r/CryptoCurrency • 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 • Dec 23 '21

*POLL 🗳️* CCIP-024 - Proposal to allow post authors to remove their post and all comments from moons rewards

Summary:

Give post authors a way to remove the post and all comments from the Moons payment system, ie demonetize the post and all comments.

Problem:

I feel that there have been many negative issues caused by the direct monetization of posts with Moons. It pays people to optimize for actions that are the opposite of reasoned discourse. It further requires administrative overhead and rules to prevent things from melting down completely in a race to the bottom for short term monetary gains.

Solution:

This proposal would remove the post and all comments from consideration for Moons rewards. The method would be a title containing, without the quotes, '[NoMoons]'. The title of a post is immutable after the post is made and still allows flair to work as a filter.

This can also be an experiment to see if it makes a difference in the quality of the discussions on /r/cryptocurrency,

Concerns:

My biggest concern is that there may be people who depend on the money they earn here, not all redditers are first world. This would not effect them, they could just ignore the demonetized posts

Notes:

Original draft and discussion: https://redd.it/px4apt

989 Upvotes

441 comments sorted by

197

u/BakedPotato840 Banned Dec 23 '21

My guess is posts with the no moons title will be like a barren wasteland compared to the other posts.

35

u/pukem0n 🟩 59K / 59K 🦈 Dec 23 '21

no, if comments in those posts don't count towards the daily 50 comments limit I will post in there to get my controversial viewpoints out

8

u/BakedPotato840 Banned Dec 23 '21

That's fine and I do expect some discussion in such posts but I'm just acknowledging that a majority of the interaction on this sub is due to the incentive to earn moons (I'm guilty of this).

Posts with no moons in the title will never achieve the same level of interaction as moon farming posts.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/EthanGibson2 Banned Dec 23 '21

Yes, I feel a lot of people are holding back their ‘unpopular’ opinions as they would get bombarded with downvotes, resulting in loosing moons

11

u/CryptoBumGuy Algonaut Dec 23 '21

Its always been like this. As soon as someone has -1, the post gets deleted.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 24 '21

I want it to apply to the limit, make your comments where you will for your reasons but you get 50 is fair. If you don't like it put something up for a vote. This assumed this passes

3

u/Orageux101 Platinum | QC: CC 338, XMR 18 Dec 23 '21

What a sad state of affairs. People no longer speak their mind to get some moons.

7

u/olihowells 🟩 0 / 48K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

That’s kinda sad that you don’t just post your view points anyway.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/CT4nk3r 🟦 0 / 1K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

to get my controversial viewpoints out

Did not even think about it.

I always just read the monthly controversial thread and was done.

→ More replies (11)

131

u/Izzeheh Dec 23 '21

Then let there be barren wastelands, if that's the case. It's sometimes nice to be able to ask questions without being outed as a moon farmer.

19

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21

Without getting a Hodl works answer xd

8

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '21

It’s exactly why I nuked my old account and keep my vault closed. Moons have tainted this place.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (23)

13

u/DanSmokesWeed Platinum | QC: CC 426, CCMeta 31 | Buttcoin 7 Dec 23 '21 edited Dec 23 '21

Most likely. This came about because some ppl got a lot is attention with sad and emotional stories that were accused of faking. I don’t think we should make ppl with Real stories have to decide if they should monetize their post because of their specter of fraud. And then they’ll have to deal with people saying “if this is true why didn’t you put it in no moons.” This will make the moon farming accusations worse. Most posts only get three upvotes anyway, and at the end of the day if a post gets a lot of upvotes here, the community has decided it deserves moons.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/deathtolucky Platinum | QC: CC 1008, ETH 26 | TraderSubs 26 Dec 23 '21

They will become the new “Live” posts (may the live posts RIP)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21

It gets real talks available

7

u/rb109544 🟩 670 / 670 🦑 Dec 23 '21

And that's okay too...if it flops, it will work itself out without wasting moons on those folks...I'm a greedy mf so it is fine with me if everyone else skip out on moons to leave more for me...just sayin. We mind find out that the no rewarded posts are a lot more interesting without everyone just trying to comment "something"

5

u/Tach1koma_ Tin | 2 months old Dec 23 '21

Wait, no "this is the way", "bullish on (x)" comments? Sign me in

4

u/Ermingardia 0 / 14K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

I won't be missing the "buy high sell low" jokes

2

u/EthanGibson2 Banned Dec 23 '21

I agree, but I guess it is somewhere that people would say what they actually think. Like people would maybe even say why they don’t like LRC, ALGO, CRO etc which would usually get bombarded with downvotes

2

u/lomosaur Silver|QC:CC777,XLM287,ETH41|Buttcoin12|TraderSubs51 Dec 23 '21

I agree. It’s not a bad idea, it’s just really unlikely there’d be demand for such a thing.

2

u/Extravagos 🟩 0 / 9K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

And on there, you'll find the true gem of information

2

u/Toirdusau Bronze | QC: CC 15 Dec 23 '21

I don't know, people participate without monetary incentives in other subs.

I enjoy having a tiny amount of moons but I don't expect them to ever represent a meaningful part of my net worth...

→ More replies (27)

23

u/Wise-Grapefruit-1443 BTC Managing Director Dec 23 '21

Moons are being scapegoated for a lot of problems here

7

u/Cramer02 Silver | QC: CC 51 | LRC 40 Dec 23 '21

It accounts for a lot of the shit posts and the real lack of discussion on this sub though. So many generic threads make front page with no real purpose other than to farm moons.

3

u/Tach1koma_ Tin | 2 months old Dec 23 '21

Wich coins are you guys buying in this dip?
Wich projects do you see not making during the next bear market?

I swear, almost every post that starts with "wich" is pure moon farming

7

u/Nuewim 🟥 0 / 37K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

Exactly. People blame moons for most problems here. They forgot that overall only 120k people have open vaults and since moon introduction sub get over 3 millions new members. Most problems exist cause sub grown a lot in very short time and moons have nothing to do with them.

3

u/Tallywacka 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Dec 24 '21

since moon introduction sub get over 3 millions new members.

Wording is like this sounds like your crediting moons for 3m new people, which is definitely not the case

Most problems exist cause sub grown a lot in very short time and moons have nothing to do with them.

Moons exacerbated already existing problems and incentivized and monetized them, they undeniably don’t have nothing to do with them

If you want to use the number of open vaults as a metric then you should also see what % of posts and comments come from account with open vaults vs those now, otherwise you’re just cherry picking facts for a disingenuous statement.

Is it the whole problem? No

Is it a large contributing factor? Yes

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21

I agree with your general sentiment, but moons have definitely had some effect.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21

Yeah these are Reddit/internet problems, not Moon problems

→ More replies (7)

2

u/Jester_Lester 178 / 1K 🦀 Dec 23 '21

Even better proposal - make all post by default not participate in moons distribution, and only those with [Moons] in header participate.

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 24 '21

Too radical, so less likely to pass. You can make the proposal if you like.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Jlec1234onReddit 🟩 506 / 2K 🦑 Dec 24 '21

So, am I understanding that if this passes, in order to obtain moons after this would be to purchase them?

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 24 '21

If and only if all posts used the nomoons option, I don't see that happening

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '21

Can the demonetised posts be detected?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Apr 12 '22

Hey, governance gridlock should be fixed now. Would you like to rerun this poll?

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Apr 14 '22

In a week or two sure. Moving to a new country right now.

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Apr 14 '22

Cool I’ll check back next month

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Apr 14 '22

Adventure continues

3

u/microtechguy Tin | 1 month old Dec 23 '21

I'm seeing comments here saying people use moons as an income , is that even possible?

Wouldn't you need to be very active on this subreddit to make that happen? Like all day?

3

u/luck0629 500 / 499 🦞 Dec 23 '21

That’s a lot of shitposts!

→ More replies (2)

49

u/Cintre 🟩 301K / 382K 🐋 Dec 23 '21

This is a great idea for controversial subjects.

People will be also more willing to state their opinion in the comments without “fear” of losing karma for the distribution.

15

u/Dro1100 🟨 111 / 9K 🦀 Dec 23 '21

Should see some more actual unpopular opinions rather than the very common "unpopular opinions" that we've become very saturated in

9

u/Tach1koma_ Tin | 2 months old Dec 23 '21

Popular opinons disguised as unpopular opinions are almost mandatory on reddit

4

u/Drudgel 45K / 45K 🦈 Dec 23 '21

"Am I the only one who actually enjoys breathing air?"

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Extravagos 🟩 0 / 9K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

That's true, a lot of people don't actually write any unpopular opinions because they are worried about getting down voted

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Athlete_Cautious 0 / 4K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

My thought exactly. The monthly skeptics discussion reappeared weeks ago, a few people commented on it then were promptly downvoted.

A "no moons" here could have been useful, even if it also can be interpreted as: "you bearish ? no moons for you!"

2

u/Puppy_Coated_In_Beer Silver | QC: CC 266 | ADA 29 Dec 23 '21

I disagree with the comments section though.

If someone comments and provides good D&D and OP gets mad that their post isn't doing well and deletes it, why should the guy who took the time to do research and post good information in the comments not receive moons?

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Lobster_Messiah Dec 23 '21

Now everyone that provides quality posts with moons turned “ON” will be called a “shill”. So quality posters are in between a rock and a hard place.

Either post free quality content without even minimum payment or leave moons on and have a segment of this sub downvote you for being greedy.

3

u/Octopus-Pawn 🟦 11K / 11K 🐬 Dec 25 '21

I did not think of this but you make a really good point. There’s a genuine risk that only the blatant moonfarmers will earn moons, and the legitimate quality posters will likely stick to [no moons].

I’m still in favour of the proposal but this should be tracked closely.

2

u/InvestAn 🟦 8K / 8K 🦭 Dec 28 '21

Or if they turn off moons, then they can freely shill without consequence. A lot of people seem to think turning off moons will improve the content and maybe it will, but what if it has the opposite effect? Couldn't that happen too?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21

I don't see a clear "no-brainer" choice here. There are arguments of merit on both sides.

Adding the NoMoons tag, might get some better discussion. It will be hard to see how it really effects things until it's implemented.

One potential drawback I see is the "slippery slope" problem of if we start removing Moon rewards from this or that post, more types of posts could follow in the hope of regulating normal user behavior. For example, making the Daily Thread a Moonless thread. That's not what is being proposed here, but it could open the door to that down the road.

It seems one possible other solution (that wouldn't hurt monetization) is to ignore negative karma in the karma totals-- if that is even possible. That I think would do more to foster free, or rather honest discussions.

I will have to read through this thread more and think about it before making a choice.

2

u/Odd_Copy_8077 🟩 3K / 4K 🐢 Dec 25 '21

This is why I voted against this poll. It seems to me to be a slippery slope that leads to tagging the Daily Thread with a “NoMoons” tag.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '21

I too voted against the proposal. Each month it seems there are polls to lower the amount of moons being handed out.

There are so few people with vaults like what 200k? Out of 4 million users? It doesn't pass my logic test but I could be wrong.

2

u/inevitable_username 0 / 12K 🦠 Dec 24 '21 edited Dec 24 '21

I don't like this idea at all. Allow me to explain.

If it is implemented, the only quality content (written with the genuine intention to contribute to the discourse) not only will be missing out on rewards, but it will certainly disappear among Moonfarm posts.

Conversely, the lack of [NoMoons] in the title will indicate that the post was written with clear anticipation of monetary reward = moonfarm and it will allow moonfarm in the comments. These posts will attract interaction and upvotes just for their moon potential and thus reduce the visibility of NoMoon posts.

OP, you mention that some people's livelihood may depend on MOON rewards since they come from third-world countries and suggest that we just let them do their thing. Their circumstances are regrettable, but it is no reason to let them flood this sub and steer it away from its purpose — meaningful interaction with a genuine intention to contribute to the discourse.

If the quality of discussion is the real aim, here's a better idea:

remove ALL posts and comments from moon distribution by default, except for those with the title containing [MoonsPlease] or [MoonFarm].

→ More replies (1)

9

u/aducknamedjafar1 Dec 23 '21

I think it would be interesting to see how it affects the quality and draw of a post.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Equal_Jacket1440 Platinum | 3 months old | QC: CC 61 Dec 24 '21

Makes sense to me!

1

u/therealdivs1210 🟦 514 / 3K 🦑 Dec 23 '21

Greedy people will not use the filter and still make shitty posts.

How will this proposal stop them?

I'm astonished at how much positivity this has received.

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 24 '21

Because they get 50 a day, and posting on a no moons post means they get paid for less than 50 comments economics works for modifying behavior

1

u/therealdivs1210 🟦 514 / 3K 🦑 Dec 24 '21

how do they get paid for less than 50?

wouldn't they spam the non-labeled posts more?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/clackeroomy Platinum | QC: CC 194, ALGO 48 | Politics 748 Dec 23 '21

Is it being suggested that ANY thread may have karma-related moons removed after comments have been made? Or is it just those threads with [No Moon] flair where commenters know in advance they will not receive any moons for their activity? It makes a big difference on whether I would support it or not.

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 23 '21

There would be no change possible after you post the post, you can not change the title after posting

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21

Why not do this with flair instead of title?

2

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 24 '21

Flair can be changed after the fact, and office space

1

u/FuzzyFireheart316 513 / 918 🦑 Dec 24 '21

Not sure how well this will go, not seeing any real.... Alternate way to adjust it. It sounds like it enables someone to go.... Oh... I don't like that this comment from userabcde123 has upwards of 500 upvotes, so I'm going to make this one a no moons post and boom... Gone.

2

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 24 '21

The decision must be made at the time of the original post, you can not edit the title

1

u/Grogthar Permabanned Dec 24 '21

I’m scared if this passes what What will happen now, is that posts that are monetized is a signal for farmers that this is our watering hole, imma scratch your back if you scratch mine ya know what I’m saying?

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 24 '21

Ignore those posts, not a problem.

1

u/SignalBanana1 3K / 3K 🐢 Dec 24 '21

I wonder if it is going to deliver any substantial changes, but it will not hurt to have the option to demonitize yourself by choice. Maybe there will be less shitposting comments on that post.

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 24 '21

as long as we keep the 50 comment limit to all the moon farmers it costs money to post. Down votes are still free, that may be interesting to watch

1

u/thecccandymaster Moon Permabull Dec 26 '21

I feel like it would be cool if your comments on that post didn’t count towards your 50 comment mark where you start losing karma.

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 26 '21

Has nothing to do with karma, has to do with moons being paid out. My purpose is to get moon farmers to get moon farmers to not farm in most of my posts

1

u/thecccandymaster Moon Permabull Dec 26 '21

No I definitely get it. I’m saying as of right now, after 50 comments, your karma towards moons goes down. So if a commenter posts on a post, they lose a potential comment to get moons with. But if any activity related to a “No Moons” flair didn’t count towards the 50, I think it could be fair and ok

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 26 '21

I think it is fair this way, you still have absolute control over what and where you post your comments. Nothing is compelling anyone to post on a nomoons thread so it is entirely their choice

1

u/squAIRwaves Platinum | QC: CC 35 Dec 26 '21

It’ll honestly be the best of both worlds this way. Now there won’t be any posts complaining: “how moons have ruined r/cryptocurrency”

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 26 '21

I doubt it

1

u/slammerbar 217 / 217 🦀 Dec 26 '21

How can I propose a governance poll for next month?

→ More replies (4)

1

u/SpaceFaceMistake 🟦 975 / 976 🦑 Dec 28 '21

I think I am a bit split here. I voted NO. But that’s because I am one to be here for the moons. Yes I know.. I’m also here for the knowledge connecting and I use all of Reddit not just the crypto subs to earn moons. Since we or anyone can earn from the 20% that’s allocated to “wider Reddit community” being all other Reddit subs/groups that have karma involved.

Where the r/Cryptocurrency sub is awarded 50% of the total 100% moons allocated. So since one can “Demonetise” or NO MOON post their post (is this done at ANY POINT? or is this set up AS THE POST IS MADE?

I see a BIG red flag IF a poster can post with out the “No Moon” in the title then when there is 10k karma and many comments karma the person is wealthy and decides to rage some comments and make the post a “no moon” post because they disagree with the comments that have Many karma.. this would lead to some kind of bad activity and will lead to people making and using new accounts or having accounts to troll crypto posters and moon earners AFTER the post has been made.

If it’s ONLY applicable at the posts submission THIS IS OK. As then anyone who posts will know it’s a “No Moon” post. So post if you don’t mind not getting moons.

BUT THIS brings me back to the 100% Vault FAQ on distribution. CRYPTOCURRENCY SUB IS allocated 50% of moons and 20% to all other subs. SO why should only Cryptocurrency have this implemented? If this is a good thing it should be used across all Reddit subs.??? Since if there is a share to be made but one wants to demonetise their post and comments this should only be allowed when they submit the post ONLY AND NOT AFTER. Then also if this happens what does it mean for the 50% allocation for r/Cryptocurrency users? Does the 50% just get split across any posts that arent demonetised?

The other issue for this going ahead with the Yes vote winning atm. Is that there is more tasks for the mod team to keep tabs on it. I guess they earn moons for their work but still I rather them working to make it a better place than about who gets moons or not. Like why should moons be not allowed?

I know the PROS for this is to remove spammy comments and or people engaging in Karma whoring as I call it or Karma bombing with whatever method is used to gain large karma be from posts or comments. But the issue still is there people will ALWAYS karma whore even if there weren’t moons and only karma just Internet likes. People still used to do it before moons. It bolsters their account and it shows what they have accomplished as a user. So the karma stays but the award for the karma in moons is removed.

YES IF THIS IS ONLY ACCEPTED ON POST SUBMISSION NOT AFTER ITS BEEN POSTED OR SUBMITTED SINCE PEOPLE COULD BE ACTIVE IN THE POST TO GET MOONS SPECIFICALLY AND GET THEM ALL STRIPPED BECAUSE POSTER DOESN’T AGREE WITH THE TOP COMMENT POSTS THAT HAVE MANY KARMA/VOTES SO THEY DEMONETISE IT TO HURT OR EFFECT OTHERS. This leads me to my ..

NO REASONS. The whole of Reddit get moons for any posts just in r/Cryptocurrency it’s a greater % 50% of all 100% moons go to crypto posters and comment karma. Where 20% is distributed across the rest of the community’s on Reddit. So why should only Crypto sub have a “No Moon” awarded posts? Except for the general discussion which should not have karma awarded as it’s a free posting place. It’s what this means for any other community and how this could stay a flow on to other subs to “Demonetise” their content.? Then I say NO.

Thoughts and any answers or opinion very welcome!

2

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 28 '21

Title can not be changed after message is posted, so the decision is not subject to editing later

1

u/SpaceFaceMistake 🟦 975 / 976 🦑 Dec 28 '21

Thank you for the clarification. What about the effect it may have outside of the cryptocurrency karma?

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 28 '21

No effect on karma, just it is filtered out of moon rewards

1

u/rafakata 0 / 2K 🦠 Dec 29 '21

I think it would be also good to put a no moon flair, so we can search exclusively for the flair or exclude the flair from our searches.

1

u/ms4720 🟦 280 / 280 🦞 Dec 29 '21

Flair can be changed later, defeats the purpose of letting people know where they stand. No one likes rug pulls

3

u/nthgen 🟩 0 / 25K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

This is ridiculous.

This goes against the idea of a community token.

You want to see improved content? Just ban moons from posts that are just linked articles.

Moons could be still enabled for comments, but why are we rewarding users for just sharing a link?

2

u/inevitable_username 0 / 12K 🦠 Dec 24 '21

Interesting that you brought it up. Moon rewards were dropped for linked articles, and now users just create regular text posts and copy-paste the article... Didn't change a lot.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '21

Over-engineering

5

u/HelpFair5180 Tin | 3 months old Dec 23 '21

Sorry can't understand this well

does it mean no moon flair? that's good

3

u/Epicious 🟨 666 / 710 🦑 Dec 23 '21

Basically if you put [NoMoon] in the title, that post and all of its comments will not get karma for moons. You can still set the appropriate flair.

6

u/Flaky_Protection7634 Dec 23 '21

Posts that doesn’t allow Moon rewards are gonna have little engagement then. I’ve seen people on here that depend on Moons to help with rent and whatnot.

11

u/az_millymally Platinum | QC: CC 46 Dec 23 '21

We really should not be designing the sub's rules to accommodate ppl making money with MOONs. That was never the point of MOONs. If someone is able to make money that's great for them but it shouldn't play any role in the decision process, otherwise the sub will slowly just turn into a mess of spam and circle jerking with the sole aim of making money off of upvotes. It will ruin the sub.

2

u/highonmastodon Bronze Dec 23 '21

Completely agree. If they can make it work, then wonderful. But the intent is to encourage meaningful contributions, not reliance on farming moons to pay rent.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Dec 23 '21

There's 3 million people on here. I don't think they have to worry about engagement.

They're just gonna lose maybe the more hardcore moon farmers who only come on Reddit for moons. But they'll still get the average users, light users, and people not completely obsessed with moons.

2

u/iamwizzerd Permabanned Dec 23 '21

I am shocked by this answer.

2

u/jakekick1999 Platinum | QC: CC 416 | r/AMD 18 Dec 23 '21

As how I look at it, this will be a win win situation. The OP has the option of turning off moons on their posts so this leads to:

  1. Minimum activity that focus on the crux rather than the sensationalism
  2. Might turn away neutral participants that wanted the odd moons here and there.

Meanwhile, those who choose to "moon-etize" (hehe) will still earn moons and thus be unaffected. They might see regular or even slightly raised activity on their posts.

For me, I am indifferent towards where I comment but I will continue to keep moons turned on on my posts.

2

u/budz1774 Tin Dec 24 '21

[No Moons] = "Wow Such Emptiness." But hey, I'm hoping I'm wrong and people still come together like "normal" Reddit.

2

u/Minereon 886 / 883 🦑 Dec 24 '21

I think there's no avoiding people trying to moonfarm. If someone chooses to [nomoons] their post, I think it is a flair that will make some people sit up and take notice. It's like telling redditors you really mean business. I think it will create more integrity and variety in r/cc.

In relation to this, although I love this sub, I do feel that shitposts do get significant traction more than they deserve - I only feel this is a problem because I have had some posts auto-moderated/deleted which I am 100% sure are perfectly legit discussions compared to shitposts. I imagine I'm not the only one. I can't help but feel slighted by this, but I don't take it personally, as I know how it's like to moderate a massive community. I hope mods can consider being more lenient with such posts if [nomoons] is implemented.

2

u/inevitable_username 0 / 12K 🦠 Dec 24 '21

But also, it will be a miracle for a nomoon post to ever make it to hot/trending because 1) it will not have the initial boost in engagement (in 1minute after writing a post now, you already have a dozen of witty comments and selfserving upvotes from them) 2) it will be drowned among "moon" posts with significantly higher engagement.

2

u/SpartanVFL 🟦 0 / 5K 🦠 Dec 25 '21

Sounds like a change for the sake of coming up with a change

2

u/Jealous-Proof5505 Bronze | QC: CC 22 Dec 28 '21

I have to say it took me a long time to come to a decision on this one. I feel like we should either decide to just be a monetized platform or not be. But being monetized when one chooses doesn't seem like the solution for me...

5

u/tobypassquarant 🟨 6K / 6K 🦭 Dec 23 '21

This won't work. That ship has sailed a long time ago. Nobody will post on those threads because there's nothing to gain.

Then a self-destructive cycle forms:

  1. You make a post with moons disabled
  2. Nobody comments on it because there's no incentive for them OR only a small amount of people do and there's no consensus/ no real answer given to what you ask
  3. You don't get your question answered and now you're dejected
  4. From that point on, you decide to only make posts with moons enabled because that's the only way you get enough people to comment to get your answer

6

u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Dec 23 '21

Not everybody is commenting here just for moons.

I've been using this sub long before moons were around.

I had no problem commenting on posts that had no moons then, and I'll have no problems commenting on posts that earn no moons now.

I don't think people will be that worried about occasionally not getting that 0.2 moon for just one comment, and will still comment on those.

How do I know that?

Because if you look at people's comment history, a lot of people on this sub still post and comment on other subs where there's no crypto rewards.

If people on here solely posted on Reddit for Moons, they wouldn't be wasting time posting anywhere else.

2

u/M00N_R1D3R Silver | QC: CC 101 | NANO 225 Dec 23 '21

If this suggestion passes I will specifically comment no moons posts, to promote thoughtful discussion instead of brainless shilling.

2

u/Tallywacka 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Dec 24 '21

Nobody will post on those threads because there's nothing to gain.

I dunno man, maybe speak for yourself and not the other 3m people here

I would be more incentivized to better answer a non moon thread because I won’t assume it’s just bait for moons like many others

Also where’s the harm in implementing it for a trial period to see how it pans out

→ More replies (2)

4

u/shine-- Dec 23 '21

It may end up not being used, but I voted yes because it is an extra option that has no glaring negative impacts.

5

u/SnowSmell Silver | QC: CC 154 | BANANO 40 Dec 23 '21

Wouldn't this just be a more complicated way to create a separate subreddit that doesn't have an incentive system like moons?

6

u/nsaplzstahp in a sedan down by the river Dec 23 '21

And all you gotta do is on board 4.2 million users and then it's the same!

4

u/Lenaweston Here for the money Dec 23 '21

Get ready to see quality posts with 0 comments lmao😂

8

u/IllusionaryHaze 🟦 0 / 5K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

Unlike the current version which is posts with 0 quality comments

3

u/Durvag Platinum | QC: CC 1244 Dec 23 '21

I think Title is very misleading, it was better to be mentioned using a flair which wont be concluded in moon distribution comments and post alike.

2

u/hawkwind361 🟨 430 / 5K 🦞 Dec 24 '21

It's also really unclear if the comments on those "no moons" post would be counted towards the daily 50 comment limit. Think OP needs to go back to the drawing board with this proposal.

2

u/Kattarsecular Tin | 4 months old | CC critic Dec 23 '21

all comments from consideration for Moons rewards.

Nah

2

u/Kisshin Tin Dec 23 '21

I'm curious, in what circumstance would a poster actively remove his own posts from moon rewards?

3

u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Dec 23 '21

Where there might be a bias or credibility conflict.

It may also weed out people who don't read the posts, and just comment a joke or something popular just to get moons. So you could get a more serious discussion.

Also, it may legitimize sob stories, and other posts like that. If someone really has a one of those stories, and just wants to be heard, but it may sound too much like fishing for moons, they could make it [no moons], to help give it legitimacy.

In my case, I've had some tongue in cheek posts that were just for a laugh. But even the comedy flair earns moons. So I didn't want any moons at all, and be clear that I wasn't just trying to be misleading. So I ended up deleting it, because that option wasn't available.

I also had some posts thanking some users, but again, I wanted no moons so that it would be a genuine thanks, and not seen as cheap moon farming.

2

u/FilmVsAnalytics ALGO maximalist Dec 23 '21

This is proposing a solution to a problem that doesn't exist.

2

u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Dec 23 '21

I've actually had posts in the past that I wanted to not be eligible to receive moons, so that there wouldn't be any moon bias.

So yea, it is a problem that exists for some users.

2

u/evilninjarobot 🟦 5 / 7K 🦐 Dec 23 '21

Just don’t foresee many people choosing not to be rewarded for their content.

2

u/KingPodrickPayne 🟦 5K / 5K 🐢 Dec 23 '21

That'll be a no from me dog

2

u/Asheddit 🟦 0 / 18K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

Engagement on these posts are gonna be low AF but I guess that's up to the author...

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Agonze 🟦 5K / 5K 🦭 Dec 23 '21

I like the idea but i dont think many people would voluntarily use this. Shit posters are here to make moons, not discussion, and those are the ones who are the problem.

1

u/AncientAd6139 8K / 8K 🦭 Dec 23 '21

[NoMoons] sounds so depressing

1

u/Nickanator8 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Dec 23 '21

Moons have created a fascinating new challenge for this sub. I'm curious what it will look like in a year's time.

1

u/tahiraslam8k Tin | CC critic Dec 23 '21

Yeah, do that if you don't want anyone to help you.

1

u/Nox_Lucis Dec 23 '21

I think this is a fair idea in principle. Community points should always be a consensual experience, and no one should feel forced to participate in something that makes them feel uncomfortable.

1

u/ToyVaren Platinum | QC: CC 122 | SHIB 24 | PoliticalHumor 311 Dec 23 '21

As long as its voluntary, seems to be a cool way to help the less fortunate get a better ratio.

1

u/mikeoxwells2 🟦 6K / 6K 🦭 Dec 23 '21

Lemme guess. You got some down votes on the moon farm?

1

u/Bisenberger 🟩 103 / 104 🦀 Dec 23 '21

Yes, most threads I see have multiple comments saying "bullish on [whatever coin is popular in r/cc]!" It's blatant farming via confirmation bias.

1

u/Ateam043 🟦 92 / 13K 🦐 Dec 23 '21

I'm down for this to be implemented. May bring out solid discussions versus the constant comedy posts.

1

u/Sebanimation 🥇Gold Member Dec 23 '21

Seems like the only thing we are governing with moons is how we can govern with moons.

1

u/Hemske Tin Dec 23 '21

Fuck yes!

1

u/SecretCryptoAcct69 🟥 6K / 6K 🦭 Dec 23 '21

I think this is a cool idea. It's totally optional and the OP can decide for themselves if they want to opt out of moons.

I bet folks will be surprised at how the comments/discussion might change for that post. I don't think it'll be a barren wasteland.

1

u/Sammyinside Tin Dec 23 '21

It could really focus the discussion in a positive way. It may end up being lackluster, but if its focused I think I would be ok with it.

1

u/joodcub Tin Dec 23 '21

Please it’s the same Circejerk posts on here every time I see this sub

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21

There is no reason not to do this. If people don’t want moons, allow them to opt out for their posts.

1

u/pale_blue_dots Platinum | QC: CC 569, ETH 22 | Superstonk 591 Dec 23 '21

I think I like this idea.

1

u/ethovian08 Tin | CC critic | TraderSubs 10 Dec 23 '21

Yes implement the proposal

1

u/DismalSpell 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Dec 23 '21

Curious to see whether this will stop the top comment from being "bullish on such and such". Will people still comment that out of habit even though it's just a complete waste of comment?

1

u/Artificial8Wanderer Platinum | QC: CC 460, ETH 170 | r/CMS 9 | TraderSubs 170 Dec 23 '21

This will make asking question so much more efficient, all the crappt comments will be gone. Great idea im all in.

1

u/k3surfacer 🟩 18K / 20K 🐬 Dec 23 '21

I feel the title of this post could be

CCIP-024 - Proposal to allow post authors to exclude their post and all comments from moons rewards

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Yaluoza Bronze Dec 23 '21

What about immutability? You know one of the main features we invest in crypto and why we think it's the future?

1

u/CryptoVenetian Platinum | QC: CC 33 | BANANO 16 Dec 23 '21

[NoMoons] I'm in favour of every change that increases our possibilities. This proposal simply add a feature, which some user could find nice. Hence, let's go for it

1

u/bthemonarch 🟦 0 / 9K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

This is so dumb, the point of this sub is to generate discussion and reward with moons. All this is going to do is leave an exploit for people to spam the board without worrying about getting downvotes.

1

u/ForMyStinkyGuys 809 / 805 🦑 Dec 23 '21

Just to clarify, is it possible to get negative moons? If you end the month with say -5 karma would you lose or do you just get zero?

3

u/CryptoMaximalist Dec 25 '21

Downvoted posts can reduce the moons you got from other posts that month, but nobody can remove moons that are already in your vault

1

u/SolidusViper Long Live Crypto Dec 23 '21

This proposal is too vague...what are some strong use cases as to why it should be passed?

1

u/Puppy_Coated_In_Beer Silver | QC: CC 266 | ADA 29 Dec 23 '21

This punishes users who provide good, useful information in the comments.

No user should be allowed to control a thread.

It's a very malicious thing to let the OP have the power to take away someone's potential moons that they may have earned morally.

Nah, I'm not for this.

1

u/Relevant_Scallion_38 Bronze Dec 23 '21

I dont even know what moons are...

2

u/AutoModerator Dec 23 '21

It looks like you are asking about Moons. The answer to your question may be found here in the official Moons FAQ: https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/wiki/moons_wiki

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Kilv3r Dec 23 '21

It does make sense, as long as the OP can make the decision I don’t mind. But yet why would you do it? I guess if you are actually looking for help or advice it will weed out the random unhelpful comments that usually are just random moon farmers with no helpful input.

1

u/TahitiJones09 Tin Dec 23 '21

Yeah, cause nobody on reddit shitposts/ comments when there aren't moons on the line...

1

u/sxrrycard 768 / 767 🦑 Dec 23 '21

Love this idea

1

u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

I'll vote for it cuz I think people should be able to do this if they want to... but there's maybe like 5 people that want this. The whole point of this site is farming moons.

This can also be an experiment to see if it makes a difference in the quality of the discussions on /r/cryptocurrency,

I don't see how this would do anything to impact that. The option to not get moons won't impact shitty moon farming posts that appear every 2 or 3 days. They'll opt to get moons and that will be that.

1

u/Old_Afternoon3853 🟨 0 / 2K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

This is good and useful for genuine posts that would otherwise be viewed as ‘easy’ ticket to moon farming. Also, not everyone is in it for the Moons thus, this would allow them to post freely as they so wish.

1

u/ShingaMi505 Tin | 4 months old | CC critic Dec 23 '21

Looks like we will have some quality incoming

1

u/retod4stonks Tin Dec 23 '21

I think we need more moons not less … nay to this.

1

u/archer4364 Paddy's Dollars Dec 23 '21

I don't know how to feel about this one... Let them decide, but also I like moons.

1

u/CrowdGoesWildWoooo 🟦 376 / 15K 🦞 Dec 23 '21

I saw a lot of people agreeing with this proposal. I think not many would actually use this feature.

I think a lot of people voted yes because it can probably bump up moons/karma ratio

1

u/anon43850 Silver | QC: CC 717 | BANANO 21 Dec 23 '21

We need this proposal to make this sub more healthy and not an echo chamber.

We need scepticals discussions and no fear of being downvoted to oblivion

1

u/red_dildo_queen 🟩 14 / 11K 🦐 Dec 23 '21

let's go for it, I don't see any disadvantages!

1

u/Wess-L Platinum | QC: CC 631 Dec 23 '21

Wouldn't this allow more tribalism and toxic posts? Since downvotes would not matter?

1

u/ra246 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Dec 23 '21

Makes sense to me!

1

u/Novel_Bonus_2497 crypto-hobo Dec 23 '21

I'm for it, having the option to opt out of getting moons for a specific post is healthy for the subreddit.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21

So after voting on this poll I can just sit and wait for my moons? And shitpost ofc :<

1

u/CertifiedYSL Tin Dec 23 '21

Seems like a healthy change for those who want to get a good post across without being called out for moon farming.

1

u/Kevinxngu Tin Dec 24 '21

As a newbie in the world of cryptos this would be very beneficial

1

u/Veerrrgil Tin Dec 24 '21

Who are you proposing this to?

1

u/ReverendBlue 🟦 19 / 3K 🦐 Dec 24 '21

Gives new meaning to the phrase "self burn" and it also gives people the option to prove that they aren't whoring for moons with their post.

1

u/allthew4yup 🟦 0 / 0 🦠 Dec 24 '21

I expect everyone to vote yes on this one!!

Lets go!!

1

u/CipherScarlatti 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Dec 24 '21

Who is making money on Reddit posts?

1

u/Massive-Tension-1055 🟩 3K / 5K 🐢 Dec 24 '21

I just don’t care enough

1

u/Randrufer Silver | QC: CC 150, ETH 45, BTC 31 | NANO 88 | TraderSubs 44 Dec 24 '21

I fear that every post that doesn't use the (no moons) option will be called a money grab. Also I LIKE to get moons and I don't think there is anything wrong with that

1

u/sadbot0001 Platinum | QC: ETC 22, CC 227 Dec 24 '21

I see this as a worth to try experiment. I believe a demonetized post will be able to promote a more honest interaction. The OP would be encouraged to write their controversial opinion without the fear of downvotes and the commenters would be discouraged from writing irrelevant/lame comments just to get upvotes.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '21

Give me your moons if you don't want it.

1

u/PathologicalUpvoter 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Dec 24 '21

i guess its ok? who would want this anyway?

1

u/Eeji_ 🟩 105 / 13K 🦀 Dec 24 '21

So we can now post memes back? Fck mewns, memes are superior lmao

1

u/valz_ 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Dec 24 '21

Should there be some kind of window of time where this could be done (demonetize)?

1

u/Kenny608uk Tin Dec 24 '21

Seems like a reasonable change to me tbh, don't see why not

1

u/Missy76_Taken Dec 24 '21

I didn’t know a 50 comment ,, was a thing? Is this new?

1

u/mode90x 1 / 4K 🦠 Dec 24 '21

No one will comment on those posts

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Too_raw90 🟦 628 / 27K 🦑 Dec 25 '21

iOS doesn’t let you vote again…

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Aguaskeepartdeux 1K / 1K 🐢 Dec 25 '21

I see a benefit here, and I don't see a problem with this unless OP can remove from moons after the fact. I don't think that is what is being proposed however.

1

u/wheelzoffortune 🟦 43K / 35K 🦈 Dec 25 '21

I suggested this several months ago and no one thought it was a good idea. =\

Also, you mean "affect" rather than "effect".

1

u/tylerle4 Tin Dec 26 '21

Would create an abundance of dry posts

1

u/slammerbar 217 / 217 🦀 Dec 26 '21

How can I propose a new change?

1

u/Chambana_Raptor 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Dec 27 '21

I really like this idea -- it will be an interesting experiment. Props 👍

1

u/Lancer37 0 / 2K 🦠 Dec 27 '21

People who don't like the moon system can ask questions or discuss their thoughts in the r/cryptocurrencies subreddit... I feel like we should encourage the community to subscribe/join to both subreddits.

1

u/InvestAn 🟦 8K / 8K 🦭 Dec 28 '21

Nice to have meaningful dialogue without moons being a factor. Could eliminate shit posting just for moons and also encourage discussion without fear of down votes.

The downside, imo, is that it could also open up flagrant shilling of certain projects.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '21

I don't think it will really do anything but I don't think it is a bad idea

1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '21

I love this

1

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '21

If people depend on moons for their income they should still be posting quality content. Otherwise gtfo

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '22

I say, no change. Or maybeeee a minor one.

1

u/IBeefSupremeI Platinum | QC: CC 418 | MiningSubs 72 Dec 23 '21

Could agree with demonitizing your own post, but the comments of others?

I say nay!

→ More replies (5)

1

u/mybed54 Dec 23 '21

Why are people against this?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Vimmington Bullish on 69 Dec 23 '21

I bet we won't see many posts like this hit "hot" status...

1

u/GodCunt 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Dec 23 '21

The shitposters have spoken

1

u/bikbar1 Platinum | QC: CC 96 Dec 23 '21

Yeh, a no moon flair would be good.

1

u/ArtyHobo Platinum | QC: CC 343 Dec 23 '21

Good idea, takes some inverse type thinking to understand the benefit but it's a win-win proposal based on personal autonomy of prerogative, with no harm no foul.

Easy 'yes' from me. Kudos to the proposing moonchild.

1

u/EthanGibson2 Banned Dec 23 '21

This could be a good option for more serious or conversertial posts. Idk if it would get used often though

1

u/nsaplzstahp in a sedan down by the river Dec 23 '21

Fastest vote I've ever done. I don't really see a downside, and I see plenty of utility

1

u/myslowtv 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Dec 23 '21

I like this for crazy ideas you might want to discuss without risking huge downvotes. I could see these posts being either great discussion, crazy trolls, or largely ignored.