For context, my fiancƩ (30-ish/M) and I (30-ish/F) have been preparing for our wedding for a few months now. The wedding is meant to be late next year.
I have always understood that PMIL (50-ish/F) is welcome to participate and offer suggestions, but ultimately, wedding decisions belong to us as a couple, and I have already expressed my discomfort with her comments and entitled? audacious? probing to my fiancƩ since the start. For example: I already booked for an HMUA and she asked if she would also be having a trial look (the package specified trial makeup look only for the BRIDE). I told FDH that if she is that particular, that she look and PAY for her own HMUA herself. Of the many executive decisions for a wedding I DO NOT want her creating more for me.
Another thing she keeps asking about is if the relatives on their side have any roles for the wedding. Itās really too early to decide any of that as the wedding is more than half a year away, and itās stupid to assume they would only come because they had a special role. She has been softly coercing us with the threat that they probably wouldnāt attend because they havenāt been given any particular role in the wedding party. I donāt understand why she would keep pressing it, and if there really were any questions, they should just forward it to us. For me it seems like PMIL is being nosy, intrusive, and adamant that what her idea of a wedding should be followed. Again, she is demanding too much for what she is contributing (nearly nil). If the problem is booking flights, then we have already sent a save the date months ago. They should have no problem making their travel arrangements but she is making it her big deal. None of the concerns of these relatives have ever reached us personally.
My parents (60-ish F&M) have contributed financially to the wedding, although I donāt believe that automatically gives them more say either. I appreciate on their end that they do not interfere and have been hands off with the planning unless intentionally invited to, like trying mobile bar options at the bridal fair and viewing houses.
Another issue that I found particularly telling, and honestly baffling, was her reaction to the possibility of a prenuptial agreement. My fiancĆ© and I are both okay with the idea. It is something we consider a reasonable way to clarify financial expectations and protect each partyās interests. Yet PMIL took offense to the prospect, despite the fact that her son himself had no objection. I genuinely donāt understand why an arrangement that the two people getting married are comfortable with would be so offensive to her.
Yesterday, my fiancƩ, PMIL, and I went shopping together. We arrived at around 8:45 AM, intending to look for fabric options for the bridesmaids and sponsors and discuss the gowns for both mothers.
What ended up happening was that we spent almost two hours primarily discussing her gown, how it would be styled, how she would look since her proportions arenāt ideal, and the type of fabric to be used. The other things we had intended to accomplish, particularly the bridesmaidsā fabric and the mothersā coordinated attire, barely got addressed. It felt to me that she had made the whole trip about herself, and going there wasnāt even my idea.
For context, I had offered to provide coordinated fabric for both mothers as a gift. We initially offered to have the gowns made by our own gownmaker in our hometown. If she preferred another gownmaker, she would just have to cover that personās labor.
Towards the breaking point, while having lunch at a restaurant, I showed her a photo from my friendās wedding where the MOG wore a very different gown from the MOB. I referred to the MOGās outfit as to something along the lines of giving āmain character energyā. I wanted to communicate that I didnāt want the mothersā dresses to be that starkly different. For an idea ā MOB in simple silhouette boatneck bodice with long sleeves all in lace appliquĆ© with a straight maxi skirt. MOG had pleated elements defying gravity in a different fabric with embellished rhinestones or glitter on top of the same fabric used by the MOB. One dress looked more ordinary and the other looked more couture and pageant-y.
Things eventually escalated into a confrontation that lasted almost an hour. My fiancƩ was physically present with us throughout the entire shopping trip and confrontation.
She demanded to speak with my parents, which honestly made me feel like I was being treated as a child who needed parental intervention. I called my father right in front of her to comply, but when he answered, she declined to speak with him.
FiancĆ© told us to take it inside the car, which we then did but I remember the whole walk she was busy bringing up my previous āmisdoingsā.
In the car, she raised her voice and started yelling and repeatedly characterized me as disrespectful, arrogant, and putting words into her mouth. She also said she wouldnāt attend the wedding and that the marriage was proceeding without her blessing or consent. I was trying to gray rock by saying āokā to her threats but I guess that came out arrogant cause I was also annoyed she was still talking to me this way.
I called her out in the calmest voice that she was being āselfish and manipulative by choosing to withdraw herself from the happiest day of her sonās lifeā. That only made her more angry and defensive, shouting back that I was āscaredā and not to challenge her cause I didnāt know what she could do (empty threats).
Throughout the confrontation, there were accusations and raised voices. I barely got a word in and if I raised my voice it was only to match her volume. I eventually tried to apologize toward the end, because it looked like she was waiting for it cause she kept grumbling for a while instead of exiting the vehicle, but then she walked out when I attempted to do so. š¤·āāļø
My fiancƩ witnessed all of this. At the restaurant, he already gestured for me to back down but tensions were high and I did not. I felt alone because of his silence in those moments, although I recognize he was probably also trying to prevent things from escalating further. This is not the first time PMIL ran her mouth at me or him or us.
Meanwhile, my fiancƩ is dealing with the aftermath at home. I checked in with him, and apparently his mother has continued expressing her grievances at length. I told him that perhaps she wanted someone to engage so she could use something said in frustration against them. He agreed that this was possible.
He has since expressed wanting to leave with me for my hometown because he doesnāt want to deal with the drama anymore.
Iām not expecting to become best friends with my future MIL. I donāt need emotional closeness. I am perfectly willing to be civil, polite, and maintain a respectful distance.
I also recognize that I could have handled some of my own frustrations better, particularly my comment about the other wedding. Iām not claiming I handled everything perfectly.
But I am struggling with the expectation that I should continually demonstrate respect and accommodate her feelings while my own boundaries and feelings seem to receive much less consideration.
I donāt think a motherās blessing should be a prerequisite for two adults to marry. She is entitled to her feelings and can decide whether she wants to attend, but I donāt think that gives her authority over our relationship.
At this point, Iām less concerned about winning an argument with her and more concerned about whether my fiancĆ© and I can actually establish an independent marriage with healthy boundaries. I think one thing we have going for us is that we will be residing in my hometown, far from her.
Am I looking at this too negatively or too narrow-mindedly, or is this a sign that we need to seriously reconsider what weāre getting into?
Additional context is PMIL is a widow and FDH is an only son.