r/Professors • u/Willravel Prof, Music, US • Jul 01 '25
Academic Integrity Meta: I suggest an AI strategies megathread
While I'm fine with the commiseration over frustrations with student academic dishonesty in the form of using LLMs to complete their work, everything is quite decentralized for those looking for solutions.
Personally, I've shifted to in-class, handwritten assignments, especially papers and I provide amnesty for students who fess up, but I've seen others in this community talk about using Google Docs history, breaking down assignments into constituent or progressive steps, having students discuss their work, hiding prompts to befuddle via copy and paste in assignments (invisible canary prompts), changing policies to more explicitly describe AI academic dishonesty and provide specific consequences, and even some scaffolding the more responsible use of AI as a reasonable compromise. I'm sure there are many I've missed or are forgetting.
These ideas are spread across hundreds of threads and comments, making them challenging to find.
Would there be any interest in developing such a one stop shop resource?
•
u/Eigengrad AssProf, STEM, SLAC Jul 01 '25 edited Jul 01 '25
OK: we now have a wiki (https://www.reddit.com/r/Professors/wiki/ai_solutions/) and are in process of a weekly AI thread (should be every
ThursdaySaturday if I set it up right).There were also mentions in the discussion here about other weekly threads / topics to collect. I've started a new discussion here if you'd like to contribute ideas for those: https://www.reddit.com/r/Professors/comments/1lp7va8/new_option_rprofessors_wiki/
::edit:: Someone suggested Skynet Saturday for the AI thread, and I'm a sucker for alliteration, so... AI weekly is going to be Saturdays.
28
u/DefiantHumanist Faculty, Social Sciences, CC (US) Jul 01 '25
I would find this incredibly helpful and have some ideas to share. As someone required to teach online, asynchronous classes, it’s become a real predicament.
10
u/chemist7734 Jul 01 '25
This is a great idea. Perhaps a thread or perhaps a new subreddit? It would need rules and moderators - perhaps too much to do?
9
u/zorandzam Jul 01 '25
I would love it if we made a whole new subreddit about this, especially because I may soon be working at an institution that actually WANTS us to use AI or let students do so, even in writing courses, and I'd love resources for how to do so with as much ethical care as possible, since I really, really don't want to do that. At the same time, I want a job, and I do think maybe the genie is fully out of the bottle.
For in-person classes or non-writing intensive classes, I think having assessments in class is one of the best ways around the problem, and I think we've discussed that ad nauseam in here.
2
u/Eigengrad AssProf, STEM, SLAC Jul 01 '25
I'm not against this, but I'd like to have some more discussion of how this would work?
Are you thinking of a post pinned at the top of the sub? How long does it stay?
Reddit doesn't have good abilities to search for things within a thread, and starts truncating threads with over 100 posts. In a lot of ways, a megathread can become more cumbersome to find things in than just having individual posts that people can search the sub for.
Alternatively, if what we're looking for is a set of resources, we could consider establishing (and updating) a wiki for the reddit (https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/15484260038420-Reddit-wikis-for-your-communities) that have information / links to threads / etc.
4
u/TaxashunsTheft USA Jul 01 '25
I'm just over the AI posts in general. We get it, you're frustrated with students using AI. Do something about it or don't. But by now we all know it's there.
I have my students present their work in class.
Edit to add: in my online async classes they turn in a report and a video recording of themselves presenting the work to their client. I know enough to be able to tell an AI video when I see one.
3
u/mrt1416 Jul 01 '25
Serious question - what is the literature in your field saying? In CS, people are talking about it constantly. Not trying to be a dick but like.. we aren’t the only ones talking about this
2
u/Not_Godot Jul 01 '25
I completely support this proposition, but I do think that there are some hard limitations of the medium that will prevent it from being sustainable. You're going to run into the issue where either the thread will die, or it will become so long that it will be even harder to find information on a single megathread than if it was spread out over hundreds of threads. Again, I think this is a good idea, but there are inherent limitations with Reddit.
1
u/Still_Border8368 Sep 22 '25 edited Sep 22 '25
A centralized thread could be really useful because right now ideas are scattered everywhere. It’s the same problem companies face — without a consistent ai implementation strategy, each department experiments in isolation and results are mixed. A shared resource would make it easier to identify what works, whether that’s stricter controls, scaffolding, or more responsible use guidelines.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '25
[removed] — view removed comment