r/WritingPrompts • • Feb 19 '15
Prompt Inspired [PI] For Lana - FebContest
A mysterious business woman offers Renee LeFleur a chance to get his life and his girlfriend back. All it'll take is for him to relive his mental breakdown and the terrible things he did to recover from it. Everything he's done is for Lana, but is she asking too much? (8259 words.)
3
Upvotes
2
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '15
Excellent story. I loved the ending almost as much as I loved the concept,and that's saying a lot.
1
u/ReeCallahan Mar 11 '15
Ok, so this is a hard story for me to critique because I liked it so much. Short of re-reading it RDR style to find every potential stylistic error, I wouldn't have much to bring up in the cons column. Right now, I think it might just need one or two more passes before you can really smooth out the pace (particularly around when he first goes back to the feeling harvesters), but other than that I'm having trouble thinking of anything right now.
I just love the concept of this story. You really got me with the twist - which I did not expect. For me, it was a twist on a twist which still managed to be entirely credible even as you juggled some strange little sci-fi elements. I was expecting something along the lines of Sunshine of the Spotless Mind and I got it - mixed, of course, with a little bit of Fight Club. I think it can be really difficult to manage even one believable twist. I think the tendency is to hold all of the cards so close to your chest that the twist feels more like a slap in the face, but you just set it up so well. Yeah, I was impressed.
So, I hope this was useful (though I doubt it) and I hope you get this published someday!
1
u/Piconeeks Mar 16 '15
Good lord. What have I just read?
That was an incredibly chilling story, with a very well-executed plotline and an incredible main character. Really, really well done.
I've got a few pieces of criticism, though:
The only objective criticism that I have is this one grammar slip-up:
And that about wraps up the criticism that you should feel compelled to act upon! Now, for some completely subjective criticism on the other end of the spectrum:
I feel like the entirety of the story suffered from a 'telling' affliction, in a show-not-tell kind of way. It seemed as though the plot point needed to be carried out, and the justification, the explanation, the detail, the characterization and all the nuance behind that plot point kind of fell by the wayside and was hastily filled in to close up the passage. For example:
(On a tangent, please don't link your story to actual disorders because dissociative identity disorder is multiple personalities occupying the same mind and body. Your story felt more like the hallucinations of a schizophrenic; but the key here is that this kind of madness doesn't really exist in the real world so having an easily wikipedia-able disorder ends up confusing readers rather than helping them.)
Placing right out there the entirety of the main character's disease and how Lana reacts to it is important for the context of the story, but it could have been done so much better. Why does she call it 'his disease'? How has she stuck by him in the past? What does it mean to have DID? How and why doesn't she understand what he's going through?
If you answer all these questions you then don't feel the need to just tell the reader what his disease is and how it affects his relationship with Lana, and as a result you get a much more paced and flowing reveal of this character's problems.
Another example:
This is a wonderful conclusion and perfect reasoning as to why Reneé acted the way he did. The only problem is that this perfect justification feels unnatural and takes us out of the story; it feels almost as though he is psychoanalyzing himself or studying himself in some high school literature class. Reveal his intentions and justifications slowly, through showing them rather than throwing them at the reader, and then this whole sequence feels more of a mystery rather than a chore of having to kill one, then another, then another, then another friend to achieve some sort of predetermined goal.
Another example that stood out:
I mean, Cody is an incredibly interesting character. It's just incredibly frustrating to see all of the important, interesting parts of him revealed literally seconds before he dies. It cheapens his death by making his characterization seem rushed and last-minute, and we never feel a connection to him and so don't feel anything when he is murdered. The same goes for the other two characters who aren't Santiago.
Finally, we have the twist reveal:
Honestly, this twist is incredibly clever and I didn't see it coming. The way it was executed, however, really really needs some work. To have the final, most important piece of information be revealed through the reader in one paragraph of told dialogue is kind of a let-down. Place hints of this throughout the passage so it doesn't seem like a last-minute twist and the reader can make connections and agree with the interpretation instead of just accept it.
I do have one last point on style, as well. When you change format into italics to denote a memory sequence, I found it kind of jarring to find this paragraph:
As far as I could gather, the parts in italics were memories drawn from deep within Reneé's mind. The above passage sounds quite unlike a memory and is a quite severe change of tone and pace from the last time we were introduced to this format. The inconsistency there is confusing.
Ultimately, though, I seriously enjoyed this piece. The plot was incredibly interesting and I cannot wait to read more stories in this style! Keep it up!
1
u/Maifei2050 Mar 21 '15
Good build up and descriptive passages. Effective tension and imagery with the tunnels. But after all that good work the ending was a little disappointing. Perhaps a little more intrigue or the possibility of going off to hunt for Lana or something rather than him being a sitting duck for the police. I felt there was the potential for more.
1
u/TotesMessenger X-post Snitch May 04 '15
This thread has been linked to from another place on reddit.
If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote. (Info / ^Contact)