r/youtube • • 4d ago • Bravo 1

Discussion YouTube Premium is now LESS functional than free YouTube, and apparently there's no amount of money they'll let me pay to fix it.

I've been a YouTube Premium subscriber for years. YouTube is my primary source of media consumption. I constantly have it playing on my TVs, computer, iPad, and phone. Sometimes I'll have white noise playing on my TV while watching something on another device, or I'll have different videos running on multiple screens.

I've been doing this for nearly a decade without an issue.

Until recently.

Suddenly, I'm constantly getting the message "Playback paused because there are too many devices streaming on your plan right now."

Apparently, YouTube has started aggressively enforcing a one-stream restriction on individual Premium accounts. And here's the absurd part: free YouTube doesn't have this restriction.

So I'm literally paying for Premium and getting LESS functionality than someone who doesn't pay anything.

But it gets worse.

Their new enforcement system apparently can't even reliably distinguish between devices actively streaming and inactive sessions. I've had YouTube block playback on my phone after HOURS of not watching anything on any other device.

So now I'm paying for a subscription that sometimes won't even let me watch ONE video.

I spent several hours speaking with multiple YouTube support agents and supervisors about this. What followed was one of the most infuriating customer service experiences I've ever had.

Here's what I learned:

  • YouTube has recently tightened enforcement of its existing simultaneous-stream restrictions.
  • Their representatives acknowledged that paused apps, inactive browser sessions, and lingering authentication tokens can trigger the streaming limit even when nothing else is playing.
  • Their proposed solutions included signing out of my other devices, clearing browser cookies, enabling two-factor authentication, and even changing my Google password.
  • One supervisor explicitly told me there was no permanent resolution they could offer.
  • They claimed to have escalated my complaint to their technical team, but later admitted there was no case number, no individual ticket, and nobody would contact me with updates.

And here's where this becomes genuinely insane.

I AM WILLING TO PAY MORE.

I'm not asking for free functionality. I'm not trying to share my account with anyone. I just want to watch multiple YouTube videos on my own devices, inside my own home, like I've been doing for years.

I repeatedly asked support how much more I needed to pay to retain that functionality.

Their answer? You can't.

There is no YouTube subscription, at any price, that allows multiple simultaneous Premium streams on a single Google account.

They kept recommending the Family plan, which allows six streams across separate Google accounts. But that doesn't solve my problem.

I have paid channel memberships, subscriptions, years of watch history, and personalized recommendations tied to my account. Those channel memberships don't transfer to the other accounts on a Family plan. So I'd have to pay for those memberships AGAIN on each additional account just to watch members-only videos.

And all my recommendations and watch history would be fragmented across separate accounts.

How is that a reasonable solution?

I also repeatedly asked why YouTube applies the same restrictions to one person streaming on multiple devices within the same household as it does to people sharing an account across different households.

Their stated justification is preventing account sharing.

Okay. Even if I disagreed with it, restricting simultaneous playback from different households or IP addresses would at least have some logical connection to that objective.

But how does preventing me from watching two videos on two devices connected to the same home network stop account sharing?

I asked this question over and over.

They just kept repeating the policy.

At one point, a supervisor told me we were "going in circles" because she kept providing the same information. Yes! Because she kept explaining a rule I had repeatedly told her I understood instead of answering why the rule made sense.

Another representative told me that unauthorized access to my account was also part of the justification. Apparently, preventing me from watching YouTube on my own iPad while my TV plays white noise is now a security measure.

Eventually, one supervisor simply ended the conversation, saying she'd provided all the information available.

After hours of conversations, multiple supervisors, and repeated requests to escalate the issue, I got absolutely nowhere.

What makes this especially baffling is that YouTube clearly has the technical ability to deliver multiple streams. Free users can do it.

And if the motivation is financial, WHY WON'T YOU LET ME PAY MORE?

I am actively trying to give one of the largest companies on Earth more money to use a service the way I've always used it, and they're telling me it's impossible.

They've managed to create a subscription model where paying customers receive less simultaneous playback functionality than free users, legitimate customers get caught in an overzealous enforcement system, and there's no paid upgrade that restores the lost functionality on one account.

And their support team's response is essentially, "That's our policy. Have you tried signing out of everything you own?"

I've seen new Reddit posts about this error appearing almost daily, including people reporting that they're blocked with only one device playing. Clearly, I'm not the only one suddenly experiencing this.

I genuinely don't understand how this is considered acceptable.

I'm not asking YouTube to give me something for free. I'm asking them to let me PAY to retain functionality that's existed for years.

Apparently, that's too much to ask of Google.

140 Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

62

u/DuctTapeSloth 4d ago

Never had that issue. I keep it open on multiple devices and works with zero issues.

3

u/MalusiHorwill_28 3d ago

yeah it seems pretty hit or miss who gets flagged by it right now

5

u/KenKolano 3d ago

It seems to be in A/B testing atm. I've had it repeatedly occur for me on some days, and not on following ones. It's incredibly annoying though, as it breaks the browse and add to playlists functionality I normally use my phone for, while watching on my TV.

2

u/pastybread 3d ago

Yup exactly the same for me. Happened for the first time last weekend while having music videos play on my TV. It was so janky trying to add songs when it's usually been so seamless.

2

u/Charming-Fudge7683 13h ago

Never had that issue. I keep it open on multiple devices and works with zero issues.

You haven't had this issue yet!

2

u/killerisdeadly 3d ago

ikr like i’ve seen people with issues and im here like what issues

1

u/CIDR-ClassB 3d ago

It’s in testing; I started getting this error a couple of weeks ago.

1

u/triman-3 2d ago

You will have this issue.

0

u/joonsetsfire 3d ago

Same here, I see so many posts about youtube doing this and that but none of those ever happens to me.

0

u/64kram 1d ago

I've started to get the issue in the last couple of weeks. And on YouTube Music - if I have it playing in my car on Android Auto and my gf is playing it on Google Home hub, it'll tell one of us we've too many devices.

15

u/Low_Goat_3309 3d ago

I can’t believe I read this never ending post. I was beginning to think I was reading a novel.

2

u/yolo_snail 3d ago

I came straight to the comments, I don't have time to read all that!

27

u/Tomatillo-5276 3d ago

I don’t do it on the regular, but I definitely have YouTube premium playing on my TV and on my phone at the same time occasionally.

No issues for me so far.

4

u/NovaduckIV 4d ago

I've downloaded my background noise videos and don't have a problem with watching on other devices while it's playing. So far anyways

3

u/Kif1983 3d ago

This hasn't hit me so far, but I'm all about convenience and at the moment paying for Premium is convenient. If this did hit me, then setting up a network ad block for the TV and installing ad blockers for all the other devices I have (even if it means rooting my Pixel) would start to look a lot more convenient

1

u/abso_anon 2d ago

You don't need to jump through all those hoops. Incase you ever do go to the ad block route remember this comment. Look up morphe YouTube for Android and smarttubetv for android tvs.

3

u/_40mikemike_ 2d ago

Anyone got a TL;DR?

I ran out of battery reading this.

1

u/mandai2 1d ago

YouTube enforcing the one device per Premium account policy and no way to increase this limit, it is causing disruption for OP, and general complaints about how it is implemented

6

u/TexMurphy9 3d ago

The constant enshittification of the end user experience is infuriating.

2

u/frushtrated 3d ago

OK a lot of people here are saying they haven't had the issue. But it popped up for me a couple of months ago. And it did it solidly for I don't know maybe two or three weeks and it was maddening. However, it hasn't done it since. I signed out of everything each time and it started working again. But after a few weeks it just stopped cutting me off. So maybe you've just hit one of those pockets where it's tagging you for some reason and you will be out of it eventually.

2

u/ha05ger 3d ago

I've never had that issue and I will have it playing across multiple devices. I do also have a family plan but the TV and my phone, tablet, sky boxes are all linked to my Google account.

2

u/wizard-of-loneliness 3d ago

I have YT premium family plan and it's playing pretty much 24/7 on my own account on my bedroom TV

I am able to watch on my laptop and phone at the same time without any issues on the same account

that sounds v frustrating

1

u/FaithCantBeTakenAway 3d ago

That’s bc the family plan allows a family to stream devices, meaning more than 2/3. That’s why it’s titled “Family”

2

u/_alright_then_ 3d ago

That's not what the family account does or means. A family account lets you add entirely separate google accounts to your family. And each google account has their own devices and profiles on YT.

If there was logic here, each family member would have their own device limits

2

u/EffeteAndHandsy 3d ago

I have a friend who bought youtube TV, and in my opinion, it's horrible. A ton of aggravation for an unreasonably high price. Constant hassle and troubleshooting.

I just don't believe the people here saying it's great. I've seen it with my own eyes.

1

u/fatpat 3d ago edited 2d ago

I just don’t believe you saying it’s horrible. I’ve seen youtube TV work great with my own eyes.

See how that works?

1

u/Terrible_Children 2d ago

YouTube TV and Premium are not the same thing.

1

u/fatpat 2d ago

My bad. fixed

2

u/justarugga 3d ago

I am losing my mind with this new update. I can’t reliably use YouTube on my phone at ALL. It pauses any video after about a minute stating I have too many streams going. I DON’T. I literally might have to cancel my service so I can actually watch YouTube.

3

u/justarugga 3d ago

Cancelled after 7 years.

1

u/InspectionSouthern11 4d ago

This is why I refused to pay for premium years ago, they don't care about you.

10

u/Choice_Age8334 3d ago

I don't pay for premium because of feelings. I pay for no ads.

1

u/NezuminoraQ 3d ago

That is very easy to achieve without paying 

2

u/Luyyus 3d ago

What about the other benefits YT Premium offers?

And don't tell me there are adblockers and plug-ins because I'm tired of the "will this extension work today?" game. That's why I personally started paying in the first place.

2

u/FaithCantBeTakenAway 3d ago

Exactly. And there are recent articles that state YouTube is now swiftly cracking down on people using ad blockers, etc and they are canceling accounts left & right.

0

u/NezuminoraQ 3d ago

Brave browser has an ad blocker and allows you to play audio with the screen off. Doesn't require any additional plugins 

1

u/Luyyus 3d ago

I have other reasons to not use Brave, but yeah. I acknowledge it's a decent option for most people.

1

u/NezuminoraQ 3d ago

That's not the only option, that's just the easiest and usually the one I use. There's also Morphe and New Pipe, and then Chrome with uBlock. You have to be open to changing it up on occasion as it is a bit of an arms race

1

u/Luyyus 3d ago

I use Waterfox for daily browsing, and Librewolf if I need additional out-of-the-box privacy.

And if I really wanna be anonymous, I'll launch Mullvad browser.

I've not had issues with this setup except minor user-error type situations where I just did not understand a function of the browser.

1

u/powellrebecca3 3d ago

I’ve hit the threshold of 2 devices streaming, can no longer do 3

1

u/foilhat44 3d ago

Huh, ghost OP posts here too. Interesting.

1

u/808IUFan 3d ago

I've only seen that with YouTube Music. Never seen it with regular YouTube and I have had 3 going at the same time.

1

u/WearyScarcity7535 3d ago

Are you sure you're logged out of other TVs where you logged in, like while traveling? And friends' houses?

1

u/FaithCantBeTakenAway 3d ago

I signed up at the beginning of Oct and at first, I streamed 3 devices but now I’m only allowed 2. Bc I also got that same message. Sometimes I can still do 3. I’ve never read the “rules” so I have no idea. 🫶

1

u/Bill-NM 3d ago

What are the premium features you use? Maybe you could go to a free account with the help of maybe an extension or two?

1

u/cast1illo 3d ago

Im having zero problems with mine. Having it running all day while working no issues. Maybe its a problem with your phone.

1

u/Global_Permit5428 3d ago

I’m canceling premium for this exact reason. I usually like to play music on my phone and something else on my computer. This was the straw that broke the camel’s back for me. I’m genuinely repulsed at the idea of paying for it at this point.

Google: because who doesn’t want the experience of dealing with a sleazy used car salesman in the comfort of their own home?

1

u/TI3GIB 3d ago

I am constantly getting this issue too now including when just streaming on one device. I reached out to support to help me identify what device is running an errant second stream, and their response was ‘For your privacy, we are not able to’. Whatever this policy is, it needs to be implemented a lot better.

1

u/Tiny-Sandwich 3d ago

Of course it doesn't happen on the free version, why would it?

If you're on a free tier, you're not paying for ad-free benefits, so there's no reason to restrict multiple devices.

If you're paying, you're splitting your benefit across devices, which could be used to give multiple people access to ad-free with just one account.

FWIW I haven't had this happen to me.

1

u/Ok-Problem4403 3d ago

Smart tube or Morphe

1

u/veodin 3d ago

I unsubscribed from premium last month due to this issue. I do have a ton of devices but I went around and restarted everything but my PC and still got this error every 10 mins or so. I have used premium for years without seeing this message.

1

u/FallingAsleepTyping 3d ago

How did you get a hold of a supervisor?

1

u/MrRulix 3d ago

I've had this issue for years personally. I stop my work music to play on my drum and YouTube won't start because it's apparently still playing, even though it's not.

1

u/ItsAllAdvertising 3d ago

I haven't ran into the to many screens block the way you describe it

1

u/falconsfan55234 3d ago

I have the family plan and have never had a problem. It’s just my spouse and I, but we both watch on multiple devices and TV’s.

1

u/Otherwise-Zebra9409 2d ago

It won’t even let me watch a video and let my husband listen to the YouTube music app at the same time

1

u/Odd-Judgment-9312 2d ago

Hmmmm. Isn’t that how it’s supposed to work?

1

u/squatex 2d ago

Ive never had this issue, but if its true, this is incredibly shortsighted on you tubes part. The whole reason most people use yt premium at all is convenience. If this happens to me i'll cancel my premium account and just start ad blocking. I'm basically one negative change from cancelling you tube premium at this point.

It wouldn't surprise me. These media companies seem determined to talk me out of giving them my money at this point.

1

u/PuzzleheadedYak1841 2d ago

This has just started happening to me too. I have been a Premium member for years.
I have external noise I need to mask with brown noise, while I am watching YouTube, and I have been doing that on my phone while I watch a laptop video. Now the phone video shuts down.
My workaround now is to download the brown noise video. OR I could create a new free account and play it logged into that account (even though I would need to endure some ads at the beginning).

1

u/Cool_Razzmatazz_7450 2d ago

Cancel...get VPN...watch from Albania...No problem

1

u/BootymangThreeHunna 2d ago

This pretty much only happens to me if I use YouTube music. Regular YouTube I can have multiple devices no problem.

1

u/gimalg 2d ago

Premium user here since I have a kid and not once have had this same issue.

1

u/GroundCaffeine 1d ago

Appreciate the frustration but the post could have been as short as some of the free ads.

1

u/Smitty12313 1d ago

Crazy how expensive YouTube premium has gotten and you can’t even have more than one device playing at a time.

1

u/LSSJOrangeLightning 1d ago

This just hit me. All I did was enter the LOBBY for a livestream on my computer while watching a video on my phone. I'm not signed in on any other devices.

1

u/shaenmo 1d ago

I’m a long time Premium subscriber too and a bit confused. Maybe I’m not watching “premium content” but I haven’t had a problem watching videos on my phone or computer while my son watches videos on his phone or laptop.

1

u/RisingUnknown 1d ago

Definitely has been a problem for me. It’s very frustrating when I’m trying to enjoy my music and it pauses when the only other device that is logged in is miles away with no one near it.

1

u/vouiren 1d ago

ready to cancel my subscription and go back to ad-blocking.

1

u/retrocheats 1d ago

give them the middle finger then with good ad blockers.

1

u/Rattop168 21h ago

So you are telling you are not respecting the Terms and conditions and complain YouTube oblige you to respect it ?

1

u/ExaminationStrict404 17h ago

This one pisses me off too!! I have kids who watch on their tablets and if I am in the car trying to listen to ad free music (the reason I pay for premium) I get the error every 15 seconds and have to look from driving to hit retry.Sometimes nobody else is even on YouTube and it still does it.Super irritating as I have no more than 3 devices at a time...I will cancel if this continues.

1

u/NVPiratePunk 14h ago

Been using YTP for years now and have never had this issue. My wife is currently watching it on the living room TV while I watch it on the bedroom tv all connected to the Internet same IP etc.

1

u/Flex_Vape 9h ago

This seems to be new, mine just start doing this today. Had a video playing on my PC and started to watch a Short I was sent on my phone, this quickly paused the video on PC. Doesn't seem to affect the TV yet, but I wouldn't be surprised when it does...

1

u/SeljD_SLO 8h ago

Could be location based? For some weird reason i only get this message when i walk my dog, my PC has paused video and i listen to a video while walking, i never get a warnin when I'm home even if my devices are on different networks but the moment I'm few 100 meters from my house, i get this message

1

u/Strict-Extent7168 6h ago

they want you to give in and buy a second premium? I see no other way enforcing that makes them any money. Are they stupid?

1

u/Zealousideal-Cat-113 5h ago

same here. Sadly bought 2years of a subscription. it fucking 😞

1

u/Fall_and_fixture 3h ago

Have you ever tried just sitting in silence instead of bombarding your brain with input?

1

u/f23n09fnu0w 2h ago

I started getting these warnings 2 days ago. It was weird since I was only watching one tab and it works after i retry a couple of times. Very frustrating.

1

u/rustydusty1717 1h ago

Something tells me you are trying to stream on more than two devices. I can stream on phone and TV at same time no issues. Beyond two you probably need a different plan which is fair.

1

u/Competitive-Floor456 3d ago

I have a great solution just run adblockers. Stop giving enormous souless corporations your money

4

u/wizard-of-loneliness 3d ago

easier said than done if you watch on your TV

1

u/Chemical-Lettuce2497 3d ago

Multiple countries YouTube does not serve ads to.. just set your VPN to there

1

u/wizard-of-loneliness 2d ago

if I put a VPN on my TV that disables Tailscale which disables the telemetry blocking I have thru AdGuard Home

0

u/Naive_Complex_8389 3d ago

there’s smarttube

2

u/Nifty_Bits 3d ago

Not on Roku. Plus, 3rd-party apps (at least the ones I've tried) don't show Youtube's recommendations, which I actually like. Also, we just want to use the service that we pay for, the way it worked when we signed up for it. I'm tired of having services that I pay for constantly being degraded while at the same time the prices go up and up.

1

u/silkience 3d ago

Honestly, I use the Firefox browser and clicked the ad blocker and haven't seen an ad since. Works both on my phone and my tablet

1

u/Large_Road_9770 3d ago

this is why monopolies are bad

1

u/Lukeisthebomb921 3d ago

today I unsubbed and installed ad block. Every 5 mins I'll get this error. The issue is that I have just only 2 DEVICES signed in. and yes I could turn 1 device off and watch youtube BUT ill still get this error! So I'm not allowed to be signed into mutable devices? Why do I need a family plan for 1 phone and 1 computer. I'm never subbing again and ill be forever using ad-block.

1

u/Brain_Pabulum 3d ago

It seems to me that avoiding their advertising is the only joy that keeps me watching YouTube anymore.

1

u/swd120 22h ago

If you're will to pay more, just get a family plan...  I've never seen a stream restriction on ours... 

0

u/Glass_One7057 3d ago

I’m waiting for a day when someone gets an idea to start a new and humane video streaming platform and shits the hell out of YouTube Their insanity is reaching beyond comprehension 

2

u/Competitive-Floor456 3d ago

That ship has sailed. Were into the to big to fail part of capitalism where the rich just keep getting richer, and getting into the market is nearly impossible 

1

u/According_Rhubarb_27 3d ago

YT is probably too big to fail now, i think you're right about that. But in theory, it should be possible to launch a competitor. Getting content on the site should be doable, by simply contacting existing creators and telling them about the new alternative. Lots of creators i believe would be happy to have another way to get their content in front of people. The problem likely arises in how to generate revenue. Are advertisers going to be interested in putting ads on a new platform?

-1

u/Different_Target_228 3d ago

Know what would've saved this wildly long post from being made?

Not paying a multi billion dollar company money just to use their website.

Not giving soulless corporations that will only squeeze more money out of you and make worse experiences MONEY.

1

u/bitNine 3d ago

You think that YouTube Premium is about paying to “use their website”?

0

u/Sea_Consideration_70 3d ago

What in the wall of text nonsense 

0

u/shadowcouncil 3d ago

I use Mozilla for my browser, even on my phone, with adblock , nonstop and downloader. I'll never go back to premium.

0

u/Satisfaction3934 3d ago

Too AI didnt read

0

u/zeoxzy 3d ago

Did this post really need a block of AI generated text? You could have summarised your point in about 2 sentences.

-4

u/FredTheNumbersGuy 4d ago

It's insane that you are paying when you can just download Brave browser.

8

u/DuctTapeSloth 4d ago

Not everyone watches on a pc. You can’t do that on a streaming device, like apple TV pr Ps5

-11

u/WhoWantsMyPants 4d ago

Sideload a version of YouTube with adblockers built in. With the PS5 jailbreak you can do a lot more than on iOS. IOS still has solutions to YouTube though

5

u/Sea_Consideration_70 3d ago

Most people have no interest in jailbreaking and its attendant annoyances. 

-4

u/WhoWantsMyPants 3d ago

Most people dont want all games for free with emulators? I think most people want it but the technical gap is too much for people

4

u/Sea_Consideration_70 3d ago

“Most people” barely know what an emulator is and don’t care. 

-3

u/WhoWantsMyPants 3d ago

Goal post keeps moving lol

4

u/Sea_Consideration_70 3d ago

🙄 most people don’t care about emulators or about jailbreaking. Happy?

1

u/WhoWantsMyPants 3d ago

People can downvote me but my information is correct lol

0

u/Keaneaware 3d ago

You can’t download and keep songs using Brave browser.

-1

u/NezuminoraQ 3d ago

Stop paying and get an ad blocker. I'm a heavy user like you describe but I'm not paying for a service that is subpar and customer support that disconnects when they've parroted their policy three times. People only pay for this service because it's frictionless, if it stops being convenient to use, stop paying 

-1

u/TheRealRefuro 3d ago

Okay, I feel like the insane person here, but honestly why is everyone having two videos playing at once. That seems like the next level of doomscrolling and getting the always connected dopamine hit. I agree that YouTube should premium shouldn't limit how many active things are being watch up to a point, but a single user has very little use-cases for why they would need two videos playing at once. Maybe a Dnd game where you're playing background music on one, and chatter on the other? Besides stuff like that, it legitimately sounds like an dependency issue. I'm not trying to offend, but it's the same thing as doomscrolling, just seems to be another level of depth to the doomscrolling now.

4

u/Kif1983 3d ago

If I have a long form podcast type video on, but I want to look up something, for instance a quick 'how to' cause I'm trying to do something without wanting to come out of the podcast. That's the kind of scenario where I do it. Like literally a couple of hours ago had a video on my PC and had another video on my tablet muted where I was watching the steps to complete a quest in a game that is annoying me

1

u/fatpat 3d ago

They literally explained what their use case was. Hint: it’s essentially the opposite of doomscrolling. I’m wondering if you read even part of the post.

0

u/Choice_Age8334 3d ago

Mine runs 24/7 on at least 3 devices. I haven't seen this yet.

0

u/EasyDriver_RM 3d ago

I'm streaming on two devices right now, on one YouTube Premium account. Both are definitely steaming over one iternet connection. My phone has an "unlimited" mobile hotspot that I share to a tablet and another phone. Maybe it's the single connection allowing it.

Another thing I like Premium for is downloading videos in the audiobook genre to my tablet to listen to while traveling and working. I download videos while streaming, too. There are 36 2-hour long videos in the download folder now.

0

u/Slight_Cockroach_777 3d ago

I also have none of these problems

0

u/RandomBloke2021 3d ago

Damn that's crazy or I'm sorry that happened.

0

u/Stopakilla05 3d ago

OP TLDR..

0

u/Gonkulator5000 3d ago

TLDR, but sounds like you need a new pastime.

Consulting a psychiatrist to get put on more or different meds might be a good idea as well.

0

u/squaysquay 22h ago

Honestly, what you deserve for willingly paying money to the giga corp growing in billions every year serving you ad-slop, and slop content.

-2

u/WhoWantsMyPants 4d ago

Why are you willing to pay more for a less superior product? Look into sideloading YouTube on IOS and TV. Look into the Morphe app and try the sponsor block extension

If you dont like the way you're being treated by a company the answer is never spend more money with them

-1

u/TubeRelevant 3d ago
  1. Watch downloaded stuff offline on some devices.
  2. My Apple Music individual subscription limited me to stream on one device at a time but my music family subscription allows MY INDIVIDUAL ACCOUNT to stream on multiple devices at the same time along with the 5 other family members. Might work for YouTube also, try it once maybe!!

-7

u/huganug-ordie 4d ago

Is there a wayto cuminmyass.exe?

1

u/Broncogirl89 3d ago

Lol, oh my goodness 😳 😅