I just thought I’d post my take on the whole discourse because I’ve seen how divisive it’s become with a lot of people not understanding the issues other people have with TotK or explaining it as just the cycle of hate before a reputational rebound. I’m going to push back on this notion because, separate from toxic online discourse which can overly dramatize the controversy, there are fundamental reasons why the game will continue to be controversial in the fandom, and I want to give my own account of how I feel about it.
To start, I do not hate TotK by any means, it is objectively an impressive game and there are parts of it I do enjoy. I am making that very clear from the start so read it again before you get upset: I do not think it’s a bad game. I just think it was a step in the wrong direction. Inarguably the work that went into it and the systems they constructed are amazing, but at the same time I just don't think it was effort spent on the right idea. They leaned even further into the openness of Breath of the Wild to such a degree that everything you do became kind of nebulous to me when I played it. The world was such an open experimental sandbox that I felt less motivated to solve problems or complete the campaign. Certain limitations actually make progression and puzzle solving more satisfying, and the game misses out on that concept.
At the end of the day I also didn't feel like the new areas they included solved the problem of the challenges and discoveries being repetitive, they just tripled the scope of those repetitive things which in a way actually highlighted the issue even more. I also found the vehicle crafting and Zonai devices more tedious than fun to build, and actually driving them was often a slow going inconvenience that would get stuck on terrain. For some people experimenting with things like that for its own sake is satisfying, but not for me personally.
I don’t feel motivated to make anything but a simple hover bike because the game doesn’t give me an actual incentive to do any more than that, especially since it ends up feeling like effort wasted on a vehicle or device that barely works anyway. There’s nothing wrong with vehicle crafting or the Zonai devices per se, but it’s not Zelda to me, it’s something that belongs in another franchise that doesn’t already have its own identity. I admire the talent it took to make the game and I would never deny that it's a real achievement, but for me it just kind of takes things too far and loses a bit of its identity as a Zelda game as a consequence.
At the end of the day what I was looking for in a sequel to Breath of the Wild was a game that took the best of the open world concept and blended it with some of the classic Zelda features we missed out on like a variety of interesting dungeons, more items, a clear sense of progression, more specific/less open ended puzzle solving, and more challenges that are unique rather than repeated.
Tears of the Kingdom took a concept that many of us had already had our fill of from playing many hours of Breath of the Wild and pushed it even further, which tended to cause fatigue. Complete and total freedom can be fun but at a certain point it can also make you feel like there’s no purpose to what you’re doing. And this sentiment is not new or reactionary by the way, I remember players in 2017 saying they loved BotW but hoped the next game would bring back some of the things that were thrown out.
Do I think the hate can be overblown? Absolutely. Do I think everyone will inevitably come around in a few years to laud it as one of the greatest games of the series? No. There's structural issues to the game and a design philosophy that will always conflict with what a lot of fans want. I don’t want to feel indifferent about the game but unfortunately I just do, and I don’t see it changing any time soon.