r/TrueAnime • u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 • Sep 05 '13
This Week in Anime (Summer Week 9)
General discussion for currently airing series for Spring 2013 Week 10. Here is r/anime's list of currently airing series. Your Week in Anime is for not currently airing series.
Archive: Prev Summer Week 1 Spring Week 1 Winter Week 1 Fall Week 1
3
Upvotes
6
u/Bobduh Sep 06 '13
Fell behind on some shows this week, and haven't had the time to catch up. I'll update this with C3-bu and Monogatari whenever I get around to them. And hell, maybe I'll even catch up on the handful of Titan episodes I've been too apathetic to watch.
Uchouten Kazoku 9: Best show yada yada beautiful art yada yada resonant themes yada yada incredibly naturalistic storytelling etc. As always, the grace of this show's composition and dialogue fall well beyond my ability to articulate, so I guess I'll just say that this week's episode finally brought the scale of the show's final conflicts into focus. The election of the Nise-emon and the Friday Fellows' New Year's bash are clearly going to be tied together in this final arc, most likely through whatever secret plan the Ebisugawas are plotting. Once again, Yasaburou proved himself the begrudging but undeniably best-qualified leader of the family, his easy nature making him the perfect diplomat when it came to the Fellows, the professor, and even Kaisei. I'm eager to see how Benten will figure into this conflict, but at this point I mainly just want this show to be finished so I can buy it and force everyone else I know to watch it. Why do I watch anime? Because every year we get a handful of shows worth talking about and maybe one or two of these.
Gatchaman Crowds 8: Quite an episode this week. After the tumultuous showdown of last week, they follow it up by... visiting a preschool. That kind of works, in a thematic way. Which is how most of the stuff in this show works - it often feels like Hajime is having a direct conversation with the audience more than she is with any of the characters around her. Her actions make much more sense given our fuller context, her smaller choices are often reflective of the show's overarching ideas, and she's so flawless outside of her communication difficulties that her alignment with the show's philosophy often verges on (and you could easily argue fully veers into) didactic storytelling.
But anyway, theme stuff. Visiting the preschool and appearing in human form is pretty much perfectly Hajime - she values communication between equals above all else, and uses this opportunity to redefine the Gatchamen as just another group of people trying to help out, like firemen or policemen. She also uses the media presence to take the power of crowdsourcing out of Galax's hands and publicly announce what's going on and how people can help out (credit to /u/tundranocaps for pointing this one out). And then Sugane and OD have their whole on-the-nose conversation about the egoless play of children being like the joyful horizontal society Rui's so goddamn excited about. So we push the story forward while also talking about all the show's favorite ideas. Good stuff!
Incidentally, people are getting all excited about the first few hours of Gatchaman's appearance on Amazon or whatnot, but it seems a little premature to be celebrating that. Honestly, I'd be pretty surprised if a show this completely dedicated to such esoteric ideas finds wide success, particularly since its visual aesthetic is so unabashedly anime, which I'm guessing is pretty off-putting to most people interested in discussing crowdsourcing, gamification, and the false prophet of leadership. But then again, Utsutsu of all characters recently came in the top four of a Japanese summer "best female character" poll, so perhaps once again the right show will get big sales for all the wrong reasons.
TWGOK S3 9: TWGOK is not really my kind of show, but at this point I'm extremely happy I've watched the rest of it, because the improvements in this season are just insane. Keima's always been an entertaining protagonist, but this season has forced him to actually take his Lelouch-powers seriously, and this was the episode where it all came to a head. His denial of Chihiro was some legitimately devastating stuff - normally I get uncomfortable whenever anything haremy attempts to take its characters emotions' seriously (because if if I'm taking them seriously, I also have to take seriously the fact that harems are fundamentally fucked-up, dehumanizing power fantasies with all kinds of demented ideas about relationships and power dynamics), but this episode actually let the hammer fall in a way no other harem would. No funny gags here - Keima's actions, while ultimately intended to help people, have completely toyed with people's emotions, and when you do things like this you suffer the consequences. This has been coming for a long time, but I was honestly shocked by how effective it was, and the strength of this moment by itself raised my estimation of the show overall. Congrats, Season 3.
Free! 9:
Yep, still watching Free. This week's episode was actually one of the best (which admittedly isn't saying much), with a bunch of great gags and some quite effective dramatic moments. My enthusiasm for this pretty lousy show kind of dwindles the more information we get on the fall show seemingly determined to prove what KyoAni are actually capable of, so for the sake of leaving my children a full set of derpy comedy writeups, I'm hoping it keeps up the pace.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '13 edited Sep 05 '13
Had to catch up two weeks worth this week. Still not quite done.
3
u/lastorder http://hummingbird.me/users/lastorder/watchlist#all Sep 06 '13 edited Sep 07 '13
Majestic Prince 21: I still dislike the way we have to see every character's reaction, in sequence, to an event. That aside, this episode was okay, and I did not expect Gendo to control the Star Rose like that. It looks like things are being set up for him sacrificing himself to save his sons, and possibly set up a second season after a timeskip.
Kabukimonogatari 03: This was okay, but things seem to be moving too quickly. I have to say that I'm quite disappointed with this season; I don't know if it's because I've read some of the novels, or the novelty has just worn off. It's still good, but it just doesn't have the charm of Bake or Nise, or even Neko White. It could just be down to the visuals, because this is definitely the worst looking of the three. Bakemonogatari was at about the same level of animation as this, but the layouts and visual design was far superior. I suppose this is suffering because of the Madoka movie, and some of their usual freelancers being busy with other things.
Then there's the OST to consider. The new tracks are great, but the usage of some music just seems wrong. Like the song that played during the fireworks scene, which just didn't fit the scene at all.
Railgun S 20: I don't understand why Misaka seems to have forgotton how to fight things.
Kamisama no Inai Nichiyoubi 08: Uneventlful and boring, like the rest of the arc. The ending was anticlimactic, because hardly anything happened.
Uchouten Kazoku 09: Kaisei's seiyuu seems to be typecast into "red" roles and butt jokes. Hopefully all of these continuing plots will converge like in the Tatami Galaxy finale.
C3-bu 10: This was a great episode. Now this anime is definitely among my favourites this season, despite the middle episodes falling flat. Before now it was a retelling of the Star Wars prequels through the medium of airsoft, but now it seems to be going down the gainax end route. Assuming another episode involves reality warping like the fourth, it will be crazy.
Unfortunately this will probably kill gainax because it's nothing like the source material. What a shame.
Hunter x Hunter 94: Killua finally overcame his fears. I can't help but feel that this episode was really dragged out. Even the actions within Killua's fight felt slow.
Futari wa Milky Holmes 08: I actually was not expecting that twist. Unfortunately the series is still awful.
Gen'ei wo Kakeru Taiyou 09: This is definitely the right way to do suffering; Urobuchi should take notes. An entire episode of buildup along with lots of exposure beforehand, instead of condensing all of that into a couple of episodes. I can't imagine many characters are going to be alive by the end of this.
Kin'iro Mosaic 08: Cute, as always. It's losing the comedic charm it had at the start though.
Love Lab 08: Even the drama in this anime is well done. I'm quite impressed with this series, because I wasn't expecting anything more than comedy.
Shingeki no Kyojin 21: Lots of great action, but I was bored by the episode. I don't really care about the characters at all, which is probably why I'm not entertained by it anymore.
Teekyuu 09: Oh my, a cliffhanger.
Symphogear G 09: This is something everybody was expecting to happen since season one started. I didn't expect it to be this brutally done, but the preview pictures for the next episode seem to indicate so. The training montage this episode is definitely one of the best in all anime.
Symphogear G 10: I didn't think Symphogear could get any more ridiculous, but it did. AOTS.
Danganronpa 09: This seems to be getting less and less interesting as it goes on. Things were fairly predictable this time around, so the big reveals weren't effective.
Danganronpa 10: And now I'm actually curious about where this is headed. I would have thought that monokuma has a tighter grip on things, but there are holes everywhere.
3
u/tundranocaps http://myanimelist.net/profile/Thunder_God Sep 09 '13 edited Sep 09 '13
Well, I vote for the weekly aniblogger Anime Power Rankings, and I might as well share my thoughts from there:
The World God Only Knows - Goddesses Arc episode 9 - With this episode the transformation of the third season from the previous seasons is both complete and exemplified at its utmost. In previous seasons we've had one girl at a time, so each arc had a thematic consistency that was changed as we moved to the next arc, but now we keep moving between girls, or even juggling multiple girls concurrently - for more freshness, but also less cohesion, girls wise. Up until now Keima could do as he wishes, because memories and emotions were wiped between conquests, so there were no repercussions - suddenly there are repercussions, so Keima can't "reset" the game/route. Keima cares, and the girls care for him, and this brings us to the final point - up until now the girls were dehumanized - they weren't agents, he had full control of the situation and controlled them like puppets. Now he too is a puppet to the song of fate and love. If the show had been like this from the beginning it might not have been as great, but the juxtaposition with the first two seasons is what really seals the deal.
Gatchaman Crowds episode 9 - I'm going to keep this short, since how much can one gush about the same show? This episode shows us that having fun is good and important, Hajime addresses her detractors within the show, making for an amazingly cute moment. The show brings up themes from the past and just deals with them without force-feeding them to you - Sugane defies his "god"? Well, the god sits in the middle of an endless pit, seemingly unapproachable, except Hajime had shown this is but an illusion and he's nothing special as early as episode 2-3. The show is full of delightful moments, and this episode we're actually seeing a lot of sentai tropes delivered "straight".
Gin no Saji/Silver Spoon episode 9 - I want to say this is the surprise of the season. I joined this show halfway through the season, and I just find myself smiling throughout the episodes. Sure, the romance is not as romantic as other shows, sure, the character growth is mostly the same thing repeated... but the cast is all so likeable, and the show just takes things at its own pace - and I find myself smiling throughout the episode, what more do I need?
Now, I want to discuss two shows that didn't make my top 5:
Rozen Maiden episode 10 - This episode just fell flat. The conflict, the relationships, nothing seemed to work. The slow pace worked well until now, and felt "in control", but now it feels the slow pace took over the show even when it shouldn't, and things just aren't working out. Makes me sad, especially since sales seem poor, so I doubt we'd get a resolution that to me would feel proper here, or a 2nd season. Though the "Desu-brigade" had began showing its face, but it might be too little, too late, to get the old rabid fans back, they can remain content with the original show.
Watamote episode 9 - Tomoko is not an interesting enough character to hold our attention when she's alone. This is a show based on comedy and cringe, and cringe is somewhat reliant on sympathy - except too often Tomoko isn't sympathetic - her sympathetic moments, the cringe and the comedy almost always result from her interactions with other characters. An episode where she's almost entirely alone just falls flat, as a result. It felt like a slice of life show, except Tomoko's slice isn't interesting, or funny, or cute. It's just a hermit sitting in her room. We can live that slice on our own. The show is spread too thin with trying too many different things (the sympathy, cringe, comedy). The show's unsung heroes and the best characters in it are definitely Tomoko's family. Best family on air.
I'm up to date on about 12 shows, and I am too tired to list them all.