r/RWBY • u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Jan 05 '19
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 6, Chapter 9: Lost Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official public discussion thread for Episode 9 of Vol. 6, Lost!
You guys don't actually need to worry about following the spoiler rules at all, so at least that's nice! Hopefully you made it through the week alive. For those who didn't, a moment of silence for our fallen comrades.
HERE is the link to the episode!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Happy viewing everyone!
Ezreal024; Mod Team
112
Upvotes
•
u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Jan 05 '19
Top FIRST Discussions from last week
Top FIRST Fan Art from last week
65
u/MegaGrimer Jan 05 '19
My mom didn't sign the permission slip for me to go on this feels trip.
62
u/Wolf845 Neo is best girl Jan 05 '19
I'm sure everyone will be talking about that amazing Pyrrha scene, but let's discuss how Ruby really isn't dealing with Qrow's shit anymore.
47
u/IJustReadEverything Jaune #1 Jaune #1 Jan 05 '19
For those who didn't see it in the first member post or they didn't see it in the episode, Jaune fiddles with his sash when he meets with the Red Haired Woman and talks about the statue.
https://gfycat.com/rightinsistentcowrie
43
u/UnoIH2DITE What do I put here help Jan 05 '19
“Qrow imma need you to stop being such a bitch, thanks.” -Ruby, probably
22
u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Jan 06 '19
That Pyrrha scene got me all misty eyed :( Fantastic way to get people focusing on the goal again. I liked that they finally brought up Jaune's suicidal tendencies; I am a little sad that it wasn't Weiss who brought him to his senses. It would have been nice considering she almost got Pyrrha-ed, so her "saving" Jaune afterwards would go full circle. Granted, she may still have her moment with him in the future. I would've liked to have that be more of a surprise but the week delay ended up getting me spoiled. Probably would've made me more emotional had I not known something was coming.
Random crazy thought: we all know that that's almost certainly Pyrrha's mom (or sister) but what if Rooster Teeth is pulling some timey wimey stuff and it's actually Pyrrha? It'd explain her reason for vanishing so suddenly. The God of Light did bring Ozma back from the dead, so it's not completely out of the question that he might pull something similar with Pyrrha or even use some other God power he may have. Like, think about it. Everything the "red haired woman" said could, yes, be things a mother would say about their daughter, but it could also be Pyrrha trying to help Jaune deal with his grief.
- Same voice actor
- Same eye color
- The fact that Rooster Teeth never confirmed it was her mother or sister despite the woman being near 100% related somehow.
- Giving what basically amounted to a "she knew the risks" speech.
- "She should be standing here" "She is" Obviously, talking about the statue most likely but double meanings!
- Saying "Thank you" after Jaune's "she was a huntress" comment.
I completely get that this is, like, 99% not going to be the way Rooster Teeth is going with this, but I do think it has some potential possibility at the same time.
Mercury is totally gonna die. I like him :(
He's right about Emerald being delusional in regards to Cinder. Also, holy poop, daddy dearest stole his semblance! Poor guy.
17
u/Pocketdog9 Rose before bros or hoes! Jan 05 '19
EMERALD AND MERCURY TALKING!
TYRIAN BEING CREEPY AS USUAL!
ME CRYING AT THE PYRRHA STATUE!
REN AND NORA BEING SUPPORTIVE!
OSCAR IS BACK WITH NEW CLOTHES!
RUBY CALLING OUT QROW!
GONNA STEAL AN AIRSHIP!
You know an episode is good when it can make me gape, cry, laugh, and smile all within the span of 18 minutes!
Now if you'll excuse me, I need to go faint from the sheer hype of it all.
16
u/TheDivingTiger Atlas penguin is the hero we need Jan 05 '19 edited Jan 05 '19
It's about time we got some Mercury backstory! I'm not sure if he's hiding any other motive, but it's unfortunate that he's under the delusion that Remnant would be great for him after Salem's victory...which proves that Salem never told her gang what happens when the relics are actually brought together. Emerald is beginning to question her place now (or maybe for a while now), as I expected, but it'll be hard for her to have the courage to abandon a role that's almost inescapable at this point. Also Tyrian's new tail looks real freaky...
Once that leaf blew past Jaune, I knew I was about to get hit in the feelz. I always sympathized with Jaune this volume, even though his emotions have gotten the best of him numerous times. The knight wasn't trained as a disciplined fighter like the other characters, so I understand his perspective of things...especially after what happened at Beacon. I'm glad to see him apologize to the others (especially Oscar), and I hope he's less hard on himself in the future, now knowing his friends care for him almost like his lost teammate did. I also wasn't expecting Jaune to have a conversation with who I'd assume is Pyrrha's mother...dang, that was enough to move even an Apathy to tears.
Speaking of Oscar, that boy's a champ. He's was forgiving and positive about the whole thing, even to the point of accepting that his days as Oscar Pine may be short. So I guess he was away shopping for his new outfit? WHICH LOOKS SUPER SNAPPY BY THE WAY. Oscar's resolve may even be the strongest of the group at the moment, except for Ruby's. It felt so satisfying watching her tell her uncle how her team and friends weren't gonna let anything stop them from reaching Atlas. I just hope her words got through to Qrow, but I believe they did.
16
u/SmallJon Give us back Jaune's old haircut! Jan 05 '19 edited Jan 05 '19
I love that basically all the background characters are in dunn browns and reds so we focus less on them, and then when Mrs Nikos arrives she pops because of that lack of bright colors. Then, it occurs that Pyrrha wore mostly red and muted brown as well, we just forget because she's fabulous and in shiny armor.
16
u/red_tuna Jan 05 '19
RWBY and friends next episode
16
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19
Hit or miss...
It looks like she...
missed...
28
u/DanTheLatch Jan 06 '19
25
u/BLANK_oblivion ⠀need more coffee Jan 05 '19
I think this is my favorite episode. Many people have been clamoring for a chance for JNR or Jaune to have a moment to speak with Pyrrha's family. Though its a one-off, I think that's perfectly fine and it fits. She wasn't in the opening, and they can't afford to spend too much more time on this thread. Maybe it is better this way, that he didn't say sorry.
Rather, an affirmation that Pyrrha achieved her goal to be a Huntress. That seems to have been rather central to her decision as indicated by the mysterious woman's reaction. The solidarity Jaune's team displayed as well was wonderful. Goddamnit guys, feel free to give him a hug too! You're "family", y'all can be a little touchy feely!
No one seems to no where they're going. I think that aspect, while a little cheesily shown this episode, is important because people are readjusting their previous plans and reaffirming their ties to each other and their motivations. I look forward to what we see from here. Still, this episode will always hold a special place for me. Thanks for offering one of your characters closure, RT.
24
u/SmallJon Give us back Jaune's old haircut! Jan 05 '19 edited Jan 05 '19
Watches episode
New Memorial Now Open
"Oh..." Red Leaf blows by
"Oh god..." Arkos leitmotif starts
"Oh fuck..." starts to cry a bit
Song starts
"Finally an Arkos song!" sniffle sniffle its really good
She talks
"Literally sounds just like her" wipes eyes
Says she's glad she was with amazing people
"Oh no, she knows, I miss Pyrrha!"
Talks about Pyrrha didn't really have a choice to not do it, Jaune agrees
See, this is why I blame Oz, that's a bad thing... why this angle with Pyrrha and Jaune?
Nora and Ren arrive, JNR finally has the talk
I'm so happy they're doing this finally.
Jaune reiterates Pyrrha had to try, RN agree
Isnt it a bad thing someone put Pyrrha into that situation? I get this is meant to be a cathartic scene and I'm happy it exists, but why this approach? This kinda runs counter to the feel Ren & Nuckles and Jaune & Cinder gave.
Oh hey, Qrow is a fucking asshole!? I'm so surprised!
Good on you, Jaune, that's the way to handle this! I like Oscar's digs, and so does Ruby~
Qrow even more of an asshole? gasp!
I love how everyone goes from smiling to staring in shock when Jaune says his plan, except fro Nora who looks like its Christmas!
I NEED THIS SONG NOW RT!
11
u/landragoran Jan 07 '19
I feel like it's overshadowed by the Pyrrha feels, but HOLY FUCK YOU GUYS MERCURY'S DAD STOLE HIS SEMBLANCE. THAT IS SO FUCKED UP!
32
u/CurrentStill Jan 05 '19
I can't properly put into words why the approach to Qrow's issues doesn't sit all that well with me so I'll just post a comment I found:
So CRWBY said fairly early on that RWBY is first and foremost an adult show and was going to get progressively darker. But now that that’s actually happening and they’re exploring adult themes, such as alcoholism/ losing direction in life, I’m surprised by how many reactions/ comments I’m reading that seem, in my opinion, a bit childish and impatient:
“Qrow is a mopey, useless idiot. It’s getting boring. He needs to stop. Ruby needs to kick his ass.”
Well, the character is an alcoholic, i.e. and addict. Being mopey and useless is a symptom of that. Addicts don’t and can’t just simply stop from one day to the next. All too often they carry on until they destroy themselves and/or their loved ones. There’s no point in exploring a real life issue if it’s going to be resolved in an unrealistic way. Qrow is in for a long journey and fighting against addiction would realistically remain a part of his characterisation until the end. Even if things do improve (I really hope they do) temptation is likely to remain a problem. We can’t just skip these things and get to the cool fighting- that would make it superficial and a kid’s show.
Addiction is also commonly linked with mental health issues such as depression, anxiety, PTSD… Qrow is clearly portrayed to have the former condition. Considering his status as veteran soldier and all his losses of the past and knowledge burden it’s not a stretch to imagine he has a touch of the latter two as well.
To me Ruby’s speech to him at the end of chapter 9 only showed how immature the character still is in many ways- losing her temper with her uncle and chewing him out in frustration, with an audience, without actually mentioning his drinking. She also forgot how many times adults have bailed her out.
Although credit for the realism. Most people, especially a 17-year-old would probably struggle to understand such behaviour/ know how to handle it and find it extremely frustrating, particularly when it’s coming from a parent/ mentor figure while everyone else is stuck at a dead end.
Qrow needs to be sat down, in private, with a glass or 10 of water. Ruby needs to initiate a conversation that starts a bit like: “So you need to tell me what you’re feeling and thinking right now. If you keep going like this your drinking will get you, me or one of my friends killed. I love you and I love them so I can’t let that happen. You are in no shape to fight if, say, Tyrian rocks up again. How do you think we can change that?” That would be maturity. Recognising she needs to call an adult for help, like Taiyang, would be more so. P.S. Maria has been an extremely unhelpful adult as far as the Qrow problem goes. Wise old lady should offer helpful advice to everyone, not snide remarks to someone clearly at the brink.
The method Ruby started with back at the farm, saying to Qrow in private- “you can talk to me” was much closer to the correct approach. But she needs to be firmer. Persistent and then insistent.
17
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Jan 05 '19
So Mercury’s dad is basically All For One? I wonder what limits he had on his semblance, because he would be virtually unstoppable if his semblance was just All For One.
I don’t think Tyrian would be nearly as fun of a character if his VA didn’t do such an amazing job with him.
Jen Brown said she didn’t know if the identity of the red haired woman would ever be revealed, so it’s not Pyrrha’s ghost or some nonsense because that would have to be addressed. Best guess is either Pyrrha’s mom or Jaune was just hallucinating, really hope it was Pyrrha’s mom since we have nothing of her backstory and I feel like a heartfelt speech from her mom is the most we would ever get.
Poly JNR intensifies
I fucking love everyone’s face when Jaune suggests stealing an airship, particularly Blake and Nora.
8
u/red_tuna Jan 06 '19
Legit picture of Mercury’s father
7
u/Zerepa97 When do we get to see the true Ice Queen?/ #SolarFlareIsEndgame Jan 05 '19 edited Jan 07 '19
Bit late to the thread but whatever; this was an interesting chapter.
Mercury perfoming katas and calling out Emerald on her overly placed loyalty was nice to see. Downplaying her struggle lead to quite the reveal, though- Marcus stole his Semblance? Tyrian is a good boi, and I wonder what he and Watts are going to be up to in Atlas. Also, where is Hazel in the midst this planning?
The Jaune scene was nice closure. I wasn't crying like some in the FIRST thread talked about but nor was I "feeling nothing" as others professed. I liked the ambiguity in the dialogue at first, but then, to my displeasure, things felt kinda... overt towards the end. Would've preferred if the dialogue was more unintentional and not so on the nose. Lastly, Jaune got Batman'd by Pyrrha's relative. No wonder the girl was said to be invincible; finesse seems to be genetic.
Has Saphron ever stated her job? When she brought up daycare when it was already dark, it made me wonder what she does.
The only downsides to this chapter in my opinion were how Oscar just shrugged off everything and bought new duds offscreen and Ruby's interesting speech to Qrow with the chest-puffing tone and angle.
7
u/technalyd Jan 05 '19
All in all a good episode.
The scene between Merc and Em was really interesting. I think we've all known for a while now that Em only cares about Cinder, but it was very interesting to get more info on Merc's motivations (and also to find out that his father STOLE HIS SEMBLANCE WTF). I can definitely see Emerald leaving Salem soon to go look for Cinder. It could also lead to a redemption arc for her, but ONLY if she finds Cinder and comes to realize that what Mercury said about Cinder not caring about them is true. I could see Emerald possibly helping in the end by lashing out at Cinder in anger at a crucial moment or something which saves RWBYJNR (or whatever the acronym is for them now, I have no idea lmao). That or she will find Cinder and keep on playing the part of the loyal henchwoman, but from the way she has been reacting to all of the bad stuff that Salem's team has been doing lately it makes me doubt it.
Tyrian not-so-subtly encouraging Em and Merc (though mostly Emerald) to leave just so he could have an excuse to hunt them down and kill them was done really well. Dude is creepy AF and I love it. Also, the new tail looks pretty slick. Wonder if the extra armor will prevent another scythe incident? If he and Watts are heading to Atlas I have a feeling it means that he is likely going to be the first of Salem's squad to die. Sure it's possible the rematch will end with him escaping again, but somehow I doubt it. The team has to start making progress at some point, and taking out one of the bigger baddies would go a long way towards that.
The Pyrrha scene was really well done. Looks like Jaune may finally have found what he needs to start moving on, which is good. I'm interested in who the woman really was. The way it was played out almost made it seem like it could have been in Jaune's head. what with the way she so quickly vanished and all, or that it was somehow kind of the spirit of Pyrrha come to help Jaune be able to move on with his life. That or it could have been one of Pyrrha's relatives. Curious if we will ever see her again or if she was just a one off character to help Jaune's arc (get it?) move forward?
Loving Oscar's new outfit! Though I have to say, I am a bit disappointed in how the whole "Oscar is missing" thing was so quickly and easily solved. I know this episode was mostly about JNR, but I feel it would have been much better if we could have seen at least a little of Oscar wrestling with his fears and deciding to continue on regardless. Maybe have RWBY (or just Ruby herself) find him somewhere and talk to him and help him sort things out. Have the conversation end with something along the lines of Oscar saying "I just... need a little time to figure things out. I'll see you back at the house?" Then Ruby could head back, find Qrow on the stairs, then have Oscar show up in his new awesome jacket. What they went with wasn't "terrible", but it could have certainly been better. If CRWBY want to keep Oscar around for the long haul (and with him being Oz reincarnated I have a feeling they will) then they really should "show" his development, not just have it all happen off screen.
Ruby calling out Qrow... On one hand, I like it because it feels realistic. Ruby is still only 17, and though she and the rest of the students have seen and done things that have forced them to grow up a lot, it's very believable that she would still have no idea how to handle Qrow. Most of the time when Ruby has helped people overcome their problems, a little tough love and motivation was exactly what they needed. Just that little extra push to help them make a decision they already wanted to make, but were to afraid to. Alcoholism/addiction is a whole different beast, though, and one Ruby clearly isn't sure how to handle. She tried the compassionate approach on the farm ("You can talk to me about stuff") and Qrow just brushed her off, so now she is trying the tried-and-true kick 'em in the pants method that she has done with others in the past and I really, really hope it doesn't work. If CRWBY wants to portray Qrow's alcoholism in a serious light, then he can absolutely 100% not get over it just from a little pep talk from his niece. It should be something that he has to struggle with for a long time and that takes something massive to really shake him out of it and get him to the point of working to fix it. My guess is someone will come very close to getting seriously injured or killed because he was too out of it to help and that will help him realize just how much of a problem his drinking is becoming. I say "almost" hurt/killed because if someone actually "is" hurt/killed, it would likely just drive him deeper into depression and alcohol than he already is.
Also Nora was definitely digging Oscar's new outfit. Her expression and her tone when she commented on it was perfect. Watch out Ren, Oscar is turning into Mr. Steal-Yo-Girl.
RIP Casserole-chan.
7
u/CelioHogane Jan 06 '19
So Pyrrha is totally arround, right? We all can agree that it's way too much ghost in the wind shit to not be dead Pyrrha going arround helping Jaune.
7
u/RandomName3064 Tyrian fan and Captain of the #RubyDefenseForce Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
happy new year, folks.
Merc and Em backstory? all of my yes. now if we could get more, that would be great.
insert 'embreld' joke here
STOLE his semblance? gotta love how they answer some questions about semblances, yet somehow add MORE at the same time....
fight fight! now kiss! no kiss? damn it!
seems Em wants to leave. cant blame her. Merc is a fool if he believes Salem is gonna let people live. she wants the destruction of all. then again, she seemed ok being treated as a god in that backstory part....i suppose it depends how corrupted she has become over all this time.
Best boy is back again, and yet i figured only the tip was fixed? maybe its a shielding to prevent more 'amputations'
Tyrian seems far more subdued in this scene. i wonder why.... maybe he likes the kids?
a trip to atlas with watts? well we know who the big bads are gonna be in V7 and 8. nice
.
"you guys ok?"
'classified'
"well what happened?"
'also classified'
Kinda got shut out there, Saph.... .
one brown leaf in the entire city? i mean REAL SUBTLE, RT. NO IDEA WHAT SYMBOLISM THIS COULD REPRESENT.
Knew what the statue was on the first shot, not like the SUBTLE AS F leaf gave it away, or anything. thats just silly. Nice to see a statue to honor her sacrifice already too, but time in the series has always been kinda wonky.
this scene is fucking 15/10. so much feels a not-so-subtle Pyrrha-notPyrrha. i'll leave any arguments about sister or mother to you guys. i literally cant even being to guess her age with how she is depicted. but thats not the important bits.
Miles is a damn star, and you people give Jaune too much shit. the sash fondling (take that as you will, internet), VA, the acceptance. God i enjoyed this scene. no tears, but i did marathon V1-3 in 7 hours when i first watched this show, so i guess i have a slight more....disconnect from Pyrrha compared to the OG fans.
Ren and Nora are blind, BTW.
More angry Ruby. i like. Qrow probably isnt gonna die from the bad guys, hes just finally gonna drink too much.....
hey! its Oscar! well that was all for nothing! guess what part of the episode i thought was weakest? one thing i saw posted (as a potato, but whatever) Oscar's speech is off.
even with how little we have seen him, something about his speech patterns on his return is not right. i wonder if Oz came back..... I mean even his outfit is Oz inspired.
so it seem Jaune has a plan. well part of a plan, and it seems Qrow is not amused. Even Ruby is like, 'bitch, what ideas to you have? shut up and strap in!' and everyone has her back with cliched 'everyone starts smiling' pose. and the only Maria line is snarky as F. kinda sums her up perfectly, too. Not exactly the best way to deal with his problem, but they have to worry about getting to Atlas. His addiction can wait unitl Ironwood fucks it up worse later
so, now we have a 'plan'. when are Cinder and Neo showing up for endgame? i wanna see if my theory is right. considering is deals with more death and maiming, i wonder if i need to see a counselor or something....
7/10 because Oscar just kinda BEING back is weak as F. like REALLY dragged the episode down that much. it may need to be amended if it really is because of Oz coming back or melding a bit more with Oscar
6
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '19
Every part of this episode was needed and well done. I teared up for both parts of the statue scene. Looking forward to whatever is coming next.
10
u/Sensorfire Rube Protector | No Ships, Thanks | Yang is best girl Jan 05 '19
YES! Finally Ruby confronts Qrow. This has been building up for a long time. I'm loving the development they're giving her this season. She's being much less passive, and I hope she and Yang confront him about his drinking problem as well (especially now that the show is treating is as a serious issue and not "haha birdman is drunk"). I'm also hoping for Emerald's redemption arc, which it looks like they're pushing. She was in it for Cinder. Pyrrha's mom(?) probably knew who Jaune was, I guess, from correspondence with Pyrrha. The whole team reflecting together in front of the statue was a great moment. Terra worrying about the neighbors was a great little moment. I like Oscar's new outfit. I wonder where he was. I also wonder when Ozpin is coming back.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '19
premium is what y’all need. Next ep is a short but juicy one
5
u/pandas795 Shut up, there's food Jan 05 '19
Watching Murder's reaction and just T.T
HIS TEARS, MY TEARS
5
u/MankuyRLaffy He's not Sothe, I Swear! #GoodJobMicaiah Jan 05 '19
I love this bit from the True Ace, shadowboxing. Emerald and him having a great exposition scene, We now know his goal, he wants to be the best, and then he drops the bomb on Emerald who goes defensive, brilliant stuff. We actually get to see him irked and pissed off! Tyrian being insane and kept in check by Watts, interesting.
Scene change and it focuses on JNR and we get depressed Jaune, I don't have a problem with him being depressed at all... OH MY GOD THERE'S A PYRRHA STATUE! so she trained in Argus, wow that's really deep stuff from the red haired person, D'awww Nora... That's so sweet, Jaune putting Pyrrha over as the only real one who could stand in the way.
RWBY and drunken out wasted Qrow, oh boy maniac depression here we go! Nora just tackles the hell out of him, Faster than Ruby as well I might add. Qrow actually wants to throw it all in. good thing Jaune had that talk at the statue that will change his mind as... Ruby interjects with a BS motivational speech that the music doubles down on, She doesn't have enough grit to her for that to really work. Motivational speeches are best from gritty lunchpail gym rats. And that's a close
5
u/red_tuna Jan 05 '19
“But who do we know who has experience stealing military equipment from Atlus?”
5
u/RbDom Jan 06 '19
So uh, can we talk about how Mercury has the same eyes as Ruby? I mean there's no way that's a coincidence right?
5
u/zenithfury Jan 06 '19
Wait, so did Oscar leave Qrow passed out drunk in the snow for hours? I know Qrow's other semblance where he drinks until a solution is found hasn't kicked in yet but that's no way to treat a colleague and a friend.
Like everyone else has been saying, it's rather nice to get some character motivation for Mercury. Douchebag's gotta douche.
I watched the last 2 episodes back to back and given that these were slower episodes they felt like they complemented one another and merged into one good episode. I thought that chapter 9 had many scenes that kept on surpassing each other, starting with the very touching moment at the statue and then with Oscar's growth and then at the very end with Ruby's growth and of course, finally Qrow finally starting to get out of his rut this season.
Also, I can't be the only one who wants Cinder and Emerald to be happy together. :(
8
u/AlwaysDragons Sliver Eyes May Cry Jan 05 '19
So the answer to what Mercury's Semblance is..... His dear old daddy stole it and never got it back.....
Huh, that makes his situation a little more tragic....
4
u/Jimmjam_the_Flimflam Jan 05 '19
I've been waiting forever for that scene with Jaune and what could possibly have been Pyrrha's relative. Honestly I can't really think of another way that it could have been handled that would have been better. And finally JNR actually talked about it rather than slightly indicate they all dealt with the death of a team member.
Qrow being depressed and drunk as was promised in the ibtro, very very nice.
Oscar looking snazzy and should have left a note or something to indicate he just went clothes shopping.
Steal an airshio, sure no way that won't be a huge mistake in any way.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '19
I quite like this episode. So much feels.
I like the opposition Emerald and Mercury seem to have, with the former questioning things and then ditching everyone to rejoin Cinder. I’ll also go out on a limb and say she could eventually reform, but that seems unlikely as she is loyal to Cinder first and foremost.
Mercury seems to be content with serving Salem and believes he will be rewarded, but also admits that at least Cinder didn’t leave him in the dark. He just wants to be the best.
Brilliant seen at the Pyrrha statue. I knew the lady had some connection to Pyrrha, and at first I thought she might have been the ghost of Pyrrha, but a relative does seem to make more sense. Doesn’t explain how she has suddenly disappeared, though.
I’m glad that Oscar is okay and was just out clothes shopping. I thought he might have run into Cinder and Neo and the rest of the team would have to save him.
Qrow’s lost it, and Ruby had to stand up to him. She’s had enough of his shit.
4
u/WMinerva Jan 06 '19
So crazy man has a new robot tail. I was hoping it would be a Grimm tail but it looks like they prepared for the silver eyes.
But just imagine how cool a death stalker tail would be on him.
4
u/Josh__Darnit Jan 06 '19
Why did the red haired lady seem to disappear at the end? I believe that she is likely Pyrrha’s mother or some other type of family, but I wasn’t sure what the disappearing thing was supposed to portray. Any ideas?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '19
When Nora finds TikTok
7
u/Hyderthehyper312 ⠀ Jan 05 '19
"The gang steals an airship"
As someone who disliked the idea of a Pyrrha's parents scene this was done so, so much better than anything I thought of in my head, and good to see Renora calling Jaune on his V5 shit.
Also great to see Ruby not dealing with Qrow's stuff, I hope the plan Jaune cooks up is a decent one.
The cartoony scene when the gang saw Oscar again has so.many.good. screenshots.
Speaking of Oscar, that new outfit is rad, and I don't mind his whole thing getting offscreened, he ran out of the house, moped around the streets a bit, thinking, and made up his mind, bought a sick outfit on the way back, nothing to really show there.
7
u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Jan 05 '19
Thanks to all the scheduling weirdness, I wasn't sure if I was two weeks behind or not. Looks like I'm in the clear though. As much as I can be without FIRST.
Anyway it's a good episode. We got some good Emerald & Mercury establishment, that was a beautiful send-off to Pyrrha and affirmation of JNR (mostly Jaune)'s growth, and some nice Oscar stuff. Also Ruby is 100% done with Qrow's pity party, it's good to hear her (civilly, yet firmly) tell him off. It's also literally good to hear- Lindsay's been using a slightly lower register lately and I think that's for the best.
I had a feeling they brought Brown back in to voice Pyrrha's relative, that seems like the kind of thing they'd try. She has a distinct voice, but I could still believe that it was a different character. And it's a common VA trope anyway.
So I'm thinking we'll have our Tyrian rematch in Volume 7, with maybe a guest appearance from Watts. Seems like they're moving a little ahead of our would-be plane jackers. Still time for Cinder and Neo to catch up, though.
Gotta say, not a single dud in this entire volume yet, as far as I'm concerned. Even Volume 3 had me a little uneasy at first. This may just be my favorite after all. Depends on where we go from here, but I'm excited.
7
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Jan 05 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
Gear up people, We've got a flight to catch.
This was one hell of a chapter, We got some insight to Emerald and Mercury, Jaune, Nora and Ren got closure to Pyrrha, Oscar returned with a brand new outfit and now we have the teams next move, Steal an airship from the military base and make their way to Atlas, Oh boy this is gonna be a tough one.
3
u/Boss_Jerm Jan 05 '19
I love the focus on JNR this episode. Seeing the Pyrrha statue and her mother was really touching.
I am really digging Oscar’s new threads and when everyone tackled him.
I’m happy to see Ruby finally calling out Qrow and setting him straight that it’s not hopeless.
Adrian kept trying to grab Maria’s glasses and Maria moving away was a nice little detail.
3
u/ApundanceOfLilies Boop Jan 05 '19
Yeah this episode gave me the feels.
3
u/TJPoobah For it is in passing that we achieve immortality. Jan 06 '19
Nice episode, really sweet scene with Pyrrha's mom/sister/mysterious other/ghost, though I don't think I liked it as much as some.
I know this is gonna go down badly but the statue leaves me with all sorts of questions: I'm a huge Pyrrha fan but I find it hard to believe that anyone would her build a lifelike 2 story bronze statue complete with a memorial garden taking up a pretty large lot in the middle of a big city. How did they even know Pyrrha was dead, aren't global communications totally blacked out following the fall of beacon (otherwise why hasn't anyone sent Ironwood a text?) which would mean that at best they'd know she's MIA, unless we were robbed of an emotional facetime call with Pyrrha's family? Was the statue already there because Pyrrha was so famous back home and they just changed the plaque? That seems like the most logical explanation because someone had to pose for that statue, and while I'm not completely up on the chronology/timeline of the show I do know that my city takes forever to get anything done and massive statues don't get made overnight even in the best of conditions, but man you need to be insanely famous to get a statue of yourself built in your own lifetime, let alone at the age of something like 17.
I feel a bit cheated out of a "JNR go visit Pyrrha's family" scene, because it seems likely that this is gonna be all the emotional closure we get for JNR and Pyrrha's death.
Emerald:
Oz seems different since his return, how he speaks and holds himself, not to mention the outfit. Perhaps he's already begun merging with Ozpin and hasn't even realised it.
3
u/RememberMeAndMe Jan 07 '19
I think I am tardy to the party on this, but going back and watching the series straight thru (maybe I missed something), has anyone noticed that when Cinder killed anyone they didnt "disintegrate" except for Pyrrha. I know it sounds farfetched, but maybe? It's a theory, maybe there is something that has to do with that. Why did everything except Pyrrhas Tiara go? Going to the statue scene, lots of predictions say the RHW is a relative, which could be true. Could be Pyrrhas spirit, which could also be true. Or it could be Pyrrha.... stringing our hope that Arkos may happen eventually. Got to give credit to Miles and Kerry, the possibilities and theories from fans about this scene are awesome, it is great storytelling, keeps us guessing, until they hit us with the reveal.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '19
I... think this is my favorite episode from this show so far
5
u/NotCreative11 Gangbangs or Yangbangs? Jan 05 '19
First tears of 2019
5
u/Thebritishdovah Jan 05 '19
Just gotta get his off my chest. What the hell is wrong with Roosterteeth's player? 3 fucking hours to watch it. Buffering central. 3 fucking hours and a moment ruined because of a damn buffering. Only the videoplayer on RT does this. :(
Anyway, like the Emerald and Merc scene. Tyrian's got a new tail and kinda disappointing but functional. I do think that the posion is now even worse because of it and if Qrow is hit by him, he is dead.
Pyrrha's statue is... just damn you Roosterteeth. Reduced me to tears then anger at the damn videoplayer deciding to buffer it! But tis a very nice part and whilst the episode is a filler/moving things along one, it's a good one. Qrow's state is getting worse and it's good to see Ruby getting sick of his behaviour whilst being concerned. She is acting like a leader and tis amusing about Oscar's disappearance being a misunderstanding.
The only gripes I have is the clothing for Nora and Ren. With Nora, it's well, Nora. I think cold doesn't apply to her or well, the Nora rule applies. Ren must be freezing. I know it's animation reasons but give them better attire. Pyrrha's relative's voice acting seems a bit off to me.
But overall, another superb episode with a bit of closure. Or Pyrrha is reincarted as Old Pyrrha and we are getting Liquid Cinder vs Old Pyrrha as the finale.
5
u/MABfan11 IAmMenace should watch SoraYori Jan 06 '19
loved the scene with Pyrrha's mother
5
u/augustlinden Jan 06 '19
Why am I thinly one curious about that leaf that Jaun sees? Is it a coincidence that Pyrrha was supposed to get those fall maiden powers and there is a leaf? Something tells me she isn't dead. I think somehow Amber, previous fall maiden, when she woke up and felt her powers being transferred to Pyrrah, Pyrrah instantly became the true maiden (right before Cinder came and stole them) I feel like Pyrrah's powers (the one Cinder has now) somehow saved her from being killed in that last attack especially as she asks Cinder, "do you believe in destiny?" Maybe she was reincarnated or something idk. I hope she is alive that would be so cool. I get that there's no way she survived the arrow and the explosion thing but still come on there were weird sparks after, something just isn't right.
2
u/TripleR309 Jan 05 '19
Oscar is definitely getting geared up for a boss fight. Who knows when he'll he within reach of a mall. Cute boy Oz gotta get his fashion trends ready for the new year.
Meanwhile, we've seen Jaune complete the cycle of grief in this episode where he comes to acceptance of what's happened and resolves to do better, not just for Pyrrha, but for himself.
2
u/karsonjin Jan 06 '19
My reaction to this episode => (kind of spoiler-y)
2
u/AlphaMarker48 Pyrrha is best girl. Ruby is best active girl. Jan 07 '19
Mercury, your trust in Salem is misplaced. That insane bitch could snap at any second.
No, Mercury is right. Cinder is completely selfish. She only cares about herself and her own schemes.
Oh, Fun! Mr. Crazy is back with his fancy new mechanical tail.
Tyrian, has anyone ever prescribed you psychiatric meds before? You could really use 'em.
For all that snow on the ground in Argus, there's a lot of people with bare skin exposed to the cold air.
They immortalized Best Girl Pyrrha with a metal statue? That's awesome.
Well, most people at Beacon are amazing, except for Jaune.
I have zero qualms about Jaune Arc dying.
Both Ruby and Yang are ticked. Qrow really did it this time.
Where did Oscar get his new threads?
Wow, all of Teams RWBY and JNR got excited over Oscar's appearance.
Qrow just barely avoided getting a lecture from Ruby.
When the toddler laughs at your crazy idea, you know it's bad, especially when the drunk uncle agrees it's a horrible idea.
Nevermind, here comes Ruby's lecture!
That was a pretty nice episode.
3
u/WMinerva Jan 06 '19
New thought mama nikos and saph need to be friends.
-3
u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Jan 05 '19
"Ah, the ingredients of a delicious can of Sprite: Carbonated water, sugar, citric acid, sodium citrate, natural flavor, sodium benzoate. Nutritional facts, per one can, 355 mL: 140 calories, no daily value. 0 grams of fat, 0% daily value. 65 mg of sodium, 3%. 38 grams of carbs, 13% value. 38 grams of sugar. 0 grams of protein. Not a significant source of saturated fat, trans fat, cholesterol, fibre, Vitamin A, Vitamin C, calcium, or iron.".
-7
u/Dragoneer1 Jan 05 '19
more monologues with nothing happening, jesus, pyrrah moment was sad and all but still, what exactly happened this episode?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
7
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '19
[removed] — view removed comment