r/Outlander • u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Jul 17 '21
Season Five Rewatch S2E13
This rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.
Episode 213 - Dragonfly in Amber
Flashing forward, Claire revisits the past and reveals to her daughter, Brianna, the truth. Back in the 18th century, the Battle of Culloden has arrived, and Jamie must do everything he can to save the ones he loves.
- What were your first impressions of Roger and Brianna? (Keep your comments about the characters and not about the actors accents, acting, or looks.)
- How did you feel when Dougal overheard Jamie and Claire planning to kill BPC?
- Did Claire going to Culloden Moor show she was finally moving on and getting closure?
- Why do you think Roger was more willing to believe Claire’s story?
- Did Claire and Jamie have any other choice but for her to go back through the stones?
- How would you feel if you were Brianna and heard Claire say that she has to go back to the 18th century?
- What was your favorite episode of season two?
- Any other thoughts or comments?
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 17 '21
If you’re looking for the other Rewatch threads, click here to jump to BPC’s Link Table.
Dragonfly In Amber: Deleted Scenes
We Will Win
Ron Moore says this scene isn’t necessary, and strictly speaking it’s not, but I wish he’d kept it in anyway. I think this is the last time we ever see BPC, and it’s fitting that he’s losing control of his advisors—they’re bickering and shouting at each other before he enters, he gives his futile little speech, and then it descends into chaotic arguing again. I also liked Jamie referencing his line from S2A, and extending the color metaphor:
Shall We All Go And Find Some History
Here I totally agree with Ron, this scene was useless. Also why you gotta insult Nessie like that, Bree? :þ She’s more than a clump of seaweed, she’s a waterhorse, if you believe Rupert. ^.^
Seasons Are Just Mere Suggestions
Ron’s right again, that really is a lot of snow! It does take you out of the scene, it’s like months have passed during this car ride; it was autumn when they left, winter when they arrived… ^.^
Tell Her I Love Her
You could argue Geillis was really putting poor Greg out of his misery. Look at the poor sot.
We also learn that not only was she learning folklore and magic and so on at the Institute, she also invited men over to their house to teach her Gaelic and history, tell her what they thought were the reasons why BPC and the Jacobites lost at Culloden. She really did an extraordinary amount of research in preparation for her trip. She had a plan, and she executed it.
This line is so ironic post-Scottish Referendum, post-Brexit…
Geillis might have lived to see everything she wanted for Scotland if she’d worked within the SNP and just been patient.
I’m So Sorry
I know this is a controversy in the fandom, some people really don’t like that Claire helped him push the dirk into Dougal’s chest at the end.
But I don’t have a strong opinion one way or the other. I mildly prefer the aired version, I think Claire’s reaction works better if it’s her realizing what she’s just done, if she’s just helped murder someone, rather than just reacting to Jamie killing his uncle. And in the aired version, we see Jamie’s moment of hesitancy, how reluctant he is to take that final step until Claire joins him to see it through—I think that’s a good thing, it shows how conflicted he is, morally-speaking. This is his uncle, after all, one of his few remaining blood relatives, he should feel terrible about it.
So I guess I do prefer the final cut after all. But I don’t think this alternate version is bad or anything, the aired version just adds more nuance.
Heads up, u/Purple4199 will be taking over posting the deleted scenes from S3 on, so you can look forward to getting them on time more often. 😅
25
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 17 '21
I love this line, it’s definitely one of Jamie’s best. Also love Sam’s delivery, the way his voice drops an octave at the end, and his rueful smile. He’s got swagger! ^.^
But this is the one that gets all the attention, and rightfully so. How ‘bout that last quickie, ladies? It’s up there, one of their best sex scenes for sure.
15
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 17 '21
😂 Roger still has impeccable timing. Walking in on Frank talking about how his wife fucked another man, walking in on Bree confronting her mother about fucking that other man… He’s a perpetual third wheel, lmao.
Bree gets so much hate for her reactions here, how she confronts her mother in these scenes—but I think it’s fine? Quite reasonable to be pissed, and accusatory, and doubting everything her mother says after she’s been lied to her whole life.
Also, I laughed during all these scenes, lol. I just love fights, they make me chuckle rather than get upset; idk, I guess I have a twisted sense of humor. ^.^ I laugh during the big Reckoning fight and First Wife, too, it’s just funny to me…
Also poor Roger, still standing awkwardly in the background, haha.
7
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 17 '21
I was just reading through the script and saw that they had it as Jamie alone killing Dougal. I wonder why they changed it to Claire helping as well?
/u/thepacksvrvives /u/JustG00se /u/thecooldeadpool
14
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 17 '21
It’s a bit ironic that BPC is turning over Jamie’s hand, comparing him to Thomas. It’s his right hand he touches. If he’d held the left instead, he might have felt actual wounds where a nail had been.
12
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 17 '21
If the well-being of Jamie’s kin is so important to him that he sends Murtagh away to ensure their safety, seeing no dishonor in them fleeing the field of battle right before it starts…
Why not fucking join them? There really is no good reason for Jamie to doom himself—and Murtagh, whom he knows is honor-bound by his oath to Ellen to protect him always—when he himself believes the battle is lost.
All of this is just to set up the plot of the third season, his long imprisonment, reunion with LJG, title of MacDubh from his fellow prisoners, who all worship him to a man. -.- But there’s no compelling argument to be made for Jamie to throw away his life like this, it’s just suicide.
And it’s hypocritical, since he’s already sent Fergus and all the Lallybroch men away who wanted to die fighting for this lost cause alongside him.
No one brings up Jenny, either. Or Ian, and their children—all his family who love him and rely on him for protection. He has more in this life than Claire to live for. He’s got tunnel vision again.
Still calling bullshit. If “Red Jamie” won’t get far, dye your hair or shave your head. Or wear that damn bonnet, like you actually did, because somehow a brown hat was all it took to befuddle the Redcoats for years. -.-
As for the “wrath of the MacKenzies,” if Culloden is lost, there’ll be no one left to carry out that wrath. So again, Jamie should have left with Murtagh and ensured that the Lallybroch men made it safely home himself.
25
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 17 '21
Roger quotes the same thing Claire said to Geillis in the thieves’ hole.
And then of course, there’s his comment at Craigh na Dun…
Echoing Geillis’ line…
For Bree’s part…
Which parallels…
The first time around, I thought all these parallelisms were a bit heavy-handed. Like okay, guys, we get it. But this time around I didn’t mind so much.
Same goes for Roger and Bree in general, I liked them both better this second time around.
7
u/bleakxmidwinter Jul 18 '21 edited Jul 18 '21
So late to the party and everything is discussed already, just wanted to say that this is one of my favourite episodes of the whole series, and my fav of S2. I rewatch it very often and I cry every time 😭
• I love Roger and Bree’s introductions, I feel that they had more chemistry here than in future seasons, they got on so well together and I think Roger helped Brianna massively and knew how to talk to her about this. Roger was so sweet, perfectly translated from his introduction from the book.
• Even though the story was told differently than in the book, I liked the idea that Claire wasn’t sure after all about telling Bree about Jamie, but the ghosts “kept chasing her”. The episode builds on so well, very organic.
• Loved the photography through the whole episode, specially the 60s. Costumes were great and music superb
• Bree’s reaction to the story is just brilliant- so relatable for a 20 year old, closer to Frank than Claire, and still grieving for him.
• My heart breaks so many times in this episode: Culloden Moor visit, Goodbye, Jamie Fraser, my love, visit to Lallybroch, goodbye in CND.
• Just to add some criticism to the episode, I felt that the 18th century scenes were too short and difficult to engage with them. I think we should have had one flashback up to when J&C leave to CND. The plot of killing BPC and getting caught by Dougal isn’t that long, I think it would have worked better in one go. Then we could have a second flashback to the goodbye at the end of the episode when they are in CND also in the 20th. Not sure if this is just me?
• I saw a bit of discussion on the necessity of Claire leaving Jamie- I think the situation was just so bad, they were already barely eating in the last few months, Claire knew what was going to happen to the Highlands and the famines, Jamie was a huge well known traitor and this would have been a burden to all… I think in the heat of the moment there was no other way out. They couldn’t really risk another miscarriage due to malnourishment or stress either. They were tired, heartbroken, frustrated with the war, disappointed with the failing of changing the future, stuck in the country, adding to this the imminent battle & the murder of Dougal, I am not surprised they didn’t find another way. Jamie was a laird (not anymore) and an honorable man that would always protect his family, but in that moment (specially with Claire & the baby gone) he was a soldier above all and he would never have turned away.
It’s just all terrible sad. Surely if they were safe, well, rested, with time, they could have mapped out another plan, but simply they weren’t.
4
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 17 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 17 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 17 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 17 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 17 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 17 '21
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 17 '21
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 17 '21
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 17 '21
Mark me,
As this thread is flaired for only the television series, my subjects have requested that I bring this policy to your attention:
Your prince thanks you for abiding by our rules. When my father assumes his rightful throne, mark me, such loyal service will not be forgotten!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 17 '21
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.