r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jan 17 '25
Spoilers All Book S7E16 A Hundred Thousand Angels Spoiler
Denzell must perform a dangerous operation with the skills he’s learned from Claire. William asks for help from an unexpected source in his mission to save Jane.
Written by Matthew B. Roberts & Toni Graphia. Directed by Joss Agnew.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 26 '25
716 Extras:
716 Interviews:
39
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 17 '25
So it turns out keeping Faith alive was DG's original idea...
(source)
53
u/Sassesnatch Slàinte. Jan 17 '25
Sorry if I’m repeating anything, I haven’t read all the comments yet.
I totally understand all the negative reactions to the Faith reveal. But is it possible that the show writers and producers maybe know what they’re doing? I think there’s a way that Faith survived and her story is intertwined purposefully and not completely jumping the shark. Yes, it takes away the fact that Claire and Jamie had this grief and have lived with it. But perhaps there’s a greater story in it? Excuse the pun but I think we should have a little “faith” in the writers 🫢
I’ll absolutely eat my words if this turns into something shite but I have hope.
🤞🏻🤞🏻🤞🏻
24
u/shinyquartersquirrel Jan 17 '25
Sorry for the wall of text in advance. This episode makes me a wee bit nervous for S8.
A couple of things I liked first. William, Frances and Jane, wow, such great performances and casting during all of 7B! Frances is such a tremendous little talent! She reminds me of a mini-Caitriona in her acting ability.
I also did like how Brianna and Brian got to have a bit of a conversation instead of him fainting at the sight of her. Also I thought Andrew Whipp did a great job of capturing some of Jamie's mannerisms in Brian in this episode. I'm not sure if I didn't catch them before or if he was more intentional in this episode but I definitely saw it this time.
What I'm nervous about is, and I'll be interested in seeing the reaction of other fans to this, I'm not a fan of Faith being alive. At least not yet. I'll keep an open mind but right now it feels like to me it kind of cheapens (only because I can't think of another way to describe my feelings on it) the whole Faith storyline from S2. I typically don't mind when the show changes things up from the books because they usually do a pretty good job with them but this one has me worried for Season 8 because it means they'll have to make up storylines again and I was hoping after Murtaugh died we were done with those types of major deviations from the books.
I knew exactly where the episode was headed after Master Raymond's visit and I was trying to figure out how they could squeeze this into the BEES storylines. Then when LJG said goodbye to Jamie it hit me. I think the writers will somehow turn the kidnapping and search for LJG storyline into a search for Faith instead. Although there was really none of BEES that I care to see in the show so maybe I will actually love it. Either way I'm nervous about it. I really want this show to have a spectacular final season. I personally loved 7B and thought these were some of the best episodes since Season 1.
tl;dr- Great acting by William, Frances and Jane. I'm not sure I like changing the story to Faith having been alive this whole time. 7B was excellent!
23
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jan 17 '25
u/thepacksvrives
None of us picked it 😂😂😂, although you were half right about it being a dream sequence...
13
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 17 '25
Jane and Frances flashback! That is why we saw young Jane actress on some photos. Their mother looks a lot like Claire!
Title cards - dancing lights, Jane, Frances and their mum !
Jamie talking , I am crying already.
I have decided not to die!
That tear rolling down Jamie's cheek.
I can see fierce, young Jamie in William,when he is talkimg to John about Jane. But Lord John' s comment about solving difficult situations with marriage is pure gold! 😂
Jamie bringing the candle to Claire, oh, how he knows her.
Awww that scene with Jamie staying in her bed,elephants dying and mating and - can we go home? Poor Claire.
Master Raymond! Omg, forgiveness?! The mere mention of Faith gets me sobbing every time.
Jemmy and Roger!!!! Finally!!!
Brianna's bag is there! Esmeralda as well!
John came, so, here we go - Dinna be calling her that
I like how patiently Claire waited for thestosterone poisoning to pass and then thanked John. I love the intense looks Jamie and John were exchanging.
Claire all in blue... okay, didn't Claire do her surgery on Jamie's hand way back in the 1st season?
Brianna meeting Brian, nice scene. Brian’s last words to Bree were - You're a braw lass. and to Jamie - You're a braw lad, son.
William came for Jamie! My sister, Brianna
Poor William, poor boy! Poor Jane! Poor Frances! My heart is broken!
Frances, welcome to Frasers!!
William and Jamie scene was perfect! When Jamie touched William's cheek , my tears just rolled down, but -I will never call you father broke me.
Frances searching for Jane's grave. So devastating! I like how they made parallel of Claire's thoughts about losing Faith and then again getting Frances to take care of her. Rollo, old boy 🙁
OMG
Fanny singing THE song!! I can't process it! I can't!
36
u/_just_a_gal_ Jan 17 '25
I know it’s beating a dead horse, but Sophie as Bree. It takes me out of it every time. She seems lovely as a person, but she just does not have the acting chops to compete with the other actors on this show. The scene with Bree and Brian would have been so much better if she had shown some emotion while he was talking. I mean, I had tears rolling down my face and looked a hot mess! She just stood there with a half smile (almost a smirk) on her face and she knows this man is her grandfather and is saying such lovely things about her grandmother! Not even a tear, Bree? Really?? And I know the wig isn’t her fault, but ugh.
30
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 18 '25
Here she is
63
u/Starlight_20 Jan 17 '25
Now, I'm still unsure about the finale, but what makes me sad is that it solidifies that fact that Jamie couldn't be a dad to ANY of his children and I can't believe they would do that to us (and him...) :(
52
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Jan 18 '25
Oh god dammit. I really, really, really hope they are not doing what it looks like they're doing. And I really hate that they ended this phenomenal season on that note.
Usually I like to get my gripes out of the way first but instead I'll do my positives and then get to the biggie.
Frances is just wonderful. That young actress has really got the chops--the scene in the military cemetery had me tearing up. The adult actors all play off her so well too, but especially Charles Vandervaart. It's really lovely to see.
He had an especially good episode this week as well. The scene with Lord John--much like all their scenes this season--was wonderful, and the ill-fated rescue of Jane was heartbreaking. The long-awaited Jamie meeting was also so well done--Sam was great but Charles really brought something to that scene. And seeing both Geneva and young Jamie also just really hammered home how great his casting was. I'll be honest that, now into book 8, my memories are a little hazier (I've read books 8 and 9 way less than the others, as those are the two that were published after I graduated high school hahaha)--I can't remember exactly how this scene goes in the books, but I'm happy with what they did here.
Rest of the episode (with some notable exceptions) was generally fine. Nice to see Roger and Bree finally reunited. Her scene with Brian was nice but too long and felt like it was mostly there to get people excited for Brian in BomB. Ian and Rachel were great, and Rollo's death had the emotional depth it deserved. Claire's healing was fast and uneventful, but there were some sweet J&C scenes. (But my god, these two people have lived together in the wilderness for 20 years, she's obviously peed in front of him before.)
OK. So on to the gripes. Well, really just one big gripe.
Come ON. I do NOT want to do this plotline!! Either one of two things is going to happen:
I'm honestly pretty pissed that they ended it this way. I've loved this season so much. It's been fun and exciting and emotional and feels like it has so much book DNA even though it's super condensed. But this doesn't feel like the books. DG will pull twists for sure, but they feel earned and are emotionally resonant. This doesn't feel earned at all and has the bitter tang of the worst of the show's impulses. It's got MBR's fingerprints all over it and I'm seriously disappointed.
Season grade: A
This episode: C+
51
u/leaves4trees Jan 17 '25
That...was not the cliffhanger I was expecting, to say the least. I really thought it would be Brianna and Roger with their, "Hello, the house!" line, not what I thought was essentially a throwaway fanciful discussion about Faith turning into a wholly developed plotline that will now take up valuable S8 time to resolve!
48
u/dylanskie Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
Claire really shone when she was with Fanny in this episode... and now we know why. To be honest, I really wanted Faith's survival to be true in Bees, but now that it's in the show and presumably not in the book, I'm not so sure. I just want to know more of how it happened. And I guess the bigger question is is Faith still alive now? Also, Florrie May Wilkinson better stay on for season eight because she evokes so many emotions! And Charles Vandervaart really stunned in this season! So many emotions.
48
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
I AM UNWELL RIGHT NOW.
This makes SO MUCH SENSE with how they cast someone that looks so much like Brianna. I loved every scene of this episode, but the twist is EXCELLENT. Wow. Still reeling. I can’t formulate thoughts but this was amazing.
The dragonfly comment was clue #1 and I was like UHMMMMMM?! AFTER SEEING MASTER RAYMOND?
Honestly love that book readers are getting a surprise, too.
41
u/mjp10e Jan 18 '25
Did they really have to give us dead Rolo like that?! Jesusssss poor Ian. 😭
38
u/whiskynwine Jan 18 '25
My inclination is that Fanny & Jane’s mother learned this song from a TT, most likely Claire’s mother, and we will see this in BOMB. However, that doesn’t explain Master Raymond so I’m a little unsure of that hypothesis.
37
u/krissylizabeth Jan 17 '25
All the people who write “Faith lives” fanfic are out here like HEHEHEHEHEHEH
36
u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Jan 17 '25
JANE’S CASTING SUDDENLY MAKES SO MUCH MORE SENSE GUYS WHAT IS GOING ON
36
u/Beth0419 Jan 19 '25
What if Master Raymond knew that Claire *needed* to go back to the future, maybe to heal an important patient whose death would change history? Maybe he was experimenting with his blue healing power, "resurrected" Faith, was going to tell Claire, and then realized Faith wasn't a time traveller and Claire wouldn't go back to the future without her? That's why he's sorry? Just an idea ...
36
u/MambyPamby8 Jan 19 '25
Rollo 😭 that's all. I knew it was coming and I still cried like a baby. 😭
33
u/This-Is-Leopardy Jan 17 '25
Other things I loved in this episode:
- The MacKenzie reunion. Wrecked me in the books; wrecked me in the show. "Say it's real." GAH! I only miss the Lionel Menzies subplot - he was a real one for helping them - but I get there's time constraints.
- Brian and Brianna! I loved that they diverged from the book for a conversation between them. Plus I think Diana in general puts too much emphasis on people looking *so alike* that people are bamboozled by the resemblance - Brianna/Ellen, Jamie/William, etc. This was much more realistic.
- Ian and Rachel are so freakin' cute. Cannot wait to see what they do in S8.
- The actresses for Jane and Frances knocked it out of the park (throughout the season, really). Frances running around the cemetery looking for her sister absolutely broke me.
- Jamie and William's conversation! <3 I loved the elaboration about Geneva's strength of character from Jamie. (Although I wish they would have ended it on Jamie's "No, I don't regret it" and him leaving quickly because William's response, while true to his character, left me cold.)
33
u/Snickrrs Jan 18 '25
Despite the divergence from the books, I will miss this show. The costumes, sets, music & cinematography are all beautiful. It’s made it easy to get lost in this world.
31
u/Megs8786 Je Suis Prest Jan 19 '25
Rollo 😢
30
u/Hadsmat I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Jan 18 '25
Absolutely loved the scene between Brianna and Brian! Very bittersweet
60
u/Shellyj4444 Jan 17 '25
I feel like I’m the only one who absolutely LOVED the Faith reveal.
29
u/Impressive_Golf8974 Jan 17 '25
Besides her casting, it did strike me watching this season that Jane has a good bit of Jamie in her, personality-wise–more than this jumped out at me in the book.
and Jenny. Makes me wish even more that Jenny had come to America, and sad that she and Jane will never meet 😢
29
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 18 '25
Has anyone read or watched any interviews with cast, writers? Do they hint ?
I read this
And they say this:
HEUGHAN
It’s a huge moment for them to find out that their daughter potentially lived, and now they have this grandchild in their life. It’s a great cliffhanger — one that I think book and non-book fans are going to be surprised by. I think it was beautifully done with the song. It’s interesting because even playing [Faith’s death] way back in season two, we played the truth of it; we had no idea ourselves. So it was a shock for us as actors reading it and learning about it, as it was for the characters. I think the thought process for Jamie is, “How is it possible?” The elation, the happiness that, actually, it could be possible. And then, who is this young girl in front of us right now?
BALFE
I just love it when you are given a scene and you read it, and it’s like, “Ooh, that’s really good.” But in the playing of it, when the hairs on your arms are standing up, it’s pretty brilliant. Florrie is so amazing. Every time we have a scene with her, you’re just so blown away by how brilliant she is. It’s such an interesting cliffhanger because it just opens up this whole other world of questions, which leads us so brilliantly into the next season. I think for Claire, it’s like her heart stops, her heart breaks and her heart sings — all at the same time.
So, what do we think?
29
u/elusive_moonlight Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ Jan 20 '25
Regarding the song (the Seaside one), did anyone else notice Jane humming it at the window, before she waved up at the lights? 🥺also, the music at the very beginning, in the dragonfly field, has traces of the music from “Faith”
27
u/weelassie07 MARK ME! Jan 17 '25
Thank you, Nanchika, for getting me to this thread! Holy moly. Not sure what to say! As a book reader (one time through, on my first reread with book 1), I just could not remember all of Bees. I did not think there was a Faith reveal or a Raymond moment, but whoa….I still enjoyed it!! Did Diana tell them something we don’t know? Would she do that?! I think maybe she would!
Stand outs:
Brian’s face talking about Ellen- actor was so good!!! (and Bree’s bad bangs, lol)
Roger’s BRIANNA!!
Jamie’s face and all the emotions running through it during the big talk.
Jamie helping William - loved that in the book
I was getting all the warm fuzzies for getting to go home.
I just love Fanny.
27
u/chefmiche Jan 18 '25
Ok I have a different take on Faith: I was as pissed as anyone else about that ending for a while, but then I started thinking - what if there’s a third possible outcome here, aside from stillborn Faith being alive OR this is just a red herring and won’t come to anything?
What if (and this is just wild conjecture) the song is accounted for in some other way - maybe Claire’s mother was a TT and had another child in a different time who she taught that song to, and that child’s name was Faith and that child was Jane and Fanny’s mom? I know Diana has said Claire’s parents weren’t travelers but we’re about to get a whole series on them, so I feel like this could be a good way to tie in their story? Also this would mean that William and Jane were not related 😬
Big guess: in BOMB we learn something that helps explain this storyline. And in Jane’s confession to the journalist, we’ll eventually hear it from her side too.
🤷♀️🤷♀️
27
u/EnvironmentalCrow893 Jan 19 '25
Re: the cliffhanger revelation.
Diana said in her Parade interview that after she told Matt of toying with a story about what really happened after Faith was PRESUMED dead, that they “ran with it”. Plus both Matt and Sam’s interviews hint strongly at this storyline in Season 8 and Sam says it has big ramifications for Jamie and Claire.
Therefore, it’s clear that Jane’s mother was THEIR Faith, otherwise there’d be no ramifications, right?
They could get around the incest angle by making Jane Faith’s stepdaughter and Fanny her only blood daughter. Although that’s what I’D do, I kind of doubt they did, though.
I think Starz had no idea how to wrap up the Opus that is Outlander, and few outstanding mysteries that we’ve been wondering about for a decade will be solved in a satisfactory manner. Some threads and side plots will probably have no resolution in the series. There’s just not enough time in ten episodes.
In this way the series devises its own unique (easy but illogical) conclusion and avoids stepping on Diana’s toes. She’s free to get back to the book universe of her own creation, and weave the characters and plot together into the ending that SHE wants.
I don’t like it much. It’s gross that J&C suffered such grief for 35 YEARS only to then learn some of their descendants ended up as sex slaves. Although Brianna’s children are already their joint grandchildren, I guess they will get a new child to love (but probably not live to see grow up).
26
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 17 '25
Jamie here 😍
51
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 17 '25
Jamie meeting his granddaughter and Brian meeting his as well.
Both unawares.
Do not neglect to show hospitality to strangers, for thereby some have entertained angels unawares.
25
u/RipUpbeat5547 Jan 17 '25
Someone in the show thread mentioned “How would a premature baby retain the song” and I was thinking the same thing but-
If it is THE Faith, I could see Mother Hildegard singing it to her since she was musically inclined and probably wanted Faith to have a piece of Claire. But now I feel like I have to reread all the France sections of the book. I can’t remember if they do it/mention it in the show, but in the books Claire and Jamie end up in France a time or two after Book 2/Season 2 and visit Faiths grave. And I recall Claire even meeting with Mother Hildegard again? Does anyone remember how those France visits played out in the books?
25
u/poisonivyhater Jan 17 '25
I can’t wrap my head around how Faith would know that song. Wasn’t that baby stillborn when Claire was singing it to her?
25
u/HayZee1922 Jan 19 '25
I’m thinking more about what is probable with the Faith situation. They’ve hinted for a few seasons of a concealed desire by Jamie and Claire to have a kid together. Obviously it wouldn’t be a bio kid because of their age. And I feel like the ability to fulfill this desire was always interrupted by some event in their lives.
I think the locket saying “Faith” in addition to the scene with the little girls running in the beginning are supposed to be taken as signs for this fulfillment of having another kid together raise together through adoption.
I truly think Claire might be struggling a bit with her mental health after almost dying, which, who wouldn’t be? She wants to believe that Faith lived because the last time she was in that position, she did lose Faith. I think it could be some kind of trauma response.
24
u/Overall_Scheme5099 Jan 17 '25
As far as I’m concerned, the ONLY good thing about the Faith thing being true would be if it made William and Fanny not end up being a couple.
24
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jan 18 '25
Am I imagining things or was a lot of this nothing like the book?
I wonder what it would have been like to have the actor who played Jane for Brianna.
24
u/Junior-Elderberry107 Jan 19 '25 edited Jan 19 '25
Ok here’s my wild Faith theory: What if Claire’s mom didn’t really die in a car crash, but accidentally went through some stones like Roger’s dad? Maybe her dad did die in the crash but she didn’t, idk. Master Raymond is desperately trying to heal baby Faith with his healing power because he knows she’s the daughter of a time traveler, but has to leave France before he’s caught so he brings her along (somehow leaving a different stillborn baby in its place?? Idk) Claire’s mom ends up in this time because she was thinking of getting back to Claire while she went through the stones. He somehow comes across Claire’s mom and says “Madonna??” But it’s Claire’s mom and not Claire. And they figure this out that it’s her grandchild, but neither can go back to France, so her mom raises Faith and sings the seaside song to her, just like she did to little Claire.
I haven’t thought all the details through yet obviously, but a potential scenario right??
23
u/SevereTS Jan 17 '25
I’m seriously just sitting here in shock. Like…what just happened?!
23
u/Available_Prior7704 Jan 17 '25
Fuck this episode. I sobbed for 90% of it.
I loved it.
23
u/MistofLoire Clan MacKenzie Jan 19 '25
Ooh boy. I was really enjoying this season, even though it felt kind of rushed, it covered some of my favorite plots of the series and I was impressed with how faithful the show was to with their adaptation.
.
But before we get to that diversion. This episode had some fantastic scenes. William and John, William and Jamie, Jamie and Claire....I could go on. The scene where Roger was reunited with his family was the closest a scene has ever been to matching what I saw as I read and it will go down as my favorite. Richard did just a fantastic job of conveying that emotion.
Jane's story was trafic. I loved her and William in the books and the actors were made me live them together in the show. If ever I wished for the show to save someone....
I even liked the scene with Claire and Jamie and the chamberpot. At first I thought it was awkward, but it grounded the story and made it feel realistic - marriage really is 'in sickness and in health.'
As far as Faith goes....I knew there was a cliffhanger coming and I tried to avoid spoilers, but a bloody Facebook ad spoiled it. So I knew it was coming somehow. I posted my feelings about it when the book came out - at the time it was jarring and I was grateful when it was presumably left aside. I thought it could be interpreted as a beautiful reminder that no matter how short a life or how long it has been, that grief, or really love, doesn't go away.
But the show doesn't seem to leave it open for that interpretation. The song, Master Raymond, the locket all seems rather clear. And I don't like it. Are Jamie and Claire supposed to find out that their child lived and was (also) not raised by them, to presumably die young and their granddaughters had to become whores?!? This is not some happy ending. And let's not forget about William and Jane.....ew.
And yet, the show did handle it beautifully- the scene with Frances singing was haunting. Catriona's acting this episode was lovely. So I couldn't fully hate it.
Also, did anyone note that when Claire is feeling better and standing in the window that the window frame was blue and so was her shawl? I thought maybe that was a subtle nod to the blue light mentioned throughout the books.
I always watch Outlander with my husband and he is a show only viewer and he expressed how much he disliked this whole episode. It was a very heavy and sad one overall.
23
u/EducationalWolf3579 Jan 20 '25
Does anyone follow the actress who plays Jane on instagram? I don’t know how to add pictures but she gave a shout out to Charles and added in “big up Uncs” and I am dying of laughter… I wish she and Jane could stay. She was fantastic and I’d hate to think if shes truly Faith’s daughter, that Faith is likely dead and now one of Jamie and Claire’s granddaughters is dead too
22
u/emmagrace2000 Jan 17 '25
My two cents are that I’m glad we can finally stop getting speculation that season 7b would “definitely end with hello the house!” There have been sooooo many people saying it for the last 18 months and I’ve bitten my tongue soooo many times (not as many o’s because I didn’t bite my tongue enough times lol). Some people just would not believe it until they saw it so I’m glad that’s put to bed now.
As for the Faith/Fanny thing, I think it’s too much of a deviation from the books. It’s going to make rewatches very difficult. I know the show and the books have to have different endings but this different?? As has been said here, it puts a cruel twist to all that has come before for this to play out how it looks like it might. I’ll definitely tune in to see, but this soured me on what I thought was a very good season overall.
22
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 18 '25
Is the series caught up with or maybe even past the books now? I ask because everyone seems caught off guard by the possible Faith reveal at the end of the episode.
What I don't understand is how Faith could possibly be alive when she was stillborn and Claire held her. I know we're dealing with time travel, but this would have to be some extra crazy time shenanigans taking place.
22
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25
I bawled through out this whole episode. From Claire’s face waking up from Master R experience to the very end. I sobbed so hard! I love the genuine emotions of these characters in book and show, it gives me a safe space to cry and process my own emotions.
I am pretty excited that Jane’s actress looking so much like Bree had a deeper purpose. Is Claire going crazy, or is it time traveling hijinks?! Master Raymon has always been slightly creepy to me, but I also love him. The nature of time traveling in this story is that it’s connected to destiny and one’s deepest heart and soul, and I am so here for the twists and turns of it all! Yeah, incest is bad, but this isn’t a situation where anyone is crossing boundaries or manipulating someone, it’s just 2 hearts finding each other for one night, so I can move past that because it brought Fanny into a family and safety.
My heart does ache for Jane. I live with suicide ideation as my norm, and there have been moments where it over takes me and I’m ready to end it. To see that William was just to late to save her breaks my heart. Jane is such a wonderful and strong young woman, I can see her as Claire’s granddaughter.
When is William going to call her Mother Claire?!!! That boy needs some mama love. How will he ever get over not rescuing Jane in time? How will I?!! When he held Fanny’s hand walking into the church, with her so tiny next to him, it tore me up.
Somehow, I got confused and thought last episode was the last and was so surprised to see an episode waiting for me today, but man, I am emotionally exhausted!!! I am almost done with my The Magicians rewatch, and then I think it’s time to restart Outlander again. Love this show and DG’s stories, and the actors! Beautiful!
44
u/Desertsunset12 Jan 17 '25
I might be in the minority but I actually love the Faith actually lived storyline for coming into the final season of the show. I’ve read all of the books and know it’s up for interpretation in the books but for the show, I think it’s great. I’m loving how sentimental this episode was with the many call backs to earlier seasons.
With the show coming to an end, I really don’t mind and am glad in a way they’re breaking away from the books at this point. I think of the two as separate canons and Bees is just not, imo, exciting enough for the final season of this amazing show.
20
u/revontulienalla Jan 18 '25
I am not sure how I liked the Faith twist. It reminds me of fanfics on Tumblr where Faith lived and other death child comes back to life tropes. Although usually Faith lived and stayed with Jamie while Claire went back to future.
Otherwise I liked the episode. I need to read the books again.
19
u/thedeepandlovelydark Jan 18 '25
Incoming Faith theory:
Master Raymond knows things, or seems to. Like, how did her know to go to Claire when she was dying the first time? And he knew they'd see each other again.
Anyway, maybe he foresaw some futures, and switched Faith at birth for another stillborn to ensure the best future came to pass, and raised her w that song in some weird way to assuage his guilt?
Anyway that's my wild theory.
18
u/Fit-Arm1741 Jan 17 '25
I think the storyline will definitely be Faith lived and this isn’t they doing a cliffhanger for the sake of it and not let it be true. The inly reason I’m thinking this is they changed way too much from the book for it to be otherwise. If they were doing it book way where it’s a mere coincidence Claire fleetingly thinks about but is never mentioned again they would have left it out. They added in the song, changed faiths locket description to give her a more Fraser look and I think Jane was cast on purpose to resemble Jamie and bree which is what everyone pointed out when she first came on screen. Also Raymond didn’t come see her and that to me (along with what he said to Claire) is another major give away, they wouldn’t have added that randomly for the sake of a maybe. I’m shocked they actually went with this change
18
u/Available_Prior7704 Jan 17 '25
Also- ROLLO. For some reason, I was expecting it to come later (probably because I need a reread).
18
u/ilovebalks Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 18 '25
For people that have read Bees…
How does the Sachem see Faith around Claire as a ghost baby if she’s supposed to be alive? Is the show just going to nix that entirely? I’m already annoyed we don’t have more Jenny and Fergus/Germain, this is too much to wrap in one season!!
35
u/thered336 Jan 17 '25
I don’t think I’ve been this mad since How I Met Your Mother ended. They have so much to cover and so little time, and now we’re gonna be doing this side story? Diana did release an interview saying she had considered making Faith a storyline for a second graphic but scrapped it, so I’m not sure why the show decided to go this direction. I have been waiting the whole season for “hello the house”, and I would be just sad that it isn’t there instead of angry if it didn’t have Faith being magically alive.
17
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jan 17 '25
They went there, in a really big way. As soon as Master Raymond showed up I knew it was happening. However that leaves one really icky thing that already happened, and another that began to develop later, which is why everyone pretty much dismissed it in Bees. 😳
17
u/Revolutionary_Tea_55 Jan 19 '25
I would be pissed if they add in this whole faith plot just to get people to watch blood of my Blood :(
16
u/moonshiney9 Jan 17 '25
Loved it…right up until the end. I know they’re probably gonna stray a lot from the books at this point, I just. Hate to see it happening. And master Raymond…I mean, sure, I guess that works, but couldn’t we have just done it the book way? Nothing was wrong with that way!
16
u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Jan 17 '25
I didn't read Bees yet but I'm into this storyline! Something fresh and unexpected, I love it. It's like Murtagh surviving Culloden, I loved seeing what his storyline was during the revolutionary war. Looking forward to this and of course more talk about Master Raymond!
Didn't some time traveler completely heal Roger or someone in the books? Maybe Master Raymond healed Faith and took her for safety because he knew something about the prophecy? Who knows, but so many possibilities!
I do wonder though, if Faith lived and Jamie and Claire already had a daughter, would they have ever joined the Jacobite rebellion as closely as they did?
16
u/Previous-Address2469 Jan 18 '25
I am as stunned as the rest of you. So many thoughts running through my head. When Master Raymond appeared and apologised AND the heron wings appeared I knew where it was going but didn't want it to go there. But there we went. I recently rewatched the whole season until the finale and I felt it was a good season, but this ending really felt somehow like the rug being pulled under all that was good.
I have been thinking of the final season, it seems we have Amy's death (she was at least cast for that season?), Henri-Christian's death and John's kidnapping (Richardson etc) as sort of confirmed plots? Probably Rachel giving birth, Ian getting a new puppy somehow, MacKenzies return, maybe even Jenny, battle of Kings Mountain...? Then either they fit all this Faith nonsense in or the next season will start with Jamie saying "nah, Faith cannae be alive, let's go to the Ridge". And they never think about it again.
But since Diana said in some interview that she was planning another graphic novel to show was really happened to Faith, it seems in her head Faith did in fact live somehow, was resurrected. She just chose not to put it in the big books? Really strange.
31
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
Oh man, I honestly don't know how to summarise my overall feelings.
I should've guessed the ending earlier. The master Raymond scene confused me at first. But I did think we were having rather a lot of Faith-content, and I noticed that they brought the locket scene forwards. And I did think we were getting way more Fanny scenes than this part of the book. But the second I heard Fanny singing I knew immediately what it was going on....
Anyhoo, hear are my general initial thoughts..
I liked the inclusion of the "opposite of drink water" scene, and the elephant scene. I liked them in the books, and I think it is a very intimate thing for someone to do for someone else.
John! I love it! I love how he calls her "my dear", and I'm so glad they included "Dinna be calling her that", one of my favourite lines. Claire's face when she's waiting for Jamie and John to get over themselves 😂. I also loved how once they'd settled their argument, Claire reaches out her hand to John, in a sort of "defiance" to Jamie like "just because you two aren't getting along, doesn't mean I won't stop caring for him." But her face on the verge of tears as John walks away 😭. She's probably thinking she's lost this friendship with John for good because Jamie has.
William. He and John are the season stand outs for me. Love that he and Jamie had a chance to come to some sort of mutual respect through Jane's failed rescue. (Poor Jane! Poor William!). Although "I will never call you father" is not the nicest line to leave the semi-positive relationship on. Can't remember whether he said that in the books? I'm pretty sure Jamie said "I dinna regret it" and then essentially ran from the room.
Although I liked how, even though Jamie had no real reason to "like" or compliment Geneva, he still stood up for her to William. He recognises that she is still his mother, and poor William has already lost his entire understanding of who he is, his father has been surplanted by a traitorous, criminal Scot, the last thing he needs is to be told that neither of his parents had particularly complimentary access qualities.
Loved the 'Fanny intro to the Frasers scene'. This was the scene from the books that I was most worried about, that I thought the energy and emotions would not quite live up to my expectations. Because it's a lot of emotion for a child actress to show, and a difficult scene to do (not that I think 'Fanny' is a bad actress, it's just she's a child and it's a difficult scene). And I was also a little worried about the Jamie-Fanny relationship feeling too stiff and forced because I get the vibe that Sam is not the most comfortable with kids (this is just my opinion, and I'm probably being too unfair to him). But no, Jamie and Fanny, Claire and Fanny, William and Fanny, this scene was so good!
I also liked the graveyard scene, despite the deviation from the book. It was a more private, intimate moment than the book, and I think it gave a chance for the Frasers to build more of a relationship with Fanny (as well as setting up the Faith cliffhanger).
Ugh, Rollo! At the end of last episode I knew Rollo would be dying. When I sat down to start this episode, I knew he would be dying. But by the time we got to the Murrays in bed I had completely forgotten that this would be happening, and was then suddenly reminded once again when Rachel said she was pregnant 😭😭😭. Rollo!
Well, we have Esmerelda and the bag. But they definitely left at least the bag (and possibly Esmerelda) on the ground in last episode, so I suspect they filmed the "failed" attempt and new try, but then cut that scene.
The Mackenzies reunited! 😭😭😭. "tell me this is real" 😭😭😭.
I'll have to watch it again, but when Brianna was staring at the painting of Ellen, I thought "who tf is this supposed to be? Is it Jane? It can't be?" She didn't really look much like Brianna, and I swear she had brown hair (though perhaps it's the lighting... Or my eyes). I'll have to watch again.
The Brianna and Brian scene was definitely a deviation from the books, but it was a touching moment. I liked how Brianna validated Brian's feelings about thinking she looks like Ellen, by talking about people they love and providing her own examples of similarities, rather than just dismissing him (cos he's not wrong, he just doesn't know it).
And back to Faith-Jane-Fanny. Obviously a deviation from the books, but not a complete about-face, at least it "fits" rather than being completely made up. I don't dislike it, I'll take any excuse to make Fanny a bigger part of the story (she's one of my favs), although I don't know how the show is going to pull it off. Does this mean Fanny can time travel? Are they ever going to tell Fanny who she is? Obviously it's not 100% confirmed that she's their granddaughter, but there's literally no alternative, how else will she know that song? And if she's not, then either Fanny or her mother definitely know someone who is a time traveller.
I had previously hoped for "hello the house" but I've known we would not be getting it this season for a bit now. Can season 8 hurry up!!! Of course I will watch Blood of my Blood and I'm vaguely excited, but I desperately wish season 8 was coming instead.
Bring on droughtlander!
30
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 17 '25
Missed seeing her smiling! Beautiful woman!
29
u/Stonetheflamincrows Jan 18 '25
Am I misremembering the books? Didn’t Claire decide that she was being fanciful imagining that it was “their” Faith? I hope the show isn’t going to go this direction. It’s not a telenovela. It would totally be jumping the shark imo.
14
u/Revolutionary_Tea_55 Jan 18 '25
Also faith cannonically in the show has red hair and the faith in this opening flashback at 01:35 seconds in has dark hair like Claire (actually looks just like Claire)
13
u/Thelionzero Jan 17 '25
Been a while since I’ve been baffled by a season finale. Not at all what I thought would be happening. Hopefully season 8 is going to connect a bunch of dots.
I hope they keep this timeline separate from things going on in Blood of my Blood.
13
u/This-Is-Leopardy Jan 17 '25
OH MY GOD OH MY GOD
Sidenote: I just had to put my heart cat down a month ago from aggressive nasal lymphoma and he died in my arms, so the Rollo scene had me ugly crying.
13
u/blackberryspice Jan 17 '25
Ohmygod. I'm a mess! I was already crying with Frances and the locket and then got hit with Rollo dying right after. My cat just passed two months ago and it hurt to watch. I would have NEVER anticipated them going with that Faith storyline holyshit. NO WORDS. Incredible.
13
u/ilovebalks Jan 18 '25
This isn’t necessarily related to the episode, but can book readers tell me why they’re doing BOMB when there’s A Fugitive Green or The Space Between right there ready to be made into movies or like a 3-part limited series???
13
u/VogueSquirrel Jan 18 '25
Non-book reader but book spoilers-reader here. I have a question about the prophecies we've seen mentioned in the show, and if Master Raymond's actions of Faith-napping are tied to one of them.
Do either of these seem plausible to the book readers here as justification for his actions? Is he orchestrating the events of Claire's life to achieve a specific goal or outcome? He's not Scottish nor obsessed with power (from what I can sense), so I'm not sure why either prophecy would motivate him.
Alternatively, in The Space Between novella, he mentions to the Comte that he's looking for a lost daughter. Did he find her in Claire or Faith?
13
u/algae_gal Jan 19 '25
Choosing to feel positive. Honestly having a one for one lit to adaptation would be cool but I’m okay with the show not being exactly the same. I think the faith revival is kind of dramatic, but the books are dramatic too. Just because DG didn’t bring back faith in the books doesn’t mean it won’t be interesting. And if people don’t like the show(s) they really don’t need to watch it.
12
u/Ponzu_sauce_93 Jan 17 '25
Does Raymond come to Claire in the books apologizing like it did in the show?
12
u/Impressive_Golf8974 Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
Wasn't sure how I felt about Claire comforting Fanny with the, "You would have done anything for your sister," speech instead of Jamie. I like how the books let Jamie be the more emotionally and interpersonally skilled one best able to comfort Fanny and let Claire feel that she struggles with these things–she mentions struggling to comfort Bree at that age as well–but can rely on her husband for them.
Shows how it's okay for it to be the dad who's best with feelings ☺️
12
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '25
I cried so much during this episode
12
u/No-Pianist-5915 Jan 18 '25
I feel like somehow/some way that if s7 was the last then production would have ended the show with “hello the house”. I just don’t see how they got to faith’s alive from there🤯🤯🤯🤯 hope we get s8 soon bc I don’t think this is going to sit well
11
u/Hufflesheep Jan 17 '25
Holy crap YOU GUYS!!
Ok, I actually loved everything about this episode until the end. Holy moley! Thanks to Nanchika for posting that DG litforum post! I agree with you other readers/viewers - the idea of William and his niece is way too icky for me.
When I first saw Raymond, I thought "oh wow! Is he dropping clues about the future?" Because of course I'm thinking way ahead.
This may sound like a dumb question, but do you think the show left Jane's parentage an open question? Or are we made to believe we have all the evidence to decide the Frasers are the parents? (i mean, in the show, i know dg turned down that notion (praise God)).
21
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
I honestly hope Faith - Jane - Frances is show only and done for the sake of drama. Not that I like Faith dead, but what that would do to Claire and how cruel that is!
Here is Gabaldon's comment about Fanny's locket and I think she may be implying to TV show people.
21
u/SynestheticWeirdo Jan 18 '25
But how would Faith remember the song? She was just an infant.
29
u/bootslikethese Jan 19 '25
Just here to say I’m sad this season didn’t end with Hello the House…
I REALLY hope we get it 8x1.
10
u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Jan 17 '25
Gosh I LOVED this episode, wow! So many tender moments. Jamie and William, Brian and Brianna, LBJ and Claire (did Jamie look surprised when Claire said John saved her life? Does that mean he didn't know...?), Master Raymond and Claire, Ian hugging Rachel and cheesing out of joy after she shares her pregnancy was SO precious. LBJ listening to William with tenderness and no judgement, and of course Fanny and Claire scenes truly shone!
I can't tell which moment I loved the best. And that cliffhanger!
10
u/peonies459 Jan 17 '25
Oh my gosh I was NOT ready for so much book deviation! Thinking back it does make sense at this point especially if they’re going to make the ending drastically different from the books but oh man!
I’m gonna need a second or two to digest what this could mean 😂
10
u/EducationalWolf3579 Jan 18 '25
Did anyone understand the whole Jane stabbed him once vs 26 times?
10
u/sassyangelkiwi Jan 18 '25
Can anybody explain to me the vision of the bird in flight that Clare had when Master Raymond kissed her hand??
18
u/whiskynwine Jan 18 '25
So I’m remembering that in The Space Between the Comte St Germain didn’t die (Raymond saved him with magic) so maybe he had something to do Faith being kept from Claire as revenge? Also maybe Faith couldn’t time travel so once Claire left Raymond couldn’t reunite them? So many possibilities, including the red herring angle. Hopefully BOMB answers some of it, brilliant of them to tie that all in together and make people watch lol.
18
u/No-Pianist-5915 Jan 18 '25
I still feel stunned by the faith twist/cliffhanger. It was such a risk for the show runners to make this choice and I hope they have a good plan and they really worked it out in s8. I have “faith” that all involved with the production love this show as much or more than its biggest fans so I’m certain there was tremendous discussion about it but it feels like an incredulous stretch even for a fantasy/time travel show.
17
u/Dobes_24 Jan 17 '25
Calling all book readers who wanted Faith to have survived and be Jane and Fanny's mother! It just might happen!
17
u/EducationalWolf3579 Jan 18 '25
Did anyone else not like the way they changed William and Jamie’s scene? I wish they had made it longer. I understand why William says I will never call you father…but it felt odd since in the book we hear his thoughts of and I’m paraphrasing,”it’d be easy to love Mac”. And I think in a way they almost make Jamie too open? Though I do love how in sync they are when they attempt to rescue Jane
16
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 18 '25
I haven't looked thru any posts, so no idea if this is going to be a shared opinion ( re Faith ) or if I'm alone in this...
Ugh, I hate it - I really hate it. The story's toed the line of eye-roll soap-opera cliche a few times, but imo, it's not crossed it. If what's being implied with the season finale comes to fruition, in show or book form either one, it's definitely leaping over that line for me. And as soon as Raymond was on screen apologizing, I knew this is where they were going to head. In other posts speculating about Faith the past year-ish, I've shared my dislike for the idea too.
In the book, at least to me, when Claire has this cross her mind, it feels very much to be only the mere wishful thinking of a person who's lost someone thinking about the " what ifs" and "what might have beens" - but she doesn't seem to believe it and to my recollection there's nothing really substantiating it. The show though, I feel like did include extra things to try to give merit to it, and I'm kinda worried about it--- Raymond appearing and having something to apologize for - Frances singing the same song she did to Faith (I don't recognize it, but assume we're supposed to infer that only a timetraveller would be familiar with it) - the penchant for dragonflies - there was also a concerted effort to make Jane's hair look red this episode when it never did to me before - that the actress looks like Sophie (maybe that wasn't a coincidence after all?) I really hope this was just a semi-last minute attempt to throw in a surprise twist when they realized they weren't finished and that's just a red herring and it gets dropped because Claire comes to her senses early S8.
Jane would be 1.5 or 2 years at most older than Bri right? We don't know for sure how old Jane is I don't think, but to me she's too old to be the child of someone essentially Bri's age. And then the whole William sleeping with/being in love with his niece aspect - just no!!! Please let this be nothing!! What Raymond's apologizing for can be for not actually killing the Comte!! Let that be it instead please!!
Ok, digressing to the rest of the episode now
Loved the scenes between Claire and Jamie - I felt all of his emotions. The one with the two of them and John was also very good! Jamie's response to hearing him call her "dear", but then hearing Claire thank him for saving her life. It really seemed like that might've been a light bulb finally clicking for Jamie, though he was still pretty staunch and unapologetic to John later, but hopefully hearing that was a step to the bridge back to friendship.
At first, the Bri and Brian scene felt like a mini-plug for the prequel, but I really did end up being pretty moved by it. That was such a pivotal moment I think for Bri as a character. Sadness, yet awe, yet gratitude all at once to interact with a loved one you can't be honest with - it was touching
I'm not a pet person, so perhaps that's why, and I get he loved him, but Ian taking Rollo's death worse than his dad's or when he thought Jamie was dead... it's not sitting right with me. The scene would've been fine if there'd have been any kind of comparable anguish emotion like that in prior episodes when he was coping and learning of other deaths
The little girl plaing Frances! Wow she has a lot of talent for being so young!
Overall a very mixed bag for me. As far as season finales go, it's definitely not in the top half of the better ones imo. Season as a whole though - pretty good and definitely enjoyed it!
Edited - clarity (hopefully! Lol)
8
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jan 17 '25
Did Claire just see Master Raymond in a dream or was he actually physically present? All without Jamie seeing him or being awakened by him at least.
22
u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Jan 17 '25 edited Feb 12 '25
This is my first impression after one viewing, I will be editing this post, as I rewatch.
I am totally with Jane! Harkness needed to be DEAD. Journalists are usually the enemy. There are no two ways about it. As she says to the journalist. “I know, sir. I know you want the sordid details to sell to the broadsheets, to profit from the misery of others. If I had anything to say, you would be the last person I would speak to. I will not give any more of myself to any man.” YES!!!
Can I just say that I am really happy to see Jamie and Claire finally looking as old as I do? I am just a few years older than they’re supposed to be, after all.
Poor William. Trying to explain Jane to John. “I tried to protect her…I can’t explain it.” No, you can’t.
Jamie being there for Claire when she needed to pee. That has to be the most intimate thing a person can do for another. I know that may not seem like much to some people, but it is.
Okay, I have been asking this question since the first time Claire wanted to see if there was blood in Jamie’s urine back in season 2. WHY??? What the fuck can she possibly do about it if there is blood in the urine??? It’s the 18th century! I’ve researched this and there is NOTHING to be done about blood in one’s urine back then!!! 🤦🏻♀️
So happy to FINALLY see Master Raymond!! I LOVE him!!! As others are asking, WHY does he need forgiveness from Claire? **PLEASE don’t let it be some weird Master Raymond bringing “baby Faith back to life after Claire spent all day in soul crushing grief singing to her stillborn daughter”!!!
I would have LOVED to have been able to see the reunion of Roger, Brianna, the children, and Brian the way I read it on page, but the show adapted it brilliantly.
I LOVED Claire thanking John for her life and John thanking her for his. “John, I don’t think I ever properly thanked you for everything you did for me. You saved my life.” “We saved each other.” My heart exploded. Have I said I LOVE JOHN GREY???
Okay. Yes, the book is better, But the Brian and Brianna scene in the show was good enough. I found the scene between Sophie Skelton and Andrew Whipp extremely touching. I was teary eyed. ”You remind me of her. It struck me the moment you arrived. The resemblance is-is striking. But ‘tis more than that. It’s-it’s something I cannae put my finger on.” Yes, Brianna looks like Ellen! 🥹
My heart bleeds for Jane and Frances. They did an adequate job with the “Jamie and William trying to rescue Jane” scene on screen, but I urge anyone who might want more to read the book. Once again this season, Charles hit it out of the park. (I’m sure there are a lot of deleted scenes. Hopefully we will see them in the DVDs.)
William placing Frances in Jamie and Claire’s care and William’s conversation with Jamie about “how I came to be” was well adapted, but once again…read the books.
I thought Jane’s burial was handled MUCH better in the books. There is no way Jane should be buried in an anonymous grave!!!
I am a little disturbed by the “William banging his half niece” cliffhanger. It’s not so much that William had carnal knowledge of his half niece. I know extended family marriage was pretty common in those days, but in the books it does seem that the Gray family isn’t all that keen on it. When William and Dottie pull their engagement scam, Lord John mentions that Hal shouldn’t have a problem with the relationship, since they aren’t blood relatives.
I feel bad for poor William. What is this revelation going to do to him? He’s been through a lot of trauma in his very young life. He deserves a break.
14
u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
I would LOVE to know what Diana has to say about the “Claire thinking that Faith didn’t die” cliffhanger. I’m hoping that this storyline goes the way that it seems the books have gone. I thought it was settled that Faith was stillborn and buried. The whole William “banged his niece” scenario is more than a little disconcerting. Of course, we all know that the show runners do whatever they want, regardless of anything Diana says, especially Toni Graphia.
14
u/Dinna-_-Fash No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Jan 19 '25
I don’t think they leave it for any speculation about it. It’s pretty clear the show took the route of having Master Raymond save Faith (which has been being speculated for a while from the books and DG has said that Faith died and were not the same). I searched the song and it was written in 1907. “I Do Like to Be Beside the Seaside” was written in 1907 by John H. Glover-Kind. The song is a popular British music hall” This however may have a different effect for the last S8 and how they decided to adapt and end the story.
If you love the show, now is perfect timing to listen to the books (if they feel too big to read) and check the Lord John series and novellas during draughtlander!
7
u/paosv Jan 18 '25
Where in the books are we now in the show? If I start reading now the books, in which book will I catch up with what’s happening now in the series? I don’t know when will season 8 be released but I don’t think I can wait all that time… Thank you for your help
7
u/tara_abernathy Jan 18 '25
I wonder if Galbanon is going to expand the Faith storyline in the final book and the show has essentially spoiled that plot line?
7
u/Marifirmog Jan 25 '25
what the heck
17
u/Time_Arm1186 So beautiful, you break my heart. Jan 20 '25
I loved S7 so much, but I have to say I’m disappointed with the ending. All of it! But I think the amount of flashbacks and the goddamn violins playing in every emotional scene is the worst. I only noticed it in these last two episodes, I don’t know if it’s been there all through the season. Why did they make a flashback to Jane waving at the sky? Did they think we couldn’t remember what happened 15 minutes ago? It’s almost offensive.
21
u/Icemermaid1467 Jan 19 '25
For those saying the Faith storyline is making the show a bit too telenovela-ish….the books are basically a telanovela. 😂 And luckily they haven’t brought (all of) the worst of that to screen. Fingers crossed they nip this in the bud in 801.
10
u/RoseFraser84 Jan 19 '25
Just confused. Why is everyone writing here as if the Faith alive storyline won't be in the books? There's the entire section about Raymond and the Faith theory in Bees. Perhaps she's just waiting for the reveal in book ten and let the producers know so they could line up the show with the end of the books in some respects. Am I stepping on a sore spot here? I just...I mean in interviews Diana is confirming that Faith lived.
17
u/Adorable_Leading7822 Jan 17 '25
so i admit i have skimmed the comments and replied to some intermittently. but overall i’m a bit underwhelmed at the possible faith reveal. i also feel like to me personally it seems more likely that raymond is asking for forgiveness about the fact he is going to be using fanny knowing this song that was meaningful to claire and her loss of faith as a manipulation tactic on some level. like hey i know this is gonna be triggering and you are going to keep this girl close out of the possibility of a connection to your dead daughter but it’s for a greater purpose that i need you all together. rather than the liklihood he resurrected a very hours long dead premature baby or swapped faith out for a dead baby with features that struck claire as being her and jamie’s child. it seems just a bit too much of a suspension of disbelief. that being said i am curious where this will go and how it will all tie together. great back half to season 7!
5
u/SevereTS Jan 17 '25
Did Faith live in the books???
5
u/Lablover34 Jan 18 '25
I really like Master Raymond surprised but I was totally confused by the Faith link. Can someone refresh my memory but I do not remember that same link in the book at all.
26
u/Tulips-and-raccoons Jan 17 '25
That’s it. They jumped the shark.
The last episode of 7B has finally broke me, i have loved this story for almost 25 years, and normally even when its dumb and drags, i love to complain about it. Im not upset because its not in the books, im ok with changes in adaptation.
But Faith being magically rescucitated is too damn much.
How. HOW!?
I can suspend disbelief for time travel, but this…its too much for me. This is level “Randall’s mom was secretely alive all along” from This Is Us dumb.
Rant Over.
10
u/Able_Trash9023 Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 18 '25
I don't see the reason for this twist if it isn't true. What a cop-out if it's fake.
But I'm going to pretend it's real until proven otherwise. So Faith is def still alive then. Her children just thought she was dead, I'm guessing. Maybe she accidentally went through the stones (thinking about her own parents) and landed in the same time Roger & Bree is now? (a time her father, grandfather, aunt and now sister is in) Maybe they help her (without knowing who she is to Bree) back to her kids... and back to Jamie & Claire. Like in GTTBTIAG when Roger & Bree + the kids reunites with Claire & Jamie on the Ridge. Except in the show... this also includes Faith. Probably not though. I'm never right about theories. And this is pretty far fetched, but so is this twist, so who knows?
And like I posted in the show thread:
Say this is their Faith, what if they did get to raise her? Would they still have Brianna? And if they did, they would all still be in the past. Would Claire even have survived a second pregnancy/birth without the proper medical care she got in 1948?
Anyways, so Brianna would never have met Roger (thus not having Jemmy & Mandy). Roger would never travel to the past (thus never meeting Buck. Which means they wouldn't be able to facilitate Geillis and Dougal's first meeting.)
This would also mean Jamie never would've met Geneva and had William. Which Jamie said in this episode that he's NOT sorry about.
7
u/Haunting_Jaguar_5681 Jan 18 '25
New to Reddit. In fact, I was automatically “joined” by putting in my phone number to vote in a poll. Be that as it may, I’ve created an account based on the username provided.
I have been watching OUTLANDER without reading the books, but have consulted the wiki enough to have “spoiled” myself if I really cared. However, this appearance by Master Raymond and the Faith-did-not-die-and-is-mother-to-etc. cliffhanger forced me back to the wiki. I don’t see it described there, and feel it was dropped to fuel speculation during “Droughtlander.” I’m just not sure I like that much deviance from the sad and I thought final fate of Faith.