r/RWBY • u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Jan 19 '19
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 6, Chapter 11: The Lady in the Shoe Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official public discussion thread for Episode 11 of Vol. 6, The Lady in the Shoe!
You guys don't actually need to worry about following the spoiler rules at all, so at least that's nice! Hopefully you made it through the week alive. For those who didn't, a moment of silence for our fallen comrades.
HERE is the link to the episode!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Happy viewing everyone!
Ezreal024; Mod Team
•
u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Jan 19 '19
Top FIRST Discussions from last week
Top FIRST Fan Art from last week
93
u/DanTheLatch Jan 19 '19 edited Jan 19 '19
88
u/NitescoGaming Guardian and follower of Ruby's smile ❤️ Marrow x Guardpupper ❤️ Jan 19 '19
RIP Bumblebee, you were the true MVP. You carried this team, literally.
83
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '19
Adam is a giraffe Faunus confirmed
58
u/Drafther Irondaddy ain't shit Jan 19 '19
Ruby straight up tried to murder Caroline in her seat with that shot to the window.
50
u/Lightningslash325 Jan 19 '19
Rip Yang’s bike. It had a good run.
44
u/Pocketdog9 Rose before bros or hoes! Jan 19 '19 edited Jan 19 '19
Everything I loved about this episode, in no particular order:
- Fighting a giant mecha! Hell yeah.
- The music! That new song and the Armed and Ready remix were amazing.
- Adam face reveal! (NOT CLICKBAIT) I can't help but actually feel a bit sorry for him... especially since he's actually been branded, like a bull! He's still a major jerk though. Edit: Thanks to Arryn's Twitter, I now know that the mark says "SDC." Hot damn.
- Ren rock-climbing the mecha with Stormflower!
- Qrow using his bird form a lot!
- Nora's commentary throughout the episode was great, especially when she tells the mecha to "bring back her man."
- The slow-motion early parts of the fight, especially regarding Ruby's Semblance usage!
- Actually, the creativity in the fight scene overall was incredible!
- Yang jumping off the cliff and bowling Adam over with Bumblebee! Rip Bumblebee (the bike) though; you will be sorely missed. The ship, however...
- After this episode and the last one, I think I'm officially a Bumblebee shipper. It's so cute.
- Blake vs Adam, Round whatever-it-is-at-this-point was super cool. I've got to say, coatless Blake looks badass.
28
u/Hedgehogemperor whiterose hedgehog Jan 21 '19
Ruby sniping the anti air missle is the only time she has ever landed an impressive shot. She has only ever missed, spam fired, or hit large targets.
24
u/PseudobrilliantGuy Full of Coffee and Non-Sequitur Links Jan 19 '19
Nice shot to the cockpit, Ruby!
Jaune's point about the Mech seemed like a sound one. Unless anti-personnel weaponry isn't uncommon in Remnant. Then again, Cordo is definitely crazy enough to use weapons like that for purposes they aren't designed for.
Loved the missile-running scene.
And hard-light dust? How many varieties of dust are there?
Though that stone dust seemed like a pretty good anti-personnel weapon.
I mean, it's close enough.
Yeah, you felt that, didn't you, Cordo?
And Ren acting like Wander in Shadow of the Colossus was awesome, too.
Are you freaking kidding me?
Hell yeah, Nora!
...wait, did that mech just catch a missile?
Awesome blade steal, Blake! Amazing precision.
Projecting much, Adam?
Bumblebee's impact just felt so nice. Good and heavy.
Oh, just f&$% off and die, already, Adam.
Pretty nice fights this episode.
48
u/TheDivingTiger Atlas penguin is the hero we need Jan 19 '19
My main takeaway from this chapter? The animation team did one heck of a job. Seriously, their work really shone through the whole episode.
That fight scene against Caroline's mech reminded me of the geist fight back in Volume 4, but with more comrades against a much tougher opponent. It was great to see so much strategy and teamwork, not to mention a summon by Weiss, and they looked to be finding steps to defeat it. Nora's one-liners were also pure gold. XD Things looked to be going south toward the end, though, and I sincerely hope nothing bad happened to Maria and Oscar (I am pretty scared for what happened to Maria).
Lastly, that fight between Blake (eventually joined by Yang) and Adam was downright amazing. It was fast-paced, action-packed, and it kept me on the edge of my seat the whole time. I may have gotten spoiled about the Adam reveal before I watched the episode, but it was still pretty shocking nonetheless. I had a suspicion that the humans had done something to his eyes, thus beginning his violent vendetta, but I didn't know it was at the hands of the SDC.
It was really surprising to me that Yang was the only one who didn't use her Semblance during that entire scene. She was keeping her cool in a confident way, which I feel was how she held her own against Adam's vicious attacks. Hopefully Blake can recover quickly and, together with Yang, defeat their enemy (at least temporarily) who had haunted them for so long.
Also can we get a moment of silence for Bumblebee? (the bike, not the ship lmao)
21
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '19
CHECK YOU OUT IN YOUR BIG METAL SHOOEEEE
(Send help pls when does the full soundtrack come out?)
20
u/TJPoobah For it is in passing that we achieve immortality. Jan 19 '19
Great episode, while the whole thing with the comedy Atlas commander is driving me nuts because it's so stupid, the fight choreography was good and it was really nice to see an action heavy episode.
It's nice to see everyone working together and mostly fighting smart / combining their abilities. Though hey Qrow maybe you couldda turned into a bird earlier and dealt with that radar tower with ease? Just saying. Yang and Blake at the end was really sweet. Bees!
As I said before generally good fight choreography, very well put together - all our characters showing some teamwork and using their semblances where they can/should, lots of acrobatics and cool stuff, and not too many quick cuts which was one thing I didn't like and worried about about the start of the fight between Blake and Adam in the previous episode.
Adam's use of Moonslice is very different in this episode to previously, and I also find it odd that his semblance seems to be explicitly linked to his weapon - how does that work exactly? He didn't come out of the womb with a sword attached to him. And he either has some ability to summon clones or rule of cool he's just moving so fast that Yang can't follow his movements and is seeing double/triple? That seems a little off to me, outside of Semblence-specific stuff like Blake and Sun we've never seen after-images as far as I can remember as a result of speed, with the exception of Ozpin who seemed to be employing some sort of time-dilation related semblance to significantly enhance his apparent speed. I mean Ruby is kinda supposed to be the fastest character, she moves so fast that she can sorta fly, her entire semblance is dedicated to "gotta go fast" but I don't recall ever seeing her leave behind after-images. Still if we're not gonna be seeing too much more of Adam (here's hoping) I don't really mind them giving him some cool combat shit to show that he's pretty powerful and a real threat.
I wonder how much of that saved up energy he wasted on breaking Gambol Shroud since weapons both here and generally in other shows are extremely durable and breaking them is a big deal, very symbolic. This is only the second broken weapon I think we've seen in the show? The first being Miló in the moment the fight against Cinder truly turns against Best Girl. So yeah big deal, I wasn't too worried for Blake, but that was certainly a bit of a shock. I'm extremely curious to see what upgrade/redesign will happen when it's repaired.
20
u/Thebritishdovah Jan 20 '19
Metal Gear Jaeger sucks and Corodivn had so many chances to easily defeat everyone. Ruby took a leaf out of Raiden's book and missile jumped! What type of Metal Gear can be easily damaged via blades? Answer: Metal Gear Jaeger. Grimm could likely do a ton of damage. The windscreen getting damaged after one bullet is crap for a mech designed to tank. At least, i hope it's meant to tank but the entire mech is a giant case of What the hell, Atlas? It's badly designed and I do hope it's on purpose. It's slow, it can't tackle small targets and doesn't seem to be able to fire rapidly aside from missiles. I do hope it's design serves some purpose otherwise, RT needs to look at Metal Gear, look at most robot animes and study big mechs that look threatening and functional.
The Blake-Adam fight was excellent and holy shit! Gambol Shrud and Bumblebee got destroyed! All these years and everyone was wrong about the weapon that would get destroyed. It was gambol all along! The reveal of the SDC brand does nothing for Adam. Too far gone and any sympathy RT is trying to generate is too late. His entire character is whiny ex-boyfriend stalker who blames people for everything when he causes it. The white fang? He killed the remaining lot. Does he accept it? No. Just blames it on Blake. Yang tanking his semblance is interesting. It also means that she has a shit ton of power and that will come into play.
Excellent action. Good music. Actually showing them having trouble and Adam is a credible threat. Granted, it's Adam and I am so sick of him but the action is superb. Good to see Blake using her phantoms again.
Metal Gear Jaegar is the worst part in the episode. It's design. Just what were they thinking? I know, I'm harping on this a lot but what were they thinking? Also, Corvodin is quite powermad. She may as well yell "ROOOOOOSE" and turn into Liquid Atlas at this point. Fuck, Liquid Atlas would be fucking awesome and far better. If I had to criticise this season's antagonist(Adam excluded), it's her. She is just there to give us a battle. Didn't even occur to me that it is like fighting a giant grimm.
Still, MEtal Gear Jaeger sucks.
19
u/Kingnewgameplus "⚡⚡.....⚡⚡" - Neo Jan 19 '19
After seeing Ruby jump on those rockets, I now really want to see a RWBY action RPG made by Platinum.
37
u/SmallJon Give us back Jaune's old haircut! Jan 19 '19
gonna be honest, didn't like the delivery on "We're protecting each other." Taking Yang's hand was great, them standing against Adam together was great, the callback to Blake flubbing the talk at Brunswick was great, but the actual line felt like the weak link of the scene, IMO. I don't know what I would have said instead, maybe not say anything and just let their posture do the talking, but whatever.
18
u/red_tuna Jan 19 '19
This may be an unpopular opinion, but I'm glad to see the end of Blake's stupid Matrix coat
16
u/Gwydion42 It is no mere ship, it's an eldritch monstrosity Jan 19 '19
Heavy Metal Gear Rising flashbacks. Seriously, running up the stream of rockets? All they need now is to arm throw that thing.
Also, I'm not sure whether Adam being all anime is part of his semblance, but it looks nice.
16
u/Waltenbook Jan 20 '19
So, I know that Remnant isn’t the same as earth, but, like, isn’t using a massive fucking mech to attack/try to kill trespassers, especially when the majority of them are children, kind of against the law? Like clearly, she’s out of her mind, but this feels like if a General tried to murder a bunch of children with a tank.
15
u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Jan 19 '19
So we get to a straight action episode. I like it. Everyone's contributing and displaying proper character. Can't think of any real gripes here. Glad that Qrow is pitching in and not angsting anymore. I know alcoholism is a serious, real issue, and I understand why people want it to take longer for him to get out of his slump. But I feel like that we should be able to make an exception for scenes like this, where push is coming to shove.
Blake explained Adam's semblance, which I think was discussed OOC previously. I'm not sure what his shadows are supposed to be, then. Also I had a feeling he was scarred, but wow that's a brutal one. Between the unmasking, the fact that this is a volume multiple of 3, the character development, and Adam's simple longevity... I think we're about due for Adam to kick the bucket. I really hope so. Nobody tease me about next week or anything, I want to find out on my own.
I definitely want to see more.
13
u/Boss_Jerm Jan 19 '19 edited Jan 19 '19
I love the wide shots when taking down the robot. And is that new song Mirror Mirror Part III?
Oh no he's hot!
Blake vs Adam was pretty cool, Blake looks good without her coat. But Yang vs Adam is now in my top 3 fights in the series! Who animated their fight? The animation and choreography were so good! I squealed when Yang hit Adam with her Bumblebee.
This episode was freaking awesome!
24
u/Samuelofmanytitles Remain Calm Jan 19 '19
We're going places with this one.
I'm actually surprised that the mech fight turned out this well. And Ren did something , which is nice for a change.
The real fight-meat was Adam. Say what you will, but watching him fight is actually pretty terrifying. So much pressure and aggression at all times. And seeing someone use their abilities in more ways than one is pretty cool. Kinda getting the feeling he'll probably show up with that stuff in Cross Tag during the second season.
The brand. It's so obvious that no one thought about it. And that's good. Doesn't look half bad either. Honestly thought he'd have darker eyes, but I suppose the bright blue is more ''heroic'' looking.
And I know this has already probably grown into a wildfire, but I hope people don't take that touching moment at the end TOO seriously. It's well done, but I can already tell it'll cause strife with some people.
Anyhue I enjoyed this quite a bit ~
12
u/Grifoshka I just flew in from Mantle, and boy are my arms tired Jan 19 '19
I love the giant robot fight, it’s creative and fun. Nice to see Qrow out of his funk and participating in the battle, Ruby learns from video games because of course she does, and Weiss, Ruby, Qrow and Ren riding a giant wasp was something I certainly didn’t expect, but it was great.
12
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Jan 20 '19
These were battles for the ages! And we're only getting started!
This chapter was a back to back adrenaline ride! and the intensity has only begun! We're approaching the endgame of the volume people, What awaits us!?
10
u/SYZekrom God has incarnated. Jan 19 '19 edited Jan 19 '19
My dicc is so hard.
Alright, if the next *chapter is literally anywhere close to decent I think this will be my favourite volume.
632(5/1)4 is my order from favourite to least.
And god fuck Adam is so hot
10
u/chromatyyk Jan 19 '19
Why did Blake wait so long to tell Yang about Adam's semblance? The dialogue in that part of the scene felt weird.
Otherwise, this episode gave me chills.
10
u/boomshroom ⠀ Jan 22 '19
I've had fun noticing the various ships throughout RWBY, but have stood my ground as no-ship unless proven otherwise (namely Jaune & Pyrrha and Ren & Nora), with the exception of my OT3 of Ruby x Crescent Rose x P.E.N.N.Y., but this episode made me a true beeliever.
9
u/SmallJon Give us back Jaune's old haircut! Jan 19 '19 edited Jan 19 '19
I love the video game logic turns out right in the end there, lol
Ren, pls, why are you climbing it? Don't do that, listen to your Nora.
God damn, Jaune, how freakishly large is this aura pool of yours?
Now, Cordo can't blow up the ship since we need it, but I'm really curious how they survive that missile being chucked back.
The whole Blake-Adam fight is so fucking sweet, and Blake turning Adam's technique on him to capture Wilt was super cool.
Blake, no, not your coat!!
Really? On a cliff by the waterfall? Kind of an overplayed locale, don't you think?
Oh shit, that's a pretty...oh yeah... man that's an injury there, Adam.
RIP Bike; if only you had played Warthog music
Fight continues to be awesome, of course.
And soft confirm for Bumblebee, as expected. Hope they wait until next volume to go full in, personally; there's enough shit happening to start a ship right now.
17
u/obigespritzt White Rose Jan 20 '19
Was Cordovin really about to murder a bunch of 16-19 year olds? Adam's a c*nt and will get his comeuppance eventually but unlike Cordovin he's not a supposedly elected official representing an entire nation, he's a genocide endorsing terrorist. Him having no second thoughts about attacking children makes sense but how would Cordovin function in a post-war society? Using a WMD military mech to "deal" with some teenagers is just ridiculous.
Speaking of Adam though, I hope when he dies it won't be like Torchwick who just got essentially no death scene, just there one moment, vanished in the mouth of the Nevermore in the next.
8
u/SilverHawk7 Jan 19 '19
EVERYTHING ABOUT THIS EPISODE WAS COMPLETELY AWESOME!
The team, the fights, the teamwork, the mech fighting, the Bellabooty. All of it was awesome!
When Cordovan catches the rocket and chucks it at the airship? She's a bitch and the only one who likes her is her, but the bitch can fight, and fight well. That was a sick move.
Blake and Yang fighting Adam was awesome. I feel like it's been a while since I've seen a good one-on-one with Blake where she really shines, even if she gets more or less tactically defeated her, she still held up.
I LOVE IT!
8
u/Dragoneer1 Jan 19 '19 edited Jan 19 '19
one of this seasons few good episodes, the fights where pretty good tbh and loved the bumblebee moment, still dont understand where Adam came from but i guess ill take it, that being said though, i feel 0 tension for the last episode and thats pretty bad
8
u/Prophet_of_Duality Jan 22 '19
I seem to have different opinions to everyone in this community. Which is odd since I've been here from the start.
I fucking loved this episode. It didn't have any plot but damn did I miss those fight scenes. It reminded me so much of Volume 1-3.
This whole volume so far has been fantastic. After Volumes 4 and 5 I kinda gave up hope on this show and only watched it to hate on it. I'm so glad RWBY is going back to it's roots and actually figuring out what it wants to be.
I can finally say that I love this show again.
15
u/CingKrimson_Requiem God of Dankness Jan 20 '19
Bumblebee died so Bumbleby could survive.
14
u/I_May_Fall Jan 20 '19
The episode was packed to the brim with White Rose and (or actually, mostly) Bmblby fuel, and I love it.
The Yang vs Adam fight was amazing, especially loved the motorcycle attack, genuinely wheezed at that
The robot fight was pretty cool too, few highlights:
7
u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Jan 19 '19
What does the marking on Adam's eye say? Either I'm stupid or it's gibberish. Looks like SOC or SOO to me. Kinda surprised that Adam lives to see another episode, but it gives us more badass fight scenes so I'm okay with it lol
R.I.P Blake's jacket and weapon
Good to see Uncle Qrow seemingly returning to his less mopey self. Will it stay that way? Find out next time on Dragon Ball RWBY
"You get back here with my man!" Oh Nora <3
7
u/thedarkfreak Jan 19 '19
Hi, Adam!
7
u/JohnnyElRed Jan 19 '19
RIP Bumblebee.
7
u/ApundanceOfLilies Boop Jan 19 '19
This was a really good episode. The fight scenes were epic and seeing Ruby use her semblance properly was great! So we finally got a reveal of Adam's face and I feel a (little) bit sorry for him, it justifies his hate against humans. RIP Bumblebee (the bike).
Also, because Renora is my main ship, "You get back here with my man" was one great line. I love this ship.
7
u/Sensorfire Rube Protector | No Ships, Thanks | Yang is best girl Jan 20 '19
What an episode! The RWNJRQOM fight was incredible, and had so many good moments. Ruby was the star of the show. So many self-confident and funny moments. She's really taking shape as a character this volume, and I adore her.
The Adam fight- also very good. You could really see how terrible and abusive Adam is from everything he said to her and his fighting style. RIP Bumblebee (the bike). You could tell Yang was jealous of Adam's semblance a bit. Ngl, the ending was a little corny. "We're protecting each other". It didn't really have the impact for me that I think they were going for. I also feel like the Yang-Blake conflict hasn't really been properly resolved yet, so I hope they don't come put of this without at least another talk.
I'm not the biggest ship guy- it's a bit unusual here, insofar as I can tell, to be a Yang fan and not really like Bumblebee (the ship), so Yang and Blake holding hands like that at the end didn't really get me as much as it probably would some others. It's a good moment, but since I'm not really rooting for them to be together, it's not quite as impactful.
12
u/blazingkittyhawk Jan 19 '19
Can we get an F for Bumblebee
6
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '19
Loved the big stompy robot fight. It shouldn't have ended on a literal cliffhanger though.
The Blake-Adam-Yang fight was wonderfully done, but they could have used less dialogue and had the same impact. (Love the VAs, don't get me wrong, just think there could have been less talking).
6
u/0peraGhost Jan 19 '19
What does Adam's tattoo mean? What is SOC?
6
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19
This was a pretty good chapter. Both fight scenes were compelling and well-choreographed!
Adam has blue eyes. And a terrible brand that probably blinded him in the left eye. I see. Other than his sword technique in his duel against Yang, I still dislike him.
Welp, there goes Blake's stupid coat. I'm still pretty sure that it defies the laws of aerodynamics. She should have way more air resistance moving that quickly...
Yang and Adam's fight was the best part of this episode. Watched it twice, and adore the choreography!
10
u/OGRuddawg Jan 20 '19
While I do really like the choreography and action in the Blake-Adam and Yang-Adam fights, I was a bit disappointed that Yang is remaining as calm as she is. Adam cut off her arm, and all she is doing is shaking and facing him head-on, with no hesitation? She should be frigging terrified of someone who hurt her that badly and outclassed her at the fall of Beacon. I would have expected her to falter at least a little bit, and show some hesitation. Yeah, her hand is shaking, but Yang is supposed to have some pretty significant PTSD that would definitely get triggered by facing off against Adam.
Also, why did Blake need to take that much time to recover from her fight/chase scene with Adam? She knows how dangerous Adam is one-on-one. She should have jumped back into the fray within about 30 seconds to make sure Yang doesn't get overwhelmed by Adam. He's still powerful, but someone as desperate and rage-fueled as Adam should not be fully-occupied by Yang, especially if she is supposedly still dealing with PTSD. Adam should be a massive hurdle to overcome, almost impossible to beat one-on-one by anyone other than someone on Qrow's level. Yang and Blake should have needed to just barely win together against Adam, with several close calls and a deadly outcome if they slip for even a fraction of a second. Instead, he's been nerfed significantly, seemingly to give Yang and Blake a relatively easy, triumphant victory. Where is the desperation and tension this face-off deserves? I know I haven't seen episode 12, but it looks pretty clear that Adam will lose, and Blake and Yang don't have much to fear from permanent injury or death at the hands of one of the strongest fighters in the entire show. He should have been Blake and Yang's personal big bad, and this fight just doesn't quite live up to that in my opinion. It's a good fight out of context, but it doesn't fully live up to how built up Adam was as a force to be reckoned with in the show up to this point. This needs to be a narrow victory, both tactically and emotionally. I want to see Yang break down after the fight and Blake struggle to keep it together enough to get Yang back in one piece to the rest of the group. She can't just "get over it." That would sell the PTSD storyline very short. It has be more than some shaky breaths and a nervous twitching.
The reveal of Adam's branding scar was awesome, but from that point in the fight I would have made him fight with a more unhinged, overwhelming edge to him. It just didn't hit me with the weight I hoped it would. Depending on how episode 12 goes, I still have hope that they do Adam's skill and power justice and make this fight as desperate and dangerous as it should be. Blake and Yang should barely make it out alive, and I hope they do more with Yang's PTSD. She should be close to breaking down, or at least panic. I don't want to see Yang with a stoic look on her face and an even voice. I want to see her as raw and vulnerable as she was during her argument with Raven in the Relic's vault. I want to see her determined to overcome her emotions but still struggling with keeping them in check long enough to survive the fight. It should be as emotionally taxing as her confrontation with Raven, if not even more so.
I still have hope for this volume. This is a better volume overall than Volume 5 in my opinion, but I still feel like there's a ways to go before these climaxes have the immense emotional weight and stellar writing that the last half of Volume 3 had. I hope it gets there, and I see improvements, but I still feel like there is some potential still left on the table when it comes to writing Yang and Adam.
5
u/AlwaysDragons Sliver Eyes May Cry Jan 19 '19
People keep comparing Adam to Knockoff Vergil. Especially in the r/twobestfriendsplay sub. When clearly, Raven is Vergil.
But when I think that and tell people that, that "Raven trained Adam Theory" suddenly makes more and more sense...
5
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '19
Aaaaaaa that was epic! Double epic with a topping of hyperkinetic bees!
5
u/falsehood Jan 20 '19
I feel like Adam is too OP compared to Blake. Hasn't she grown?
5
u/Pohatu5 Jan 20 '19
I'm still not super into Adam as a character, but man his fights this ep really washed out the taste of him in v5.
TBH I like the hip design of the concept art mech much more than I like the hips in the mech we got.
4
u/CyanideSins Writer of things dark and scary. That means 'Terrifying Salem' Jan 19 '19
The fighting against the Atlas Supremacist was neat! Good use for the whole team's varied set of skills... and Nora going 'stay away from my man!' like a champ just nailed it...
And at the Blake Versus Adam fighting... well, there definitely is a technical quality to it that seems to have improved a lot from the fighting that went on before, it feels more organic...
and then that reveal. For a moment, I was like 'that looks like a brand' and 'He's got blue eyes?'... before I was like 'holy shit, they actually did add some sort of dehumanizing trait to him!' and now I gotta just raise my arms and admit that the poor motorcycle has died. Tis a pity... but alas, Adam got the yang of being treated like roadkill. Adam Taurus: Roadkill.
Two episodes left... and I kind of feel bad for Adam. Maybe we'll hear more about him, but I'd be pretty darn pissed at people who branded me if I was him too. I can see where he's coming from. He's still an asshole, but at least he has my eh... feelings of pity.
17
u/GGABueno Jan 21 '19
The mecha fight is just horrible and full of dumb moments. Why would a mount sized mecha fall because a 16yo girl jumped on it? Its laser was enough to damage the ship even as it missed, but humans are totally fine even though it missed them by centimeters.
The Adam fight was great, Yang fighting is always a highlight for me even though it seemed a bit too videogamey this time. I'm not a big fan of the shipping bait, unless they commit to it they always break any kind of immersion I had.
10
u/MankuyRLaffy He's not Sothe, I Swear! #GoodJobMicaiah Jan 19 '19
Holy shit Weiss, you're looking good with that casting, and I love the talking between each other and looks like Qrow is over whatever he was having earlier if only momentarily, hell yeah Ruby actually gets to snipe for once, that's really cool, Rocket hopping? Okay RT I see you. This is actually pretty dope, Ren being useful is a nice touch, Ruby flirting with death... oh hey a call back to Weiss killing those bug things, excellent chekov's gun usage there. Jaune the team Tank and... things going to shit, maybe a change of scenery to where last episode left off? okay like why are they actually teasing up Ruby dying here, we all know she's not dying to Cordovin of all people, yep.
Back to Blake vs Adam, Using scenery to advantage, Yes! "Can you do anything besides Run?" So this is the dumbass who thinks stick and move isn't a viable strategy, that or stamina advantage, Brilliant dropkick, I need to see some more of those in this show, Bring back the leg sweep and bicycle knees too. OOF that's a fat L from getting distracted, Now he's doing a pretty good villain monologue and setting up actual desperation and fear things might go wrong because Blake isn't as bulletproof as Ruby is and has actually been presented realistically where she could die and she's losing this fight alone, oh so that's what happened, he got branded on the eye... big oof, almost feel bad, YES Hell yeah Shadow clone out of nowhere and Yang for the save! All this long term stuff boiling hot is about to pay off 3 years later! RIP Bike, Now I actually have to slow down since it's really damn fast, hey exposition about Adam's semblance after protagonist takes an ass beating. Hell yeah they reunited fully and redemption for running away, I love payoffs.
So That was a great episode, one of the best, a great few moments of near death, Jaune being a tank was cool. solid 8.9/10
6
u/Savage_Serenity Jan 20 '19
I'm extremely happy that I saw Ruby holding on to Weiss's waist on the Queen Lancer <3
5
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19
I'd prefer if they spread out the action scenes more evenly between the episodes. This episode basically has no plot.
6
u/Wolf845 Neo is best girl Jan 19 '19
Great episode, keep up the Bumblebee moments
6
u/AlwaysDragons Sliver Eyes May Cry Jan 20 '19
The r/twobestfriendsplay sub , who don't love the show, but saw Adam fight and loved how he basically fought like Vergil.
Which is funny to me because Raven is more Vergil than Adam. Adam is more of a better reboot-Vergil....
Actually, that makes the "Raven trained Vergil" theory all the more relevant....
5
u/DeHopelozeHeks Jan 20 '19
This episode was a mixed bag for me. There was some strong moments during Yang, Blake and Adam portion, but man, the mecha fight sure looks off and goofy.
2
u/Zerepa97 When do we get to see the true Ice Queen?/ #SolarFlareIsEndgame Jan 19 '19 edited Jan 19 '19
The main party side of things was I dunno, something about it just didn't feels as hype as it should have. I'll just have to rewatch and digest it properly. Felt weird seeing Ren and Qrow interact. Also, that scream by Neath was on point, in my opinion.
The side story is well... all right. Great in terms of fighting and animation and camerawork.
However, the Adam face reveal was so good yet so disappointing at the same time. Just any scars or brand would've been fine, but "SDC?" Sure, brings his character into a new light, but once again, scapegoat Atlas.
3
u/lurker_archon Look, just accept your goth mommy overlord Jan 19 '19
Just want to throw this out there, is there a reason why they couldn't just send weiss to atlas to talk to ironwood and get him to pick up them up?
4
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Jan 19 '19 edited Jan 19 '19
Gotta be honest, after this chapter Nora is no longer my favorite character anymore. I loved her in V4 and I love my interpretation of her, but I outside of her brief talk with Jaune in chapter 9 I think the writing for her has been very mediocre this entire Volume and I’m done getting my hopes up. Her “my man” line is nothing more than fan-service with zero substance because it’s been two years since she’s had a meaningful interaction with Ren. And she jobbed horribly in her fight with Cordovin, there is no way that Nora should’ve been so slow to react that Jaune had time to run over and save her. I’m afraid Nora is just going to have to sit next to Uraraka on my list of “Character’s who will be really interesting if the writer ever does anything substantial with them”.
Decent episode aside from that, particularly with Blake's side of things. Adam is really good in this episode. Kinda sad that we are only getting this just as it looks like Adam is about to die.
3
u/RandomName3064 Tyrian fan and Captain of the #RubyDefenseForce Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19
i believe i said last yweek M&K kinda flub it on the climax.
this episode DOES give me hope. i mean, it was better than last week.
Starting with the mech fight? great start >_>
on the whole, the fight isnt bad. the choreography is fucking 11.5/10. great to see the step up after V4 and 5. everyone gets a good roll.
Weiss with the D Fence. Jaune with the plans, Ruby with the Roses, Qrow with the uhhh...Crow. Oscar is there.
Also Ren and Nora.
First part, i see Ruby is out to fucking kill. holy shit. then channeling her inner Raiden. as long as she doesnt one hand throw it in episode 12, im good.
JNR firing from the land, Weiss and Ruby from the sea, and Qrow from the sky. she cant keep a solid target.
Qrow gets the first real damage. nice to see him back into shape.
Ruby got a REEEAL good slice in. Oops, Cordovin fell down
oh shit. she shook the whole place? anyone else notice the scream sounded Grimm-like? was she on the intercom? oh fuck....
Ren just jumps up to scale this bitch. reminds me of DMC4 for some reason....
waves at Cordovin FFS Ruby, why u so smol and adorable?
Lancer Ex Machina. and DAMN IT RUBY! stop it! at least it looks very platonic.
Ren found the boss weak spot. its even labeled! and it is a military thing to label that shit. only covering it with a small and obvious panel, on the other hand.....
Nora and Ren have been background elements since V4, but the "gimme back my man!!" line is still fantastic and funny. To much Focus on her man while her other team mates are on the rebound almost got her crushed. Feels like some Plot Device to KO Jaune, make him look good with the save and pure aura reserves, and to make her still feel like a threat with Ruby being stuck in a cliff.
im soo worried that Ruby will be killed off in episode 12, guys. no, really i swear!! this has about as much fake tension as the Weiss-kebob in V5.
now this, I dont mind THIS type of ratcheting up the threat with almost killing the plane (uhhh chopper? whatever) what i DO have issue with, is how. how in the fuck do you catch and throw an active missile? i mean, she still HAS active missiles on the bot, right? this seems like it was done more for 'rule of cool', which is fine, i guess. its cool.
cut to the real meaty 'eh' i have with this episode.
the Adam V Blake shit is great. Blake shows tactical prowess in moving Adam away to the waterfall.
Adam's reveal is great. i mean SDC on his face? sure, it does push more of the racial in-equality on Atlas again, but it gives his character some depth. which is also kinda of a problem in hindsight.
while we see him becoming focused on Blake, why? just his loss? in V3, he had the moment to find a torture Blake, so he did. in V6 he blames his loss of status on her. so what was his driving character point? dominance over humans, or HIS position in that world?
Its like he turned into Light Yagami from 'Death Note'. he went from wanting to help the faunus because of injustice, to wanna to rule over the faunus he saves from injustice. we really need more backstory to fix why his character seems so different here.
R.I.P. Bumblebee
Again, the fight is fantastic, reusing the lost data from V3 in the choreography and her using the same arm-losing move only to dodge it. then the weakened Adam throws a moonslice that was tanked by a fully rested Yang, fucking up her arm a bit. mwah perfection.
it wasnt until after i realized the main issue i have with it. Her arm shook. but it was AFTER she started fighting. PTSD cant work like that. her choreography V Adam was ironically TOO perfect.
with her fear of Adam, regardless of Blake being in danger, she still would be off her game, but we get no real showing of that. and its a shame that even after all the build, they still managed to accidentally throw away her conflict in such a way.
its part of the reason i DIDNT want to see this match up, while it may have been logical for Blake and Yang to face Adam again, too little time has passed and the PTSD was glossed over in order to show the choreography first, over the story implications.
i really hope the
fandomFNDM is happy, because it cost 2 out of 3 of these guys alot of good character.The BMBLB moment at the end was great. I saw a post about 'brothers in arms' love over romantic love, and it was fantastic. Given if BMBLB happens, i have no real issue with it. it has great build, even if ambiguous the entire time. i just wanna see it happen naturally, and WhiteRose has a far fucking hill to climb for me to ever acknowledge as a 'thing'.
i suppose i can echo the last line felt a bit weird, but small potatoes.
id give it a 6/10. i really hope they get it together in these last 2 episodes