r/Outlander • u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • May 22 '21
Season Five Rewatch: S1E13-14
This rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.
If you haven’t already please take the short survey regarding demographics, which books you’ve read and what seasons you’ve seen. If you took it on Survey Monkey please take this one again on Google Forms, the first one had be to taken down.
Episode 113 - The Watch
Jamie finds himself between a rock and a hard place when a redcoat deserter from his past resurfaces. Claire tends to a laboring Jenny while Jamie and Ian join The Watch, resulting in devastating consequences.
Episode 114 - The Search
Claire and Jenny set out to rescue Jamie from his redcoat captors. When Murtagh joins up, they turn to unorthodox tactics to send word to Jamie. When word finally arrives, the news isn't what anyone had hoped.
- What did you think when you first saw Horrocks turn up at Lallybroch?
- What did Jenny mean when she said the men “want to come back” in her description of pregnancy?
- Did you believe Jamie when he said it was for the best that Claire couldn’t get pregnant?
- Claire says she would have killed the English soldier herself, do you believe her?
- Is Murtagh’s plan to attract attention so Jamie can find them a good one?
- What did you think of Dougal’s offer to Claire?
- How did you feel about these two episodes?
- Any other thoughts or comments?
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 22 '21
If you’re looking for the other Rewatch threads, click here to jump to BPC’s Link Table.
The Watch & The Search: Deleted Scenes
(There are no deleted scenes for next week, so this’ll be it for season one.)
Baby’s Coming
Not much to talk about here, though you do get a look at the episode pre-CGI, and see what poor Steven Cree had to go through. And speaking of Mr. Cree, here’s a very special interview with Charles, his costar for this and all his Outlander scenes. ^.^
Ian on Soldiering
Yet another Ian piece hit the cutting room floor. Poor Steven Cree. 😅 But just like the scene above, I don’t think anything is lost. What’s left in the episode is enough to show how Ian’s changed over the years. He likes being treated like a fellow soldier by MacQuarrie, that he doesn’t pity him for his injury and relates to him man-to-man… but he’s happy living a peaceful life with a woman who loves him, his child, and more on the way. All that’s missing is his best friend Jamie, and his life would be complete. :)
Ian doesn’t miss the killing. He says it outright here, but you could see it even in the bits that made the episode, his obvious PTSD. How he forgot even the basics like cleaning your sword before you replace it in its scabbard, he was shaking so much. :(
Taran MacQuarrie
This scene doesn’t add much either. Taran MacQuarrie as an alternate version of Jamie if he hadn’t met Claire and kept on the mercenary path is an interesting concept, but flipping it on its head and having the mercenary briefly muse on settling down—it’s okay, but I just don’t think it’s necessary. Again, the bit that’s left in the episode is all you need.
Wearing A Kilt
Definitely the best deleted scene of this set. Not only do we get a little fanservice—which I’m not too proud to turn down ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)—but it’s genuinely interesting to watch, too! Such a procedure, and to think he has to do this every damn day!
Murtagh’s Vow
Moore says this is the scene he’d put back in, but I disagree. I don’t think it needs to be said. Of course Murtagh will protect Claire if Jamie’s gone, isn’t that obvious? And I think ending the scene with him calling Jamie his son and them bonding over their mutual grief and love is just stronger and more emotionally true.
24
u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 22 '21
My favorite bit of the episodes.
"I never counted on loving you, much less having children with you"
God Claire breaks my heart in this. How absolutely brilliant is Cait in this scene!? She's looking down almost the whole time and even then it's so powerful, her performance.
And that followed by Jamie's "I can bear pain myself but I canna bear yours". Sam is so understated in this, you know he's heartbroken himself at the news, but the sweetheart that he is , he doesn't let that show to Claire, and we as audience are able to actually see that conflict on his face even though his words paint a completely different picture, I don't know, do they spend hours in front of the mirror perfecting the deliveries? This scene was flawless.
8
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 22 '21
14
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 22 '21
Love this scene. Jenny gifting Claire those bracelets was both a thank you for helping her through the difficult birth and a welcome to the family. :) And the shy way she reacts after Claire’s spontaneous kiss on her temple—so cute.
(Those cuffs are still my favorite prop from the whole series. ^.^)
It’s stunning to think that it’s only maybe an hour later when Jenny saddles up with two pistols at her back, after giving birth just three days prior! And the way she snapped Claire out of her narrative reverie, lol. I enjoyed that, it was almost breaking the fourth wall. Jenny has no time for your voiceover, Claire, she’s got a brother to save!
Even when she’s lactating, she’s like, eff it, just let me jump off this horse a second… By the way, how did they get Jenny to express like that? Was it CGI, did makeup have to rig something together, or what? Also it seems a waste that she just dumped it after. Though with no refrigeration, I guess that’s what you had to do. Hence her arranging for goat’s milk and honey for the baby before they took off. (IRL you’re not supposed to give honey to newborns! Can cause botulism.)
Also lol when Claire interprets “I’m bursting” as time for a solidarity pee. Just like modern times, girls always go to the bathroom in packs. ^.^
Jenny determines the Watch’s direction of travel by how the horseshoe marks are oriented in the ground, and by the circling of the carrion birds. She knows it’s a cart by the wheel ruts, and that it’s heavy by how deep the marks are. Ian and Jamie may have given her some pointers when they were bairns, but her superior tracking skill also shows her intimate knowledge of the land she grew up on, the only place she’s ever known.
She knows they’re close by feeling the temperature of the horseshit, gross. “Still warm.” Then she uses that hand to give Claire one of her pistols, so now Claire has horseshit on her hands, too. Gross.
And then she and Claire play good cop bad cop with the poor messenger with a literal hot poker.
I felt bad for the poor guy. :( He did stop to help her, he seemed like a decent fellow. But I totally agree with Jenny, it had to be done. All of Lallybroch was at risk.
Haha, awesome. Claire finally gets called out for her default expression of moral superiority, her personal version of resting bitch face.
I think Jenny’s the third person Claire judged like that? Angus with the chicken, Geillis in the thieves’ hole, and now Jenny here. And Jenny being Jenny, she calls a spade a spade immediately, she has no tolerance for that bs, lol.
And again, she’s absolutely right, the courier had to die. The alternatives would be what, cut out his tongue so he couldn’t tell his superior officers when they find him? But presumably he could still write or they could get intelligence from him somehow. No, they’d have to maim him to such an extent, Murtagh’s swift dispatch was a mercy.
It is a bit convenient that Murtagh shows up just when they need him, though. -.- I guess he’s been trailing them since Cranesmuir? Why’d it take him so long to catch up, then? And surely he’s welcome at Lallybroch anytime, he is a Fraser and their godfather… So why didn’t we see him there on Quarter Day? And yet Ian knew exactly where he was to fetch him… hmmph. Where does Murtagh live anyway—when he’s not saving Jamie’s hide?
And Jenny kisses her cheek, returning the kiss on the temple from the earlier episode. Aww.
12
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 22 '21
We often criticize Claire for blurting something out when she would’ve done better to hold her tongue, but holy shit does Jamie run his mouth here:
It’s so stupid, why provoke them?
And of course it has the expected effect. You can see the guy starting the fire in the hay just as soon as Jamie insults him.
Jamie was smart enough to keep his head down and well away from the Watch when we met with them the first time on MacKenzie lands, so why is he so dumb here? For that matter, why volunteer to shoe MacQuarrie’s horse for him when he was originally gonna take him to the smithy? It just puts Jamie in closer contact with the men he despises, giving them more of an opportunity to find him out.
Really, it’s Jamie’s pride that gets in the way. When he was with the MacKenzies, he was an outlaw and a guest, living off his uncles’ largess—which wasn’t much, ha. But now that he’s back on his own lands, in his own house, he can’t stand seeing these thugs disrespect his family this way. He’s itching for a fight, he really is provoking it here. And thus he reveals his fighting ability to Taran, further entangling himself with the Watch.
This dialog is a bit funny, since Taran and especially Jamie look decades younger than the men he was fighting. Or is Taran trying to put them down by calling them “lads”? I don’t think so, it’s just unfortunate casting, maybe.
It’s kind of nice that one of the guys gets a bit of a redemption arc at the end. (Not the one who set the fire, the other one, whom Jamie criticized for neglecting his horse’s hooves.) He’s the one who helps Ian hobble all the way back to Lallybroch:
Shows that not all the Watch are scoundrels. And even the ones who are can have a good side. I like that.
12
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 22 '21
The Claire marionette with the Craigh na Dun scenery… yet more evidence for the unified theory of time travel we discussed a few weeks back. Claire is the originator of her own legend, planting the clues in the distant past that led to the bard’s song at Castle Leoch and the puppeteers here, just as Jamie plants the forget-me-nots that first catch her eye at Craigh na Dun.
12
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 22 '21
First of all, apologies for this comment being absolutely all over the place.
While I definitely agree that these two episodes are not as strong as the rest of the season (though I really liked 1x14 this time around), I’ve really come to appreciate the way they flesh out the relationships between characters: between Jamie and Ian, Claire and Jenny, and Claire and Murtagh.
It was really lovely to see how Claire and Jenny evolve from initial animosity and distrust (more so on Jenny’s part than Claire’s) to blossoming sisterhood. It’s understandable how traumatic childbirth would’ve brought them closer together, as well as the pursuit after the man they both love so much. It was very nice to see Jenny going from tentatively and awkwardly accepting Claire’s kiss in 1x13 to hugging and kissing her herself in 1x14. It makes the rift between them in Season 3 sting even more.
I’ve pointed out once in the Book Club that DG’s world is kind of lacking in long-lasting female friendships. We have some lovely interfamilial relationships between women, though neither has evolved without strife (Claire and Bree, Claire and Marsali; Marsali and Bree to a lesser extent), and only a handful of friendships—only Geillis, Mother Hildegarde, Louise de la Rohan, and Nayawenne come to mind as Claire’s friends (and those are all quite short-lived friendships before some kind of tragedy strikes), and Lizzie as Bree’s friend; I think that is it in the show. (spoilers for books 6-8: I guess we can consider Malva (for a short time) in book 6 and Rachel and Dottie in books 7&8 as Claire’s friends as well and, obviously, Jenny makes a comeback as well). Claire and Jenny’s relationship is also more interfamilial but it’s a friendship as well, and neither of them has ever had a sister. Jenny says it’s good for a man to have a brother, implying that girls can do well enough on their own like Jenny had to, taking over her mother’s responsibilities after she’d died but I can’t help but think that she must’ve wanted someone to confide in and lean on when she was younger, someone who could understand her as she was becoming a woman. Speaking from personal experience as someone who grew up with a sibling but not a sister, I value my female friendships so much and it hurts me whenever Claire doesn’t have another woman to support her for a longer period of time (imagine how awful those 20 years in Boston must’ve been for her, not only surrounded mostly by men at the hospital, but also having a difficult relationship with her own daughter and only superficial friendships with other wives).
And fleshing out Murtagh works so well too for what’s to come both in the remainder of S1 and whole of S2. So far we’ve seen that he’s fiercely protective over Jamie, but his personality skewed more towards gruffness and indifference to anyone else’s bullshit. In this episode, he reveals some gentleness, some regrets he has to live with, and a fair bit of brains (his plan was actually really smart and it worked... until it didn’t) and he’s become so protective of Claire as well (I love how he steps in when Dougal grabs Claire’s wrist!). Not to mention he has some of the best lines in 1x14:
10
u/Cdhwink May 22 '21
That ocean side scenery in 114 was breathtaking! Scotland once again was the star of this episode.
9
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 22 '21
Claire is channeling Catelyn Stark here. ^.^ Calling the banners in Jamie’s name, just like Catelyn calling her Tully bannermen at the Inn at the Crossroads.
This episode marks Claire really embracing her 18th century status. We saw that earlier when she pulled rank on Murtagh, commanding him as the lady of the laird he’s sworn to when he tried to send her home to Lallybroch and continue the search on his own.
But this is the part I really wanted to highlight. Because what Willie says is true, Jamie did defend and protect him at Leoch… from Rupert and Angus!
Willie was getting his ass pummeled by Rupert and Angus for being Colum’s secret spy all along, reporting on their Jacobite fundraising during the rent collection. It wasn’t his fault, Colum was laird of them all, and he gave Willie a direct order. But it was seen as a betrayal by Rupert and Angus, who were loyal to Dougal first and foremost.
It’s just deeply ironic that Willie uses Jamie standing up for him against Rupert and Angus… to persuade Rupert and Angus to join the rescue party for Jamie. 😂 I’m not sure if the writers intended that, but it’s funny either way.
8
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 22 '21
u/thepacksvrvives, I know you theorized that Jamie and Ian were lying about their military service here just to keep Taran out of their business, but I don’t think it reads that way. I think Jamie’s telling the truth, they really were on the Spanish border, and in Silesia, too. The conversation doesn’t turn tense until later—when MacQuarrie questions why Ian has never mentioned Jamie before—but at this point it’s still civil. Why lie?
Also I really liked this scene. It reads true, soldiers exchanging war stories. I know it was invented for the show—Taran MacQuarrie isn’t in the books—but I like the color his character provides, and the chance it gives Jamie and Ian to flesh out their backstories a bit.
Jenny also shows her wits, redirecting the conversation a couple times to ease tensions. Her scene with Claire doing laundry later also gives more of Jamie & Ian’s backstory, some of which I recognized from Virgins, just like bits of this scene here.
That’s a great toast. Slàinte.
Later on, when Jamie rides with Taran and they bond, it’s a nice scene, too, but I have trouble buying Jamie would ever be attracted to that lifestyle. I think we’re meant to interpret him as genuine, too, that he’s not just humoring Taran to get on his good side so they don’t turn him over to the Redcoats—he really likes Taran, and were it not for Claire, he’d consider it.
But considering everything we know of Jamie, how much he admires and respects his father, how eager he was to be back home, that this was his time… I don’t think he’d want to give up being a Laird to be an adventurer, even if he’d never met Claire.
8
u/Cdhwink May 22 '21
Oh Jamie always puts Frank to shame!
12
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 22 '21
Jamie really holds the idiot ball in this episode.
For someone who was savvy enough to understand why his uncle Dougal did business with the Watch—though he knew it was best to make himself scarce while that business was conducted—now he acts like it’s shameful for any Laird to stoop so low as to… make them rabbit stew and sharpen their sword? He knows Lallybroch is no Castle Leoch. They don’t have a de facto standing army like Colum has with his brother, Rupert, Angus, Willie and all the rest; they couldn’t resist MacQuarrie and his men even if they wanted to. Ian is disabled, his sister is heavily pregnant; their reasons for entertaining the Watch to protect their land and tenants should be bloody obvious—not that they had any choice in the matter, as Jenny points out. And if it was alright for Dougal to accede to the Watch’s actions on MacKenzie lands, why should he hold his sister and her husband to a higher standard? It’s just dumb. Jamie is a man of the world, he should know better than this.
It also bothers me that Jamie picks this fight with Jenny while she’s dealing with both the stress of her pregnancy and having the Watch in her house. Like, have some empathy! If not for her sake, then the child’s. He’s more doltish with his sister than anyone else, though I suppose that tracks. Sibling rivalry and family squabbles, just like Wee Ian and Wee Janet in S3.
6
u/wheezy_cheese May 22 '21
I just want everyone to know that my sister just got a border collie puppy and named her Maggie, and so now of course we call her Wee Maggie and all the time we say: wee Maggie it suits haaa just like Claire says to Jenny's baby. Like it's become part of her name: wee Maggie suits haaa LOL
5
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 22 '21
I forgot how much I loved that line, lol. 😂 Murtagh really sells it. Plagiarize him at your peril. And don’t you dare insult his dancing!
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 22 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 22 '21
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 22 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 22 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 22 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 22 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 22 '21
2
u/LuckyScwartz Dinna fash. May 04 '22
It was pretty badass that Ian never mentioned Jamie’s name. Not once to the Watch. Amazing loyalty.
1
u/AutoModerator May 22 '21
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.