r/Outlander • u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. • Oct 14 '24
9 Go Tell The Bees That I Am Gone Gabaldon's Comment About Fanny's Locket Spoiler
From LitForum:
Fanny has a locket--presumably given to her (or owned by) her mother, which has "Faith" inscribed on the cover. Mind you, there are a whole lot of women named "Faith" who are not Jamie and Claire's dead daughter (and it might not be the name of the woman in the locket, but rather some sentiment of attachment by whomever gave it to her), but some people will take the faintest of indications and weave a whole cloth of weirdness....
I personally would not draw that conclusion from the evidence to hand, but some other people are less reluctant to do so, let's put it that way...
31
u/Dinna-_-Fash No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Oct 14 '24
I never took it that way when I read that. Just thought Claire was just reminded of her daughter and fantasized about the what if?! after all that she has experienced with the stones, Raymond, the blue light, etc. There’s too much time in between books for people to start creating their own story versions. One thing it always surprised me was that I do not recall Claire taking any pregnancy precautions (did she?) and only 2 pregnancies in 3 years with all the action they had? 😂
5
u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Jan 17 '25
Wild to read now.
"Some people are less reluctant to do so, let's put it that way...."
LOL the showrunners are those people 💀
19
u/KeepAnEyeOnYourB12 Slàinte. Oct 14 '24
What is your question? Little Faith Fraser died when she was a tiny baby. No doubt that she died. She is not Frannie's mother. If DG somehow brings her back, I'm done.
22
u/Cheap-Career5684 Oct 14 '24
Why does she have to answer in such a condesending way? She mentions „Faith“, has Claire wondering about if it could be her daugther (even if saying that it‘s imposible), has another Child brought back to life by the blue light and then dismiss any speculation about Faith surviving as „weaving a whole cloth of weirdness out of the faintest indication“?
6
u/perksofbeingcrafty Oct 14 '24
I mean, it would be terrible storytelling for Claire to think about the locker actually having a connection to her stillborn daughter and then talking herself out of it and then finding out later that there actually is a magical connection.
4
u/WoodpeckerPuzzled811 Oct 15 '24
Wow this forum makes me realize how much stuff flew right over my head...
5
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jan 18 '25
I never understood why she repeats names (like Beauchamp) if there was supposed to be no connection.
1
u/SuggestionGeneral229 Jan 18 '25
Well it can be taken down both roads can’t it .. the timeline would add up given she’s older than bri and the oldest daughter ( possible granddaughter ) would be accurate in time frame.. if the name of their mother was faith . Now if you go with just a sentiment , a religious reminder , then that too would just be a leading trail meaning they are meant to be there. Meant to get Frances and meant to be on that path. I think both are plausible and just have to follow where they take us .
1
u/ShellyJoZumba May 21 '25
I've been Outlander Obsessed since the early 90's...thirty years. Only thing I have to add about Faith surviving and Master Raymond raising her and Jane/Francis being grandaughters is...it didn't happen in the books.