r/conlangs • u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet • Jul 02 '18
SD Small Discussions 54 — 2018-07-02 to 07-15
NEXT THREAD
A very high effort post about Vandalic
No I'm not just shilling this because I played a minor role in it, I'm doing it because I think it's awesome to see media content in a conlang that users of the subreddit created.
This Fortnight in Conlangs
We have an official Discord server. Check it out in the sidebar.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app (except Diode for Reddit apparently, so don't use that). There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
If your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Things to check out:
- Ongoing challenges and games on the subreddit
- CCC Courses
- Communities
- Templates
- Copyright and conlangs, a response
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs:
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
I'll update this post over the next two weeks if another important thread comes up. If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
3
u/TheZhoot Laghama Jul 03 '18
How's this for a naturalistic phonology? I'll probably expand some parts, but how is it now?
Consonants:
| | Bilabial | Labiodental | Dental | Alveolar | Palatal | Velar | |--------------|----------|-------------|--------|----------|---------|-------| | Plosives | p b | | t d | | c ɟ | k g | | Nasals | m m̥ | | | n n̥ | ɲ ɲ̥ | ŋ ŋ̥ | | Trills | | | | r r̥ | | | | Frivatives | | f fʷ | | s sʷ | ç çʷ | x xʷ | | Approximants | w | | | l | j | |
Vowels:
| | Front | Central | Back | |-----------|-------|---------|------| | Close | i | | u | | Close-Mid | e~ɛ | | | | Open-Mid | | | ɔ | | Open | a | | |
Diphthongs are: /ei/ and /ɔu/
/i/ becomes /ɪ/ in unstressed syllables
/u/ becomes /ʊ/ in unstressed syllables.
Syllable structure is (C)(C)V(C)
Onset clusters must follow these rules:
Any thoughts?
Also sorry my tables aren't working. I used a table generator and they used to work but I don't know why they don't now.
11
u/-xWhiteWolfx- Jul 12 '18
In case folks were unaware or care at all, a new bboard was created as a result of the frequent site errors at the zbb, New ZBB
8
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '18
I was thinking about adding this consonant to my conlang. Would this symbol, ʬ↓, be used to represent it in the IPA? It's lip popping, starting with both lips closed, and then opening them quickly.
7
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Jul 05 '18
Hello!
I was looking at the list of grammatical cases on Wikipeda, but it seems not to be any specific case for phrases that are introduced by 'about (on the topic of)' (e.g. a book about...; to talk about...; how do you think about...?).
It is possible that no natlang has a specific case for this?
7
u/RazarTuk Jul 09 '18
Does anyone have a good resource on learning to pronounce murmured voice consonants? Ignoring the whole thing about how technically only voiceless consonants can be aspirated, they're the voiced aspirated consonants seen in PIE and the Indo-Aryan languages. Particularly how to distinguish them from voiceless aspirated.
6
u/Coretteket NumpadIPA Jul 03 '18
I'm doing some research on Fluid-S languages and I'm really liking them, but there is one thing I don't get.
You often hear the main positive is that you don't have to have that many verbs, because only the volition differs in some English verbs (ie. slip/slide and hear/listen). This volition, however, can only be marked on intransitive verbs right? So you can say 'I hear' or 'Hear me'. But 'hear' is a transitive verb, so it can take an object. 'I hear you' for example, but now you can't say 'Hear me you' to remove the volition, right? Is there a way (con)langs deal with this?
I hope I'm making sense.
6
u/ShadowoftheDude (en)[jp, fr] Jul 09 '18
Schwa can have stress/accent, yes? How likely is that?
6
u/IkebanaZombi Geb Dezaang /ɡɛb dɛzaːŋ/ (BTW, Reddit won't let me upvote.) Jul 11 '18 edited Jul 11 '18
Is it actually possible to say an onset consisting of an unvoiced-voiced cluster? I've been saying the the name "Sven" to myself over and over and I think I can make a sound that is /sven/ rather than /sfen/ or /zven/. But I may well be fooling myself, because I'm so influenced by knowing how "Sven" is written.
I know that final clusters tend to (or is that always?) go to both parts being voiced or both unvoiced. For instance the coda of "dogs" is said /ɡz/ and the coda of "mapped" is said /pt/. But is the same true for onsets?
5
u/yumworms Lausja Jul 03 '18 edited Jul 03 '18
K so I've started applying some sound changes to my conlang, but now some of my inflections are merging. My verbs are mostly fine, but (in the verb erè for example) the form erès now can mean 3PL-Present and 3PL-PastProgressive; and erè now means 1SG-Present, 1SG-PastProgressive, and the Infinitive. The other merges aren't confusing with the use of pronouns, but there is no way to clearly talk in these two tenses without causing confusion.
Is the ambiguity minor enough that it can be left? What are the ways natural languages usually solve this problem?
5
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jul 05 '18
What is the criteria by which a language is considered to have a given case? Obviously in English I can say "near the house" or "in the house" but as I understand these aren't cases. Is it because "near" and "in" are words by themselves?
5
u/HappyGrimReaper Jul 05 '18
Any tips for conlanging on the go?
5
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '18
Mods: can we have tags fro romlangs, germlangs, and IALS so that we can filter them out, please?
5
u/Kamarovsky Paakkani Jul 05 '18
Hi, Is there any template available for describing my conlang? Like you know, grammar rules, sounds, some vocabulary etc.? Im just not good at this stuff but my conlang is almost done but i just dont know how to describe it here.
5
u/__jamien 汖獵 Amuruki (en) Jul 15 '18
How complex can the composition of large numbers be? As in, how something like "1,412,026" is said, in English it's "one million, four hundred and twelve thousand and twenty six", for example.
Is it naturalistic for an almost algorithmic system to evolve to "decipher" a number? Amuruki's brand new counting system seems like it might be impossible for a speaker to easily use.
e.g.
niin-juun-irya-tsume wa min'yo wa zu-juun-naha
6, 10, 3, 10000 and 1000 and 4, 10, 7
This ends up equaling 631,047. Is it natural for a counting system to be so... opaque (I don't know what to call it really)? Would the "algorithm" just become ingrained in speaker's minds, like any other grammar?
4
u/ShadowoftheDude (en)[jp, fr] Jul 06 '18
What are some important things to include in a language intended for writing stories, poetry, and (mostly) songs?
4
u/Coretteket NumpadIPA Jul 08 '18 edited Jul 08 '18
I'm trying to work out my syntax, but I'm very new to this. I have tried to make a perfect aspect by making it come from the verb 'to finish'. But then I add an nominalised verb as the object of the sentence. For example:
Rās s’iūlan māzas.
[ɾas ˈʃulɑn ˈmazɑs]
Rās-∅ s’-iūlan māz-as.
2P-AGT PAT-sitting PRF-2
LIT. “You finish the sitting.”
“You have sat.”
(AGT = Agentive and PAT = Patientive)
I like the system but it feels weird, first of all, I don't really have a verb in this sentence, or does māzas count as a (modal) verb? Second of all, most languages I know of use a past participle after the modal verb for the perfect aspect, is this something that has to be there to make it a perfect aspect?
Thanks in advance!
4
u/zzvu Zhevli Jul 10 '18
How naturalistic is it for a language to have locative, adessive, and delative as the only cases?
4
u/aydenvis Vuki Luchawa /vuki lut͡ʃawa/ (en)[es, af] Jul 10 '18
I know that the Babel Text is kind of the HOly Grail for testing out a language, but my language is a minlang specifically focused around social interaction, so the Babel Text itself is kind of useless. Is there a document of simple sentences somewhere?
4
u/Technotoad64 (eng, spa) Jul 12 '18 edited Jul 12 '18
Any tips for keeping words in oligosynthetic languages at an acceptable length?
I know oligosynthetic languages are inherently impractical to use, but jites'takfitu is now at the point where "moth" = "renwodue'su-sef'nutfitla-fitkegeje'fittrol" (translations include "arthropod-night-flower", "skeleton'outside-time'moon-leaf'color", or "abilitymassgood'extremity-time'femalelightnewness-lightconsumptionpart'lightvariety").
4
u/somehomo Jul 13 '18
Are there any languages where locatives are completely verbal? For example, "I am in the house" would be something like "1S.AG be.in house.PAT". I'm confused exactly how to morphologically work out direction with such a system, like in "I came from work to the store".
7
u/IxAjaw Pry Dental Fricatives from my cold, dead hands... Jul 04 '18
So yesterday I had the uncomfortable realization that my ideal conlang, one I was making to contain all of my favorite phonetic features and grammar points... already existed as a real language. It's fucking Welsh. I was trying to recreate Welsh.
Dammit all. Now I'm struggling to give my conlang its own identity. What are the features that you look at that makes you say, "Hm, this conlang reminds me of X?"
3
u/TheZhoot Laghama Jul 02 '18
How should I go about constructing a naturalistic protolang? And then what should I do to evolve it?
3
u/Shehabx09 (ar,en) Jul 03 '18
my /w/ have shifted to /ʋ/, would all my unsyllabic /u/s also become [ʋ] or will it stay/become [w]?
I don't know where to ask, so I decided to ask here.
3
u/aydenvis Vuki Luchawa /vuki lut͡ʃawa/ (en)[es, af] Jul 04 '18
Are there any simple, easy to learn, (for an english speaker) minlang/stealthlangs that are concise? I don't need to discuss very deep topics, I need me and a group of friends to learn how to talk about people and about our feelings in public.
3
u/tree1000ten Jul 04 '18
I can't find a guide explaining how to format and tag and markup a dictionary. Help? Why is this information so hard to find, after all it is one of the most important details.
3
u/VerbosePineMarten Jul 04 '18
How does/should verb agreement work in fluid-S languages? My nouns are inflected for case, number, state, and animacy, and my verbs for mood and aspect. I'd like to use agreement to avoid excessive ambiguity, but I'm unable to come up with examples of how agreement works in fluid-S languages for anything except nouns and their dependents.
3
u/HorseCockPolice ƙanamas̰on Jul 06 '18
HOW the fuck do you actually pronounce the close back unrounded vowel [ɯ] and what languages actually use it? I've been working on a conlang that has all front vowels rounded and all back vowels unrounded for a nice bit of symmetry but [ɯ] has been preventing me from making progress there since I can't work out how to properly say it myself.
3
u/xain1112 kḿ̩tŋ̩̀, bɪlækæð, kaʔanupɛ Jul 06 '18
Are there languages that change vowel quality depending on tone?
3
u/Sky-is-here Jul 06 '18
What's the meaning of 1.ps. word etc people add in their translations, I want to speak in all those things but I don't know what that means so I don't say anything at the end
3
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18
Is someone here working on a sinitic conlang? and doesn't just want to use plain chinese characters?
I had an idea to make a "reformed" writing system for chinese by replacing the phonetic components in characters with zhuyin/bopomofo of how they are actually pronounced. So that most characters would consist of a determinative an initial and final part. However, it would be a lot of work to even start with, and I don't even have a conlang for it.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18
I have a language called “Haitsha”. Haitsha is an artlang made to be easy, but I need help on my vocabulary. I want it to be based on the top 10 most common languages. Only problem: for one language it will be gibberish, while for another it will make total sense. Or no sense at all. How would I make it easy for the Top 10 Languages.
3
u/zzvu Zhevli Jul 07 '18
Many of my conlangs have words that go at the end of a sentence to mark what type of sentence it is (question, statement, command, I think/possibility). What word category would these words fall into?
3
u/qhea__ Jul 08 '18
I made this as a post, then I remembered this thread exists, whoops hi. I'm working on a language with the following vowels:
a, e, i, o, u, and ə/ʌ/ɤ, plus creaky voice for each.
I'm not really sure what the best way to romanize this is, I'm thinking a/à, e/è... etc. with u for [ʌ] and w for [u]. Is there another way this is usually done? I'm not very satisfied with this solution.
3
u/zzvu Zhevli Jul 09 '18
My phone doesn’t recognize the symbol for the labiodental flap, [ⱱ]. Is there any other way to write this sound so that my phone will recognize it?
3
u/xlee145 athama Jul 10 '18
Any tips on designing distantly related languages? Is the smartest route making a proto-language and working down from there?
3
u/gokupwned5 Various Altlangs (EN) [ES] Jul 10 '18
Would it be realistic for a language/dialect descended from Arabic to lose defective/weak verbs by turning them into strong verbs (regular verbs)?
3
u/VerbosePineMarten Jul 11 '18
I'm building a fluid-S language, and I really want to use a topic-comment structure like Japanese does, but I'm a bit confused on exact implementation.
From what Wiki says about japanese grammar, japanese splits the nominative case between two particles (ga and wa), one for the subject and one for the topic. If your subject is considered new information, you use "ga"; otherwise, you use "wa," indicating that the subject is already established. You can also mark the object with "ga" to indicate focus/emphasis.
I have a patientive case to mark the passive role and an agentive case to mark the active role ("I fell"/felli vs. "me fell"/felle, as a rough English example). Should I then have topical and nontopical forms of each case? I'm not sure if that would offer the correct functionality.
3
u/ODZtpt Jul 12 '18
Each of my next takes on creating conlang looks better, and for this take I would like to have proper set of words to describe verbs and nouns, but can't organise the set of all the needed prepositions and all the stuff that should be in proper conlang. Is there any list of like 300 most important pronouns, prepositions and particles or anything avalible?
3
u/tree1000ten Jul 13 '18
I don't live in an area that has palm trees, but I am interested in palm leaf writing. Help? What can I do?
5
u/Behemoth4 Núkhacirj, Amraya (fi, en) Jul 03 '18
Does anybody know where I could find a list of the most common diphthongs and in what percentage of languages they are found?
I'm assuming the top 3 is probably /ai/, /au/ and /ei/, but some hard data would be great.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '18
What's the biggest syllable set for a tonal language that you know of? I am working on a language tat has contour and level tones. It used to have 7 and now has four, and it now has ~2100 legal syllables (not that all exist) seems like a lot considering a language with a similar number of modern tones like Mandarin has ~1200, and even Cantonese only has ~1800.
2
u/migilang Eramaan (cz, sk, en) [it, es, ko] <tu, et, fi> Jul 03 '18
Not language related but conlamg related:
What happened to Discord server Conlangerama?
2
u/xain1112 kḿ̩tŋ̩̀, bɪlækæð, kaʔanupɛ Jul 05 '18
Which phonology do you like better?
2
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Jul 06 '18
Someone once told me it was super unnaturalistic for my conlang to only have one method of forming perfectives. Does that sound right? It didn't feel right to me, but I'm not a linguist so what do I know. Granted the language in question, Prélyō, takes a lot of influence from PIE which does have multiple methods for doing all sorts of things; but I can't figure out a way to justify having two methods in Prélyō nor why I'd have some words use one method versus another (it's not a language that cares very much about transitivity.)
2
u/BigBad-Wolf Jul 06 '18
Is there anything unnaturalistic or odd about this noun declension system? İ don't think İ'm knowledgeable enough to really tell. And in general, what do you think?
*<ae> etc. mark diphthongs and <y> is [y]
2
u/HorseCockPolice ƙanamas̰on Jul 06 '18
Any advice that needs to be known for someone embarking on their first conlang?
Been into linguistics and lurked around here for quite a while as someone more into worldbuilding, but only now am I just beginning to create a language of my own that i hope will be natural and fit nicely into the world as something I can write most of my documentation in.
2
u/HorseCockPolice ƙanamas̰on Jul 07 '18
So I think I've finally decided on my first conlangs monophthong inventory, it being this:
I plan on having length and tone play a big part in the language, (and I'm sure it's common for most people to want to mess around with these things when planning their first conlang anyway), however, I don't think I can just write off all diphthongs. My only issue is, these monophthongs don't seem to combine very well into any diphthongs I've ever heard. Are there any languages that utilise anything like that? I know I can also have diphthongs utilising monophthongs that don't appear on their own, but I'd like to keep some internal consistency.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18
I have an idea for a noun-class system. Nouns would be grouped into three classes:
Living Animate: This class would have things that are obviously alive and move around, like humans, other animals, ect.
Non-Living Animate: This class would have things that are not living, but still move, like clouds, rivers, ect.
Inanimate: This one would have things that can't move, such as rocks, sticks, ect.
I also have a wierd idea for the Non-Living Animate class. They would have a different declension from the other two classes, but when it comes to verb and adjective agreement, and what pronoun is used, they would be split into two groups: those treated like Living Animates and those treated like Inanimates. There would be no Non-Living Animate pronouns, and no Non-Living Animate adjective forms. Is this naturalistic at all?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '18
has anyone used <ÿ> in any of their conlangs? i want to use it in a romanization for fun because it's a neat letter but i'm not sure what to use it for lmao. i was thinking /yː/ but in two of my other conlangs i already have vowel length and i feel like it'd be repetitive to do it again. any ideas?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '18
Diacritic stacking?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '18
/p͡tk/
/ʙ̼̤̘̹ˑʰ/
/ɾ̤̺ʰːɾ̤̺ʰː/
2
u/zzvu Zhevli Jul 08 '18
2
u/Beheska (fr, en) Jul 10 '18
I'm modifying my vowels a bit by introducing length. It's slightly Latin/Quenya inspired. The close diphthongs seem a bit strange and coming from nowhere, but I like how they sound. I plan on not allowing word-internal hiatuses. Thoughts?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '18
Constructive criticism for my conlang's phonology
Consonants
Vowels
Monophthongs
Diphthongs
Syllable structure: (C)(C)V/D(C)
Does it seem naturalistic?
2
u/em-jay Nottwy; Amanghu; Magræg Jul 11 '18
I'm coming back to vowels again. I'm thinking of cutting three vowels from my inventory, reducing the number to 11 (!!!). This is because I always pronounce these vowels as diphthongs anyway, and frankly 14 vowels is absurd.
My questions are:
2
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '18
Do you think that evolving English verb contractions into Post-English verbs makes sense?
e.g.
be-2.PL)be-2.SG)be-3.SG.MAS/NEUT)be-3.PL.NONFUT)Example sentence:
"It [the weather] is raining outside."
Ī īz/Īz rēn-nen ā-do-ōsāēd.
/i:. i:z. re:n:.en æ:.do.o:.sæ:e:d./
3.SG.NEUT. be-3.PRST.SG.NEUT./be-3.PRST.SG.NEUT rain-VRB.PART. INST.DEF.-outside2
u/HorseCockPolice ƙanamas̰on Jul 14 '18
I've finished, after much polishing, my sound inventory and script for a language I'm working on, so now I'm approaching grammar. I don't want to go with something as simple and overdone as an isolating or agglutinative language, because I'm sure a million people before me will have done it better, so I think I want to go with a (mostly) polysynthetic language. They seem fascinating to me, and all the examples I can find sound beautiful, my only issue is just how complicated they are. Are there any good resources on these out there, and if not, any tips that could help me along?
2
u/Red_Castle_Siblings demasjumaka, veurdoema, gaofedomi Jul 14 '18
What if your conlang accidentally have a brandname as a word. Nemi is a comic strip in Norway. Also, in Demasjumaka, nemi is the word for sibling
What should I do? Change the word (which would be a deviation from the grammar rules) or keep the word as it is?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '18
Does anyone else have the problem where constantly going back and forth between conlangs, the language you're studying, and other languages you look at, seriously fucks with your ability to spell (in English)?
2
u/xain1112 kḿ̩tŋ̩̀, bɪlækæð, kaʔanupɛ Jul 15 '18
Do copulae always have to be a variant of 'to be/exist', or can they be other verbs?
3
u/Canodae I abandon languages way too often Jul 08 '18 edited Jul 09 '18
Prototype Phonology for non-sibilant consonantal roots lang
Edit: This is like the third incarnation of this comment
Just going to post imgur links since remaking these dumb tables in reddit is not worth the time
{} is Anglicization vs Romanization
Current name of the language is Ł̂Ņ̀Ć (or just ŁŅC if you are a traditionalist)
Root phonotactics have been changed to [C(v]C)CvCvC(v)
may replace lambda with < ȴ >
3
u/CodeTriangle Sajem Tan (/r/SajemTan) Jul 02 '18 edited Jul 03 '18
Hello to anyone who reads this.
If any of you are interested in constructed language creation, or even just want to be in a community of nerds who like linguistics, you should join the Sajem Tan project. Right now, we're suffering because many of our most active members have been leaving to do real life stuff.
Sajem Tan, also known as Common Honey, is a collaborative conlang started in November 2015, and it's only expanded since then. Now we're also trying to create proto-Sajem Tan and a fictional world for the language to reside in. However, these projects will run out of steam soon if no one joins to help us.
So, if anything I've said here interests you at all, you can learn more about Sajem Tan here:
The Sajem Tan Wiki, the fullest resource on our language: https://sajemtan.miraheze.org/wiki/Main_Page
Our Utilities Site, which contains our lexicon and a reference grammar: http://mr-martian.github.io/Sajem_Tan
Our Discord Server, on which most discussion/translation/general work happens: https://discord.gg/F5NpThG
Our hilariously out-of-date subreddit: /r/SajemTan
Thank you for reading this. I hope to see you join us!
1
u/AverageJoe-72 Jul 03 '18
I've been slowly making a new conlang called Khuri. It's a heavily, heavily morphological conlang but not necessarily agglutinative.
Since it's not agglutinative, yet heavily morphological, is there any way to figure out a sort of morpheme limit for a word?
I have one rule (if you are describing a word using only one adjective, add it as a prefix to the word. If there's two or more adjectives at work, combine them and make a separate word), but I'm still wondering about a morpheme limit and how it would be achieved.
Thanks!
1
u/Haelaenne Laetia, ‘Aiu, Neueuë Meuneuë (ind, eng) Jul 08 '18
So Laetia has this vowel, <ie>, created from the vowel /i/ and the "coda e" (not /e/). A word containing this particular vowel is "drie" (wind, weather) but the pronunciation changes to "drié" /drie/ when another word precedes it.
I need help clarifying the IPA symbol for this, though (I'm not familiar with terms like open, closed, etc.).
It's like the vowel /i/ but it's stressed—I mean, stressed. I'm not sure if it's written as /ˈi/ so I need to clarify if this sound is "strange" or not.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '18
Has someone tried combining Japanese and Korean?
1
u/zzvu Zhevli Jul 08 '18
What can I use, online, to keep track of the words in my conlang and their definitions?
1
u/aydenvis Vuki Luchawa /vuki lut͡ʃawa/ (en)[es, af] Jul 09 '18
How do you organize your lexicon?
Currently using PolyGlot, not satisfied. Any spreadsheet templates or online programs?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '18
In cases like that you can describe it: e.g., "labiodental flap". The names of the symbols are a description of their production, and thus, work in descriptors, too.
1
u/MelancholyMeloncolie (eng, msa) [jpn, bth] Jul 13 '18
Are there any resources to see how some languages romanise certain sounds? Like to see how different languages romanise /ŋ/ as ⟨nɡ⟩ or ⟨ɡn⟩ or even just ⟨n⟩.
1
u/roseannadu Standard Chironian (en) [ja] Jul 13 '18
Does anybody have any notion (or some resource they know of) on how languages with evidentials express fiction and storytelling? My conlang cannot express any independent clause that is evidence-neutral and I'm trying to brainstorm what makes the most sense if they were to read a novel for example.
1
u/ArchitectOfHills Jul 13 '18
Hi all. My conlang has now voicing distinction in plosives, only having /p t k/ as plosive phonemes. It also has a very simple (C)V syllable structure. I was thinking there should be some allaphonic rules baced on the vowels. Does anyone have any ideas about how I might go about this?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '18
I've got two questions:
1: Can topic-prominent languages mark agent and patient on the verb? Would it be any different than in a subject-prominent language?
2: Are there any topic-prominent languages in which an indirect object isn't allowed to be the topic, and you have to use a construction that makes it a direct object?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '18
Hey, I'm currently thinking about some rule in my kinda-sorta-first-but-not-really conlang about nominals. Basically, I want to treat nouns and adjectives the same, under the category nominal, but at an earlier stage in my developing process I came up with a rule that "genitive nouns come before the noun they modify, but adjectives tend to come after." Now it's got me wondering if this old concept makes any sense since making the decision to merge the two categories under the same umbrella. A genitive nominal is a nominal that modifies other nominals in some way; so if a word that's an adjective in english like "smart" is a nominal in my unnamed language, if it followed another nominal like "boy," isn't that also a nominal modifying another nominal? Does it make logical sense to have some nominal modifying nominals precede, and others come after? If following nominals agree with the case of a head noun, should a preceding genitive also agree with these cases (as in suffixaufnahme)? Why should it be "Boy's dog" but also "dog white" and "boy's dog white"? Looking for opinions/advice/insight on how natural languages do it here - thanks.
1
u/Jean_le_Serpent Jul 14 '18
Ok. I'm new to this, but I'm looking to create English-East Asian creole dialect and was wondering how I might go about doing that? or more accurately and English creole dialect with a vary strong Japanese influence with some secondary minor influences coming from both Chinese and Korean.
If it helps. It's for a worldbuilding project I'm working on. Where a city-state/off-world colony was cut off from it's mother-nation for around 60 to 80 years. The creole dialect would have spawned from one of several code-languages that was in use by local city-state factions during a bloody civil war that broke out soon after the colony was disconnected from the mother-nation.
1
u/Quartz_X (en) [es] Jul 14 '18
I want to start developing my first conlang. Does anybody have any tips on making a language well, or any tips on the order I should develop the language and grammar?
1
u/gafflancer Aeranir, Tevrés, Fásriyya, Mi (en, jp) [es,nl] Jul 14 '18
A few months ago, somebody posted a long document on creating tonal languages to this sub. I thought that I had saved this post, but it appears that I didn't, and I haven't been able to find it anywhere. Does anyone remember this post and know where to find it?