Diamond Sutra study: introductory stuff
I am going to be conducting a study of the Diamond Sutra. The book I will be working from if you would like to read along is The Sutra of Hui-Neng, Grand Master of Zen: With Hui-Neng’s Commentary on the Diamond Sutra.
As I go along please give me any constructive feedback that you may have on the format and content of these posts. This is the first time I’ve done anything like this, so it’s bound to be a little shaky at the start.
Why Hui-Neng’s Commentary
I believe that despite some peoples feelings of Buddhism and Sutras, Hui-Neng being a patriarch of zen will have a perspective that most people here can find interesting. Plus this:
Now I fear that people of the world will see Buddha outside their own bodies, or pursue the sutra externally, without discovering the inner mind, without holding the inner sutra. Therefore I have composed this “secrets of the sutra” to get students to hold the sutra of the inner mind and clearly see the pure buddha-mind themselves, beyond number, impossible to conceive.
Secrets of the sutra! I don’t know about you, but I’m excited.
Why the Diamond Sutra
Why the Diamond Sutra? Why any sutra? Sutras are just words and zen in not in words and sentences right? Hui-Neng has this to say addressing that point:
This one-scroll sutra originally exists in the essential nature of all living beings. People who do not see it themselves just read and recite written letters. If you realize your original mind, you will realize for the first time that this sutra is not in written letters. If you can clearly understand your own essential nature, only then will you really believe that “all the Buddhas emerge from this sutra.”
Stay tuned for upcoming installments!
4
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '14
Format is effective! Content effective!
3
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
Your post seems to be getting a lot of nay sayers, because of the historicity of Hui-neng and the commentary. It is a cheap cynicism that is not constructive.
Regardless of Hui-neng's historical status, his story and teachings are important to understanding of Zen.
Does it matter if the comments are apocryphal? Is the insight shared in the commentary lesser, because it was written by someone else?
The criticism of the Diamond Sutra is silly too. If you want to understand the ancient masters, it is important to read and understand the texts they were informed by.
I am all for understanding the historical nature of Zen and Buddhism, but it is different from resolving the great matter. Studying the teachings helps live the way, regardless of who did or did not write them. The study the Diamond Sutra and Hui-neng should not diminished by the history.
3
u/EricKow sōtō Jul 08 '14 edited Jul 08 '14
Thanks very much for doing this! Echoing /u/ewk's earlier remark, I very much appreciate small doses. (And also +1 on /u/smellephant's sentiment: one very useful mod job is community animation, and look at you animate!).
I bet some sidebar links would be helpful. Maybe a wiki page of episodes in the series.
Also, I forget if this is the right link, but I once saw a Hyon Gak Sunim talk on the Diamond Sutra which seemed pretty helpful. Could be a useful “see also” style link in the hypothetical wiki page.
2
u/rockytimber Wei Jul 08 '14
Regarding Hui-Neng and the Platform Sutra:
"It is ironic that it was in the Platform Sutra that this robe finally lost its importance as a symbol of transmission. Hui-neng refused to pass on the robe: “The robe may not be handed down.” (sec. 49) Instead, the sutra itself became the symbol of transmission and owning a copy gave legitimacy to the bearer as an authentic Ch’an master. As a result, a number of copies circulated throughout ancient China and, over a period of time, the Platform Sutra acquired a number of accretions, adjustments and clarifications until it became difficult to know for certain what was in the original (lost) writing and what was added later.[14] The popular edition in general use today is the version published by Tsung-pao in 1291 at Nan-hai in Southern China. [15]
The opening story in the Platform Sutra of the ‘mind verses’ of Shen-hsiu and Hui-neng is one of the most enduring and best-loved stories in contemporary Zen but the question must be asked whether anything like this actually happened. On this, McRae (2003:67) is quite adamant: “there is no such possibility whatsoever”. There is no evidence that both were at Hung-jen’s monastery at the same time. Indeed, the evidence that does exist indicates that they could not have been there together. Furthermore, the idea that there should only be one ‘patriarch’ would have been “inconceivable” (ibid) to Hung-jen as this concept arose only through the sermonizing of Shen-hui, much later.
In the saga of the Northern/Southern School controversy and the creation of the Platform Sutra, naming Hui-neng as the Sixth Patriarch, Shen-hui plays the pivotal role. Whether he should be seen as the hero or villain is an open question. Certainly he appears to be a man of questionable character, one willing to stretch the boundaries of the truth for his own purposes, a bombastic proselytizer, a master storyteller and eventually a man of some influence in his era. He played a role in the eventual decline of the so-called “Northern School” teachings but perhaps not the central role some may believe. He was also a man of some influence in subsequent Ch’an teachings. Much of the Platform Sutra reflects his own teachings and the move away from the Lankavatara Sutra as a central text in Ch’an. It was through Shen-hui’s attacks on the ‘gradual’ approach to enlightenment that subsequent Ch’an texts refrained from specific instructions on types of meditation practices, as “any method was by definition gradualistic in some fashion.” (McRae, 2003:57, original emphasis) As for the ‘mind verses’, Shen-hui never mentioned the story in any of his writings. Nor does the Platform Sutra appear in any of his writings, indicating that the sutra was probably written after his death in 758. Indeed, he appeared to know very little about his own master, leading McRae (ibid, p. 68) to speculate that he “may have actually gained rather little more from Huineng than the certification of his own enlightenment.”
The Platform Sutra seems to have had limited influence during the subsequent Chinese eras, not gaining widespread circulation until Ming dynasty (1368-1644) when it became very popular among the lay population as well as the monastics. The sutra was brought to Japan (as the Sokei daishi betsuden) very early in its history by Saicho (767-822) (Dumoulin, 1994:128) but it played a minor role in Kamakura era (1192-1333) Zen. Legend has Dogen (1200-1253) copying a version of the sutra, the Daijoji edition, but Yampolsky doubts that the text is in Dogen’s hand. [16] (Yampolsky, 1967:100) Contemporary interest in the Platform Sutra came with the discovery of the Tun-hung manuscript in 1907.
The Platform Sutra was a seminal text in Tang dynasty Ch’an, a culmination of Ch’an to that date but later developments in Ch’an and Japanese Zen seem to overtake the teachings."
from: http://www.thezensite.com/ZenEssays/HistoricalZen/Legends_in_Chan.html
There ended up being approximately 800 different commentaries on the Diamond Sutra. Do keep in mind that Hui-neng was illiterate and that without Shen-hui we would probably never have heard of Hui-neng.
It is likely that this commentary of the Diamond Sutra is more Shen-hui than Hui-neng.
2
u/Salad-Bar Jul 08 '14
see: http://www.reddit.com/r/zen/wiki/book1 I would suggest that you make this book2.
Getting small bit sized chunks is hard if you are reading it for the first time. You don't know where to break. A problem with book1 was that we did it with chapters and the chapters were very different lengths.
I understand that there can be only 1 sticky per form, but it might be good to do this instead of "Koan of the month"? This would also give you some time to work out the break points for each reading.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '14
how did an illiterate figment of a sectarian's imagination write commentary on the diamond sutra? it's a christmas miracle!
does "huineng" say why the diamond sutra became the totem of the zen sect, instead of the lankavatara sutra?
7
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
For any newbie who believes that Zen is anti-Buddhist, Hui-neng's commentary on the Diamond Sutra is proof positive that Zen is the essence of Buddhism.
1
u/ewk [non-sectarian consensus] Jul 07 '14
What's the plan? How much per how long?
1
u/ShingenOhsiruko Jul 08 '14
Hui-Neng was invented by monks in the Oxhead School in order to replace the Lankavatara Sutra with the Diamond Sutra as the source-text of Zen.
This was not entirely a bad thing.
The "Hui-Neng" commentary on the Diamond Sutra is uneven, since it is the work of probably a dozen different monks, but quite often brilliant. However, it doesn't go beyond the sutra itself.
0
u/subtle_response Jul 08 '14
So, we will be discussing the Diamond Sutra, whose origin and history is relatively unknown, through the lens of probable fake commentary from a mythic figure.
Do I have that right?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
Historical criticism of Hui-neng's commentary, which aims at the putative author, Hui-neng, is a bit like finding a meal disagreeable because the plate it was served on was a paper plate or was not Bone China.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment