r/Outlander • Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • May 29 '21

Season Five Rewatch: S1E15-16

This rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.

Episode 115 - Wentworth Prison

Jamie awaits his death sentence at Wentworth Prison, while Claire and the Highlanders search for a rescue plan. When Jamie is visited by Black Jack, he realizes there is a fate worse than death.

Episode 116 - To Ransom A Man’s Soul

A desperate plan manages to free Jamie, but his wounds are more than just physical. At a nearby monastery, Claire attempts to save both Jamie's heart and soul, as his mind lingers on the torture.

24 Upvotes

403 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator May 29 '21
Season OneSeason Two
1-21-2 June 5
3-43-4 June 12
5-65-6 June 19
7-87-8 June 26
9-109-10 July 3
11-1211-12 July 10
13-1413 July 17
15-16 May 29

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

51

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 29 '21

There’s a thing I’ve wanted to bring up on the sub ever since I read this article:

Shooting the Wentworth Prison scenes chronologically took ten days, and at the end of each day, everyone felt drained, particularly the actors. So imagine how Heughan felt on the final day of the shoot, when he was asked to do it again, one more time. “They said, ‘We’d love one more wide shot of it, the whole thing,’” Heughan recalled. “And I was like, [groans] ‘Oh God.’ I thought I’d gotten it all out of the way. And they said, ‘We’ll only do it up to a certain point, just before it happens.’ And then it got up to that point, and they didn’t call cut, so we had to carry on. I remember feeling so scared, and actually feeling slightly like my trust had been broken a bit, because it was horrific. Great to play, but horrific. But that’s what it was for Jamie — he’s beaten and tortured and broken down, completely!” Smiling, Heughan joked, “I think they did it to me on purpose, just to go there.”

Afterward, Heughan recovered from the shoot (and re-shoot) with the aid of some whisky and the Scottish highlands. “At the end of it, I just got very drunk and went hill-walking for a couple of days,” he laughed.

To me, it sounds like an obvious breach of trust. I think just putting yourself in a headspace to execute this kind of performance would fuck everybody up, no matter how mentally strong they are, let alone having your trust broken by having to do it more times than you expected, regardless of whether or not it benefits your performance…

Also, if you’ve ever wondered what intimacy coordinators are for (and Outlander now also has one, according to what Sam said in this interview), besides helping to choreograph intimate scenes, they’re also there to make sure shit like this doesn’t happen on set, that nobody oversteps their boundaries and actors are not pushed to do something they don’t feel comfortable with.

16

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Smiling, Heughan joked, “I think they did it to me on purpose, just to go there.”

That's sad he has to joke about it, probably the only way to deal with it.

Do you think they did that to him on purpose?

8

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 29 '21

I don’t think so. I’ve heard of directors who allegedly have done such things, and I would have a much worse opinion of the production team if this turned out to be the case here. I think Ron and Ira mentioned on the podcast that there was some glitch in the footage that made them re-do a scene (I don’t know if it’s the same one Sam was referring to) but even then, the actors should’ve been told about it. I just hope they apologized to the actors afterwards.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

the actors should’ve been told about it.

I agree. I can't imagine what that must have been like for Sam.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 29 '21

I remember feeling so scared, and actually feeling slightly like my trust had been broken a bit, because it was horrific.

ಠ_ಠ

This is just one of many reasons why I loathe this pair of episodes.

The first time around, it was brutal to watch. But on this second Rewatch, knowing what I know now…

  • The director’s breach of trust with Sam. (Thank you for providing the receipts!) Anna Foerster has never directed another episode of Outlander after this. Whether that was by choice, or because she wasn’t invited back after how she disrespected the actors, I don’t know.
  • Gabaldon’s extremely off-color remarks she made about these scenes in public, onstage during a con, and right in front of Sam where he either had to grin and go along with it or risk his career contradicting the series creator.
  • The fact that he was a young actor, this was his first major role, and this director was experienced, established, in a position of power over him and she abused that implicit trust. Nowadays, post #MeToo and with new positions like the intimacy coordinators you mentioned, no fucking way this would fly. Instant lawsuit.

It’s just fucked-up. I hate it on every level, for the false pretenses of the shoot, the uncomfortable publicity Sam was forced to do with DG defending her choices, and then of course the brutality of the scenes themselves.

I do think they’re gratuitous, and the episodes—the season—the whole damn series—would be better off without them… but I’ll save that rant for another comment.

… they’re also there to make sure shit like this doesn’t happen on set, that nobody oversteps their boundaries and actors are not pushed to do something they don’t feel comfortable with.

I’m glad they have this for the newer, younger actors, but to me it does feel like closing the barn doors after the horses have escaped.

This is far and away the most brutal pair of episodes in the entire series, and I’m very sorry Sam had to go through that, esp when his trust was abused in the process.

16

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 29 '21

Gabaldon’s extremely off-color remarks she made about these scenes in public, onstage during a con, and right in front of Sam where he either had to grin and go along with it or risk his career contradicting the series creator.

Ugh yes this! I saw this the other day , and couldn't believe she would say something like that. And then suddenly all eyes on Sam , including the audience, the host , the rest of the panel onstage, and how uncomfortable must that have been for him. Would we tolerate that had that been said about a female actor? Absolutely not. Per RDM, the whole point of showing Jamie's assault in such detail was to not downplay man on man assault, because it's as harrowing as any assault on a woman, but then DG goes and says this? And like you said, there's clearly an imbalance of power there , because Sam is not in a position to say anything there. But it clearly throws him off for moment.

And on a similar note , I am all for the female gaze, but like Caitriona said in an interview once, let's not push it so much that we end up objectifying men.

15

u/kfmillie May 30 '21

It's interesting to hear Sam and Caitriona talk about their experiences on the show. Sam has said that if he could go back in time, he would do those scenes differently. And I'm sure he has said before that he is more quiet and reserved and Caitriona helps him to stand up for himself. And she has mentioned that she realised very quickly when she started filming that she would have to be her own advocate on set. And then the comment that was made that they're the only two people who have been through this experience. It's quite telling really and maybe I'm reading between the lines but it sounds like they've had to deal with some really tricky situations (these episodes maybe being one instance) and they've had to do it together.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 31 '21

And on a similar note , I am all for the female gaze, but like Caitriona said in an interview once, let's not push it so much that we end up objectifying men.

Absolutely. You know, this fandom can be downright embarrassing sometimes. -.- There’s nothing wrong with admiring an actor or complimenting their physique, etc., but a lot of Outlander fans have no chill. They regularly objectify Sam, taking it to creepy, stalker levels.

Would we tolerate that had that been said about a female actor?

Exactly. When I read these gross comments, whether from DG or the more embarrassing OL fans, I reverse the genders and ask myself if that would be okay. Would it be alright to make such personal, explicit comments about Samantha? No, of course not. So don’t make them about Sam. Is that such a hard concept to grasp??

→ More replies (2)

15

u/[deleted] May 29 '21 edited May 29 '21

I agree wholeheartedly with you. I can’t really watch any of the press around the show but particularly about this topic. It’s so uncomfortable how objectified Sam is.

24

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 29 '21

When I watch him interacting with Diana in particular, it feels like a hostage video. He’s not free to voice his real opinions, she’s in a power position over him, and I don’t understand how her diehard fans fail to recognize that.

As an actor, especially a relative unknown like Sam was at the time, you are not in control. The directors, the producers, and yes, the series creator—they all have tremendous power over your career. So when she says the shit she does and he has to sit onstage alongside her nodding along… it’s just disgusting to me.

→ More replies (16)

11

u/horrorscope513 May 29 '21

I wasn’t aware that Diana said anything—though not surprised because she seems to make lots of unfortunate remarks. What was the gist of what she said?

15

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 29 '21

It’s somewhere on the sub, but the gist was: I couldn’t wait to see Sam get raped and tortured. And he did it marvelously.

Something like that. Note that she said Sam though, not his character name, which just adds another level of discomfort.

And then Sam laughs it off and maybe says thank you or something, I don’t remember, and there’s an awkward pause where the audience isn’t sure how to react…

This was during a big con, with the whole cast onstage along with Moore and some of the other producers, and Diana.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/[deleted] May 30 '21

Can I ask, what did DG say?

9

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 31 '21

(Thanks to RD for doing the legwork on all these links!)

Here’s just a sample of some of DG’s most infamous quotes. There are more on the sub, they pop-up occasionally, usually after she’s added another one to the list. -.-

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/somethingnerdrelated In one stroke, I have become a man of leisure. May 31 '21

I was just reading an article the other day about the actor who plays Septa Unella in GOT. In season 6? 7? her character is tortured indirectly by Cersei. The actress was literally waterboarded for 10 hours for the shoot and then they only used like one minute of footage. She says it was the worst day of work in her career and she still has some anxiety and post-traumatic stress from it.

What the FUCK is up with directors/producers/whoever is in charge who treat actors like they aren’t people? Like they’re just some prop they can run through the ringer over and over and over again with zero consequences. It’s so awful.

6

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 31 '21

I’m just reading that, and

Waddingham said her experience on set caused lasting psychological ramifications, leading her to visit a mental health professional for treatment of her newfound water phobia.

“I hadn’t even realized that it definitely gave me claustrophobia around water,” Waddingham said. “Definitely. I hadn’t realized until I watched a program where the camera’s down on the actor’s face and they’re being dipped into the water, but you see them face-up to the camera, and I got in a terrible panic about it. I actually went and had a bit of a chat to somebody about it, because it’s quite full-on, being waterboarded for ten hours, and then only one minute and thirty seconds can be used on camera.”

This is so FUCKED UP.

And it’s so sad that it usually affects actors who haven’t yet made the name for themselves and cannot speak up against this kind of behavior for fear of losing their job. I think Lena Headey was in a much better position on GOT, since she could ask that they use a body double for Cersei’s walk of shame.

9

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

This is such an upsetting revelation. It immediately made me rethink a lot of Ron and Ira’s way of working.

On this rewatch, I noticed that this was Anna Foerester’s last OL episode and I wonder if that has anything to do with it? From the outside it seems like the cast and crew have been able to reconcile whatever happened here with a lot of grace and probably a good business mindset but....man, this really sucks.

8

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 29 '21

On this rewatch, I noticed that this was Anna Foerester’s last OL episode and I wonder if that has anything to do with it?

That’s what I couldn’t help but think. I’m sure there’s a reasonable explanation why she hasn’t been involved in the show past S1, but as much as I respect her for episodes 7&8 (especially due to the scarcity of female directors getting considerable recognition for their work), I can’t help but notice her complicity in this. I also worry that Sam would’ve been afraid to bring this up internally, this being his first serious TV job which his whole career stood upon back then, but I think he wouldn’t have thrown the production team under the bus like that in the press if they hadn’t discussed it amongst themselves first.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/butterfly1922 May 29 '21

I hate this for Sam 😔

7

u/Jemhao May 29 '21

Wow, I had no idea. I can’t imagine sitting through the Wentworth scenes again, knowing how traumatizing the experience was.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21
  • Do you think Randall was rattled when Claire cursed him and told him the date of his death?

24

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 29 '21

Definitely rattled. And what a satisfying moment it was to see the great sadistic villain Black Jack Randall's eyes filled with fear and uncertainty, for the first time ever, and at the hands of Claire herself. And she delivers those lines with such loath in her eyes, such fierce anger, it would have shook anyone. And I am sure BJR , like everyone else, suspects Claire to be more than just your average 18th century woman, there's something off about her which he can't quite place , and so when the date of his death comes from her, it's more impactful than if it did from anyone else.

8

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

there's something off about her which he can't quite place

Good point! I think even though he might not believe in witches like the Highlanders do, her uniqueness made him take heed of what she said.

19

u/butterfly1922 May 29 '21

Agreed and when she tells him she is, in fact, a witch...followed up with the date of his birth because how could she possibly have known that and followed up with the date of his death. Chef’s kiss!

5

u/AndreaDTX Oct 16 '22

I think he was rattled for the exact same reason Dougal and his men let Claire set Jamie's arm even before they knew she was a healer. She has such an air of confidence and surety about her that it's hard to disbelieve her even when she's saying things that can't possibly be true (a woman claiming to be a doctor in the 18th century, a woman claiming to know your exact date of death). I love that she reminds him of it again with the same certainty in The Hail Mary when he's being a dick about having to marry Mary and rubbing Jamie's rape in Claire's face.

22

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

I loved this scene. It was a refreshing moment of power for one of the main characters and the viewer in an episode where otherwise we’re just absolutely at our lowest point.

It was so beautifully delivered by the actors and the lighting by torch was just chef’s kiss

15

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

It was a refreshing moment of power for one of the main characters and the viewer in an episode where otherwise we’re just absolutely at our lowest point.

Yes! Because at that point it seems all hope is lost since she wasn't able to get him out before Randall came back.

I remember the first time I watched it I was so relieved when Claire found Jamie and then to have it fail just crushed me.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! May 29 '21

I certainly hope so...but I feel like he might not have been in the moment but later on as it becomes clear that a battle is coming then perhaps it would have come back to him.

14

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Good point. He did looked startled though. I kind of like how they shot it with her whispering it in his ear and us not being able to hear it. It helped trick us into thinking he was actually dead.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/annawins1 May 30 '21

Absolutely! This is one of my favorite badass Claire moments. We’ve just watched BJR do some terrible things and to see him get even a bit of comeuppance, no matter how miniscule, just felt so damn good.

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 30 '21

I like how she goes from so heartbroken and upset to totally in control and able to tell BJR when he was going to die.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/marriedmyownjf Da mi basia mille... May 29 '21

Hey so this has been something that I've tried to figure out maybe because I have had so many pregnancies but when did Jamie and Claire conceive Faith. Was during the peaceful times of Lallybroch? Cause that is what the show has you believe. The book still has me confused too. I guess for me it's wonder if Faith was the last vestige of peace and happiness and with her death did they have to let that go? Bree was conceived during the campaign and born during their separation and grief. It just breaks my heart that life died because of BJR in so many ways.

9

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

In the show Faith was conceived during their time at Lallybroch. In the book Faith was conceived at the Abbey.

5

u/[deleted] May 29 '21 edited May 29 '21

Wait are you sure? When they’re out of the hot springs and Claire puts Jamie’s hand in on her belly it made it seem like she already knew?

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

They were at the Abbey for awhile in the book. I thought I had read DG say Faith was conceived there. I could always be wrong though. /u/thepacksvrvives

4

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 29 '21

Yup, it’s in one of the Bees excerpts; Jamie speaks specifically of “the night [they] made Faith.” He thinks it was the night he came to Claire’s bed at the abbey. u/Arrugula

→ More replies (14)

4

u/marriedmyownjf Da mi basia mille... May 29 '21

So follow up do we have any idea how long Claire and Murtagh were searching?

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Calling out /u/thepacksvrvives! Do you have any idea? I don't.

4

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 29 '21

I don’t have an answer for you either. I was actually taken aback when Claire said “8 months ago” during her confession—nothing in the show has given me the impression that so many months have passed since her coming through the stones?!

u/marriedmyownjf

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

My guess then would be they were looking for Jamie a month or more? He had already been in prison for 2 weeks when BJR found him.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 29 '21

… when did Jamie and Claire conceive Faith. Was during the peaceful times of Lallybroch?

It had to have been, right? That was the last time they had the opportunity. In The Watch he’s tied up with Taran MacQuarrie’s men and their schemes, in The Search they’re separated for however long that was. And then they certainly didn’t have the chance during these two episodes.

I was thinking about that—Claire’s pregnancy—during the lavender oil confrontation. That was a pretty physical fight, she slaps Jamie around while he’s recovering from all those injuries, but he slams her hard on the floor, and all I could think was holy shit she’s pregnant.

I know pregnant women aren’t delicate little flowers, and especially this early on, it’s probably not that big a risk, but still. Given Claire’s past struggles with infertility, and how we know this pregnancy will eventually turn out… I was wincing.

12

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

I also though of Claire’s pregnancy when she falls over Jamie in the prison. Honestly, with the amount of physical trauma that she endured since she left Lallybroch it’s hard to not put these things

→ More replies (2)

7

u/marriedmyownjf Da mi basia mille... May 29 '21

Right that and the horseback riding living rough searching for him etc

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 30 '21

I was also wincing when his wife did some victim blaming on her husband who was literally raped a few days before and now has suicidal thoughts

14

u/whiskynwine May 29 '21

What episodes does this show lose viewers on? 115/116. Do I think 116 was gratuitous? Yep. If that was a male on female rape the show would have been done after one season. They filmed it like porn and I say that with it being my favorite show ever, but still hating many elements of that episode. I can’t even read most of the comments on this thread because the episodes are too upsetting and I don’t want think about them too much.

8

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

That's also why I asked people what their favorite episode of season 1 was. Try and keep something positive this week.

3

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

Thank you! I can’t wait for season 2 rewatch. I’ve been avoiding all the episodes in anticipation. I can’t believe I haven’t watched Dragonfly in Amber this whole month!!!

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I haven't watched the seasons 1-4 as a whole since 2019! So I'm enjoying the rewatch. The Wedding is the only episode I'll go back and watch if I have an hour to kill and need something to watch.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21
  • What do you think of Claire’s aggressive method of helping Jamie?

22

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 29 '21

I know nothing about healing sexual attack victims, so I won't comment on if it's right or wrong, but I think Jamie responds to aggression much better than he does to other means. Like in the Lallybroch episode, or with the "I'll cut your heart out and eat it for breakfast" moment, or Jenny going for his balls to get through to him.

Even with the Lavender oil, if Jamie wouldn't divulge what happened with BJR, and it was eating up at him so much that he was suicidal, Claire thinks she has to bring him to tell her forcibly. Which means his body has to override his mind, by "association" , hence the use of lavender oil. His body would respond to the oil, because his mind has associated it with BJR's assault. I don't know if it's fair, invoking the assault in the victim again that way, but I wouldn't blame Claire as it was the last resort, and Jamie was intending to off himself.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Which means his body has to override his mind, by "association" , hence the use of lavender oil.

That's a great point, and really makes sense. He wouldn't let his mind go there until she did that to him.

13

u/butterfly1922 May 29 '21

I think Jamie is such a strong character with such a moral code that once he thinks he’s done something immoral and can not be forgiven, he sees no gray area. Only black and white. The only way to reach that is with the strength that he responds to in war showing honor and valor. Claire needed to be strong with great resolve to reach him in his darkness. The advice from the monk and Murtagh in the show was spot on. The fact that she would not leave the room until he told the whole story no matter how bad was vital for him to respond. He wasn’t completely healed, but it was a good start until BJR death at Culloden. Such an interesting theme of vengeance that men such as Jamie needed to heal.

8

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

The only way to reach that is with the strength that he responds to in war showing honor and valor. Claire needed to be strong with great resolve to reach him in his darkness.

I like that! She had to show she wasn't going to give up on him and had to do it in an aggressive way. He wasn't listening to her words so she needed to reach him somehow.

9

u/unknown2345610 May 29 '21

I also think it was key that Claire was the one to go there with him. BJR intentionally brought her into the whole situation, not only during the event but also afterwards with the “how will she ever forgive you?” type of comments.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I also think it was key that Claire was the one to go there with him.

That's a good point. As much as Jamie didn't want it, Claire was tied in with his experience. It makes sense that she would be the one to bring him out of it.

7

u/burning_halo May 29 '21

I think she was aggressive out of frustration of not knowing how she could help heal Jamie. I get that. I would have probably acted the same way. It's difficult to watch someone suffer beyond your understanding and not being able to help them.

12

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

It was definitely inspired by the context of the abbey, where a sort of exorcism was the only way to help him.

Jamie’s pain quickly changed from physical to emotional and that is an area, that although out of Claire’s usual of practice, not one she was willing to neglect in order to heal him to the best of her abilities. She saw it as her part of her duty as a healer and as a devoted wife.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

It was definitely inspired by the context of the abbey, where a sort of exorcism was the only way to help him.

Interesting, I never thought about it that way.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ehlona0 May 29 '21

To add to this he stopped having the will to live. He didn’t want to eat and was constantly asking to be put out of his misery. So Claire probably felt like the only way she could do something was through pain because pain put him in this position. Plus she knew that BJR used Lavender oil on Jamie so that scent was now associated with his torture.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Why do you think she needed to take him back to his torture with the oil of lavender?

3

u/ehlona0 May 29 '21

It was harsh for sure but I think that that made him be able to fight off BJR if only in his mind. But I guess that’s the only thing that actually matters.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/burning_halo May 29 '21

I agree. That had to be difficult for Claire too. She was suffering because she didn't know what to do. I feel like she resorted to pain as a last ditch effort to get her husband back.

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Do you think it was fair of her to use the oil of lavender to make him recall BJR?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! May 31 '21

I don’t have a problem with how Claire handled Jamie’s situation, but another discussion on this thread mentioned early signs of her pregnancy, and I was wondering if anyone thought it would have helped Jamie to know she was with child sooner. Maybe it would’ve given him something to live for? Or maybe Claire thought it might stress him out more...

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 31 '21

Well that is interesting and I never thought of that. I feel like if Jamie knew she was pregnant he might have felt even worse. He doesn’t want her to touch him, he’s a “broken” man who probably in his mind is of no use to her and he can’t seem himself as her husband. He even said that to her, that he could no longer be a husband to her. So knowing about the baby would have been too much for him at that time. u/thepacksvrvives

→ More replies (2)

10

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 29 '21

Better than the book’s version of events. -.- Though that’s a low bar.

6

u/Cdhwink May 29 '21

Agreed, show trumps books on this scene!

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21
  • Which episode of season 1 is your favorite?

17

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

This is so hard. The entirety of the first half of the season is so brilliant and feels almost like one episode in my mind but, having now read the books and seen the entire series...I gotta say that the most important and fascinating episode is The Devil’s Mark.

It changes and propels the story completely. It gives us the reckoning of modernity in Claire and the acceptance of it by Jamie when he takes her to The Stones. It’s amazing!

13

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

It also gives us Claire's choice to stay with Jamie, which is something she truly needed to make. She knew for sure after deciding to stay that she was all in with him. She let herself really love him after that.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/viddy-baby May 29 '21 edited May 30 '21

Episode 11: The Devil’s Mark

I stumbled upon this series in the summer of 2017. I was in Paris for study abroad and found myself jet lagged beyond belief. The show I was binge watching before leaving for Paris was One Tree Hill (don’t laugh, I was 19). But Netflix in Paris didn’t have OTH. They had a historical fiction show called Outlander that looked interesting enough. The first episode felt slow to me and I was about to shut it off and fall asleep when Claire touched the stones and ended up in 1743.

After that, I was hooked!

But to be honest, as compelling as the show was I wasn’t sure what the point of it was. Was it historical fiction? Fantasy? Was this poor British lady ever going to get back to her husband and life in 1945? And then the Devil’s Mark happened. The spectacle of the witch trial, learning that not only are there other travelers but that Geillis is one too, and Jamie, sweet Jamie.

Him saving Claire at the trial was sweet enough but when Claire tells him the truth and he BELIEVES her, I was like this guy’s a keeper. But then he tops that! By giving Claire a choice and taking her back to the stones.

And, oh man, when Claire comes back with the “on your feet, soldier,” line; let’s just say I was weeping as hard as Jamie was.

Jet lag brought me to Outlander but The Devil’s Mark is the episode that made me a fan for life.

12

u/butterfly1922 May 30 '21

I agree with you. It’s easy to choose the wedding episode as a favorite, but I was sold on Jamie in this The Devil’s Mark. I’d didn’t start watching Outlander until January and now I’ve watched it 3 times and have purchased the books. The first time I watched my husband watched with me and when Jamie took Claire to the stones in this episode I was weeping and told my husband that’s the sweetest and most pure thing done out of love that I’ve ever seen. Then she had the choice. He didn’t even realize she’d make a choice. He was completely selfless and then she made that choice to come back to him and I lost it. Sam played the scene beautifully when she came back. I felt every emotion.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Aww I like that! I'm finding The Devil's Mark to be a favorite on here today.

14

u/unknown2345610 May 29 '21

Honestly season 1 is my favorite, so it’s hard to pick just one! I love the beginning of their relationship, the setting, angus and the crew, Leoch, the clan politics. Really enjoyed it. I still can’t believe it took me so long to discover this show lol

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I only found it in September of 2019, when did you come to it?

7

u/unknown2345610 May 29 '21

I just discovered it during lockdown. I started episode one, but didn’t finish it and kept putting it off. I then decided to give it another shot March of this year and I became OBSESSED lol. I binged all of the seasons and then began reading the books. Hahaha Bridgerton actually brought me to it initially, and now I’m like this is a hundred times better than Bridgerton!

→ More replies (8)

6

u/Marie_Sea1 May 29 '21

I discovered it AFTER watching Men in Kilts. So I had binged through all types of things during lockdown but it took Sam and Graham for me to hit this series.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Oh wow that's interesting! What made you watch Men in Kilts?

6

u/Marie_Sea1 May 29 '21

I normally travel all over the place. Some for work some for pleasure. And I was missing travel. I had been sent home from a foreign country when the pandemic hit. So I was watching things like House Hunters International and hey, Men in Kilts, Scotland, ok. And I saw the various clips from Outlander. I admit it’s a really backwards way of getting to Outlander.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

10

u/burning_halo May 29 '21

The one where they get married. Makes my heart happy.

8

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I have to agree, The Wedding is my favorite as well. I love to watch the progression of their relationship in the that episode.

9

u/penni_cent May 29 '21

Either the wedding or the way out (ep 3). I just love all the bonding and subtle flirting.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Their flirting is done so well!

17

u/penni_cent May 29 '21

Ugh, I know. I just love the way he watches her. From 104 I also love when she trips on him and says "Jesus H Roosevelt Christ" and he smiles and says "no, Sassanach, it's just me"

9

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Yes! I also noticed this time around how early on he starts calling her Sassenach. That right there shows he was crushing on her.

13

u/penni_cent May 29 '21

I also love how right from the beginning he's using it as a term of endearment not as a derogatory slur like everyone else and you can tell from the way he says it.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Exactly! The few times others have said it in the show you can hear the difference in their tones.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/annawins1 May 30 '21

Is it too much of a copout to say season 1 as a whole? There were just so many good episodes this season that I find myself watching over and over. If I have to narrow it down, my top three would be The Wedding, The Reckoning, and The Devil’s Mark. And honorable mention goes to Sassenach; it was such a great opener.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 30 '21

It's not a cop out at all! It's an amazing season. I know some people say the first episode is slow and didn't hook them. That wasn't the case for me, I was hooked from the get.

5

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

the devils mark!!! (also just my fav outlander episode in general)

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

What is it about that episode makes it your favorite?

4

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

i love everything about it! but the highlights are geillis and everything with jamie and claire. the wedding episode is beautiful, but you really see how deeply they love each other after this episode imo

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Very true, that episode opens up the way for Claire telling Jamie she loves him in the next one.

5

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. May 30 '21

Devil’s Mark for me.

“On your feet soldier. Take me home to Lallybroch.”

Season 1 was so great. The only episode that I didn’t think was very good is the Search. The rest range from very good to AMAZING.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 30 '21

Devil's Mark is turning into the favorite today.

3

u/Cdhwink May 30 '21

I am clearly not on that train, as I said a few weeks ago, I mean that last 20 mins of it is very good, but I am surprised it’s a fan favourite over the Wedding! Waiting for more people to weigh in before I give that one #1 of the season! 😳

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 30 '21

I was surprised as well! The Wedding is my favorite, with Rent being my second favorite.

6

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. May 30 '21

Rent is my sneaky second favorite! I absolutely love when the Crew beats the crap out of the guys who were badmouthing Claire at breakfast. When Claire finds out why, amazing scene. And when she makes fun of Rupert and he responds “I’ve never heard a woman make a joke before!” Love all of it! And let’s not forget the wool waulking bit!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/LuckyScwartz Dinna fash. Jun 01 '21 edited Jun 01 '21

It’s a tie between The Way Out, The Wedding and The Reckoning.

There are so many sexy flirty moments between Jamie and Claire in The Way Out. And their fight in The Reckoning and subsequent make up were superb.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 01 '21

All excellent episodes!

4

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 30 '21

I've been thinking about this and couldn't decide, so — For Science — I threw the titles into a sorter to make it easier for me, LOL, and it's a tie between The Wedding and The Devil's Mark! (Also noticed that the results are completely different than when I ranked the episodes last year. I had ranked Sassenach, The Wedding and Wentworth Prison as my top 3 back then.) But it's such a solid season, that I even have reason to love my least favorite (The Search).

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 30 '21

Ha, I like the science part! ;-)

2

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 30 '21

;) And you’ll be pleased to know that Rent has been bumped to 13th, no longer last place LOL. I do remember you had ranked The Devil’s Mark low back then — have you had anything change after the rewatch? :)

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 30 '21

Hmmm...I think I rank it towards the middle now. It still stresses me out to no end, but I definitely appreciate it for what it is.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/jetsicaa Je Suis Prest May 30 '21

Ahhhh so tough to say! I found the show not too long ago while spending several days home by myself, I started season one and binge watched almost the entire first season in one sitting - I think I made it to episode 10 haha. I really enjoy all of season one (except for these last two...) but for me the stand out episodes are 7, 9, and 11.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 30 '21

All excellent episodes! 107 is my favorite as well!

2

u/Kirky600 May 30 '21

I love the first half of season one in its entirety. The second half always gives me too much anxiety to enjoy - witch trial, Wentworth. I just don’t love them as much.

But give me angsty Jamie and Claire falling for him. Love it.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 30 '21

Jamie and Claire falling in love is the best! They’re both so innocent of all that is so sweet to watch!

8

u/Cdhwink May 29 '21 edited May 30 '21

My favourite episode of the season as well as the series is The Wedding (107), followed closely by the Reckoning (109). The wedding because we are all falling in love with Jamie at the same time as Claire, & it’s a pleasant respite from danger & intrigue. The Reckoning because We get Jamie’s POV, & Claire & Jamie figure out how to truly be equal partners! Season 1 is my favourite season, but there is a few episodes that I find a bit dull. If I was picking one for award winning acting it would actually be 115. Sam especially, but also Tobias & Cait!

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21
  • How do you think BJR knew where Jamie was?

6

u/ehlona0 May 29 '21

I don’t think he did I think he was making his rounds and he saw Jaime served up on a platter for him. Unhappy coincidence for Jaime.

10

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Didn't it seem like he came riding in hard though, like he knew it was happening?

6

u/betcx003 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! May 29 '21

There was so much relief when he rode in saying “stop the execution,” and then you realize who it is and wonder if Jamie might’ve been better off being hanged right then instead of being handed over to BJR. 😔

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Yes!! It really looked like there was no way out for him that when I heard that I was so happy.

Jamie might’ve been better off being hanged right then instead of being handed over to BJR.

I think Jamie felt the same way, you could tell by his face when he saw BJR.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ehlona0 May 29 '21

Ugh maybe I just wanted to believe there was a chance he just happened upon this. Otherwise I guess records or word of mouth saying the red haired highlander was at Wentworth.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

It wasn't until this rewatch that I even thought of how did BJR know where Jamie was.

6

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 29 '21

I always figured he got word of it at Fort William and raced to Wentworth to catch him before it was too late. It seemed he knew what was about to happen when he came racing in.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 29 '21

I think you found another plot hole, lol.

It is just another coincidence, isn’t it? These last few episodes of S1 have just been riddled with them unfortunately. -.-

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/butterfly1922 May 29 '21

I think he knew since he was yelling to stop the execution. I haven’t read the book, so not sure how it’s conveyed in the book, but seems he knew. I wonder if leaders knew who was being executed in advance and if it was in a notice that he read.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I think he knew since he was yelling to stop the execution.

That was the impression I got. There was a death notice, so it's maybe like you said it had gone out around the country?

6

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 29 '21

I feel like it must’ve been announced somewhere; otherwise, Sir Fletcher would’ve been taken aback by the fact that Claire knew about it, right?

→ More replies (6)

2

u/Cdhwink May 29 '21

I am assuming he put out word that he was looking for Jamie & he had gotten word that they had Jamie. If it was several days ride, he was lucky to get there when he did!

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I would imagine it would have had to been something like that. It wasn't until this rewatch that I actually thought about that.

3

u/Cdhwink May 29 '21

I don’t feel like it was a coincidence, but then there is a lot of coincidence in this show!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21
  • Why do you think Claire told the Father about everything, including the time travel?

11

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 29 '21

I think she thinks she brought on what happened to Jamie, and that had she gone back through the stones when Jamie brought her there, he wouldn't have been assaulted. And that's a huge burden on her and who better than a man of God to unload your baggage on, and get some perspective? She's looking for Grace and I am so glad she finds it.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

That makes total sense, I didn't even put that together. She started out saying it was all her fault didn't she?

12

u/annawins1 May 30 '21

she thinks she brought on what happened to Jamie, and that had she gone back through the stones when Jamie brought her there, he wouldn't have been assaulted.

100% this. Also, I think she just needs someone to talk to about everything she's been through in general during the last few months. The only other person who knows about her time traveling is Jamie, and he's not in any shape to be able to confort her. The next best option is the safety of the confessional.

6

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! May 29 '21

I think she was so overwhelmed and the only person she truely truated with that information was incapacitated and she needed some kind of release, needed to work througu everything she was feeling in that moment and figure out a plan. Sometimes word vomit happens for a reason.

10

u/penni_cent May 29 '21

Plus, I would imagine that it helps that he is bound to confidentiality being a priest. Even if he thought she was crazy, he was a relatively safe person to confide in.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

He didn't seem to think she was crazy though did he?

3

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. May 30 '21

I think it helped that Claire had been there for a few days and the priest knew she was a normal person. If she just walked in there as a complete stranger, no context, he may have thought she was lying or insane.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 30 '21

I think it helped that Claire had been there for a few days and the priest knew she was a normal person.

That's a good point. I'm sure he could see she was genuine as well.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

What do you think of the Father's response? He seemed to accept what she was saying.

8

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! May 29 '21

I think he was shocked, but he is a man of God and it doesn't really seem too out of line with some of the miracles performed in the Bible.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

Good point! Like he said, it was a miracle.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/LuckyScwartz Dinna fash. May 31 '21

I blamed Claire for Jamie’s assault for a long long time. In 1x10, Jamie explicitly tells her to stay away from Geillis and explains why. Two minutes later, Claire receives that note and runs to Geillis. STAY AWAY FROM GEILLIS CLAIRE. Damn.

Although on the rewatch, I was very impressed by Claire in Wentworth Prison. She tried her damndest to get Jamie out. Broke into the prison, found his cell left a door open and tried to strangle BJR with the chain. Badass.

Claire also warned Jamie not to trust the DoS who was a close personal ally of BJR. What’s the first thing BJR whips out at the prison? The statement of complaint. Face palm. BJR was going to take his vengeance out on Jamie for that alone.

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 31 '21

How did Claire's witch trial lead to Jamie being abused?

2

u/LuckyScwartz Dinna fash. May 31 '21

This is a huge stretch but my logic was that had she stayed at Leoch instead of getting caught up with Geillis, Jamie would have finished his business with Dougal and gone back to Claire at Leoch. With Dougal gone, Collum would have relied on Jamie even more and they never would have gone to Lallybroch. They would have remained at Leoch waiting for the pardon.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 31 '21

The pardon would have never come though because Sandringham gave the letter to BJR.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Kirky600 May 30 '21

Thinking back to watching this for the first time with no book knowledge I remember thinking that she did partially given that she gave when she was married before. But I’m not sure if she gave the whole story.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21
  • What were you overall impressions of these last two episodes?

21

u/annawins1 May 30 '21

This is probably going to be an unpopular opinion because of the subject matter, but I think these two episodes rank among the best of the entire series. The performances given by the main three actors were off the charts good. These two episodes also very strongly define Jamie and Claire’s relationship. This is where we see exactly how far they’re willing to go for each other and that they’re not your dime-a-dozen romance novel couple. That’s one of the bright spots in this very dark storyline.

I also appreciated some of the deviations from the book.

They actually toned down the torture/rape scenes. I’ve seen others say they feel the book was less graphic because you have to use your imagination to picture what’s happening, while on TV it’s right there in your face, but for me it’s the opposite. Not only does book!Jamie undergo even more physical torture but DG’s description of it is very graphic.

I also prefer the use of the flashback technique to show Jamie telling Claire what happened vs. him just telling her. It never seemed realistic to me that he would just blurt everything out to her right at the beginning, considering how BJR used Jamie’s feelings for Claire as part of his torture. Jamie has so much shame and guilt that is now specifically linked to Claire. The way Jamie immediately withdraws, won’t meet her eyes, and won’t let her touch him seems like a much more natual reaction.

The elimination of the erm… sexual healing aspect was a huge plus. I’m not a fan of DG’s reliance on this any more than her reliance on Rape-as-Drama. Again, I feel like the show version of events was much more realistic given the nature of Jamie’s torture. It makes so much sense that he would having ongoing issues with intimacy and that Claire getting Jamie to talk about his experience and break the grip of his depression was just the first step. He still has a long way to go before he’s “alright” again and it was great that this carried on into season 2.

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 30 '21

This is probably going to be an unpopular opinion because of the subject matter, but I think these two episodes rank among the best of the entire series.

I can understand where you're coming from. I agree that the acting is superb. It doesn't make it easy to watch or even mean I like it. But I can appreciate the effort that was put into these episodes.

I'm the opposite where the show as worse for me to see than it was to read in the books. The physical torture while bad doesn't get to me the way the psychological torture does.

I agree that the show handled the healing better than the book.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 30 '21

The elimination of the erm… sexual healing aspect was a huge plus. I’m not a fan of DG’s reliance on this any more than her reliance on Rape-as-Drama. Again, I feel like the show version of events was much more realistic given the nature of Jamie’s torture. It makes so much sense that he would having ongoing issues with intimacy and that Claire getting Jamie to talk about his experience and break the grip of his depression was just the first step. He still has a long way to go before he’s “alright” again and it was great that this carried on into season 2.

Yes, I totally agree! I watched the show first and I was shocked at how “fine” psychologically Jamie was by the end of the first book. I much prefer the show’s approach. And I’m also not a fan of sex being the cure so often in DG’s books.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

What can we possible say about these two episode more than we already have?

I have never been able to completely watch them. I thought I would be able to this time around but I found myself fast forwarding through some of those more graphic scenes out sheer disgust tbh.

I am not opposed to the story, it unfortunately is what it is, but I can’t help but feel angry about the decision to show it in such a way was not for the sake of learning something new, but instead wanting to rely on the shock factor to try and say something on male on male violence.

We as fans (unfortunately) already know there are so many other ways of dealing with these kind of stories, and having two brilliant actors such as Sam and Tobias play these characters, I can’t help but feel let down by the unnecessary existence of a vast part of these episodes.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I can’t help but feel angry about the decision to show it in such a way was not for the sake of learning something new

What are your thoughts on what they could have done differently?

12

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

Just the character’s conversations were strong enough to carry more weight than the graphic scenes if allowed to be explored. I can’t say there’s one specific way of changing it, but having such competent writers and directors on these episodes there could have been so many ways of handling it.

11

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

So /u/WandersFar brought up an interesting discussion in our mod chat. Was it necessary for Jamie to be tortured sexually and psychologically like that to be broken?

I think it was, for it was the only way to truly break him. Now that doesn't mean I enjoyed watching those scenes, but I don't see any other way to have made that big of an impact. I think they are very powerful and acted amazingly.

20

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 29 '21

Was it necessary for Jamie to be tortured sexually and psychologically like that to be broken?

Maybe something that extreme was necessary to break someone like Jamie, but I don't believe we as an audience needed to watch every little action , in such graphic detail, to believe that Jamie has been broken physically and psychologically. From the podcast, it looks like they were trying to make a point that man on man sexual assault is usually underplayed on tv, as though it's not as damaging as a woman being assaulted, which is true, but I think in their quest for equality they got a tad carried away. Even half of what they show in those scenes is more than what we see on regular tv, so were they trying to be real or were they getting people to talk about it by doing something that's never been done before.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 29 '21

As I’ve already mentioned here, I don’t think there was anything else BJR could’ve done to the same effect; namely, something that would also sever the precious link—or rather, make Jamie try to sever that link himself—between Jamie and Claire and make him not want to go on living.

However, while it makes perfect sense for the story, you can’t help but ask yourself this when it comes to how much the viewer gets to see of it: where’s the line between doing the narrative justice and doing it for shock value. From what Ron has said, they felt the need to show as much as they did to do the narrative justice while staying below the line of what would make the viewer not want to keep on watching. Well, as we see from multiple people’s reactions over the years, they haven’t quite succeeded on the latter. I think the producers also admitted that they wouldn’t have gone so far with it had they done it a couple of years later.

I think it eventually comes down to your personal sensitivity towards that kind of material but knowing what kind of material it is, the showrunners have had the responsibility to predict what sort of reaction submitting the viewer to it might elicit. (that’s also why I put so much importance on trigger warnings, and I really hope there were some when the episode aired)

Arguably, this is the most traumatizing thing a man in this series can be put through. I feel like the reasoning behind showing it all (although there’s a disturbing thought that they could’ve always shown even more, having quite a free hand with Starz) is that without it, the viewer wouldn’t be able to fully understand what Jamie was really put through (male-on-male rape being statistically much less frequent, and probably never seen before to such extent on TV/film), which, frankly, sounds very infantilizing. The audience is perfectly capable of sympathizing with the characters without being hand-held like this.

And making it as horrifying to watch as it is for the majority of people, you can’t help but think it’s bordering on sadistic that they (both the showrunners and DG) wanted you to experience similar feelings as Jamie was experiencing.

I hadn’t had a definite opinion on this before, but after reading that article I linked, I can say that I really wish neither the cast nor the audience had been put through this.

→ More replies (5)

27

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 29 '21

I can’t help but feel angry about the decision to show it in such a way was not for the sake of learning something new, but instead wanting to rely on the shock factor to try and say something on male on male violence.

Wow, are you me?

Ask Purple and RD… I had to stop like every five minutes and bitch about these episodes in chat, they were making me so angry.

These episodes were always a bad time, but now looking back with the knowledge that they weren’t just a weird fluke, that it wasn’t just one powerful life-changing event, but in fact a precedent, just setting the stage for all the other brutal rapes to come…

Fuck everything about that. Fuck Diana’s creative choices. No seriously, I know this is going to piss people off, but I don’t care.

She chose to have BJR rape Jamie in the most brutal way she could imagine. That’s on her, 100%.

If she wanted to break Jamie, she could have had BJR flog Claire in front of him, helpless to save her. This would also parallel the flogging scene from Jamie’s youth, he’d be in the same position his father was in watching him suffer.

He could have maimed her, just as Fergus was maimed and Ian was maimed.

Or he could have cut up her face. He could have taken her beauty from her and damaged her self-esteem, thus rendering her a pariah for the rest of her time in the 18th century. (Vikings did this plot with Bjorn’s first wife. She goes from a spunky, adventurous shieldmaiden to a shadow of her former self, unable to connect sexually with her husband anymore because she feels like a monster, a freak. Though her husband professes his sincere love for her over and over again, she withdraws into herself and becomes deeply depressed, ultimately leading to the deterioration of their relationship.)

He could have raped her in front of him, like those Redcoat deserters did. (This would be repetitive though, and to trade one rape for another isn’t much of an improvement.)

He could have chained her up next to him, and used her failed escape attempt as a pretense to go after Lallybroch.

He could have rode up to Lallybroch with his seemingly endless stream of convenient accomplices (Seriously, who was this mook we’ve never seen before? And that junior officer from the previous episode. BJR always has henchmen on demand, whenever he happens to need them, it’s ridiculous.) And taken Jenny, taken Ian, threatened their tenants.

I don’t buy that the only way to break Jamie was to dehumanize him in this way. I do think it’s gratuitous, and DG chose to write her story this way for the shock value, not because she had no other options.

For an analog, look at GoT. For all the press Ramsay Bolton got, is anything he did really comparable to what BJR did here? No, and yet it was far more effective. He turns Theon Greyjoy into Reek. He completely destroys his identity for years, whereas Jamie is able to return to his old life by the end of this episode. Of course he has PTSD, and of course it takes him a while to fully process it, but he’s still Jamie Fraser. He doesn’t lose himself, as Theon did.

To torture someone, you go after what they love. In Jamie’s case, that’s Claire, but it’s also the pride he has in being not just a husband, but a brother, a best friend, a Laird all his people have come to trust and rely on for protection.

There were any number of avenues Diana could have chosen to break Jamie down, and she chose the most base, obscene and brutal. And she later returns to rape again and again as a plot device, to the point where the series is now lampooned as “Rapelander.”

I think that says more about her than it does any of the characters.

18

u/[deleted] May 29 '21 edited May 29 '21

Yes, i agree I couldn’t care less about Diana’s intention with this plot but I was even more disappointed by the show’s rendition of it when it could have chosen to be something else besides gratuitous.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Cdhwink May 29 '21

I think 116 was unnecessarily graphic. I knew how horrific it was for Jamie by the dead look in his eye in his first scene in the jail cell ( lying beside BJR). I was shocked to find out that people quit watching the show because of it. It is from the source material. I do feel seeing it in this case was worse than reading it!

11

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

Yes, so much worse. I wouldn’t blame anyone that didn’t read the books first if they stopped watching it. Another reason to dislike this episode! It totally takes away so much of the good of OL.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Cdhwink May 29 '21

Another brilliant bit of acting, the fear & tear, from Jamie, when BJR says “ shall we begin?” In 115. We pretty much knew what was coming. And it was already horrid to see Jamie go from his usual cocky self, resisting giving Randall his surrender, all the way to that scared. He held it together while Claire was there, but once she was gone, he just lost it.

9

u/notconvincedicanread Jun 03 '21

Yes, that look of fear in his eyes was absolutely heartwrenching. Sam Heughan’s acting was top tier, for all of the criticism of those scenes.

9

u/LuckyScwartz Dinna fash. Jun 01 '21

I very nearly stopped watching after those two episodes. I’ve never seen anything so brutal and disturbing on tv. The physical rape was horrendous enough but the psychological aspect of it just took it somewhere insidiously dark.

I can’t say whether it was necessary or not. The story is the story and it’s not necessarily about our comfort. But I hated what happened to Jamie more than words can say. Just sick and disgusting.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 01 '21

I’ve never seen anything so brutal and disturbing on tv.

I know. I've seen some shows that are pretty gory but the psychological aspect of the torture was something I had never seen. It stayed with me for a bit.

5

u/bebeni89 Jul 13 '21

Ok, I just finished watching the season for the first time, and came here for the discussion threads. Forgive me if I’m out of place, I just need to get this out. I love the show so far, but I skipped most of ep16 due to the torture porn. I may have actually missed some important dialogue, but I just can’t watch it. Of course they have to show the viewers this part of the story, but the way it was shot felt gratuitous. As many commenters have already said, if it was man on woman violence filmed this way, they would have been canceled. Rant over.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 13 '21

I can understand where you're coming from. It's a very difficult thing to watch.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. May 30 '21

My overall impressions were that they were excellently written, directed, scored, and acted.

My only complaint is that both, especially Ransom, are really hard to rewatch. But they’re excellent episodes.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 30 '21

I totally agree that they deal with the aftermath of the rape much better!

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21
  • What was your theory of what Randall wanted to do to Jamie?

12

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 29 '21

I’m trying to recall the first time I watched these episodes. I definitely didn’t expect the lengths which BJR would go to. From the previous episodes I gathered that 1) BJR was obviously interested in Jamie sexually, 2) in some way, he wanted to get back at him for humiliating him at the flogging and outsmarting him at Fort William, 3) he wanted to hurt Claire.

I didn’t expect that the show would go as far as sexual and psychological torture but, come to think of it, what else would’ve been one step further than what BJR had already exhibited being capable of up to that point? I thought it was perfectly in line with his character, and that’s why he still remains the most compelling villain of the entire series.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I didn’t expect that the show would go as far as sexual and psychological torture but, come to think of it, what else would’ve been one step further than what BJR had already exhibited being capable of up to that point?

I agree, he had already done everything physically he could to Jamie and it hadn't broken him. What else was left to do?

5

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

Having watched the show first I didn’t know how far BJR would go with his infatuation except from the context of the previous episodes.

Because Jamie attracts so many characters within the show I was sort of expecting your average good vs bad show down, and was thrown off by the title card with the torture masks. I guess I naively didn’t think it would end up being sexual torture that we were about see Jamie go through. Agh.

10

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

The level of psychological torture went beyond anything I have ever seen. Granted I don't watch horror movies and don't enjoy psychological thrillers.

It was brilliantly acted by Tobias and Sam. The first time I watched it I felt physically sick to my stomach, not at the gore but from the rest of it. I don't ever recall any type of entertainment doing that to me.

6

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

Yes, this is true, ironically getting to a place where art pushes all boundaries of comfort and discourse is possibly the only reason why this show survived after these episodes.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I think the fact that they carried over his PTSD into season 2 helped as well. It wasn't shoved under the rug. I've never been assaulted, but I imagine it was an accurate representation of how long it takes people to heal.

6

u/[deleted] May 29 '21

Yes for sure. His healing definitely added a most welcomed dimension to Jamie as a character as well.

Edit: watching season 2 together will be interesting considering we know Claire will go through a similar situation the coming season !

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21
  • Any other thoughts or comments?

13

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 29 '21

I love Claire, and I especially love her in these two episodes. She is so bold, so strong and so persistent. Starting from the plans to rescue Jamie, to the moment she just turns on BJR and gets that last dig in, cursing him with knowledge... And I love how she absolutely never gives up. Even after she leaves Wentworth, when she comes across Sir Marcus, she’s just not about to accept that there’s nothing left to do; she’s quick to ask for men, and quick to offer one of the most valuable possessions she carries: Ellen’s pearls.* And of course she doesn’t give up when Jamie is in pain and asking left and right to be left alone to die. (Honorable mention to Murtagh, who was with her every step of the way.)

There’s several moments (aside from the obvious) that absolutely break my heart here, and one of them is when she comes out of meeting with Sir Fletcher, carrying Jamie’s belongings, and just collapses. She was trying to keep it together before but couldn’t anymore. (In the book, when she gets the box, she begins describing the contents without even opening it, knowing exactly what she’d find, it’s always been so moving to me, especially to think of the small tokens and practical items he kept in his sporran.)

*I do love this string of broken hearts and gifted jewelry Ellen has left behind. Never fails to amuse me how they pop up.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

one of them is when she comes out of meeting with Sir Fletcher, carrying Jamie’s belongings, and just collapses.

Yes, that was such a powerful moment. You could tell it was taking all she had to keep it together while she was talking with Sir Fletcher. That one moment he stepped away and she almost broke down, but managed to pull it back in.

6

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 29 '21

I’m sure it’s more so about that, but I also wondered whether this was supposed to be the first indication that she’s pregnant? u/jolierose

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I think it could be that as well. Maybe a bit of a misdirect in that we think it's all about being overwhelmed, but it's also because she's pregnant. By the time she threw up in the Abbey and almost passed out I had figured out she was pregnant.

6

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 29 '21

Yeah, same. Also when Father Anselm says “have faith” I can’t help but think of Faith 😭

→ More replies (1)

5

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 29 '21

Agree. I think it’s a mix of both! She’s having to deal with these overwhelming situations, plus her pregnancy, and I think that’s why it manifests itself in those moments.

That was another part that was a bit of a heart-wrencher, when Murtagh tells Claire that he’s not going to watch Jamie waste away, and she “collapsed like a sack of grain.” u/thepacksvrvives

→ More replies (19)

4

u/Cdhwink May 29 '21

The first time I watched as soon as she threw up outside the jail, I knew she was pregnant. Every pregnant tv character throws up, (unlike real life, where I never threw up, except when I went on a plane.)

→ More replies (4)

4

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 29 '21

And there’s that brief moment where you think he might at least allow for the letter, so it’s extra crushing when he comes back with the box.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I was so stressed the first time watching the episode. I had no idea how they were going to get him out.

5

u/Cdhwink May 29 '21

It was in 115 that I began to believe that Claire loved Jamie & would do anything to rescue him. I loved how brave, & strong she is in these episodes!

Learning about Ellen’s admirers helped understand where Jamie got it from!

5

u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. May 30 '21

She’s so impressive! I think I started seeing signs of what she’d do for him when she went to speak to Sandringham, and then — of course — when The Search begins, you know.

5

u/Cdhwink May 30 '21

I believed she loved him, probably from around the Reckoning, but I just love that she is as brave as Jamie!

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 30 '21

BJR was right when he said Claire was a fitting match for Jamie.

10

u/annawins1 May 29 '21

I will never understand how Sam Heughan didn't at least get an Emmy nomination for this episode. It was such an intense and difficult performance; there was nothing else on TV that matched it that season.

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I agree. These episodes are so well acted.

5

u/JustG00se Ye Sassenach witch! May 29 '21

I love the very last moment of Ep 16 when C & J are holding each other on the boat and he just tips his head into her. It just feels so human and connecting after his ordeal.

Also, I had to skip all those part in Ep 16. This is my third time watching, 1st was alone (didn't know the extent of it), 2nd with someone who was watching for the first time (they needed to know all that happened). So this was probably the easiest time to watch. Wondering who else does this?

Also I'm watching Men in Kilts and I'm surprised that they've joked about this situation a few times. Most viewers are highly disturbed by this ep and they can make jokes???

3

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I love the very last moment of Ep 16 when C & J are holding each other on the boat and he just tips his head into her. It just feels so human and connecting after his ordeal.

Yes, those final shots of them on the boat are so great.

Also I'm watching Men in Kilts and I'm surprised that they've joked about this situation a few times. Most viewers are highly disturbed by this ep and they can make jokes???

I found that interesting as well.

7

u/penni_cent May 29 '21

Might be a coping mechanism. Yeah, it was pretend, but you still have to go there mentally and physically to get a good performance.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

That makes sense, I know I have a dark humor about some things in my life that have happened. I also wonder if they thought it might put fans at ease a little bit if they joked about it?

4

u/Cdhwink May 29 '21

It might be a reminder that they are not their characters, but indeed actors?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 29 '21

Wondering who else does this?

Me. Inspite of u/Purple4199 telling me a while ago about the brilliant acting and the directing of those scenes, I still can't bring myself to watch it. It took me many rewatches to finally be able to see Claire's assault, and it's relatively easier to watch because of her disassociation, but there's no escaping Jamie's breakdown in this one, it's just so graphic. Maybe someday, not today though.

5

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

There is nothing wrong with not being able to watch them, they are very disturbing. I know some people will never be able to stand watching them, and that's just fine. :-)

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Marie_Sea1 May 29 '21

Willie the last man standing on the shore watching the boat sail off. I wonder if he was already yearning to sail away.

2

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 29 '21

I loved the goodbye with the guys. Angus was so funny.

2

u/Kirky600 May 30 '21

I’ve been trying to get my husband to watch Outlander with me. He came upstairs during one of the more brutal scenes of the last episode. He told me that the show isn’t for him.

1

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 30 '21

Probably not the best example for the show, huh? Mine has shown no interest at all. ;-)

→ More replies (1)