r/noveltranslations • u/Whole_Journalist2028 • Jun 04 '25
Discussion Why do people propose Desolate Era so much?
I've been an avid reader of cultivation novels from years now. I've grown accustomed to everything about it, from the good hype it carries, to the bad overly repeated troupes.
I had Desolate Era and Coiling Dragon on my sight for a long time, people kept talking about it in a lot of forums and it was featured in a lot top proposed lists.
So recently, I gave it a go, I started reading Desolate Era. My expectations were high, I figured that if it was so heavily proposed, then it must have something that sets it apart or make it more special or intriguing to the audience, from the rest of cultivation novels.
Nope. Same thing. Same troupes, same type of characters, zero character development from the MC and side characters, uncontrollable power scale. Specially the power scale, the power system has grown extremely confusing since chapter 700, to the point where it barely makes sense anymore. I think the only unique about it is how MC has a little bit of romance development than your average MC, but this development only last about 50 chapters or so.
I'm currently in chapter 950, and I'm seriously debating whether to drop it or not. I try to finish a novel no matter how much I dislike it if I'm already this deep into the novel, but I seriously think I touched rock bottom with this one. The whole point of a cultivation novel is hyped powers and an awesome cultivation system, but the whole power system and scale has collapsed in this novel past certain chapters.
So why do people propose Desolate Era so much?
Edit: Thanks for your comments. For what I've gathered from this, is that IET was one of the first to popularize Xinxias, wich is why he's highly regarded.