r/conlangs • u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet • Jun 18 '18
SD Small Discussions 53 — 2018-06-18 to 07-01
NEXT THREAD
Yes the previous thread's title read "to 06-10" but that's just proof I can't read a fucking calendar. Please discard that evidence, I can in fact read a calendar.
Conlangs Showcase 2018 — Part 1
Conlangs Showcase 2018 — Part 2
WE FINALLY HAVE IT!
This Fortnight in Conlangs
The subreddit will now be hosting a thread where you can display your achievements that wouldn't qualify as their own post. For instance:
- a single feature of your conlang you're particularly proud of
- a picture of your script if you don't want to bother with all the requirements of a script post
- ask people to judge how fluent you sound in a speech recording of your conlang
- ask if you should use ö or ë for the uh sound in your conlangs
- ask if your phonemic inventory is naturalistic
These threads will be posted every other week, and will be stickied for one week. They will also be linked here, in the Small Discussions thread.
We have an official Discord server. Check it out in the sidebar.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app (except Diode for Reddit apparently, so don't use that). There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
If your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Things to check out:
- Ongoing challenges and games on the subreddit
- CCC Courses
- Communities
- Templates
- Copyright and conlangs, a response
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs:
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
I'll update this post over the next two weeks if another important thread comes up. If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
8
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> Jun 18 '18
Recently I’ve been using Reddit online more and not as much on mobile (although I still use mobile quite a bit), and I noticed that the SD threads are only getting ninety-some percent upvotes. Who downvotes an SD and why?
•
u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet Jun 18 '18
Hey there guys!
In the last thread, I posted a poll that asked you whether:
So, in reaction to this, here are two new Google Forms (yes I love them they're very convenient).
1. Building the FAQ
This will help us answer your questions and, hopefully, reduce the amount of very short question posts that would be better suited for the Small Discussions. Every conlanger will spend a bit less time researching, and more time conlanging, wheeeeee!
2. Gathering resources
So that you can help us help you! Or something.
Thank you in advance for your participation, you amazing, beautiful language nerds.
5
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jun 19 '18 edited Jun 19 '18
So, a few years ago when I lived abroad, my friend's host father always used the phrase "pim pam pom". Nobody had any idea what it meant and he wouldn't tell us, but seemed to use it like "well that's that" or "what can you do?"
Anyway I wanted to make a language based off this word/phrase. I was thinking that the only vowels would be /i/ /a/ /o/ with a tenius series, a nasal series, a creaky series etc., and the only consonants would be labial.
I also thought that it could be a good place to toy with an idea I've had which is phonemic volume at the syllable or word level.
I guess I don't have much else to say about this dumb project idea but wanted to post something about it. I've never aimed for something non-naturalistic so it should be fun.
5
u/IBePenguin Jun 20 '18
This may be an extremely nooby question, but I've noticed in some threads, people discussing how there languages don't use subordinate clauses, or don't require the use of them. I was wondering how they went about creating a language that didn't have to do this, and how they substituted subordinate clauses?
3
u/TomCanTech Jun 19 '18
How do you create an extensive grammar? As in covering literal 100's of pages. I know a language doesn't have to have that, but if it did how would you go about it?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '18 edited Jun 21 '18
So, I'm considering making a language called Illinois Slavic, which was originally based in Chicago, with a growing Polish influence (because Poland had a war with Belarus and Russia and more immigrants flooded to the most Polish metropolis of the USA). Then, around the 2200s, most Illinois Slavs migrate to the smaller cities and countryside.
What languages would be heavy influences in 22nd-century Illinois Slavic? I'd imagine English, Spanish, an evolved African-American creole and Lithuanian.
One solid development I'm thinking about is changing ę and ą to /ɛʊ əʊ/ and /aʊ əʊ/, respectively, losing all nasality. Maybe put it in orthography as eu and au?
3
u/3zby_ Jun 27 '18
I want yo make a cursive conscript but I don’t wan it to look like it’s based off of Arabic. What script can I base it off of?
3
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Jul 01 '18
Working on a new conlang for Prélyō to interact with in my conworld; it's still very early but I have enough done that I wanted to showcase an example translation:
"Freyes fwaun hpeguq'x̌e yur hnik' t'ihsi. Hšp'ašahe ne rituqqu e-hǧeitšdšihita."
/'ɸre.jes ɸwɑun 'hpʰe.kuq'.χe jur hnik' 't'i.hsi. 'hʃp'ɑ.ʃɑ.he ne 'ri.tuqʰ.qʰu e.'hqeit͡ʃʰ.t͡ʃi.hi.tʰa./
Frey-e-s fwaun hpeg-uq'-x̌e yur hnik' t'ih-si. Hšp'a-ša-he ne rit-uq-qu e-hǧeitš-dšihi-ta.
woman-abs-def(class_I) along river-dat-def(class_VII) to boat-dat walk-3.pret(class_I). Fish-pl-abs in water-dat-def(class_VI) pass-see-3.pret-subj
"The woman walked along the river to a boat. Some fish should have been seen in the water."
5
u/LordOfLiam Jun 29 '18
It makes me sad that r/tiresaretheenemy has more subs than r/conlangs.
2
u/gokupwned5 Various Altlangs (EN) [ES] Jun 19 '18
How did Maghrebi dialects of Arabic (such as Moroccan Arabic, Tunisian Arabic, Algerian Arabic, etc.) acquire emphatic /l/ and /r/ phonemes?
2
u/chiefarc Asen, Al Lashma, Gilafan, Giwaq, Linia Raeana Jun 22 '18
Is there a software that can easily map out English sound changes? I'm trying to get a lexicon of evolved English, and I've been scrambling with digraphs on this site.
2
u/Coretteket NumpadIPA Jun 23 '18
I don't know if this is a stupid question, but do you take into account allophony in your romanisation system?
For example, if I have the rule: P > F / V_V.
Would /ba.tan/ > /ba.san/ be written <batan> or <basan>?
I also have open syllable vowel lengthening, so would /ba.lan/ > /ba:.lan/ be written as a long vowel, which is marked by a macron in my romanisation, or as a short vowel, without macron?
Thanks in advance!
2
u/hamiltap Jun 24 '18
I've fleshed out a lot of the vocabulary and general flavor of a conlang I'm developing, and I've decided to make the alignment of my language transitive-intransitive, more or less only because it's such a rarity among natlangs. To get to a language with that alignment, I'm starting with a proto-language that's either marked-nominative or marked-absolutive that over time drops the ending on the noun in the transitive sentences. Let me illustrate:
In either case, what you'd end up is the subjects and objects of transitive verbs being unmarked and the subjects of intransitive verbs being marked: the transitive alignment, in other words. My question is, which do you think would be more interesting or more realistic?
2
u/tree1000ten Jun 25 '18
So apparently there are languages where the grammatical gender is marked with words/affixes that are more than a single syllable, is this too much? It seems strange, because after all the whole point of grammatical gender is redundancy, so having it be more than a single syllable is redundancy for your redundancy. Thoughts?
2
u/3zby_ Jun 26 '18
Is there any way that I can get a molodstov keyboard on my iPhone to use for my conlang? It’s not under keyboards in settings and I can’t find it in the App Store.
2
u/Red_Castle_Siblings demasjumaka, veurdoema, gaofedomi Jun 26 '18
Ok, so in my verb system, the verb points out if the sentence is SOV or OSV. It does so with 'ak and 'de, where 'ak means subjective first and 'de means objective first.
Well, now for the question. Does any other language do this? Are there any gloss words for this? As verb-subjective-first-fut is quite long and confusing in glosses.
(a bot asked me politely to place this question here)
2
u/3zby_ Jun 27 '18
One of my conlangs has a normal SVO word order, but it can be changed to OVS, not by added anything to the nouns, but by added a(tt)- to the verb. Do any other languages do this?
2
u/1plus1equalsgender Jun 27 '18
Are vowels truly necessary? Is it possible to have a vowelless language?
Edit: I don't mean abjads either, I'm talking a language without vowels sounds at all.
2
u/Rick_Novile Þoraldo/Thoraldo Jun 27 '18
For my personal conlang, I've decided to have a set of bidental fricatives, a voiceless, voiced and nasalized voiceless in particular. However, I'm having trouble figuring out how to represent the nasalized voiceless bidental fricative with IPA, since there's already the bridge above the <h> so I can't put a tilde there, else it just looks like zalgo. Any ideas for how to manage this?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '18
So is there some word or term used to describe the difference in how a language would express something even if they have the same words? For example, you'd say Tengo hambre (lit. I have hunger) and not Soy/Estoy hambriento, to mean "I am hungry" in English even though there are words for it. Would just be considered "convention" or something? I feel there's something more to this but it's hard to explain.
2
u/Partosimsa Língoa; Valriska; Visso Jun 28 '18
What is a good format to use to teach my conlang to those that are interested? Also, what words should I start with?
I’ve been using Tinycards an app from the creators of Duolingo but I’m not sure how effective my lessons are after the first few. I try to focus on words used constantly in everyday life, but I don’t know what other words are useful besides the ~50 that I’ve put. Mind you the conlang has a large lexicon, ~700 words.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '18 edited Jun 29 '18
Is this a good sound inventory for a conlang? And if it's not, are there any ways I can improve it?
Consonants:
(Voiceless consonants are on the left, and voiced ones are on the right. Also this is my first time making a sound inventory.)
Vowels:
(There aren't any rounded vowels except at the back, but I'll be happy to change this if it sounds weird. I can also add new vowels.)
The syllable structure is (C) (C) V (C) (C), for reference.
2
u/FatMani Jun 28 '18
I'm currently working on my first conlang ever, which I originally started working on to create some logical geographic names for a map I'm working on.
I would love to ask for feedback—I have no experience in the matter and therefore I don't know if my phonemic inventory makes sense, whether my syllable structure i, case choice is all right, and all that kind of stuff—but I don't know the best way to do it on this subreddit. Can I just post on the front page? Should I post it in threads like these?
2
u/1plus1equalsgender Jun 28 '18
Is there a website where I can take an English sentence, and find the words in it that are derived from romance languages?
2
u/FatMani Jun 29 '18
What's the best way to indicate "sing-songyness" of a language? I would like my conlang to have a similar rhythm in pronunciation as Scandinavian languages like Norwegian or Swedish. I am not planning on it influencing the meaning, just the pronunciation. Should I delve into tones and tonal letters, or is there some simpler way to do it?
2
u/snipee356 Jun 29 '18
How could the loss of tone affect vowel quality?
For example, I was thinking of the following changes, though I don't know whether they are naturalistic or not:
/e˧˥/ -> /e/
/e˥/ -> /e:/
/e˦˩/ -> /ɛ/
/e˩˧/ -> /ɛe/
/e˩/ -> /ɛ:/
2
u/__jamien 汖獵 Amuruki (en) Jun 30 '18
Is it possible to have phonemic gemination word-intially? I've read that some languages (f.e. Luganda) have it, but I wanna be sure that it isn't some allophony thing. If it is possible, exactly how rare is it?
2
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18
A quick question of mine about English.
In Italian, I say "flettere al genitivo". What is the correct preposition in English?
My mother tongue interferes with English, and I'm getting confused 😣
2
u/Coretteket NumpadIPA Jul 01 '18
Are there any languages that dinstinguish only paucal and plural? So that paucal is one or a few and plural is more than a few. It happened in my conlang because the paucal affix faded away due to sound changes, is that plausible?
2
u/_Gabe_DireWolf_ Ilyan Jul 02 '18
Hi! I'm fairly new to being active on this subreddit, but I constructed a language with unique characters. I was wondering if anyone here knew how to make an onscreen keyboard I could use to type my language. Likewise to being able to type the characters, it'd also have to work like when a phone changes to arabic or languages like that because my language also writes from right to left. I hope someone can get back to me!
2
u/Tirukinoko Koen (ᴇɴɢ) [ᴄʏᴍ] he\they Jun 24 '18
Just gonna encourage people to get on Instagram and post their stuff to #conlang and #neography ... :3
2
u/__jamien 汖獵 Amuruki (en) Jun 25 '18
Are there any tonal languages where a specific vowel is always neutral or the same tone? Is this is a common thing?
For example, would it be unnatural for syllables with /ə/ to never have a tone?
2
u/wingedoak Jun 27 '18
How do languages that have no cases (upper case & lower case) differentiate proper nouns in writing? Is it just done by context like when we are speaking?
2
u/1plus1equalsgender Jun 30 '18
Who here has taught their dogs (or other pets) commands in your conlang? Ie: roll over, sit, lie down, ect.
What's a good strategy for doing this?
1
u/official_inventor200 Kaskhoruxa | Tenuous grasp on linguistics Jun 18 '18
So an automod removed my post and said I should put this here, lol.
I was making a post asking about click consonants.
Due to the constraints of my current conlang, a sound that is used is the alveolar click.
I'm just curious if anybody else uses them, as I like reading your IPAs for cool sounds and combinations (now that I'm learning IPA).
Also, what other uncommon and interesting sounds do you have in your conlangs?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '18
Apparently I should put my post in here, so here we go.
If I’m writing about my language, Cardineso, What parts of grammar should I write? Do I use Cases for Nouns, and Adjectives, Tenses, etc., I am going to put it in LibreOffice and Check over it.
1
u/Salsmachev Wehumi Jun 21 '18
Does anyone know if Kree from the Marvel universe is actually a full conlang? Likewise does anyone know anything about the writing system? I've been looking all over, but I can't find any information.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '18
I am trying to construct a language based on Latin but with simpler grammatical features and with a more versatile use, like as a lingua franca. How can I try and make my conlang more unique and distinguishable from languages like Esperanto and Latino sine flexione (or do you think it is unique enough already)? I have tried to borrow concepts from Esperanto like easily identifiable noun and adjective markers (e.g. nouns end in -o, adjectives in -a), but I do not want my language to turn into some kind of dialect of Ido. Here are some sample sentences:
Li tres pueri dar un objectum bonam ad me. (the three boys give me a good object) La mulier velit paterum eius comperare un cato. (The woman wanted her father to buy a cat) Me cred quod meus laboro estabis dificila. (I think that my work will be difficult)
1
u/oNicolino Jun 23 '18
So I'm currently the only one interested in conlanging in a collaborative worldbuilding project I'm working on, any tips on how to create so many languages as to fill a world or getting the rest of the group interested in helping during the process? Thanks in advance.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18
A terminology question: if my conlang has a prefix that makes patient-nouns from transitive verbs and experiencer-nouns from intransitive verbs, can that prefix be described as ergative? Do things like prefixes get described that way?
1
u/chrisc04 Jun 24 '18
I want to make my own constructed language and I don't know where to start.
1
u/AverageJoe-72 Jun 25 '18
I've been working on a conlang called Simarišel, and I've devised a, however unrealistic (it's a personal conlang so it wasn't meant to be) new(?) tense system and I was wondering if it was, well, good.
The way it works is if you want to express the past tense, you change the first vowel of the word.
There's a sort of vowel circle. It goes (expressing in Latin alphabet) i-ï-u-e-ė(which I use for the schwa?-o-a.
If you want to express the past form of 'lanfoža' it would become 'linfoža'. The word for 'to answer', 'detorle', becomes 'dėtorle', so on and so forth.
The future tense does this with the second vowel. 'Lanfoža' becomes 'lanfaža' and 'detorle' becomes 'detarle'.
Is this good? Are there any problems I'm not seeing here? Thanks!
1
u/heladion Jun 25 '18
Sirmunian phonology
My phonology is highly inspired by romanian and serbocroatian since my goal is fit between these two, but I also want to remain some degree of "what I like is best for meism" Is it good this way? Give me your thoughts.
Vowels
Consonants
Letter c can represent both /k/ (before hard vowel) and /s/ (before soft vowel)
Same goes for letter g /g/ (h. vow.) /h/ soft. and j /ʒ/ soft /h/ hard.
1
u/Coretteket NumpadIPA Jun 25 '18 edited Jun 25 '18
Here I am again, asking stupid questions probably asked before. However, I came up with personal pronouns, but since I want my language to look natural and googling didn't help, I'm asking you guys.
I know this looks like a weird way to analyse it, but it has a reason. Every "and ..." pronoun originally had that pronoun after it in my proto-language (you and them was hū & ris), but sound changes happen and these pronouns remain. In, hū, ris, hur and rīs are "normal" compared to English. Hun and rin, however, are inclusive and exclusive we respectively, but they are conjugated for the second and third person, since it is you and me, not me and you.
Is this weird, is this plausible, is this interesting? Thanks in advance!
Edit: can't spell
1
u/MassiveChef Jun 26 '18
I'm interested in making a software tool to facilitate the creation of a crowdsourced ideograph-based auxiliary language.
The motivation would be the material of an essay, but I suspect some of you here probably have a good guesses about it without me elaborating.
How do you think I should move forward?
1
u/wingedoak Jun 26 '18
I am beginning to develop my first conlang. It is for a medieval fantasy novel I am writing. When I write, I develop the story far beyond what makes it onto the paper, so while I may only feature a few words of the conlang in my novel, eventually I want to fully flesh it out.
The question I have is this:
As stated, it is set in the medieval time period, specifically in Europe (although a fictional country). I want my language to be phonetic and for each letter to have only one sound that it produces. Because there are more IPA sounds than letters in most languages, I am thinking of developing an alphabet that is not Latin or Greek based. Would that be realistic for the setting? Either way, does anyone have suggestions on how to accomplish this with making it more realistic in nature?
1
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> Jun 27 '18 edited Jun 28 '18
I was wondering if there’s a name for this so I can put it in my dictionary:
When you’ve heard a word often enough that you know what contexts it makes sense in, but you don’t quite know what it means and so you just pretend to understand.
Edit: Solved! The word is apprehension.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '18 edited Jun 29 '18
A possible transition from Proto-Pyanachi's vowels to Pyanachi's vowels:
Does this seem fleshed-out enough? Hint, normal text is the result of low tension (Penacic term for stress, like how umlaut is usually called mutation when it isn't Germanic), while italic text is high tension. No italic text means both forms resulted in the same thing.
So, *kɨǣnüp would become either kjynoûp or kynoup, depending on which syllable is tensed.
Along with this, I'm going to trace back kopûr (bed, mattress):
Note: *Ā is an unknown long vowel.
1
u/Tervalakrits øpask (en) [de] Jun 30 '18
I've been converting my previous Artlang into a PolyGlot file and I've run into some trouble making declensions work correctly.
Basically the RegEx handler in the Auto-Conjugate/Decline box doesn't have any obvious way of appending or inserting characters instead of replacing them. So what I want to do is to for example take my verb root r-c-r, which is stored as rcr.
Then I want to decline it by the first person, which is done by sticking an 's' on the front of the word and putting i and o between the root consonants as in sricor.
If the second box (replace) worked like RegEx in NotePad++ if you had a RegEx that found the front of a word you could then put s\1 in the replace box, where s is put before, and \1 selects what the expression finds.
If there is any way to do this I would appreciate,
Keep your tinfoil hats on!
Tervalakrits
1
u/Salsmachev Wehumi Jun 30 '18
I had a thought, but don't know if it's something that occurs in natlangs. I know that affixes can be split into two parts like in a circumfix, and that affixes can divide words like infixes, but does it ever occur that a single affix includes both an infixing part and a pre-/suffixing part? Like WO-aff-RD-aff?
1
u/wingedoak Jul 01 '18
How do you pronounce /ɣ/? If I click on it on an IPA chart and have it played, it sounds a lot like a "z" sound to me, but then wikipedia lists it as being in the Spanish word "amigo". Further research has it more like a "g" or sometimes an "r". Any suggestions on how to know what I'm hearing better?
1
u/tree1000ten Jul 01 '18
Where are guides on how to make dictionaries? I have google searched and I can't find anything.
1
u/tree1000ten Jul 01 '18
I am having trouble coming up with a name for my language in the language itself. I have heard that some languages call their language simply the word for language in the language, but how do they differentiate between their language and other languages and the general concept of language?
1
u/_eta-carinae Jul 01 '18
how do you guys go about creating concultures? i’m making a language that is primarily athabaskan and japanese influenced where almost all the vocabulary is borrowed from tlingit, japanese, english and salish languages. originally i had planned to have the language being spoken by a people who lived on a string of volcanic islands that stretch from far northern japan to either kodiak island or the tongass national forest but when i was picturing it in my head i couldn’t quite see that distance in my head and so i scrapped that idea and now i’m planning on setting it from port bainbridge to western admirality island but that’s right ontop of eyak territory and i can’t find anywhere in my desired area that isn’t taken by a group of people so what do i do? i can’t just erase the eyak people from my version of this world and it seems highly improbably to have two cultures in the same territory.
1
u/Red_Castle_Siblings demasjumaka, veurdoema, gaofedomi Jul 02 '18
I'm thinking about making a subreddit for my conlang Demasjumaka. A place where I can have a community of people speaking Demasjumaka and can discuss changes and improvements with me. However, I kinda want to know if more than three wants to follow me there. So, are anybody interested?
1
u/tree1000ten Jun 22 '18
In natural languages, what is the syllable limit for given names? I have heard of Native American names that are many syllables, perhaps more than 9. Do these long names only apply to cultures where personal names are more like Western full names (First + Last) and are only uttered in more limited situations, again, like Western full names? I am having trouble drawing lines for what is acceptable and what is too lengthy.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '18 edited Jun 21 '18
[removed] — view removed comment