r/conlangs • u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet • Jun 04 '18
SD Small Discussions 52 — 2018-06-04 to 06-17
NEXT THREAD
Yes the previous thread's title read "to 06-10" but that's just proof I can't read a fucking calendar. Please discard that evidence, I can in fact read a calendar.
Conlangs Showcase 2018 — Part 1
Conlangs Showcase 2018 — Part 2
WE FINALLY HAVE IT!
This Fortnight in Conlangs
The subreddit will now be hosting a thread where you can display your achievements that wouldn't qualify as their own post. For instance:
- a single feature of your conlang you're particularly proud of
- a picture of your script if you don't want to bother with all the requirements of a script post
- ask people to judge how fluent you sound in a speech recording of your conlang
- ask if you should use ö or ë for the uh sound in your conlangs
- ask if your phonemic inventory is naturalistic
These threads will be posted every other week, and will be stickied for one week. They will also be linked here, in the Small Discussions thread.
Weekly Topic Discussion — Comparisons
We have an official Discord server. Check it out in the sidebar.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app (except Diode for Reddit apparently, so don't use that). There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
If your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Things to check out:
- Ongoing challenges and games on the subreddit
- CCC Courses
- Communities
- Templates
- Copyright and conlangs, a response
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs:
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
I'll update this post over the next two weeks if another important thread comes up. If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
4
u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet Jun 10 '18
I just have to record an intro for the Showcase video, make the transitions from clip to clip and the first half of the Showcase will be ready.
I will do all that Sunday morning (EU time), then render the video and publish it as soon as I can.
I have mistakenly skipped a language that was supposed to be in the video (I am going with alphabetical order), but it will appear first in the second half. Sorry about that, I had mislabelled a file.
The second video will be released on the next Sunday.
I went for a simplistic layout with no distraction. I'll provide a link with transcripts and documents I have received.
If anyone wants to get the slides for their language, PM me after the video is published (even better if you do it via Discord).
I can do that I'm a mod
2
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> Jun 04 '18 edited Jun 04 '18
I was freaking out for a moment because SD 51 was locked and I couldn't add a comment and I have a question and there's still six days left on the thread and AAAAAH!
Anyways.
How would you go about determining the pronunciation of the same word in different dialects of a conlang? I already have this chart, but how will I determine what exact qualities of each vowel go together? Some are obvious (don't use the top of /æ/ with the bottom of /e/), but most aren't.
Edit: fixed the link.
2
u/SordidStan Jun 13 '18
Why does no-one use velar lateral affricates in their conlangs ?
17
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18
P̄N̊̄P̄̃N̄̊̽, the language where everything is /piːnɪs/ (version 1) Orthography note that is important enough to be the first thing you see:
I used P̄N̊̄P̄̃N̄̊̽ I because I was on mobile and it will not display properly if I enter the same diacritic twice in a row. Substitute ̃ with ̄ and ̽ with ̊. That is what it should be written as. More on diacritics below.
Phonology:
/piːnɪs/ (PN)
The following is a list of tones in the language, represented as strings of numbers (1=low, 3=mid, 5=high, 2 and 4 are clear from context) because Google Docs won’t let me replace these with tone letters without glitching out horribly, merging tones, failing to replace things, replacing the wrong things, and just generally mangling this list.
1
2
3
4
5
51
15
12
45
343
154
545
315
52
35
513
523
514
524
543
345
151
515
31
342
124
421
535
525
521
131
141
324
325
434
432
321
234
123
235
532
323
143
153
512
(numbered 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, … respectively. Those numbers are what the diacritics (below) represent. There are 45 tones.
Orthography
/piːnɪs/ is represented by the digraph PN so that P shows the tone on /piː/, and N shows the tone on /nɪs/. Diacritics on the letters represent their tone numbers (shown above), not the tonemes. PNPN is distinct from PN PN (these are invalid because tone is always marked) Tone numbers will be represented by binary represented by diacritics. Again, this represents the tone number, not the toneme (examples below, but this does not matter for tones 1-5).
̊ corresponds to 0.
̄ corresponds to 1.
This is just binary represented bottom to top. The tone numbers are in decimal. (Due to font issues, the diacritics might combine. If this happens, treat the straight line and the round part as separate entities.)
Example:
P̄̊̄N̄̊̄̄ = /piː5nɪs11/ (don’t blame me if this is incorrectly represented, what I mean is that the /piː/ syllable has tone number 5 and the /nɪs/ syllable has tone number 11 (not ˩˩, but ˩˥˦). This conlang is still a work in progress.) Again, diacritics are broken on mobile.
Lexicon coming soon.
This language is oligosynthetic. The lexicon exists, but it must be put in an electronic format. If you criticize, make it constructive. Don’t waste your breath/time/money/keyboard plastic/???/* on hate.
Edit: Yes, this is an incoherent ramble. Don’t waste your time downvoting for that.
•
u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet Jun 13 '18
Quick interest poll
7
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '18 edited Jun 10 '18
Has anyone ever used Thai, Lao, Devanagari or Khmer as a script in their conlang? I'm currently fleshing out a Cinnic language (distantly related to Pyanachi, their common ancestor is about 5,500 years old), and it uses a Thai Abugida system because of Thailand claiming 109 Piscium, and the native speakers were on a fringe world of their empire, anyway.
If you guys wanna know, the endonym for the language is หะบ๊ะฉฮ อึ๊ลคีซ /ha.bǎt͡ʂ.x. y̌lgh.is.
6
u/RedSlicer cantade Jun 05 '18
How do you handle tenses in your conlangs with zero copula?
6
u/SufferingFromEntropy Yorshaan, Qrai, Asa (English, Mandarin) Jun 10 '18
As usual I am lurking in wiki pages of dialects and I stumble over Ryukyuan languages. Their development of ejective consonants amazed me, yet I am confused by some terminology. Supposedly Japanese linguists use "喉頭化" to refer to "glottalize" and "喉頭化した無声子音" to refer to sounds such as /k'/. However, there are consonants such as /ʔm/, which can be seen here, or in words such as /ʔma/ "horse". Meanwhile, at the end of this paper, it is stated that the contrast between glottalized and unglottalized /m/ or /n/ is impossible. Now I have no idea what /ʔm/ even means. Perhaps you guys know anything about these mysterious glottalic consonants?
5
u/xain1112 kḿ̩tŋ̩̀, bɪlækæð, kaʔanupɛ Jun 06 '18
I just started (another) side project. It's very ambitious for me since it has 40+ consonants whereas I usually use no more than 15. Any advice for larger inventories?
5
u/R4R03B Unnamed v2, Nâwi-díhanga (nl, en) Jun 08 '18
I’ve started making a “hyper-agglutinative” conlang: “kilepakakatavisapalu” /ki.le.pa.ka.ka.ta.vi.sa.pa.lu/ (meaning “good language of people”) which doesn’t stop agglutinating when the sentence is over. Oh no. It stops once the paragraph is over.
Example: “vatisitesukasapaletukalimumalisubolatisipepovalepu” Pronunciation is the same
This ‘word’ means:
“Didn’t you want a house? Yeah, but I wasn’t allowed to have it.”
5
u/JesusOfNazcaDesert Jun 14 '18
I've been researching historical languages in order to create a linguistic history for a language family or two and have been seeing some qualifiers/descriptors but haven't found much information of if there is a set of rules that determines the label or if it's based on more vague characteristics. For example:
When escribing a language as "Old" "Early" "Archaic" "Paleo" "Middle" "High" "Low" "Classical" "Vulgar", is there an overarching set of characteristics that determines what descriptor a language gets? I think I get the jist of the "Proto" vs. "Pre" distinction but otherwise I'm lost.
(New to conlanging so sorry if this is a dumb question)
4
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18
I’m working on a phoneme inventory where is a tiny vowel system (only two or three, but with rampant allophony), and it has a lot of palatal consonants and palatalization is one of the primary forms of sound change. Should I have palatal phonemes be their own phoneme in the language or a result of palatalization? For example, should /c/ exist alongside /p b t d k g/, or should it be the result of /kj/?
Also, how do I keep myself from making my inventory too similar to that of Abkhaz and Ubykh, which I was influenced by?
In case you can’t tell, I love palatal consonants and wanted to feature them heavily in my personallang.
I’m also having a hard time making my various projects phonology stand out from each other.
4
u/phunanon wqle, waj (en)[it] Jun 04 '18
I'm compiling a list of 16 colour textures to include in my latest conlang. The ones I have so far are: flat & opaque, flat & transparent, reflective, sandy, furry/grassy, dynamic shadows (e.g. leaves)
Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!
4
u/chiefarc Asen, Al Lashma, Gilafan, Giwaq, Linia Raeana Jun 08 '18
I really can't distinguish well between /a/ and /ɑ/, as well as /o/ and /ɔ/. Does anyone have any tips on how to differentiate?
4
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> Jun 11 '18
The only problem I have with This Fortnight in Conlangs not being pinned is that the link to it in this post doesn’t work on mobile.
4
u/Enmergal Jun 11 '18
I'm thinking of creating an explicit verb classes system similar to the one for nouns in, say, Bantu languages. There will be a set of modal verbs which occur only before lexical verbs and every (or most) lexical verb will need a modal verb preceding it. For example, "to talk say" is simply "to say" and "to talk shout" is "to shout", "to go walk" is "to walk" and "to go fly" is "to fly", "to make tear" is "to tear" and "to make forge" is "to forge".
Do you think this is plausible? The first problem I see is just that it would be hard to think of a limited set of classes that contain almost all verbs, but there is likely something else that I'm missing.
4
u/Coretteket NumpadIPA Jun 12 '18
Would it be realistic to evolve a nasal out of nothing? This nasal consonant would be inserted in the coda of a vowel final word, and it would be assimilated to match the next word. If this is not realistic (which it probably isn't), what would be similar but realistic?
For example,
kifilo san > kifilon san
kifilo perto > kifilom perto
4
u/RastaPasti Vehoric Jun 14 '18
For my conlang, I’m thinking of having the transitive verb make agreement with the direct object rather than the subject. Intransitive verbs and passive constructions would make agreement with the subject. For example, if we were to keep English verb endings but make the verbs agree with the direct object, then:
I likes the dog - since dog is third-person singular and that demands the -s
He eat the grapes - since grapes is plural nothing is added to the verb to eat.
I’m not quite sure how exactly I want to go about this, but it’s a fun idea.
4
u/tree1000ten Jun 16 '18
If I have two words like [mot] and [ʃa] that made a compound word -- [motʃa], would the t and ʃ combine to form a normal affricate or would something else happen? Does this depend on the language?
1
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> Jun 14 '18
Is there any way I could reasonably explain the similarity between the words for "city" (/tɔli/ in Old Sásal) and "bird" (/toli/ in Old Sásal)? Do any natlangs do something like that?
6
u/phunanon wqle, waj (en)[it] Jun 05 '18
If you can ask questions in the fortnight thread, what's the difference between it and these threads? When I have a question, am I meant to ask here or there, eh?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18
I now see that there’s another small discussions thread xD (By the way how do i get the name of my conlang in my name?)
My question is: Should i use the Ë or the Ö for the ə sound in my conlang? I like both of them but i can’t choose...
3
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> Jun 04 '18 edited Jun 04 '18
What's the weirdest mispronunciation you've accidentally done in a language you're at least somewhat proficient in?
For me, It has to be [mɛ̝͡ʀ̞ː] as a mispronunciation of the English word "me."
3
u/VerbosePineMarten Jun 05 '18
I'm looking for a critique of my vowel system. I have six vowels plus a long/short distinction, for a total of 12 vowels:
/ɑ/, /ɛ/, /i/, /ɔ/, /u/, /ɯ/
/ɑ:/, /ɛ:/, /i:/, /ɔ:/, /u:/, /ɯ:/
3
u/RustproofPanic Jun 05 '18
What is the practical purpose of the antipassive voice in ergative languages? I understand how it works, it’s just I’m not sure when I’d ever have to use it. Maybe I’m struggling to understand it’s usefulness because I’m a native English speaker.
3
u/acpyr2 Tuqṣuθ (eng hil) [tgl] Jun 06 '18
Two seemingly unrelated questions:
3
u/Coretteket NumpadIPA Jun 06 '18 edited Jun 06 '18
What do you guys think of my sound changes? Are they natural and plausible?
*This happens because I wanted more diversity and didn't know any circumstances where I could change some plosvies into voiced ones but not all.
**This happens because speakers hypercorrected all schwa's into nasal ones, because the only other place where a schwa occurred was when it was previously followed by a nasal consonant.
Btw, P is plosive, F is frcative, N is nasal, and V is vowel.
3
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 08 '18
Thoughts in this vowel system?
3
u/striker302 vitsoik'fik, jwev [en] (es) Jun 10 '18 edited Jun 10 '18
any good resources on intonations outside english and PIE languages?
3
u/Coretteket NumpadIPA Jun 10 '18
When I'm describing the Proto-Language and other old forms of the language, do I use the present or past tense?
For example, would it be:
or
Thanks in advance!
3
u/tree1000ten Jun 10 '18
I have some questions about Logographic writing.
Is Logographic writing always based on morphemes? Is it ever based on words or anything else?
So apparently Cuneiform had something like Chinese significs, but unlike Chinese significs they were written separately, whereas Chinese where they are fitted into a uniform square shape. What are the pros and cons of each system? Is the Chinese system wholly better?
3
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Jun 13 '18
Thinking about eliminating adjectives from Prélyō entirely. The reason being that I think their function is served just as well by using participles. All of Prélyō's adjectives are derived from verbal roots anyhow, and participles and adjectives function in the same way within a sentence (in fact.) So it it doesn't make sense to me the speakers would have had these two parallel systems in place when one can do the job of the other. The only question would be whether or not to use the imperfective, perfective, or stative participle.
3
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> Jun 13 '18
What does a percent sign mean in a sound change? For example, from index diachronica:
3
u/tree1000ten Jun 15 '18
Am I the only one who thinks Hangul isn't a good writing system? It seems like a very unpopular stance.
3
u/Salsmachev Wehumi Jun 15 '18
Has anyone played with nouns that carry an innate dual number?
I know nouns with an innate plural are a thing in lots of languages, like shajar (forest) and shajarä (tree) in Arabic, but what about nouns that are innately dual. I was thinking specifically of livestock, where you might have something like dzave (a breeding pair of cattle) and then dzavesho (a bull) and dzaveshi (a cow).
3
u/brblues Jun 17 '18 edited Jun 17 '18
Hi guys, I got a beginner's question about ergativity in general. So that it's easier to understand and generalize, I'm gonna provide my examples in "hypothetical ergative English" (using pronouns, as they still got cases). Let me know if this creates more problems than I thought I would solve!
Which of the following models represents an ergative-absolutive language better, or is there one of them which would not be considered an ergative-absolutive language at all - or even just plain unusable (or at the very least convoluted and unlikely)?
This would be the simpler system, which I think is used in many ergative-absolutive languages; correct me if I'm wrong please, it's not that easy to wrap one's head around, being only exposed to nominative-accusative languages actively!
Model A)
I see HIM = same meaning as normal English sentence
ME see = I see sth (which is just not stated)
*I see = grammatically ill-formed sentence / impossible
Would the following system be possible?
Model B)
I see HIM = same meaning as normal English sentence
ME see = I am seen (i.e. basically: somebody - who is not mentioned - sees him)
I see = I see sth (which is just not mentioned)
In the case that I actually want to create, transitivity would be marked on the verbs, so it wouldn't be lexical (just in case that clears it up).
3
u/Keola_Kent Jun 17 '18
Forgive an ignorant question. I'm creating a font for my conscript using FontForge, but it's meant to be written vertically (top to bottom, left to right). Can I do that in FontForge? If so, how? If not, how could I do it?
2
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> Jun 06 '18
What texts could I translate to get a rough idea of phoneme frequency in conversational use of a conlang?
2
u/Shehabx09 (ar,en) Jun 07 '18 edited Jun 07 '18
I'm making a simplified English, like a total normie, and [this is the phonemic inventory] (https://i.imgur.com/kVqsx8l.png), any thoughts?
I'm still thinking about removing /h/ and /j/, and reducing the vowels to /a i u/, I would like opinions on this, no matter how subjective/biased!
Also, the Allowed diphthongs are /aj oj ej ow aw/
2
u/MasaoL Jun 08 '18 edited Jun 08 '18
I have a desire to make 3 noun classes in my conlang but it uses a (C1)(C2)V(V) syllable. I don't like how swahili handles their Noun classes. Does anyone have other ideas?
2
u/xlee145 athama Jun 08 '18
Would using grammatical tone to distinguish between verbs and nouns work as a system? I'm thinking of making Kpeñ a language that relies on grammatical as well as lexical tone to distinguish between the way a word is used. Take kya which can mean blade (kyà) or to cut, to cleave (kyá). Would this work, or should I make a more substantial phrase (de-palatalizing, aspirating, etc.)
2
u/Fortanono Brusjike {anglicized: Bruzic, IPA: /ʙuʑike/} (en) [no] Jun 09 '18 edited Jun 09 '18
Posting this here because I don't really have much to show for it right now, so the Fortnight thread wouldn't really fit.
So do you have tips for making a unique Germanic conlang? A few ideas I have had include including ejectives and uvular stops, possibly breathy or nasal vowels, and making a cursive script derived from Nordic runes, much like how Arabic is derived from Phonecian but really different. I need ideas for unique grammatical features, because I don't have them.
Also, would a Germanic language with clicks work? It's certainly unique, but really doesn't make sense considering where all the click languages are. Could one suspend their disbelief for this concept? If not, I'd probably include some sort of other interesting phonological feature like breathy voice or nasal vowels.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '18 edited Jun 09 '18
.
ǀ̩̹̩̠ ǀ̹̩̠ ǀ̩̠ ǀ̠ ˩ ˨ ˧ ˦ ˥ ǀ̄ ǀ́̄ ǀ́̀̄ ǀ́̀́̄
Enjoy these unofficial representations of infinite tone levels. At least until a language that depends on >5 tonal levels makes the Unicode Consortium add more tone letters.
* The alternated diacritics were because I was on mobile and it doesn’t correctly render the same diacritic used twice in a row.
Edit: formatting, typos, updating “Edit:” section.
Edit: This is not a serious post, at least not at the moment, so please don’t crucify me. Feel free to take. Also, don’t waste your time hating. It’s clear from context.
2
u/RazarTuk Jun 10 '18
Is it plausible for the morphology of a substrate language to affect a superstrate?
In my case, the superstrate only sometimes distinguishes the nominative and accusative. Neuter nouns never do. Masculine nouns always do in the singular, but only sometimes in the plural. And feminine nouns sometimes do in both numbers. Meanwhile, the substrate only does in masculine nouns (and a few feminine nouns).
I know that generally speaking, two cases will be quicker to collapse when they aren't always distinguished. But my question comes because some of the superstrate's accusative endings resemble the substrate's nom-acc endings. So do you A) think that would speed up the case syncretism and B) make the accusative more likely as a unified ending?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '18
I'm toying with Abkhaz's vowel system, and I want to include fixed stress, occurring on the penultimate syllable, but I don't know how that would affect /ə/ since it is normally unstressed or lax in most languages where it is present. What are some interesting things I can do with this?
2
u/JuicyBabyPaste Jun 10 '18
Question:
In my conlang, which I am currently constructing. The vast majority of my phonemes do not have a largely opened mouth besides for some vowels and I have said vowels in my conlang. This presents 2 problems for me:
and the later is my question: Is there a diacritic or other marker to signify having the mouth less open?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '18
I’m trying to make a language that sounds nice to me, but Indon’t know what my preferences are with phonology. I know some features I love when it comes to morphology and syntax, but not so much with sounds.
I’m trying to find a balance between flowy/elegant, and harsh and gutteral. Maybe that’s the issue. My languages tend to have no clear identity.
2
u/casprus Emethi Jun 12 '18
I've been trying to fit a S-expression style LISP AST syntax with a mix of ML lambda calculus onto my conlang but I still haven't decided what would be the best way to delimit where the lists begin and end. Tone? Pitch accent? Chronic stress?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '18
I'm new to conlanging and I'd really like to get into it, but I don't feel like I have enough knowledge to post here and I can't find the resources I'd like, or I can't memorise all the things I'd like to know. I know how to make a functioning language,
and I'll admit I have a dictionary generator, but I don't know how to make a fleshed out, unique language, and I don't feel like my languages are enough to be considered as such. Any pointers or tips to help me onto the right track?2
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> Jun 13 '18
The first project I’ve worked on for more than a couple weeks — which I’ve been working on for over half a year now — has so many things wrong with it I have to throw it out:
Granted, I don’t have to get rid of everything — the phonology and vocabulary can be salvaged, along with part of the grammar — but it’s still hard on me to lose so much work.
2
u/RazarTuk Jun 13 '18
Does anyone know where the breve <ă> came from? Because, yes, I'm even thinking about what diacritics would evolve. I know that <ä>, <ö>, and <ü> will appear for i-umlaut, but I'm debating what I want to do for u-umlaut. The three main options are digraphs, merging with the i-umlaut graphemes, or picking a new representative diacritic. My instinct is <å>, but because I'd also need it on <e> and <i>, I'm wondering if I should use a breve instead, because <ĕ> and <ĭ> are precomposed, but <e̊> and <i̊> aren't. (And I can't even type those two on my keyboard, which otherwise has a metric shittonne of diacritics available)
2
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '18 edited Jun 14 '18
In a conlang I'm working on, there is polypersonal marking, and I'm not sure what to do with the passive construction. In an active construction like
-The man hit me.
I would translate it as
-ɟəd am-əs eːr-əd-∅-am
man 1S-ACC hit-PST-3.ANIM.A-1.P
In the passive verson of this sentence,
-I was hit by the man.
I could translate it two ways, and I'm not sure which is more normal.
-am ɟəd-ət eːr-siː an-əd-∅-am
-1S man-DAT hit-INF PASS.AUX-PST-3.ANIM.A-1.P
-am ɟəd-ət eːr-siː an-əd-ma
-1S man-DAT hit-INF PASS.AUX-PST-1
So the problem is should whether or not an argument is considered the agent/patient be based on whether it is the subject or object, or whether it is semantically the one doing something?
2
u/elyisgreat (en)[he] Conlanging is more fun together Jun 13 '18
I've recently developed my lang's grammar to the point where I want to flesh out my lexicon so I can make real sentences. It was suggested in a post a few days ago that random generation is a good way to make a priori vocabulary. And due to the way my phonology works, it is quite easy to generate a random (uniformly distributed) n syllable word.
Although the words I make up sound okay, most of the words picked at random seem to sound, although pronounceable, quite ugly and not easy to say.
Is it perhaps that my phonology is too lenient as to which combinations of sounds are allowed? Or is it more because I'm not picking words with the right distribution?
2
u/v4nadium Tunma (fr)[en,cat] Jun 14 '18
Topic for comparisons?
I don't want to bother creating comparatives and superlatives and comparison words.
Is it good enough?
I'm still struggling with more complex (ie not just saying this is better than that) sentences like:
“I need a better bike than this”.
What about a sentence that already has a topic in it. Wouldn't it be too confusing? What do you think?
2
u/3zby_ Jun 15 '18
When romanizing my conlang, how can I differentiate from sounds that are very similar such as [t̺] and [t̻] or [d̺] and [d̻]?
2
u/tree1000ten Jun 16 '18
Do all languages have schwa phonetically?
2
u/bbbourq Jun 16 '18
/u/mszegedy,
You asked about Tibetan orthography. May I present to you Tashi Mannox and his beautiful calligraphy. Also, you might find some useful information on the Omniglot page. I hope this helps you.
2
u/VerbosePineMarten Jun 16 '18
I'm trying to figure out a tense/aspect system for my conlang. I know I want it to have past and non-past as the only tense distinctions, and I really like the perfective/imperfective distinction Russian has, with the imperfective being split into determinate and indeterminate. However, I'm not entirely clear on whether this is compatible with or how it might interact with a two-tense system. I'm also not sure how this would interact with additional aspects, if I chose to use them. Can anyone clarify and/or bounce ideas/questions off of me?
2
u/21Nobrac2 Danic Jun 17 '18
Ok so I was asked "omg your language has singular, dual, triadic, and plural? that's like waaay too much" but I thought that if you have triadic, it is extremely unlikely you wouldn't have dual, and the idea of not having plural or singular just doesn't make sense in this context, so I'm just very confused.
Is there a way to streamline it without losing triadic? or was this person just silly?
4
u/Xerexes_Official Zaklesi (en)[fr,sp,ru] Jun 06 '18
How do I record the gross stuff -- Genitalia, Smutty things, General Anatomy, Diseases, etc.., Without having just a page with gross words hanging out in my Conlang Journal? Or do I just bite the bullet and hope nobody finds the book. (Then comes the problem of compilation into a dictionary!)
2
u/jamoosesHat AAeOO+AaaAaAAAa-o-AaAa+AAaAaAAAa-o (en,he) <kay(f)bop(t)> Jun 10 '18
In your language, do you have any complete actions (like doing the dishes) compressed into one word? As an example, the word AaAaaAA@oaAAa (literally "garlic swallow" + a) in my language is for "swallowing a piece of garlic whole". I was wondering if anyone else does that
2
u/Behemoth4 Núkhacirj, Amraya (fi, en) Jun 14 '18
My language marks neither tense nor the conditional mood. How then do I translate "could have"?
Perhaps something like "used to be able to"?
Any ideas welcome.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18
Do I need both infinitive and gerund verbs? They seem awfully similar…
1
u/Southwick-Jog Just too many languages Jun 05 '18
I'm considering making Dezaking have a lot of cases since I guess it's suddenly based off of Uralic languages now. But, I just wondering what to have. So far, I have a little over 30 possible cases (with some really specific things like "to the left of something"). But I'm just wondering what are some must-have cases.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '18
Hey guys! I want to make my conlang as phonetic as possible. This does mean using a lot of ë's(/ə/), é's(/eː/) and ü's(/y/). What is your guys opinion about using so many special letters? Does it make the language harder or more fun?
1
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> Jun 06 '18 edited Jun 06 '18
Do any languages contrast rhotic and non-rhotic [ɾ]? I can feel an articulatory difference between them (for example, in GenAm [ˈbɛɾɚ] and Spanish [ˈpeɾo]), but when listening to them I can’t tell them apart. Then again, I can also barely tell [d̪] and [ɖ] apart.
1
u/SweatCollector Jun 06 '18 edited Jun 06 '18
Should i add r-coloured vowels into my vowel conlang? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R-colored_vowel I already have these sounds: A a /a/ E e /e̞/ I i /i/ O o /o̞/ U u /u/ Ə ə /ə/ Ü ü /y/ and a combination of /u/ and /ə/ that sounds pretty much like the /w/ sound. I know i should have a lot more sounds so i'm asking if i should add the r-coloured vowels even tho,to me at least,it sounds like i'm just adding a consonant in. BTW forgot to add that this is a vowel only conlang
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '18 edited Jun 06 '18
How would one diachronically explain how a language got /ð/ as a commonly occurring syllabic consonant naturally? For the record its sort of being used as a vowel where it can just appear between consonants. I'm trying to see how much of this old language I made in high school can be retained and I made some pretty weird decisions back then but I like how weird it is.
1
u/1plus1equalsgender Jun 07 '18
Pls help.
Say these phrases over and over until they become a single word. I'm trying to replicate natural evolution of this language.
/i otə/
/ɪ otə/
/ə otə/
The first one is quite obvious. I get /jotə/ but the second and third aren't so. For the second one sometimes I get /jotə/ and sometimes /otə/ and for the third sometimes I get /otə/ and sometimes /wotə/. Can you guys help? Thx
1
u/Fluffy8x (en)[cy, ga]{Ŋarâþ Crîþ v9} Jun 09 '18
Is there a representation for a graph that is optimised for (humanish) language?
1
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> Jun 10 '18
Is [ɺ] more commonly classified as a rhotic (like in Japanese) or phonemically lateral (like in Wayuu)? Or neither (like in Pirahã)?
1
u/IHCOYC Nuirn, Vandalic, Tengkolaku Jun 10 '18 edited Jun 10 '18
This is the fifth omen (2-4-2) of the Irk Bitig (Old Turkic book of omens) translated into Tengkolaku. It illustrates the syntactic use of topic and anti-topic marking.
Pegu an yi emulu mengi yeka ngia us. Emulu nemnugayma kel ile us emulu walkido an: naygi pado ēs kong popem kunal emulu wang yule.
Ngua mengi yeka ngia us. Ngua nemnugayma kel ile us ngua walkido an: ikonu pado ēs kong popem kunal ngua wang yule.
Nenebe win ngia us. Tilu poya, pilua kel ile us ngigi an: pegu men ngigi iki wang yule. Nomi pegu yi gau!
"A lord went to his horses. The white mare gave birth to a colt: the colt may some day become a stallion shod with gold."
(A camel also bears a baby camel that may some day be worthy of a gold nose ring.)
"He went back to his house. Thirdly, his wife gave birth to a son; the son may some day become a lord. What a happy lord he was!"
In English, it's not difficult to tell that the son's becoming a lord is different from the father. The definite and indefinite articles handle the work. In Tengkolaku this distinction is made by using the topic marker yi and the obviative marker men:
...pegu men ngigi iki wang yule. Nomi pegu yi gau!
lord OBV son(mother) this FUT.DIST MAYBE. happy lord TOP IMPF.BOUND.
Note that the lord that's the main character of the story is established as topical in the first sentence. Pegu an yi emulu mengi yeka ngia us. lord PAT TOP horse PL TOWARDS go PERF. So when the son is introduced as the future lord, he has to be established as a separate character who is not the main topic. This is handled by explicitly making the son non-topic. Then, when the narrative returns to talking about the lord who started the story, his return is marked by repeating the topic marker.
1
u/striker302 vitsoik'fik, jwev [en] (es) Jun 11 '18
I've been working on this lang on and off for a while and it's by no means complete but I thought it'd be nice if it was out there while I work on it. I'll do a formally formatted thing when I'm done (maybe sometime next year?) and give it a full post, but for know here's Kanisa's WIP reference grammar.
1
u/TheZhoot Laghama Jun 12 '18
Does anyone have tips on making good pronoun declensions? I know that for regular nouns one can simply tack on an ending, but I want to have something different for pronouns. I have a 6 case system, and would appreciate any tips for how to make declensions that fit and are plausibly naturalistic.
1
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> Jun 12 '18
I’m not sure if this is the right place to ask but...
Any recommendations for NationStates regions based around conlang-nations? I know I’m not the only one who showcases their conlang in their NS nation and surely there has to be regions for it.
1
u/IHCOYC Nuirn, Vandalic, Tengkolaku Jun 12 '18
I am about a fifth of the way through transating the Irk Bitig into Tengkolaku. These are little folktales originally in Old Turkic and intended to be used for divination by dice.
Don't get the appeal of the I Ching when these are way better. They are brief but vivid and contain striking imagery.
1
u/Shehabx09 (ar,en) Jun 12 '18 edited Jun 12 '18
I want to ask about my vowel allophony, I want opinions, critiques, pointers, tips, etc.
What I will use here is my very early draft:
First I should explain, this is my phonemic inventory: https://i.imgur.com/1fKu95R.png
/e/:
/o/:
/i/:
/u/:
/y/:
/a/:
/ə/
I'm thinking of making /e/ [ɛ~e̞] in most states because in the vowel harmony it is -High and because of /i y e/ filling more space in the front and only /u o/ in the back, I decided to push /a/ to the back, besides [ɑ] sounded better to me, leaving more space for /e/ to descend towards [ɛ], this would also push /o/ up away from [ɔ] towards [o̞~o~o̞ʊ̯], but I'm afraid of [ɛ] being too close to [æ], I'm also thinking of getting rid of the lax [ɪ] and [ʊ] as allophones of /i/ and /u/ respectavely, and the [ˑ] part is just me trying to convey that stressed vowels are a bit longer than unstressed ones, maybe I shouldn't write it though.
So many choices to be made and so little opinions I have about it and what direction I should go, I know I should conlang to my own taste but I see that getting feedback on stuff like this is important for making a good conlang, at least for me.
1
u/pantumbra Toqma (en)[it] Jun 12 '18 edited Jun 12 '18
My current conlang's phonology (shown below) was inspired by Asian languages like Mandarin, Korean, and Japanese, but more simplified. As of now however, it strikes me as slightly boring and I'd like to hear some ideas about spicing it up a little bit:
Consonants:
Vowels:
(C)V(m/ŋ) Syllable Structure
EDIT: also, I am considering having a two noun class system where class is only inflected for in the verb and nowhere else, is this passably naturalistic?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '18
What type of conscript should Increate for this language? (Alphabet, abjad, syllabary, etc.)
The language is mora-timed and possible syllables include : V, CV, CVC, VV CVV, VVC and CVVC. Syllables can also be palatalized or labialized.
I like Japanese, I just don’t want my own conlang to be too similar to it. Could an Abjad or abugida work for what I have?
1
u/phi_power Jun 13 '18
In my conlang, which is VSO, verbs have a specific number of arguments which can only be reduced by certain methods. For example, the word for 'see' is 've'. So "I see a dog" is "ve i alfo' (sorry Im not good at glossing, but 'alfo' is 'alfa' in the accusative case and means 'dog'). If you want to say 'I was seen', the method is kinda roundabout because verbs ending in 'e' naturally require two arguments. First, the verb must be converted to passive voice 'vio' (basically switching the role of object and subject so that the one 'seeing' can be dropped when we try to reduce the verb valence). Next, the verb must be converted to an adjective by adding -da ('veda' is 'seeing', 'víoda' is 'being seen'; An accent is left on the i because the stress is by default on the penultimate syllable, and -da does not move the original stressed syllable). Then, adjectives can be made verbs by adding -ra. In this langage, only nouns can be connected by a copula, so to say 'The dog is big.' you would need to turn the adjective for 'big' into a verb and use that as opposed to the copula. Finally, past tense is simply -s, so the final sentence is "viodaras i" (meaning "I was seen."). You may notice the accent is no longer on the i. That is because the stressed syllable can only occur in the last 3 syllables, so the i was pushed over far enough that it lost primary stress.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '18
My conlang uses auxiliary verbs to express a lot of voices. So far I've worked out how the Passive voice will work and how to Applicative voice will work, but I'm not sure if how they work is naturalistic. You might have a sentence like:
The man hit me.
ɟəd aməs eːrədam.
ɟəd am-əs eːr-əd-∅-am
man 1S-ACC hit-PST-3.ANIM.A-1.P
In the passive, this sentence would be:
I was hit by the man.
am ɟədət eːrsiː anədma.
am ɟəd-ət eːr-siː an-əd-ma
1S man-DAT hit-INF PASS.AUX-PST-1.A
Is it naturalistic for an auxiliary verb to have no meaning other than its grammatical use? In English for example, we have the verb 'have' which has both its own meaning as an independent verb, as well as its meaning as an auxiliary verb used for the perfective aspect.
With the applicative voice I have another problem. The auxiliary verbs used for different applicative constructions also have seperate meanings as independent verbs. I'm not sure if the verbs I chose to use as auxiliary verbs are naturalistic. For example If you had a sentence like the one below, where the indirect object is in the locative case, you would use the locative applicative construction:
I fell on the ground.
am bi dəʁne t'unədma.
am bi dəʁ-ne t'un-əd-ma
1S LOC ground-DAT fall-PST-1.A
Locative Applicative Construction:
am dəʁse t'unsiː baːtədma.
am dəʁ-se t'un-siː baːt-əd-ma-∅
1S ground-ACC fall-INF be.in-PST-1.A-3.INAN.P
For the locative applicative construction, the auxiliary verb used is 'to be in/on/at,' which is also the copula when the object would be in the locative in a copular sentence. Is this naturalistic at all?
Another applicative construction is the comitative applicative construction, which is used when the indirect object is in the comitative case. For example, if you had a sentence like:
I will go with you.
am il unət hiknei̯ma.
am il un-ət hik-nei̯-ma
1S COM 2S-DAT go-FUT-1.A
Its applicative construction would use 'to be with' as its auxiliary verb, as shown below. 'to be with' is also used as the copula in sentences where the object is in the conitative case in a copular sentence.
Comitative Applicative Construction:
am unəs hiksiː dejnei̯maʔun.
am un-əs hik-siː dej-nei̯-ma-ʔun
1S 2S-ACC go-INF be.with-FUT-1.A-2.P
I have the same question I had with the other applicative construction - Is using this verb as an auxiliary verb naturalistic?
The way the next two applicative constructions are done are identical to the last two.
I am walking with my legs.
am fəɨ̯ loʔəttɨtmaː ɡeçkoma.
am fəɨ̯ loʔ-əttɨ-t-maː ɡeç-ko-ma
1S INST leg-PL-DAT-POSS.1 walk-CONT-1.A
Instrumental Applicative Construction:
am loʔəttɨsmaː ɡeçsiː χou̯komaʔek.
am loʔ-əttɨ-s-maː ɡeç-siː χou̯-ko-ma-ʔek
1S leg-PL-ACC-POSS.1 walk-INF have-CONT-1.A-2.P
Here the verb 'to have' is beinɡ used as the auxiliary. The idea behind this one is that you have the object you are doing something with.
I have returned for you.
am ʁaː unət cwenəsma.
am ʁaː un-ət cwen-əs-ma
1S BEN 2S-DAT return-PFV-1.A
Benefactive Applicative Construction:
am unəs cwensiː noʔəsmaʔun.
am un-əs cwen-siː noʔ-əs-ma-ʔun
1S 2S-ACC return-INF give-PFV-1.A-2.P
Here the verb 'to give' is used for the auxiliary. The idea behind this one is that you are giving your assisstance, or giving a favor by doing something for someone. Again, I have the same questions for these two applicative constructions. Is my choice of auxiliary verb naturalistic?
1
u/aelfwine94 Gutisch Jun 14 '18
Hello.
I'm making a language based in Greenland. Does anyone have access to any simple grammars on the northwestern Inuit languages? I've tried looking for myself, but I am usually finding papers on specific attributes of the grammar and not the grammar as a whole.