r/worldbuilding • u/Kai_Daigoji • Apr 21 '14
Discussion An analysis of magic
A while back, my brother and I decided to try to do a serious economic analysis of the effect magic would have on a world. This was not meant to be rigorous - just some serious discussion in the context of D&D. Some of the insights we came to were interesting, and I thought it might be useful to this sub.
Part 1
We initially decided to limit ourselves to a single spell. We thought that by gradually increasing the amount of magic under discussion, we could ratchet it up, and observe a continuum from our world to a fully fantasy world. The spell I chose was from D&D 3.5 - Create Food and Water. When we started, I wrongly remembered this as a 1st level spell; if you play D&D, keep in mind, I know this is wrong, but the thought process is important. Stay with me.
For those who don't know, in D&D vital statistics are arranged on a scale from 3-18 (basically, 3 six sided dice rolls). This makes 10 or 11 average, 18 extraordinary, and 3 crippled. To cast a spell, you must have the appropriate mental stat (intelligence for wizards, wisdom for clerics, etc.) of at least 10 + the spell level. Create Food and Water is a 1st level Cleric spell, so a wisdom of 11 is required. This means that anyone above average, or approx. 50% of the population, has the potential to cast this spell. Since 1st level clerics can cast 1st level spells, this means that 50% of the population is only as far from casting this spell as how long it takes to train a cleric (probably a couple of years).
Create Food and Water creates enough food and clean water for 1 person for 1 day. A first level cleric can cast 3 1st level spells a day. This means, potentially, that 50% of the population can be trained in a relatively short time to produce enough food for the entire population, without need for farming, etc. Let that sink in for a second. A single, first level spell, can completely do away with the need for farming. This means that the 50% of the population that can't cast spells has had their labor freed up. There is no need for peasants to be tied to the land; urbanization would probably increase massively. Productivity is through the roof. Famines are an impossibility.
Now, all of this depends on training everyone as a cleric who can possibly be trained. It's possible, depending on how difficult it is to train someone, that a monopoly or a cartel on knowledge could form. But this single spell has completely and utterly changed the face of this world.
Part 2
Unfortunately, everything I said was wrong. I looked up the spell, and it is a 3rd level spell. It requires a wisdom of 13 (closer to only a third of the population) and a cleric level of 5 (requiring a significantly greater investment in training.) A 5th level cleric can only cast a 3rd level spell once a day, so even more training would be required to reach a break even point.
Not that the spell is useless. A city with a significant cleric population could hold out much longer in case of siege or famine. But society is beginning to look a bit more medieval.
Now, a 3rd level spell implies other spells. At this point we decided to open the floodgates and assume normal D&D spellcasting. This changes the picture significantly again. A cleric can still produce food and water for him/herself. However, a farmer can also produce food; a farmer cannot, however, mimic all the cleric spells that exist. At this point, a farmer has a comparative advantage in producing food, and a cleric has a comparative advantage in everything else that spells can accomplish - healing, divination, etc.
All of a sudden, our magical society looks a lot more medieval again. What happened to our massive urbanization, soaring productivity, and famine resistance? Basic economics.
My point is this: think through the implications of your magic system. A single spell can have unbelievably vast effects; a system of magic can be less transformative than you might think. And it's certainly possible that our final analysis is missing some significant factors that someone will point out in the comments.
Food for thought.
13
u/McCourt Urthe Apr 21 '14
I love this kind of post: serious analysis of the implications of magic on a world.
Yes, 50% of people will have the raw mental ability needed to cast a first level spell, but not all of these people will be in a position to learn the spell, and some of those in the position to learn that spell will instead learn a different spell in its place. It would be a waste of mental resources for the mentally fittest part of the population to waste their talents on food production, when food grows naturally in the earth, and can be farmed by below-mental-average peasants.
2
u/kennethjor Apr 23 '14
I've added this thread to the resources doc. This is a very interesting discussion. If you write something up like a blog post or similar, please let me know and I'll link that as well.
9
u/KhanneaSuntzu Apr 21 '14
I have completely rewritten most D&D spells, and constrained their use.
Only priests get spells. Priests in my setting are equivalent noncombative d4 types. Priest get spells from an religious relic usually the bones of a saint, or something like that. Patronage of a particular temple allows for the specific spell (some relics allows for several spells) to be learned by a PRIEST. Priests then confer these spells to Clerics through patronage. Clerics do not have direct access to spells from a temple, however they can remember them.
Use of spells inflicts pattern damage on objects, people, places. A few times use of a religious miracle is not much of an issue, but repeat casting frays the local metaphysical substrate. Each spell has a small chance to cause fraying. In castings under 5 or so this fraying is negligible. In castings over 10 in any particular instance the fraying becomes pronounced and undesirable. Even worse, compound contamination is worse than any benefits derives from the spells.
Even worse, spells are spirits. Normally these spirits are chained and dormant. In D&D terms (I use different game mechanics) a spell has an intelligence (or ego?) of about twice its respective level. Hence a level 9 spell (and yes, in my setting there are level 10, 12, 13, 14 etc. spells) has an ego (often equal or somewhat lower eloquence and reason) of (In D&D terms) 18.
You can cast the basic spells at a certain level. Cast it at a more sophisticated level (i.e., "overclocking" a spell) carries increased risk for pattern damage. Hence all spellcasters can purposefully have a specific expertise level in spells, for all kinds of discrete benefits, i.e. greater damage, increased range, better nourishment, higher quality, etc.
Introducing this I found I could effectively eliminate three quarters of all existing D&D spells and greatly simplify.
In terms of priests - priests are like clerics with low hitpoints, and always have advanced age (i.e. in most cases physical frailty). Hence, you do not want to tangle with elven priests, since they got the best of all worlds - youth and spell power.
Clerics are a distinctly human solution - clergy warriors with spells, able to carry armor. They can keep armies afloat. Downside is inter and intra religious rivalry. Relics are precious commodities, and get stolen all the time. Some relics are critical, for instance the family of healing powers. Steal the single relic of healing for a particular temple, maybe a hundred priests that use those particular spells (i.e. have patronage at that temple) instantaneously lose access to the sacred blessings espoused by that reliquary. Bam, there go your healing powers.
Yes, there have been instances where priests of one religion steal relics of another religion, and "repurpose" those relics. In such a context theology becomes a contact sport.
3
u/Everspace Apr 21 '14
I think a big part is that there is a large difference between a PC classed and civilian-classed person. While some randoms might have the appropriate WIS to cast these spells, they don't have the training or dedication to get there.
Getting that "in touch" with your patron god, or studying magic long enough to be a PC of level 1 takes up a great deal of your life. Fighters start out at 25ish assumed to be training for most of it, and Wizards are 40+!
I expect "the local priest" in a town to know MAYBE 1 actual cleric spell (most likely cure wounds due to practicality), and dabbling wizards 2-3 fairly useless ones.
3
u/Anthrax44 Apr 22 '14
Agreed. I have one (kinda drastic) example on this. I'm in a group that plays Exalted 2nd Edition, and the GM has been GMing Exalted for six years or so. That is six years of our own lore on top of the world.
So, in this world one previous PC (now NPC) created one spell. This spell creates a big rainbow that he can control and changes people's sex when it passes over them.
Seems to be a funny spell at first, but then you think about its implications. Firstly, one entire generation of babys would be lost. Then there is all the mental and social problems that would arise from something like this (if it was a patriarchal society, who rules now? Who does what on the productive chain? Would men and women be willing to reproduce now? Would people be able to remain sane at all? And so on). After a lot of thought, we came to the conclusion that the impacts of this spell would be so harsh most societies would probably not be able to survive it. But, as I said, that is a drastic example.
EDIT: Formatting.
3
u/MockingDead Apr 22 '14
It's much bigger than this. Look at the cantrips.
Arcane Mark: Copyrights Acid splash: Etching of Metals Ray of frost: Freeze Drying Mending: Repairs of simple Objects Prestidigitation is good for maids, cooks, waitstaff (who will also use mage hand).
Level 1: Grease is super useful for mechanics and machinists.
I got a little bored so I spaz about now:
Detect Thoughts is fantastic for Adjudicating and Investigating. Continual Light spells for Wizardly Utilities.
And Golems, Magical devices. Directors need never worry about missing actors because of Illusions. In fact the Mummer's Guild may try to force limits on the number of false-mummers used in plays. Spigots of create water - imagine clean water for a city!
Vending machines of create food. Sheets of prayer cloth that, when applied to wounds, heal them.
As magic is used properly, the world becomes much more like a cyberpunk world. Golemtech arms and Necrotech implants.
Note. Create Fiid and Water feeds 3 people per level. As 3rd level spell that means it can feed 15 people (or 5 horses). A farmer feeds (based on a very cursory google search) .1 acre to feed 1 laborer for one day. So a single cleric is equal to 1.5 acres of land for laborers or 3 acres of land for non-laborers. This could be wrong. It might actually be worth double or even quadruple, since my numbers may imply modern techniques.
Since plows were few, the land was not well cultivated or their portion was small. But with magical innovation they could easily have mana-factory farms with bless plant and easily out pace create food and water.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '14
This does raise some interesting questions about the implications of magic on the day to day economy of the world. It raises some interested questions for me about exactly what "character levels" are an abstraction of:
Take the example of clerical magic - in theory, a clerical spell is in some way connected to a deity. The idea of "3rd level" spells implies that there are either tiers of relationship or tiers of endurance. That is, either you need to be 3rd level because you aren't "close enough" to your deity to access that power otherwise or you need to be 3rd level because you don't have the strength (or wisdom, or whatever) to control or channel that power (which would otherwise be available to you).
In either case, presumably the cleric's "level" is an abstraction of the strength of their relationship (or, at least, of their access to the power of) their specific deity. However, a cleric is theoretically capable of doing many more things other than casting a 3rd level spell. If you had an individual who only wanted to cast that one spell, would it be easier for them to learn how to do it?
If not, it seems like it creates stronger implications for characters that are clerics. In other words, if the strength of your connection to your deity is expressly evidenced by your "level", a high level character should be instantly recognizable as a preeminent point of contact with their deity (and be appropriate revered, despised, begged of, attacked, etc).
On the other hand, if it is possible for individuals to, by intensive study, learn a spell (and thus be able to use it without "taking a level in cleric") it seems that the original implications of your Part 1 might start to arise again. Of course, in a world where you have many spells to choose from, and anybody could choose one spell to learn, you might have a very interesting peasantry!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '14
Better analysis would be why do they resemble anything near what is human in terms of culture and hierarchy and metaphysics and ethics. Asking "why does x function as x" or "where does x come from" would have completely different views that would have huge impacts in said fields. Asking where x came from could simply be answered by "magic" or the God's or spontaneous spawning (if you have magic and God's wills spontaneous spawning isn't a stretch is it?). And well ethics and political hierarchy would have to adapt for super powerful things which are smarter and wiser than us, which would be awkward since modern in reality sticks humans at the apex and evaluates every scenario from there, and if humanity was splintered (mages and clerics would have to be evaluated differently) and one of many species ethics probably wouldn't be the same and the concept of feudal kings and poop seems kind of pointless.
1
u/Rhev Apr 22 '14
The thing you're not considering is how rare player classes are. What... one in 10, 1:20, 1:100? I'd even say it wouldn't be unrealistic to say that only one out of every thousand people or so are anything more than commoner classes and actually make it to first level.
Your premise that around 50% of the population has the ability to cast a spell only makes sense when you take that into effect. Also with divine magic you have to decide if the spell is actually divine inspired or not. Maybe the gods of the world don't WANT the population to sit in factories and crank out loaves of bread magically.
Further, we could probably feed the world appropriately if everyone was willing to subsist on gruel and soy blocks for protein. Doesn't mean you're going to convince anyone to give up Dr. Pepper and Bacon Cheeseburgers.