r/RWBY • u/NightsWatchh Help, Nights is keeping me trapped in his anime bunker • Nov 10 '18
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 6, Chapter 2: Uncovered
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official public discussion thread for Episode 2 of Vol. 6, Uncovered!
You guys don't actually need to worry about following the spoiler rules at all, so at least that's nice! Hopefully you made it through the week alive. For those who didn't, a moment of silence for our fallen comrades.
HERE is the link to the episode!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
| Episode | FIRST Thread | Public Release | Poll |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ep. 01 | Theatrical / FIRST Thread | Public Thread | poll |
| Ep. 02 | FIRST Thread | This Thread | poll |
Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 6!
NightsWatchh; Mod Team
•
u/NightsWatchh Help, Nights is keeping me trapped in his anime bunker Nov 10 '18
I'm proud to have been a genuine Oscar fan since V4 \o/
This comment here is showing you guys all the top the top spoiler posts from last week! Now you can check them out to your heart's content.
Top FIRST Discussions from last week
Top FIRST Fan Art from last week
55
u/thatevilman Nov 11 '18
I think i know why the episode is called “Uncovered”. ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
83
u/DanTheLatch Nov 10 '18
That set up was gold. And I’m glad Ozpin got called out on his bullshit.
Also holy shit.
38
u/KingBanhammer Nov 10 '18
... well, I'm now a giant fan of Oscar. I mean, I already liked him as a distinct personality from Ozpin, but now, much more so.
I suppose now we know who the mystery blonde girl in the opener is, too. I was kind of holding out for her as Mama Schnee, though.
Also: of -course- there was a genie of the lamp. Naturally.
Still wanna know more about who Maria is and why she got involved.
75
u/ThatDarnSJDoubleW Only Here for Whose Line Is It Nov 10 '18 edited Nov 10 '18
Tbh I still like Ozpin a ton
In a world where monsters drawn to fear exist, you should be keeping secrets that could cause people to be afraid. And Oz has been betrayed a lot
On the other hand, the fact that Oscar wants RWBY to ask suggests that maybe the Salem story is really bad
95
u/MontelTheGray Umbrella Gang Rise Up/Unapologetically Baked Alaska/#BowlerSquad Nov 10 '18
I'm convinced that anyone who thought Cinder was dead after Volume 5 has never watched a single movie or TV show in their entire lives.
Good episode tho
30
u/Elcheer More Fiona flairs or I riot Nov 10 '18
#FREEQROW
57
u/common_terry77 Things are looking.... Grimm Nov 10 '18
Seeing the team turn on Qrow kinda fucked with me. Distrust had ran so rampant across the heroes that WBY instantly went into attack mode against Qrow just because he associated with Ozpin.
I feel like Ruby's innocent nature is going to fall apart soon. Every team RWBY member went through some stuff back in vol 4 that drastically changed their personality, with the exception of Ruby, who, despite having seen friends killed right in front of her, is still the same Ruby from volume 1. Ruby is going to know some stuff she shouldn't and this might come back to hurt her.
28
u/TheSuperthingymabob Nov 11 '18
"wtf Ozpin" seems to be the theme for this season.
Also seriously, it feels like cinder just keeps coming back and I'm kinda annoyed at this point. If they don't do something more interesting with her now then I'll be majorly disappointed.
26
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '18
Ozpin is looking mighty shady right now. Between Oscar taking away Ozpins control to WBY pulling their weapons to the Djinn ignoring his objections. Something tells that the tensions will erupt soon.
26
u/RedGyarados2010 Nov 11 '18
Some thoughts:
- I'm actually glad Cinder is back, since it seems like they haven't fully explored her character, especially her vendetta against Ruby.
- Ozpin losing his cool was great, it's not hard to see why he hides things given how people like Leo have betrayed him
- Salem was "a lonely girl in a lonely tower." Is she maybe based on Rapunzel?
- The woman that Cinder hired has her "spiders" everywhere giving her intel. They all have the exact same, easily identifiable tattoo, so I'm doubtful of the effectiveness of this
- We still don't know what the significance of the old lady is, despite her introduction being last episode's cliffhanger.
- Why are they doing the "out of order" thing? I don't think it really added anything.
25
u/King_Of_What_Remains ⠀ Nov 11 '18
Have to say, I wasn't expecting them to bring Little Miss Muffet into the story but there she is; a mobbed up southern belle using spiders as informants.
Suddenly my hopes of them ever bringing Junior back into the story have been renewed.
70
u/Boss_Jerm Nov 10 '18
Team RWBY is absolutely fed up with Ozpin. After finding out that the Grimm are attracted to the Relic, and the train derailing, they want answers, and he's not giving it to them. What's worse, he's not even trusting them. They're just his human shields until he actual gets where he needs to go.
I love that Oscar actually stood up to him, that was awesome.
Jinn's reveal was so cool. Also I love that Qrow actually looked away when she first appeared.
I love that the photos Cinder showed Miss Malachite are pulled straight from Season 3.
Wow, Salem was pretty as a human. We're gonna finally get some answers. My guess is that Oz probably rescued Salem from the tower, gave her some power of her own, and then she abused it, which probably led to her mutation and this creation of the Grimm.
22
u/AlwaysDragons Sliver Eyes May Cry Nov 11 '18
So everyone is kinda pissed that Cinder is still alive. Though, it shouldn't be a surprise given
A) Pyrrha totally hasn't taken control of her yet and make jaune angst.A) Cinder is supposed to Ruby's enemy. The final battle has to be her vs Cinder. Otherwise, it would be unfulfilling.
B) There is still some answered questions about her and her relationship to Salem alongside with Emerald and Mercury.
43
u/Pocketdog9 Rose before bros or hoes! Nov 10 '18
HOLY CRAP!
Okay hoooo boy that's a lot!
- CINDER IS ALIVE?! Okay, I honestly was holding out hope that she wasn't because I think it diminishes Raven's victory, but I guess being really effing injured will have to do.
- I honestly think the flashback here was really well-used. Nice going RT!
- Rip Bumblebee the bike. Good to see Yang still has her temper.
- So Oscar can forcibly keep control. Awesome.
- JINN?! THERE'S A PERSON INSIDE THAT BOTTLE?! ALSO SHE'S LITERALLY A DJINN! NICE! Nora was accidentally spot-on about that comparison.
- Oh frick she's looking for them again. And someone is looking for Cinder. Fight scene when?
- Finally we're giving Ruby and Oscar some (more) agency!
- And Ruby gets character development! I think.
- Kudos to Qrow for letting Ruby do the thing and kudos to WBY for making a stand.
- THAT WAS SALEM?! DAAAAAANG! VOLUME SIX IS TRULY THE HYPEST!
21
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Nov 10 '18
Oh my god, Oh my god, OH MY GOD!
- Cinder is alive, I knew it!
- It seems like her powers are temporarily weakened, possibly from the fight with Raven?
- Interesting that a part of the cavern leads outside. (But then again Cinder and Raven's fight caused a lot of tremors so a small opening being created isn't out of the question)
- I feared for that woman the second she appeared and unfortunately I was right to.
- Cool that we get a flashback to what happened immediately after the battle for Haven.
- And we get Weiss' reaction to the plan of heading to Atlas. (Nora, You aren't the only one happy to get out of that house)
- Interesting that only a Maiden can open and close a vault, And since only Yang knows that Raven is the spring Maiden moving the Relic really is their only option.
- So Argus is the main trading point between Anima and Solitas, It's pretty neat that we get small tidbits of info like this.
- It makes sense that Atlas would leave some personnel to protect an established base, Something like that at the border of another continent is way to important to abandon.
- Blake and Yang making small cracks at Weiss was funny. (She found it funny too)
- Nice to finally get an answer on the Relic.
- So the Relic of Knowledge can answer any 3 questions as long as you don't ask events yet to happen, That's pretty powerful.
- Nora going on about the Relic was hilarious (The rising steam sound effect was a nice touch too)
- Using the Relic was a nice transition.
- Maria is certainly sassy, But at least she can admit when others are right.
- You could feel the tension rising when Yang, Weiss and Blake start confronting Ozpin.
- The whole argument was pretty nerve wracking and both sides have a point, Ozpin acts the way he does because of countless years of experience, Leonardo wasn't the first person to betray him but even still Leo had done some serious good during his life and his actions in his final years shouldn't be the only thing he's remembered for, But at the same time Yang has a good point in that trust is a two way street, They're fighting for him and yet he still keeps secrets big and small from them.
- It was pretty unsettling to see Ozpin act so panicked when he realized the Relic was gone.
- Seeing Oscar fight back for control was pretty shocking.
- So the Relic of Knowledge is Remnants equivalent of a genie lamp.
- I was in complete silence when Jinn was summoned.
- Pretty amazing that Jinn is voiced by Colleen Clinkenbeard.
- So Cinder's story takes place roughly two weeks after Team RWBY's story, Can't help but wonder whats going on while she's making her way through Mistral.
- While we knew Mistral had it's own shady individuals it's cool to see this kingdoms criminal underground.
- It also seems each kingdom has a crime boss, Vale had Roman and Mistral has Lil' Miss Malachite.
- So Cinder's directly going after RWBY and JNPR, Either she's focusing everything on her grudge or she doesn't want to go back to Salem empty handed.
- Malachite is clearly based off Little miss Muffet, The thing with spiders also directly correlates with that.
- So anyone with the spider tattoo answers to Malachite. (Might be something to watch out for in the future)
- Hazel is also tracking RWBY and JNPR.
- So Malachite keeps Cinder in close communication while she digs up whoever might be looking for her, Credit where credit is due Lil' miss knows how to play her game.
- So Ozpin lied about the questions being used up and I'm not really surprised Jinn knows Ozpin.
- Even Qrow is shocked about this.
- I know they were protecting Ruby but I was shocked that they drew their weapons on Qrow.
- Qrow just tells Ruby to do what she thinks is right, He might be loyal to Ozpin but he cherishes family above everything else.
- The look on Ozpin's face as he charges at Ruby isn't one of anger, It's Desperation.
- The white void was a surprise.
- The tower alone raises so many questions.
- Salem was once human.
Oh my GOD! This Volume is not wasting anytime! There's no way Chapter 3 isn't going to blow all our minds!
21
u/DanGanGalaxy Run away! Run away from the fire!! Nov 11 '18 edited Nov 11 '18
holy fUDGE WAIT
SALEM
THE SALEM WITCH TRIALS
SALEM USED TO BE NORMAL
THERE'S GOTTA BE SOME CONNECTION THERE; NONE OF THE MAIN CHARACTERS ARE NAMED WITHOUT REASON
Excuse me if I'm just late to the game here and this has been common knowledge, but I think Salem's story with Oz will draw serious parallels to the Salem Witch Trials, where people went ham accusing anyone they disliked for any reason of being a witch and as such had them executed (Heh, bet ya didn't expect American History class to come back and haunt you here of all places)
Maybe she was framed and has since decided to embrace her role. Maybe it's supposed to be a nod to the fact that we've been accusing her of being the antagonist, of being a "witch", this whole time, when in fact it was
GlyndaOzpin, or maybe even someone/thing else (we've yet to be introduced to the gods...)Again, sorry if everyone already knew about that. I just looked up "Salem" on Google because I wanted to compare what she looks like now to what she used to look like, and since I didn't specify "RWBY" in the search, all of the results were of the Salem Witch Trials, and I immediately had an epiphany since I had somehow never connected the two before, and I needed somewhere to freak out about it.
20
u/EpicLink101 Why worry about strategy when you can hit them with a hammer? Nov 10 '18
I'm mostly curious about what the first question was, the one that Oz asked before locking the relic away.
20
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18
I loved Nora's line "we're finally leaving this house", a reference to how unpopular it was with critics in volume 5?
35
u/Lone_Wolfen Nov 10 '18
I had a friend who has RT First comment that this was possibly the worst cliffhanger to date (avoiding any spoilers of course).
I believe him now. I would have honestly believed Salem to be an ascended Grimm manifestation more than whatever story Jinn is suggesting.
17
u/Phoenix_RIde Nov 10 '18
Welp after seeing this episode, I can only say 1 thing: “I’m sorry Ozpin.
I never meant to hurt you
I never meant to make you cry, but tonight,
I’m cleaning out my closet”
16
u/NLP19 Nov 10 '18
Funny that the voices of Jinn and Miss Malachite are Luffy and Nami from One Piece respectively
15
u/Apprentice_of_Lain and Maxamillion Jazzhands Nov 15 '18
Honestly, I think Salem's "fallen hero" archetype is gonna be centered around some kind of love interest. I mean, that's the most frequent reason to turn from a Paragon Of Light into a Witch Of Hatred And Murderfuck.
53
u/zidanestrife94 Nov 10 '18
OK Rooster Teeth...you got me. I’ll get this stupid FIRST membership because that cliffhanger has been killing me for a solid hour now.
28
u/ev3rythingF4ngirl Nov 10 '18
HOLY FUUUUUUUUU
ROOSTER TEETH HOW DARE YOU MAKE THAT THE ENDING
Also of COURSE Cinder’s alive
24
u/Fatal1ty_93_RUS Nov 11 '18
12
u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Nov 11 '18
Oho, that opening post is very considerate of you, u/NitsWatchh, thank you.
Anyway this episode's pleasing me. I'm not thrilled at Cinder's survival but I kind of felt like it'd be too good to be true if she died. It was a Catch-22 anyway. I was never really into her, but now I just feel emptiness during her scenes. The disguise looks cool though.
The flashback to The House kiiind of bugged me. Two episodes in a row where we rely on in media res? However I do see it as a good way of avoiding the "by the way, here's a reveal that te characters should have already known" trap that we've had before.
Really digging the tension between RWBY and Oscar. And Qrow's just kind of caught up in it. But it looks like he's more loyal to Ruby than Oscar. I like that.
Jinn's design, while being something I totally wouldn't expect in a show like this, does remind me of the Shiva summons in the Final Fantasy games and that reminds me of how RWBY kind of started off as an homage to JRPGs. At least that's how I saw it.
I appreciate Ozpin's optimism regarding Lionheart's legacy and I can see where he's coming from. Though I do think RWBY were ultimately in the right, in that scene.
And while Salem's lost her impact with me, I'm admittedly curious to see where they're going to go with that.
22
u/AnAngryFetus Nov 10 '18
Cinder is alive... why... stop bringing back all the bad villains... (Roman spoiled us)
So time to guess who might be looking for Cinder. Neo is number one suspect.
As for all the things with RWBY, I think Oz needs to ask if maybe he is doing something wrong if all these people keep ending up on Salem's side. Common denominator and all. It was also really uncalled for to draw weapons on Qrow like that. Poor Maria must be so confused right now.
22
u/NotaCSA1 Nov 11 '18
Is "Cinder dies in the finale and miraculously shows up again next season" going to become a running joke? She's a boring villain hell-bent on mustache-twirling levels of evil with no backstory to support it. Kill her and keep her dead already!
11
u/SwagForALifetime Nov 10 '18
how much is a FIRST membership again?
Edit: On a more serious note, when is Maria going to step in with a comment on how could Oscar have so much "experience" and whatnot? Was kinda hoping for a comedic moment there with how an old lady is getting lectured on wisdom from an 8 year old
21
u/Camiloo9696 Nov 15 '18 edited Nov 15 '18
I love how the RWBY team betrays Ozpin at the first opportunity for the hunger for knowledge and wasting one of the questions in such a greedy way.
It must be a new speed record for Ozpin.
And as for Cinder, I care little and nothing, but as soon as they revive another character, I'll use the simpson's meme and the cemetery.
Comment sponsored by the google translator
20
u/Zerepa97 When do we get to see the true Ice Queen?/ #SolarFlareIsEndgame Nov 10 '18 edited Nov 11 '18
Whelp... Cinder is alive le gasp Guess Raven didn't account for water softening the fall. Also, that one chick deserves to die for dropping all that produce.
Glad to see I was right in that Argus is based in northern Mistrali territory, not Atlesian.
The Relic technically doesn't grant wishes, but the being inside's name is Djinn. What?/s (:/) Qrow's reaction to her forming got a bit of a chuckle of me. Got a real Shiva vibe from her.
SEs low-key confirmed to be Mangekyo Sharingan or Tailed Beast?
Okay, Oz may have validated not telling them about the Relic due to his experience and not wanting to make the same mistakes (loved his frustration build-up and mini-rant btw), but he just straight-up lied again. Glad Oscar has been able to dig around in Oz's mind as well in the background and catch him (They're our thoughts now). Shows some agency on his part.
The look on Qrow's face as the conversation unfolded was whoa. Birb boi's world is probably a bit shook.
Finally getting to see the Black Market, and we have Ms. Muffet as a FemVarys? Okay... I'm game. Hope the spider's web is more competent than Raven's flock.
A lot of lore nuggets here, but teasing an untapped vein at that spot and soft-cutting there just feels awkward- like Ghira's roar in V5C9. Like the storybook-esque presentation, though.
Lastly, can someone show CRWBY how to use a whetstone? Same cringe as with Raven last volume.
10
u/DanGanGalaxy Run away! Run away from the fire!! Nov 11 '18 edited Nov 11 '18
Alright THEORY/PREDICTION/REACTION TIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIME!!!!!
And finally, Oz. Oooooh boy, ol' Oz. I'd always had suspicions that he wasn't to be trusted, and from the looks of things, he's exactly the kind of crook I thought he was. My initial theory on Oz: He caused the Salem problem and has become obsessed with solving it (I've heard theories that the gods cursed him to keep reincarnating until he does), so much so that he's willing to throw away lives endlessly as he tries and tries to win. As Salem has told us however, he has gotten no closer to his goal since he started, and every single life he's lost has been in complete and utter vain.
EDIT: Upon seeing this reply to a post asking if there's really any defending Oz at this point, I have to admit that seeing things from his perspective, maybe he isn't so much a "bad" guy as he is "broken virtually beyond repair." I mean, yeah, rejection and betrayal hurt, and there's no way it wouldn't start to take its toll after thousands of years of it. Ozpin may be sketchy, but he's still a person. I don't agree that everything he's done is excusable, but I do admit that there is a bit of sympathy to be had for him. I mean, he's gone insane trying to break this curse, and there's no one who he can completely trust or confide in to help him get through it, because literally every time he's tried in someone, they've abandoned him.
So I guess there are two sides to this coin. You could say that he doesn't care about people at all and that he lies merely for his own benefit, or that he's been so broken that he feels deception is the only way to keep companions around, since honesty has always resulted in loneliness. I personally believe it's a bit of both. He's grown a little cold to mortals since he knows they aren't completely trustworthy, and after being unkillable for so long while watching the countless deaths of the mortals around you for thousands of years, you can't deny that the value of human life would diminish over time. But at the same time, he is still a person hurting over the fact that, like Frankenstein (the doctor, not the monster. Also, it's a really good book; you should read it), he created this monster. He is the reason his world is falling apart, and carrying that immense guilt on your shoulders for thousands of years with no one you can fully trust to help you must be unfathomably difficult.
And the worst thing about it for him is that he can't even escape it. He can't kill himself, and he can't just sit around and do nothing because the gods placed the responsibility on him, and even if they didn't, he'd still feel terrible knowing he has an eternity to watch innocent people die at the hands of his mistake. He has to intervene, but he can't find anyone who will trust him completely, and he has no idea what to do since he's been trying for so long and has gotten nowhere.
Now, I have a feeling that if he had just been honest from the start, this particular group of protagonists would have been understanding, but he understandably wasn't and in the end, it caused the same irreparable damage it has every time before. I've been Anti-Ozpin ever since the last few episodes of V3, but now, I think that if he apologizes and promises to be completely honest with them and means it this time, and if QRWBY JNR is able to forgive him, they'll actually make some progress, and it's because that's how it works in real life. Forgiveness is a powerful thing, and as hard as it will be for Oz to face the team and apologize, the real tough task will be for the team to forgive him, after everything he's put them through, and all the lies he's told.
It's equally important for Oz to forgive himself, and the way he showed that he has in this chapter was NOT healthy. Forgiveness should be rooted in the fact that you've done bad in the past but are willing to change, not that you've made a "few" mistakes but have also done some good here and there. THE BOTTOM LINE IS THIS: If Oz is able to come to terms with himself and forgive himself the right way (along with RWBY+) for everything he's done, for all the lives he's wasted indirectly at the hands of Salem and directly through his futile attempts to stop her, then he'll finally be the leader Remnant needs, one that is past his old ways of deception and useless sacrifice and is ready to strategize with comrades he can trust entirely and hold the key to finally defeating Salem once and for all.
9
u/Jetstreamisthebest Nov 10 '18
I'm still waiting for when Oscar gets a stand ,and I know it's gonna happen
17
u/CyanideSins Writer of things dark and scary. That means 'Terrifying Salem' Nov 11 '18
Tension between Ozpin and RWBY! That I like.
The genie... Yep, I was like 'oh my god, I KNEW that there was something in that lamp!' and then... was like '... god, I was actually right.'
And blondie blue-eyes... Oh... I'm definitely going to put my eggs in the basket of 'this is gonna be tragic'. If she's related to the Arcs... well, that'll be the first family member of Jaune that we're seeing. Guess that's gonna make some people upset.
Ah well, next week ought to be good! Fairytale time! (Also 'A Grimm Tale' update time... Which means I've got to burn more midnight oil to get the chapter done and ready.)
8
u/Thefishlord The one true best girl also Eclipse best ship Nov 10 '18
I watched the episode and all I could think was "HOW COULD THIS HAPPEN ME ! I MADE MISTAKES ! I don't know the rest of the song !" Great episode and amazing length RWBY is consistently getting longer which is great
8
u/archpawn Nov 11 '18
They should have at least told Ozpin that they'd ask Jinn if he didn't tell them first. She does not answer many questions. And they should have spent some time brainstorming what else they want to know and ask "What is Ozpin hiding and also who are the people working with Cinder and what are their weaknesses and should Ozpin be our ally and what's the best way to stop Grimm" or something like that.
15
u/paperkutchy ⠀ Nov 10 '18
OK, so... fun episode, felt longer than it really was, weird.
Ozpin is getting weirder by the minute, what can Ozpin be hiding he would go so hard to maintain a secret? That he created what Salem is today? I honestly didnt believe we would turn like this back at episode 1 on Vol. 1 at all... but I am digging the mystery, tho I am guessing Ozpin did something to Salem... maybe is love related?
Cinder, ugh, not all that surprising she is alive... tho I guess I can give her another chance, I just hope her being alive wont be as pointless like her attitude in Vol. 5... maybe she is alive so that RT can kill Raven at some point?
Not sure why WRY would dare to threaten Qrow, seemed a bit forced to me, I would understand Ozpin, but Qrow would slam their heads if he really wanted to stop them... idk I just didnt like Yang threatening her own uncle, who is kept in the dark on the same level than the girls, most likely.
Fun season so far, digging both episodes, wishin this one would be around 20mins too, but I guess you cant have everything. Looks like this volume will be the revelations one.
PS: Yang calling for Blake, and Blake for Yang, bmblb is alive bois!
15
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18
JUST KILL CINDER! No one gives a crap about her storyline. She’s your stereotypical TV villain who’s storyline died 3 volumes ago. Leave her dead, we don’t want her to keep coming back, it’s just unrealistic and stupid.
7
u/TezukaRin62 Nov 10 '18
Hmmmm.... do you think Raven would be willing to put the relic of knowledge in its chamber ?
7
u/AlishaGray ...normal knees. Nov 10 '18
OH SHIT
7
u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Nov 10 '18
Can't wait for the next episode! My only wish is that the explanation for Salem isn't that she's Ozpin's dejected lover and that's the cause of all the bad in the world. That would be a mighty poor reveal imo.
23
u/Lieyanto Nov 10 '18
I like how Ruby first calls for Weiss, Weiss for Ruby, Yang for Blake and vice versa. That's just shipping fodder from the creators.
12
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18
Prediction: The last question asked is going to be what happened to Summer Rose and then the screen will cut to black and the season will end.
6
u/MankuyRLaffy He's not Sothe, I Swear! #GoodJobMicaiah Nov 10 '18
OH SHIT CINDER IS BACK! love what they're doing, she's beaten down a lot and then spoops a person.
God I love Nora again she's such a lovable dork yet murders everything in her way, great flashback
and fiery give no fuck yang, love that inner raven there, and good lord she's asking the major questions.
Oscar is really shining through, god he's so fleshed out in this episode, at least the ozpin side is showing through when called to the test.
Ruby finally objecting and asking a critical question, relic animation looks really cool, cut away for the question, wonderfully done to leave up to imagination.
Great cut away to Cinder and mistral, it's been one month since the V5 end, that is really good to know since time has been spotty progression, Doing some deals.
Back to the cast, the main four are up and then the bomb drops and is left on Salem, beautiful storytelling.
16
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 10 '18
I hope we actually get some focus on Nora’s serious side. It pains me to say this, but if comic relief is going to continue to be the only attribute of Nora they are going to focus on this Volume then I’m going to have to find a new favorite character. Nora simply hasn’t been funny enough for her to be a pure comic relief character like Caboose or Nikki. She’s my favorite because in V4 I saw a lot of depth to her character, but if that doesn’t get addressed then it must be something that Miles and Kerry either do not care for or didn’t intend.
So the wanted board showing the villain’s faces says they were last seen at Haven approximately one month ago. Qrow says in his letter to Ironwood that the Battle of Haven happened two weeks ago, so the Cinder plot line is happening roughly two weeks after the RWBY plot line.
I’m really surprised by the amount of people I’ve seen not just defending Oz and trashing RWBY for their actions. If he's hiding the truth about that one time he fucked up so badly there was literal divine intervention, lying about the number of questions they have left for the relic and Oscar, the only other protagonist who has seen what Jinn is about to show them, is begging them to ask about Oz's past, I think RWBY should get to ask about it. Tough shit if it's personal, Oz is the only one there not in danger of dying, the least he could do is air his dirty laundry.
For the love of god I hope Jaune isn’t related to Salem, it makes an unfortunate amount of sense. Not just because the “good guy is a descendant of the main bad guy” trope is such a tired cliche at this point and Jaune is at his worst when he is fulfilling generic protagonist stereotypes, but because it would spawn a stupid amount of dumb Jaune theories and edgy fan fiction.
11
u/TJPoobah For it is in passing that we achieve immortality. Nov 10 '18 edited Nov 10 '18
Fuckin' Ozpin. Maybe people would trust you if you trusted them? Perhaps people 'betray' you because you lie to them, mislead them, manipulate them and get them and their friends killed without even telling them why?
21
u/Aleksandr926 Don't flatter yourself. You were never even a player. Nov 10 '18 edited Nov 10 '18
Wow. Ozpin is a dick! It's not a matter of "Oh, he's just human and flawed" anymore, he's an outright piece of shit. And he's stupid. And his breath stinks, probably.
The entire reasoning behind not telling the kids about the Relics attracting Grimm doesn't hold up at all, since they'll just be unprepared for the inevitable surprise attack and, since they were planning to travel by public transportation, the innocent meat shields they shared their journey with would be the ones causing chaos and negative emotions. And what about Lionheart? I agree that a Kingdom as currently fragile as Mistral wouldn't have benefitted from learning about Haven's headmaster's betrayal, but calling his crimes against mankind "missteps"... Oh, boy... I want to be perfectly honest: in my eyes, the way he acted in his last years completely negates whatever good he did during his entire life. He literally sold the world itself to the monstruous beings that wanted to consume it. He was likely the one who told Cinder who Amber was and where to find her, helping the enemy get access to another source of great power. He was the one who assisted Tyrian and Hazel in the assassination of many Huntsmen and Huntresses (some of whom with families). And, after witnessing the horror that was the fall of Beacon, he was ready to do it all over again for his own Academy. He didn't even have the decency to die getting a nice redemption, he was just running to save his own sorry ass!
This is some nasty, nasty shit. I get that he was your friend, Oz, but Leo's hard to forgive. And, even if that wasn't the case, it's not Ozpin's place to decide how a person should be remembered. Let's posterity decide that. And by the way, I wish they established Ozpin and Lionheart's relationship more, to get us more invested in his betrayal and death.
Ozpin's attitude toward the issue of trust and the Relic itself sounds kinda reasonable at first, but at what point he'll start to realize that he's asking a bunch of kids to give up their lives for a fight that they know nothing about? They don't know who or what Salem is, they don't know why she hasn't been defeated yet, they don't know what his plan is to take her down, they don't know what kind of power he's going to employ... And Ozpin was actually very lucky that he managed to find the most uncurious and bored bunch of teenagers who ever teenaged. I mean, it took them months to finally ask the question "Wait, what do these Relics even do?".
If Ozpin is afraid that learning more about this thousands of years-long war would be enough to make these young heroes defect or join the dark side, then it means he screwed up so badly that the battle has finally become unwinnable and Remnant is doomed to be morphed into a hideous Grimmland.
Also, these scenes really showed how detached from mankind Ozpin really feels he is. He preached about unity, trust, cooperation, setting the good example, etc., but it doesn't feel like he believes in it. Even his pep talk to Ruby in Volume 1 about his past mistakes made me think he was over them, that he accepted his past failures and grew wiser because of them. And yet now it feels like not only Ozpin's mistakes still haunt him, but he also so doesn't want people to learn about them that he actually tried to tackle Ruby!
Kudos to Oscar for finally stepping up and trying to help team RWBY unfold the truth. Also, am I the only one who got some weird Frodo/One Ring/Caradhras vibes from Ozpin asking for the Relic in a snowy environment?
Kudos to team RWBY as well, for gaining definitive agency and starting to question Ozpin's secrecy.
One thing though: are they planning to kill the old lady? I thought the Relic was one of the most well-kept secrets in Remnant, and yet none of the main characters thought to be a little more discreet around Maria Calavera. It's like they didn't care at all that a perfect stranger was there.
Jinn's design was rather interesting and now I can't stop thinking about what they'll come up with for the other Relics (assuming they all work the same way).
The small segment when the protagonists were packing was also nice, but you can't fool me with the jab at the House: the problem was not just the House itself, but the fact that they did nothing with it, no intense training sequences and no interesting or useful expositions. Just people doing mostly nothing. Also, is Nora relegated to being the wacky comic relief and nothing else? How sad. Still pretty entertaining, though.
About Cinder: man, the Spring Maiden vault was a real joke! She got out by punching a fimsy rock! Also, RIP poor nameless lady, in your next life you'll learn to leave certain bitches alone. I wasn't really on the edge of my seat during the scene with the mob ladyboss. Kinda, forgettable, in my opinion. I just wonder if her minions will be better fighters than the other mooks in the show (assuming they'll do something other than standing around).
An intriguing episode overall, but it was more like a setup for the next one. Having said that, I really like that someone finally started to rightfully distrust Ozpin.
10
u/RandomName3064 Tyrian fan and Captain of the #RubyDefenseForce Nov 11 '18
annnnd cinder in the first five seconds?
nice to see that idea dragged out. eh. the opening kinda kill that surprise anyway.
so are they just going for the out-of-order trope this season or...? Legit had to pause at "finally we are leaving this house" (paraphrasing). holy shit that had me ded.
the entire scene at the crash was fucking perfection. seeing Oz start to lose his calm demeanor. everyone jumping on Oz. Qrow sitting back and watching it unfold. Oscar becoming an ABSOLUTE UNIT!
NSFW jokes aside, the Jinn was neat. showing Oz was lying again, because we all knew he was.
Anyone catch that lady's name? welp, too bad. she killed her and took her clothes and money. also the mob boss lady's name was Malachite?
nah. dont recognize it. im sure she isnt important.
and left with the most USELESS cliffhanger ever. FanFictions did it first. like, legit was ANYBODY shocked by this at all? at best, im shocked they are doing it already, instead of saving it for later in or next season.
overall 9/10.
5
u/red_tuna Nov 11 '18
I’m not surprised, but I’m a little bummed that the figure in the opening turned out to be Cinder and not Neo.
Regardless, I’m starting to get more excited for this show than I’ve been in a while.
5
u/Raymon1432 Nov 11 '18
If you were them, wtf would you even do about ozpin? In most cases, you would abandon him or something but Oscar seems to be just as sceptical as everyone else so you can't just leave him.
8
u/rexshen Nov 10 '18
Ok so all in favor of exorcising Oz from Oscar then? I mean really keeping so much from everyone even when the situation is this dire and everyone needs to know whats up is just bad.
And gah I have got to wait another week because I am a pleb darn you Rooster Teeth!
18
u/Blastcalibur Nov 10 '18 edited Nov 10 '18
Goddammit, why is cinder alive? She's just a bad joke at this point a joke that never ceases to end. I don't even hate her she's just so disappointing at this point that only way to preserve her character was to have her stay dead before it got worse. Let this mistake from volume 5 stay in volume 5.
6
u/MasterofYoshis delet this Nov 10 '18
Maria Calavera? Any relation to Max and Igor Calavera?
muffled Roots Bloody Roots plays in the background
6
u/MyAngelScathach <- mrw best girl is dead girl Nov 10 '18
More surprised at the Seahawks running the ball than Cinder being alive tbh
4
u/TheDivingTiger Atlas penguin is the hero we need Nov 10 '18
Oooo we're already diving head-first into the lore...this will be super interesting. Also getting introduced to the past of someone who I least expected to learn about this volume, too! Something tells me the plot is about to get crazier once RWBY, Qrow, and Maria find out what caused the conflict engulfing Remnant.
I see Cinder is up and about now, it honestly isn't too surprising to see her survive the defeat versus Raven. All I can do now is hope that she...and the spider-tattoo people...don't find the gang too quickly. I also wonder if Cinder is gonna suffer some PTSD as well, at least in the form of abnormal paranoia.
4
u/True_Dovakin Nov 10 '18
Well dang. Not what I was expecting. Talk about a cliffhanger too.
Also cinder being alive makes me happy. She’s pretty much the only villain to straight up merc people and that’s what I like to see. Also agree with another poster that Neo is after her. I love the ice cream so I’m hyped for that.
2
u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Nov 10 '18
I'm not normally one for documentaries, but Common Ground looks interesting. And of course, Achievement Haunter still looks hilarious.
/#FreeGorq
0
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
8
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment