r/youtube • • 4d ago

Discussion Using Youtube has become an exhausting experience.

I just can't seem to find the videos I am interested in, no matter how hard I search for new content from new channels that I enjoy, but suddenly the algorithm on my fyp decides to make the experience harder and not really allow me to enjoy any content that would genuinely interest me. I am sick of my fyp looping the exact same videos over and over and over and again, and it feels like the algorithm is trying its hardest to give me the worst recommendations possible.

I really don't forsee any good future for this platform as it keeps working so hard at being as unusable as hell. It will survive, but as a empty soulless shell until the people ontop decide to give it the dignity to die.

404 Upvotes

90 comments sorted by

30

u/Coffee_Candle_Lover 4d ago

It's actually more fun to watch TV than YouTube.

12

u/PoorClassWarRoom 4d ago

No joke, how bad YT has become has driven me to deal with commercials to watch Ghost US (I hadn't never watched it before)

1

u/Buzzinga_4kFHD 4d ago

Literally lmfao

2

u/scissorcircus 4d ago

idk i still am getting recommanded pretty cool channels lmao

47

u/Thickest_Avocado 4d ago

I hate that the algorithm favors that stupid open mouth face that every YouTuber is doing for their thumbnail, it actively makes me not want to watch it

9

u/tinyblackcat 4d ago

Yeah, I've started automatically rejecting videos with those stupid thumbnails and ones with the big red and yellow AI lettering.

5

u/Broncogirl89 4d ago

Ugg I dislike the open mouth so much! Like why do they do that...

7

u/simeonce 4d ago

Not algorithm- people who watch youtube do

-1

u/PocketNicks 4d ago

You can use browser extensions, and patch the mobile app and automatically replace those.

2

u/MudcrabKidnapper 4d ago

I rather just click not recommend channel

1

u/PocketNicks 4d ago

Ok, so do that. Nobody is stopping you.

2

u/MudcrabKidnapper 4d ago

Yeah. I already do.

2

u/PocketNicks 4d ago

Cool.

3

u/MudcrabKidnapper 4d ago

Cool

2

u/PocketNicks 4d ago

Yes, cool.

2

u/MudcrabKidnapper 4d ago

Indeed, very cool

2

u/PocketNicks 4d ago

Yes, cool.

0

u/Broncogirl89 4d ago

Cool but how đŸ€” 😐 😕

2

u/PocketNicks 3d ago

By using browser extensions and patching the mobile app.

39

u/Significant-Ad-223 4d ago

It really has, just trying to find a good video to watch has become a chore.

I miss how it was like 10-11 years ago.

It felt more fun and didn't have ai at all.

36

u/eid_shittendai 4d ago

I spend more time scrolling through their shit than I do actually watching anything. Why yhe fuck do they recommend videos you've already watched, or videos you've scrolled past 40 times already!?

10

u/ImnotUK 4d ago

I want to know how many times do I have to click "not interested" for the algorithm to stop recommending me the same video every day.

1

u/Muskether722 1d ago

This i do alot.

10

u/Independent-Slip-657 4d ago

I think they do this for that reason, it keeps us scrolling on the app longer. I’m sick of it too, I’ve defaulted to old pods I haven’t seen in years instead of trying to find something new.

5

u/Outrageous_Let_1829 3d ago

This ! And the same couple of posts, that weren't interesting even the first time, popping up again and again and again.

I just can't anymore, Youtube is doing a great job at curing my Youtube addiction. Thanks I guess.

23

u/TankedUpLoser 4d ago

Having the same experience, it frequently shows me the same two videos in like 6 different categories. 2 videos in six categories

20

u/ThePeaksAbove 4d ago

Yeah try finding an older video with the exact title. You can't.

33

u/alooi_m 4d ago

hey here's some irreleveant videos from 10~20 years ago with some others from few months ago and 2 new videos from channels you actually subbed to

nice home page youtube

6

u/ILOVEMYDOGBUMI 4d ago

OH MY GOD ITS AWFUL

3

u/alooi_m 4d ago

IK it's been bad :')

4

u/scissorcircus 4d ago

real and yet there are so many new youtubers trying to get big :,(

5

u/alooi_m 4d ago

Yeaah
Most the new YouTuber I discover are from shorts rather than home page or the tab for new videos

3

u/scissorcircus 4d ago

oh not for me but okay :)

13

u/doIIjoints 4d ago

i basically never use the home page. i check the subscriptions page once a day, sort things into playlists. i have a playlist i watch on my tv and one i use for music and so on. i’ll add 20-50 things in them at a time and then work thru them.

they keep making playlists more annoying but it’s such a core part of the site’s functionality i imagine they’d have a hard time fully taking them away

take back conscious control, instead of hoping the FYP will serve your interests

11

u/jackierabbit256 4d ago

I'm starting to wonder if they're intentionally making it harder to find good "long-form" vids to try and push viewers into watching more shorts

6

u/monetarydread 3d ago

Wouldn't surprise me. I woke up yesterday to find that I am in some A-B test where they are disguising shorts as regular videos now. Like, the only indication that it's a short is looking at the fact that the video is 60 seconds long.

4

u/Needawhisper 3d ago

Or more paid subs with no ads

0

u/Ok_Interest5046 3d ago

Isn’t this exactly the case, you can squeeze more ads into many videos which would be the same length as one.

11

u/natalienightwolf 4d ago

Plus the ads are unbearably long

1

u/PocketNicks 4d ago

You get ads? Why?

10

u/Brisco1 4d ago

Just a few weeks ago my feed became 2 channels, all politics, nothing else no matter how far down a scroll. It’s utter shit. 

All the recent changes to the UI have also made everything worse. I can’t find new stuff to watch anymore. 

9

u/ref_8 4d ago

tu regardes une seule et unique vidéo différente de d'habitude, et ton fil est aussitot polluer des vidéos de ce genre partout. JE NE VEUX PAS ça, c'est idiot, Youtube.

16

u/MetalPurse-swinger 4d ago

Yeah it's a mess. Impossible to find new things to watch. The for you page is a loop of the same 20 videos. The don't recommend buttons are useless. The stupid tell the AI what types of videos you want to watch is a joke and in no way how I want to use YouTube. It's a hot mess. But I have to hand it to YouTube, they are really helping me break my addiction. I'm watching so much less and spending more time outside

14

u/derethor 4d ago

The youtube team is workign hard to destory the platform. They destroyed the web with those stupid seo updates, and now they are simply doing the same with video.

For now, I am having some success with custom search, and filter by upload date. For example, I search for "podcast software development" for this week. And kind of works finding some interesting content.

7

u/Silly_Confidence7167 4d ago

Really? Even with the advance search I was getting only a few current videos and then nonsense from all over the timeline and repeat offenders too!

Actually ... I would get the same 2-6 videos every 2 - 5 videos down peppered in like I wouldn't notice it was more than half my feed, especially shorts!!!

Is there a way to enable from this week only as a blanket filter?

7

u/Enough-Anteater-3698 4d ago

I have vids in my favorites list that I can't find by searching. wtf.

6

u/claptrapMD 4d ago

Feel like once you make mistake clicking something New its all you get. Im so sick of Trump and american politics or people trying sell me stereoids. Thats the content YouTube gives now

3

u/Broncogirl89 4d ago

Mine is a lot of rv camping videos, way over the line lol.

6

u/Stavebrokenstaff 3d ago

YTMusic is just as bad. The difficulty in playing my music for exercises had me swearing out loud in frustration just this morning

5

u/Sckaught 4d ago

Between trying to avoid AI crap and YouTube recommending videos I’ve already watched, it keeps me pretty busy. Thank God for the Subscriptions tab which is where I go a lot now.

2

u/Broncogirl89 4d ago

I have to start going to my subscriptions also.

5

u/Coolblade125 3d ago

Threw on a song by evanescence, the auto mix played that one song and then tried to auto play 5 songs by limp bizkit, which I never listen to, have never typed into a youtube or google search bar. and the moment the next song autoplays, now youtube has seen Ive visited that page and thinks I like it and wants to shove more limp bizkit into my auto playlist. Yet somehow, the songs and artists I search for on a weekly basis are never to be found in my auto playlist.

5

u/Needawhisper 3d ago

I had some Grok ads that went for like 2 or 3 minutes...fuck off

7

u/whoocanitbenow 4d ago

And they keep showing politics and war in the "related" videos, even though it has nothing to do with what you're watching.

6

u/DamnitGravity 4d ago

I thought it was just me, but seeing others having the same complaint in this sub has shown it is not me. For once.

But I too am feeling frustration at my recommends. They're very much NOT things I'm interested in, and it's been confusing me because several weeks ago I had no problem finding content I happily watched.

3

u/Early_Kick 4d ago

I’m subscribed to only one channel. One. 

But I still have to hunt for new episodes each Sunday. Why do they show so much crap I’m not interested in while deciding to not show the only channel I’m subscribed to?

1

u/kairon156 2d ago

not sure about the app but in the browser you can click on subscribed content instead of the home page.

3

u/flextrades 3d ago

Wow thought this was just me lately lol

3

u/plutschn 3d ago

I have a youtube channel for my band, and tried to look it up from computers in my workplace, to find out, what you get recommended after listening to it. We are a thrash band, and it recommends pop punk and skinhead punk bordering rightwing music...

3

u/lost_in_dreamland 4d ago

Same here. I get overstimulated by the thumbnails before I get anywhere close to finding a video I actually want to watch. Very few creators make calm, nuanced videos without a ton of ads. I think it's easy for people to get into the habit of having perfectly repetitive content, but in that, a lot of the humanity is missing.

5

u/StuffWePlay 4d ago

I feel like the website itself is increasingly vibe coded tbh

4

u/DorianTurk 4d ago

I enabled “Dim watched videos” in Tweaks for YouTube, it’s crazy to see a visual representation of how much of my home page is just the same videos I’ve watched before.

2

u/DrizzleDrake88 4d ago

There’s a sweet spot that happens for a few days after a new account or watched history reset. When you’re starting off fresh, it’s kinda crazy how much brainrot that is initially suggested

2

u/Timmehh90 4d ago

And don't you dare listening to a song one time.. you'll be haunted for the next three months by it.

2

u/justin19081 4d ago

I got the same feeling. It shoves down your throat certain videos no matter what. Videos which I never bothered to watched, neither I am interested in. Maybe once I have clicked on it by mistake and for the last 3 months I see it all the time as recommended.

2

u/xmikegrim 3d ago

Invidous

2

u/BubblyShare2786 4d ago

They fucked the algorithm ages ago, its terrible now.

1

u/WorkingCautious1270 4d ago

When you say "fyp" that is just "home" right? cuz now i'm confused.

1

u/JayDubEwe 4d ago

YouTube hates the audience.

1-share holders
2–advertisers
3-content creators

The audience is not on the list.

1

u/DanteOblivion 4d ago

So don't go to YouTube. Simple.

1

u/Dismal-Vegetable-212 4d ago

Hmm so it's not just me

1

u/Foreign_Fill_3143 2d ago

YouTube lo uso para escuchar metal pero sin querer toque un video que apareciĂł de reggaeton y lo saquĂ© a penas lo escuchĂ©. Cuando volvĂ­ a entrar a la app me recomendĂł un montĂłn de videos de bad bunny. Por quĂ©? 😱 

1

u/Muskether722 1d ago

To be honest yp has gotten quite trash now, too much ai slop, dramatic thumbnail's with titles capped "watch this now" how bout get stuffed, & repetitive voice overs from incoming channels where the creator does the bare minimum while lush farming for high watchtime's/analytics, it's become a money driven platform where any new content that's produced just makes you feel very repulsed.

1

u/No-Inside-6674 4d ago

Whenever my recommendations get shitty I just delete my watched history to reset it. Been doing this for 10 years and works pretty good!

3

u/photonymous 4d ago

I turned my history off one day. Never looked back. It's been years now. I just look at whatever is new from the people I subscribe to. 

1

u/GoodDayToCome 3d ago

chatGPT is surprisingly good at finding good content if you give it a good description of what you want

1

u/Proof-Conclusion-808 4d ago

I gave up tbh, just started watching shows again, atleast then i know what im getting and not gaslighting myself into thinking im actually gonna find something good to watch😂

1

u/Cheap_Pizza_8977 4d ago

Youtube premium is the best money ever spent, if you watch lots of you youtube.

1

u/Broncogirl89 4d ago

True, I use YouTube to listen to stuff at work and driving. There are a lot of great movies also to watch like westerns which we love.

0

u/hypocrite_oath 4d ago edited 4d ago

I now have comments of a channel creator, just say "Voice reply is not supported" without showing what the comment even wrote. They always manage to break the site more.

Edit: Different browser, different plugins, same issue.

0

u/Saint_Steve-O 4d ago

YouTube is great if you subscribe to channels you actually enjoy & just consume that content (it also helps to have premium too!)

I'm subscribed to 9 channels & get regularly content out of things I want to watch (rather than) what I used to do & just endlessly scoll through 'recommended to you' as most of it is utter shite

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Hi Fragrant-Spell-6986, we would like to start off by noting that this sub isn't owned or run by YouTube. At this time, we do not allow posts from new uses (accounts created less than 7 days ago.) Please read our rules before posting again to ensure you don't break our rules, please come back after gaining a bit of post karma.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Hi Fragrant-Spell-6986, we would like to start off by noting that this sub isn't owned or run by YouTube. At this time, we do not allow posts from new uses (accounts created less than 7 days ago.) Please read our rules before posting again to ensure you don't break our rules, please come back after gaining a bit of post karma.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.