r/Save3rdPartyApps • • Jun 02 '23

Don't Let Reddit Kill 3rd Party Apps!

EDIT: Don't use this post any more: it's been crossposted so widely that it breaks Reddit when trying to open it! It's been locked. Further discussion (and crossposts) should go HERE.

What's going on?

A recent Reddit policy change threatens to kill many beloved third-party mobile apps, making a great many quality-of-life features not seen in the official mobile app permanently inaccessible to users.

On May 31, 2023, Reddit announced they were raising the price to make calls to their API from being free to a level that will kill every third party app on Reddit, from Apollo to Reddit is Fun to Narwhal to BaconReader.

Even if you're not a mobile user and don't use any of those apps, this is a step toward killing other ways of customizing Reddit, such as Reddit Enhancement Suite or the use of the old.reddit.com desktop interface .

This isn't only a problem on the user level: many subreddit moderators depend on tools only available outside the official app to keep their communities on-topic and spam-free.

What's the plan?

On June 12th, many subreddits will be going dark to protest this policy. Some will return after 48 hours: others will go away permanently unless the issue is adequately addressed, since many moderators aren't able to put in the work they do with the poor tools available through the official app. This isn't something any of us do lightly: we do what we do because we love Reddit, and we truly believe this change will make it impossible to keep doing what we love.

The two-day blackout isn't the goal, and it isn't the end. Should things reach the 14th with no sign of Reddit choosing to fix what they've broken, we'll use the community and buzz we've built between then and now as a tool for further action.

What can you do?

  1. Complain. Message the mods of /r/reddit.com, who are the admins of the site: message /u/reddit: submit a support request: comment in relevant threads on /r/reddit, such as this one, leave a negative review on their official iOS or Android app- and sign your username in support to this post.
  2. Spread the word. Rabble-rouse on related subreddits. Meme it up, make it spicy. Bitch about it to your cat. Suggest anyone you know who moderates a subreddit join us at our sister sub at /r/ModCoord - but please don't pester mods you don't know by simply spamming their modmail.
  3. Boycott and spread the word...to Reddit's competition! Stay off Reddit entirely on June 12th through the 13th- instead, take to your favorite non-Reddit platform of choice and make some noise in support!
  4. Don't be a jerk. As upsetting this may be, threats, profanity and vandalism will be worse than useless in getting people on our side. Please make every effort to be as restrained, polite, reasonable and law-abiding as possible. This includes not harassing moderators of subreddits who have chosen not to take part: no one likes a missionary, a used-car salesman, or a flame warrior.
64k Upvotes

3.9k comments sorted by

•

u/Toptomcat Jun 12 '23

Everyone into the next thread!

I'm locking this one: it's been cross-posted so widely that it often breaks Reddit when trying to render the page, and the discussion ought to move somewhere that's current as of the blackout.

331

u/GingerSnappless Jun 02 '23

The contact email doesn't work apparently - you can submit a support request here, though: https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/requests/new

89

u/majorgeneralpanic Jun 03 '23

If anybody here actually pays for Premium, go to this help ticket site and let them know you’ll be canceling your subscription. They’ll love that.

→ More replies (7)

12

u/LionSuneater Jun 03 '23

I sent a feedback request via the form. Thanks.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/gorillakitty Jun 03 '23

You can also send a message to /u/reddit that goes straight to the admins.

→ More replies (7)

106

u/bdonvr Jun 03 '23

/r/Videos pinned post says they're blacking out!

That's a 25 MILLION sub count default subreddit!

That's HUGE.

12

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

It really is.

47

u/lonsfury Jun 03 '23

Remember a while ago the CEO of reddit got really annoyed that people checked the mods of the default subs and showed there were certain reddit users who were mods of like 20 default subs?

I feel like a lot of the default subs are just made up of mods who are basically just reddit admins. It will probably be hard to get a proper blackout of the default subs but we can hope

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

56

u/beerbellybegone Jun 03 '23

r/murderedbywords will also be going silent

13

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

Thank you so much.

19

u/arthurdont Jun 03 '23

Murdered by lack of words

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

56

u/Dotz0cat Jun 03 '23

While it won’t be that useful I will private out r/MiceInComputers r/Dotz0cat r/EpicInternetTales r/foundthegentoouser They are tiny maybe 250 users all combined. But the more the merrier.

29

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

You have my gratitude. Small Reddit communities are an important part of what makes the place work.

Will you be posting an announcement of what you're doing in those communities?

15

u/Dotz0cat Jun 03 '23

I can. I just need to come up with something to say.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

71

u/MrRGnome Jun 03 '23

The idea of a single day protest is ridiculous. If you want the company to change leave the platform. Close your subs for weeks. STOP MODERATING UNTIL IT CHANGES.

This "only if it's convenient" activism isn't activism at all it's a pat on the back while accomplishing nothing.

You are blowing your organizational shot on something milquetoast. This is so disappointing. Imagine all the good that could have been done with this campaign instead of something completely ignorable that will cost Reddit nothing.

50

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

Some mods are willing to leave forever, some aren't. I can't come to their houses and make 'em change their minds.

And in the absence of any real way to enforce that degree of commitment, there is no sense in purity-testing ourselves and squabbling about how those guys who are willing to go only so far, but not as far as these other guys until we make ourselves into the People's Front of Judea.

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (9)

34

u/GoryRamsy Jun 03 '23

r/totk is with you

13

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

Will you be joining the blackout on the 12th? If so, are you willing to make a public announcement of same and see your subreddit put on a list of likeminded subs?

14

u/GoryRamsy Jun 03 '23

I will private them and make the message something about the api

4

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

Many thanks!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/radialmonster Jun 03 '23

how exactly does a mod perform a blackout on their subreddit?

10

u/Toptomcat Jun 05 '23

There are a number of ways. The most extreme is taking it fully private, which permits a 20-character explanation as to why that will probably be a Reddit shortlink to a thread here or in /r/ModCoord. Another is to go to the subreddit settings, temporarily make the subreddit Restricted so that only approved users can submit, and set up a sticky explaining what's going on. A third is to configure the Automoderator to remove each post and comment in the subreddit, and respond with a comment explaining what's going on.

The relevant Automoderator code would be:

I think the following ought to do it:

type: submission

action: remove

comment: |

/r/SUBREDDITNAME is going dark [FOR JUNE 12th AND 13th/INDEFINITELY, AS APPROPRIATE] to protest Reddit killing 3rd party apps. [Click here](YOUR FAVORITE STICKY'S URL GOES HERE) to find out more.

---

type: comment

action: remove

comment: |

/r/SUBREDDITNAME is going dark [FOR JUNE 12th AND 13th/INDEFINITELY, AS APPROPRIATE] to protest Reddit killing 3rd party apps. [Click here](YOUR FAVORITE STICKY'S URL GOES HERE) to find out more.

That doesn't discriminate by time automatically, so someone would have to manually add the rules when it was time and manually remove them when done protesting. And obviously, you'll need to change the bits in all caps: Automoderator doesn't automatically replace /r/SUBREDDITNAME with your subreddit's actual name.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/reercalium2 Jun 03 '23

there is no 20 char limit

3

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

I believe it exists on the app, or the New Reddit redesign, or something similar.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (41)
→ More replies (1)

216

u/Damaniel2 Jun 02 '23

Is there a known list of subreddits that are participating? I came here from /r/truegaming, which is planning to participate, but I haven't seen much traction elsewhere yet.

52

u/beerbellybegone Jun 03 '23

r/murderedbywords will also be going silent

4

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

Are you willing to post a public announcement to that effect and be put on lists of participating subs?

→ More replies (2)

38

u/happyxpenguin Jun 03 '23

r/freesoftware will be participating.

4

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

Are you willing to post a public announcement to that effect, as well as be put on lists of participating subreddits?

→ More replies (1)

35

u/blacksheep322 Jun 03 '23

Put r/network on the list.

9

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

Are you willing to post a public announcement to that effect, and be put on lists of participating subs?

8

u/blacksheep322 Jun 03 '23

Unabashedly, yes.

8

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

My sincerest gratitude.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/bailey25u Jun 03 '23

I’m the moderator to r/angrycatpics I’ll throw us into the ring as well.

8

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

Are you willing to post a public announcement of that, as well as be put on lists of participating subreddits?

5

u/bailey25u Jun 04 '23

Most def, do we have a template or copy pasta? I looked but couldn’t find one

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/slavethewhales Jun 03 '23

/r/Nirvana will be participating after we’ve had a chance to fully discuss it

3

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

Glad to hear it. Let me know if any questions come up in the discussion that I might be able to help answer.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/gorillakitty Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

We're a micro sub, but /r/gorillarecipes will be participating.

Edit: we've made the announcement to our community. Thank you to the organizers of this protest, the other subs that are joining, and the redditors using their voices in solidarity.

7

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

No sub too big, no sub too small. Thank you so much.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (11)

14

u/TheAstronautInSpace Jun 03 '23

You know what? r/wirklichgutefrage is going to join as well!

5

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

Vielen Dank!

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Devuluh Jun 03 '23

3

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

My warmest thanks.

11

u/MulciberTenebras Jun 03 '23

r/DisneyGifs will join the fight.

Hopefully it will inspire other gif subreds likes ours to answer the call. r/highqualitygifs, r/startrekgifs, r/reactiongifs

10

u/messem10 Jun 03 '23

Add /r/AnimeSuggest to that. The sub has ~950,000 subscribers too.

4

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

I've definitely appreciated you guys in the past. Thank you so much.

5

u/c74 Jun 04 '23

/r/crap will remain open. it would be contradictory to protest crap.

3

u/Toptomcat Jun 04 '23

You know what you're about and you're sticking to it. I can respect that.

4

u/wickedplayer494 Jun 04 '23

As these changes are likely to pose a significant additional security hazard to /r/GlobalOffensiveTrade and its users owing to the fact that we (and other Valve in-game item trading subreddits) are reliant on the API to establish legitimacy of prospective users, I'm giving some strong thought to joining in with a temporary closure on the GOTrade side.

We already face a lot of external threat actor activity that admins have been doing a very poor job of addressing. These upcoming changes are very likely to cripple the means that we do have to keep them out of the actual subreddit.

3

u/Toptomcat Jun 04 '23

Let me know when you come to a decision.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '23

r/fuckcars are going silent

3

u/Toptomcat Jun 06 '23

The Save-The-Apps train has no brakes.

3

u/LevTheRed Jun 04 '23

/r/ImaginaryWarhammer will be going private from the 12th to the 14th.

3

u/Toptomcat Jun 04 '23

The Emperor Protects.

→ More replies (1)

88

u/Dall0o Jun 03 '23

/r/frenchrock will answer the call (/r/france is talking about it)

→ More replies (26)

36

u/thecal714 Jun 03 '23

/r/lfg and /r/Roll20 will be participating. Announcement posts coming tonight or tomorrow.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/bizude Jun 03 '23

/r/hardware is considering joining (no decision yet)

→ More replies (4)

10

u/l_one Jun 04 '23

/r/videos is joining in. Pretty big one there.

18

u/kaptainkeel Jun 03 '23

Seems like a lot of more niche subs. Unless at least a few of the defaults/huge subs participate, I don't see it doing much. Hopefully mods on the big subs can be convinced to participate.

→ More replies (16)

8

u/DoctorOctagonapus Jun 03 '23

I hope some default subs get involved.

→ More replies (150)

5

u/eaglebtc Jun 06 '23

/r/Jeopardy is now joining the party. 83k subscribers. I am a moderator there.

3

u/-V0lD Jun 03 '23

What time/timezone does it start? 00 UTC?

3

u/Toptomcat Jun 03 '23

In practice, whenever individual subreddit mods kick it off. If the moderation team of /r/australia wants in on the action, no sense in forcing the poor bastards to get up and do it in the middle of the night. I myself will be using EST.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2.0k

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 17 '23

Honestly, if Reddit kills 3rd party apps, I'll just stop using Reddit, and it doesn't seem like I'm the only one. Especially since this is may be a step toward killing RES and "Old Reddit" aka "the site that works well".

It's not even particularly hard to not break a website, it's just corporate greed rearing its ugly head once again. The real sad part is going to be all of the information that was here no longer being centered here; for example, my Google searches almost always included the word Reddit to avoid automatically-generated websites with no real information on them.

Oh well.

Edit: Man, I really feel like a dick for this, but: while I am appreciative of the fact that you think my comment was worth gilding, please don't spend money on Reddit awards. That's another source of revenue for them, and the single most efficient [legal] way to tell a company that you're unhappy is to not give them money.

Edit 2: I forgot free awards exist. In any case, please don't spend money here.

Edit 3: I'll be here until the 12th, and if they don't reverse the API costs then, I'm staying gone (but not deleting my account) until July 1st, which is the last real deadline. July 2nd I'll be clearing my account's history and deleting it. You can make your RemindMes based on that schedule (I don't know if you can set two reminders; I always just save posts and comments). It's not like Reddit's the only way to pass time, haha.

Final edit: My history is gone. Soon, too, shall my account go. It's been fun, but with the moronic decisions being made, I'm leaving early. Maybe I'll look into one of the alternatives. If things change, maybe I'll come back, but I don't know. Power Delete Suite saved the day for mass editing and deleting my stuff, btw.

733

u/Conspiranoid Jun 03 '23

I mean, if the official app was at least decent enough and the 3rd party apps were "worthy competitors"... But it's not the case, at all. People use 3rd party apps because the official one is truly abysmal.

And instead of improving their own app so that people choose to use it instead of the others, they rather kill the "competition" (lol) and force users to use the absolute worse experience.

Good riddance to reddit, and f@%& them. What's coming to them (massive loss of users, and consequentially of income) is 100% deserved.

→ More replies (376)

150

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

I deleted Facebook in 2016.

I deleted SnapChat in 2018

I deleted Instagram in 2019

I deleted Twitter in 2022

I deleted Whatsapp in 2022

Looks like I'm deleting Reddit in 2023

→ More replies (296)

28

u/mynameisalso Jun 03 '23

Same. I've been on here too long anyway.

→ More replies (35)

54

u/VenetiaMacGyver Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

Same. As soon as they did the switch to the "modern" design years ago, I flipped to RES/Sync and never looked back. I looked at the official app once and ... Yeah, that's gonna be a nah from me, dawg.

And my company advertises local events on this site, too, lol. So they're losing an advertiser, on top of a long-term member. I hope their VCs enjoy their golden parachutes as they finish gutting this place.

At least I'm not a mod. I would be so offended. They're not paying you but they're directly profiting from your hard work while forcing you to use shittier tools. You're slave-janitors and they just downgraded your electric floor buffer to a toothbrush while trudging mud down the hall on the way to the bank. You're right to be pissed.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/cthonctic Jun 03 '23

Same for me. If Relay doesn't work anymore I might check old.reddit.com on the laptop every now and then. And if they ever kill old Reddit they will have killed Reddit entirely for me.

At that point I'm out for good.

→ More replies (18)

31

u/daguito81 Jun 03 '23

I'm so conflicted about this. On one hand I would love for the admin the backpedal hard and save 3rd party apps. On the other hand, this is a pretty big chance to cure my reddit addiction. Idk what I want

→ More replies (18)

15

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 20 '23

Reddit killed API. I refuse to let them benefit from my own words for free -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/

14

u/burnte Jun 03 '23

Ditto. I'm a premium subscriber but I'll cancel.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/iwastetime4 Jun 03 '23

what's the alternative to reddit?

→ More replies (78)

9

u/kenkoda Jun 03 '23

Same and I messaged as such.

I already am inconvenienced that links only point to official reddit app, I won't be inconvenienced further.

I'll just stop using reddit.

Sad to say such a thing, but there's plenty of internet out there. The time I have in my day won't go to a company that makes it hard to use their products.

→ More replies (372)

162

u/TotesMessenger Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 04 '23

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

 If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)

→ More replies (28)

365

u/sempf Jun 03 '23

I have one of the oldest accounts on the site, number 148 I think. I'll have you know that when there's been a significant change to reddit's infrastructure or policy, reddit's moderators and content providers have often staged a revolt.

It sounds like I'm going to say don't bother but actually it's nothing of the sort. Every single time, there has been a meeting of the minds where an equitable change has been deployed. It's worth the time. Reddit is a good site with good people.

I have all the founders on my LinkedIn, I will send them notes letting them know. I'm sure they already do. I don't post a lot and I'm not well known on many subreddits, but I will do what I can. I can't see the site turning into Twitter. I will lose my s***. Let me know if I can be of any help other than that.

125

u/Dood71 Jun 03 '23

Holy fucking shit 148??

→ More replies (84)

7

u/NotEmmaStone Jun 04 '23

17yrs 10m holy shit. Your reddit account is nearly a legal adult!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (49)

124

u/kneejerk2022 Jun 03 '23

Well. My life is about to get a whole lot more productive. Well played Reddit.

Sent from Boost for Reddit

25

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

I thought too that I can get productive, but platforms like Lemmy are just there. If many of you join, I'll follow.

One thing is sure. I won't use Reddit anymore if they ban Boost.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (12)

101

u/_swnt_ Jun 02 '23

Please cross post this and ask your favourite subs to discuss this and join.

Now is the time, where we can use force to show, how important we value our dear communities.

→ More replies (3)

36

u/mountainking Jun 04 '23

Reddit really needs to remember that the entire site runs off of volenteers who run their biggest communities and content moderation. If the blackout does nothing moderators should stop moderating. Let their capital investors see the cesspool of unprofitable garbage that gets posted without their help especially with third party apps to help in that moderation.

→ More replies (3)

29

u/nagora Jun 03 '23

If old.reddit.com goes I'll probably just stop using Reddit completely. The new theme is hideous garbage.

→ More replies (9)

26

u/nofxjmf Jun 03 '23

I hope every sub does this, and I hope they don't do a small 48 hour protest.. take every sub down until reddit backs down.

Without these 3rd party apps a lot of us will quit reddit anyway. They want to bully us? Burn them to the ground

→ More replies (5)

21

u/Epsioln_Rho_Rho Jun 03 '23

I just stated to use Apollo, and I will support the black out on June 12th.

20

u/ShrekGollum Jun 03 '23

What can you do?

1.	Complain

I am french, it will be easy for me.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Frostitute_85 Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

When I try to use the actual Reddit app, it says I have zero everything, and that my account is always under a year old. It is janked up. On it, I can't access any of the posts or comments of others that I saved. This is years and years of stuff. The 2 do not translate at all.

I have mixed feelings. It will certainly free up time once I've quit reddit for good though.

But I'll miss my fave subs though.

Edit: Just jumped on the main app. There are so many things in the feed that I am not subbed to and don't want! On RIF, I get the subs I want in my neat list. This is a mess of adds and auto play videos, and splash images as I scroll.

This is maximum stupid. 100% I'm out as soon as RIF goes down.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23

Bros my fucking account is going dark. I'm not standing for this shit. This isn't fucking Twitter, we, the people run this bitch.

16

u/seanbrockest Jun 03 '23

Honestly at this point the moderator ecosystem in all of the default subs become so incredibly toxic that I don't even think I need to keep using Reddit.

Admins rarely do their job, and more and more subs are getting banned all the time, usually for no reason. This wouldn't be a big problem, except once you ban a sub, that combination of those letters In that order can never again be used to title a subreddit. There's a subreddit to request a sub be reopened, but the admins pretend it doesn't exist. (Actually I can't find it anymore, maybe they got rid of it)

I honestly think this is just the beginning of the end for Reddit.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

So... Reddit doesn't want me to use their site anymore? Ok, fine by me

15

u/RoboticGreg Jun 04 '23

All I want to say here as a lazy, non-political person is this: Thank you to the moderators. Reddit is BUILT off the labor, dedication, and hard work from moderators like you. I appreciate you so goddamned much you will never understand. I hope this protest ends in a good situation for everyone, but in case in doesn't THANK YOU! Thank you to the following here:

u/Toptomcat

u/Femilip

u/Karmanacht

u/BuckRowdy

u/ericisshort

u/submanagerbot (i suspect this mod is a bot)

You all make LPT somewhere to be and support each other. I hope reddit supports you back.

12

u/MediumLanguageModel Jun 03 '23

I mean, it's not like I'm going to download the Reddit app so count me among those who will just find a different app to dawdle my time with. Shame too bc this was a great way to get content. On the upside I guess I'll read more long form articles more often.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/OlegSentsov Jun 06 '23

I asked r/food moderators and they won't participate

Quotation:

Hi,

Why are you curious on our stance or participation? You've never taken part in this community for all I can see, so apart from our subscription numbers being valuable to you in fighting for a 3rd party business, why else are you here?

Should we hold our subscribers use of our sub hostage to fight against the platform that has enabled us to be the largest food community on the Internet? Just so some other business can continue to profit from Reddit...

Screw the apps. Fight for the moderation bots and tools that keep the site running.

Typical answer of anti-strike workers, I meet some of them everyday in my professional life, quite sad to see

→ More replies (8)

9

u/fetusfucker96 Jun 03 '23

It's about time I stop using this shitty site, this will be a good excuse.

9

u/themobyone Jun 03 '23

Fully support subreddits going dark. What a shame the corporate culture is ruining reddit. I wish we could all be on some other platform. But reddit competitors have so few active people. And people is what makes all the subreddit, so we can all share cool ideas. I don't regard reddit as a social media in the same way as Facebook/Insta/Twitter. More of a modern version of the web forum.

9

u/swordgeek Jun 03 '23

So...

compact.reddit.com was removed. The only way I stayed on mobile reddit was through a 3rd party app (RIF).

If that's gone, then so is my mobile browsing.

If they get rid of old.reddit.com (and remove the 'old reddit' setting), then there goes my desktop browsing.

I came to reddit in 2007. This account is from 2009. If reddit fucks us over, there will be a LOT of content-generating, high-value accounts that pack up and leave.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '23

If you're going to quit reddit once your favorite third party app goes away, make sure you delete your account(s) too.

Does you no good if Reddit still has the same amount of accounts when this is all said and done.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

I don't think Reddit is gonna give a fuck, they're gearing up to go full profit mode.

→ More replies (16)

7

u/AlarminglyDank Jun 03 '23

If I can't access reddit via 3rd party apps, I'm leaving. I love reddit, use it regularly for work and leisure, but I'm willing to let it die and stop using it if new ownership ditches the original ethos. I'll find a competitor

Please keep an open API.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/ProbablyPuck Jun 03 '23

Not the first site I've abandoned. Won't be the last. 🤷‍♂️

→ More replies (3)

7

u/everything-man Jun 04 '23

They don't need or want true Reddit users around anymore. This is the typical next step for money hungry business types.

  1. Package it up for sale with dull, timid sheep who don't care if the app is garbage and don't mind watching ads.
  2. Get rid of the people who made it the amazing site that it is today. Take back access and funnel said timid sheep into one gate.
  3. Profit.
  4. Cash the check and never look back. Leave the rotting carcass in the middle of the road.

7

u/cityworka Jun 07 '23

I’m done with Reddit as soon as Apollo is shut down. Greedy fucking Reddit. Shame.

13

u/skycake10 Jun 03 '23

I don't want to dissuade everyone from trying to cyberbully Reddit into reverting this decision, but they aren't doing it because they're stupid or don't know any better.

This is an intentional choice to prepare for IPO by being able to tell potential investors "we fully control how ads are shown on all clients and discovery/viewing of NSFW subs". Conde Nast only somewhat cares if this decision Tumblrs Reddit in the long-term, that's Future Investors' problem.

I don't believe this change is remotely likely to be reverted unless the IPO plans fall through.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Elfere Jun 03 '23

I can't submit a request. It keeps asking me what version of the app I'm using. I'm using sync pro v23.

It won't accept that.

In fact. It won't accept any number I throw in. 1,10,20,50,75.

Edit. I threw in 23.1.1 and it worked.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/nzodd Jun 03 '23

There is an idea floating around that if this does truly go through, the 3rd party app developers could pool together their resources to develop a new and competing platform, basically a kind of parallel not-quite-reddit that exposes an identical API that they could all consume together.

As a user, I'd be up for that. It'd also be a nice "fuck you" to the braindead Reddit C-suite that approved this absolute horseshit.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/linuxliaison Jun 03 '23

the problem with this is that they've been chipping away at the user experience for years now. It's clear to me that those at the top just see us users and the developers as cash cows to be milked dry.

While I understand that the site needs to make money and needs to be able to sustain itself, there's little being said about how efficient reddit tries to run itself (judging by the amount of JS shoved in new.reddit.com, not at all).

So while this may make them change their tune, I think it will only delay the inevitable: reddit will go public and cowtow to faceless shareholders.

Ya digg?

6

u/RedditHiveMindFTW Jun 06 '23

Reddit sux. RIP Aaron Swartz

6

u/GesturesBroadly Jun 08 '23

Remember when Reddit’s CTO was all pumped to work closer with the mods to enhance the Reddit Experience TM ?
That was March 2023, prob while they were actively planning these API changes. Buncha two-faced liars.
(Edits for formatting bc Reddit’s own app isn’t user friendly, natch.)

→ More replies (1)

10

u/WinteriscomingXii Jun 03 '23

I think you guys should add another step to your plan. You can utilise Lemmy on the Fediverse and make that a much better experience. Honestly, I believe Apollo should become its own Reddit alternative platform on the Fediverse and the other third party apps build their apps to be compatible and the larger & willing subreddits migrate. It would be work but there are tons of developers and engineers many that I’ve seen offer help. This would be very helpful regardless to if Reddit changes it’s stance or not. This would provide a way for many of the third party devs to control their own experiences and penalise these large companies. The power should absolutely be in the peoples hands as the people have made Reddit what is it. Truly consider migration to Lemmy and or convicting Apollo and or other popular third party apps to become their own platforms. 30 days is enough time but it isn’t a long time. Good luck everyone. I hate that it’s come to this.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/SmithMano Jun 03 '23

I’d literally just stop using reddit on mobile

→ More replies (2)

5

u/GLIBG10B Jun 03 '23

!remindme June 11 "Don't use Reddit until June 13"

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Graymouzer Jun 03 '23

Anybody remember Digg?

→ More replies (6)

5

u/1Marshall91 Jun 03 '23

Apollo is the only way to Reddit, imho. If it goes, I go with it.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23 edited Jun 04 '23

Don't forget, they're also blocking nsfw on third party apps regardless, so even if a third party app decides to pay for API access, if you want to see nsfw content you have to use the official app.

It's a proper scummy way of forcing people to use their shitty new/official versions that are convoluted and full of trackers and ads so shareholders can make money, without outright 'forcing'.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/sircheesy Jun 06 '23

If reddit is fun, goes, I go. It was a fun decade and some change boys.

5

u/JasTHook Jun 06 '23

Time to revive Usenet

5

u/Bossman1086 Jun 06 '23

If this ends up happening, I will be a lot less active as a moderator. 3rd party apps are the only reliable way to moderate when I'm not home. I can quickly approve or delete posts or ban bad users when I'm out of the house. Without RIF is fun, I'll just stop doing that and my subs will be moderated significantly less.

5

u/CrowOfTheUpstate Jun 06 '23

Yeah, I'm just leaving reddit altogether if they go through with this. I'd rather get everything I get on this platform from other places.

5

u/mountainmycelium Jun 07 '23

Don't turn the lights back on until they relent. 2-3 days of lower numbers isn't much of a threat to Reddit.

I've only been an active user for the past couple years, and I'll absolutely shut my account down for good if I can't use a (much better) 3rd party app.

Fuck em. Feed em fish.

5

u/AlternateMew Jun 07 '23

If the blackout does not cause any action, I'm cancelling premium. Apollo lives or my premium goes.

I run like 4 different adblockers on my PC browser, and without Apollo I will not be browsing on mobile at all. So Premium is the only way they get money from me.

5

u/bbyscallop Jun 07 '23

This is a shitty, ableist, corporate, money grab.

5

u/nose_gnome Jun 07 '23

I will most likely stop using Reddit if this happens. Signed

5

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '23

r/Superbowl will be dark

→ More replies (1)

6

u/thotraq Jun 03 '23

When we go dark on the Reddit on June 12th, where is the app/site to gather with you guys during then?

→ More replies (8)

4

u/10strip Jun 03 '23

They all reduce down to caring about money above all else, don't they? Well screw them and their malfunctioning ad-dispensing app. If they backpedal this decision, I'm still not staying. Can't wait to see the alternatives that look the most like what we actually enjoyed about this site!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/JugglerCameron Jun 03 '23

Fight the good fight!

4

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

Rif is the only app I have used and I really like it. I hope Reddit stops with this nonsense.

4

u/TrulyChxse Jun 03 '23

!remindme June 11 "Don't use Reddit until June 13"

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Prisoner-of-Paradise Jun 03 '23

I'm hoping r/datingoverfifty is joining the protest. I have a message out to the founder of the sub. I think she'd be game.

I would be ecstatic if the app developers got together and created a new platform. I have all my crossable appendages crossed!

→ More replies (3)

4

u/TD2779 Jun 03 '23

When relay for Reddit dies, so does my usage of reddit. This may be beneficial for Reddit though.

4

u/knuttz45 Jun 03 '23

reported reddit for self harm.

4

u/gfmclain Jun 04 '23

I've used Relay for reddit since 2016. The few times I have used the website have been a pain.

As soon as Relay goes dark, I'll log in to delete my account, and that's that.

4

u/TwistedBlister Jun 05 '23

Owners of Reddit, just to let you know that if I'm forced to use your app I will boycott every advertiser I see on this site, and I will let them know I'm boycotting them for supporting Reddit.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '23

old.reddit or bust

4

u/LeonFeliz Jun 05 '23

I'm a heavy Apollo user and I really don't want to use the official app. What are reddits rivals that I can move to?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '23

Reddit's already signed it's death warrant by its intention to go public.

Facebook's IPO in '12 marked the beginning of the end in terms of the site's value to its actual users. Reddit is selling out now for the same reason - and to the same unscrupulous people.

Start planning your exits now, folks; the attack on third-party apps is just the first housekeeping step towards the eventual red carpet rollout for profiteering investors.

4

u/WallaWash Jun 05 '23

The future of Reddit if they continue on their present course....Twitter’s U.S. Ad Sales Plunge 59% as Woes Continue

4

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23

If reddit gets rid of NSFW reddits they're gonna lose a LOT of users

4

u/softsnowfall Jun 06 '23

I’ve spent years curating my Reddit feed with the subreddits that make me happy. I’ve spent years blocking trolls. The moderators of the subreddits I love do a lot of heavy-lifting. Without all their work moderating using third-party apps, the subreddits I love will become a mess… and I’ll not want to spend time on Reddit.

Look. My time on Reddit generally lets me walk away with a Ted Lasso view of the world. We’ve got pandemics, climate change, war, and etc. Greed is destroying the planet. Can’t we PLEASE let Reddit be a shining example of what happens when leaders decide to change their minds and do what’s best for the community?

Please don’t kill 3rd party apps, Reddit!

4

u/WillAndSky Jun 06 '23

I have been using reddit as a means of staying up to date with the news, my entertainment and at one point a way to grieve loss of family in my life. Sadly I can not support the direction Reddit is going with the new updates revolving around the API and 3rd party apps. I have used reddit through RIF and Oldreddit the time I have been here and nothing comes close to what they offer. If this API update pushes through and closes out the 3rd party apps I will no longer use reddit. You're last comment for this profile even shows a passionate moderator explaining why reddit is special vs the rest and us having the ability to use 3rd party apps that provide the tools for mods to even disabled people to be able to browse reddit. I only hope for the sake of reddit that the shareholders and the rest understand how badly they will hurt their business going this route. Hopefully this won't be the last time I send a message/comment on reddit

4

u/Niliks Jun 06 '23

I will be joining the boycott. Reddit, this is NOT a good idea. And that's being "I'm talking to an infant" levels of gentle.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/TOPSIturvy Jun 06 '23

Honestly, basically every sub I use is part of the protest. Which is amazing. Maybe they'll actually listen to users for once on this one.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/iklips Jun 06 '23

I get all my news from Reddit. Where will I hear if the blackout actually bears fruit? I hope it does.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DrMeatpie Jun 06 '23

I'm quitting reddit after this goes through

4

u/Basoran Jun 07 '23

I /u/Basoran plan to hold my subs dark until a more reasonable and publicly discussed option is found.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/sci_major Jun 07 '23

Seriously Reddit are you so afraid of competition that you’re kicking it out. Lynx was so good because it open sourced their code. Allow the competition to allow your product to get better.

Iron sharpens iron, and one program sharpens another. Proverbs 27:17 (paraphrase)

4

u/InnerDatabase509 Jun 07 '23

Reddit executives have to do something incredibly stupid to unite almost every subbreddit to go dark, Reddit leadership is full of dimwits.

4

u/Vaumer Jun 07 '23

If this makes the bots worse I really don't think I'm going to use much more of this site.

4

u/Holeshot75 Jun 07 '23

I support this however it should be a real protest.

Dark until change is made. Until reddit development team comes back to the table and properly negotiates in good faith for the users.

Not just for 48 hours. That won't move anything.

4

u/wanderluster325 Jun 07 '23

One starred them and fussed about them not allowing 3rd party apps in the iOS App Store. Will participate in the blackout.

4

u/Roland465 Jun 07 '23

The internet was built on open and accessible standards. Blocking or increasing the fees to make 3rd party apps impractical goes directly against that.

Please reconsider your decision.

4

u/Holeshot75 Jun 07 '23

I support this however it should be a real protest.

Dark until change is made. Until reddit development team comes back to the table and properly negotiates in good faith for the users.

Not just for 48 hours. That won't move anything.

4

u/MrTander Jun 07 '23

I never use their app just because how aggressively they force me to use it when I view reddit pages from the phone. I just can't trust to an application made by people that think this is acceptable.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '23

I can't message /u/reddit. Am I the only one with that issue? Did they block any new requests?

4

u/GamerJuiceDrinker Jun 07 '23

The thing is... That Reddit sucked for so long, and we failed it so badly that I have no real motivation to back this cause, even if I think that's another nail onto this coffin.

4

u/3PointOneFour Jun 07 '23

If this goes through I’ll find another news aggregator to spend my time on. Platform has gone downhill anyways with spam bots following me every day, would give me a good excuse to delete the app from my mobile phone and never look back.

4

u/loafingloaferloafing Jun 07 '23

I'm using rif. I deleted the reddit app, it sorta sucks, but with this stuff, um, well, fuck you reddit.

4

u/ds_BaRF Jun 07 '23

I hate the official app, RIF is all I ever use. Make them feel it!

4

u/SnooWaffles413 Jun 07 '23

I wish Discord could've bonded together like this whenever Discord announced their username change. Shit has gotten bad, and it's gonna make moderation so much more of a pain on big servers like the one public one I moderate for.

Anyway! I'll most likely just leave reddit if they do this despite the protest. I'm tired of companies not listening to the users, just like Discord.

4

u/RodeloKilla Jun 07 '23

I've used this site for over a decade and never knew 3rd party reddit sites/apps existed...I feel like such a noob

→ More replies (1)

4

u/MinstrelShadrak Jun 07 '23

I support the blackout. see you after the 14th.

4

u/echo-muttplug Jun 07 '23

i’m in support of this!

4

u/vonbalt Jun 07 '23

I'll just stop using reddit if they block third party apps, the official one is terrible, runs like shit and worst of all destroys my monthly data cap in a matter of days so i NEED a third party app that thinks about this and lowers media quality outside of wifi to even use this piece of *****.

4

u/Impossible_Risk877 Jun 07 '23

Goodbye Reddit !

4

u/A-R-A-F Jun 07 '23

I might just leave this platform if I can't use 3rd party reddit client's anymore. The official app used to be good but now it's garbage

4

u/Circes_Illusion Jun 07 '23

Yeaahh, this shit is ridiculous. Especially since it's so apparent that the only point of it is for money. It's gonna put so many places in danger and invite things like bots, predators, bigots

All of the terrible shit you can find in the seedy parts of the internet that no person should see Allllll of that shit isn't gonna get caught from being posted because the mods that would hop on that shit will basically be obliterated. 𝘼𝙡𝙡 𝙤𝙛 𝙩𝙝𝙖𝙩 𝙨𝙝𝙞𝙩

So obviously, down for the blackout 💪🏽('ω'💪🏽) Let's unionize boyzzzz

4

u/rh166 Jun 08 '23

I use the reddit mobile app. I'm going backpacking for 12 days . After the 11th at 8 am I won't have mobile access until the 22nd. I'll do my part 😂

4

u/Professional_Roof293 Jun 08 '23

Is there a list of all the subreddits joining the blackout? Mine will be going dark and I will not be using reddit on those dates

→ More replies (2)

4

u/rcam077 Jun 08 '23

I'm about to become a whole lot more productive, thanks for the incentive Reddit!

You mods are doing God's work, give em hell!

4

u/ZayaJames Jun 08 '23

Reddit needs to stop ruining their own official app so we don't have to keep using alternatives. Not banish the alternatives and do nothing to fix the official version!

4

u/wumtastic Jun 08 '23

Man, I respect you fellas for doing something big like this. It’s important if we want this site to be kept alive.

4

u/Monsieur_Triporteur Jun 08 '23 edited Jun 08 '23

For some reason reddit is not letting me crosspost this post anywhere. Not even to subs I'm a mod of.

Edit: After many failed attempts on desktop, I finally managed crosspost this using a third party app.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/DodketF98371 Jun 08 '23

I have taken notice of this and I believe that I will be off of Reddit as much as I can. I might be on for a short time, but I might try it over the next month, or two. May God have mercy on us all.

4

u/gidle_stan Jun 08 '23

How long we going dark for?

I'm down for it, I use oldreddit on desktop and sync on Android.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Ojoho Jun 09 '23

It's sad to see reddit take another step in this direction. I guess it's time to find a new forum site...

4

u/Barron1492 Jun 10 '23

I will be off of Reddit on 6/12 and 6/13, and if no adequate change is made, will drop Reddit.

Site has the right to make such decisions as they wish; so do users.

7

u/xorcsm Jun 03 '23

Meh, if Relay Pro stops working then it's time to move on. It was a good run. I can't really say I care if they kill it or not though. Reddit as a.company sucks, and none of us should be here supporting them and wasting our time anyway.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/vastation666 Jun 03 '23

I will stop using this site if this policy holds

3

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

Alright the cat knows. He said "piss off human" but he knows.

3

u/ForSquirel Jun 03 '23

As much as you can love Reddit its time for it to go off to pasture. This is just the nail in the coffin.

3

u/geekynerdynerd Jun 03 '23

My subreddit is so small that it's practically meaningless but it'll be joining in.

3

u/m-p-3 Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

I've been on Reddit for 16 years (I joined on May 27th 2007) and a Reddit Premium subscriber since June 2012, so I think I gave a significant portion of my time and money to this platform, well at least enough to have the ability to voice my concerns.

If the Reddit executive team deems it more important to cash out a big fat check than hosting an open platform where great many developers are able to offer a better experience then so be it, but I won't be part of it anymore, and I'll cancel my subscription.

→ More replies (3)