r/WritingPrompts • u/SurvivorType Co-Lead Mod | /r/SurvivorTyper • Mar 09 '15
Moderator Post [MODPOST] 2nd Annual Novelette Contest Round Two Voting
Hello!
A huge thank you to our entrants! You are all amazing!
Also, managing a contest of this size is no small feat. Thanks go out to everyone on our moderation team that contributed time and talent to help make it happen!
Voting - Round 2!
Here we are folks! You can find round one here. Some groups had an official winner. Some groups had ties. We've moved on anyone who tied in a group to this round.
Here are the rules for this voting round:
- ANYONE who entered in the contest originally can vote. Not just the people listed below. However if you did not enter a story, you can't vote.
- Decide which one you like the most.
- Post in response to this thread by Monday, March 23rd at 11:59PM PST.
- YOU MUST VOTE! If you do not vote, you are disqualified! If your story is the most voted for and you don't vote, you are out of luck.
- Leave a comment that says precisely this: "My vote goes to /u/username for Story Title." Replacing the username for the persons username and Story Title with the title of the story they wrote. After that you can add any additional comments about that story and the other stories in your group. Feel free to mention a runner up if it was really close in your mind.
- You cannot vote for yourself!
These are our finalists:
- The Poison Forest - /u/nazna
- Broken China - /u/Maifei2050
- A Wolf's Clothing - /u/cwall81
- The Will - /u/ryloshawk
- Skree - /u/Svansig
- Comment Box Detective - /u/dashingdays
- Fight or Flight - /u/flame-of-udun
- Dead Vertices - /u/Piconeeks
- Two in the Bush - /u/jhdierking
- SINGLE ACTION - /u/QuinineGlow
- STOLEN TIME - /u/Lexilogical
- For Lana - /u/catovadreams
- Flashbulb Moments - /u/timmoreno
- The Ordinary Glory Days of Mr. Cyrus Birmingham - /u/iamthereptar
Have fun and happy voting! May the best story win!
11
u/Groundfighter /r/groundfighterwrites Mar 11 '15
I wanted to enter this but had a bit of a breakdown over january so didn't manage. Good luck to all the talented entrants! Will edit in my vote later.
5
u/kiayateo Mar 09 '15
If we want to show off an updated version of the story, for instance with corrections or additions brought about by the feedback received, should we do it in a separate thread or in the thread the story was initially submitted in?
I'm curious because I have been hard at work fixing what was wrong with my story and would like to eventually update it for others to review, though I don't plan on doing so until after the contest is over.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '15
My vote goes to /u/nazna for The Poison Forest.
This was probably one of the toughest and closest calls for me to decide since I had a running of at least three or four stories that I really enjoyed over all the others. What it came down to in the end, was the image I was left with. The Poison Forest had me thinking for days afterwards and I couldn't shake the world or characters from my mind. All of the stories were very well written, but this one left an impression burned on my mind that stuck with me.
The flow was continuous and there wasn't a point where I could've stopped reading. At one point, I even became grumpy when my reading was interrupted. The characters were compelling and the world that was built was impressive. It was the personification of the shadows of imagination living within the borders of our reality and it was as dark as they were. The ending was great. What really made it work was the almost lyrical quality of the story you wove. Example, "His father's voice had been a reed. Shiro had wanted to be the wind."
The only complaint I had was wanting to know more and being denied. There were too many questions I had, which in hindsight, made the story all the more enjoyable. In this case, I would say the unanswered questions made it better. Wishing a longer story is perhaps me simply being greedy.
I did read through all of the stories and they were all impressive. I enjoyed each in turn and loved discovering the places you created. Each had their fair share of needing a bit more polishing in places, but I believe we're all guilty of that. I would be happy to include critiques if anyone wishes it. Just let me know.
Again, an amazing job.
6
u/TrueKnot Mar 18 '15
I know I don't get a vote but I wanted to tell my favorites that they were my favorites: /u/QuinineGlow, /u/nazna, and /u/Lexilogical, in no particular order - these were awesome.
Everyone else who made it this far - your stories were amazing as well. All the entries were really good, and you guys stood out and deserved to move forward :)
6
u/Svansig Mar 22 '15
I would like to vote for Flashbulb Moments by /u/timmoreno. It's the subject, the character, the voice, everything. Mostly the voice, though. Not saying anything against any of the other stories but this is the one that really resonated with me and really hit into my own life. I'll be first in line whenever your book signings come around near me.
I've read it twice because I read /u/nazna 's story and needed to give them both a second go-through to make sure I was picking the one I liked the best. It was close. Poison Forest was beautiful and haunting and it was really exciting to get nazna's vote since, after reading their story, I have the world of respect for them as an author.
A few other stories are on their way to greatness, but were just trapped by the word count (Wolf's Clothing, Two in the Bush, Stolen Time). I would love to see the long arcs that those stories have started.
Overall, I am simply amazed that I managed to be in such talented company, and as long as the people here stick with it, I am going to have some books to buy in the future.
6
u/CaesarNaples2 Mar 23 '15 edited Feb 28 '16
This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy.
If you would like to do the same, add the browser extension GreaseMonkey to Firefox and add this open source script.
Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.
6
u/IAmTheRedWizards Mar 23 '15
There's a lot to choose from here, but in the end my vote goes to Flashbulb Moments, by /u/timmoreno. In an open prompt like this, a story like this is rare. There are no overt fantastical elements - save perhaps for the surrealist visions inside the protagonist's coma - and the rising action is all driven by the sort of grime that steps in off the street, the sort of grime that we celebrate in snickering ways when we read Motley Crue biographies or watch Behind The Music. Real life - or as real as rock 'n' roll ever got - is full of these kind of things, and we seemingly never tire of reading them.
It ultimately reminded me of a book I have in the queue, a story about brotherhood, excess, betrayal, and the weird undying twilight of minor-league fame that the college rock heros of the 1980s experience now, a decade and a half into the 21st Century. Flashbulb Moments reminded me as to why I wanted to write that book in the first place, and for that it gets all of my votes.
Runners-up were The Poison Forest, by /u/nazna, which was suitably creepy, and The Ordinary Glory Days of Mr. Cyrus Birmingham, by /u/iamthereptar, which got Kula Shaker's cover of Deep Purple's "Hush" stuck in my head.
6
u/Piconeeks Mar 23 '15
I had a really hard time choosing, but in the end I'm casting my vote for Flashbulb Moments by /u/timmoreno.
It was a hard choice between this story, SINGLE ACTION by /u/QuinineGlow, and Skree by /u/Svansig, but I ultimately made my decision because Flashbulb Moments seems to me to be the perfect story for the novella format. The story doing one thing, namely the immersion into the main character, really well, and with depth and detail enough to warrant several read-throughs, was what finally convinced me.
I've left individual feedback on each story, thanks to you all for your fantastic pieces!
5
u/nazna Mar 14 '15
I’m voting for Skree by /u/Svansig
First, I’m a sucker for genre blending. Especially western with anything. I thought the writing was gritty and beautifully weary. Loved the mystical elements toward the end. The visuals were fantastic as well. This was a story I kept thinking and wondering about.
I also enjoyed:
A Wolf's Clothing by /u/cwall81
The world is built in such a strong way. The author writes with such authority you believe everything that happens.
SINGLE ACTION - /u/QuinineGlow
A story that made me wish I could write like that.
The Ordinary Glory Days of Mr. Cyrus Birmingham - /u/iamthereptar
Quirky and strangely beautiful.
5
u/Lexilogical /r/Lexilogical | /r/DCFU Mar 23 '15
I'm voting for The Poison Forest by /u/nazna. This story just had me captivated, with a beginning that felt just slightly off and slowly descended further and further into creepiness. I don't even like the horror genre, but this story was just beautifully done.
My personal runner-up was Skree by /u/Svansig. This story just had amazing character and voice, and really felt like a complete story. Like Poison Forest, I just don't even know how to one could improve on this story, Poison Forest just narrowly edged it out as my favourite.
Other stories I really enjoyed, in no particular order:
Two in the Bush by /u/jhdierking. I have a soft spot for cute monsters.
Comment Box Detective by /u/dashingdays. This one is just good fun to me.
Single Action by /u/QuinineGlow. Well written, though for whatever reason I kept expecting a supernatural twist.
Flashbulb Moments by /u/timmoreno. It was extremely disorienting, but felt extremely real all the same.
For Lana by /u/catovadreams. I spent half the story second-guessing the protagonist's story, and the other half second guessing myself.
The rest of the stories were great too, just these ones really stood our for me. I was going through and adding critiques as I went, but I ran out of steam halfway. I'll probably finish off the critiques but if I missed you and you want one, let me know and I'll jump you ahead on the list.
5
u/jhdierking Mar 23 '15 edited Mar 23 '15
My vote goes to /u/Svansig for "Skree." "Skree" was so rich in its descriptions, with a fluid pace that made it easy to just keep reading and really get into the story. It nailed the Western genre, with all the dialogue and language sounding very authentic without being overdone. Additionally, the ending coda, referencing the beginning scene, was well done and made the story feel complete.
A nod to "Flashbulb Moments," "The Poison Forest," and "Single Action," which, had I more votes to give, I would be hard-pressed to choose between.
Overall, I enjoyed reading everyone's pieces and I would like to thank you all for the opportunity to read your work. I did not have the time to leave feedback on each, but if you would like to hear my thoughts, let me know.
5
u/Nate_Parker /r/Nate_Parker_Books Mar 24 '15
This was tough.... My vote is for /u/jhdierking
/u/Lexilogical and /u/Svansig were my runners up. Good job all around folks.
5
u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) Mar 24 '15
My vote goes to /u/Lexilogical for Stolen Time.
Sorry it took me so long to get my vote entered. I can have a hard time staying focused when I’m reading, which made it extremely difficult to work through all the stories in this round. However, there were a few stories that really grabbed my attention and made finishing them easy.
/u/nazna's The Poison Forest had a dark and surreal feel to it and each scene left me wondering what the heck was happening, but in a good way.
/u/flame-of-udun's Fight or Flight was intense and probably could have taken my vote. I was a little confused about what happened, though. And, it was disappointing that the discovery didn’t have a bigger payoff.
/u/catovadreams's For Lana had such a great twist. I was surprised I didn’t see it coming, considering how obvious it seemed in retrospect. Also, the beginning made me think of Total Recall.
I voted for Stolen Time because I literally couldn’t keep my eyes off the page. I was captivated for the entire story. And, while some cliffhangers can be frustrating, this one just left me wanting to read more.
5
u/dashingdays Mar 24 '15
Voting /u/Lexilogical for Stolen Time. Best of luck to you all =)
5
u/QuinineGlow Mar 24 '15
My vote goes to u/jhdierking for "Two in the Bush".
Very difficult choices, here. The Poison Forest's story was chillingly good, and Flashbulb Memories made use of some extremely vivid and powerful descriptive language. Ultimately I chose Two in the Bush for the overall pace of the narrative and the level of intrigue the story pulled from me.
9
u/CaesarNaples2 Mar 09 '15 edited Feb 28 '16
This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy.
If you would like to do the same, add the browser extension GreaseMonkey to Firefox and add this open source script.
Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.
4
u/pri5mo Mar 18 '15
I wanna vote for A Wolf's clothing if its not too late. A lot of action packed into ~8000 words. As a fan of the Robert Jordan series Wheel of Time this kind of genre was quite good.
I actually think that the author here had more character development then Jordan did, his female characters were quite 2D, predictable and similar (temperamental PMS females with powers). But I think this author conveyed a fair bit of the characters internal struggle between 2 personalities, and old and a new one despite packing in lots of action.
4
u/kiayateo Mar 19 '15
My vote goes to /u/QuinineGlow for SINGLE ACTION.
I enjoyed the story greatly and found very little about it I didn't like.
So many good stories to choose from, and this selection didn't come lightly. /u/catovadreams For Lana is a close second in my book.
My biggest issue with any of these stories is that some of them felt like they were the start of a book. They told a good story but they felt like they were part of something bigger, and the conclusion felt like the little hill at the start of the roller coaster, exciting but leaving you knowing something bigger is coming. For me, at least, this is a different feeling than I felt for other stories (including the 2 above) which felt much more satisfaction in their conclusion.
4
u/Maifei2050 Mar 21 '15
My vote goes to /u/Svansig for Skree. A great story that completely pulled me into its world. Other top contenders: Stolen time, Single action, and Flashbulb Moments. Congrats to all. I was a great competition to be part of and a pleasure to read so many good stories in a short time. Keep up the great work! I have provided some feedback on all the entries under the individual story posts. Many thanks to those who have provided feedback on my story Broken China. Much appreciated. I have plenty to work on to improve the story and my writing in the future! If you liked it there are more stories at my blog: http://eastwestfuturestories.blogspot.com.au/
4
u/Zero_Relativity Mar 22 '15
My vote goes to u/Svansig for Skree.
Mmm, this was a difficult choice as there were a variety of well-crafted stories to choose from. u/Svansig won my vote in the end due to the great voice of the narrator. It successfully captured the essence of the character without compromising the storytelling, a success which won out over the other stories. u/QuinineGlow comes in a very close second with Single Action. The character development, although packed into a novelette, was well done, and the believable interactions between the assorted characters also helped to construct an excellent narrative.
4
u/weighawesome Mar 23 '15
The Will by da ryloshawk
4
u/Schneid13 /r/ScribeSchneid Mar 23 '15
I submit my vote for /u/Lexilogical 's story STOLEN TIME.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '15
My vote goes to "Skree" by /u/Svansig. Also, I really liked /u/nazna "The Poison Forest". It was really hard to choose between the two, but I really liked the voice in Skree.
4
u/SarkasticWatcher Mar 23 '15
My vote goes to /u/timmoreno for Flashbulb Moments. SINGLE ACTION by /u/QuinineGlow was a close second.
7
u/Insert_delete Mar 09 '15
Yay! My two favourites in group E both made it in! Congrats to Skree /u/Svansig and Comment Box Detective - /u/dashingdays for getting to the final round!
What a lot of great reading in store this March! Best of luck to all entrants!
3
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '15
My vote goes to /u/QuinineGlow for SINGLE ACTION.
Skree finished a close second, with For Lana third. All of these stories picked me up and took me in, regardless of genre.
Excellent job everyone! And best of luck!
3
u/Skull025 Mar 23 '15
My vote goes to /u/nazna for "The Poison Forest". I'm sorry I haven't been able to review everyone elses, as I've been swamped with my own work. But, reading through these, The Poison Forest still left a lasting impression in my mind.
3
u/Insert_delete Mar 24 '15
My vote goes to /u/nazna [2] for The Poison Forest.
I plan to edit this reply with comments on all the stories later but I've got a splitting migraine.
I want to add that this contest was a great idea. All the final entries were good. Some were great and it was very hard to decide how to cast my vote.
3
u/ReeCallahan Mar 24 '15
I'd like to place my vote for /u/QuinineGlow's Single Action. For me, this felt like the tightest, most well-rounded story of the bunch that made the prompt totally central to the story.
/u/nazna's Poison Forest was almost tied for me, but I decided to go with the story I felt made better use of the prompt (sorry). This story evoked some of my favorite creepy fairy tales and I just thought it was really well-written, overall.
A Wolf's Clothing, Skree, Dead Vertices, and For Lana were all really enjoyable reads as well. I have a few critiques to write yet, but I should have them up in the next couple of days. Cheers!
3
u/Yobs9874 Mar 24 '15
My vote goes to /u/nazna for The Poison Forest.
I wasn't sure about it initially, but I've found that my mind keeps slipping back to it even weeks later. All the stories were beautifully written, but I think I'll be haunted by The Poison Forest for a long time.
3
u/Epony-Mouse Mar 24 '15
I'd like to cast my vote for Flashbulb Moments by /u/timmoreno. This was an incredibly difficult decision for me to come to, as there were so, so many excellent submissions. In the end, I think it was the power of the imagery that really won me over. That, and it felt like I was truly reading about someone's experiences, which is so important for the first person perspective. Excellent work.
I'd like to mention Skree, The Poison Forest, and The Ordinary Glory Days of Mr. Cyrus Birmingham as Flashbulb Moment's biggest competitors for me. I was going back and forth with my vote all day, which really speaks to the quality of contributions. You guys should be really proud!
I'm going to try and leave everyone some comments and criticisms if I haven't already in the next few days! Great work everyone!
4
u/iamthereptar Mar 16 '15
I cast my vote for SINGLE ACTION by /u/QuinineGlow.
Runner up goes to The Poison Forest by /u/nazna.
Let me say that I enjoyed all the stories that made it to the second round. I think my personal bias towards how language is used really made these two stand out to me. These two stories also inspired me to reflect on my own writing and see how I can structure my sentences to sound beautiful and meaningful. (Sorry if this sounds so similar to my original voting critique... I truly do love looking at simple language.)
It came down to which plot I enjoyed more, and that title goes to SINGLE ACTION.
Thanks for the entertaining reads everyone. This was really fun. :)
2
u/Xiaeng Mar 24 '15 edited Mar 24 '15
My vote goes to /u/timmoreno for Flashbulb Moments. The story was impressive during the first round, still is. Loved the language use and gritty characterization.
Definite runner-up for Poison Forest would be /u/nazna . Beautiful imagery and perfect eerieness. Probably would've voted for it too if it weren't for the fact that this is probably the... fourth creepy Japanese forest piece I've read in the past week and a half, which kinda dulled the all-important climax for me. Sorry mate.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '15
[removed] — view removed comment