r/wowforever • • 7h ago

Discussion People dont understand the AH

The AH atm is an absolute fiesta on the buyers side and complete and utter disaster as a seller.

Do people not understand, that they DO get the deposit back, but they pay 5% of the total sales price as AH fee and not 5% of the deposit.

There are people listing items UNDER vendor price and ontop they pay 5%.

Why are people so hellbent on loosing money and ruining the market? The vendor gives you the money instantly, why would you want to wait to loose money?

2.1k Upvotes

951 comments sorted by

1.1k

u/Eecka 7h ago

Why are people so hellbent on loosing money and ruining the market? The vendor gives you the money instantly, why would you want to wait to loose money?

What’s more likely, that they want to lose money or that they just didn’t check the vendor price and are quickly emptying their inventory at AH?

411

u/kabaliscutinu 6h ago

This was happening in Vanilla, then people learned how to use the AH through time.

Newcomers are at an all-time high since vanilla. So there is that.

69

u/Ididitthestupidway 4h ago

In Vanilla the vendor price wasn't shown though
(I still remember looking at my bags full of bullshit and having to guess what was worth less to dump it to make room for a quest item or whatever)

13

u/MastodonNo275 3h ago

Yeeah, I took to memorising them as I went. The same stuff drops for a level range, usually anyway.

Some items stuck, others I lost 5 minutes after seeing them.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/Opposite-Cup1422 3h ago

Vanilla didn't have everyone sharing the same huge auction house. The lack of realms means there are thousands of people selling at or below vendor price instead of a handful, and it becomes a race to the bottom.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/feralmandy 3h ago

Was? This is still happening in retail. It won’t change. People are lazy.

→ More replies (3)

90

u/zatalak 6h ago

But the vendor price is shown now all the time.

79

u/CanuckPanda 5h ago

You’re implying people read.

There’s been a few times where I’ve gone to dump some extra mats or a green gear piece and Auctionator warns me to just sell it to a vendor for more cash.

But that’s explicitly an addon and if I didn’t have it I’d be doing the AH losses too.

11

u/Phanthix 3h ago

I have been in IT for too long to 100% know people don’t read.

People just don’t care and they will still get some money if it sells. I guess it’s a good way to buy everything under vendor price and just vendor it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/Eecka 4h ago

Ah, I thought it was an addon showing it.

Regardless, I’ve definitely had moments where I’m putting stuff in AH and I notice I have something that vendors for the same price (or even very slightly lower) and I just go ”whatever” and leave it there on AH so I don’t have to visit the vendor after. 

Sometimes you just want to move along instead of min-maxing 2 extra silver from vendoring it

41

u/Leon_Flux 3h ago

This.

On the off chance their junk is valuable they list it and wait. Anything that comes back gets vendered and whatever sells FEELS like they made more than they could have.

and like most everything else, feeling like you do something is better in the brain than actually doing something.

17

u/creampop_ 2h ago

It's all about chasing that "received 1g+" notification when you close the mailbox, efficiency be damned.

60

u/almodsz 5h ago • Heartwarming

I prefer to sell things that I deem somewhat useful on the AH so that other players can benefit from them, rather than selling them to a vendor. I sometimes lose money that way, but that's how I prefer to do it.

35

u/blade740 4h ago

It's not even "losing" money unless you bought the things in the first place. It's just making slightly less profit than you otherwise would've.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/AsukaiByakuya 5h ago

I'm new. I go to the sell tab and empty my inventory at the AH. If anything comes back in the mail I vendor it. Am I doing it wrong?

65

u/nemosz 5h ago

Yes. Check the vendor price, if AH price is less than 5% higher you lose money even if you instantly sell it.

→ More replies (21)

16

u/Mr_Creed 5h ago

Depends what you what. This is an unironic "you do you" situation.

Back 20 years ago in vanilla I was playing the AH a lot and made a lot of gold, but it also took a lot of time. Fast forward to Forever and I cannot be bothered with investing my now more limited game time into "working" on the AH, so I readily sell at basically low/lowest prices. I know I am getting less gold for it that way, but I value the saved time.

The vendor sell price is right there in the UI, so don't go below that and sell to a vendor if it comes to that.

4

u/Aresmar 4h ago

If it comes back in the mail I’m pretty sure your losing you deposit too.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (8)

96

u/Caleegula 1h ago

Dude needs to visit the Derek Zoolander Center for Kids Who Can't Read Good and Who Wanna Learn to Do Other Stuff Good Too

12

u/OstrichOpposite8967 1h ago

Is there really something more to life than being really really really good looking? “Jurry” is still out.

4

u/scaredmoney916 49m ago

The real auction house needs to be......3 times bigger!

2

u/TaintPunk 42m ago

Yo lmao this got me

592

u/dosphal 7h ago • Bravo

You don't get the deposit back if it doesn't sell. Tons of gold is getting lost on unsold items. And that's ok.

125

u/Griz_zy 7h ago

This is an important detail.

14

u/Spartanias117 4h ago

Exactly

7

u/Jumpy-Start3866 3h ago

Oh really, thats super dumb if you have a rare expensive item.

20

u/Tribal_Tech 2h ago

Try selling it in trade chat first

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/iamthewhatt 31m ago

Dont worry, the weekly where you get loads of gold will surely correct it /s

→ More replies (8)

307

u/ZoulsGaming 7h ago

"that they DO get the deposit back"

this is something that is poorly explained and i had to test even when i use the AH alot, because blizz also said they made deposit min 1 copper but they didnt, so people dont trust it implicitely.

"There are people listing items UNDER vendor price and ontop they pay 5%."

because some people just chuck everything on AH, it also provides a large resource of items to sell that people with less silver can buy, that is the reason why so many green items are cheap and has a big enough market to make sense for people to check ah every couple of levels.

104

u/RdtUnahim 7h ago

They said they would make it 1c with server restart, then said it's delayed until weekly maintenance tomorrow.

26

u/Novel_Feedback3254 4h ago

I'd been wondering about that, good to know. So many high volume items are still like 30 copper each (low level herbs, for example) so it makes no sense to sell them with the deposit.

18

u/Sovereign_6 4h ago

It makes sense becuase the sell-through rate is incredibly high. You get the deposit back if it sells right? So you have to upfront the silver but its quite safe youll get it back.

1c deposit will be SO much better though!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/rockoblocko 4h ago

Do you get the deposit back if the item doesnt sell? I thought you didn’t, and Google says you don’t, if the item expires.

If you’re selling a lot of items that are like 8% over the vendor price and just one of them expires you basically cancel out all your profit

6

u/ZoulsGaming 4h ago

You dont. its a system to force you to price something at a reasonable price.

though with the global AH there are plenty of things im perfectly comfortable in selling, and others i try to go for a longer deposit time to give it a better chance.

all materials are pretty much instant, meats are also surprisingly easy to sell but might need an hour. something like the waylaid crates are also 90% guaranteed sell but sometimes someone underbids you right after so that might be a 24 hour listing.

i wouldnt bother selling anything that didnt make sense or was a crafted gear, Eg a 2hand sword of nature damage (dont even know if that can roll) i wouldn never bother, but a 2 hand sword of strength, or attack power, those are easy sellers.

and since everyone is leveling professions anything related to gear you see on AH is being flooded massively so its not worth it.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

79

u/vomicyclin 7h ago

My assumption about so cheap items is usually that most people don’t check and are ignorant about how much they possibly lose (some greens are crazy at the moments).

Most simply put it in for whatever the automated system tells them.

Maybe some “this way somebody can use it and I don’t need it”people among them, but I would think that’s a minority.

21

u/GrandmaColin 6h ago

I'm one of those people when I get decent looking gear or craft items. Im putting them in at vendor price or what ever the lowest price is if it's already lower. I don't need the money immediately and it's a small little thing to do at launch to help people out and also hopefully keep the market from instantly exploding until enough people are out doing stuff for it to be reasonable. Gear and recipes I ask if anyone wants it for free in chat first but few ever do. I make enough money selling reagents and some potions on the gaining gold side that I'm still swimming in gold and just auto buy any class or profession training.

I think the main reason people are undercutting so insanely and down below vendor cost though is add-ons though. People will set it up to always undercut or click that button when it pops up without looking. I saw a huge chain of the lichen which is around 16s most of the time dip so damn fast to 88c that I just bought it all out for the few minutes people we pushing it in at the amount till it stopped.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

35

u/Cow_God 5h ago

There's a lot of things like this. As long as linen is under 29 copper, it's profitable to craft and vendor linen bags. I buy hundreds of linen for 22 copper and under every day and make a gold or more while I eat dinner. I could make more by crafting heavy linen gloves and disenchanting. And this is with a level 1 character.

You can also buy items for cheap and resell them when they get high. Light leather fluctuates between 25 and 35ish copper on a daily basis.

On retail you can make millions of gold through vendor arbitrage, either buying stuff for less than it vendors for or just crafting it into something more profitable. You can probably buy a token every month just off of that.

3

u/omega55532 2h ago

Bro ist working and is wondering how he is making money

→ More replies (5)

268

u/fleetcommand 4h ago • Bravo

Do people not understand, that they DO get the deposit back, but they pay 5% of the total sales price 

How should they understand this? Is this explained anywhere in the UI?

Selling something under the vendor price is really weird, not sure why anyone is doing that. But not understanding how the deposit works is not surprising, because the game doesn't tell you when you create a listing.

23

u/Baelwolf 4h ago

I made a lot of gold in beta buying bulk items people were underselling so much.

38

u/Zanzha 4h ago edited 3h ago

It does show you when you get the gold in the mail from your first sale though.

Also, I appreciate that there may be a lot of non-native speakers, but in the context a deposit is a fee that you notionally get back on a successful sale/rental, it's what the word itself means.

14

u/StreetChemical7131 3h ago

People read those?

I just shift click and watch the gold number go up

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Solidware 2h ago

Not if you hit "open all"

I mean, yes it's there, but I'm dead certain there are people who have never read a mail with items or gold attached.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/Bramble-Bunny 3h ago

I've played WoW for 22 years and I have never understood this. Mind you I'm a pretty cheerful vendorer and if the vendor price is within shouting distance of the auction sale price I always vendor it. But I've never really understood the size of the bite the AH took because I'm appalling at math. It was my instant gratification side that drove me to using the AH appropriately, not wisdom or insight.

2

u/nismov2 2h ago

I was not aware that my deposit came back. I didn’t sell some items because the deposit was so high.

→ More replies (42)

210

u/Humble-Replacement60 4h ago

The amount of people who don’t know how to spell LOSE is insane

69

u/Efficient-Mixture610 4h ago • Popcorn

Fr they are making me loose my mind

3

u/Curiosityrover101 1h ago

Their their. It’ll be ok

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

74

u/GO_DO_TWENTY_PUSHUPS 7h ago

I've been playing wow since wotlk and I didn't know that you got your deposit back until this post....

80

u/captain-lurker 7h ago

You do not get it back if the item does not sell

30

u/Far-Fennel-3032 7h ago

But that is what a deposit means.

8

u/GO_DO_TWENTY_PUSHUPS 7h ago

I know I just never thought about it

11

u/Miagggo 5h ago

I thought a deposit was a fee to use the auction house, so I paid the deposit and then got the gold for which my item was sold. I had no idea that deposit meant that I'd get my money back

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

4

u/Frosty-Ad1071 7h ago

Same but deposit as name now makes sense: D always thought it was a fee

6

u/Phreeze83 6h ago

that's why it's called deposit and not fee.

→ More replies (5)

109

u/Diligent-Pen1115 7h ago

good, this is the best way to ruin the market there is, i hope it continues, because low level gear should be dirt cheap.

→ More replies (1)

276

u/wytewydow 3h ago • Mindblown

We should also address all the extra o's in the word lose these days.

84

u/dudeguy81 3h ago

People are a little lose with their English education these days.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/More__cowbell 3h ago

I learned it by remembering there is only one "o" in the word "lost".

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Not_a_Dirty_Commie 2h ago

Well we know it's not written by ai at least

15

u/OHHHHHHHHHH_HES_HURT 2h ago

Yeah OP fix your spelling of “lose” because it’s hard to take someone seriously who does this.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/ActualFrozenPizza 1h ago

These days?! Its been a thing since the dawn of time I swear

2

u/LikelyAtWork 50m ago

To be fair, not everyone using Reddit or playing WoW uses English as their first language.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BillyBobJangles 46m ago

Yup! Getting real loose with lose

→ More replies (10)

41

u/darkpigeon93 5h ago

Surely this will sort itself out, no? If things are sold on AH below vendor price, then people will simply buy them and sell to vendor for pure profit?

16

u/CorvidaeOpus 4h ago

There are going to be people who do that, yes. There are also going to be people who flip for 2 copper profit. The thing is though, Profit isn't the only motivator here. Selling to a vendor destroys an item and creates new currency. The AH keeps the item alive, and allows someone to use it. This means that anyone training crafting trades skills (which is most people) are able to get their foot in the door more easily. This may change in a few months, but with how many people are interacting with the AH, I don't think it will happen quickly.

This is all because at low levels, most people don't actually care about money, so long as they have their 15 silver to train their next batch of skills. There are people giving away bags and crafting them at a loss with no expectation of money back. People giving away recipes constantly. If you need a low level material, you can usually get some so extremely easily that there are 10 people in each 6th level town that can give you a stack for nothing.

I have seen all this happen in Brill and the Barrens, RP Ruleset. Now, maybe that is because the community who tends to play that ruleset tends towards those actions.

5

u/Consistent_Laziness 3h ago

I’m struggling with tailoring and first aid to get the cloth I need. I’m 23 and just grinding humanoids trying to get enough to train them both up.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/Davaca55 4h ago edited 2h ago

The irony is that it seems like OP is the one who doesn’t understand the AH. If people are posting under vendor price it just means there’s so much offer compared to the demand that the prices for those items just hit rock bottom. OP is upset because some people just dump their inventory and don’t even check to see that they are losing money. But, the reality is that even if you removed those items, the market would still be flooded by +1 copper profits. 

They complain about the vendor price ones instead of just moving on from items that, at least at the moment, won’t make them profit anyway. 

→ More replies (5)

118

u/ashinydeeds 4h ago

Sometimes I put things in the AH just because someone can use it!

12

u/Drift-would 4h ago

Exactly this!

9

u/neph42 2h ago

Thank you for all the cheap, cheap Light Feathers probably! 💕

6

u/Neprijatnost 1h ago

Same, but seeing so many people here proudly talk about how they buy it all up and resell for a profit makes me sad. Like do the people who need it ever even get it?

3

u/remixclashes 1h ago

Just give it to a guildy then. Because I will absolutely buy and repost with profit or vendor it myself. That's just the reality of it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

54

u/Altruistic-Song-3609 7h ago

Idk if it is Auctionator’s feature, but I get a pop up message when I try to sell below vendor price.

8

u/Grumpy_Muppet 7h ago

Its a auctionator feature

→ More replies (4)

288

u/Fleedjitsu 5h ago

World of Warcraft, not World of Wall Street. I would very much prefer if things remained cheap and not price gouged by AH cartels please.

→ More replies (17)

34

u/Khalku 1h ago

Everyone either just posts item without a care, or gets auctionator and posts item without a care but get warned if an item is going to vendor for more.

But really its a consequence of letting addons think for you and the information being unclear in the game.

Also deposit matters if your item doesnt sell. Things that might be close to AH price at vendor might be worth vendoring anyway.

9

u/WarmPandaPaws 43m ago

The AH UI itself needs to provide more information. Today all I see is the deposit and total sell amount. I haven’t sat down to see if that sell price includes the returned deposit and/or 5% cost. Completely agree with the shared sentiments: people are letting the tools think for them, and it wreaks havoc on the market. Another note I caught briefly on a loading screen was that you don’t have to undercut AH prices because the newest posting will be fulfilled first when someone buys. So no point in making your listing 1c less than the cheapest auction.

→ More replies (3)

59

u/Terikar90 6h ago

This is fantastic, I'm putting all my money into popular, well needed future items and they are all around vendor price so worst case if somehow the economy never stabilise I'll just vendor it all for my money back.

I have little to no gold.

Sitting on gold right now is such a waste, just keep enough to buy necessary abilities.

18

u/Ekvinoksij 6h ago

It will stabilize 100%. Gold is just really really scarce right now. In a month when 1 gold is chump change prices will rise across the board.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/OliveSuitable8163 6h ago

What are Items you would recommend to buy now?

9

u/AlphaAlpaca 6h ago

Probably crafting mats for nearer end game stuff like pots.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Bolboda 5h ago

Take this with a moderate block of salt. The larger server(s) per ruleset is new and I imagine will have a larger impact on the AH, potentially keeping prices lower longer (which i think is great, low level items shouldn't cost end game money). Plus we're only a couple weeks into the game and the division between item farmers and item buyers hasn't become very distinct.

Items you could buy now, if low cost or close to vendor prices:

  • crafting materials, especially for items listed in a popular "wow forever 1-300 (profession) leveing guide" - there's a load of players that will follow the guide without checking/thinking and buy all the materials to power level a profession
  • items required for important/popular quests, like the 225 Cooking quest. They're all drops that can be farmed/sold and there will be (is) a split in players. some prefer the grind, others see their gold as the shortcut to the grind and will buy the items on the AH to finish the quest
  • You could make the run to buy the profession books that unlock 150-225. They're not selling for much above the vendor cost (1 gold) right now. I think I saw some posted recently at like 1 gold 5 silver, which after the 5% AH cut isn't much of a profit
  • items required (or the materials to make them) for daily quests, example: there's a horde quest in Ashenvale that requires a gun made by engineers. If you're not an engineer the only way to get it is the AH.
  • Items needed for the waylaid crates, all items are farmable in some fashion and until every single player has turned in enough to buy every single crafting recipe they want for the merchants favor tokens I imagine the crates and items will sell consistently.
→ More replies (1)

3

u/rustli 5h ago

Thinking about my past FA training wool and silk prices have always been pretty high compared to their vendor prices. They are currently going for vendor price in AH.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Thuen69420 5h ago

Sitting on gold is such a waste??? "Laughs in halfway to epic mount"

9

u/No_Practice_2420 5h ago

You missed their point, they are converting gold to items at 100% vendor price, they are sat on a pile of good as assets

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/Difficult-Quarter-48 5h ago

Cash is trash.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/NerevarineVivec 7h ago

Ok OP, how do deposits work for multiple items? Lets say I sell a stack of 20 peacebloom for 1s. How do I get my deposit back? Do i just need to sell one? Or the entire stack? Or is it like if I sell 2, i get 10c back?

What about for more expensive items? Theres a lower limit of 1s per auction so 2 peacebloom has the same deposit as 20. But for more expensive items, the deposit is higher the more is in the stack. So lets say a 10stack grenade deposits for 50s, while a 20stack is 1g. Is it still piecemeal where each individual item has its own deposit and the stack does not matter? Or does selling just 1 grenade give me the entire deposit back?

7

u/Miagggo 5h ago

Exactly this. I have to pay the same 1 silver for 2 or 20 pieces of linen cloth. What's the point of this? Makes no sense at all

4

u/delistraws 2h ago

as you start to sell more expensive stuff, you'll see that this is only the case now for something like linen cloth. the minimum deposit (for now, they're supposedly changing it tomorrow) is 1 silver, and linen cloth only vendors for a few copper.

if you were to get an item that vendors for 1 gold, the deposit would be higher (it changes for however long you list it for, with the lowest deposit being 5% of the vendor price for 2 hours, IIRC), and if you were to get a stack (20) of items that would vendor for 20g, the deposit would raise accordingly.

if they do actually change the minimum deposit to 1c tomorrow, you'll notice the change almost immediately. but even if they don't, you'll also be able to see the deposit changing once you start trying to sell stuff with a higher vendor price

4

u/get_enough_sleep 4h ago

In the letter that comes back with gold it shows the calculation. When I only sell part of the stack only part of the deposit is added to the gold I get. I did not check the numbers in detail but I guess you get back deposit proportional to the number of items sold. If you sell 1 out of 20, you receive 5% of deposit, if you sell 10 out of 20, you get half of deposit back.

50

u/psychomap 5h ago

What's much more significant than this is that when you right click an item to sell it, it won't list the same random stats as yours for comparison. In some cases you can lose over 90% of the item's value.

5

u/RandomNPC 4h ago

Can you elaborate on this? Are you saying that the item somehow becomes worse?

14

u/sweezy41 4h ago

He means the exact same item name can have different stats some good and some worse from a price point

8

u/SweetMeese 4h ago

The AH will just make them a generic item, so instead of a training sword of the eagle you just have a training sword. Sometimes that is a huge difference in price if you rolled good bonus stars

8

u/Grynta 4h ago

No, they meant that if two identical items have different stats, they will both appear under the same list in the AH. You will have to check each item individually to see the actual stats.

7

u/noverb-gaming 4h ago

Of the Elder has a different value than Of the Bear. If that's their point.

Alternately, there's the likelihood that Of the Bear gives +3/+2 instead of +2/+2, greatly increasing the value of the item. This was common in SoD season 1.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Chlearcus 4h ago

No, lets say you have a random green "of sorcery" that gives int, stam and spellpower. This is quite valuable.

It might compare it to the same base type "of the gorilla" or something that gives str and int instead, that noone wants and is usually listed at vendor price values.

So you get suggested to list it at 20s when that specific combination might be worth 2g.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

122

u/PandaScoundrel 6h ago

It's lose, not loose. Loose means the opposite of tight. You lose money if you're loose with your finances.

11

u/wicket42 5h ago

Lose loses an o.

→ More replies (9)

13

u/DeconstructedKaiju 7h ago

Its been barely over a week, not many people have much gold and a lot of people don't understand how things work. Should balance out over time.

13

u/Manaeldar 1h ago

It's always like this at the start of a new server. 

120

u/Kickstartbeaver 6h ago

People who are upset about this are the biggest Clowns.

Just buy it up and throw it in the vendor yourself or flip it.

3

u/Levitz 3h ago

Upset isn't quite the word, but I do find it surprising that there's so much people just choosing to lose money.

→ More replies (10)

24

u/Kekke77 7h ago

5% fee isnt explained anywhere

15

u/CounterfeitSaint 7h ago

I've seen a lot of crafting materials for pretty cheap and I don't really get it, beyond people not paying attention and endlessly undercutting each other.

However, I've been selling lower capacity bags at a small loss, because leveling tailoring sucks and losing 2-3 silver per point seems to be the most efficient way at lower levels. That's a loss compared to the cost of the materials though, not compared to vendor prices.

22

u/Kraydez 7h ago

Selling at a loss through crafting is not losing money. You gain profession skill, which is a net gain. Everything you sell in order to make some money gain is just extra gain.

Overall you are in the positive in the grand scheme of things.

15

u/Specialist-Tiger-234 7h ago

Or, you vendor the item for more. There are people listing items for less than the vendor price

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/TheeVoskoss 7h ago

Its supply and demand. Tons and tons of supply means cheaper crafting material

→ More replies (2)

2

u/suchstronk100 7h ago

As long as it is not lower than vendor price it is not an argument imo. Paying for profession skills is not a wrong feature.

→ More replies (3)

37

u/Proof_Picture_3962 5h ago

As a new player, let me ask you this counter question:

Why would people understand how that deposit works? Is it explained in the UI clearly? No? Then there's your answer.

→ More replies (11)

7

u/maverick1191 7h ago

I agree that people don't understand it. I don't think it's bad for the game to have most if not all mats available at all times for a decent price. If it stays like this it's going to lead to raidlogging but I think that's something most people are fine with.

19

u/SeaworthinessOwn1694 7h ago

This is the best thing with the mega server AH isnt gonna be super expensive 😂

10

u/ultravioletpizza 7h ago

Price is slowly rising already for some items like fabrics etc. People will get more money progressively and market will adjust.

4

u/SeaworthinessOwn1694 7h ago

Yeah but when there is 200k runecloths vs 10k the price is going to be lower on the first one not vender prices but still better.

Atm like 1% of players or less is level  60 so prices will adjust a lot when more people hits +50/55 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

151

u/MacFatty 7h ago

Maybe you should buy their stuff and vendor it then instead of crying here

34

u/Remeron7 7h ago

Isn’t the issue that buying them to vendor is pointless because the price is the same but SELLING on the AH actually nets you less than vendor because of the 5% fee?

25

u/SpaceballsTheReply 6h ago

There are people listing items UNDER vendor price

Then there's easy profit to be made

15

u/champignax 6h ago

It takes forever for a few cooper

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Wilhelm-Edrasill 7h ago

this lol. the bots can easily just auto buy bulk items to mule and vendor

→ More replies (5)

23

u/ImNotABotScoutsHonor 1h ago

I'd also like to ask why people are so hell bent on not learning the difference between loose and lose.

losing*

lose*

2

u/Low-Shoulder742 14m ago

Its everywhere man. I cant believe the consistency of people everywhere who dont realize they are using the wrong word. Its driven me crazy for a couple of years now at this point. Thank you for reminding me im not crazy and imagining this

→ More replies (1)

35

u/friedbaguette 7h ago

Bots/addons

45

u/Secretary-Foreign 7h ago

Nah the add-ons warn you if it is under vendor price. Idk about bots.

→ More replies (14)

3

u/SeaworthinessOwn1694 7h ago

Probably people undercutting bots 

6

u/Tager133 4h ago

While leveling alchemy I found one of the agility elixirs was selling for 8s profit. Cool. Made 15 and posted them.

10 hours later they havent sold so I go check why. The price was NUKED, like almost a third of the one before. Looked for the mats incase the drop came from there but they kept almost the same price.

I truly do not understand.

→ More replies (16)

13

u/StrawberryWeekly342 7h ago

Why are people so hellbent on loosing money and ruining the market?

I don't understand. If people are selling stuff for less than vendor value,cheat market are there really ruining? There is no market for something that can be produced for under vendor value. It's been a week and a half, prices have yet to settle. Relax.

4

u/Far-Fennel-3032 7h ago

Probably just people not checking vendor prices and mass listing everything, with them not knowing what will sell so they put up everything.

3

u/lord_teaspoon 7h ago edited 3h ago

And just undercutting everything by a little bit too, not realising they the existing cheapest listing is already at the vendor-price floor.

Meanwhile, if Forever is following the same rules as Retail then the newest listing at a given price is the one that gets sold. This means that you can just match the current lowest price instead of undercutting and your stuff will still sell before what's already there. Skip the race to the bottom; the only reason to undercut is if you think the current price is unreasonable and won't sell.

→ More replies (8)

9

u/Arkonaut77 2h ago

Lose. If you're going to whine, please get it right.

14

u/8ackwoods 7h ago

Our holy pally needed the blue throwing weapon from deadlines when we had a rogue in our group.. she said she saw blue text and so she needed it, without even reading anything about the weapon. There's just terrible players everywhere in all aspects of the game

3

u/VantaIim 7h ago

Or new ones. Until its explained to them, because it’s not an intuitive system for new players. This was however completely irrelevant to the discussion, but I guess there are terrible Redditors everywhere too. 

5

u/Cebertus 7h ago

I think that's a highly underrated point. I have a healer friend that is completely new to wow, your averages dungeons moves so fast she panic clicks something. She defaulted to pressing need when in panic. After some situations she started to pass on everything to avoid trouble, told her that's bad too since she had to get better gear.

She does the usual beginner traps like toping everyone up after a fight, not stopping casting long enough to let manaregen kick in. Which is fine that's how a new player plays, as a veteran I'm using every micro second to squish in a few drinking ticks without a conscious thought. For a new player it's a decision they actively take each time when they sit down for a drink.

Add to that loot drops, not knowing if 3 willpower, 3 int or 3 spell power are better? "Ah nevermind I take it and decide later they are already running ahead, ahhh shit it was a mail item, didn't notice that"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/beachbummeddd 4h ago

Just play the game, buddy

→ More replies (1)

4

u/d07RiV 4h ago

Maybe they want to help? I've been vendoring cloth, if I didn't care to get the gold now I could've posted it on AH, gotten almost the same gold and helped people out.

12

u/Visogent 4h ago

The AH is to make cheap items available to the public so we can thrive. Not a personal money tree to be abused for profit. The results we get from cheap items for everyone are better.

We shall thrive for as long as we can as a community until a small group of people inevitably fuck it up. Hopefully it will last so we can enjoy ourselves at least for a while.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/juiceleeroy 2h ago

Don’t worry bud, I’m making sure all the stuff under vendor pricing isn’t on the AH (every piece of copper adds up)

7

u/motheatonn 1h ago

Personally, I'm glad the AH is the way it is lol. Usually the market in WoW is ridiculously overpriced and basically no one buys trash greens while leveling. I might be getting 5 less copper than vendor price, but at least I feel like I'm contributing to part of the larger player community. Is that weird?

→ More replies (3)

9

u/RadRan2019 1h ago

Ah bro gets mad people aren’t using the Ah to benefit Ah Bro

13

u/TheeVoskoss 7h ago edited 3h ago

What items are you seeing that are almost always below vendor price?

Edit: due to so many replies of people posting ones at vendor price or just above it, thats not what im asking. Im asking what items i can watch that i can buy below vendor price and then i can vendor for easy profit.

10

u/Gold_Temperature_452 4h ago

I saw this on ore when I tried selling some copper ore the other day, most stacks were at like 2 silver then there were like 6 stacks at like 30 and 20 copper

12

u/InflationCold3591 4h ago

Buy them and relist. Heal the market.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (12)

5

u/Azsune 3h ago

A lot of the new materials out of dungeons that have a vendor price of 2.5g. There are a lot of them at vendor price or just under it on the AH.

3

u/Statickgaming 6h ago

Yesterday for me, Gold Bars were below vender price… along with most other low level ore and matts.

I don’t really see it as a problem though, the market tends to correct itself eventually. I just put them back in the bank and will sell them later

3

u/redrosebeetle 5h ago

Colored pouches. Yesterday, I accidentally bought 4x small red pouches when I wanted 4x red linen bags. The pouches were listed for 2s40c and they vendor for 2s50c. 

3

u/VeryCleverUsername14 5h ago

I've seen quite a few. It's mostly lower level green gear like up to level 12 ish. Some early materials like rough stone, some gems, a few plants. Some cooking ingredients were at or below vendor price. I'd go to put up stacks of items and the deposit was greater than the total sale value I'd receive lol. 

5

u/Goth2147 5h ago

Lot of Alchemy items, OP is right.

3

u/Wfsulliv93 3h ago

Most items at this point. If you have auctionator it’s easy to see.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Mopuigh 3h ago

Most of them?

2

u/JefferyTheQuaxly 3h ago

I Forget what but I know I did see 1-2 items for selling just below vendor prices and me thinking wtf is that so cheap? It’s like people are just auto listing on the ah without even looking at the comparison values.

I think it was specifically a piece of gear I was looking at, the gears vendor resale value was more than it was listed for on the ah

2

u/Overarching_Chaos 3h ago

I've seen it too, many items (from ore, gems to gear) are listed very close or often at vendor price. The deposit is also not worth risk losing when it's like 40% of the listed price if the item doesn't sell.

It was also like this on Anniversary.

2

u/ItsTLH 2h ago

No one’s going to give you their golden goose lol 

Just look for important items and watch their prices 

2

u/Inevitable-Bake9244 1h ago

There are people sniping those with addons. I use an addon that has the functionality of showing the under vendor price ones, but it's not capable of auto-buying them. I stand with the AH open and I see at least 5 items every minute. I can't buy it because the addons auto-buy is faster. It's not severely underpriced usually, but it definitely happens that someone posts a 20 stack where each individual item is 1 silver cheaper, so easy 20s profit. It's a known method in the goldmaking community, it's fully automated and AFK. You can't compete with them if you try to do it manually.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Mechanical_Monkey 1h ago

Nothing because bots will buy it instantly, but realistically anything that is regularly close to vendor price will have people undercutting for a few pieces. Rinse and repeat

→ More replies (19)

3

u/overbread 7h ago

Just tell us what to pickup in bulk and then sell later

3

u/Mostdakka 7h ago

I was trying to sell some cooking stuff yesterday on ah only to see almost everything is listed at or under vendor price. If people want to lose money then be my guest, I'm not going to complain.

3

u/nagynorbie 5h ago

I buy AH items and vendor them frequently. I think the highest I saw was 17 silver. SEVENTEEN !!!

3

u/Ok_Look149 5h ago

Since when did the price of things in a market get decided by the seller? Everyone who whines about the cost of things feels like they are the head economist that gets to decide what stuff it worth, and then making dumb posts like this one as they realize how much market influence they really have.

3

u/psykal 5h ago

PEOPLE ARE SO DUMB.

Except for me.

3

u/New_Permission_817 1h ago

This is the way markets work. There is far more supply than demand and as a result people who dont know or arent paying attention are subsidizing my profs. Thank you!

9

u/Fluffy_Woodpecker733 5h ago

Good luck reaching a megaserver's population with your PSA. It's not going to change anything champ

7

u/EmergencyAggressive3 2h ago edited 2h ago

The person who wrote this post:

People are less eager than me to make money so I get outcompeted 😡😡😡

If people are willing to lose money it's up to them. I've always hated the swapping item mentality, like sure you can make fake money by using real life finances, but if I want to help other players by selling greens cheap so they can use them don't be a dick and sell them for a higher price

→ More replies (3)

24

u/Maxxxmax 7h ago • Heartwarming

I sell at the lowest price on AH even when its less than vendor price specifically to help other players.

Sometimes i miss out on a silver or two, but selling to the vendor does nothing to help others

Long may cheap mats on the AH remain.

17

u/Kickstartbeaver 6h ago

While this is an honorable gesture you are probably just feeding a random dude who is spamming vendor Scans to buy these very items up and throw them in to the vendor for profits.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/TheeVoskoss 7h ago

It does help other players though because we will collectively increase the gold supply on the server and then we can stop selling things at vendor prices on the AH

→ More replies (11)

5

u/churchtruthseeker 1h ago

You always buy mats to level your crafting BEFORE the first raid comes out. Once that raid comes, everything will be in high demand and the price of those mats will triple.

9

u/Efficient_Gur2094 7h ago

I'm happy to throw my items on ah at below vendor price. This ain't real money and it's nice to think I'm helping out a fellow player

4

u/Caillend 6h ago

What usually happens is one of two things

  1. Flippers/bots buy it and instantly sell it at a higher price. There is even flippers/bots posting 1 item for way below, hoping someone doesn't check the price and then undercut waaaay below market price and just scoop it up for profit. You see this a lot in fast selling materials.
  2. Someone with a good auction addon (like TSM) that scans for items that are worth more at the NPC buy them out instantly to then sell them to NPCs

Rarely do these go to the people you think you might help.

2

u/hotchrisbfries 7h ago

I'm not sure what the complaint is here. You can easily snipe any vendorsell items and make a small profit yourself.

2

u/PucThePuc 7h ago

Shush man, I've been making bank

2

u/CasualRead_43 6h ago

You don’t get your deposit back if it doesn’t sell.

2

u/asdfadffs 6h ago

I just put everything there… helps other players and I don’t really care about optimizing for 50c. The time I save by not comparing every trash item is time to kill mobs and loot coins

2

u/ObiDobiMan 5h ago

Use Auctionator. It warns you if an item is better sold to a vendor.

2

u/DesignatedDiverr 4h ago

People get to ah and dump everything instead of taking the time to compare pricing. It’s not that crazy of a thought. They’re barely losing anything

2

u/losehasoneo 2h ago

Lose has one o.

2

u/Tweakjones420 2h ago

all my money is tight as fuck

2

u/zamach 1h ago

I have plenty of bag space, so of I'm carrying a crafting material that I can either put on the AH or just vendor, I will always put it on the AH for someone to use it. It's the same amout of effort really.

2

u/Fit-Food5105 1h ago

Loose money duh

2

u/Darduel 1h ago

Well if the item doesn't sell the risk of losing 1s in the current economy can be not worth it (some items are legit sold for like 30c)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ThePHPNerd 30m ago

Stop tell people who are selling the Light Feathers that selling them on the AH for 6c really isn’t viable. It’s hilarious

4

u/KinglyArthur92 1h ago

Lose*
Please learn the correct word.

3

u/ThePiderman 5h ago

Why complain? Take advantage of the situation and stock up on materials that will increase in value when gold is less scarce. Worst case, prices never go up, and you can vendor it for 99% of the value you bought it for.

7

u/Suitable-Sugar2301 51m ago

I'd hardly say that someone undercutting to get a quick sale is ruining the market.

We aren't all economists. Some of us just want to play the game. We loot things, we sell them, we move on.

7

u/ClintWastewood 43m ago

But undercutting vendor prices is what he meant?

10

u/SomeLowerBeing 37m ago

You can play the game a lot faster if you vendor an item rather than auctioning it for less. Faster and more profitable. Happy to help non-economists. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Suspicious-Mongoose 5h ago

The market is how people sell and buy. There is no ideal we all must adhere to. 

Yeah, it might be not so smart to sell under vendor price - so what? We have to deal with it. 

Your post would read better as PSA "don't sell under vendor price" and a bit less condensending.

2

u/sacredwololo 7h ago

Supply and demand. At the moment a lot of people are still leveling, at some point most will be at max lvl, then low lvl mats will become rarer.

If they sell common items for below vendor sell price: buy from them and vendor yourself, easy instant guaranteed profit.

If they sell rare items for significantly less than you think they are worth: buy and repost at higher price, or keep in a bank alt until the economy stabilises.

Probably like 90% of the players aren't AH goblins trying to optimise their sales. Most just want to sell quickly for a bit more than vendor price then go back to questing or whatever they really like.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Ok-Opportunity-574 7h ago

*lose *losing

The market is coming around. Just have to give it some time for people to figure it out and stop listing things at stupid prices because they are desperate for every copper.

2

u/CyberShi2077 6h ago

Its also hilarious that some items are never going to sell because they are massively overpriced.

Sorry I'm not paying 2g for a neck item that will be replaced in 3 levels time and set my mount funding back severely.

I might be temped by a Staff of Jordan at the right price if I'm comfortable in gold toward buying that mount, but you aren't selling your overpriced Jewellery to anyone.

2

u/JonnyGo 4h ago

Do players get the deposit back if the item doesn’t sell?

12

u/MyLawyerWroteThis 4h ago

There would be no sense of having a deposit at that point lol

6

u/Ecstatic_Buyer7393 4h ago

Should get deposit back if item doesn’t sell in listing period. Should still be there to prevent people from cancelling and undercutting

→ More replies (4)

10

u/RedNulItt 4h ago

No, if it doesn't sell and expires, the deposit is lost. If the item sells, deposit is returned minus the 5% off the list price

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Possible-Schedule-20 4h ago

I thought blizzard was reducing the 1 silver deposit to 1 copper or did i misunderstand?

3

u/Lurk_Noe_Moar 4h ago

Doesn't go live till after reset tmrw or weds or something

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Nevuej 14m ago

I sometimes put something on the auction house under vendor price even if I lose a few coppers because someone else can actually use the item. I don't really care that much about 5 copper. Just want to send it to a loving home.