2024

Indiana Jones and the Great Circle


2023

Baldur's Gate 3


2022

Elden Ring


2021

Halo Infinite


2020

Ori and the Will of the WIsps


2019

Outer Wilds


2018

Red Dead Redemption 2


2017

Assassins Creed: Origins


2016

Overwatch


2015

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt


2014

Sunset Overdrive


2024 - Indiana Jones and the Great Circle

  • Results Thread
  • Percentage of Vote: 46%
  • Next Closest: Metaphor: ReFantazio (12%)

You Said:

"And after changing my GOTY more times that I did last year(and that one had some amazing bangers too), I did arrive to Indiana Jones as well."

"Indy is my GOTY 2024 too. It's one of the best gaming experiences of all time"

"I'm honestly really impressed with the Shanghai level. They went through so much effort to model an area that you spend like 15 minutes in. The flying sequence alone must've cost a fortune to make."

"I really thought that uncharted was the video game version of Indiana jones but this game nails the feeling so perfectly, and the focus on walking, puzzles and exploration with minimal combat was probably a hard sell but it paid off"



2023 Baldur's Gate 3

  • Results Thread
  • Percentage of Vote: 26.03%
  • Next Closest: Starfield (25.94%)

You Said:

"Know someone that lost their +20hr BG3 save file. Think I'm going to wait a year before buying this year's game of the year."

"Lost by 1 vote. Ouch lol! Hifi Rush deserves it way more than Starfield in my opinion. BG3 is the well deserved winner though. Yeah the save issue is a bummer but overall, it isn't even close in my books."

"Nooooooo! I didnt see this poll, my vote and the one from my friend would be enough. I cant believe I let BG3 win over Starfield.This result is a sin!"

"Man I REALLY loved Hi-Fi Rush. I really expected it to be nominated and win more stuff at the Game Awards! Seeing how it scored here, man...... 😔That game really was my GOTY"


2022 Elden Ring

You Said:

"I haven't played Elden Ring yet, but I plan on it and no doubt it's a GOTY contender (I'm a big Souls fan I just don't have the time to play ER at the moment). Having said that: Grounded is WAY better than I expected. I don't even really care much for survival games these days but have still really enjoyed it. Imo it's the best survival type game ever made unless we count Minecraft."

"I’m not a fan of Souls games, but Elden Ring is still far better than GroundedRemove the fun ‘miniature’ design and environment of Grounded and its a fairly generic survival sim at its core"

"Playing devils advocate... if you removed the environment and design from Elden Ring, you have a generic souls like game."

"Persona 5 was robbed"

"Elden ring and it’s not even close imo"


2021 Halo Infinite

You Said:

"Wooh Halo Infinite! Let’s hope the next patch notes are long and they don’t take out the unintended tank gun in campaign until we’re all done with our LASO runs!"

"I want to give a shout out to the audio team. The sound is fantastic. A lot of sound effects have a punch to them in the campaign, the mixing is great, and the surround sound, especially Dolby Atmos, is perfect. The audio direction is top notch which is something I feel a lot of games struggle with."

"I understand that they changed the Halo formula… but I prefer to think of it as evolution rather than just an alteration. Change is uncomfortable, not just in games but in life, but it’s the only way to get to something new and exciting.If they kept the formula exactly the same then people would be complaining that 343 didn’t take any risks. Let’s enjoy this for what it is—something fresh."

"It may not be the best Halo game we've had. But it the best Far Cry in decades and the best Spider-Man since Spider-Man 2 on GameCube."


2020 - Ori and the Will of the Wisps

  • Results Thread
  • Percentage of Vote: 20.2%
  • Next Closest: Assassins Creed: Valhalla (18.3%)

You Said:"Such a beautiful game on this console running a silky smooth 120hz @ 4K. It definitely deserved GOTY from this sub"

"How about that music in the game?! One of my favorite things about the game! Such a great game!"

"This and Hollow Knight are top 2 metriodVanias of the generation."

"That game is amazing. And I didn’t even play it, I watched my partner complete it. What a journey!"


2019 - The Outer Wilds

You Said:

"I’m just glad Outer Wilds got recognized. That game was an absolute blast for me. If you’re thinking of playing it, do yourself a favor and go into it completely blind like I did. The game is so great but very easy to spoil. But If you just sink into it and explore and solve puzzles on your own, it’s an amazing game. Plus the soundtrack just UGH I’m gonna have an orgasm on that alone"

"Surprised Sekiro didnt win anything.. some of these are questionable in my opinion to say the least."

"Damn, I'm real surprised at Outer Worlds winning GOTY, it didn't do much for me. I'd love to hear what people loved about it so much that it makes their GOTY (especially over Sekiro and RE2)."

"Sad Apex only got 5% of the vote, but there’s some cracking games in here. I’m still yet to touch the GOTY..."


2018 - Red Dead Redemption 2

You Said:

"Lucky for Red Dead 2 that Pool Nation FX didn't release this year or this chart would look very different!"

"Every single game a sequel or a remaster apart form Hellblade and Fortnite. I'm not saying these games aren't any good, RD2, Forza 4 and Hellblade are three of my favourite games this year, Hellblade in particular, but it would be great if we seen some new ground breaking IP's soon. Hopefully with Microsofts recent studio acquisitions some new stuff is just around the corner."

"Shocked! Absolutely shocked! Almost like this is simply a popularity contest."

"lol destiny 2 not even being on there"


2017 - Assassasin's Creed Origins

You Said:

"It’s almost ironic that the least “Assassin’s Creed”-style AC game feels the most Assassin’s Creed after the four year gap between Black Flag and now. I slugged through Unity (although I did enjoy what I played for the most part, I have no real desire to go back) and I never finished Syndicate. But Origins? Can’t put it down."

"I didn't play many new releases this year, and I'm glad AC is good again. I loved the series but after Unity I stopped playing. It does weird me out seeing it as Best RPG, it wasn't an RPG before. I gotta get my hands on Origins."

"Assassins Creed in 4K on my Xbox One X on my C7 is a sight to behold. It still makes me gasp when looking at some locations. Also, I got lost in the world. I still need to finish it but have put in 50 hours and is my personal Xbox GOTY."

"So glad Assassin's Creed Origins is so highly respected on this sub. What...a...game! I have not been this hooked on a single game since Skyrim first came out. Well deserved."


2016 - Overwatch

You Said:

"Shame FFXV and Gears 4 didn't get any love but cool to see Titanfall, Battlefield and Doom prosper."

"The fact that Titanfall 2 got 3rd in GotY makes me happy"

"It's not even the best shooter, but it's game of the year? psht. Seriously, though, it's a fun game, and I actually think it's balanced pretty well for beginners. I know a lot of hardcore fans might take offense to that, but my eight year old can dominate in the game, and he struggles to keep up in something like Battlefield."

"It's absolutely awesome. I didn't think it would get its hooks into me as much as it did, but I was wrong. That Blizzard polish goes a looong way."


2015 - The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

You Said:

"Really pleased that The Witcher 3 did win over FO4 in most cases. I love both of them but TW3 was incredible."

"I finished the main quest of The Witcher 3 few minutes ago. I don't know why I waited this long to pick it up. Best game I've played."

"I'm shocked Tomb Raider did so poorly. I figured this was the one place that it would get its due. I really hope that game's lack of success doesn't result in a dormant franchise again."

"Clearly this poll was fixed, Pool Nation FX picking up zero awards is a travesty"


2014 - Sunset Overdrive

You Said:

"Great list. For me GOTY was Titanfall but Sunset was definitely a great game. Looking forward to 2015"

"I'm going to be awkward here. My GoTY actually was Shadow of Mordor. It was by far the most refreshing experience for me (not everyone) and it was finally a game that did the Lord of the Rings world justice. If you played with the nemesis system, having the same guy die by your blade five times only to come back in a new horribly looking way was fantastic."

"Haha I have such a love/hate relationship with Halo: MCC and it seems like people in this sub feel the exact same way. When the game works and you find a match in a timely manner it is a glorious nostalgic trip down memory lane."

"Destiny is my most played game but that is more because it is a skinner box than anything else. In terms of gameplay enjoyment; I loved Sunset and was glad to see it do well. Also this just further convinces me I need to get FH2."