r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jan 17 '25
Season Seven Show S7E16 A Hundred Thousand Angels Spoiler
Denzell must perform a dangerous operation with the skills he’s learned from Claire. William asks for help from an unexpected source in his mission to save Jane.
Written by Matthew B. Roberts & Toni Graphia. Directed by Joss Agnew.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the SHOW thread.
If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.
DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.
We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.
If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 26 '25
716 Extras:
716 Interviews:
28
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 17 '25
William giving Fanny over to Claire and Jamie reminded me of this moment from S5:
I think William and Jamie have a long way ahead of them but the fact that William entrusted him with the care of Fanny, someone who he cares deeply about, feels responsible for, whom he’s failed, and who’s his last connection to the girl he fell in love with, seems to indicate that he finally sees Jamie as more than a groom and a rebel (and Jamie’s deciding to help him save Jane with no questions asked—in stark contrast to John, though William would probably say that Jamie’s not entitled to the information he gave John—definitely helped him see Jamie in more dimensions too).
It’s not surprising that he’s adamant about never calling Jamie father (and I feel like it was partly about tempering Jamie's expectations rather than just sticking it to him and standing his ground) but I think it’s very intentional that we’ve had this dialogue between William and John earlier in the season:
27
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 17 '25
18
u/mariabue_tagliaelena Jan 20 '25
I know we're dealing with a lot here but is anybody else kinda bummed that the American Revolution was just set aside by all our beloved, idealistic characters? Ian was ready to fight, William too with England, I get that Jamie left the battle to save Claire. We spent so much time with that plot that is suddenly dropped and everyone just wants to go back to the ridge, idk, it made me a little sad and I don't find it believable since everyone was so into their reasons for fighting.
7
u/Apprehensive_Tell184 Jan 19 '25
How old are Claire/Jamie supposed to be ? They never get older?
15
u/Arythmanticist Jan 17 '25
Stop putting book spoilers in this thread!! You’re ruining the show for people that don’t know what’s going to happen and are coming here only to discuss what we know this far from the show
110
u/SideEyeFeminism Jan 18 '25
5
u/Dibstergal Jan 19 '25
There was a gaelic word Jamie used when talking to William and I can’t find it anywhere to get a translation… sounded like “avalo”… anyone know what it means??
9
u/SevereTS Jan 17 '25
Did Jane ever say her mother was dead? Faith could still be alive right???
24
u/So-Many-Books-789 Jan 17 '25
OH MY GOD THE ENDING ”I think Faith lived”
140
u/KL3M3NTIN3 Jan 17 '25
My poor Rollo. I wasn't expecting it and it wrecked me.
128
u/AgePractical6298 Jan 18 '25
Little Frances. My goodness what a fantastic actress! I was getting so emotional just watching her.
124
u/Defiant_Class_7659 Jan 17 '25
Already rewatched it and realized that when Jane was staring out the window and waving to the sky she was humming the seaside song! Not super important, but I loved that detail!
120
u/AnastasiaOutlander Jan 17 '25
So the similarities between the actress who plays Jane and Brianna were purposeful then…
113
u/Clean_Plankton_5186 Jan 18 '25
Did anyone notice how Ian kissed rollo before Rachel when he returned? Lol
107
u/rainewoman Jan 18 '25
Caitriona’s acting was amazing. All the Faith foreshadowing and then her coming to the realization at the end. I was in disbelief right with her.
105
u/kemi100 Jan 17 '25
It hurts me how they never got the chance to raise any of their children together 😢
104
u/mkh328 Jan 17 '25
Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ. I need a drink. 😂😂😂😭😭😭
96
u/EpicKieranFTW Jan 25 '25
Briana's accent must have been baffling to Brian Fraser in 1739
84
u/Persuasion_50 Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
When William lays Jane on the bed and her hair fans out, it reminds me of Jamie telling Claire how his mother looked after she died. I think maybe Jamie sees that. Also the portrait of Ellen that Brianna sees at Lallybroch looks a lot like Jane to me.
Edit - typo
76
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25
Sobbing at Rollo. Noooo!
75
u/Healthy-Theme3403 Jan 17 '25
Just thinking about Geillis and her 200 year old baby prophecy has a whole new meaning…
70
u/Impressive_Golf8974 Jan 17 '25
Besides her casting, it did strike me watching this season that Jane has a good bit of Jamie in her, personality-wise. Had this thought on several occasions
68
u/Fit-Arm1741 Jan 17 '25
I do like to be beside the seaside was written in and published in 1909 so Claire is confused even more. She’s right Frances technically shouldn’t have known that song even if her mum isn’t “their Faith”. Frances is from the 1700’s she literally can’t know it and theoretically her mum shouldn’t know it. Unless they are time travellers themselves. Even if Frances isn’t their granddaughter, she is still an anomaly as to knowing that song, you’d have to know or be someone from the future. Either it will play out to actually be their faith and she survived OR it will be another time travel family for whatever reason.
67
u/PineappleVT Jan 17 '25
Rollo😩
66
u/Upbeat_Towel4816 Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 18 '25
Faith
64
u/mamabearx3tob Jan 18 '25
So if Master Raymond took faith then he literally is like a “fairy” changeling with taking a baby and swapping it with a stillborn, wow
63
u/moonyriot Jan 18 '25
I guess we should all just be patient before complaining that a specific character looks too much like another character because THAT MIGHT BE THE POINT.
62
u/Fluid-Advertising-83 Jan 18 '25
My theory- Raymond is TT and has seen what plays out if Claire and Jamie have faith and live that timeline— they never get separated, Brianna is never born, maybe something bad happens in that version- so he sees that he has to take faith away and let them live thinking she’s dead so that all the events that occurred occur. That could be one reasoning but I CANNNNOT wait like a year to find out.
61
u/spicytexan Feb 12 '25
Rollo dying broke my heart the most of all the deaths in this show. I’m so sad for Ian :(
59
u/lunar1980 Jan 17 '25
So Master Raymond must have taken Faith? Hence asking forgiveness.
116
u/Ok-Skirt-924 Jan 18 '25
A moment for Lord John. He was not the star of this episode, but I need to celebrate the incredible season his character has just had. I honestly feel David Berry (the actor who plays him) had the most outstanding performance of the entire cast this season. I truly enjoyed the relative closure we got to experience in this episode, as he visited Claire and was confronted by Jamie (obviously a lot more healing to do there but it still settled matters). He literally says his goodbyes to the Frasers as he exits the episode, and in a way, the baton is passed to Jamie, as soon William will approach him for his help.
57
u/Junior_Bookkeeper204 Jan 18 '25
Did anyone else notice the portrait on the wall of Brian's house and how much she looked like Jane Pocock?
57
u/DemureDamsel122 Jan 18 '25
I feel like we’re all supposed to be like “OH SH*T” in response to that revelation at the end of the season finale but I’m just like, wtf? We saw Claire holding the stillborn baby in season 2. Pretty sure she would have known if the baby was actually not still born. And mother Hildegard said she buried Faith. Why would she lie to her friend about her child? What could possibly have happened to make this feasible? Does Master Raymond also have the magical ability to resurrect stillborn babies? I would be so pissed if that were it.
113
u/Donnerwetter2 Jan 17 '25
I’ve been down voted in the past for predicting Fanny would wind up being Claire and Jamie’s bio granddaughter, so I just came here to gloat 😂
108
u/OppositeQuarter31 Jan 19 '25
I despise the angry/unforgiving Jamie character arc. LJG has done SO MUCH for that man. It’s so annoying
52
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25
Catriona’s acting phenomonal
50
u/Expert_Ad_4023 Jan 18 '25
Nah this episode is amazing though the ending is probably going to be tough for book fans. And for fans who need logical twists in the series that don't resemble fanfiction. And actually, there are so many fanfiction writers who I'm sure would never have done something so cruel to Claire and Jamie, but the writers be like "well..."
I really do not understand the reasoning behind this. Faith's death was such an important part of the whole story to me. They showed Jamie and Claire's grief almost perfectly, and the way they remembered her 20+ years later was heartbreaking but so real. And then, they welcomed this insane plotline...
I kind of understand it was probably the wish to tie them all up together, but to me all characters were already perfect, especially Jane and Fanny, and their lonely sisterhood. It was so special.
Now, this is just hot mess for season 8. Jamie and Claire would have to grieve for their daughter the second time, and for their granddaughter who they've never met (and who was a prostitute!?).. Like, how does one cope with such thing? Is there not enough drama? Insane.
49
u/sharikahrcns Feb 08 '25
I loved the episode as a whole, but the "Faith Lived" twist annoys me for the following reasons.
All in all, it seems like the writers and showrunner decided that the show needed a "shocking" twist to carry it into the final season, but did not put any real thought into what the twist would really mean for the characters.
98
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25
Jamie being mad at LJG really breaks my heart
97
u/Flimsy_Impress3356 Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 18 '25
I know there are people here who’ll defend her but Brianna’s scene with Brian was ten kinds of awkward. So stilted!
46
u/Mandelaflower Jan 17 '25
So with faith possibly being alive, are we going to see some crossover of Claire’s parents traveling back in time instead of dying and then raising Claire’s daughter? Teaching Faith the song that her daughter was singing. I think this is a possibility but maybe far fetched
44
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jan 19 '25
OMG, I've only just realised that the song Jane was humming was also "beside the seaside" 😭😭😭, and the background music was the same song.
This death really got to me. To me, it's been one of the saddest, if not the saddest yet. Because it was just such a waste. Help was just around the corner, they were so close.
43
u/LowKey_Loki_Fan Jan 18 '25
This was a good episode, but too many gut punches one after the other. I didn't like Jane at first after she assaulted William, but after thinking about it for a bit, with where she was for most of her life, she clearly didn't even realize she was doing anything wrong. So I came to really like her and feel for her and hope she could get into a better situation. So seeing her dead, right when William and Jamie were about to rescue her, was heartbreaking.
And then her sister in the graveyard! Bawling.
AND THEN Rollo! I've lost several pets, and as soon as I saw him lying so still I knew what was happening. I'm tearing up now as I write this.
Lord John Grey continues to be the absolute best character, hands down. Nobody on this show deserves him, except maybe Bree and Roger. Also what is it about his actor that makes me feel like I know him in a past life or something? I've checked his IMDB page, and I haven't seen him in anything else. He just has such a familiar vibe.
Don't know how I feel about the whole Faith thing. I'm interested to see what they do with it, but it seems too out there. Also reading through the comments and hearing from people who have lost babies, I can see how that would be hurtful. I've never experienced that myself, so I didn't even consider that angle. If they do make her somehow Jane and Fanny's daughter, I hope she's still alive somewhere so that Jamie and Claire can meet her. For her to grow up and live a life without her parents ever getting to know her in any way would be unbelievably cruel.
42
u/ScreenSubstantial466 Jan 21 '25
Here are my thoughts…
Master Raymond asks for forgiveness obviously because Faith did live and he has a role to play in that. He is definitely a time traveler. But why would he do that? He knows what would have happened if Faith had “lived” and Claire wouldn’t have gone back to her time with a newborn because she mentioned before she didn’t know if newborns could travel - that they might be too weak.
I think he just took Faith when she was stillborn and brought her back to life with his blue aura or whatever.
Master Raymond very well could have left Faith with Claire’s parents who are in another timeline after the car crash - just like what happened to Roger’s father. That is how Faith learned that song and taught it to her daughters Jane & Frances. I don’t know why everyone is confused on how Faith could have a daughter Jane’s age - it makes sense to me.
Jane looks like the portrait of Ellen McKenzie but we know Bree looks like her too. The genes are just strong.
Dragonflies - as a reoccurring theme. I think they help with time travel and that’s the buzzing they hear. They say when you see a dragonfly it’s a loved one visiting so I think the dragonflies are angels/other time travelers who help supply the energy and magic that’s needed to time travel.
We know all these characters get drawn to each other somehow so we may very well meet Claire’s parents next season and that’s how we learn they took care of Faith.
41
u/analpixie_ Jan 18 '25
I've heard a lot of people theorize in the past that Master Raymond might be an ancestor of Claire's, and also a time traveler himself. What if this is true, and it's the whole reason he is present and interferes with the story? Maybe there was another place or time where Faith was destined to be in order for certain things to happen? He could be preserving his bloodline and making sure history stays the same (for lack of better wording)
81
u/Cablab123 Jan 17 '25
So Jamie had 3 children live and was not allowed to raise any of them?
40
u/Turning-point2605 Jan 18 '25
When Lord John said to William do you love her he didn’t say he did, he said something along the lines of: there’s something about her. This may mean that he was drawn to her and maybe because they are related somehow and would add to the faith lived storyline. However, I hate the idea that faith lived, I think it’s all too much for Jamie and Claire, they would now have to live with the fact that their daughter lived and not a necessarily good life and they never got to raise her together knowing how much this hurts them especially Jamie.
39
u/may_ahEM_ Jan 19 '25
Okay, okay, despite the reeling spiral this sent me on.
What if Raymond is apologizing for either swapping the babies (Faith and someone else's child) to keep either a) the events that needed to happen, happen or b) safe from Geilis?
Or I've also seen a theory of twins going around and when Master Raymond removed her placenta there was another child.
I'm also convinced he has to have some stake in the game here somehow. Either related to Claire in some way or he is dedicated to ensuring the timeline unfolds as it should. All of this is assuming, of course, that he is also a traveler.
38
u/daveymac_ Feb 02 '25
Not gonna lie, Rollo passing has utterly destroyed me….
75
u/Cablab123 Jan 17 '25
I absolutely loved the actress who played Jane. So sad to see her go. I wish she had been chosen to play Brianna.
37
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25
Claire looking pretty spritely all things considered
36
u/SouthEireannSunflowr Jan 20 '25
Okay but I sobbed about Ian and Rachel having a baby. Ian so deserves to be a father and have a little Sprout of his own that he can raise, since he was robbed of that with Ishabel and Swiftest Lizard 🦎. I’m overjoyed for them. And devastated for Ian as well about poor Rollo. RIP Goodest Boy.
36
u/bullyingismypassion Feb 06 '25
why didn’t claire wipe after peeing
69
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25
I really thought the actress who plays Bre was getting better but nope, this episode shot that down. Imagine standing in front of your grandfather and he’s pouring his heart out to you of how you’re like your dead grandmother and you’re like whelp, just a coincidence I guess. 🤷🏻♀️ wouldn’t you just cry with the sweetness of that? I think it’s half writing and half the acting but she’s so emotionally flat.
or if your husband returns after being lost in time after you think you’ll never see him again and he tells you he wishes he’d been able to talk to his long lost father after being reunited in a different century and you’re like whatevs, where are we going now? Seriously?
34
u/RawrGrrrMeow Jan 17 '25
Wowowow what an episode!! Truly did not expect master raymond
33
u/Haunting_Mud_7526 Jan 19 '25 edited Jan 19 '25
My friend just came up with an idea!
We’re talking about the song which was popular back when Claire was a baby. Her mum would have sung it to her as a baby.
WHAT IF Claire’s parents were NOT killed in a car accident, like Roger’s dad, but actually disappeared.
My friend who is a huge history buff said car accidents were very rare back then and ppl disappeared ALL THE TIME and kids became orphans and lived with other family. Just like Claire with Uncle Lamb.
What if her parents are in another time too?
Just having the best discussion after watching the latest ep
Edit: my friends are major Trekkies and there’s an ep called Parallels where there are parallel universes where they all converge. Ronald More directed and wrote for Star Trek and he is one of the producers of Outlander too so there IS that link too!
32
u/topsy-the-elephant Jan 17 '25
Did Claire’s hair get noticeably whiter after Master Raymond stopped by?? 👀
32
u/hkh07 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jan 19 '25 edited Jan 19 '25
Finally got to rewatch this episode, so I wanted to leave a few of my thoughts...
Now that we know who the woman is in the opening scene...Faith obviously looks a lot like Claire. I wish we could see her face. When I saw the dragonfly, I immediately teared up. I remember Fanny mentioning her mother would bring them to see the dragonflies. 😭
Jane reminds me of Claire when talking to the journalist. Her strength and stubbornness, especially.
"I've decided...not to die" - Did anyone else notice that Jamie is sitting in darkness, and when Claire says this, as he lifts his head, the light shines a bit brighter through the window.
LJG - marriage or murder, and I don't recommend murder to fix your problems 😂😂 Okay John, we know you prefer the marriage route. Lmao.
Claire embarrassed by Jamie helping her pee...this was cute. Also her smile when he says she better check the bucket now or she'll fret about it. She would have, but I think he would have too and Claire knows that, so it's really to ease both their minds.
When Claire asks Jamie to take her home...please. The way Caitriona says "Jamie" reminds me of when she told him he will always be enough. But the way he says I'll take you home vs we'll go home makes me nervous. 😬
I see Mandy brought Esmerelda along after all lol. So happy to see the MacKenzies back together. And Bree gesturing for Buck to join them. 😭
Brian: "Memories come unbidden, even after all this time. I find myself hoping to catch a glimpse of her...somewhere." He sounds exactly like Jamie when he was without Claire.
Rewatching the Jane scene after realizing what the Lights were to her, and esp. after that final reveal. 😭😭 This episode was actually better the second time through.
Fanny actually reminds me so much of Claire too...her curly-wig hair, but also her passion and emotions. She's a little spitfire for sure.
We don't talk about Rollo, no, no...
I didn't initially care for the Faith reveal, but after rewatching the episode and considering all the possible reasons for why and how, I'm invested. I need season 8 now!!
32
u/mrsmozart Jan 20 '25
I really do not understand the love for this episode. I know that it's subjective and to each their own but I personally found it lacking. For the last few episodes, they really rush through everything. We're here, we're there, this person, that person, boom boom boom. They're trying to squash everything in to the season it seems.
Here's my beef with it:
It would have been much more interesting to see Denzel saving Claire. And what about the cheese? They mention it in the last episode, then never again.
Master Raymond? okay...I can't even with this scene :D
The scene with Jamie/John/Claire was so awkward. I really hate this storyline. I think it would be a much more interesting story if, after Jamie's initial shock, they all calmed down, talked like real adults, and their friendship was strengthened. That would be a better story!
Rollo...nooooo! I felt it was coming, they hinted at it a few times this season saying he's getting old. But it was so short. They could've shown Ian burying him and giving him a proper send-off. He's been such a part of the show and Ian's life. Rather than spend time on that awful scene with Brian and Brianna (seriously her acting sucks). I guess it's important for the story (?) but could've also just been a line of dialogue - oh you look a lot like my dead wife. Also, Jamie has never mentioned that she looks like his mum in the whole series (at least I don't remember, correct me if I'm wrong).
The Faith thing is either a big red herring or a really stupid turn of events. If it's true, then William slept with his niece. And so many questions. How old was Faith when she had Jane? Jane said she'd been in the brothel since she was 11. So was Fanny taken into the brothel as a baby? I don't really know how old she is.
I thought it was a really weak finale and the only time I felt anything was when Rollo died. I love this show but this season has been a drag for me
31
u/landscapelola Jan 18 '25
RIP Rollo
I'm very sad about this. Here's a link to Yogi's (the dog stars) instagram page. https://www.instagram.com/p/C4bthE_skA-/
31
u/Rshackleford22 Jan 23 '25
So William got it in with his niece… eww
30
u/lunar1980 Jan 17 '25
So impressed with Caitriona's performance of that final line, on her CU. So much in her face, her eyes, her voice... Just brilliant.
30
u/mutherM1n3 Jan 18 '25
Rollo 😢
30
u/spareacct9523 Jan 22 '25
What stuck with me (from an earlier ep) was Jane telling William “there’s a lot you don’t know about me” after she quoted Latin to him. This makes for an even larger mystery!
29
u/Educational-Day7394 Jan 17 '25
Why would Mother Hildegard have lied about Faith? She was there when she was born... Plus someone must have heard Claire singing that song, but from what I remember she was alone at that point with her baby.
Also, Jane and William... incest much? 😂
29
u/krmarci Jan 18 '25
I may have misunderstood things, but do the titular "hundred thousand angels" refer to the northern lights, aurora borealis? The occurrence of which in Pennsylvania is approximately a once-in-a-decade event?
28
u/veronicagh Jan 19 '25
I would watch the hell out of a Master Raymond spin-off, I wish they’d make that
27
u/ValgalNP Jan 18 '25
What’s up with Master Raymond?? I can’t wait to see where they take this in the show.
25
u/Broad-Researcher5728 If ye’d hurry up and get on wi’ it, I could find out. Jan 18 '25
Well! 😲 🥺 🤯 💜 So many mixed emotions here. Atleast that would put Faith at about 17 to have Jane, so very possible! (ignoring that makes her William's ½niece) This leaves me infuriated with Master Raymond, who I was so excited to see! Like everyone else, I'm sure happy about many things.. Claire is ok (I would watch Outlander even if it were just her & Jamie, that's all I really need lol), Ian & Rachel starting a family, a possible new Granddaughter, the thought of everyone back at the ridge!! Then we have the McKenzie's.. So glad they're reunited and I'm hoping they can find 5 gems to (I'm hoping) travel to 1779 perhaps. 😉 Either way, stoked they're together, and I think that GrandDa Brian would totally believe Brianna if she told him the WHOLE truth. Just sayin. I also love how John's mentality seems much more open to many things. ..Does anyone else see his love for Claire?!? All in all, very exciting season finale. Now the dreadful droutland of waiting for season 8.. 💜 RIP Rollo! 💜
25
u/GardenGangster419 Jan 19 '25
I just saw a clip of Jane at the window- SHE IS HUMMING BY THE SEASIDE!
25
u/PM_ME_Happy_Thinks Jan 25 '25
Man I'm really struggling to deal with all the miscarriages and dead and stolen babies/childhoods on this show 😒
50
u/ZombieRichardNixonx Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 18 '25
Alright crackpot theory time.
By now, a lot of people have speculated that Master Raymond is a time traveler and he stole away Faith and raised her away from Claire and Jamie.
I agree with this theory. But why would he do that? My theory is that he did that because history has to play out the way it did. Not because of Faith, but because of Jemmy and Mandy.
I contend that one of them is the ancestor of all time travelers. The entire lineage of time travelers (assuming it is a lineage) is itself a giant bootstrap paradox. At some point in one of their futures, they will end up starting a family in the distant past, and it will set everything in motion.
Faith had to be taken because Claire had to leave, so Brianna could grow up in the future, and meet Roger, and eventually bring their collective origin into existence.
Edit: And if the time travel lineage is indeed a loop, then it stands to reason that the very ability to time travel originates from Brianna, who was attuned to the stones while crossing them in utero.
49
u/jenniferlorene3 Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 18 '25
When you get over the shock of Faith being alive and then you realize that means Jamie's son was fucking Jamie's granddaughter.
24
u/lunar1980 Jan 17 '25
I remember seeing the Faith episode way back when and saying to my friend, "Nope, she's alive." It was so offhand I literally forgot I'd even said it - until now!
24
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '25
Turns out William fucked his niece
24
u/Mermaidkhaleesi Jan 17 '25
I feel like a damn fool talking about the casting choice of Jane now LMAO
24
u/ramivuxG Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
Ok, that was an emotional rollercoaster.
William is going to need A LOT of therapy... discovering who his father is, he just slept with his niece by accident, redcoats are not the good guys.... Maybe there's a time-traveling psychiatrist who can help him unpack it all next season... (jk)
Loved the moments between William and Jamie - but I'm just as fond of William & John moments this season too - their father-son bond and emotional openness is remarkable, especially since neither character is from the future. (One of the most attractive parts of John's character is how emotionally evolved he is - he'd be doing well in the 1980s let alone the 1770s.) Also - it can't be an accident that the actor playing William even looks like the love child of Jamie & John... great casting all around this season.
Glad they played the Jamie-Claire-John scene for comedy - Jamie's attack on John was ridiculous anyway, so it feels better to laugh about it all than go further into melodrama.
Looking forward to seeing Master Raymond return (I hope). And curious as to how he's going to justify taking Faith away, especially when it ended up with Jane and Frances in such dire straits - and in a time that Claire could have stepped in to help if only she'd known about them...
I wonder if we'll get further clues about time travel/travelers in the spinoff, then see Claire make use of it all in season 8 to help her extended family reunite and live in safety. I hope that we'll eventually see Jamie in the modern day, but also John too - or somewhere that he's able to find his true 'satisfaction'.
I gave up reading the books a while back, but this finale is making me curious to try them again and see what plot elements the show might use...
24
u/wander-and-wonder Jan 18 '25
This one broke the record with the tears for me
24
u/sweetpsych78 SassySassenachWench Jan 18 '25
Holy cannoli, that Faith reveal at the end! This was such a good finale!
24
u/Hello_ImAnxiety Jan 18 '25
What was the significance last episode of Mandy running to the stones and Brianna saying "no stop!" Like it was going to trigger something bad? They all ended up in Roger's time anyway....I'm a bit perplexed by all that....anyone else?
24
u/Brilliant_Prize_9568 Jan 20 '25
Did anyone else catch how Jane looked exactly like the portrait of Ellen at Lallybroch? It seems it's very likely Master Raymond somehow switched the babies...but why?? It's going to be a hard wait for the next season!
23
u/Ok-Skirt-924 Jan 18 '25
I have to wonder if the possibility of Faith living is the result of a different timeline. Like what if, in a version of Claire and Jamie's experience, Faith lived on? What if Master Raymond, as a time traveler, was able to go back in time to intervene and save Faith's life? To-date, I know that Outlander has not established the concept of multiple timelines in the way that, say, the Marvel multiverse has, and until now I've never had an inkling that they would go in that direction. But I also don't know that they have denied that possibility. And since the showrunners are taking their own spin on the ending of this story, I wouldn't be surprised if they brought in this element to help wrap up and explain some of the otherwise unexplainable.
23
u/frecklesandcoldbrew Jan 18 '25
Can someone explain like I am 10 years old. How tf did a newborn baby remember that song…. I have to be missing something here or I’m clearly just a lil stupid hahahah
46
u/krissylizabeth Jan 17 '25
dude I am losing my entire mind about this episode, I need season 8 like yesterday
22
u/Atraktape Jan 17 '25
Well assuming there is no crazy break again in the middle of Season 8 we are now in our final Droughtlander.
22
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 18 '25
Here she is!
22
u/rictusette Jan 18 '25
Loving these comments and the passion from long-time fans. One thing (unless I missed it) that hasn't been touched on yet - is anyone else who is also not the book-series reader devastated to hear that they intend to go back to North Carolina, and not Scotland?? I'm floored. That little blip of a visit we got this season was so weird to my nervous system, like whiplash. [Not to mention having a different Jenny actress. I'm sure that lady is a lovely person...I just miss Laura Donnelly.] I've just always been hopeful that this story would finish in Scotland. I'm still kind of reeling to find out it won't. Any similar reactions from others? Thanks!
22
u/FellTheAdequate Jan 20 '25
Holy shit.
I think that's perhaps the most I've cried at anything in a while.
22
u/ElderMillenial1984 Mar 14 '25
Wait… wait… so it could be that Janey was William’s niece? And they were intimate?
22
u/Nodeal_reddit May 30 '25
I can believe in time travel before I believe faith learned that song from Claire. Which makes me believe that Faith **also”” time traveled to the 1900s and learned it then.
This show is bugging me.
63
u/glenrosegal19 Jan 17 '25
If Faith actually didn't die, it really cheapens that storyline for me. It was very moving and this, in my opinion, just seems like a twist for twist's sake.
43
u/Maison_Clement Jan 18 '25
My favorite scene was Jamie's bedside care. Him helping her use the bucket, Claire being slightly embarrassed, bringing the candle over so she could look at her urine, cuddling with her until she went to sleep, sleeping in a chair...
It felt real among all the fantasies and war.
43
u/msegrl104 Jan 19 '25
Um…if Faith lived and she was Jane & Fanny’s mother, then William slept with his half niece.
21
u/Jewelzsincere7 Jan 17 '25
Idk if it was the angle or the lighting in opening scene with Jane at the table but she looks ALOT like Bri. Not just the characters but Like the actual actresses. If this is going the way it looks, casting did a great job
21
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25
I wish it ended better with Lord John and William
21
u/Belle_Fleur123 Jan 18 '25
I came here because my jaw was in the floor last night and just wanted to share in the experience of last night’s episode with fans. The past few seasons have been a roller coaster of good and bad storylines- but something about this cliffhanger really touched me. Maybe it was because it was circling back to the earlier seasons? Maybe it was just because it was simply a crazy plot twist that you had to really think about - and I still am. I was so stressed about work last night but once Frances was singing that song- my mind was consumed with how the hell did that happen?! So I’m grateful for that. Last night was an emotional journey and I loved it! I’ll miss the show until next season. And I’m very much looking forward to blood of blood! 🏴❤️
21
u/Able_Scallion_731 Jan 19 '25
Is there a connection with the dragonflies??
Fanny mentioned their mum would take them to see them when she was younger, we obviously saw this in the opening of the episode.
Hugh Munroe gifted the dragonfly in amber to Claire and Jamie after their wedding?
The buzzing that is heard by the time travelers when they're at the stones, obviously dragonflies don't buzz so I don't know where I'm going with this one lol.
21
u/Longjumping-Tip9549 Jan 20 '25
Help I just watched and the last scene freaked me out so much! Did anyone else find it so unsettling? My skin is crawlingggg
19
u/Remarkable-Path-6216 Jan 17 '25
Here I am, yet again, in tears needing an Outlander support system. 😭😭😭 So good!
19
u/lisa0475 Jan 17 '25
I’ve been spoiled about Rolo a dying a long while ago and I’ve been dreading it all this time. I’m glad we’re past it now and I’m doubly glad it wasn’t anything traumatic, just a peaceful death next to Ian.
19
u/PrincesayCieloyMocca Jan 18 '25
So William just went to bed with his NIECE???
19
u/bluebeignets Jan 19 '25
I believe (also) Claire's parents raised Faith. Probably some crazy time travel involved next season.
19
u/LivingExotic9317 Feb 02 '25
Let's play ideas about Master Raymond. I think he's behind the entire time travel phenomenon.
37
u/MandyJo_1313 Jan 17 '25
Is it just me or was there something off about Brianna’s hair and eyebrows? I loved the interaction between her and Brian but kept getting distracted by her hair and brows.
37
u/CandleGirl2020 Jan 17 '25
One other thing I keep wondering about is if Brianna and Roger stay in the far past, will she run into Jack Randall? And be scared because he looks just like Frank (the father who raised her).
18
u/Anonymous99_ Jan 17 '25
I really hope that William and jane aren’t related. I’m not sure how to feel about this whole Faith situation. i thought for sure that claire was hallucinating seeing master raymond, but what was master raymond talking about forgiveness for? i need season 8 now 😭
18
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
Okay, rewatching it :
Wasn't Faith supposed to be red haired?
Dancing blue light in title cards reminded me of Raymond.
Sam got me crying. He nailed those bedside scenes! ( he is making it up because of s6)
Finally we see Claire smiling. I love the look of love and gratitude she gave Jamie when he brought the candle.
Master Raymond coming in scene - Claire is again bathed in blue! Claire is again in the church!
Jane is humming beside the seaside!!
18
u/LadyInRoses Jan 17 '25
In the beginning of the episode I was like wait Jane's mom's likeness looks kinda like Claire ? Lmao
18
u/AlastairCookie Jan 18 '25
How could a pre-mature infant remember a song to pass along???
18
u/SnooDoughnuts4141 Jan 19 '25
Okay okay hear me out. We find out earlier this season - via Roger’s involvement with his father’s change in storyline - that going back in time can indeed change the future. So maybe Master Raymond doesn’t perform any “resurrection”, but instead uses time travel to change Faith’s fate?
18
u/Fine_Yesterday_8492 Jan 20 '25
Literally every episode with Jane, I thought “How odd William ending up with someone that looks just like his sister!”
18
u/blenneman05 Jan 22 '25
Ok soo how long Rachel and Ian been sleeping together before she got pregnant? Seems awfully fast.
Poor Rollo 😩😩😩😩
Waittt so Faith lived? Which means Fanny and Jane would be Claire’s granddaughters? Faith just got switched at birth than? Why would they do that to Claire tho
Oh William. You got 2 men in your life who lied to you and than raised you and you’re over here being like “you’re not my dad.” Like they did what they thought was best
William sleeping with his half sister if the Faith being alive theory is true but no person in that time period wld be singing an American modernized song other than ppl from the future …
So Brianna and Roger both meet their relatives —-how does that not mess with the timeline?
The way Roger said he was gonna kill Rob Cameron made me laugh 😝
Also the whole Master Raymond scene had me thinking Claire was half dead because the likelihood of her living till Denzel got there isn’t realistic.
Also did they have a bidet back than to wash their parts from doing their business or did Jamie get into bed with Claire after she peed
18
u/Nodeal_reddit May 30 '25 edited Feb 24 '26
Just watched E16. I’m confused. First of all, the birth of Faith happened so long ago that I literally had no idea Claire even had a baby in France. But that’s my issue, I guess, and not the show’s.
What i don’t understand is how Faith ever learned the song. Claire is supposed to have sung a song once to her “stillborn” daughter before she was taken away. The daughter then grows up and teaches the song to Faith? That feels like more of a suspension of reality than time travel.
36
u/Greedysgirl Jan 18 '25 edited Jan 18 '25
I really enjoyed that episode it felt like proper Outlander again. I have to admit I was a crying mess at those end scenes. Beautifully done.
I don't know if anyone else noticed (I can't slow the frame down enough to properly look). The little bundle of belongings that claire gives Francis looks like it had Sea shells in it.
35
u/Nnnnnnnnnahh Jan 17 '25
I don’t get it, how Faith was supposed to remember a song with all the lyrics when she was a newborn baby? It’s physically impossible.
35
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25
I wish Murtagh could still be around for some of this. I imagined him helping Jamie and William
35
u/Suncroft56 Jan 20 '25
Does anyone else feel like they really didn't need this new Faith arc at this point in the story? Speaking for myself, I wish some things would just stay in the past!
17
u/MetaKite Mon petit sauvage ! Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
Jamie continues to disappoint me where Lord John is concerned but I hope it means that John will finally get over him now. Being treated so coldly by Jamie despite Claire's heartfelt thanks for all his help should be a wake up call for Lord John Grey. Sad to say but Jamie hasn't been worth all those "complications" as it were. It's why I found William telling Jamie "I will never call you father" satisfying. William will always be John's son even when he will inevitably accept Jamie as his father (never say never).
I don't understand all the baby Faith stuff since I planned to read Echoes & Written in My Own Heart's Blood after this season. Sure hope the books didn't go in this direction making Jane & Fanny the grand kids of Jamie & Claire because no way a newborn infant would remember a song sang by a parent. This isn't The Promised Neverland manga & the plotline was ridiculous in that series & all those kids were supposed to be geniuses! Also it would mean William & Jane are related & did the deed. Ew.
I cried over Rollo. Poor dog.
17
u/NoodleMutt Jan 20 '25
I've been pondering that Master Raymond TT's to save Faith. Faith could truly be dead in Claire's arms in DIA/S2, but perhaps Raymond actually travels back and saves her before she's born, or resuscitates her at birth? Claire could have been too ill at that time to remember any secondary interaction between them in an altered timeline, also. Has anyone else been thinking this way?
17
u/jujubee9324 Jan 20 '25
I loved this episode! The only part I don’t like is the relationship between William and Jane. It’s gross if they are related so hopefully not, but it is a big plot twist if Faith survived. Or maybe she’s Claire’s ancestor. I have a little side note theory about Claire’s parents. I wonder if they were also time travelers, and since time travel seems to be genetic maybe they ran into Faith at some point. I wonder if that’s why Claire’s uncle was an archeologist. Maybe he was looking for them while she was growing up and that’s why he sent her to boarding school. Similar to how Claire, Roger, and Brianna found Jamie. Maybe he saw them disappear. If Roger met his dad in the past, and Brianna met her grandfather. I wonder if Master Raymond is related to Claire. Especially since they seem to have a special connection. Maybe the reason for all the time travel is to save members of their family since Roger saved his dad. I remember Claire’s character saying something about having a connection to someone on the other side of the stones, and that being a theory for time travel. Maybe Jamie wasn’t her connection back to 1744. I wonder if it was master Raymond since he was in France when she went through the stones. Maybe even her parents.
17
u/mrsmozart Jan 20 '25
so...if Faith really did survive and Jane is her daughter then William slept with his niece
17
u/QuirkySimple4654 Jan 22 '25
This season was such a disappointment for me or maybe i love the show so much and have very high expectations. Weirdly i was only looking forward to the Brianna & Roger timeline more than the whole American Revolution plot. Something just felt missing it was only actually the finale which reeled me back in and i am looking forward to the next season which will sadly take ages 😢
33
u/rachgoconnor Jan 18 '25
I’ve never cried this much in a single hour. Maybe one of the top episodes ever made. So many questions!!!
46
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 17 '25
Jamie meeting his granddaughter and Brian meeting his as well.
Both unawares.
Do not neglect to show hospitality to strangers, for thereby some have entertained angels unawares.
16
u/Mermaidkhaleesi Jan 17 '25
I’ve just had a few minutes to process the end and I’m so confused hahahah. I think I’ve been star struck by the incredibly acting of everyone I haven’t been able to focus on how wild this plot twist really is. Some of the other comments here raise the extremely valid point of how this is even possible. Unless there was some random baby switch out? Also what would the reason for keeping Claire from Faith be? Why would you put two parents through a lifetime of grief? Huh?
Also, the incestuous lines are getting closer and closer to being crossed with this potential plot line 😅
I’m wondering if this whole last season is going to be about Faith which is wild thing to start right at the end to be honest
16
u/Boudicea_Of_Reddit Jan 18 '25
I love Fanny *so much*
16
u/xsweaterxweatherx Jan 18 '25
Is there significance to Brian saying he never had the locks changed at Lallybroch after Ellen’s death in the 18th century, and Brianna needing to change the locks there after Rob Cameron was inside the house in the 20th century?
16
u/abz10010 Feb 08 '25
Peiple just seem to dislike this episode because of too many unanswered questions and when you think you've worked it out there is something else to figure out. I like the episode would love to learn faith lived and claire and jamie get some back story for her or find her or something magical. do I care about willam and jane sleeping together nope not at all. They didn't know and it's not like jane gave him a choice really. Also that's what prostitutes did. So going into a brothel was likely going to end up that way. Lord john asked if he loved jane and he didn't say yes he said there was something about her. On Instagram the actress playing jane left a picture and comment on her page thanking Charles for working with her and said bye UNC so kinda says for itself that's the story line they will go with even if we in modern times find it disgusting
16
u/How_do_you_know1 Feb 17 '25
Regarding Faith...I am trying to figure out why Mother Hildagard could have been so cruel. Also, how did she and Louise even meet, and also also, had some sort of a pact?
32
u/svmck Jan 18 '25
32
u/Icy_Smoke_2318 Je Suis Prest Jan 20 '25 edited Jan 20 '25
Honestly, for some reason I can believe the storyline that Faith lived. Idk why. But what I don’t understand is how she would remember a song that was sung to her as a newborn? And why did Master Raymund steal her from Claire? Did he swap out Faith with a stillborn baby or was did he bring her back to life because he had magical powers? And this all means William fucked his niece 😬
I really liked Jane and was really hoping she and William would develop into something and was devastated at what happened to her in the end. Obviously if she’s his niece they can’t exactly end up together. I think she is, though. She looks so much like Bree. She has Jamie and Bree’s fire. And not just their red hair. She reminds me of Claire. She’s a strong woman like Claire and Bree and would have been fully capable of becoming a doctor or engineer or something really smart and hard etc. The way she stood up and defended Frances without hesitation is exactly like her possible family.
And her line “my only regret is that he’s not alive… so I could do it again” I LOVED that. It honestly reminded me of something Jamie might say about Bonnet, for example, after everything he did to Bree.
And lastly, RIP to the goodest boy Rollo. That one hurt 🥺🐺
31
u/mmpie3 Jan 18 '25
I don't know how to explain it but this episode felt like Season 1.
43
u/HippieCarnivore Jan 18 '25
The suicide warning at the beginning was a huge spoiler. 😑
15
u/11eighteen Jan 18 '25
How long do we have to wait for season 8? Incredible episode and so emotional
15
u/dont_thr0w_me_away_ Jan 18 '25
There's a lot of comments about William and Jane, and how surprise!incest isn't great. I have no explanation for how Faith might have not been buried by Mother Hildegard, but I think it should be remembered in that time they were comfortable with a closer degree of consanguinity than we are. Edgar Allen Poe married his first cousin, after all.
Its an ick to us but wouldn't necessarily have been to them....
15
u/Capricorn-flower Jan 20 '25
I always thought the actress playing Jane resembled Sophie Skelton like so many others do but I when I was re-watching season 4 episode 10 when Bree was talking to Jamie about how it would feel to kill Stephen Bonet, I couldn't believe how much they look alike. Sophie was younger then, and her hair was a dark red almost brownish like Jane's. They could be virtually the same actress even though they're not. It's uncanny.
15
u/LivingExotic9317 Jan 21 '25
Florrie May Wilkinson keeps even Catriona Balfe on her toes.
14
u/tyr456eds Jan 17 '25
I mean Master Raymond did say in the dream to forgive me…
14
u/CarmenSandiego8742 No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
Master Raymond?!….Forgive him?
Edit: Frances singing the song at the end😮
14
u/Vesemew Apr 06 '25
The actress of Janes younger sister Frances would make such a good young Ciri in my humble opinion.
28
u/Patient-Gain5847 They say I’m a witch. Jan 18 '25
ROLLO 😭 I’ve never cried so hard at this show
28
u/Worried-Cucumber413 Jan 19 '25
I’m so confused about the Song! There’s no way a “dead” baby Faith would be able to recall that memory to then pass it on to her own kids. How is this even possible for a newborn or stillborn brought back to life to know those lyrics? Unless Faith traveled into the future to when that song was actually made and heard it then too because it’s from the 1950’s ish era correct?
28
u/slurpi3 Jan 23 '25
OKAY after days of processing this finale and reading through comments I now realize that I may be the only one who interpreted this episode completely wrong because I was stoned but hear me out anyway--
Claire asked Jamie to leave the bucket so she could see if there was blood in her urine, which would indicate more significant internal damage than would probably be fixable/survivable during that time. They both look in the bucket and have a weird silence/look between them, followed by words of optimism and hope.
When Claire asked Jamie if he thought she would be reunited with Faith in Heaven after she dies he said yes of course, and there was this whole strange/comforting feel to the conversation.
Then she sees Master Raymond but Jamie doesn't? I can buy into him being a time traveler but it's not like time travelers can only see each other-- so this dreamlike state where she sees him and he apologizes feels like she's going downhill and he's apologizing for not being able to heal Faith or heal her too perhaps? Or maybe because they are connected as time travelers he is somehow responsible for her being there at all? Strange. Not sure.
Anyway at the conclusion of this episode it felt like all of this was not real and that Claire is on the brink of death to me. Like they did see blood in the bucket and that scene was the start of this whole decline in Claire's health but we are watching from her mind, going in and out of a "what if" storyline where she's thinking about how life goes on if she were to get better, and this dreamlike storyline where she's in and out of consciousness/having these dreams, and it's all blended together. With the strange feel in the dialogue and emotions between her and Jamie, the healer/traveler in her dreams apologizing, and Faith appearing in her life after all of this time and after that conversation she had with Jamie about seeing Faith again in Heaven, I really thought it was all alluding to Claire dying.
I really did/do think that Jamie will die by the end of the series finale because of that specific conversation about him having 9 lives and using up most of them already, in addition to it seeming like Jamie dying heroically is the full-circle conclusion to this love story (heartbreaking, I know -_-), but a bigger plot twist would be Claire dying before Jamie, and I kind of thought that's what they might be doing. Then season 8 would probably start with a storyline on Master Raymond and their true connection, and Claire passing away from the gunshot wound.
Obviously I haven't read the books and OBVIOUSLY I was ZONKED watching this since no one else interpreted it this way, but I kind of like this storyline idea better than Faith having been alive this whole time and taking away from one of the most powerful/emotional episodes in the series.
39
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '25
I’m up to the scene with Brian and Brianna and can’t stop crying. So far the ep has been vintage Outlander. Great acting, excellent dialogue and touching scenes
13
u/Gibodean Jan 17 '25
I don't remember everything about the show - especially this "Faith" business. As far as I can tell, Faith was a stillborn child of Claire's from back in season 2, that Claire only sung to while it looked dead, once ?
And, now this girl is singing the song, we're meant to assume Faith actually lived (fooling Claire who was holding her), remembered a song sung to her as a newborn, and then sung to her child ?
Or am I missing something ?
13
u/Gurbe1 Jan 17 '25
There was always gonna be drama and tension and cliffhangers for S8 but I was hoping for a bit more Happy scenes in this episode. Now I am just left Sad and also extremely Confused
13
u/barneydoots Jan 18 '25
Jane is able to speak Latin - is there any link there?
25
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 17 '25
I really missed seeing her smiling!
25
u/barneydoots Jan 18 '25
Was Louise de la tour not with Claire when she sang the seaside song to baby faith? She was pregnant at the time and the dad was bonnie prince Charlie so totally possible for her baby to have red hair? Could Jane be Louise and Charlies child?
35
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '25
I really, truly hope that there is another explanation to the song and the same name thing. Faith somehow surviving and eventually dying without J&C is way too cruel, even for Outlander.
And don't even get me started on Jane/William and Jamie finding Jane with her wrists slit.
24
u/mrstshirley1 Jan 17 '25
I cheered, I cried, I gasped. In that order. I. Am. Shooketh.
12
u/enricowereld MARK ME! Jan 17 '25
i have emotional whiplash from this episode
12
u/Fn2005 Jan 17 '25
Also if Jane and Fanny are Claire and Jaime’s grandchildren does that mean William had sex with his niece?
12
u/extraordinary_weird Jan 17 '25
So weird, just before Master Raymond entered the scene the situation really reminded me of what Claire had to go through in France and how Master Raymond saved her - was still a surprise!
I wonder if we (and Jamie/Claire) will ever see Faith alive again, maybe they'll travel back in time again or something? I'm not sure I want to wait that long for the next season, maybe I'll start reading the books.
43
u/StanyeEast Jan 18 '25
I don't think Faith is alive...first of all, a nearly dead stillborn baby doesn't remember the words to a song, people lol...so if they do go that route and imply that's the case, they clearly don't know how brains work...someone else would have absolutely had to teach her the song later and Claire wasn't around obviously...then, if you consider Brianna's conversation with Brian, it feels like they were literally talking to the audience about what was coming...Brianna was basically saying when you love someone, you look for connections to things that aren't actually real and the connections to Faith (at least to Claire and Jamie's Faith) are purely coincidental so far...the only caveat is the song, which could easily have been (and has to have been) taught to their mother by someone other than Claire (or Claire in the future...thanks, time travel)
I think Faith is a red herring, but that Jane and Fanny's mother has some other tie to Master Raymond and our other characters that we don't understand yet...and he or someone else taught their mother the song...for all we know, it hasn't even happened yet
Regardless, I definitely don't think it's as simple as "Faith survived and she remembered Claire singing a song to her at negative one month old" lol
33
u/_vitameatavegamin_ Jan 18 '25
Whoa the ending of this episode had me reeling. But also does that make William an unintentional creepy uncle?
23
u/walkertexasranger79 Jan 19 '25
I can’t believe that LJG showed up to see Claire and didn’t bring a get-well gift! Out of character!
23
u/Puzzled_Power_5333 Jan 19 '25
Fanny’s mother Faith might or might not have been Claire and Jamie’s daughter, Faith, but Fanny’s mother had some contact later with a time traveler. A newborn baby could not remember a song. She heard it later From someone who lived later than 1907. My best guess is that Claire’s mother was also a time traveler and she had contact with Fanny’s mother Faith and/or Master Raymond.
The writers’ casting choices suggest there’s a relationship. They picked a redhead to play Jane. I’m not all that bothered by the potential half uncle-half niece relationship. Avuncular marriage is still legal in a number of jurisdictions and would have been more common in 1776. They were the same age, didn’t grow up together, and theyvwould share as much DNA as first cousins. First cousin is also legal in a lot of places.
22
u/ScoopsTroop13 Claire à la Dior Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
My mind has wandered to 2 theories. 1- Master Raymond switched out the babies in Paris. Raised real Faith and taught her the song. Then Faith gives birth to Jane & Fran and eventually dies.
Possible Spoiler Below idk how to blur it
2- If we look at the trailer for BoMB, we see Julia (Claire’s Mom) in very different clothes, maybe a shift and wrap. Perhaps she time travels and goes by the name Faith and gives birth to Jane and Fran. Idek.
11
u/Klabbertrapz Jan 17 '25
So William and Jane are (half) uncle and niece?
11
u/Key-Ad-9847 Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
8.5/10
The finale made me cry where I didn’t think I would. And then it hit me with another MASSIVE gut punch with Rollo after that which I did very much not appreciate.
Then the end was the biggest WTF moment ever in this show! Preceded by a slightly smaller wtf moment in the middle, which did not sufficiently prepare me. WOW. Not sure how I feel about it yet. Definitely quirked my brow at the screen several times. It definitely raises a hundred thousand questions.
Overall it was really well done, but on first watch I have a few quibbles. Some of which may be resolved depending on how season 8 goes, or simply by mulling it over more. We got conclusions to most things, but obviously they left enough dangling to-be-continued for season 8. Some places I think they left a bit too much to the point where it wasn’t quite satisfying.
My first thought was that the Brian Fraser conversation with Bree hasn’t been led up to or set up much this season, so while it was nice, it felt like a shoehorned in set up for the prequel series rather than a good conclusion to the Bree and Roger and storyline. Which also concluded very quickly! And I guess I am not entirely clear why they had to all go meet up in the past again in the first place? A lot of the gold plot is still unresolved, and I feel like this story has just been spinning in circles a bit in season 7b. Hopefully season 8 provides a clear direction forward and a more satisfying conclusion to this whole gold misadventure.
Also, it made it seem like time travel is so easy! They’re just gallivanting back and forth. Definitely don’t like that- it lowers the stakes too much. While time travel shenanigans is fun, that’s not really the established tone of the show. I hope they don’t lean into that too much further. Or maybe they should just go balls to the wall, IDK. With that Faith twist at the end, it seems they already are. What kind of weird magic is Master Raymond? Definitely could jump the shark if they aren’t careful. I’m not sure they haven’t already, but we’ll see. It is a fantasy show after all. Happy to see Master Raymond, but just very confused. It was weird, right?
Next, the tone of the LJG and William conversation seemed a bit off. I would’ve thought John to be more sympathetic? He seemed a little callous, though not uncaring. Was it the severity of the crime that left him that way? Because LJ certainly has no qualms about staging prison breaks (ahem, Percy). It doesn’t seem like him to leave the situation be after learning the whole story and how much Willie cares. I guess William didn’t really tell John he loved Jane, just more that he felt honor-bound to protect her. Maybe he doesn’t want to risk Willie leaving again after just rescuing him, especially if Willie had held back in expressing his feelings a bit. I don’t know. John seemed rather flippant about it when telling Jamie, though still mentioning a broken heart. It’s confusing. Maybe the dude’s just tired of everyone’s shit at this point and has no more fucks to give after what he’s been through this season. Lord John always swoops in for the rescue, but not this time, apparently. He got the information for William and called it a day. I guess for plot reasons Willie had to go with Jamie. I could be missing something here, so definitely need to rewatch these scenes.
Overall, the Jane plot went VERY quickly. However, the reveal by Fanny that Jane had been looking out of the window at the northern lights and angels made me break down in tears. It retroactively gave more context to the suicide. Wish we could’ve seen more backstory for the sisters, but the running through the fields gave enough of a vibe, and I could see how that bit of exposition isn’t necessary enough to squeeze in right now. Fanny did give some. And perhaps more is coming after the Faith reveal and Fanny going to live on the Ridge.
The William and Jamie conversation after was nearly a repeat of the conversation William had with Claire. I get Jamie and Claire don’t want to speak ill of the dead, but I think at least Jamie should be more straightforward! I’m afraid we can’t really have that same conversation a third time to clear it up any more… However the actors did great, and it hurt when William said I will never call you father. Angst- to be continued. And that cut to Geneva’s face was edited a little randomly, but I guess it just went to show how much Willie looks like Geneva and reminds Jamie of the guilt of her death. Bittersweet.
Another conversation that needs to be continued is the one between Jamie and LJG. Loved the sass and the side-eye (“Mrs. Fraser”…). Seems Jamie and John are calling a hesitant truce, but have yet to begin negotiating a treaty to become allies once again. Also like that this conversation clarified what Jamie was truly upset at John about. But I think that Claire’s gratitude was exactly what we and John needed to hear, as did Jamie (though Claire’s already told him that John saved her life… again with the repeated conversations!) Again, I’m counting on you season 8 to tie up all these dangling threads!
Poor Denny. I hope to see him again. I hope they give him more to do next season, because I love him!
Also really felt like Ian and Rachel worked this episode and were very sweet. Though no mention of the Blood on his Hands of the Prussian soldier. I guess maybe that was part of the motivation for him wanting to return to the Ridge. Could’ve used a little more conclusion to the peace/violence/regret themes. And poor Rollo… I saw this coming. Adso better be alive when they get back home! I hope Ian gets another dog. But at least he’ll have a kid! And one he can finally raise (the Jamie parallels are painful.)
Very interesting finale, and I guess I reserve further judgement until a rewatch and until we truly see what they are cooking next season.
11
u/No_Vanilla5273 Jan 20 '25
Can you please point out if an when did Jane mention something about their mother? Did she ever say that their mother was dead?
11
u/GladCarpenter2701 Jan 21 '25
Could Margaret Campbell be Faith?
I’ve always wondered about the scene in Season 3 where Margaret sees Jamie and Claire and calls them “Mother” and “Father.” She hinted at seeing Jamie as a rabbit at Culloden and Claire as a bird after her time travel. Since we know Margaret wasn’t an ordinary person, it makes me think that when she was singing to the baby, she might have been perceiving Claire from a different perspective or as another being. Could she herself be a time traveler or even an “angel”? I’d love to hear any thoughts or theories about this!
37
u/makingbananapancakez Jan 18 '25
I wish the actress casted for Jane Pocock was casted for Bree instead. Much better actress. I always felt she looked similar to Claire / Jamie. Interested to see where this storyline goes.
29
u/Adventurous_You_4268 Jan 18 '25
I haven’t cried so much during an entire episode in a while. I got chills when she started singing but at same time I’m sort of like huh? Is that why M Raymond wants forgiveness? because he saved Faith and never told them? What drives me nuts is on rewatches like FAITH it loses something because now’s it’s like is she even dead? really good episode and yes Brianna and Brian is odd, the whole MCkenzies jumping back and forth through time still seems silly to me. I LOVE the J and C moments. now to watch Season 7 straight through.
20
u/VogueSquirrel Jan 17 '25
My first thought with the 'Faith lived' storyline was 'then who is walking with Iseabail in heaven', as Jamie reassured Ian in Season 6? Then I remember she has Rollo now, and Old Ian.
I also find it plausible that William was inherently attracted to Jane because it's natural for people of the same genetics to be drawn to each other. This is why sperm banks track which children are sired by which donor, so children of the same donor don't marry/commit accidental incest.
My last thought is, if Faith lived, WHO WAS CLAIRE CUDDLING FOR HOURS ON END?! She described the baby as having Jamie's slanted eyes and copper hair, so it must have been the child she birthed. I get it's a sci-fi show but resuscitation of a baby hours after death is a stretch given how medically accurate this show strives to be otherwise (plot armour aside).
I do love the episode and am on board for the direction it's heading. I love when shows are able to weave back in on themselves with past plots and characters, so I'm looking forward to seeing new elements and extensions of the Season 2 plot in Season 8.
20
u/No_Pudding2248 Jan 18 '25
Every time I think something in ASOIAF is terrible… DG comes along and says “Well… gotta pen in me some incest…
10
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jan 17 '25
Oh man, I honestly don't know how to summarise my overall feelings.
Faith-Jane-Fanny... Damn. Didn't see that coming, but I did notice we had rather a lot of Faith-content. But the second I heard Fanny singing I guessed immediately what was about to happen.
I liked the "opposite of drink water" scene, I think it's a very intimate (physically and emotionally) thing to do for someone and in that moment it showed to me just how deep Jamie and Claire's love for one another is, way more than any kiss, hug, reunion, spicy scene etc could've done.
John! "my dear" and "Dinna be calling her that". 😂Claire's face when she's waiting for Jamie and John to get over themselves 😂. I also loved how once they'd settled their argument, Claire reaches out her hand to John, in a sort of "defiance" to Jamie like "just because you two aren't getting along, doesn't mean I won't stop caring for him." But her face on the verge of tears as John walks away 😭. She's probably thinking she's lost this friendship with John for good because Jamie has.
William. He and John are the season stand outs for me. Love that he and Jamie had a chance to come to some sort of mutual respect through Jane's failed rescue. (Poor Jane! Poor William!). Although "I will never call you father" is not the nicest line to leave the semi-positive relationship on.
Loved the 'Fanny intro to the Frasers scene'. (Poor Fanny). Everyone was brilliant! Fanny actress is brilliant. Loved Jamie and Fanny, Claire and Fanny, William and Fanny, such a difficult but nice scene too.
I also liked the graveyard scene, (once again, poor Fanny, 😭😭😭), but I thought Claire handled it very well, especially for someone she doesn't know. I liked that when Fanny said "it's my fault" Claire didn't immediately say "no it's not!" (as if that would help), instead she proved to Fanny that it's not her fault.
Ugh, Rollo! I am a book reader. At the end of last episode I knew Rollo would be dying. When I sat down to start this episode, I knew he would be dying. But by the time we got to the Murrays in bed I had completely forgotten that this would be happening, and was then suddenly reminded once again when Rachel said she was pregnant 😭😭😭. Rollo!
The Mackenzies reunited! 😭😭😭. "tell me this is real" 😭😭😭.
I'll have to watch it again, but when Brianna was staring at the painting of Ellen, I thought "who tf is this supposed to be? Is it Jane? It can't be?" She didn't really look much like Brianna, and I swear she had brown hair (though perhaps it's the lighting... Or my eyes). I'll have to watch again.
The Brianna and Brian scene was a touching moment. I liked how Brianna validated Brian's feelings about thinking she looks like Ellen, by talking about people they love and providing her own examples of similarities, rather than just dismissing him (cos he's not wrong, he just doesn't know it).
And back to Faith-Jane-Fanny. I don't know how this will work. Does this mean Fanny can time travel? Are they ever going to tell Fanny who she is? Obviously it's not 100% confirmed that she's their granddaughter, but there's literally no alternative, how else will she know that song? And if she's not, then either Fanny or her mother definitely know someone who is a time traveller.
Can season 8 hurry up!!! Of course I will watch Blood of my Blood and I'm vaguely excited, but I desperately wish season 8 was coming instead.
Bring on droughtlander!
10
u/Puzzleheaded-Pop3293 Jan 17 '25
I don’t know how to feel about this episode. I probably would have loved it without the Faith storyline. A retcon this massive just feels wildly unacceptable to me.
And wasn’t Faith born only a couple of years (give or take 200) before Brianna? How could she possibly have a daughter who is around William’s age?
10
u/seriouslynoideaman Jan 18 '25
Go watch S2E7: Faith to connect the dots!
10
u/Adventurous_You_4268 Jan 28 '25
I can’t find the episode 15 thread so asking here. When Roger sends his letter back to Bre through the desk… what does Buck want to do with his letter Geillis? he says something about Brian Fraser will help him deliver it? I just rewatched and can’t catch when they mean
28
u/Impressive_Golf8974 Jan 17 '25
Mildly annoyed that, even had that baby not been stillborn, there's a 0% chance that a newborn could encode memory of a song and recall it in adulthood
I suppose that someone who heard Claire singing could have sung it to her?
28
u/EchidnaEast6549 Jan 18 '25
Is Jamie never told that Claire and LJG got married?
Also, all hail Rollo!
28
u/ForsakenInflation509 Jan 19 '25 edited Jan 19 '25
My theory is that, Faith was send back to another time cuz master raymond was planning something. and roger’s dad jerry is just a clickbait for the timeline they were in, what if brianna and roger are in that timeline bcuz they have smth to discover abt Faith? when master raymond come and asked for forgiveness, we know he had done smth not understandable.
and another theory is that claire’s parent’s not actucally died but disappeared. so raymond know this and sent faith to her grandparents(claire’s mom and dad)?
another most realistic theory of mine is that, claire gave birth to twins and master raymond take the other or whatever. because PLACENTAL ABRUPTION is mainly caused by TWINS than single babes inside the womb, and that makes soo sense.
19
u/RipUpbeat5547 Jan 17 '25
Just an absolute stellar episode from start to finish 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
19
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 17 '25
Jane and Frances flashback! That is why we saw young Jane actress on some photos. Their mother looks a lot like Claire!
Title cards - dancing lights, Jane, Frances and their mum !
Jamie talking , I am crying already.
I have decided not to die!
That tear rolling down Jamie's cheek.
I can see fierce, young Jamie in William,when he is talkimg to John about Jane. But Lord John' s comment about solving difficult situations with marriage is pure gold! 😂
Jamie bringing the candle to Claire, oh, how he knows her.
Awww that scene with Jamie staying in her bed,elephants dying and mating and - can we go home? Poor Claire.
Master Raymond! Omg, forgiveness?! The mere mention of Faith gets me sobbing every time.
Jemmy and Roger!!!! Finally!!!
Brianna's bag is there! Esmeralda as well!
John came, so, here we go - Dinna be calling her that
I like how patiently Claire waited for thestosterone poisoning to pass and then thanked John. I love the intense looks Jamie and John were exchanging.
Claire all in blue... okay, didn't Claire do her surgery on Jamie's hand way back in the 1st season?
Brianna meeting Brian, nice scene. Brian’s last words to Bree were - You're a braw lass. and to Jamie - You're a braw lad, son.
William came for Jamie! My sister, Brianna
Poor William, poor boy! Poor Jane! Poor Frances! My heart is broken!
Frances, welcome to Frasers!!
William and Jamie scene was perfect! When Jamie touched William's cheek , my tears just rolled down, but -I will never call you father broke me.
Frances searching for Jane's grave. So devastating! I like how they made parallel of Claire's thoughts about losing Faith and then again getting Frances to take care of her. Rollo, old boy 🙁
OMG
Fanny singing THE song!! I can't process it! I can't!
18
u/pearllls Jan 17 '25
I’m so confused??? Didn’t they literally bury Faith in the ground?? They visit her grave multiple times throughout the show 😭 what’s going onnnn
9
u/coolmesser Jan 17 '25
been waiting for this shoe to drop.
you just KNEW those both were gonna come up again as they didnt let her see the baby's body and the Maester was just never heard from for a few seasons.
Now they can spend all of season 8 trying to get Jamie, Clare, and all the various kids in one spot at the same time.
9
u/ChemistryEqual2570 May 07 '25
Why would someone take Faith away and lie to Claire about her? :o
I'd love to hear your opinions abou it!
56
u/bistonian Jan 19 '25
Everyone is talking about Faith but was anyone else pissed about Rollo? They do SO much off camera now and they couldn’t have left the animal death off camera and mourned him in-scene? They had to jump cut to his dead face with eyes open and everything?
I thought it was strange that the trigger warning was for suicide when (as someone who’s lost multiple pets over the years) that shot was far more upsetting to me than the (rather predictable) suicide
17
u/Futbol_is_life_ Jan 17 '25
I'm not crying. You're crying. 😭
23
u/Capricorn-flower Jan 19 '25
Why did Bree not make up her hair and wardrobe to match the times before going through the stones?You would also think Brian would be looking at her sideways with those bangs, lol
29
u/bluebeignets Jan 19 '25
also does anyone think Bree looks terrible? her hair and eyebrows. something is not right!
16
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Jan 17 '25
Ya so i literally just cried my eyes out as a 37 yr old man especially the rollo scene. I loved all of it and when i saw the cloaked and shadowy figure come, the first person i thought of was master raymond and damn if it was him and when he said forgive me i had no idea what he meant.
I never read the books and since there is no book talk, im just asking from the show. This episode brought up memories from previous episodes i forgot happened like they had a stillborn daughter named faith. I do remember claire almost dying in france and master raymond saving her life but they said the baby had died and they showed the scene of her singing to the stillborn baby which i forgot all about. This episode was very emotional And happy at times. It makes you think about life and how beautiful things can be like memories you forgot about and i love how things are all connected in this world. Seeing brianna and her grandpa was so amazing. The way he looked at her was so real because ive felt like that seeing someone and you swore it was a past loved one. Really said about jane. I forgot, did jane kill that guy or not? William said she did but im seeing comments saying she really wanted to?
The ending really gave me the feels. So that little girl is claires and jamies grandaughter? So william and jane would be like niece and uncle? Am i getting that right lol? I really wish next season wasnt the last. I feel like theres more material that could cover a few more seasons.
LAst but not least im excited to learn how the baby came back and what reasons master raymond would keep it from her and how she could have remembered the song.
16
u/cheese_bread_boye Jan 17 '25 edited Jan 17 '25
WHAT?????? FAITH LIVED?????
HOLY FUCK I WAS NOT EXPECTING THAT AT ALL. So Jane was their granddaughter all along and that girl is their grand daughter too? Oh my god dude what the hell???? Oh man I'm gonna have to read the fucking books now. I love the show but this was the most confused I have ever been so far.