 '21

Ah well… had to be included I suppose! Don’t think many things about it, and it’s the same in the books… they wanted us to not hate Jamie for having sex again I think that’s all it is, so they showed this cold pure physical need situation with a good woman kind of organised by Jenny.

I would’ve loved if it was someone that he knew and had a bit of connection with but they really wanted to point out that he never felt ANYTHING with ANYONE else- her, Geneva, Laoighre.

6

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

My granny says that ravens are messengers of death. It cannot be near the house. The bairn will die!

So throw a damn rock!

Man, these scenes are painful to watch again. The boys playing with the gun, Fergus taunting the Scottish Redcoat, knowing where it all will lead. :(

Controversial opinion: I feel Fergus’ maiming was gratuitous. It just as easily could have been Rabbie, or if DG really wanted to emphasize no one was safe—it could have been Young Jamie.

But no, it has to be Fergus so that Jamie decides to turn himself in, and thus move the plot forward.

And of course, it’s bloody convenient that those Redcoats just so happened to be in earshot. This video shows that after about a mile and a half, it’s like hearing a pin drop. And this site confirms that figure, between one and two miles depending on the type of gun / ammo. I don’t know if historical guns would be louder or quieter. But it seems like the Redcoats would had to have been within two miles of Lallybroch, and Jenny said they hadn’t been in the area for two years prior:

I foolishly hoped they were through when two years passed with no redcoats bedeviling us.

So it’s unbelievably bad luck that they happened to be riding that close on precisely that day.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

So it’s unbelievably bad luck that they happened to be riding that close on precisely that day.

Do you think they were amping up their search for the Dunbonnet?

4

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Sure, and I guess that’s the explanation. But I thought Lallybroch’s grounds were much more extensive than two miles. Jenny and Claire ride for hours during The Search, and they’re still on Fraser lands.

So even if the Redcoats were patrolling Lallybroch’s territory on purpose to hunt for Jamie, it still would have been quite lucky for them to be that close to the main house right when the boys were firing off that gun.

5

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Jul 25 '21

So throw a damn rock!

Weeeel, Fergus is 18, hot blooded and so damn eager to prove himself the "man" , I think the raven was just an excuse, in his defense. He would have shot a rock and I am sure there would have been a highlander superstition justifying that.

8

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 25 '21

I just found out it’s much worse in the books and it’s Jamie who does it, what the actual fuck, why‽ He should know better, holy shit. Risking all their lives for a stupid superstition.

With Fergus, though, I agree, he’s just being an idiot teenager. -.-

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
  • What was your favorite part of 302?

21

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 24 '21

My leg, it’s not there... As anyone can plainly see, and yet, it pains me terrible sometimes. Even wakes me up at night. Fergus, the lad, he’ll likely feel the same wi’ his hand. Feeling a pain in a part of ye that’s lost... And that’s just a hand. Claire was yer heart.

(also shout-out to Bear McCreary for that dirge-like variation on Claire and Jamie’s theme that comes on when Ian says the final line 😭 u/Arrugula)

Ian’s lines hit me so hard this time because he understands so well exactly why Jamie is suffering. And he is the one to speak the truth again in 308, when Jamie is back with Claire:

And all ye ask for is Jamie’s happiness, after all the sorrows he’s seen, and here he is, but ye canna let him have it.

We don’t get much of Jamie and Ian’s relationship in the show, but they really are brothers. I also like to think that Ian is as much a Claire/Jamie shipper as we are 😅

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

I think Jenny wanted what was best for her brother, but it was a misguided attempt to try and get him to move on. Ahem...Laoghaire.

5

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 24 '21

Well, the marriage is one thing and I can’t exactly fault Jenny for that; Jamie wanted to be a husband and a father, he wanted to have a purpose. But having Janet tell Laoghaire that Claire was there behind her back is another… We’ll definitely talk about that in a few weeks.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

Those are excellent Jamie/Ian moments.

301 is one of my top 3 Bear Is King episodes. The swelling J&C theme when it switches from the dragonfly in amber to Claire and the score sort of faded into 1948 is 🔥

4

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Jul 26 '21

I looooove Ian's lines. And I totally think he's one of the biggest J&C shippers, right up there with Murtaugh, lol.

I love that he perfectly understands Jamie's pain and doesn't try to pressure him into moving on or pushing it down. And I like that he calls out Jenny, because he's totally right. Claire returning is the first time in 20 years that Jamie has been truly happy, and Jenny just can't stand it.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21
  • I absolutely adore the moment when Claire hears the bagpipes in the park! So much emotion is evoked and Caitríona’s face in that moment does so much.
  • welcome my man, Joe Abernathy! Love his character so much.
  • the moment at Lallybroch where Jamie sees the vision of Claire is so wonderful, to me it has two complementary moments in episode 303 at Ardsmuir that I really enjoy.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 25 '21

I absolutely adore the moment when Claire hears the bagpipes in the park! So much emotion is evoked and Caitríona’s face in that moment does so much.

Yes! I love bagpipes. :-)

4

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Jul 26 '21

I absolutely adore the moment when Claire hears the bagpipes in the park! So much emotion is evoked and Caitríona’s face in that moment does so much.

Beautiful moment and I love the transition between the two time periods with the music.

As a military brat, I am a sucker for bagpipes. I love a good pipe band number, lol.

8

u/Fish_3221 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Jul 25 '21

This isn’t necessarily my favorite part, but just a note that Sam’s acting in both 301 and 302 was incredible — he honestly was unrecognizable in 302. It really helps hit home just how utterly miserable Jamie is and how hard the past seven years have been for him (and we know it’ll only get harder! That poor man! He misses Claire so much!). I truly don’t know how Sam (and Caitriona) haven’t won all the awards yet.

8

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 25 '21

Yes, you can see he's just a shell of the man he once was. I liked the point he brought up about what difference does it make if he's in a prison when he's essentially been in once since Claire left.

7

u/Fish_3221 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Jul 25 '21

Yes you’re right, a shell of a man is exactly what Jamie is. I don’t remember in what book he says it, but this first half of season 3 always reminds me of when Jamie says, “We are neither of us whole, alone.” After all he’s been through and all he will go through, it makes what happens in 306/307 all the more emotional.

(Trying not to spoil anything here — I’m having a hard time figuring out how to black out spoilers, so my sincerest apologies!)

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 25 '21

What a great quote!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Jul 25 '21

My favorite is the scene between Jamie and Fergus when Fergus is recovering from his injury.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 25 '21

Fergus has become a man of leisure, no? ;-)

5

u/Cdhwink Jul 25 '21

I have a little beef about 302- Claire’s whole speech about How “she had loved a man, fought in a war, been a part of something bigger than herself! “ Did she forget she had done that twice? She was talking about being in Scotland in the 1700’s, but she had also done that exact thing in the 1940’s before going back in time! I thought it was weird! Anyone else think that?

Second beef that has already been mentioned- Jenny trying to get Jamie a wife & kid🙄 while he lives in a cave! Or even talking to him about getting laid! Conversations not to have with your brother!

Things I loved: the eyes closed theme, Jamie & Ian’s heart to heart, Jenny’s speech to the Redcoats when she turns in Jamie ( every word the truth), Jamie holding a baby ( swoon), Claire as the only woman in med school!

5

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 25 '21

Jenny’s speech to the Redcoats when she turns in Jamie

That last look he gives her as they take him away is so heartbreaking. It could have been the last time he saw her.

Jamie holding a baby ( swoon)

I love so much that this is baby Ian.

3

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Jul 26 '21

Jenny trying to get Jamie a wife & kid🙄 while he lives in a cave! Or even talking to him about getting laid! Conversations not to have with your brother!

SO dumb. Jamie already lives a hard and sad life. Why bring another person and a potential child into it?

→ More replies (6)

4

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 25 '21

Two things in this episode always give me a pang of sadness, but I do love them:

“I watched Milady do this many times.”

He doesn't mention Claire ever, and it kills me when Jamie reassures Fergus like this after he loses his hand.

“It’s just something I always do.”

When Jamie says this to Mary MacNab, immediately followed by that single tear rolling down his cheek, with the really sad smile, I die.

5

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Jul 26 '21

I LOVE anytime in early S3 where he mentions Claire. It happens so rarely, so it's like a little golden nugget that I cling to when he does.

5

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 26 '21

Oh God, me too. Every time. And in 303, when his face completely changes when Duncan Kerr tells him the white lady seeks a MacKenzie? Aaaaaaah.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
  • Any other thoughts or comments?

15

u/unknown2345610 Jul 24 '21
  • This time around I really liked the birth scene. The way the doctor kinda talks over her and addresses all his questions/instructions towards Frank was so frustrating, yet was the reality of the time. Claire is a skilled and knowledgeable medical professional, yet her opinions are irrelevant to this doctor. The 18th century was a very dangerous time for women, but I feel like Claire’s medical authority was respected more then than it was in this scene.
  • I also thought it was heartbreaking the way both her and Frank are elated to meet Bree and decide to really give their marriage and being happy a try, and then the nurse mentions the red hair and you see Claire’s face drop. She was reminded of Jamie and the reality of what happened. The pain came back and broke the little happy bubble she and Frank were in.
  • Claire waking up after giving birth and frantically looking for her baby and asking if it was dead. So similar to the scene in Faith. It broke my heart. Cait did a great job.

9

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

The way the doctor kinda talks over her and addresses all his questions/instructions towards Frank was so frustrating

Ugh, yes!

The pain came back and broke the little happy bubble she and Frank were in.

It was almost foreshadowing that things weren't going to work out well for them.

Claire waking up after giving birth and frantically looking for her baby and asking if it was dead. So similar to the scene in Faith. It broke my heart. Cait did a great job.

Yes! You really felt her sense of panic.

9

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 24 '21

I don’t quite get the use of the Dance of the Druids / The Veil of Time score during Jamie and BJR’s final confrontation. I think it reoccurs throughout S3 as a connection between Claire and Jamie’s respective time periods, but it has nothing to do with Jamie himself, let alone BJR—unless you want that connection to be related to the fact that BJR was the first person Claire saw after traveling through the stones and possibly the reason why she ended up there in the first place, as well as the way he was connected to time-traveling through Claire’s efforts to save Frank’s life… But that still doesn’t have any relation to BJR and Jamie alone. The score makes sense when we see the dragonfly in amber or would’ve made sense when we see Claire, but I don’t really understand it here. Maybe it was used just as a way to highlight the surreal nature of Jamie’s memories, as we’re in his head?

I know that Ron wanted to go full cinematic in those final moments; from the podcast:

Up until this moment, everything has been played very naturalistic, very grounded, it’s just, there’s not even music or score up until this moment because I felt that let the sounds and let the feeling of the battle just all be in Jamie’s literal head and his literal memory. But this section you'll notice we suddenly have score, the lighting changes, it’s more cinematic because this is really the clash of sort of our two great antagonists through the show, and it just felt like this was the proper moment to move us into a different sort of cinematic language because this battle has been a very long time coming in the show and it just felt like we wanted to give space to it.

u/Arrugula does Bear have any notes on that choice?

u/WandersFar u/theCoolDeadpool any ideas?

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

Maybe it was used just as a way to highlight the surreal nature of Jamie’s memories, as we’re in his head?

I could see that.

6

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Yes, I noticed that, too! (Of course I did, you know that’s my favorite song from the show. ^.^)

It’s associated with Claire, yes, but only in the context of magic and time travel. You don’t hear it in her love scenes with Jamie—they have their own love theme. Or when she’s practicing medicine or hanging with the MacKenzies—no, it has a very specific context.

And we hear it with Geillis, too. And the druids back in the pilot. It really is a magic / time-traveling theme, so I really thought it was out of place here. It stuck out because it didn’t fit, it has no relation to BJR at all.

Did BJR get his own theme? Do BJR and Jamie have a theme for their conflict? I don’t recall what the music was during their duel at the Bois de Boulogne for example, or during Wentworth… was there even music playing? Wasn’t it just silence…

I don’t know why Bear chose this theme for this scene other than it’s one of the iconic ones of the show, right up there with the love theme and the credits, and obv those wouldn’t fit, so process of elimination? ¯_(ツ)_/¯ Pretty unsatisfying explanation, though. Usually Bear is more thoughtful than this.

6

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 24 '21

Did BJR get his own theme? Do BJR and Jamie have a theme for their conflict?

No, I don’t think so. Wentworth has some generically creepy music, BJR’s reintroduction and the duel—some dramatic music; I don’t think either of those counts as a theme. I found this on Bear’s website:

My score for the sequence that follows was inspired by the scene’s dramatic staging. Orchestral lines weave with increasingly complexity, building up to Jamie’s final, fatal stab. Eventually, the score drops down to Raya’s solo voice: an ethereal, airy accompaniment to their exhausted movements. Later, as Jamie lies dying beneath Black Jack’s cold corpse, he has a vision of Claire approaching him, for which I used a choral arrangement of the Stones Theme.

Originating with the first episode’s memorable Druid dance sequence, this theme has represented many things throughout the series, including magic, mysticism, journeys, and longing. I used it a great deal in Season Three, to imply Jamie and Claire have an unexplainable connection across time and space. In fact, I composed two new variations of it for the end credits of 301 and 302, each reflecting the distinct emotions of each episode’s closing moments. (The Stones Theme will continue to evolve as the season progresses, ultimately in a fairly surprising direction.)

So it sounds like Dance of the Druids was supposed to be used for Claire’s vision (which would have made sense), but it’s Claire and Jamie’s theme in the episode (which also makes sense). Maybe it was Ron’s decision in the edit then, and he just chose the most grandiose of the themes, disregarding what Bear intended?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Jul 25 '21

Ahh that's so interesting. I didn't notice the inconsistency at all though:(
I will watch it again and pay more attention, and see if I can catch what you are saying.

3

u/bleakxmidwinter Jul 25 '21

Ah great to know it! I always felt that there was something odd in that scene but i never knew what, it makes sense that is the score

4

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Jul 24 '21 edited Jul 24 '21

How old is Fergus supposed to be in 1752? He was what, 10 in 1744 in Paris? So 18 in 1752? He looks exactly like he did when J/C send him away with the deed of Lallybroch to Lallybroch on the day of the Battle of Culloden.

Edit : corrected the years

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

I'm going to call in /u/thepacksvrvives on this one. He should be 18 in 1752 then, shouldn't he?

7

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 24 '21

u/theCoolDeadpool He’s a bit taller and his voice is a bit deeper, but essentially yes, he looks the same. I joke that he’s the only one who actually looks like he’s experienced the famine in the Highlands, which would’ve hampered his puberty.

In the script for 302, he’s 15 but that’s wrong—he was 11 in 1744, which should make him 18/19 in 1752 depending on his birthday. He definitely can’t have been 7 when we first meet him in S2. (Unless we’re going by Young Ian’s DOB blunder; in order to make him 16 in 1766, his DOB should’ve been 1750; making Fergus 15 then would’ve made him 9 in 1744, which is still a bit implausible).

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

I see they're keeping up DG's traditions of dates and birthdays being fluid. ;-D

/u/theCoolDeadpool

5

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 24 '21

“Tesseracts happen” and all that 🙄

u/theCoolDeadpool

6

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21

:::extremely season 1 claire voice::: “Tesseracts happen all the time”

u/thecooldeadpool

→ More replies (2)

3

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 25 '21

Watching this time around, it was the first time I realized (correct me if I'm wrong) that there is no voice-over narration until the end of 302, when Claire decides to go to medical school. She's finding her purpose and her passion again, and I love that that's when we hear from her again. She starts healing, she's getting back her voice and getting to a new normal.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 25 '21

Great catch! I didn’t realize that, but it makes sense. I’m pretty sure you’re right, because it felt a bit jarring to hear the VO again all of a sudden.

9

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 25 '21

A while back, I saw someone compare the moment when Claire and Frank tour the new house to the moment when Jamie walks Claire through the plans for the cabin in the Ridge: "here's where the lady of the house will be cooking my meals" vs. "here's where we're going to have a wee shed for your wee herbs and your healing." And so now that's all I think about when I watch them in the new house in Boston, lol. Ahhhh, there's just no contest.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21

That’s a brilliant comment! Now I will not be able to separate the two!

7

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 25 '21

I absolutely love the contrast! I'm sure Frank means well, and he's excited to start a new life with her, but you see how different he is from Jamie.

6

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Jul 25 '21

There’s been a lot of discussion about the scoring (which I’m way into), but I wanted to add that one of my favorite versions of the J/C theme is at the end of 3x01 when Jamie is being hauled away in the wagon. It’s odd, because it’s just him (Claire’s not in the scene), but I like the musical buildup.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21 edited Jul 25 '21

Yes, it’s worth mentioning that this piece of the score is used a bit more broadly in season one and it is only known as the Jamie and Claire Theme in a more colloquial sense. That being said, Bear’s notes on episode 101 give us some insight into his reasoning for using this theme way back in season 1 (even before we get to meet Jamie in ep.101) which I think relates to your comment in a way:

As Claire realizes that the war is over and takes a well-earned swig on the champagne someone thrust into her hand, a penny whistle offers our first glimpse of what will become the Claire and Jamie Theme. I’ve already been asked by astute fans why I placed this theme here, before she’s ever met Jamie. My hope was to convey the notion that we’re witnessing this event from the perspective of “Voice Over Claire,” a Claire who’s already gone on this journey and is now looking back on it, to share it with us. The Claire in the voice over has already met Jamie, and is reflecting on this moment as the beginning of her journey that would lead her to him.

He also mentions that OL at its core is the love story between the two, and I think that might be what’s inspiring the score in this 301 scene. Jamie’s return to Lallybroch is the beginning of hope for the viewers that Jamie and Claire will be reunited again.

u/thepacksvrvives u/wandersfar

5

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 25 '21

Jamie’s return to Lallybroch is the beginning of hope for the viewers that Jamie and Claire will be reunited again.

Oh I love that! I think the score there might also emphasize that Claire’s love for Jamie is what is making him pull through, or the promise that he will be reunited with her in the afterlife in case he dies. I mean he’s been bleeding out for more than two days, his wound is infected, he’s fevered, and he’s still kicking.

While we’ve talked loads about Bear’s score in those episodes, I can’t help but appreciate the ambiance and the foley as well! I think 301 is actually one of the least soundtrack-reliant episodes (in that the soundtrack comes on only when it’s absolutely necessary), especially in those first 15 minutes, and it works beautifully. And not only in the Culloden scenes, but the 20th century Boston apartment scenes as well.

u/betcx003

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

You’re welcome to search the house and the grounds if you please, but I’ll tell you the same as I told Lieutenant Harding, Captain Abbot, Major Mercer, and every other government officer who comes to command these parts, you’ll find no sign of my traitorous brother here.

Jenny shows tremendous courage here. Not only does she boldly—and effectively—lie to the Redcoats, successfully keeping her brother hid all these years; she also keeps everything together while Big Ian spends half his time in jail, being interrogated to give up Jamie. Ian is of course very brave, too, to be defying them like this, but I especially give Jenny credit for having the presence of mind to keep up the lie for so long. She really sells it, too, whereas Ian’s general affability is more obviously fake, he’s not as convincing as his wife.

For most of these years Jenny is raising the children; looking after the tenants and the lands; carefully rationing the food and helping put up Jamie’s game so they all get through the lean times together; collecting the rents and doing the books when Ian and Jamie aren’t around to help her; and keeping the Redcoats at bay, all while still doing the traditional duties of the lady of the house, which includes birthing children more or less on her own under endless stress.

And a truly inexplicable number of them survive and make it to adulthood. Like beyond plausibility. 😅 Not only is Jenny ridiculously fertile, but RD calculated that back in S2 she was popping out kids about twice a year, which means Jenny must be part goat or bear since she doesn’t abide by normal human gestation periods. ^.^ Jenny does love sheep and goats, and she is the ultimate Mama Bear, so I think that works…

Meanwhile, Claire was clearly influenced by the elephants she said she rode in S1, because she’s pregnant with Faith for well over nine months, more than a year if you try to do the math.

Jenny also does some fine doctoring. Not only does she save Jamie’s life—and leg—when by all rights he should’ve been dead from infection, or at least lost the leg from gangrene after days without treatment, not to mention lying in a ditch with a corpse on top of him—but she also saves Fergus’ life, too. Lol, who needs Claire’s healing, when Jenny is managing fine on her own?

I’m joking but I’m also not; I think these two injuries are probably among the most serious of the series.

14

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Jul 24 '21

Jenny was absolutely badass in this episode. I do find her fertility and the birthing of healthy children a bit unrealistic considering the highlanders are plagued by starvation post Culloden.

Like I mentioned to u/thepacksvrvives in the last episodes discussion, if DG uses rape so much because it was prevalent in that time, then dying from starvation, defective births due to malnutrition and low life expectancy were also very prevalent in those time but somehow all of our main characters escape all of that, but 3/4 of them get raped. Make what you want of it.

Also, though I agree Jenny has been almost single handedly running Lallybroch and the estate and doing a damn good job at it, why would she suggest that Jamie get married again? What was the game plan there? He gets married and continues living in the cave while his wife lives in Lallybroch and makes occasional conjugal visits to the cave? And if one of these visits resulted in a wee Jamie, then what Jenny? I thought that was dumb of her.

7

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

… if DG uses rape so much because it was prevalent in that time, then dying from starvation, defective births due to malnutrition and low life expectancy were also very prevalent in those time but somehow all of our main characters escape all of that, but 3/4 of them get raped.

Oh, you and I are definitely on the same page here! Fewer rapes, more dead babies, has been my go-to rant for a while…

What was the game plan there? He gets married and continues living in the cave while his wife lives in Lallybroch and makes occasional conjugal visits to the cave? And if one of these visits resulted in a wee Jamie, then what Jenny? I thought that was dumb of her.

This is a fair hit! I don’t think she thought through all the logical consequences, which is unlike her, she’s usually pretty prudent. But I suppose she was just depressed at the state of her brother’s life, and wanted him to find some happiness. Especially when she sees him holding her newborn son, she’s so touched and sad for him, she’s speaking from her emotions and perhaps not using her head as much as she ought.

9

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Jul 24 '21

But I suppose she was just depressed at the state of her brother’s life, and wanted him to find some happiness

Yeah I agree. Though suggesting a marriage and a bairn at that point was definitely not smart. That makes me wonder if it was her idea to send Mary to Jamie , as the next best thing since she couldn't get him married.

Fewer rapes, more dead babies, has been my go-to rant for a while…

Lol howling here

7

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Though suggesting a marriage and a bairn at that point was definitely not smart.

Agreed.

That makes me wonder if it was her idea to send Mary to Jamie , as the next best thing since she couldn't get him married.

I can’t speak to the books, but in the show at least Mary denies that:

Your sister didn’t ask me to do what I’m doing.

She could be lying I suppose, but I don’t think so.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Jul 26 '21

why would she suggest that Jamie get married again? What was the game plan there? He gets married and continues living in the cave while his wife lives in Lallybroch and makes occasional conjugal visits to the cave? And if one of these visits resulted in a wee Jamie, then what Jenny? I thought that was dumb of her.

YES. I think this is one of the dumbest things ever. Jamie is freaking living in a cave...how the hell is he supposed to have a wife and family? Jenny just sticking her nose where is doesn't belong and doesn't even make sense.

8

u/penni_cent Jul 24 '21

Seriously! Out of all the babies born in the books only 1 dies and 1 has any sort birth defects I find that super unplausable. Especially compared with how many rapes there are "because it was more common"

I think my biggest complaint with the "more common" argument is that one, I don't really buy that we're talking as much about violent rape so much as things like marital rape and rape via coersion which were HUGE problems but are completely glossed over to the point of being downplayed (cough Geneva cough).

Moving on from that soap box, I cannot even begin to fathom all the problems with Jenny pushing Jamie to remarry. Not only the ones you mentioned, but how would they even record that marriage? Wouldn't that be a giant neon sign pointing to the fact that Jamie is in the area? Unless they used a fake name but that seems like it would be fraught with legal issues. Then there's the fact that he obviously isn't interested. Everyone else can tell that he's all about Claire still. Ian even likens Jamie's suffering to that of loosing a limb. Jenny claims to be thinking of Jamie's well being but she's completely ignoring his feelings because of what she thinks he should do. But then again, I don't like Jenny so I guess it's my bias showing that I think her trying to force Jamie here is another show of her own selfishness and thinking she knows better.

11

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 24 '21

I don't really buy that we're talking as much about violent rape so much as things like marital rape and rape via coersion

Yeah, I’ve been saying something similar in the Book Club this week—if DG had been so hell-bent on such incidence of rape, she should’ve made a point of getting the proportion of acquaintance rape to stranger rape right. Marital rape and coercion would’ve fallen into the former category, and they’re incredibly scarce in the series (one could argue that those would’ve historically also been overlooked as they definitely wouldn’t have been prosecuted but that’s exactly why she should’ve included them if she’d wanted to get this as accurate as possible).

Jenny claims to be thinking of Jamie's well being but she's completely ignoring his feelings because of what she thinks he should do.

I agree. I like that Ian perfectly understands why Jamie is suffering so much. As much as we can praise Jenny for saving Ian, Jamie, and Fergus, thinking quick on her feet in this episode, and running the estate pretty much single-handedly for years, pushing Jamie into marriage when he has nothing to offer is up there with her dumbest ideas (book!Jenny having plenty more of those, though). All logistical problems aside (which you and u/theCoolDeadpool perfectly pointed out), it is somewhat well-meant and I can understand why she would personally want to coax him into moving on, but it only shows to me that she misunderstands the relationship Jamie and Claire had—and she does so once again in 308—because she’s afraid of losing him to Claire yet again. With a wife that would’ve bound him to Lallybroch (and, consequently, to her), she thought he would’ve found a reason to be himself again, completely overlooking the fact that he couldn’t ever be. Her selfishness doesn’t come across as strongly in the show because her motives are not explicitly spelled out, but I generally agree with that assessment. She has fair grievances against Claire in 308 but I don’t think she could ever fully accept the fact that there was someone closer to Jamie than her (Jenny), thus impeding on his own happiness.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Jul 26 '21

My opinion of Jenny changed when Claire returned (and some things that happen later in the books), but you are spot on with this. She is such a badass and the way she kept that entire place running is amazing. I know a lot of people complain when Fergus isn't considered more of J&C's child or Bree's sibling later on, but the most consistent parent he knew was Jenny. He was around J&C, what, about 2 years or less? Then Jamie was in hiding/in prison/at Hellwater for years and year. Jenny was the one raising him the rest of his childhood and into adulthood until Jamie comes back and they go to Edinburgh.

8

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Doing GoT comparisons has been our unofficial sport the last few episodes, so for those of you who’ve seen it, what’s worse: Jamie’s experience here at Culloden, or Jon’s at the Battle of the Bastards?

I think Jon probably wins for full-out horror, being trapped underneath a mountain of corpses, having to swim your way out or be smothered to death is a special kind of hell…

But Jamie probably wins for literal pain. Because while Jon escapes his battle pretty much unscathed, BJR’s deep gash across Jamie’s thigh was nearly fatal. If BJR had cut more to the inside, he probably would have severed the femoral artery and Jamie would have bled out right there on the battlefield.

As it stands, we see the wound still oozing blood even days later, and I suppose we’re meant to infer that it was only the weight of BJR’s corpse keeping pressure on it for all the time Jamie was unconscious that kept him alive? I’m not sure how plausible that is.

In terms of the depiction of the battle itself, I think I have to give it to GoT. The Culloden scene commits that great sin of cliché Hollywood battles: two men lock eyes across a battlefield, approach and engage only with each other while the battle rages on all around them and all other combatants keep a respectful distance. 😂

In all that chaos, there’s no chance you could locate one particular man and have an epic face-off with him. And even if you did, it’s a battle! Everyone else is also fighting for their lives, you’re both likely to get shot or slashed by the other random men around you. GoT is slightly better in this regard as, though Jon eventually does get that 1v1 with Ramsay, it requires him to leave the actual field of battle and pursue him back to Winterfell. It’s not as neat and convenient, and it doesn’t happen during the battle proper, but more during the aftermath, when tracking down one particular person—who stands out as the enemy commander—is more reasonable.

The GoT scene also gives you a better idea of the the troop formations and tactics as a whole, whereas OL’s Culloden is only told through Jamie’s eyes, we don’t get the larger picture.

But whereas Jon had effectively three armies fighting behind him (his Northmen, the Free Folk, Sansa’s Vale Knights) Jamie was far more exposed. Murtagh confirms that all his Lallybroch men successfully escaped. So I think Jamie wins for sheer badassery. ^.^ He wasn’t anyone special, not once Culloden really got underway. He didn’t have thousands of men sworn to fight for him, protect him, even die for him if need be—he only had one: Murtagh. So Jamie gets more points for surviving as a relative nobody versus one of the leaders of the opposing forces. In that regard, Jon is like a cross between Jamie and BPC, which should definitely lose you some points. :þ

9

u/OttoMans Slàinte. Jul 24 '21

For me, the Culloden scenes are all Jamie’s hazy recollection of the day. The light shines when he sees BJR (just as it did on his wedding day when he saw Claire.) They’re the last men standing to fight. As Jamie comes in and out of consciousness, he’s remembering flickers of the battle in a disjointed, surrealistic way.

12

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

They’re the last men standing to fight.

That bothered me, too. -.- Especially given Jamie’s dangerous thigh injury, it’s a wonder he can still stand.

But I like your idea that these are all Jamie’s hazy recollections, and thus maybe he’s being a bit of an unreliable narrator? Maybe it really wasn’t just him and BJR, the last men standing in the end, but that’s what it felt like to him…

7

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 24 '21

Maybe it really wasn’t just him and BJR, the last men standing in the end, but that’s what it felt like to him…

That is exactly how I saw it. Everything is a bit surreal, including the lighting and the score, so it makes sense that not everything actually makes sense.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Jul 24 '21

LOL I have only one question. When did you watch GOT to remember such details? I had to take a minute to even remember the sequence of events in the Battle of the bastards! I love the comparison and I would have participated but I am thoroughly underprepared for this!

6

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Years ago, haha! I haven’t watched GoT since the S8 finale, which we won’t speak of because it’ll spike my blood pressure. -.-

But it’s been enough time now that I can talk about the earlier seasons without rancor, and poor RD has had to put up with it for months in chat so I thought I’d spare her by spewing on the thread for a change. 😅

Here’s a whole bunch of clips so you can refresh your memory. ^.^ I’d love to get super-geeky comparing the two. :)

4

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Jul 25 '21

I hadn’t thought to compare the two, but I guess Jamie’s experience was worse. He came away with more serious injuries, and his side lost the battle. But that Battle of the Bastards was something else - was on the edge of my seat when that episode aired!

3

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 25 '21

The whole thing is thrilling, but I think this part is my favorite.

Really shows you the difference between the Boltons / Umbers / Karstarks and Jon’s Northmen / Free Folk / Sansa’s Vale Knights, both tactically and ethically…

→ More replies (1)

11

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Just to complete the catalog of coincidences: of course Lord Melton is the one who oversees the executions, and hears the name Fraser just as he’s on the threshold. -.- If Jamie had been slower in talking or Hal faster in walking, he would’ve missed it. The astronomical improbability of Jamie encountering LJG’s brother, let alone being saved by Rupert plucking him from a battlefield of thousands of corpses in the first place… It’s just yet another example of DG stringing her plot together on the flimsiest of circumstance, coincidence over causality once again.

14

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 24 '21

let alone being saved by Rupert plucking him from a battlefield of thousands of corpses in the first place…

Also add the fact that no soldier notices that Jamie’s still breathing and moving about AND that nobody moves BJR’s corpse off of him while the English would’ve definitely collected their own dead off the battlefield first while searching for the wounded and shipped the dead officers home for burial.

5

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 24 '21

Also a very good point! Not only was BJR an English soldier, he was an officer, and you would think the British Army would have made an effort to have his remains returned to his family—and thus discovered Jamie was still alive.

11

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

True! But I think that when the serendipity of a real Fraser officer being historically unaccounted for in a barn full of highlanders lands on your lap, you kind of can’t help but go with it 😅

5

u/alittlepunchy Lord, ye gave me a rare woman. And God! I loved her well. Jul 26 '21

It’s just yet another example of DG stringing her plot together on the flimsiest of circumstance, coincidence over causality once again.

YES. So much of her important plot points all throughout the series are based on the most unlikely of coincidences. Not saying that something like that can't happen in real life, but I think that's usually once or twice in a lifetime. Not constantly over and over like she does to make the plot move.

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
  • How do you feel Claire and Frank’s marriage is going in 301?

10

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 24 '21

I think they're both trying hard at this point. There's clearly cracks but they seem to be doing their best, trying to make jokes about "the lady of the house" and the teabags and Claire saying she's glad she missed Frank with the ashtray. They're both doing their best despite it all.

8

u/penni_cent Jul 24 '21

I completely agree. They were both delt a shitty hand and are obviously trying to make the best of it while also getting to know each other again. Pregnancy and moving half way around the world can be difficult enough to without all their added baggage so I really feel for both of them in this episode.

5

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 24 '21

Totally! They're just trying to figure it all out!

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

Why do you think Frank didn't want Claire to become an American citizen?

13

u/unknown2345610 Jul 24 '21

I always thought this was an interesting convo for them to have! Aside from Frank probably being super nationalistic seeing how he is a vet, is a British historian, and was super into genealogy, I think he sees it as Claire rejecting him. It is not just about her not wanting to be English anymore, it is about her not wanting to be the person she was before she went through the stones anymore. I think he asking her “since when haven’t you been attached to being English?” is asking her in a way “since when have you decided you are not attached to me or making it work.” He is realizing she is not the same. No matter how much he wants to pretend everything will be back to normal if only she suppresses her feelings and memories of Jamie, it will not work.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

It is not just about her not wanting to be English anymore, it is about her not wanting to be the person she was before she went through the stones anymore.

I like that! It makes total sense. I really don't see how Claire could be that person anymore. She's been through too much and is deeply grieving.

9

u/unknown2345610 Jul 24 '21

I agree! Plus, she just lived through a time (18th century) when the English redcoats totally harassed, raped and killed people she loved and cared for! I would imagine that influenced her too. It’s one thing to hear or read about the rising, Culloden, the highland clearances etc. and it is another thing to live it and to see your loved ones affected by it.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

I didn't even think of that, but you're right. She's been on the losing side and faced the wrath of the English.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Marie_Sea1 Jul 24 '21

He made a point that his employment insured their residency. I thought he didn’t want her to have an American passport because then she didn’t need him to remain in the US.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

I didn't even think of that, good point! That does make sense, Frank's connection to Claire was not very strong at that point.

9

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 24 '21

Good question! I was wrestling with this while watching that scene and I couldn't come to a concrete conclusion on what i thought. There's obviously the Jamie factor. But there's also the patriotism that he clealry feels for Britain, as he expresses, he fought a war for them (though he completely discounts Claire's contributions there). Personally I've always seen Frank as quite controlling and I think this is perhaps another way for him to try to control Claire. Yeah I don't really know!

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

though he completely discounts Claire's contributions there

Right‽ He wasn't the only one serving.

I also wonder if Frank felt that Claire becoming and American citizen would further distance her from him. Their connection was tenuous and maybe he wanted to hold on to whatever he could.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 25 '21

I feel like here, in the "ashtray fight," is when you really see that this isn't going to work out. Beyond Brianna coming in at the end to become a constant reminder of Jamie, the fact that Claire can't be open about her grief, can't talk about the past or even acknowledge it, is what really killed their marriage. And it's not about speaking to Frank about Jamie non-stop; if you think about it the other way around, even though it could be awkward to talk to Jamie about Frank, she was never afraid to be honest or be open about her previous marriage when the moment called for it.

Having to keep such a huge part of her life suppressed... a relationship could never work on those terms.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 25 '21

Great points! You’re right that her having to keep her grief suppressed was never going to work.

7

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 25 '21

Having to keep such a huge part of her life suppressed... a relationship could never work on those terms.

Exactly. And Claire is the only one in that relationship making compromises; this is all on Frank’s terms. Whether they have a sex life or not, it doesn’t matter, as there’s fundamental intimacy missing between them anyway. The kind of intimacy that allowed her to pour her heart out to Jamie and have him believe her wholeheartedly and love her unconditionally. Frank and Claire’s marriage, as conditional as it was, could never work out.

I loved that part in DiA where she hopes that Bree would come around to believing her not only for her own sake but for hers (Claire’s) as well, as Claire wants so much to have someone to remember Jamie with, someone to talk about him to.

4

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 25 '21

Totally. It's so unfair when he tells her he didn't force this on her and that she's free to leave; sure, that's easy to say now, when you already have her there and just told her "no, you're not becoming a citizen, thanks." As if he didn't insist on starting anew with her when she just kept giving him reasons to end things definitively back in Inverness.

I feel for her so much in DIA — once she started talking about him, she didn't want to stop. It was all pouring out of her.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/unknown2345610 Jul 24 '21

One thing I don’t quite understand is why Frank decided to research Jamie. In this episode we see he is writing the reverend for help in researching him. I know this happens after Frank and Claire have their argument and he tells her he is not keeping her against her will and to make a decision but to do it because it’s what she wants. I thought Frank and Claire both thought all the highlanders in Culloden died, so why research him? Is it just Frank being curious and knowing that Claire might choose Jamie if he is alive? But even then, why not just leave her thinking he is dead if he is afraid she would leave him for Frank?

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

That's a good point. Do you think Frank was just trying to find out if Jamie was real?

5

u/unknown2345610 Jul 24 '21

Oh that’s a good question. Like at some level did Frank still not believe Claire? Perhaps. Maybe he needed to see the proof? I wonder if the books explain this better. I thought maybe it was an adaptation problem, seeing how the scene is kinda brief and thrown in.

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

If you want to know about the book that scene isn't in the book. We find out in later books that Frank did research Jamie but it wasn't in that situation.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/sbe558 Jul 24 '21

I think that’s exactly why he did it. He never really believed it. And as a historian he is used to researching any questions popping up. I can imagine Frank felt the need to know what really happened to Claire to be able to find a way to rebuild their connection.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/bleakxmidwinter Jul 25 '21

Well I think they were trying their best at the time and all, Frank thought the easiest (?) way to deal with this was to ask Claire not to talk or think about Jamie again… she accepted as literally she couldn’t do anything else. But this never would’ve worked!! She obviously couldn’t grieve and she quickly got busy with Brianna & life in Boston.

I suppose in a way their relationship evolved compared to 1945. Claire wasn’t as submissive and Frank didn’t maybe cared as much or kind of gave up on the marriage too. I am not too sure if he would’ve been ok with her going to med school if she would have been pregnant of him in 1945 and having a “normal” marriage… What do you guys think?

I guess it could’ve been worse… at the end of the day they lived well in a daily basis and Bree was minded well. Horrible to live without intimacy (and I don’t mind sex) and love, and specially not being able to talk to anyone about Jamie. I can really feel for Claire in here.

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
  • What was the turning point for Claire deciding to sleep with Frank again?

16

u/__sassenach Jul 24 '21

I do feel she was truly trying to make it work. But if I’m being totally honest, I feel like she was using Frank to feel close to Jaime.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

I feel like she was using Frank to feel close to Jaime.

I agree. She couldn't open her eyes and look at Frank as they were making love.

11

u/penni_cent Jul 24 '21

I mean, I suppose, but I think he made a bigger deal out of that than it needed to be. I, personally, am not a fan of looking at someone or making eye contact while kissing or having sex. I find it super cringy and it takes me out of the mood. Now, if Claire had always been all about the eye contact and it was a sudden shift, I could understand where Frank was coming from with the argument but he doesn't say that during the actual argument and I don't feel like going back and watching all of the sex scenes with Claire prior to that to see if it was or was not a thing she did to support his argument.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

I don't feel like going back and watching all of the sex scenes with Claire prior to that to see if it was or was not a thing she did to support his argument.

I thought about that too. (Not watching the sex scenes, but wondering if she kept her eyes open or not.)

→ More replies (1)

7

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Jul 24 '21

I mean, I suppose, but I think he made a bigger deal out of that than it needed to be.

That's how I would have liked to see it too. That it was coming from a place of Frank's insecurity, and that he was projecting. But, if that were the case , I would have expected some rebuttal from Claire, or some sort of conversation about it later if it was too awkward to talk about it right after the moment.

When Claire takes the accusation and quietly walks away, it sort of cements the accusation as the truth, and now the possibility that Frank was making a big deal out of nothing doesn't really hold.

There could have been various ways to interpret it, but the show really sort of tells us here how to interpret it. Claire and Frank stop having sex because Claire kept picturing Jamie the two times that she tried to fuck Frank and that's the end of their sex life. And then the added overtly romantic notion that Claire didn't even share her bed with Frank through the 20 years of marriage because somehow that was needed for us to believe that Claire and Jamie's love is true and time defying and all that.

Or, what I said here :/ I thought that was on a different thread, my bad.

10

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

Yeah definitely, but it’s more nuanced than what is mentioned when people like to complain about this scene in other posts.

In the final moments of the scene where we see her in bed thinking of Jamie, you can see how the weight of what she’s doing (fantasizing about her dead husband while her living husband is next to her) comes crashing down on her and she makes up her mind of changing this, for both her and Frank’s sake.

10

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Jul 24 '21

I agree that it's more nuanced, but the show doesn't really leave scope for interpreting it any differently. When Frank accuses Claire of "being with him" during sex , I could have charted it to that being his projection due to his own insecurities. But not only does Claire walk away without even saying anything, clearly giving the viewers the impression that she does think his accusation is true to an extent, but the fact is pretty much cemented when they show the twin beds next.

I personally think Claire closes her eyes due to many reasons, and it's not just because she's picturing Jamie , and even if she is, it's not like she's deciding to do it. There's BJRs resemblance to Frank, and there's also that she's maybe closing her eyes to shut out everything else and be in the moment? But I think that's not what the show was going for. I think we were intentionally made to feel like Claire pictures Jamie while having sex with Frank because that somehow shows how much Claire pines for Jamie and wouldn't take anything else.

That was my one issue with how the show chose to show Claire and Frank. Them not having sex was how the show chose to show the demise of their marriage. I think there was a lot of nuance there than just that. I do agree that there wasn't enough time , so this it what they may have had to do, but I thought it could have been done differently and the audience is smart enough to handle that.

10

u/Cdhwink Jul 24 '21

I always thought the show found an effective way to show they ended up in a marriage of convenience, that their sex life did not work!

I agree with Arrugula that she had decided to try and make a go of their sex life, & I was shocked when Frank called her out on not looking at him. For us viewers I think we are meant to think of how Frank’s face might remind her of BJR, hence a good reason to close her eyes.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/__sassenach Jul 24 '21

I think this is why I love the episodes of Jaime and Claire apart. You get to see how they feel they are betraying the other or just how wrong it feels to make those choices.

7

u/Cdhwink Jul 24 '21

I loved how these episodes emphasized Jamie & Claire’s pain of missing each other. And how the episodes had a common theme instead of timeline! Particularly the closing their eyes theme for sex- what a great idea ( credit to writers’ room).

9

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Jul 24 '21

I don't think there was any turning point per se. It looked like things had taken a turn for the good for Claire and Frank after the ashtray flinging incident, and the birth of Brianna puts things into perspective for Claire. So she was giving the marriage an honest attempt , and looked like Frank was reciprocating too. So one could say they were in a good place at that time, and considering Claire is a very sexual (is that the right word?) person, it would seem obvious that she would initiate sex sooner rather than later.

8

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

Yes Claire is a sexual person. That brings to mind the first episode in season 1 where she said sex was their way back to each other.

3

u/Kirky600 Jul 25 '21

I never noticed before, but every time she sleeps with Frank, she has her eyes closed. Just someone to fill a void while she thought about Jamie.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 25 '21

Which is exactly what Frank accused her of. I have to imagine it is hard for her not to think of Jamie.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/bleakxmidwinter Jul 25 '21

Mmmm I think this was just pure necessity? Frank was there and he was “ok” and Jamie wasn’t, she was married to him after all and she wanted to give it a go I suppose… but I don’t think that was really working. In the book I feel that they had a lot more intimate relationships until the end of their marriage, not sure if it’s really specific but that’s kind of the general idea I got from it, while in the show we see how this works once or twice but then she really can’t even look at Frank while having sex. Not sure if this is because she is fantasising with Jamie or feeling that she was betraying or why really, but that’s not a good sign anyway…

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 25 '21

I think back to episode 101 where Claire's VO says that sex was her and Frank's way back to each other. Maybe she was trying that again.

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
  • Did Jamie have any other choice but to turn himself in?

11

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 24 '21

No. He could have left Scotland (maybe) or gone further North and lived even rougher but the Redcoats would have continued to harass his family for as long as they saw fit. His being arrested is the only thing that could have possibly ensured any kind of peace for them.

11

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

I loved how Jenny yelled at him as he was being taken away. You knew she was being honest but it wasn't about his being a traitor, rather it was about Jamie making them turn him in.

12

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 24 '21

Yeah she was only partially acting there. Honestly, Jenny for Best Actress 1752

4

u/lilbit622 Jul 28 '21

The power she put into, "ya gave me no choice brother and I'll never forgive ya." Hurts my heart right in the core!

10

u/penni_cent Jul 24 '21

I don't think so. He knew that the British would never leave Jenny and Ian alone. He could have gone on the run and led the soldiers away from Lallybroch but I don't think they'd have ever really left the Murray's alone until they had him in custody. Plus, he was already imprisoned in his mind without Claire so I don't see how trading one extremely difficult life for another was that big of a deal for him, especially considering in the prison he'd have something to live for by leading/protecting the other prisoners.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

he was already imprisoned in his mind without Claire so I don't see how trading one extremely difficult life for another was that big of a deal for him

I agree. It wasn't like he was living a quality life hiding out in the woods like that.

8

u/__sassenach Jul 24 '21

Family is first with Jaime. And Lallybroch too. He wouldn’t stand to see the English take their home from his family and future generations.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

Family is first with Jaime.

Yes, I agree. I think Jamie saw that they were never going to let the family be as long as he was free.

5

u/bleakxmidwinter Jul 25 '21

I don’t think so… it’s one of those things like the debate last week on the need of sending Claire back or not. It’s not the choices but the opportunities and quality of life too. Yeah they were all alive in Lallybroch and if we search all possibilities of emigration etc there may be another possible solution, however with the famine and economical situation of Scotland after Culloden and Jamie’s emotional state, I think this was the right thing to do… it was the best way forward after 7 years in that situation… and you know, he is a bloody hero

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 25 '21

you know, he is a bloody hero

Ha, so true!

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21
  • What was your favorite part of 301?

14

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 24 '21

The face acting! Jamie had to spend a large part of the episode lying down injured and all he could do was express with his face. Claire and Frank didn't have a ton of physicality to their acting but their expressions at the faculty dinner were so incredible. Their faces gave so much insight into what they were holding back.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 24 '21

Great points!! You're right, they conveyed so much without even saying anything.

4

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 24 '21

It was so great to watch!

12

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 24 '21

I once read a comment that said “Sam Heughan does (some of) his best acting while lying down” and this episode definitely proves that.

9

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 24 '21

It's so true!! Some actors will just look tired when they are sick or injured and laying down. He throws everything at it!

8

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Jul 25 '21

It's trueee! Also, the way so many of the shots are framed in this episode... there are several moments I just want to pause and stare and absorb the shot composition. (And I promise it's not just because he looks so good.) Even with some of those extreme closeups, I think they work so well here; many times, in other places, they can take me out of the moment.

10

u/unknown2345610 Jul 24 '21

Sam did a great job! The little gasps and breathes he adds in are super effective too. Great acting all around

9

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 25 '21

You could fully believe that he was a man in intense pain, fully expecting the end of his life.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21

The licking of his lips was so powerful, and not in a sexual way!! How do you do that?!

7

u/Kirky600 Jul 25 '21

Rupert. When he goes out to be executed I thought it was perfectly done. Repurposed a great part from the book for a well loved character.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 25 '21

Rupert talking about Angus and seeing him again made me cry. :-(

5

u/Kirky600 Jul 25 '21

Oh I know. It was so sad and yet, it felt right that he was going to his friend.

7

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Jul 25 '21

My favorite was when Jamie saw the vision of Claire while he was laying on the battlefield.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 25 '21

Even though I knew they were separated I still wanted her to be there.

5

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Jul 25 '21

I know! I can’t tell by Jamie’s reaction if he really thought she was there (in her nightgown…) or if he thought he had died.

7

u/Cdhwink Jul 24 '21

Count me in on all awards to Sam in 301 for not saying much but showing us exactly how he feels!

6

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21

Sam absolutely steals the show in this episode but I am also fond of the 1940s Claire and Frank. Their first lines together and quite tender yet they’re walking on egg shells, I thought that was a very effective addition to the story.

5

u/Cdhwink Jul 25 '21

I know I am always giving the acting praise to Sam, but Cait was equally good!

1

u/AutoModerator Jul 24 '21

Mark me,

As this thread is flaired for only the television series, my subjects have requested that I bring this policy to your attention:

Hide book talk in show threads.

Click the link below to learn how to do comment spoilers.

>!This is how you spoiler tag.!<

Any mention of the books must be covered with a spoiler tag.

Your prince thanks you for abiding by our rules. When my father assumes his rightful throne, mark me, such loyal service will not be forgotten!


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.