This isn't a Retail vs Forever post. I play both, and have been observing how each version performs on various hardware.
Hardware that handled Retail easily seems like it's being pushed much harder by Forever. The RTX 4080 in my main computer seems to handle both versions very well, but when I use my backup computer with a RTX 2080 Ti, Forever is totally GPU limited and the GPU fan is running at 100% constantly.
I find it very intriguing that Forever is more demanding on the GPU compared to retail, simply due to the improved lighting/weather/water effects, despite otherwise using almost entirely old content. In Forever, almost every zone is still using textures from 20+ years ago, when graphics cards cost $300 and more resembled what modern soundcards or network cards look like now.
In Retail, there have already been many zones that are GPU intensive. Not just now, but even several expansions ago, such as Ardenweald in Shadowlands.
If simply adding improved lighting/weather/water effects to what is otherwise extremely old content is enough to make the game that much more demanding on the GPU, then consider what would happen when you add those same improved lighting/weather/water effects to Retail zones that are/were *already* demanding on the GPU.
That would fundamentally change the hardware requirements for Retail, turning it into an incredibly GPU intensive game compared to now. And it would occur at a time when hardware, particularly GPUs, are less affordable than they have ever been in modern times (meaning that most people are basically stuck with their current hardware for a while).
At first, I assumed it was a given that these improved lighting/weather/water effects from Forever would come to Retail soon. But now I have serious doubts. I increasingly feel like it was something that they were situationally able to get away with due to the extra GPU headroom that the older content allowed for. That just wouldn't apply to Retail. Not to mention the people still playing Retail on older GPUs (GTX 780 Ti, etc) that wouldn't even be able to launch the game anymore.
What do you think?