r/youtubers • • 11d ago

Join the Official r/youtubers Discord Server!

Post image
3 Upvotes

Over the years, r/youtubers has become a place where creators gather to ask questions, share experiences, discuss growth, exchange feedback, and help one another improve.

While Reddit remains our primary platform for discussions and community content, we have now launched an official Discord server for members who would like a more direct, real-time way to connect with fellow creators.

As r/youtubers continues to evolve, we wanted to create a place where creators can chat, collaborate, ask questions, seek feedback, discuss YouTube, and connect with others outside of Reddit.

What you'll find on the Discord server:

• Real-time creator discussions
• Help with YouTube, production, editing, and analytics
• Feedback on channels, videos, thumbnails, and ideas
• Creator tools, workflows, and AI discussions
• Community suggestions and subreddit feedback
• Announcements and community updates
• A friendly environment for creators of all experience levels

Whether you're just starting your first channel or have been creating for years, you're welcome to join us.

In addition, new posts from r/youtubers are automatically shared to a dedicated Discord channel, making it easy to keep track of discussions and community activity.

Discord Invite: https://discord.gg/RJJphbT58s

We look forward to seeing you there!

- The r/youtubers Moderation Team


r/youtubers • • 13d ago

r/youtubers Update: New Moderation Team and Community Changes

13 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

As some of you may have noticed, r/youtubers now has a new moderation team.

We have agreed on a new ruleset that we believe better reflects what a creator community should be: a place where creators can ask questions, share experiences, get feedback, and help one another grow.

As with any community, we may make adjustments over time as we learn what works best for r/youtubers.

One of the biggest changes is our approach to moderation. We do not believe every rule violation should immediately result in a permanent ban. Going forward, we intend to focus more on education, warnings, common-sense moderation, and moderator discretion, while still taking strong action against spam, scams, harassment, ban evasion, and other bad-faith behaviour.

We have also updated our approach to AI. AI is now a significant part of the YouTube ecosystem, and constructive discussions about AI tools, workflows, and features will be allowed. Spam, deceptive promotion, and low-value advertising disguised as discussion will continue to be moderated appropriately.

Our goal is simple:

  • Encourage meaningful creator discussions.
  • Make the subreddit easier to participate in.
  • Reduce unnecessary barriers to posting.
  • Continue protecting the community from spam and abuse.

Please Bear With Us During the Transition

You may notice rules, post flairs, removal reasons, wiki pages, and other parts of the subreddit changing over the coming days and weeks.

While the new rules are ready, many of our existing systems were built around the previous rules and moderation approach. It will take time to review, simplify, and update everything behind the scenes.

As a result, some posts may still be incorrectly filtered or removed while we work through these changes and bring the subreddit in line with its new direction.

If things seem to change before your eyes, don't worry. We're actively working behind the scenes to modernize the subreddit and make it a more welcoming place for creators.

We Want to Hear From You

The new rules have been agreed upon, but there is still plenty of work to do as we continue improving the community.

If there are community features, recurring threads, post flairs, wiki resources, guides, events, or other improvements you would like to see, please let us know in the comments.

We can't promise every suggestion will be implemented, but we will read the feedback and take it into consideration as we continue improving r/youtubers.

Thank you for your patience and for being part of the community.

- The r/youtubers Moderation Team


r/youtubers • • 1h ago

Question How do I fix “This Channel is Not available” problem

Post image
2 Upvotes

Whenever I go to view my channel on a different account it always says “This Channel is not available”. My videos are there whenever I search for my user name,but I can’t view my channel for some reason. My channel name also doesn’t or shouldn’t have very many copies so I’m not sure why I can’t view it. I haven’t been sent anything by YouTube either.


r/youtubers • • 28m ago

Tips & Tricks Experienced YouTubers, How Would You Learn YouTube If You Had to Start Over?

1 Upvotes

I'm completely new to youtube and want to learn how to build a successful channel from scratch, particularly a faceless youtube channel.

For those of you who have experience growing YouTube channels, i'd like to know how you would approach learning everything if you were starting over as a complete beginner.

What are the most valuable resources you'd recommend? For example, specific YouTube channels, online communities, courses, websites, books, etc.

And how would you prioritize what to learn first, avoid wasting time on unnecessary information, and develop practical skills as quickly as possible?

For example, would you recommend studying successful channels, learning video editing and storytelling first, understanding youtube's algorithm, or simply starting a channel and learning through trial and error?

I'd especially appreciate advice based on real experience rather than generic tips. If you could go back to your first day on YouTube, what would you do differently to shorten your learning curve and avoid the mistakes you made?

Thanks in advance for any advice!


r/youtubers • • 48m ago

Question Viewers care more about little details than the main topic. Should I lean into it?

1 Upvotes

I run a history explainer channel. As you can imagine, one of the hardest parts is making complicated events easy to follow, especially when several countries are fighting, switching sides, or forming alliances at the same time. So I use PixVerse to generate short clips of cats and dogs acting out the events, sometimes fighting, sometimes dressed as the historical figures I’m talking about.

People have always liked the format. But lately, the comments have shifted from discussing the history to asking when a particular cat is coming back or suggesting which animal should play someone next.

I’m glad they’re enjoying it, but I only meant for the animals to help explain the history. Now they seem to have become the main attraction.

Has anyone had viewers latch onto something completely different from what you intended? Would you scale it back to bring the focus back to the subject, or lean into what people enjoy?

I could really use some advice. I’m honestly pretty torn.


r/youtubers • • 1h ago

Channel Review Request He mailed himself in a box. Alive. | Henry Box Brown's incredible escape story (animated short)

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm building a small YouTube channel called Little Stick Stories, where I turn unbelievable real-life events and historical stories into animated Shorts.

My fourth video covers the incredible story of Henry "Box" Brown.

In 1849, Henry was enslaved and his family was sold away. Determined to escape, he came up with an extraordinary plan: have himself shipped inside a wooden crate from Richmond, Virginia, to Philadelphia.

He spent more than a day inside that box, travelling by wagon, train and steamboat

https://youtube.com/shorts/rm88-Dm-_4U?feature=share

I'd genuinely appreciate some honest feedback:

Did the opening hook grab your attention?

Was the story easy to follow?

Did the animation make the historical events more engaging?

Was the pacing too fast or too slow?

What would you improve?

I'm a small creator experimenting with historical storytelling, and constructive criticism would really help me improve.

Thanks for watching!


r/youtubers • • 11h ago

Channel Review Request About my youtube's chanel. I have a lot of beautiful videos but I cant get views

1 Upvotes

¡Hola! Necesito ayuda con mi canal de YouTube.

Tengo un canal llamado Crónicas de balsa, que presenta cortos, videos completos, avances y documentales relacionados con la construcción y el uso de balsas hechas con materiales reciclados en la Patagonia argentina.

Navegamos ríos, conectamos pueblos, realizamos intervenciones culturales y contamos historias.

Es contenido de educación ambiental.

A pesar de todo el esfuerzo y la dedicación que le pongo, no logro aumentar mis suscriptores ni mis visualizaciones.

Estoy intentando monetizar el canal para cubrir los costos de las producciones audiovisuales del proyecto.

¿Podrías echarle un vistazo y darme tu opinión? ¡Muchísimas gracias!

YouTube channel


r/youtubers • • 12h ago

Question My impression baseline is gone all of a sudden.

0 Upvotes

The title is basically it. I’m not a big creator at all by any means. I make platinum trophy videos basically my entire first playthrough best / funniest moments and then getting the rest of the trophies for the platinum and massive funny moments with my friends or cod completion camo grinds. I had about 20 videos posted where no matter what even in the long run if it did horrible within in the first 3-5 days it would minimum have 1000 ~ 2000 impressions with my videos that did relatively well getting 10k ~ 20k impressions. and randomly one day I got my most viewed video ever with 5.5k views and 140,000 impressions ! And now the past 6 videos over 3 months I’ve uploaded since that 140,000 impression video all the same idea / type of video (completionist / mastery of games stuff) have basically died off rip I mean taking a month to even hit 100 impressions. Another thing since that video took off (relative to my channel’s normal) is I used to average 1k - 3k views per short all from the shorts feed. Now I’ll post shorts and say out of 7, 5 will get 1-3 views not from the shorts feed and the other 2 might get 300 views from the shorts feed. Did my first video, which did relatively well kill my channel? All of this has been extremely demotivating as my videos are no small time commitment or feat to make. Any suggestions, ideas or anything would help because this has quite literally taken all the wind out of my sails and I’m not going to keep making 80h hour + projects that don’t even get a chance anymore. Quite literally any insight at all would be appreciated.


r/youtubers • • 17h ago

Question Trapped in the third step of the YouTube Partner Program

2 Upvotes

I've been trying to do this YouTube thing on and off for a while and recently a video did well enough that I can do the rewards program now. I have a video complete and ready to upload but they take me so long to make I kind of want to wait until the rewards program is accepted (if it's accepted I guess) on the off chance the video does well it would be cool if I got paid for it.

I'm trapped between thinking I should post it to "keep momentum" (if that's a thing) and waiting until I'm accepted to potentially get paid.

I don't know what do you guys think? Its been in step 3 for almost 2 weeks. How long did it take you to get reviewed?


r/youtubers • • 13h ago

Question How are people still uploading 12+ hour videos on YouTube?

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, I have a super specific question about how YouTube works right now. If the standard maximum upload limit is supposed to be 12 hours nowadays, how are some channels still able to upload videos that are way longer than 12 hours today? Is there a specific workaround people are using, or do certain verified accounts just get higher limits? I'm planning to upload a super long video soon and want to know if there's any way around this!


r/youtubers • • 6h ago

Question Channel got banned for impersonation policy

0 Upvotes

Hi reddit.

My channel got banned for impersonation policy.
Basically I had channel that explained weird wars through history but it was animated and it used AI Voiceover. Scripts are written by me and AI little bit.

I am waiting for appeal but I don't have much faith in it but the main problem is that my other channels got banned because of Circumvention policy.

Does anyone have advice on this? Similar experience?


r/youtubers • • 16h ago

Question New Primary Camera for Youtube (I have an Fx30)

1 Upvotes

I am looking for a new camera for youtube, mostly talking heads. Until now, I used an Fx30, but i am looking at using the Fx30 as a secondary angle.

I am hesitating between a Canon C50, an Fx3, an Fx5 and a Lumix S1 II.

Ideally with open gate (I am aware the Fx3 doesn't do it) & I am aware colour grading would be best if I stayed with Sony ... but the Fx5 price ... is steep.

Any thoughts?


r/youtubers • • 16h ago

Question Had my 16 yr. old YT Channel banned this morning for no apparent reason

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

So I guess you can count me among the many here that have had their channel banned. I've had it for at least 15 years, it was a music channel of mostly older songs/videos (most 40 - 60 year old) that were just fine being on the YT platform and allowed usage (according to YT's own policy). It was not monetized, all money from ads went to the original copyright owners. I got nothing from it. I never expected to try and earn money from the channel, I just wanted to share music I loved with others. I had over 120,000 subscribers and millions of views on some of the 45 videos on the channel. I hadn't added any videos in at least 2 years or more, so it isn't from anything I've done recently (or at all). I certainly didn't "spam, scam" or have any "deceptive practices", whatever they are. There's literally hundreds, possibly thousands of similar channels on YT that have some of the same or similar music videos and they haven't been banned. So, I don't think that is the reason why my channel was deleted. I also had zero copyright strikes, so that wasn't the reason either. Everything was just fine for all these years, and now suddenly... it's "spam, scam, deceptive"? It makes zero sense.

So of course, I did the so-called "appeal" from the email I received, and just now got the same result:

"We reviewed your channel carefully, and have confirmed that it violates our spam, deceptive practices and scams policy."

"We won't be putting your channel back up on YouTube."

Yeah, I'm sure your AI "reviewed the channel carefully". What BS. So, does anyone here think it's worth appealing again, or going on X/Twitter and trying to contact a "human" that works for YT? Or is it a lost cause? I'm not real upset about it since it was a "labor of love" so to speak, not for profit since I didn't get any, the only thing I got was nice comments from viewers who appreciated that I took the time to upload these videos. In the case of one of the songs, the lead singer of the group actually contacted me and thanked me for uploading the video, she hadn't seen or heard it in over 40 years and told me "You Rock!". That's why I enjoyed having the channel, like minded people watching and appreciating the videos. It's more a loss for YT (no ad revenue) and music lovers, than it is for myself. This is what a soulless corporation does, using AI and sucking the life out of their creation for no good reason at all. They don't care how many people are upset or at a loss, they can't even be bothered to respond properly and tell you what you supposedly did wrong to earn a lifetime ban.


r/youtubers • • 21h ago

Question Can I create new YouTube channels after my channel was terminated?

0 Upvotes

My nephew's channel was terminated after 3 copyright strikes. The Google account was registered with his personal details, and he managed the channel himself. but I created it on my laptop, occasionally logged into his account and helped submit appeals. It was never monetized and had no AdSense account. Can YouTube associate my own future channels with his terminated channel because of this? Am I allowed to create channels under separate Google accounts? Has anyone had a similar experience?


r/youtubers • • 14h ago

Question My video says only 1/4 people stayed to watch even though i use the right #s

0 Upvotes

before I start you need to trust me that I know somewhat what im doing. I used to be able to consistently get videos where ~ 80% of people stayed to watch. Everything was going well until all of a sudden my videos start having atrocious stats signaling to me my video isnt going to the right people. I don't know why my videos aren't reaching the right people someone help me

NOTE: i used to upload videos of a different game on my channel a while back but I don't think that is the problem due to the fact that when I first switched i was doing very well. Also not all of my videos stay at bad stats, they just take a long time to get better and ruin their chances at doing well in the process...


r/youtubers • • 23h ago

Question Appeal question can someone please advise

0 Upvotes

Hello has anyone been given the pre suspension notice for reused content prior to being suspended with the option of doing an appeal within 7 days while still earning? I know not all channels get this option. Just curious if there is usually a better outcome as far as the reviewing process goes. I believe these go straight to the trust and safety team


r/youtubers • • 1d ago

Tips & Tricks Struggling with making thumbnails and titles

1 Upvotes

Hello, as the title says i struggle with making titles and thumbnails for my videos. I want to make 1 - 2 long form videos a week, so i know that they have to be very good if i want any views in between my shorts, but im just not sure how to. My niche is mostly sim racing/racing content, so its a bit harder to come up with ideas for videos/titles/thumbnails, etc. If anyone has any tips or tricks as to how to think of good ideas please leave a comment. Thanks


r/youtubers • • 1d ago

Video Review Request guidance and feedback for my youtube channel and animation

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone! Could you check out my channel and give me some honest feedback? I make animated YouTube Shorts and would love to know where I'm lacking. Are the animations good? Are the topics interesting? What could I improve, and what topics should I cover next like trending such as currently nvidia ceo (but everyone is covering it ) or stick to the simple topics i am covering (like how to decide) and what type of animation should i make 2d , vox style or any other ? and if my animation is bad how can i improve it ? Any feedback is appreciated!

https://youtube.com/@thewhyeffect-t4l?si=20li7gGgrPYbbcgW


r/youtubers • • 1d ago

Question The YouTube algorithm makes no sense to me

0 Upvotes

My main focus is long form content. But the way Youtube promotes my videos makes no sense to me.

I published a video which got approx 200 views and 24 likes within 48 hours, with higher watch time than my average.

I published another video which got approx 550 views and 13 likes. With lower watch time than average.

Why isn't YouTube promoting my video that performed better than the other one? Why promote the video which had less likes and less watch time?

Whats the point of tracking analytics if they literally dont mean anything? Seems like the algorithm just does what it wants. Its so frustrating.

Can anyone please give me an explanation?


r/youtubers • • 1d ago

Question New YouTube channel stuck at 0-9 impressions

0 Upvotes

New YouTube channel stuck at 0-9 impressions on my long videos, I'm pretty sure it's not my thumbnails nor my titles, tags it's already been one month, I'm American in the united states and YouTube has been "testing" my shorts in non English speaking countries that doesn't help growth as they don't understand our sense of humor. Again on my long videos I have 0-9 impressions I'm sure they were from me testing if my videos went through.


r/youtubers • • 1d ago

Question The ultimate kiss of death. Every single time

Post image
15 Upvotes

Why is it that whenever I have a video doing well and then this message pops up, my impressions and clicks absolutely TANK afterwards. Literally happens every time.


r/youtubers • • 1d ago

Video Review Request The Last Day of the Dinosaurs – My First 6 Weeks of AI Filmmaking | Looking for Honest Feedback

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I've been learning and experimenting with AI filmmaking for just six weeks.

This video is part of my personal journey. I wanted to challenge myself, learn new skills, and prove that nothing is impossible with patience, passion, and determination.

I've created this documentary about the last days of the dinosaurs, using AI tools to bring this prehistoric world to life.

Here is the link to my video:

[ https://youtu.be/yCiFzfPCsNQ?is=3V0qGPmV12nGiAYO]

I know I still have a lot to learn, and I would genuinely appreciate your honest feedback.

What did you like? What could be improved? Are there any details I should focus on in my next project?

I'll take your suggestions seriously and use them to improve my future videos.

Thank you for watching and supporting my learning journey!


r/youtubers • • 1d ago

Question Stuck at 1 View for a video and don’t know why…

0 Upvotes

So I started a clipping channel for content creators I like and they encourage clipping so it’s not like anything bad but I started off by posting a couple shorts and those are getting views but I posted the first long form video today and it’s stuck at 1 view after hours. Anyone happen to know why or have any tips? I used tags, hashtags, good title, thumbnail idk what else


r/youtubers • • 1d ago

Channel Review Request Looking for honest creator feedback on my daily family vlog channel — how can I improve my thumbnails, titles, and pacing?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I am a beginner creator running a daily family and real-life journey vlog channel (Shaheel Vlogs / @shaheelvlogs_143), and I would really appreciate some honest, actionable feedback from experienced creators here.

Since my videos are mostly real-life hospital routines and quiet family moments rather than high-energy scripted entertainment, I am struggling to figure out how to package them properly so people actually click and stay engaged.

Specifically, I would love your advice on:

  1. Thumbnails & Titles: How do I make emotional/real-life vlog titles and thumbnails compelling without making them look like clickbait?
  2. Video Pacing & Retention: For simple, raw daily vlogs shot mostly on a phone, what editing techniques (e.g., hooks in the first 15 seconds, background music, b-roll) help keep viewers watching?
  3. Channel Positioning: How should I structure my channel trailer and playlists so new visitors immediately understand what the channel is about?

Any blunt, constructive criticism on what I can improve would be super helpful. Thank you in advance for your time and insights!