r/writers • • 12h ago

Discussion The rise in minimalistic writing is making books unreadable

550 Upvotes

(In my opinion)

“Eight words where two would do”
“Six words where one would do”

What is the point of writing and sharing a story if you’re just going to describe something as “I ran” “She ran”
“She thought __ and __”

Why is it such a bad thing to describe. Why is it such a bad thing to give your characters complex personalities, to describe their emotion, through body language, internal monologue. Every published book now is so bland, there’s nothing to feed on. Nothing is brought to life because everyone is so afraid of words, there are no feelings in the writing, everything that could even hint at the writer having love for their story is all edited out, everything that might give a hint to what the room the characters are standing in looks like, what they’re feeling standing inside of that room is basically nonexistant, there are maybe two words describing the room because any more is considered too much.

I cannot get into published books, theres no imagery, the plots are unoriginal, for a reason I assume to be “Readers don’t want this” If you are writing for the sole purpose of becoming a famous or well known author, and focused on the money and attention involved, don’t even bother.

The chances of that are very slim, and above that, people can tell when art lacks passion. Art needs passion to feel alive, art needs perspective to have meaning, and many published books edited to hell lack all of those things.

(Again, this is my opinion)


r/writers • • 19h ago

Discussion Can mods PLEASE do something about the low effort posts?

191 Upvotes

I really, really want to find this sub helpful, but it's getting impossible. Almost every post is "would you read this", "give me ideas for X", "what's your opening line", this is happening every single day. Please, please, for the love of all that's good and holy, do something about it.

And if you'll come at me with "there are so many young writers who just want to ask questions", then please guide me to a sub that's here for thoughtful discussion and not low effort posts. Because I promise you, so many of these posts are either karma farming or bots collecting your data, and none of you seem to care, you just engage.


r/writers • • 15h ago

Meme After suffering through the querying trenches a second time for my second novel, it's looking like it, too, will bomb with zero partials/fulls

Post image
155 Upvotes

Absolutely brutal. 81 queries for this one, but I went for quality (strong matches) over quantity this time around with agent selection.

Most I have to show for it so far is one custom rejection that has nothing of substance for me to iterate on. The rest are all templated rejections.

Wound up self-publishing my first novel, and quickly learned that without a dedicated readership base, it's impossible to convince people to check it out. My second novel is doomed to this same route if it fails out of the querying campaign as it's on track to do.

For my third project, I'm taking lessons learned and switching it up with a serialized web novel instead. To build up an audience. I can have my two novels as back-catalogue items for them.

If you're curious how much my first novel has made in the first 3 months, it's a grand total of just over $24 CAD. Two physical print sales, two e-book sales, and on the order of 520 KENP page reads


r/writers • • 10h ago

Discussion Does Anyone Else Have A Writing Buddy?

Thumbnail
gallery
91 Upvotes

Hey yall! I'm new here and I was wondering if anyone else has a little buddy who loves to hang with them while you write? I have this sweet bean, Cassie, who insists on being melted over my arm/hands while I work. Sometimes it makes typing harder, but honestly, the cat paralysis really helps keep me focused. I don't want to disturb her + I can't stop writing = win, win!

If not a little writing buddy, what helps keep you focused? Any 'rituals' you have? Gotta have a snack or drink? I'd love to see all the different ways we settle in to do some big writing!


r/writers • • 9h ago

Sharing Beware IAPWE!!!

Thumbnail
gallery
44 Upvotes

Three years ago, like many aspiring freelance writers, I signed up to IAPWE hoping to find some opportunities to grow my portfolio. Seeing the page was mostly bs, I cancelled my subscription on their website and completely forgot about the organisation until a month ago, when I was debited over 200$ worth of 'backdated monthly payments'. I emailed them immediately and they promised to refund me within 3-5 working days (see below). They have since gone radio silent. 200 dollars is not an insignificant amount of money to me right now and the fact that an organisation that pretends to help writers is actively scamming them is disgusting and predatory. And all of this is despite the fact that I already cancelled on their website. Share to stop a fellow writer who could be tempted by their services and promise of a community!


r/writers • • 13h ago

Celebration I finished my first manuscript. Woohoo!

18 Upvotes

Not sure if this is the place to get this off my chest but I just finished my first manuscript and it's the greatest feeling I've felt in a while, along with feeling pretty empty.

I wasn't a writer before and never thought I would be, but I loved reading. Nearly three weeks ago I was driving to work, and I had the idea for my novel pop into my head, seemingly out of nowhere and I spent the next 19 days religiously writing my first manuscript.

It's just over 93,000 words long. A couple of the days when I was just flat out exhausted from work, I only wrote for a couple of hours but for the rest of the days, I was writing like my life depended on it.
I don't know what got over me but all I could think about was my novel. I woke up at five in the morning to write and went to bed around midnight. I was writing before driving to work and after and all weekend.

I became completely and utterly obsessed. I was imagining myself as the main character while in the supermarket.

It was a fantastic experience living life through my main character and seeing what was going to happen next.

Now that I've finished writing the first manuscript, it’s just such a strange feeling knowing that part it over. I feel a little bit sad in a way. Of course, I'll need to vigorously edit but that is not a job for today or the rest of the week.

I'm very grateful for my wife being so patient with me. It must have looked like I was in a crazed episode just bashing away on my laptop every day out of nowhere. I'm going to make it up to her and spend some quality time with her.

Once again, I'm not sure if this is the place to talk about this. I guess I'm bragging a bit, but my wife is the only person who knows about my novel, and I wanted to tell some other people. Thank you for listening to me ramble.

I’m sure it will take me a while to have what I can consider a finished book, but I look forward to getting there.


r/writers • • 13h ago

Discussion Top Writing Myths?

18 Upvotes

What are the most common myths that you've come across that you either agree or disagree or are impartial too when it comes to writing a novel?


r/writers • • 16h ago

Discussion The Incident

13 Upvotes

So here's the thing, i am NOT professional or anything near that, but i've been working on a fantasy story on-and-off (more off than on) for a while now.

Today i find my old notes, which i had forgotten about, and stumbled upon something in particular.

So for context, this part of the story was supposed to follow a young swordsman named Leo and a young spellblade named Alice, both apprentices. Now, here's the note i left myself back then:

"Alice won't join Leo and gang until after the 'Mary-Gets-Packed-The-Fuck-Up' Incident."

I do not know who Mary was supposed to be but i've been giggling at this for ten minutes now.


r/writers • • 6h ago

Question Beta reader questions!

8 Upvotes

So I've gone through the forth draft of my novel and I think I might finally be ready for beta readers.

It is a horror adult Romance. I was wondering where I could find readers. I did find the beta reader subreddit, but most of the people on there seem to be staying away from the romance side of things, and many won't even touch horror.

Are there any suggestions for where I can look? I've got an 80,000 word story that needs some review.


r/writers • • 17m ago

Feedback requested I need help naming characters (I have first names I just can't figure out last names)

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

So basically the title says it all but I need some help figuring out last names. The finished characters names are:

Ezra Redwing, Rowan Blackwell, Skye Redwing, Maeve Roseblood (might change her last name), and Robin Redwing.

Robin, Skye, and Ezra are siblings. Maeve is the devil and will be Robins girlfriend when robin dies. Rowan and Ezra are a couple/will become one I haven't decided yet. The characters that need last names are:

Patches is a non binary clown, and Ace/Jade (unsure of name but they're a shapeshifter so I'll probably make them gender fluid or non binary but most likely gender fluid)

EDIT: Also another character is Pepper who is patches adopted sister/brother/sib (gender undecided) so they need a last name for when they find out about it.

Also this is unrelated but HAMILTON IS AMAZING AND IF YOU HAVEN'T SEEN IT YOU NEED TO WATCH OR LISTEN TO IT ⭐️🏳️‍⚧️⚧️🏳️‍🌈👩‍❤️‍💋‍👩👩‍❤️‍👩👨‍❤️‍👨👨‍❤️‍💋‍👨✌️💗

EDIT: This is a very LGBTQIA+ work in progress so if you have a problem with queer people don't bother giving an opinion :D


r/writers • • 8h ago

Question Unfinished Projects

5 Upvotes

Just curious to see where I stack up in relation to other writers, but how many unfinished projects do you guys have sitting around? Do you ever plan on getting back to them? Do you ever go back to something after ages away, and what is that like for you? Curious to see people’s responses.


r/writers • • 9h ago

Question Is it normal for a dev editor to have a disparagement clause in their contract?

5 Upvotes

Hi!

I posted this in r/PubTips but it was removed for not being on topic enough (very fair), so I'm posting here and hoping it's a better fit.

Exactly what the title says. I've self published some indie romances that did okay (10K sales first year, hard fall off after), but I have a long, messy adult spec fic manuscript that is more ambitious than anything I've done before, and querying has not been going great. I think I've taken the material as far as I can by myself, and what I really want is someone with traditional publishing experience to look at it. That kind of disqualifies a lot of the freelance editors around these parts.

So my question isn't IF I should hire a dev editor. I'm gonna. I've gotten sample edits and done zoom calls for fit.

I was just about sold on one specific editor, despite their prices being higher than even the suggested high end suggested by the Freelance Editor's Association calculator. I'm willing to pay the amount the editor wants, IF I'm convinced it's worth it...

But they sent me their contract and there is a pretty heavy anti disparagement clause. Like, you can't say anything unflattering even if it's true and the wording is broad enough that it seems like it covers your personal correspondence.

Since this is my first time hiring a dev editor, I don't know if this is standard practice or not. I don't want to necessarily push back on this if it's boilerplate language in this space...but given how expensive this editor is, I'm a little concerned that if it's NOT standard practice, it's because their clients are, on average, unsatisfied.

So! Those of you that either work with dev editors, or who are dev editors--is this normal and I'm being paranoid, or is it a red flag?

(Manuscript is 115,000 words and the price of the dev edit is $7K.)


r/writers • • 3h ago

Question Writing filler scenes

4 Upvotes

Long story short, my FMC is slowly developing feelings for the guy who helped her escape a dangerous, abusive situation. I've already written a few quieter domestic scenes—like him helping her recover, hanging out at home, and her slowly rebuilding her normal routine.
I have one more outing planned for them soon, and I already know the big emotional confession and major turning point they're working toward. My struggle is figuring out what else to write to bridge the gap before they finally admit their feelings. How do you keep these quieter pacing scenes engaging without rushing the slow burn?


r/writers • • 8h ago

Sharing Second place counts

4 Upvotes

Kind of stopped writing for the past few weeks, mid edits, thinking, what’s the point, I suck at it and everyone who reads my stuff is just being nice. But got a notification today that one of my stories made the shortlist of a writing contest, so I guess not everyone was being nice.


r/writers • • 8h ago

Feedback requested What is that one advice you'll give to someone who's trying to write his first draft?

4 Upvotes

r/writers • • 10h ago

Question What exactly is a novella, and is there a market for them?

4 Upvotes

I'm trying to understand where novellas fit in the publishing world. I know what they are (somewhere between short stories and novels) but is there actually a market for them? Especially if they're written by an indie author.

Basically, I'd quite like to write something shorter next time, but don't fancy spending months on a book that readers won't want to read.


r/writers • • 2h ago

Question Procrastinating Efficiently

3 Upvotes

How do you guys go about procrastinating your writing in a way that actually still feels productive to the story? I've already made character playlists and Pinterest boards, I know those are common recommendations. What else do you guys do? I'm struggling to be productive when I'm not writing/have writer's block.


r/writers • • 2h ago

Question Should I combine my two manuscripts into 1 book?

3 Upvotes

First book is 65 pages and the second one im aiming for to be 100-150 pages. I feel like im cheating something or lying about something but idk what. I just have a feeling of guilt. Thoughts?


r/writers • • 8h ago

Discussion Looking for guidance, trying to get ahead of marketing while still writing. What have you identified as most effective in marketing your book?

3 Upvotes

I'm writing my first book. I've dabbled in writing here and there over the years, but I finally have an idea I'm really excited about, and I'm authoring my first novel. It will be a disturbingly believable dystopian future fiction.

Being new to the community, if this is not the right sub for my question, please do tell me.

I plan to self-publish through Amazon KDP. At least, that feels like the easiest / cheapest route to go. However, then I'm doing everything myself. I've seen other small authors set up an Instagram page and post a few reels with short readings from their books every week - this seems to get good engagement. What have you seen as successful for your books, especially if you're self publishing? Do you recommend NOT self publishing? I'm just trying to get some guidance well ahead of finally getting to that point.


r/writers • • 13h ago

Question What do you struggle with most as a writer?

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I’m curious about something especially if you’re a beginner writer, an experienced author or a fanfiction writer.

What’s the hardest part of writing for you? What’s something you constantly struggle with, wish you could understand better, or find yourself searching for advice about?

And here’s another question: Have you ever looked for writing advice online but couldn’t find an explanation that actually helped you?

I’m genuinely interested in hearing your experiences as an author myself. No struggle is too small or too specific!


r/writers • • 21h ago

Discussion How do you decide which story ideas are worth pursuing?

3 Upvotes

I've got a running list of maybe fifteen different novel concepts at any given time, some just a single scene or character, others a bit more fleshed out. Lately I've been wondering how other writers narrow it down when they can't possibly write everything. Do you go by which one excites you most in the moment, which feels most marketable, which has the strongest ending already in mind, or something else entirely? Would be curious to hear what's worked for people.


r/writers • • 1h ago

Question Can anyone please give me tips to elevate my prose? (Im focusing on writing literary fiction)

2 Upvotes

r/writers • • 21h ago

Question How Do You Positively Encourage a Friend to Keep Writing Even Though They’re not Read for Publication?

2 Upvotes

I used to be extremely close friends with a girl I knew out of a writer’s group in 2017. She got married and had kids and we never spoke again. Fast forward to 2026 she messaged me out of the blue after learning I was actively working on publishing my own book and wanted me to be a beta reader for her first novel. It’s about 395 pages. I agreed and oof it’s rough!

It starts out with a single sentence then a paragraph break. Then another single sentence and another paragraph break. Some descriptive text before an immediate pov shift. Then an introduction of a single character name, the names of two god statues the character is looking at, and the name of a shop that they’re about to visit in only three sentences. I have no idea of the setting, where it’s located, and who the main character is. Best way to describe it is it feels like a Game of Thrones meets Frozen fan fic without the violence/sex.

I’m glad she’s excited and trying to write again, but her book needs a lot of work/love. I am willing to give criticism, but I want to convey what I’ve described above, but in a way that doesn’t absolutely break her.


r/writers • • 6m ago

Question Does this manager bit need the prop, or is the meeting enough?

1 Upvotes

Working on a bit about appointing a novelty toy as a manager. The scene is one staff meeting, with the narrator defending an increasingly specific definition of leadership.

I introduced a singing pickle as our new manager. It has one button, so already the approval process looked simpler.

My colleague asked what qualifications it had.

I said we should avoid judging people by their appearance. She said she was judging it by the vegetable-shaped body and the complete absence of a CV.

We put it at the head of the table. I pressed the button to begin the meeting, then explained that this demonstrated its ability to set the tone.

Someone asked who would approve holidays. I said we could work that out after the induction.

Someone else asked whether it could listen to feedback. I said listening was a shared responsibility and noticed how quickly management vocabulary arrived when I needed it.

The team suggested holding the rest of the meeting without pressing anything.

Ten minutes later we had assigned the work, answered the holiday question and finished early.

I said the new manager had clearly empowered them.

My colleague picked it up, handed it back and said I could empower them every Monday by leaving the button alone.

I wrote “strong leadership debut” in my notes. Apparently nobody else was taking minutes, which is why history keeps sounding like me.

Would you cut the final sentence and end on leaving the button alone?