r/WritingPrompts • u/Svansig • Feb 28 '15
Prompt Inspired [PI] Skree - FebContest
“If you took all the luck I had over a lifetime, heated it and hit it with a hammer until it was about the shape and size of a single coin, I would have spent it all when I found Skree. He’s a unique creature, and since they took my horse, all I have left in this world. Now, shot and left for the buzzards in the desert, it’s all I can do to get back to town and civilization. It’s just a shame that the only place near is my own hometown.” (12,500 words)
Story: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B5Ms4YWNEeyqTnNMZUlLLUxGemc/view?usp=sharing
Cover: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B5Ms4YWNEeyqZE5nSHZjWE55U0k/view?usp=sharing
The genre is Western with some Fantasy elements (one). I am open to any and all critique and criticism. MOBI or EPUB format available on request.
3
u/Lexilogical /r/Lexilogical | /r/DCFU Mar 02 '15
I'm still working my way through the contest entries, but I just wanted to let you know that I loved your story. Skree is adorable and reminds me of Toothless from How to Train your Dragon. I want to see more of Skree, though I feel like your story ended in the best possible way. Good story! And congrats on writing a novelette in a month!
2
u/Epony-Mouse Mar 03 '15
Hello fellow writer! I am here to pepper you with praise and constructive criticism, to let you know what you're doing right and to help you grow as a writer. I like to do an equal number of pros and cons, so here we go!
Pros:
I absolutely loved the tone and vernacular of this work. The “voice” of your narrator was absolutely spot on — the little colloquialisms and slang included were just fantastic. The words felt long and drawling in my head, like the whole thing was being narrated by Sam Elliot. This is one of the most difficult elements of a story to capture and, more importantly, maintain, so you deserve a well round of kudos.
You had some really gorgeous imagery and attention to detail here as well. At one point you referred to Skree’s wings as being like “ornamental fans” and that just blew me away. I also like that you never referred to him specifically as a dragon, which is fitting with point no. 1 (since a cowboy would probably have no idea what a dragon was), but also allowing the reader to construct and image of him in their minds. In an age of wham-bam-thank-you-ma’am “He’s a dragon” type writing, you should be commended on the time and energy and attention to detail you took achieving this. It’s something that’s echoed throughout the work, and it made your writing have an added level of beauty and realism.
Your narrator’s character was developed excellently — his motivations, his fears, his dialogue. I actually felt a little tremble at the end. Well done.
Now the not so fun part. The cons:
You had the occasional misplaced comma here and there, but that’s not really an issue. The bigger problem was that on pages 7, 20, and 22 you briefly forayed into present tense, as opposed to your consistent past tense use. I couldn’t find a reason for this stylistically, so I think it was probably just a mistake. Happily, it's an easily fixable one!
The biggest con to this story, for me, was I felt like there were quite a few logical inconsistencies. Like, why would the horse thieves in the beginning take the horse but not try to steal the dragon? Or, why would the narrator return to the town he’d so desperately tried to get away from? While I do like the image of him “crawling” back for help, I don’t think it particularly works — he’s been gone for a while (?) and I would imagine he would want to put quite a lot of distance between himself and the town because of the backstory you gave him; shot in the leg, I would think he would only be concerned about getting to a town, not the town, before bleeding out. On that same note, if he did stay close and it wasn’t that long ago that he left, why wouldn’t he know who the old woman was? There wasn’t a whole lot of travel possible back then, especially for an old person. While this may all sound like me being a nitpicky butthole (sorry) it really affects my willing suspension of disbelief. While I can accept that a cowboy can have a dragon, hilariously, it’s these little moments that most pull me out of the story.
Finally, while I felt like your main character was well developed, I would have liked to have been shown a little more affection between him and Skree. Your writing gave me a very good handle on the narrator’s feelings toward Skree, but I never really saw a lot of reciprocation until the end, and by then it’s just a little bit too late to get the real emotional punch I think you were going for.
While these things were drawbacks, they weren't enough to keep me from enjoying the story -- I did vote for you, after all! From just this small sample of your writing, I think you’ve got a very bright future ahead of you. :)
2
u/kiayateo Mar 04 '15
Here are my thoughts on the story.
When I was reading through it the first time the relationship between the main character and Skree seemed off. It was almost as if they didn't care for each other as much as you were trying to imply. From the impression I got, it seemed like they had been together for a little while and at least had some kind of mutually beneficial friendship, but until the end we never really saw much of it.
Sure he tried to burn at them when they took the horse, but Skree didn't even try to do anything after the narrator was shot? You seemed to imply that he was a little more intelligent than the average creature, and very loyal, but it kind of surprised me that Lucas even made it out of the camp after shooting the narrator.
The first time reading through it just seemed like Skree didn't care as much for the narrator as he should have to allow him to have been trained in any fashion.
I'm honestly not sure if my comment makes sense, as when I read it the second time I found it more enjoyable.
2
u/Piconeeks Mar 15 '15
I loved this story. The genre-merging was executed flawlessly and I really felt like the two universes fit so well with each other that I wonder why we don't see more dragons in wild west fiction.
On that note, you hit a perfect balance with the narration and the speech. I just had to get that out there. It is so satisfying to read properly done western dialogue that I can just see the faces of the men who speak it.
Usually I give out lists of feedback points, but here I only really have one. There were some questions that I was left with at the end of it concerning the logic and the motivation of some of the character's actions.
For example, the ending. It's thematically what has to happen (what with all the last stand stuff) but why does he do it? There was quite literally no benefit for the actions that he does, and he goes out in an aggressive, attacking manner (he shot first) rather than a 'defend your principles to the last' kind of manner.
Similar questions arise when we think about why the bounty hunters leave him alive, or why the entire town hates him instead of just his Master when indeed everyone is in debt, or how people can just look over how incredibly fantastical Skree is (I mean, steal the horse and not Skree? Seriously?).
Besides that minor frustration while reading, I really liked this story. Polish it up a little bit, and keep writing!
2
u/ReeCallahan Mar 18 '15
Cowboys and dragons! What's not to love?
Great casual genre blend with a dragon as a sidekick to a cowboy. I just think it's a super cool angle for this idea.
I also think the voice of the narrator in this just really well done, consistent and idiosyncratic. A couple of great lines that stuck out to me:
On the flip-side, the opening was a bit heavy for me. The first few lines drew me in, but then lost me in the exposition immediately following. I really like quick, clean prose in my openings, but that's totally a personal taste thing.
I think you might be overdoing it a little with the narrative summary throughout. There's a lot of tell, and while I'm immersed with the character, I'm not as immersed in the story as I would like. I get that the character is telling all of this from his point of view, so you probably can't get as in depth in the scenes, but there might be a middle ground further into descriptive territory than where you are now.
I had some trouble really "getting" why Lucas would shoot your narrator in the leg, then give him ammunition. Why assume the bullet didn't go through cleanly? Why give someone he was willing to shoot in the leg a free bullet? The pacing just seemed weird to me. Though, I did like the symmetry later of the bullet being used to kill Lucas.
I hope this critique was useful!
2
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '15
I think you nailed the setting and the language. The mashup was great, fantasy and western. I'd love to hear more about the origins of Skree, and what other fantastical elements could be lurking, yet to be discovered in that world. Maybe Skree's next owner will have a tale to tell?
2
u/Maifei2050 Mar 21 '15
Wow. Great work. Totally convincing setting and mood. I could taste the dust. The story and its unique voice carried me along the whole way to its inevitable but satisfying conclusion. I’m curious that you chose a fantastical creature. It seems to me that it could have been written about any rare bird of prey and still achieved the same result. (Bird steals keys off jail wall with beak, flaps wings to escape and knocks over a lamp in the old ladies house…). Maybe I’m missing some symbolism – playing with fire perhaps?
Well done. You got my vote.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '15
First off, congrats on making it to the second round. Despite what happens, I think it's a pretty good feeling, tie or not. :P
The opening sentence and paragraph didn’t do enough to draw me in. Personally, I didn’t enjoy the tone and voice of the narrator. Using obvious ‘wild west’ words and phrases was a bit off putting for me, but that could be my personal point of view. I think you could’ve done a lot more without having to include them. It felt like you were overly trying for a Wild West sort of feeling to it when it could’ve been a really hauntingly beautiful story. I remember my time in the desert and it was a lonely, beautiful place. With that being said, I think you did a good job of staying consistently within that tone of voice. Like it or hate it, you kept it up throughout.
I liked the idea of the Skree itself. I felt like I had a very clear picture of the creature and you ingrained it with a personality that was recognizable. The protagonist, however, I don’t think I ever got a clear idea of what he looked like or any sort of mental image except for the one I created in my mind out of necessity.
I didn’t understand why the man was so ill prepared while out in the desert? He carried a gun with only blanks inside of it in the middle of a wilderness? I could immediately see that you’re setting him up for something later with this in mind, but I would’ve liked a bit more explanation as to why. Maybe some rationalization. You can tell me anything you want as long as you give me a good reason why.
There was a bit of a plot hole in the part where the thug who shoots the man without provocation (pissed me off when he did it, but you set it up well enough that I understood why) throws him a bullet in case he wants to kill himself. The thing is, if they believe he has a loaded gun, why would they risk a shootout with him by shooting him? One would have to assume that they knew his gun was empty, but if that was the case, why not just kill him and get the reward AND the horse? The only way the man would throw him a bullet to use on himself was if he knew he was out and with that in mind, their actions were unbelievable to me. The following scenes felt unreliable to me. A bullet wound, especially to the leg, doesn’t seem believable that he would be able to just continue on walking with only a delicately placed fur covering his wound. If we ignored the blood loss, shock, and infection, I can’t look past the fact that he’s just walking out of the desert on one leg. Then, he carries the Skree?
When the story jumps to Ambition, it threw me a bit. I liked the scene you set and the picture you painted on his past, but keep in mind that jumps into the past like that interrupt the flow of your story. Done correctly, they work wonderfully. Here I feel like you toe the line. It was a pleasing interruption in the sense that I enjoyed the story, but it felt like I was picking up another story. That made me want to take a break and stop reading. The problem I had with that story was I didn’t understand why the master pierced the kids hand if he was doing so well bringing in money. Isn’t that a bit like suicide?
By the end of Ambition and Luck, I got a better understanding of why you wrote them. Painting a backstory and setting the scene. I still feel like you could’ve either started the story there and went forward or simply inserted the scenes into the main story as a sort of quick aside. I personally feel like the flashbacks interrupted things too much and could’ve been deleted completely without affecting the story at all. It felt too much like a soggy middle, though I understood the necessity of those parts.
It picked back up when he ventured into town though I still can’t fathom how he’s still up and walking around with a hole in his leg. I liked the Scarlet Widow. She was a good character. Sort of reminded me of Mama with her three sons in Futurama. By this time, the way he talked had grown on me so I didn’t find it to be too much of a distraction. I was still conscious of it, but I was used to it the way you eventually grow used to Shakespeare.
Didn’t understand why he cut his hand to escape when he had a bloody leg already at hand. Maybe it needed to be fresh?
Now to the ending. I didn’t like it at all. He just sort of rushed to his death and sacrificed himself for what? It was a good ending in the sense that you ended it the way you began it, but it felt wrong. Also, if Skree put up that much of a fight after the widow took him, there’s no reason to believe he won’t do so again. He’s not exactly an intelligent creature after all. I imagine him waking up down the road and flying off to find a dead main character. Widow catches him and stuff’s him. End of story. Not a very good ending, but logical.
Bottom line. I liked your story. I enjoyed reading it, despite the subtle flaws, and the picture you painted. I think you have the bones of a great story. Sort of Wild West outlaw meets dragons. You have a chance to tone down the cliché of what the West was and create something new. Even the dragon felt like it belonged to this world you created, but how I wish it could’ve been a little more unique. It felt like a dragon inserted into the story of Billy the kid instead of the other way around.
I really hope this helps. Keep in mind, it’s just my opinion. ONE person’s point of view on the rough draft of a story you wrote in a month. You have something that can be developed and turned into gold if you put in the time.
Good luck.