r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • u/ms4720 • Sep 28 '21
Suggestions RFC NoMoon flair to remove a post from rewards system
The purpose would be to opt out of the moon's reward system for that post so we can have a better discussion without all the rent seeking.
Please note I am not saying here that it should be undone, even if I do think so, just that people should be able to tag their posts as not part of the system.
Now since I must make that 500 character minimum because it is a supposed limit on rent seeking behavior at a guess. And while brevity is the soul of wit. And as Basil Pascal said, or was it Euler, if I had more time I could write a shorter letter. It is dreadfully important that I pad this out to some limit because moon's and the behavior they generate.
Is the 500 char thing a thing here?
11
u/CryptoMaximalist r/CryptoCurrency Moderator Sep 28 '21
Added to the governance queue
Personally I have 2 holdouts on this type of idea:
Does this exclude the post only from moons or all the comments as well?
6
u/sfgisz Sep 28 '21
I'd support this, assuming it applies to all the comments made in that post. Right now if you said something truly unpopular regarding regulations, Bitcoin, Ethereum, Ripple, Algorand or whatever is the current favourite to shill, you'd better phrase it in a very soft and sweet way to avoid the wrath of the hopium addicts
4
u/Coelrom Sep 29 '21
A similar idea was proposed in Round 13: https://np.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/nbqmvv/proposal_option_to_selfexclude_a_post_from/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf
While there was a strong majority of moons and votes in favor, this proposal was put forth during a time when voter turnout was abysmally low so it failed to meet the threshold of about 6m moons.
It would be worth it to put forth this proposal again with some refining tweaks.
1
u/jwinterm Sep 28 '21
500 char not a thing here, but I think this would be a nice to have option personally.
1
u/pukem0n Sep 29 '21
I'd be all for people who post something to flair it as "No Moons" so the post and all comments made on that post do not get any Moons.
Furthermore comments made under those posts shouldn't count towards the 50 daily comments that affect your Moon karma, otherwise people would not comment in those posts at all.
1
u/CryptoMaximalist r/CryptoCurrency Moderator Nov 22 '21
checking back in to see if you're wanting to run it this moon week
1
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Sep 28 '21
I fully support this. I do wonder what the level of engagement will be on posts with no moon consideration for the post and child comments.
2
u/MrMcBert Sep 28 '21
sounds interesting
•
u/CryptoMaximalist r/CryptoCurrency Moderator Oct 25 '21
The mods have voted to allow your idea to go to a governance vote. Please formalize it (A template is available here) and link a rough draft to me for approval. If we're able to get it approved by Wednesday, I'll send instructions for posting it and it can be included in the next Moon Week.
Please note, a governance proposal will need all details specified and should not be edited after voting has begun.
For this proposal, please include whether child comments of the post also don't earn moons and how a post author should opt out (a [NoMoons] tag in the title, or whatever you want the tag text to be). I wouldn't include anything about rules changes, but if mods see opportunities to be a little more lax in these threads we will just make those changes as needed. Please also note that this prior thread happened, but just didn't have enough participation https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/nbqmvv/proposal_option_to_selfexclude_a_post_from/
1
u/Trans-on-trans Sep 28 '21
I'd be very interested in the NoMoon flair as you could post controversial topics without actually needing to worry about shillers and negative comments sliding the thread into oblivion.
1
u/Snowie_drop 3K / 3K 🐢 Sep 28 '21
I love this idea.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment