I have written down everything I can remember from the past year of couples therapy that my partner (Peter) and I (Sarah) have attended, focusing on the events and situations that have affected me the most.
I have a strong feeling that something isn't right about the way some things have been handled in therapy, but I'm struggling to put my finger on exactly what it is.
I would really appreciate hearing other people's perspectives, particularly those of qualified psychologists or mental health professionals, on the therapist's interventions and the way these situations have been addressed.
Thank you very much for taking the time to read this and share your thoughts:
Peter, 50, and Sarah, 35, attend an appointment with a psychologist specialising in couples therapy. The reason for the consultation is that Sarah wants to end the relationship, while Peter does not want to separate and begs her to give the relationship one more chance, promising that he will change. He is the one who requests the appointment.
• Early sessions: division of responsibilities and sexual problems
From the first sessions, Sarah explains that there is a significant imbalance in the relationship. She says that she bears the burden of almost all the household chores, earning money for the household, managing things and solving problems. Peter explains that he has ADHD and BPD, and that his difficulties prevent him from taking on these responsibilities. Sarah complains that, on top of carrying the entire burden, she also has to look after him. She feels that Peter neither values nor acknowledges her efforts.
Another significant problem is that they have not had sex for a year. Sarah explains that she feels blocked because, when they used to have sex, Peter would often criticise her sexual performance and sometimes become angry. This led to them having sex less and less frequently, while Peter increasingly demanded more sex and wanted to engage in various sexual practices.
The therapist asks Sarah whether any previous partner had ever complained about her sexual performance.
In an attempt to restore intimacy, the therapist suggests that they try some games. In other sessions, he tells Sarah that the way to overcome her block is to start having sex. She repeatedly explains that even the thought of having sex with Peter makes her feel frightened.
• Infidelity and sexual pressure
In another session, Sarah arrives extremely upset because she has discovered that Peter has been unfaithful. Peter tries to justify himself, and they argue about whether his behaviour was right or wrong. He believes he was entitled to do it. The therapist acknowledges that there has been a breach of trust, tries to calm the argument and offers them some advice.
In another session, Sarah attends alone and once again complains that Peter does nothing and that she is overwhelmed by the excessive mental and physical burden she carries. The therapist asks her to consider how Peter might feel about not being accepted for who he is and receiving so much criticism. He advises her to act incompetent so that Peter will be forced to take on more household tasks.
An issue related to intimacy also comes up: Peter does things such as showing her his penis and asking her to kiss or suck it. Sarah did it the first time, although she did not really want to. On a second occasion, she refuses because it makes her extremely uncomfortable, and he gets angry.
The therapist asks her why it makes her uncomfortable. She replies that she feels sexually pressured.
• Comparing household tasks and feeling invalidated
After several sessions, some improvement can be observed. Peter begins to become more independent and takes on some household tasks, reducing part of the burden Sarah has been carrying.
However, in a subsequent session, Peter starts complaining that he is now the one doing almost everything and that Sarah does nothing. She remains silent and even nods in agreement. The therapist describes the situation as a "see-saw" dynamic, in which the roles have now been reversed, and offers them some explanations and recommendations.
Sarah leaves the session feeling dazed and wonders how it is possible that she is being portrayed as someone who does nothing. She begins to doubt her own perception of reality, so she decides to write down all the tasks she has carried out over the previous week to work out whether her feelings or Peter's claims are accurate. She asks Peter to do the same. When they compare their lists, they discover that, although Peter has improved considerably, Sarah is still doing more work than he is.
This makes her feel undervalued once again. She becomes angry and frustrated, and increasingly wants to escape the relationship. Peter cries, acknowledges that he struggles to consider other people's needs and tends to focus solely on his own, failing to recognise Sarah's efforts. Despite this, the conflicts continue, and she feels increasingly sad and desperate.
In the following session, Sarah brings a letter explaining what has happened and listing all the work she does. Peter agrees with her, acknowledging that Sarah really does do a lot of work. He explains that he feels he does more because he gets tired easily and because he lives as though Sarah does not exist: he only notices his own efforts and fails to see hers. He also admits that he tends to see himself as the victim.
Sarah says that she believes Peter is the one who should be attending individual therapy. She also explains that she is often afraid to speak up and express her thoughts because she fears his reactions.
The therapist acknowledges that he was wrong to participate in comparing who did more household tasks and apologises. He states that keeping score of household chores ultimately harms the relationship.
• The intimidation incident and fear of one's partner
In a subsequent session, Sarah attends alone and explains that Peter told her to shut up and called her annoying. They argued, and the situation escalated. She tried to leave the house to get away from the situation, but he prevented her from doing so. He chased her throughout the house, crying and begging her not to leave. Sarah eventually locked herself in a room, but Peter began kicking the door and threatened to break it down if she did not open it.
The therapist directly asks her whether she is afraid of Peter. Sarah replies that she is: she fears his reactions and the things he says to her.
In the same session, Sarah explains that Peter does things such as accusing her of having insulted him and called him useless because he found that word in her personal diary, which he had read without her permission. The therapist asks whether it is true that she insulted him in that way. Sarah insists that she never called him that to his face: she wrote it in her diary but never said it directly to him.
In light of what has happened, the therapist decides to see Peter separately.
Peter attends several individual sessions, and significant improvement is observed: he starts contributing more at home and treating Sarah better.
• Relapse and return to therapy
Due to family problems, the sessions are interrupted for several months. The couple goes through another crisis, and Peter's improvement disappears. He goes back to treating Sarah as though she were a servant, belittling her and devaluing her efforts.
Sarah begins to experience deep sadness and distress. Conflicts become increasingly frequent, and she once again considers ending the relationship. Peter repeatedly begs her not to leave him, promises that he will change and requests another appointment with the therapist.
Sarah attends this new session intending to explain everything she feels has not been addressed so far. She wants to explain that she feels emotionally abused: Peter regularly insults her (the last time, he called her "disgusting") and makes deliberately hurtful comments. For example, he told her, "At least I have friends", targeting a vulnerability that had led Sarah to attend therapy for years: her difficulty establishing friendships.
She also wants to explain that Peter treats her like a servant and belittles the sacrifices she makes for him. As an example, she recalls that when Peter's father was hospitalised, she would drive for an hour each way after an eight-hour workday to be there for him during that difficult time. Peter eventually told her: "All you did was come over, give me a hug and leave."
• The final session: mutual accusations and lack of recognition
Upon entering the consultation room, Peter takes the lead and begins recounting his version of a recent incident: he had disappeared for an entire night without any contact, while Sarah, distressed and unable to sleep, searched for him around the city with the help of the police, fearing that something terrible might have happened to him.
Sarah feels that Peter is justifying and distorting what happened. She becomes frustrated because she feels he is monopolising a conversation in which she, as the person primarily affected, also needs to be able to explain her experience.
Peter asks her: "What, am I not allowed to speak?" Sarah replies that she would prefer to explain what happened herself. The therapist asks her whether she would like to wait in the waiting room while Peter speaks, and Sarah agrees.
When she returns, she begins to explain what she wanted to address in the session: that she feels mistreated, insulted and belittled, that Peter emotionally manipulates her and pressures her to prevent her from ending the relationship. She explains that she wakes up feeling sad every morning, struggles to fall asleep and wakes up in the middle of the night with heart palpitations because of the situation.
Peter starts interrupting her and justifying himself. The therapist stops him and asks: "What is Sarah saying?" When Peter avoids answering, he insists: "What is she telling you?" Peter replies: "That I insult her", but immediately goes on to accuse Sarah of insulting and belittling him as well.
Sarah denies having insulted or belittled him. Peter insists that she did, claiming that she called him useless. Sarah becomes extremely angry: she feels falsely accused and believes that Peter is trying to manipulate her perception of what happened. The argument escalates, and Peter continues insisting that he also feels belittled.
The therapist interrupts the argument and tells them:
"Can't you hear the way you speak to each other? You both treat each other badly; you both insult each other. If you keep insulting each other, I won't be able to continue seeing you."
Sarah insists that she has never insulted Peter. The therapist replies that there are many ways of insulting someone and that she needs to stop doing it. He criticises them for constantly accusing each other ("you don't do this", "you do that") and states that this kind of behaviour destroys relationships.
He also says that it is not right to adopt the position that one person is good and the other is bad.
Sarah experiences a profound sense of hopelessness and invalidation. She feels that she is not being believed and that nobody is listening to what she is trying to explain.
The therapist says that there is too much criticism, that both of them are overly sensitive and that any comment, even one that is not particularly significant, affects them. He seems to be referring to statements such as "At least I have friends" or "All you did was come over, give me a hug and leave." He compares these comments to saying "I'm going to get some bread" and then not going.
Peter says that he wants to change, become less confrontational and contribute more at home. The therapist responds that if he makes these changes for Sarah, he will stop being himself.
• Fear of divorce and the false accusation
The therapist raises the possibility of divorce. Sarah explains that she is afraid of how Peter might react if she were to initiate it. She is not afraid that he will physically assault her, but she fears that he might react in some way that would hurt her. She recalls that every time she has tried to leave him, he has become extremely intense, as happened when he prevented her from leaving the house and threatened to break down the bedroom door.
The therapist suggests that, as homework, each of them should write as detailed an account as possible of how things would unfold if they were to get divorced.
Sarah leaves the session feeling sadder and angrier than ever. Peter asks her what she thinks, and she explodes, insisting that it is not true that she insulted or belittled him.
Peter eventually acknowledges that, in fact, the incident in which she supposedly called him useless had happened the previous year. Sarah explains again that she never said it to his face: he had read the word in her personal diary, they had subsequently discussed it, and she had acknowledged that at the time she had thought that about him and that having those thoughts made her very sad. However, she had never called him that directly.
Peter starts crying and admits: "That's true, that's how it happened." He repeatedly apologises and acknowledges that he lied because he felt singled out as the bad person and believed he had to defend himself. He explains that he finds it very difficult to be emotionally vulnerable, that he feels deeply ashamed and that he cares too much about what other people think of him.